1 STEP Arbeidsnotat / Working Paper ISSN A Thor Egil Braadland Innovation in the Norwegian food system Thor Egil Braadland STEP-gruppen Storgaten 1 N-0155 Oslo Norway Working Paper prepared for the RISE project, financed by the EU commission s TSER programme, and Norwegian Research Council Oslo, Sept. 00
2 Redaktør for seriene: Editor for the series: Dr. Philos. Finn Ørstavik ( ) Stiftelsen STEP 1999 Henvendelser om tillatelse til oversettelse, kopiering eller annen mangfoldiggjøring av hele eller deler av denne publikasjonen skal rettes til: Applications for permission to translate, copy or in other ways reproduce all or parts of this publication should be made to: STEP, Storgaten 1, N-0155 Oslo
3 Preface This report is one of three publications by the same author on innovation, knowledge and processes of change in the Norwegian food system. The full list of publications is as follows: The Norwegian food clusters an overview (STEP working paper A-04-00) Innovation in the Norwegian food system (STEP working paper A-05-00) R&D in the Norwegian food system (STEP working paper A-06-00) The reports are written for the EU-financed project RISE (Research and Technology Organisations in the Service Economy) under the TSER program, and for the Norwegian Research Council. Proejct manager has been Dr. Mike Hales, CENTRIM (UK). Norwegian project coordinator has been Johan Hauknes, STEP Group. The author iii
5 Summary This paper concerns innovation in the Norwegian food system. The paper seeks to investigate three interrelated questions: What is innovation in the food system, how does food companies innovate and what policy is better aimed at stimulating innovation in food companies? There are basically two ways of understanding innovation processes; innovation as a linear process with R&D as major driver, and innovation as an interactive process where multiple sources found important drivers together. We use this paper to argue that the food industry is a good example of an activity where innovation is interactive instead of linear, and that innovation policies should take this result into consideration when designing food industry innovation policies. We argue that important innovation sources in addition to R&D are consumer signals and machinery suppliers. Innovation surveys normally distinguish between product and process innovations as the two major indicators of business development. We argue in this paper that in an industry where business development also stems from improving markets for existing products (through branding), the industry comes out comparatively less innovative than other industries where product and process changes are more important to competitiveness. Understanding innovation as major attempt to improve business would include branding as an innovative activity. The food industry is one of the industries where size still matters. In Norway, the share of employees working in the largest companies has been slightly increasing during the 90s, and small food companies are in average larger than other small companies (less than 50 employees). However, food companies are also more flexible than other industries, measured in share of innovation costs used to market surveillance. We argue that the dominant reason why companies use market surveillance expenditures is to change production according to what these results show. The analytic result is that food companies both carries signs of scale-intensity and flexibility, which is in line with the perspective of Toyotism, or flexible mass-production. v
7 Content PREFACE... III SUMMARY...V CONTENT... VII INNOVATION IN THE NORWEGIAN FOOD SYSTEM... 1 The Norwegian food system... 1 Innovation in the food industry... 3 How do food companies innovate?...4 Formal and informal innovations...8 Barriers to innovation...9 Conclusion: A new conception of innovation?...10 Three important sources to innovation Suppliers of machinery and equipment...11 Research and development (R&D)...15 Consumer relations...19 Summary and policy implications LITERATURE...23 Interviewed persons/companies/location/date Map over Norway, with counties and largest cities, surrounding waters and countries...27 vii
9 Innovation in the Norwegian food system The Norwegian food system The size of the Norwegian food activities is quite remarkable. Food production centres around the Norwegian food processing industry 1, but also include upstream activities like fishing, fish farming, shipyards and agriculture, and downstream activities like retail, hotels and restaurants. Total cluster employment is about persons 2, or about 9 percent of total Norwegian employment. The food processing industry is a central part of the cluster, and is the largest industry in Norway today - measured in both gross product and employment. With approximately employees, this is the largest manufacturing industry in Norway on a two-digit NACE-level. The food industry alone represents as much as 21 percent of all Norwegian manufacturing value added 3, and it stands for the fifth highest value added per employee among all Norwegian manufacturing industries - higher than industries like electrical and optical instruments, machinery and equipment and printing and publishing 4. In terms of employment, the food industry alone represents about 19 percent of Norwegian manufacturing employment (Table 1) 5. Table 1: The Norwegian food industry, main figures and share of mfg activities, Source: Statistics Norway, ukens statistikk, 35, 1998 (NACE 15) 6. Companies Employment GVP Value added Number/amount mill NOK mill NOK Share of Norwegian mfg 16 % 19 % 25 % 21 % Two types of innovation processes Joseph Schumpeter was one of the first writers to relate economic development to technological change and innovation. Schumpeter published his main works in the 1920s. What Schumpeter basically argued was that economies evolves 1 NACE 15; manufacturing of food and beverages 2 Employees with main occupation in food related activities. In addition come persons working part time in for example agriculture or fishing. Source: Haukes (1999). 3 Statistics Norway (1998), Ukens Statistikk, 35 4 Statistics Norway (1998), ibid. 5 For a more detailed presentation of the Norwegian food system, see Braadland (2000), The Norwegian food system an overview, STEP working paper, Oslo 6 Include only companies with 20 or more employees NOK = 122,46 (Nov 1999) 1
10 2 STEP Working Paper A-05/2000 qualitatively, and that new technologies and industries emerge and gradually destroy old production system in what he termed a process of creative destruction. In the 1940s, Vannevar Bush followed up on Schumpeter, claiming that the major engine behind innovation and change was research and development (R&D) efforts (Figure 1) 8. Figure 1: The linear model of innovation R&D Innovating company The fact that innovation drives the economy has regained attention, in particular the last two decades. The dominant work putting this perspective on the policy agenda in the 90s was the OECD publication Technology and the Economy - the key relationships, (OECD 1992), marking a shift in the perspective on how economic development was to be understood, and which policy implications to be drawn. One of the central outcomes of this work was to bury the Bush model the linear approach - of innovation. The linear innovation model defends a perspective that economic progress is a result of commersialisation of succesfull R&D efforts. The problem with the model is that it indirectly argues that the more money one spends on R&D, the more innovation and economic development is gained. Empirical evidence showed, however, that the relationship was not that simple. The striking example was US and Europe in the 1970s. In spite of increases in R&D efforts in both the US and Europe, Japan was the country that could show to the most rapid growth in the economy 9. The major outcome of this rethinking was a more complex understanding of the innovation process. The linear model was gradually replaced with a so-called interactive model of innovation. The interactivity notion stems from the perspective that not only R&D, but also factors as external knowledge suppliers, organisational corpus of scientific and technological knowledge, marketing, design, testing and distribution 10 can be important factors to innovation. 8 Bush, V. (1945) 9 OECD (1992), 10 OECD (1992), ibid. p. 25
11 Figure 2: Example of an interactive innovation model Suppliers Design R&D Innovating company Colleges and universities Consulting services Customers/ consumers Competitors The interactive innovation model carries three basic differences from the linear model. I) it is interactive, i.e. the different units in the system have the important ability and power to influence choices and strategies within the other units, and vice versa, II) it is multidirectional, i.e. there are no mono-directional influence from one unit to another - like from R&D to economic development in the linear model - and III) there are variations in unit strengths and influence between the units across different production systems; some innovation sources are more important than others across varying sectors or different types of innovating companies. The basic idea of the interactive innovation model is hence a relativistic one; there are more factors - and often more important factors - behind economic renewal than R&D inputs. As we shall see, this is true not at least for the Norwegian food industry. Innovation in the food industry Reducing R&D activities to only one of several inputs to industrial innovation has implications for how we understand complexity and advanceness in innovation processes. And it has direct implications on how we perceive and measure innovation efforts 11, because level of R&D used in innovation processes is not any more proportional to how advanced innovations are. The food industry is an example of an industry where direct R&D expenditures have never been dominant innovation expenditures as share of for example turnover. Still, compared to other industries, the food Norwegian industry is fairly innovative. The fact that R&D is not dominantly important to food innova- 11 Keith, Tore etc (IDEA).
12 4 STEP Working Paper A-05/2000 tion at the same time as food companies do innovate, leads us towards the fact food companies have other important sources to innovation. As we shall see, other important sources to innovation are consumer and consumer relations and machinery suppliers. How do food companies innovate? The common approach product and process innovations... It is common to distinguish between two archetypes of innovation; product innovation, i.e. introducing new or improved products; and process innovation, i.e. introducing new or improved way of doing things. A change in product would typically be a new type of mustard, a new brand of beer or a new pizza, or a totally new product like Ox; a milk-based drink with peculiar tastes aimed at adolsents, manufactured a while by the largest Norwegian dairy company TINE (more about Ox later). 12 A change of process would typically be to implement new machinery, like the recent activities at the Ringnes Gjelleråsen brewery north of Oslo. In Ringnes, as an overall trend in production of beverages, emphasis is put on automatification. Production of soft drinks has been profoundly automated the last decade, with German mechanical machines and Japanese robots gradually taking over manual tasks, like lifting, loading, moving and storing loads of bottles. At Ringnes is just about to finish a completely new plant, after moving from inner Oslo. The storage room at the new plant is immense. It includes several hundred 13 meter high shelves filled with a seemingly chaotic mixture of loads of empty bottles ready for cleaning and refill, and loads of beverage bottles ready to leave the factory. The storage room is completely automated, and a computer keeps perfect track of which are tour and which are return bottles, bringing bottles to and from the conveyor belt. The computer is making sure that the right kind of bottles is brought from the shelves and put at the right conveyor belt; either leading to the cleaning machines or to one of the 20 truck ramps further down the hall. One computer and two computer controllers now run what was earlier performed by 15 factory floor truck drivers. 12 One major trend in product development is the increased emphasis on prepared meals (Christensen at al, op.cit.). The basic reason behind this development is competition from restaurants. People spend generally more time at restaurants than before, as a result of a combination of increased welfare, less spare time and increasingly continental eating habits. Fjordland is a typical food producing company illustrating this point. Fjordland was established as a co-operation between TINE, Gilde/Norsk Kjøtt, Prior and Hoff in 1994, and had 50 employees in 1999 and an annual turnover on 335 million NOKs. Fjordland produces prepared meals like Fjordland Biff Stroganoff with rice, Meatballs with mashed peas and potatoes and Indian Carry Chicken with rice. The four owners have traditionally been producers of separate products, like milk and milk products (TINE), meat products (Norsk Kjøtt), eggs (Prior) and fried potatoes (Hoff); together they are capable of producing products that are in line with recent consumption trends.
13 A particular feature of innovation in the food industry is the fact that product and process innovations in the food industry are often interdependent activities. The CIS Survey (1997) showed that Norwegian food companies rarely performed product innovations without performing process innovation at the same time. The dominant share of innovating companies reported that they had performed both process and product innovation the last three years. Very few companies reported that they had performed product innovation only. This indicates that when food companies start producing a new product, they predominantly have to undertake major investments in equipment and machinery. It could also indicate that when food companies perform product innovation, the innovations are rather radical and need a whole new set-up of the production line. This perspective is also argued for in Christensen at al (1996), stating that the food industry has been strong in introducing radical innovations the last two decades, and that Norwegian food companies in particular has been radical innovators in the 90s. There are in other words a seemingly strong complimentarity between product and process innovation in the food industry much stronger than in other industries. On this background, it is interesting to look closer at how food companies actually perform in terms of product and process innovations. A major critisism towards the Norwegian food industry has namely been the ability to renewal, as a result of lack of competition in central fields of the industry. Already since the mid 1800s, Norwegian farmers in mid- and eastern Norway 13 have had large influence on public policy, both directly through party representation and indirectly through large pressure groups. However, as 80s and 90s increased focus on liberalism, trade and international competitivism, the way of arranging the food production system has been highly critisised. As a result of what might be describes as a succesful result (seen from the view of the food producers), they are often critisised, however. Neoclassical economicst and liberal mercantilist claim that the particular mix of sheltering and public and interventionism reckognising large parts of Norwegian food production on the one hand and strong, farmer-controlled co-operatives on the other are factors that have been bad for efficiency, competitiveness and a healthy, economic development. A hypothesis is therefor that the innovation frequency in food companies is much lower than most other industries. However, in a Norwegian all-industry survey from 1997, 45 percent of the food companies said they had performed an innovation the last three years (Figure 3). Average share of innovative companies for Norway as a whole is 46,2 percent. The food industry is in other words neither particularly more innovative nor particularly less innovative than other Norwegian industries, in average. The share of food companies performing innovation is higher than what we find in textiles, metal goods and graphical industries (35 percent of them reported to be innovative) and production of transport equipment (44 percent). The share is lower than industries like metals, pulp and paper and machines and equipment (appr. 60 percent). 13 See Appendix for map
14 6 STEP Working Paper A-05/2000 Figure 3: Norwegian industries and share of companies reporting innovative activities, source: Community Innovation Survey Norway, 1997, STEP Group / Statistics Norway, N= Chemicals Electronics, instruments Machines and equipment Pulp and paper Electrical machinery Metals Rubber, mineral products Other production, recycling Food and beverages Transportation Metal goods Textiles, leather, wood prod. Graphical Average = 46,2 percent It seems that some of the critics towards the food system is based on wrong empirical evidence, as the food industry is not less innovative than other industries. In addition to this, there are two points that such critics often forget. but also organisational innovations Firstly, food production is often a scale-intensive activity 15, and processes that development of large units can be seen as an innovation efforts in themselves. A good example of this is TINE, the close-to-monopoly Norwegian dairy cooperative. Although TINE is large in a Norwegian context and faces little or no competition, the company keeps promoting new products, like new youghurts, new milk and milk-drinks, new cheeses etc. TINE has also performed major process innovations. The company has over a decade reduced its number of plants while maintaing the same production and even diversified production. It seems therefor to simple to argue that size in itself is of major concern. Building of large food units also echoes development we see in Europe 16 and US 17. and branding Secondly, critics tend to ignore that innovation in food companies can often be, in sharp contrast to other industries, to maintain or develop market share for already established products, a phenomenon termed branding. There is in other 14 Share of companies in sample reporting innovation. In this sample, large firms are better represented than small firms. Since the probability of being innovative increases with firm size, the actual /weigthened innovation share is a little lower for all industries than presented in the figure. Average weightened share for all industries is appr. 40 percent, in the individual industries the share is between 3-10 percent less than presented in the figure. For the food industry, the difference is about minus five percent. 15 Pavitt 16 EU Panorama of European Industry Fortune top (http://www.fortune.com)
15 words a contrast between the regular notion of innovation on the one hand (new or improved product) and what is regarded as business development in the food industry on the other (maintaining success for established brand or product). The notion of branding is of particular focus for food companies, and we suggest that branding must be included if we want to understand business development for this kind of companies. The basic idea behind branding is that customers will be more apt to consume products they already trust, products they know (or think they know) or at least have heard of. Branding stems out of the phenomenon that food manufacturing basically is about factories turning raw materials into manufactured foodstuff. Marxists would claim that moving the tradition and culture of household food preparation from homes inside production halls located on giant company plants is a sign of entfremdung - what used to be gathered, caught and prepared at home by individuals is increasingly processed, manufactured, automated, packed, transported and marketed behind the gates of plants belonging to big multinational companies. The idea that people now eat products processed by people they don t know and companies they never go inside creates a kind of distance to the food product. To overcome this level of distance, infamiliarity and uncertainty, branding is used to make consumers more comfortable with the product. Branding is mostly done through regular commercials (television, radios, journals, newspapers), but also through distributing product samples (like small attachments to journals or newspapers) or by sponsoring activities, like sporting activities or music concerts. We find branding in most consumer-oriented industries, not only the food industry. Typical examples are Swatch watches, Bosch car batteries and window wipers, Hundai cars and Nokia mobile telephones. However, branding is more important to the food industry than most other industries. Not necessarily because the threshold of trying new products are higher per se for food products than for other consumer goods (we know that the share of Norwegians eating non-traditional dinner are slightly decreasing 18 ). But because eating and drinking is a process of putting manufactured items into in your mouth and swallow it. This requires a high degree of consumer trust in the products or the producing company. Branding is a way of creating this trust. International food brands are particularly important for beverages, like Carlsberg, Heineken, Tuborg, Coca Cola and Nestlé. In Norway, there exist a wide array of brand names that most people would recognise. These brands can analytically be divided in two. One the one hand there are product brands, like Farris (Ringnes sparkling mineral water), M (Freia s chocolate) and Grandiosa (Stabburet s Pizza). On the other, there are portfolio brands / company brands, like Freia, Nora (jams and juices produced in Norway by Stabburet), Eldorado (a wide array of imported canned fruits and vegetables, in addition to juices, soft drinks and jams produced in Norway), Gilde (Norsk Kjøtt s meat products) and TINE (milk and a wide array of butter and cheeses). Several of these names, like TINE, Gilde and Eldorado, are all relatively new names, established as pure 18 Stræte (op.cit.)
16 8 STEP Working Paper A-05/2000 marketing brands for companies that go back a long time. TINE 19, for example, is the marketing name for what used to be called Norske Meierier, Gilde is the marketing name for meat products from companies organised as Norsk Kjøtt, and Eldorado is NorgesGruppen s private label. To sum up, a basic difference between food manufacturing and other manufacturing is that innovation (interpreted as major business effort ) may very often be to keep a product exactly the way it is, focussing on maintaining or increasing the product s market share by familiarising the product to consumers. As branding as phenomenon is not captured in regular innovation surveys, food companies come up less innovative then what one should believe them to be. Interpreting innovation as a major effort to increase or maintain business or profits, branding would surely be one such important factor. In addition to the fact that food companies are innovative in these two ways that is not captured by regular innovation surveys (size and branding), there are also other innovations taking place. A central area of change the last decades has for example been the profound improvements and changes in transport 20. These changes have dominantly taken three forms. Firstly, there have been gradual improvements in trucks and cooling systems, which have increased the potential for extending the transport routes for food (or a toning down of physical space), if you like. Secondly, there has been a development in logistics activities. This change has taken two forms. Firstly, there has been an increased division of labour between the people in charge of logistics on the one hand and the truck drivers on the other. And, related to this, there has been an increase in professionalisation of the logistics people and the technology they use, in for example turns of the shape of satellite based control systems which are opening up for more economic flow of goods 21. The third development has been the retail chains gradually taking over transport services through their vertical integration with wholesale (more about this in Braadland (2000) op.cit). Formal and informal innovations Another way of distingusihing different types of innovations is to divide them by how they emerge; from strictly informal to strictly formal. There are basically three types of food companies; small family-owned companies, corporate companies and companies belonging to a co-operative 22. The difference between formal and informal innovations seems basically to vary with company size. Large companies, both the corporate controlled and the companies belonging to a cooperative structure tend to formalise product development through use of market divisions, research divisions, external and internal market analysts and external research suppliers. The TINE development of a new milk-based drink called Ox, mentioned above, illustrates the formal way of developing new prod- 19 [tee:ne] 20 Ørstavik, F. (1998), Innovation regimes and trajectories in goods transport, STEPreport R , STEP Group, Oslo 21 Ibid,p. 22 Onsager, K. and Berit Aasen (1995)
17 ucts. In the process, TINE involved their market division and research division, in addition to external knowledge suppliers like trend analysts, market pollers and web designers. This is an indication not only of a formalisation of the innovation process; it is also a sign of a highly professionalised innovation process. The same applies for product development in Maarud, a major snack provider, owned by Freia / Kraft General Foods. When Maarud develops new products, it is in close co-operation with their Nordic sister companies of the food innovation process, using test and development laboratories and staff, sometimes involving several hundred variations of product taste to find the right one. In Ringnes, product development takes place in the company s product development department in Gjelleråsen, involving a range of persons, mainly chemists and market analysts. Product development in Fjordland, owned by large cooperatives, is taking place in the owners R&D laboratories, in addition to cooperation with market agencies and scientific knowledge suppliers like Matforsk and Norconserv 23. At the other end of the scale, we find small companies with rather informal innovation processes. Majonæsfabrikken is an artisan factory with 14 employees, located at the heart of Oslo, producing mostly private-label, high quality majonese salads for supermarkets in the Oslo-region. Both father and son work in production. The company sometimes develops new products by copying their competitors salads. If they see a new type of salad from the competitors (like major majonese salad producers Denja or Mills) in the grocery shop, they buy it, determine the ingredients by smelling and tasting the salad. Then they decide whether to go for it or not, based on how they find the product. Barriers to innovation Quantitative industry-studies of barriers of innovation are important to understand how the industry innovates, and which factors companies consider as important hampering factors to renewal and innovation. In an all-industry survey from 1997, Norwegian companies were asked to respond if any of nine given factors ever had been a hampering factor to innovation activities during 1994 to Food companies separated from most other industries by emphasising i) organisational relations, ii) lack of market information, iii) too strict standards and regulations and iv) market failure for new products and processes 24 as factors being important barriers to innovation. The industry did not separate markedly from other industries in factors like lack of qualified personnel, lack of technological information or too high innovation costs. i) Organisational barriers to innovation. This picture harmonises with what we have seen so far. Large companies dominate the food industry. We know that large companies are often marked by embedded organisational resistance to change, but according to the survey, it may seem that food companies are more 23 Sources: Interviews with TINES market director, and various homepages. 24 Nås et al (1999), Innovasjon i norsk næringsliv, STEP report R-04-99???
18 10 STEP Working Paper A-05/2000 often regarded as intrinsicly resistant to organisational change than large companies in other industries are. ii) Too strict standards and regulation. In the barriers survey, public regulations is also often regarded as a barrier to innovation. This answer may be an echo of regulations on consumer security and demands on purity, nutrition etc. (see Braadland (2000)) iii) Market failure. The very fact that food production is a consumer-oriented industry is also reflected in the fact that market failure is frequently reported as a barrier to new food products (and processes). The very fact that market failure is a profound hindrance to innovation in the food industry is in itself an interesting observation. It namely underscores our suggested interpretation of the food industry as an innovative industry, but that the problem is more that new products have trouble in finding new markets fast enough. Interviews in the food industry have shown that some claim that this is a problem caused by the increasingly dominating standardised, low-cost retail chains. Others claim that the problem is related to conservative consumers and their willingness to try new and altered products. Market failure for new products goes together with the last barrier, namely iv) Market information. Lack of market information does, together with market failure, underline the fact that food companies have both a very dependent relation and a very vulnerable relation to consumers and customers (retail chains). Food companies express that there are potential for product innovation, but that such development demand a better knowledge of what the consumers actually want. Conclusion: A new innovation concept? We have shown that although innovation seems more rare in the food industry than in many other Norwegian industries, the food industry is still innovative in its own terms. In a perspective where innovation is understood as new products or processes, and less as major effort to maintain or increase profitability, 25 many details on food industrial dynamics are lost. The key lies in the concept of branding. How important branding is, is documented in a research survey from 1993 among food produing companies. At that time, Norway was preparing for a EU membership referendum. The food industry managed, through their long tradition of strong political influence, to get financial aid to perform strategic investments in preparation for increased competition. The companies were free to use the grants the way they felt were necessary, with a clausal on 50 percent self-financing. The only criterion was that the support was used strategically, aimed at increasing competitiveness. The interesting result was that very few food companies used the strategic means to develop new products. When asked what was the decisive factor behind their investments, they collectively ranked highest these four factors; i) product quality, ii) quality and hygiene in the production process, iii) customer relations and iv) ensure quality on raw materials. Of 24 indicators, developing new products was ranked second least important 25 Hauknes and Braadland (1999), op.cit.
19 reason for strategic investing. Developing existing products was ranked 21; change in technological level in production was ranked The conclusion is that non-technological innovations like branding and consumer-relations (for example in terms of product quality and hygiene) are equally important features to maintain or increase profitability as development of new products or prcesses in the food industry. In an innovation concept for the food industry, relations to consumers is an integral part of better performance in the food industry. As we shall see in the next section, consumer-industry relation is one of three dominant sources of innovation in the food industry. Three important sources to innovation In this section we look more closely the most central, external knowledge suppliers to the food processing industry. We find three such important supplier categories. These are suppliers of machinery, consumer relations (and consulting companies supplying consumer information, like suppliers of trend analysis and market surveillance) and internal and external suppliers of R&D. We give a detailed presentation of the importance of these knowledge providers and give an overview of relations between these knowledge suppliers and the industry part of the food cluster. Suppliers of machinery and equipment New machinery and equipment is the single largest innovation cost for Norwegian food companies, if we judge by 1993-statistics. Investment costs represent about 50 percent of total innovation costs, a higher share than what we find in heavy machinery-based industries like pulp and paper and metal production (Figure 4). Norwegian food companies are mainly using machinery from Danish, German, Dutch, British and Japanese companies, most often acquired through Norwegian retailers localised near the Oslo-fjord area 27. Relations between the industry and suppliers of machinery are in dominantly market-based. In some cases, however, food companies and independent machinery suppliers collaborate in developing technological solutions. During the period, almost 50 percent of all food companies reported they had performed at least one such collaboration with machinery suppliers. There is also one example of more formal integration between machinery suppliers and food companies. TINE is majority owner of Landteknikk AS, a supplier of complete process chains and machinery, consulting services and a broad array of equipment. Landteknikk has about 250 employees, and has locations in Oslo, Stavanger and Trondheim. Most of Landteknikk s technology is imported from Nordic and central European countries. Some products are produced in Trondheim, Norway. Landteknikk serves the whole food industry, but is owned by the agrobased co-operatives: The largest shareholders are TINE Norske Meierier (90 26 ECON/Coopers and Lybrand (1997), Evaluering av omstillingstiltakene for den landbruksbaserte næringsmiddelindustrien, Sluttrapport fase 2, ECON, Oslo, p Aasen and Onsager ibid.
20 12 STEP Working Paper A-05/2000 percent) and Norsk Kjøtt (8 percent), but also Grønt and Eggsentralen/Prior participate in Landteknikk. An important issue to take into consideration in an industry where suppliers of machinery play such an important role, is the fact that although the food industry uses little direct money on R&D it uses very advanced technology. In a European survey on innovation in food and beverages, Christensen et al write: The considerable size of this industry implies that many of its firms will be especially responsible for making use of innovations developed in other technologically more advanced industries... 28, and that (t)here is a high degree of dependence [in the food industry] on those developments in high-tech areas, like information technology, biotechnology and advanced materials. 29 Figure 4: Innovation cost shares in different Norwegian industries Source: Community Innovation Survey, Norway, STEP Group / Statistics Norway. 100% Investment costs Innovtion cost (percentages) 90% 80% 70% 60% 50% 40% 30% 20% 10% Other running costs Market analyses Purchase of products and licences Test production Product design R&D 0% All companies Chemicals Metals Pulp and paper Transport eq. Industry Machinery and eq. Electrical and optical instruments Mieral prod. Rubber and plastics Food / beverages Furniture Metal goods Textiles Graphical Wood products A Norwegian example on use of advanced technology is Frya dairy (Østlandsmeieriet). Frya was the second dairy in the world upgrading to SattLine, a process automation system for dairy production based on compatible PC systems (Windows/NT/ Ethernet), autumn The picture below is taken at Frya, and shows two operators controlling the new automation system, supplied by Landteknikk. The picture illustrates how a seemingly backward industry can be advanced through implementing and using new technology. 28 Jesper Lindgaard Christensen, Ruth Rama and Nick von Tunzelmann, Innovation in the European Food Products and Beverages Industry, European Innovation Monitoring System Publication 35, IKE Group, Aalborg University (DK), Christensen, op.cit.
R-05 1999 Performance and cooperation in the Oslo region business sector Redaktør for seriene: Editor for the series: Dr. Philos. Finn Ørstavik (1998-99) Stiftelsen STEP 1999 Henvendelser om tillatelse
OECD Directorate for Science, Technology and Industry 7 July, 2011 ISIC REV. 3 TECHNOLOGY INTENSITY DEFINITION Classification of manufacturing industries into categories based on R&D intensities High-technology
The Danish grocery market The yearly revenue in the Danish grocery market amounts to 105 billion DKK, which means that groceries on average represent 15 percent of the Danish household s total consumption.
INTRODUCTION The Consumer Price Index, commonly referred to as the CPI, is one of the most used of the statistical series produced by the Statistical Institute of Jamaica (STATIN). In its many applications,
INTERNATIONAL COMPETITIVENESS LABOR PRODUCTIVITY LEADERSHIP AND CONVERGENCE AMONG 14 OECD COUNTRIES Morton Schnabel * Office of Business and Industrial Analysis Office of Policy Development Economics and
The Orkla Group Preliminary results 1999 10 February 2000 1 Orkla 1999 - Highlights Substantial value increase for investment portfolio Profit improvement for Nordic food and beverages Continued strong
Innovation in New Zealand: 2011 Crown copyright This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 New Zealand licence. You are free to copy, distribute, and adapt the work, as long as you
TITLE: The Market for Food Processing and Packaging Equipment in Yekaterinburg COUNTRY: POST OF ORIGIN: Yekaterinburg DATE OF REPORT: June 5, 2001 AUTHOR: Yelena Zheberlyaeva Summary: This report focuses
from research. to market Manufacturing technologies for food and bioeconomy Giacomo Copani 26 Maggio 2015 Expo Milano Bioeconomy between Food and Non-Food: the Italian Way Italian Manufacturing in Europe
Certified Once Accepted Everywhere The value of accredited certification Survey Report Published May 212 In 21/11, the IAF carried out a global survey to capture market feedback on the value of certification.
Food & Drink Market Analysis, Saudi Arabia Jeddah, Saudi Arabia Industry market shares 2011 Source: AMR International 2011 Globex market report; RX analysis Total market share represented by top 14 companies
The Community Innovation Survey 2010 (CIS 2010) THE HARMONISED SURVEY QUESTIONNAIRE The Community Innovation Survey 2010 FINAL VERSION July 9, 2010 This survey collects information on your enterprise s
Executive Summary In light of the i2010 initiative, the Commission has adopted initiatives to further develop the Single European Information Space a Single Market for the Information Society. However,
Summary: TØI Report 1135/2011 Author(s): Eivind Farstad, Arne Rideng, and Iratxe Landa Mata Oslo 2010, 66 pages Norwegian Foreign Visitor Survey 2010 In 2010 a total of 4.8 million foreign guests stayed
European Manufacturing Survey Bulletin Number December 2014 3 Backshoring of Production Activities in European Manufacturing Bernhard Dachs 1, Christoph Zanker 2 In cooperation with Susana Azevedo (University
1.8.2 Grocery Shopping Within a Budget Grade Level 10-12 Take Charge of Your Finances Materials provided by: Heide Mankin, Billings Senior High School, Billings, Montana Janice Denson, Twin Bridges High
Sustainability Strategies within the Global Food Industry Prepared by: Jonathan Thomas, Principal Market Analyst, Leatherhead Food Research E-mail: firstname.lastname@example.org Innovation Nutrition Regulatory
Understanding Drivers and Barriers to Consumption of South East Queensland Local and Regional Foods 1 Prepared for: Queensland Government Regional Services Level 1, 60 Wises Road PO Box 5395 Maroochydore
Foods With Healthy Supplements and Organics Have Room for Growth Major Perception Gaps Across the Globe Towards Fortified and Organic Foods Popularity Held Back by Pricy Image, Niche Distribution and Credibility
Grocery Shopping Within a Budget Lesson Plan Grade Level 10-12 Take Charge of Your Finances National Content Standards Family and Consumer Science Standards: 1.1.6, 2.1.1, 2.1.2, 2.1.3, 2.5.1, 2.6.1, 2.6.2,
Interserve and Sheffield Hallam University market research 2012 Page 2 www.commercial.interserve.com How are companies currently changing their facilities management delivery model...? we have a strategy
Segmentation Conventionally, industries are defined broadly; the automobile industry, the computer software industry, the shipping industry. But competition tends to occur at more localised levels - within
www.exportmarketresearch.com Your smooth market entry Export Market Research Market Entry Services in the CEE region Scandinavia & beyond Who We Are Export Market Research Ltd. is a privately owned company
A STUDY ON INFLUENCE OF ADVERTISEMENT IN CONSUMER BRAND PREFERENCE (Special Reference to Soft Drinks Market in Hosur Town) Dr.A. VinayagaMoorthy Professor, Department of Commerce, Periyar University,Salem-11.
EU sectoral competitiveness indicators EU sectoral competitiveness indicators A pocketbook prepared by the Enterprise and Industry Directorate-General Unit B2 Competitiveness and economic reforms European
Measuring Intangible Investment The Treatment of the Components of Intangible Investment in the UN Model Survey of Computer Services by OECD Secretariat OECD 1998 ORGANISATION FOR ECONOMIC CO-OPERATION
Welcome to Love Food Hate Waste An Introduction Welcome to Love Food Hate Waste How can the programme benefit your customers and staff? In 2007 WRAP launched the Love Food Hate Waste programme which helps
UK PRINTING THE FACTS & FIGURES 600 MILLION P.A. CAPITAL INVESTMENT WORLD S FIFTH LARGEST PRODUCER OF PRINTED PRODUCTS 13.5 BILLION TURNOVER 122,000 EMPLOYEES 750 MILLION POSITIVE TRADE BALANCE IN 2014
Next generation insurance - insights into the behaviour and beliefs of the European consumer Dr John Schoonbee, Chief Medical Officer, EMEA, Swiss Re IAA Colloquium 2015, Oslo, Norway, 7-10th June 2015
Expense Reduction Analyst Survey on SMEs Vision for the future: Are you ready for Industry 4.0? Finding sources of funding and securing new business opportunities Content 02 Content and imprint 0 Foreword
SURVEY OF EMPLOYMENT PRACTICES OF MULTINATIONAL COMPANIES OPERATING IN DENMARK Home-based English version Please select a language: SECTION A: INTRODUCTION English... 1 Danish... 2 First page: EMPLOYMENT
Chapter 10 Advertising and What We Eat The Case of Dairy Products Noel Blisard Two national programs for dairy advertising, authorized by Congress, have concentrated on advertising for fluid milk and cheese.
Quarterly Report World Manufacturing Production Statistics for Quarter IV, 2013 Statistics Unit www.unido.org/statistics Report on world manufacturing production, Quarter IV, 2013 UNIDO Statistics presents
PRINCIPAL BUSINESS ACTIVITIES OF THE COMPANY S. No. Field Name Instructions II Number of business Enter the number of business undertaken by the company. II Main code Based on the number of business undertaken,
Feedback Baked Products in South Africa Food 2012 Baked Products Product Definitions Products Bread Rolls Speciality Breads Baked Confectionery Definitions This category is divided into white bread, brown
Waste Action Plan Author: Alan Spray Securing crop supply through whole crop purchasing This Action Plan is intended to be used by a Director or Senior individual within a Procurement function in a Retail
Selection and Preparation of Foods Management of the Food Budget* Healthy meals on a limited budget! How can you serve healthy meals on a limited budget? It takes some time and planning, but you and your
2005 World Robot Market Total world-wide sales: 126,700 units, up 30% on 2004 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY World total stock of operational industrial robots: 923,000 units, 9% greater than 2004 World market surged
Walking the Silk Road: Understanding Canada s Changing Trade Patterns International Trade and Investment Centre May 16, 2012 Michael Burt Director, Industrial Economic Trends email@example.com 200
Peru Driven mainly by domestic demand and rising investments, Peru s economy will be one of the best-performing economies in South America in 2014 according to Euromonitor International. The trade agreement
EMBARGOED UNTIL RELEASE AT 8:30 A.M. EDT, WEDNESDAY JUNE 1, 2005 Thomas Anderson: (202) 606-9879 BEA 05-23 Foreign Direct Investors Outlays to Acquire or Establish U.S. Businesses Rose in 2004 In 2004,
North Carolina in the Global Economy Presentation to the 2015 mfgcon NC State McKimmon Conference & Training Center Lukas Brun Senior Research Analyst October 20, 2015 Agenda Center background & activities
CIPS Position on Practice P&SM: Supply Chain Management The supply chain conceptually covers the entire physical process from ordering and obtaining the raw materials through all process steps until the
Bulletins of the Number Manufacturing Performance Survey June 2005 33 Innovation: More than Research and Development Growth opportunities on different innovation paths Steffen Kinkel, Gunter Lay and Jürgen
Seafood & sustainability - Influences on the buying behaviour of seafood purchasers Royal Greenland/Deloitte Sustainability 2015 2 Royal Greenland/Deloitte Sustainability 2015 Contents Preface 1. Introduction
The Changing Shape of UK Manufacturing Author Name(s): Michael Hardie and Andrew Banks Abstract The contribution of the manufacturing industry to the UK economy has changed markedly over the last 60 years.
#LPE12 Communicating Sustainable Food Certification Schemes and the Supply Chain Dr David Barling, Centre of Food Policy, City University Presentation Overview 1. Sustainable food: standards & certification
Food waste prevention in Norway Miljøstyrelsens Conference 28th November 2014, Copenhagen Ole Jørgen Hanssen, Østfoldforskning Østfoldforskning Located in Fredrikstad, Østfold, SE Norway Established 1.
Trends in the advertising market Report 2015/12 Monthly report on developments in the Swiss advertising market Highlights in December 2 Short summary of the advertising year 2015 3 Advertising impact within
Business and Agricultural Loans Business Loan Proposals Fund based business requirements. Non fund based business requirement. Classification of Loans based on Loan Pricing Sub-PLR (Prime Lending Rate)
You need to be aware, however, that the operative decisions have to be integrated within the broader corporate framework established by the strategic decisions. In consequence, you must always refer to
Quarterly Report World Manufacturing Production Statistics for Quarter III, 2013 Statistics Unit www.unido.org/statistics Report on world manufacturing production, Quarter III, 2013 UNIDO Statistics presents
Just Married Level: 1º E.S.O. Grammar: Demonstratives: this, that, these, those. Use of the definite and indefinite article "a", "the". Some and any, countable uncountable nouns. Irregular plurals Functions:
Value of production of agricultural products and foodstuffs, wines, aromatised wines and spirits protected by a geographical indication (GI) TENDER N AGRI 2011 EVAL 04 Leaflet October 2012 The information
Comparing Chinese Investment into North America and Europe 1 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Chinese outbound foreign direct investment (OFDI) has grown rapidly in recent years and is increasingly flowing to high-income
The Canadian perspective Retail landscape transformation Sheila Botting Partner Financial Advisory Deloitte Jennifer Lee Partner Financial Advisory Deloitte The way that Canadians live, work and shop is
Realizing the full potential of maintenance Company Introduction CONTENTS Quant is a global leader in industrial maintenance. For over 25 years, we have been realizing the full potential of maintenance
Policy on Scoping Quality/Environmental Management Systems Certification Bodies Purpose: The purpose of this policy is to ensure that the International Accreditation Service (IAS) applicants and accredited
Chapter 3 - Demand and Supply - Sample Questions Answers are at the end fo this file MULTIPLE CHOICE. Choose the one alternative that best completes the statement or answers the question. 1) A relative
EC-learnings: how to measure e-commerce? Peter Boeegh-Nielsen Statistics Denmark Sejrøgade 11 2100 Copenhagen Ø Denmark E-mail firstname.lastname@example.org 1. Introduction Statistics on the Information Society is one of
Actual Inflows & Stocks of Foreign Direct Investments (Millions of dollars) in KSA by Country & Sector FDI Inflows Total Stock ( Millions of dollars ) TOTAL FDI Inflow to KSA (Millions of dollars) 8 8,,,,88
IRG-Rail (13) 2 Independent Regulators Group Rail IRG Rail Annual Market Monitoring Report February 2013 Index 1 Introduction...3 2 Aim of the report...3 3 Methodology...4 4 Findings...5 a) Market structure...5
A Matter of Perspective? Some comments to the draft report from the project In Search of Process Based Regional Policy (PROB) Knut H. Sørensen Introductory remarks The PROB project has produced three case
Framework for data integration in support of SNA compilation and modeling: Exercise for use of SNA in early estimates and projections in Central America By Jan W. van Tongeren, IVO. April 2006. A. Framework
Just good isn t good enough We have the energy and motivation to be the best. We want to learn and improve constantly. We appreciate a challenging partnership with our customers and colleagues. By sharpening
Flash Eurobarometer INVESTING IN INTANGIBLES: ECONOMIC ASSETS AND INNOVATION DRIVERS FOR GROWTH REPORT Fieldwork: January February 213 Publication: May 213 This survey has been requested by the European
DISTRIBUTIVE TRADE AND SERVICE INDUSTRIES STATISTICS 1. Introduction Distributive trade and service industries [DTSI] account for a substantial proportion of economic activities in every country, whether
Yvonne van Everdingen, Jos van Hillegersberg, and Eric Waarts ERP ADOPTION BY EUROPEAN MIDSIZE COMPANIES Searching for ERP systems offering a perfect fit. JEAN-FRANCOIS PODEVIN Until recently, the major
2 Pine Trees, Chertsey Lane, Staines-upon-Thames, TW18 3HR, UK ISO/IEC 17021:2011 to provide environmental management systems certification to Unit 6, Gordano Court Gordano Gate Business Park Serbert Close
Research briefing October 2005 Do good environmental management systems lead to good environmental performance? Stephanie Maier/ Kelly Vanstone Inside What are environmental management systems?... 2 Measuring
European Union, Trade in goods with USA Table of Contents pg - Key Figures 2 - / 2015 2 - - AMA/NAMA product Groups 2 - - SITC product Groups 2 - - Top 5 - HS sections 2 - - Top 5 - SITC sections 2 - EU
This is to signify that STAREGISTER INTERNATIONAL INC 250 NORTH WASHTENAW AVENUE CHICAGO, ILLINOIS 60612 Management System Certification Body MSCB-107 has met the International Accreditation Service (IAS)
Employment Trends in the Western Region Roscommon Education & Training Fair, 13 Jan 2012 Pauline White, Policy Analyst, Western Development Commission WESTERN DEVELOPMENT COMMISSION 7-county Western Region
www.anuga.com NEWS 2015 COLOGNE, 10. 14.10.2015 10 TRADE SHOWS IN ONE Anuga News 2015 The very good result of the 32nd Anuga in Cologne is reflected in the around 155,000 trade visitors from 187 countries
Summary: Norwegian Foreign Visitor Survey 2011 TØI Report 1166/2011 Author(s): Eivind Farstad, Arne Rideng and Iratxe Landa Mata Oslo 2011, 67 pages Norwegian language In 2011 a total of 5.0 million foreign
INVESTING IN SAINT LUCIA SPECIALIZED INVESTMENT OPPORTUNITIES FOR SMART BUSINESS PRESENTED BY: McHale Andrew CEO INVEST SAINT LUCIA SAINT LUCIA - Country Profile 2 Source: Central Statistics Office ECONOMIC
NIT 5: Food I like UNIT L e s s o n 1 1.vv vvlisten and read Debbie: Do you want some chocolate, Leo? Leo: No, thank you. I love chocolate but I can t eat it. I want to be a football player and sport men
Statistical Data on Women Entrepreneurs in Europe September 2014 Enterprise and Industry EUROPEAN COMMISSION Directorate-General for Enterprise and Industry Directorate D SMEs and Entrepreneurship Unit
The Conclusions The Nordic Tourism Index 212 The Nordic Investment Index 212 Nights spent in the Nordic countries The total number of guest nights in the Nordic countries included in the 212 Nordic Investment
Bottled Water - Market Overview July 2012 Disclaimer The following information is offered in good faith and represents an unqualified interpretation of a range of industry commentary and market data. It
AQA Level 3 Technical Level Business Marketing principles Unit Number: Y/506/6086 Specimen Question Paper Time allowed: 2 hours Instructions Use black ink or black ball-point pen Answer all questions You
Ireland and the EU 1973-2003 Economic and Social Change Table 1 Population, 1971-2002 viii Table 2 Population of the provinces ix Table 3 Births, deaths and life expectancy ix Table 4 Numbers in education