arxiv: v1 [cs.ai] 23 Nov 2013

Transcription

1 A brief network analysis of Artificial Intelligence publication Yunpeng Li a, Jie Liu a, Yong Deng a,b, a School of Computer and Information Science, Southwest University, Chongqing, , China b School of Engineering, Vanderbilt University, Nashville, TN, 37235, USA arxiv: v1 [cs.ai] 23 Nov 2013 Abstract In this paper, we present an illustration to the history of Artificial Intelligence(AI) with a statistical analysis of publish since We collected and mined through the IEEE publish data base to analysis the geological and chronological variance of the activeness of research in AI. The connections between different institutes are showed. The result shows that the leading community of AI research are mainly in the USA, China, the Europe and Japan. The key institutes, authors and the research hotspots are revealed. It is found that the research institutes in the fields like Data Mining, Computer Vision, Pattern Recognition and some other fields of Machine Learning are quite consistent, implying a strong interaction between the community of each field. It is also showed that the research of Electronic Engineering and Industrial or Commercial applications are very active in California. Japan is also publishing a lot of papers in robotics. Due to the limitation of data source, the result might be overly influenced by the number of published articles, which is to our best improved by applying network keynode analysis on the research community instead of merely count the number of publish. Keywords: Artificial Intelligence, Network Analysis, Keyword Network 1. Introduction Artificial Intelligence has been a long-pursuing goal of scientists, technicians and even novelists and philosophers long before the birth of electronic computer[1, 2, 3, 4, 5]. But it is until the Corresponding author: Yong Deng, School of Computer and Information Science, Southwest University, Chongqing, , China. address: ydeng@swu.edu.cn, prof.deng@hotmail.com. Tel/Fax:(86-23) Preprint submitted to Elsevier November 26, 2013

2 1940s when electronic computing machines was successfully developed that we have a chance to create such fantasy in places outside our dreams and papers[1, 6, 7]. The invention of computer becomes a trigger in the history of AI, booming the experimental research which in turn prompts the theoretical developments as well[8, 9]. Over the past 73 years, many kinds methods has been raised, developed and diminished, as well as communities and researchers. A lot of reviews [10, 11? ]and short histories[5] has published to give brief summary of the development of AI. Most of such reviews are made by the witness of the big things[1]. In this paper, we present an illustrative review of the history of Artificial Intelligence(AI) by statistically analysing the publish over the past 73 years. Many resources of online publish data base has been considered before choosing the IEEE Xplore as the unique data recourse of the research. 610,051 articles are returned responding to our query, which occupies 1/6 of the entire IEEE database. Then we applied natural language processing techniques to analysis the meta data returned by the query. The authors, affiliations and keywords are the main fields in our analysis. Then we build a coauthor network of authors as the fundament of our analysis. The coreness of each author is caculated (to be added). The importance in research of each institute and country is based on the authors coreness in them(to be added). By clustering the keywords network which is derived from the co-occurring relations of the keywords, a keyword-to-field table is made as the fundament of the by-field analysis. It is showed that while the research in Data Mining, Pattern Recognition, Computer Vision and Machine Learning are quite consistent, Electronic Engineering, Robots and application-orientated researches are highly centralized. 2. The method The data applied in this research is retrieved via IEEE Xplore XML search API at[12, 13]. We choose IEEE API because it is sufficiently representative, abundant in volume and convenient for use. Most of other scholar APIs we have also referred to can be found at The raw data was allocated with a query word of AI, Data Mining, Natural Language Processing and synonyms in the field of title and keywords (including Thesaurus Terms, Inspect Controlled Terms and Index Terms, see definitions at As of 2

3 Oct. 15, 2013, the query returned 610,051 results of the 3,563,516 articles in IEEE data base. The total volume of the XML reply files is 1.39 GB. Then the raw data is processed with R. Unnecessary symbols like quotes, slashes and dashes are all replaced with blanks. For the scale of consistency, all the and are replaced with symbol &. All the the, no matter leading or not, are eliminated. All the at are also eliminated because they are often placed between the name of a university and the location of the campus, and might be left out in other cases which causes duplication. Leading, tailing and duplicated blanks are eliminated. All abbreviations and acronyms occurring 10 times or above are rewritten, like, among which the most popular abbreviation Univ., is rewritten as University. Some synonyms are also unified. For instance, University of California are replaced with California University. Besides structuralizing and calibrating the meta data, we also applied some text mining processes to excavate the affiliation (university, institute or company) and geological information (city, state, postcode and nation) of each author for further analysis. Since each paper is related to one or more authors but only one affiliation, we associated this affiliation information with the first author. Then we aggregated the geological information of all the authors in certain organization to get the geological information of the organization itself. Typically the needed information is the most frequent non-empty string of such field. However,in order to deal with organizations with multiple sites (typically universities with different campuses like California University and New York University, which has campuses in different countries), all the cities meeting certain conditions need to be reserved. In this study, to aggregate the city information, we kept the most frequent non-empty one, and all others of which the frequency is beyond 5 times and 3 percent of the most frequent one at the same time. Then the state, postcode and nation terms are the most frequent non-empty one of each field in each city. We then adhere the city name at the end of the organization name for secernment. In following processes, different sites are regarded as independent entities. Further more, most organizations are then accompanied with their coordinate in order to illustrate some of our results with a map. For 2105 organizations in the US, all coordinates are queried with google map geocode API. Then 27,715 organizations outside US are matched 3

4 with a coordinate dataset of 257,495 cities all over the world, nation by nation. After these processes, 14,422 organizations are still not matched with coordinates. Then we tried to match these organizations with our dataset of cities to the name of the organization institutes are such matched. Then we processed the rest again with google map API. At this step, 6,546 out of all the 29,820 organizations are matched with its coordinate. Then we reverse geocode the coordinates to check for validity and to complete nation / state fields. 351 coordinates are found inconsistent with nations, most of them (35) are at French-Swiss border. We checked them with google map and believe such error is due to the minor mistakes of map at the border. These coordinates are reserved and all others are taken as mistakes and reset to NA. 3. Results The processed data is then analyzed for revealing trends and connections in AI research. We first build the network of authors with coauthor relationship. For each paper, we build a undirected complete graph of weight 1 between all authors. The links connecting the same pair of nodes are then accumulated. In total, there are 4,954,982 links between 662,762 authors with a total weight of 7,133,757. The distribution of degrees of each author is as following: It can be seen from Fig. 1 that the coauthor network fits the power-law quite well. This suggests that the coauthor network is possibly a scale-free complex network. It is also showed in Fig. 1 an abnormal decrease in number of authors with degree of 2 to 4. The reason might be that most of the papers are published in a group of 3 rather than 1 or 2. It could be seen that the number of authors in each paper also have a decrease at the beginning, which might be the reason. In this we may conclude that most of research in AI are made up of three or more participants Global connection After getting the coauthor network, we used it to find the cooperation relations between organizations, mainly universities. Generally, Fig. 2 maps the coauthor network to the globe. Each line is the geological big circle (i.e. the shortest path between two points on the sphere) of the linked organizations. From the 4,954,982 coauthor relations between authors, we obtained 4

5 10,000,000 1,000, ,000 10,000 Count 1,000 Degree Number Degree / Number Fig 1. Degree distribution of coauthor network of AI research(o) and distribution of author numbers of papers ( ) on a double logarithmic scale

6 6 Fig 2. Global connection of universities, institutes, companies and other research institutes

7 486,120 connections between 29,820 organizations. The connections are all illustrated on Fig. 2. It could be clearly seen on the map that most of the researchers locate in the United States of America, China, Japan, and some countries of Europe like the United Kingdom, Germany and France. Researches in Brazil, Singapore, India and Australia are also very active. These national differences are more obvious in Fig. 3, which accumulates the links by nation. It is significant that the United States and China are leading partners of global research cooperations. Japan, although geologically close to China, are more connected to the US and European countries academically Global distribution With the method to be described in 3.3, we also get maps of activity in each field of AI. It could be seen that the research institutes in the fields like Data Mining, Computer Vision, Pattern Recognition and some other fields of Machine Learning are quite consistent, implying a strong interaction between the community of each field. The most active research has taken places in the institutes of the United States, China, Singapore and the United Kingdom. Despite the consistency, yet a small but interesting difference in such fields is that the activeness in Computer Vision, Pattern Recognition, Data Mining are in descending order for the west countries (the United States and England), but ascending for the east countries (China and Singapore). It is also clear that the United States is extremely competitive in the research of Electronic Engineering, especially for the Californian Institutes, which is also very strong at combining AI with industrial and commercial products. As for Robots, the United States, especially the northeast corner of which, and Japan are dominating most of the researches, which is not unexpected at all. It is also interesting to statistic the performance of the top researching institutes, mainly universities, and their area of professional. The 20 most active universities in the community of AI is showed in Fig. 4. It is clearly seen that the California University is the biggest host to many productive researchers. Best of our effort has been made to clarify the affiliation of them but due to the incompleted addresses left by many of the researchers, the exact affiliation of many of them are still indistinguishable, leaving the California University the biggest host to researchers. As for followers, Tsinghua University is the most productive institute in AI, if we 7

8 Fig 3. Global connection of universities, institutes, companies and other research institutes

9 (a) Data Mining (b) Computer Vision (c) Pattern Recognition (d) other fields of Machine Learning (e) Robot (f) Electronic Engineering (g) other fields of Computer Science (h) Industrial and Commercial Applications Table 1: global research interest distribution in AI

10 choose not to take the California University as a single entity. Tsinghua is competitive in almost every field of AI, only to except Robots and EE, which are dominated by the United States and Japan. On the other hand, Carnegie Mellon University, the second productive university in AI, is extremely competitive in Robots, which, in our statistics, is even stronger than California University as a whole. Massachusetts Institute of Technology, which ranks the 20th in this list, might be suffering an under-representation from the number of the publish. It is also found that the groups of research team are generally much bigger in China and Singapore than in the US etc. Explanations and analysis to be added in the next version From keywords to fields In order to analysis the presentation of entities in different fields, we need a table to map each keyword to a certain subfield of AI. There are some ways to accomplish such procedure like ontology, clustering or just assign the field manually. In this review, we made the classification via clustering and then manually checked the result. We monitor the most popular 1000 keywords, and build a network of their correlations. Each of the keywords of the same paper are linked with an undirected edge of weight 1, then duplicated edges are accumulated. After building the keyword network, which occupies 1000 keywords and 542,048 edges with a total weight of 3,716,812, we used the random walk algorithm to detect the community structure of the network. The hierarchical structure of the monitored keywords is showed in Fig. 5. Noting that a complete graph of 1000 nodes contains 999,000 edges, the keyword network contains 54.26% of the complete graph, and holds an average weight of 6.85, implying quite a strongly connected graph. Then we cut the dendrogram at a place to get 50 groups. The groups are manually classified into 8 fields of Data Mining (DM), Computer Vision (CV), Pattern Recognition (PR, which includes keywords like handwriting recognition which involves both PR and CV), other fields of Machine Learning (ML, mainly general proposed algorithms like Neural Networks, and supporting theories like rough set), Robots (Robot), Electronic Engineering (EE, mainly microelectronics and communication), other fields of Computer Science (CS, mainly computer architecture related and programming methodology), and Application

11 Fig 4. Top researching universities in AI 11

12 areas(application, including industrial and commercial products). The group assignment of 65 keywords out of the 1000 are manually corrected. The monitored 1000 keywords are then applied to the dataset to find the main research area of each author. The activity of each author in certain field is related to the number of published articles in the field. Each paper is assigned to the 8 fields proportionally to its membership of the fields according to its keywords. For example, if an article has 10 keywords, 3 of them are in PR, 2 of the rest are in DM, and the rest are not monitored, then we say the article is 0.6 PR and 0.4 DM, which will contribute to the activity in these fields of the author. The monitored keywords occupy % ( 1,400,000 out of 6,771,660) of the keywords in the dataset. The activity of each author is the sum of the fields of all papers the author have ever published.the most productive authors in each field is listed in Fig.??(to be added). With similar processes, we may also find the activity of research by field of institutes, cities and countries, as is already showed in Section 3.1 and Hot words With the keyword to field correspondence obtained in Section 3.3, we made a further exploration into the hot words in recent 5 years. The 5 year span covers the publish in As this research is carried out at mid-october, some of the publish in year 2013 might be unavailable at the time our data was collected. The result is showed in Fig. 7. It is clearly showed that technique-neutral words are generally more popular. Data Mining, Learning, Training, Computational Modeling are all among the hottest 10 keywords. Support Vector Machines, as a technique-specific term, seems to be an exception, which is the 3 rd hottest keyword. Feature Extraction, the 2 nd hottest one, benefiting from the rising attention in Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition, is neither as neutral as DM nor as specific as SVM. Meanwhile the Educational Institutions may be a dark horse for the MOOC movement is in full swing. 4. Chronological analysis Besides the features discussed in section 3, there might be some more inspiring information beclouded. While static analysis offers us some overall status of AI research, or what the status 12

13 is like, chronological analysis can tell us how it becomes like this. In this section, we divided the dataset of papers by the year it was published, and reapplied some of the analysis carried out in 3 to find out how the AI community evolves over the past 73 years ( ) Total publish over year Since the development of ENIAC, EDVAC and Colossus in the 1940s, Artificial Intelligence has come to more reality than just fantasy. Computers provided a chance to bring the theoretical possibilities of intelligent machines. But the annual publish in AI seems not much affected by the events. The publish number raise exponentially steadily. The annual publish can be fitted with publish = exp(year ) with a Adjusted R-squared of Trend in keywords 4.3. Community evolution 5. Conclusion and outlook In this review, a statistical review of the history of AI in publish is presented. The publish in IEEE data base is analyzed to give some holistic analysis of the global research in AI. We collected and mined through the IEEE publish data base to analysis the geological and chronological variance of the activeness of research in AI. The connections between different institutes are showed. The result shows that the leading community of AI research are mainly in the USA, China, the Europe and Japan. The key institutes, authors and the research hotspots are revealed. It is found that the research institutes in the fields like Data Mining, Computer Vision, Pattern Recognition and some other fields of Machine Learning are quite consistent, implying a strong interaction between the community of each field. It is also showed that the research of Electronic Engineering and Industrial or Commercial applications are very active in California. Japan is also publishing a lot of papers in robotics. Due to the limitation of data source, the result might be overly influenced by the number of published articles, which is to our best improved by applying network keynode analysis on the research community instead of merely count the number of publish. 13

14 electrocardiography shape gesture recognition biomedical imaging digital images cancer routing writing computers data models data handling data structures multimedia systems multimedia communication document handling computational efficiency random variables time series probabilistic logic signal processing signal detection surgery roads entropy tv logic contracts yarn intelligent agent gallium arsenide iii v semiconductors current measurement temperature capacitance gold silicon probes telecommunication network reliability database management systems hidden markov models image processing vectors support vector machines layout classification algorithms support vector machine classification image coding image retrieval remote sensing principal component analysis gaussian processes maximum likelihood estimation character recognition training data detectors geometry image databases feature extraction image recognition video signal processing image analysis object detection computer vision object recognition wavelet transforms image classification image segmentation face recognition cameras motion estimation electroencephalography medical signal processing interpolation noise face detection estimation filtering theory covariance matrix handwriting recognition three dimensional displays unsupervised learning neurophysiology matrix decomposition pixel image representation image edge detection image colour analysis image color analysis histograms image matching educational institutions computer science monitoring electronic mail joining processes stereo image processing face independent component analysis image sensors signal classification smoothing methods spectral analysis emotion recognition brain modeling gaussian distribution discrete cosine transforms content based retrieval geophysical techniques noise reduction noise robustness speaker recognition acoustic signal processing correlation methods quantization transforms brain video surveillance color discrete wavelet transforms computational linguistics fourier transforms skin synthetic aperture radar image resolution image texture medical image processing telephony image motion analysis image sequences edge detection image reconstruction parameter estimation neural networks computational modeling cities and towns information science context modeling lighting informatics standards assembly physics computing paper technology software algorithms elemental semiconductors cardiology frequency domain analysis geophysical signal processing image restoration wavelet analysis signal resolution gaussian noise solid modelling patient diagnosis fractals transform coding cellular biophysics biometrics (access control) document image processing biometrics optical character recognition software videos radar detection singular value decomposition acoustic noise mutual information vegetation mapping linear discriminant analysis video sequences spatial resolution data processing abstracts silicon compounds annealing motion analysis geophysical image processing image fusion computed tomography gabor filters image enhancement biomedical mri magnetic resonance imaging algebra image registration radar imaging kalman filters backpropagation prototypes neural nets learning (artificial intelligence) artificial neural networks performance evaluation performance analysis instruments neurons mathematics space technology virtual reality interactive systems cognition computer displays australia materials organizing cad ultrasonic imaging medical robotics inverse problems human robot interaction multi layer neural network art function approximation feedforward neural nets radial basis function networks games road vehicles generalisation (artificial intelligence) approximation theory production engineering computing parallel algorithms benchmark testing laboratories boolean functions virtual environment minimisation feedforward neural networks least squares approximation position measurement biological neural networks spread spectrum communication synchronisation stock markets vibrations accelerometers convergence state estimation equations jacobian matrices finite element methods knowledge based systems systems engineering and theory multiaccess communication pipelines tracking signal generators robot vision robot vision systems multilayer perceptrons least squares approximations large scale systems system testing game theory decision making intelligent networks traffic control automata transportation cognitive radio explosions councils weapons joints muscles gradient methods adaptive filters least squares methods planning nonlinear filters biomechanics target tracking electromyography machine vision iterative methods noise measurement mean square error methods eigenvalues and eigenfunctions robustness matrix algebra knowledge acquisition computerized monitoring aerospace computing environmental factors nasa sensor arrays risk management risk analysis calculus estimation theory iterative algorithms working environment noise logistics supervised learning wireless sensor networks hardware signal processing algorithms delay statistics field programmable gate arrays communication system control power engineering and energy signal analysis signal to noise ratio self organising feature maps wireless communication parallel architectures pipeline processing synchronization digital filters frequency estimation electrodes array signal processing design methodology cellular radio calibration frequency measurement very large scale integration digital simulation batteries optical sensors switches decision trees event detection patient monitoring failure analysis pattern analysis clustering methods visualization geophysics computing dictionaries inference mechanisms computer simulation mathematics computing reliability medical computing data mining computer graphics linear programming condition monitoring wire medical treatment vlsi computer animation pattern matching computational intelligence space exploration merging marine vehicles aircraft geology biomedical monitoring indexes computerised monitoring real time systems automation displays psychology quality control sun complexity theory real time systems redundancy sorting petroleum graph theory trees (mathematics) expert systems safety encoding partitioning algorithms automotive engineering system performance planning (artificial intelligence) economic forecasting aerospace electronics earth particle measurements testing artificial intelligence energy consumption manufacturing data acquisition logic design logic testing interference helium clocks time measurement computer aided manufacturing design automation analytical models relays stress timing fading fires rough set theory packaging bandwidth algorithm design and analysis multi agent systems statistical analysis clustering algorithms costs pattern clustering design engineering accuracy speech recognition user interfaces production control system synthesis information processing random access memory microprocessor chips microprocessors multidimensional systems microcomputers topology set theory job shop scheduling inspection fault tolerance usa councils arithmetic heuristic algorithms character generation power system management manufacturing systems petri nets computer errors energy management intelligent systems visual databases global positioning system production systems spatial databases content based retrieval manufacturing processes indexing text analysis problem solving pricing decoding maintenance engineering software packages rendering (computer graphics) music speech synthesis embedded systems correlation process design automatic testing bioinformatics genetics biology computing manufacturing industries multiagent systems sequences economics proteins environmental economics investments genomics dna multiprocessing systems embedded system molecular biophysics fault tolerant computing speech processing processor scheduling scheduling classification tree analysis discrete event simulation automatic speech recognition scheduling algorithm speech speech analysis labeling data communication data compression throughput video coding network topology watermarking computer interfaces diseases medical services medical diagnostic imaging satellites data engineering computational geometry surveillance training kernel filtering pattern recognition bayes methods machine learning query processing authentication agriculture access control arrays cooperative systems rivers sea measurements reflection transmitters oceans man machine systems communication system traffic control load management reliability engineering production facilities modems clouds virtual manufacturing voting time factors process planning drugs gene expression heart asynchronous transfer mode fingerprint recognition ground penetrating radar traffic engineering computing medical information systems multimedia computing health care buildings history approximation methods graphical user interfaces computer games regression analysis aggregates random processes knowledge engineering decision support systems solid modeling finance human factors biomedical engineering engines bridges knowledge representation nearest neighbor searches sparse matrices military computing pattern classification error analysis parallel processing research and development error statistics computer networks instruction sets bayesian methods machine learning algorithms registers workstations filters statistical distributions time series analysis concurrent computing sensor fusion telecommunication computing road traffic books computer applications handicapped aids application software animals europe polynomials protection proposals high performance computing optimisation approximation algorithms vehicles sampling methods libraries radiofrequency identification sensors broadcasting cybernetics databases intrusion detection data analysis decision theory machine intelligence tree data structures data visualization computational complexity biological system modeling animation data visualisation grammars probability markov processes prediction algorithms human computer interaction humans graphics probability distribution belief networks measurement frequency information theory conferences information analysis information filters soil scattering information filtering observers extraterrestrial measurements geographic information systems itemsets nonlinear systems association rules hospitals force control natural languages motion control streaming media position control nonlinear dynamical systems vocabulary natural language processing optimal control motion pictures stability actuators predictive control manipulator dynamics multimedia databases information retrieval servers damping internet mobile computing data security information security three term control security of data torque velocity control temperature control collaboration servomechanisms computer aided instruction adaptive control information management peer to peer computing fuzzy control ip networks grid computing nonlinear control systems neurocontrollers robust control programmable control telecommunication security computer crime peer to peer computing friction computer security rotors management information systems induction motors closed loop systems lyapunov methods public domain software organizations stators electronic learning distance learning collaborative work machine control computer science education robots java electronic commerce groupware business underwater vehicles torque control intelligent robots ubiquitous computing cloud computing xml robot kinematics humanoid robots robot sensing systems service robots robotics and automation remotely operated vehicles vehicle dynamics multi robot systems permanent magnet motors pervasive computing authorisation web server privacy ontologies (artificial intelligence) ontologies path planning mobile robots orbital robotics wheels portals data privacy legged locomotion trajectory collision avoidance content management information resources html robot control manipulators kinematics world wide web distributed databases communities social network services data warehouses relational databases meta data fuzzy neural nets web sites linear systems web pages search engines semantics fuzzy logic control systems steady state fuzzy neural networks nonlinear equations recommender systems social networking (online) web services fuzzy systems intelligent control recurrent neural nets recurrent neural networks stability analysis service oriented architecture owl semantic web error correction software maintenance software quality unified modeling language software architecture middleware power generation power generation economics transfer functions software reusability identification stochastic systems software development management documentation web and internet services open systems network servers knowledge management automatic control voltage control power system reliability power system security power system protection power markets software metrics power system planning electricity supply industry context aware services client server systems business data processing reverse engineering industrial control power system control power system stability product development project management formal specification specification languages software prototyping software tools learning systems power systems load flow program testing software testing computer network management object oriented programming software systems software engineering software design programming navigation sensor systems stochastic processes search problems fuzzy set theory optimization intelligent sensors optimization methods dynamic programming inference algorithms reactive power power system analysis computing power system simulation electrical equipment industry power system economics substations systems analysis program verification automobiles power transmission lines software reliability organisational aspects innovation management educational programs computer aided software engineering software agents engineering education computer industry teaching biological cells predictive models upper bound immune system haptic interfaces man machine systems conference management consumer electronics technological innovation object oriented methods industries resource allocation resource management permission linux protocols evolutionary computation cost function acceleration distributed processing formal verification educational courses programming profession operating systems computer languages technology management telecommunication traffic information technology computer architecture genetic algorithms mathematical model fault diagnosis uncertainty feedback quality of service fuzzy sets power system modeling process control design optimization delay effects simulated annealing genetic mutations message passing productivity engineering management object oriented modeling environmental management companies ad hoc networks adaptive systems cryptography context software information systems voltage runtime power engineering computing fault detection delays distributed control couplings mechanical engineering product design digital signal processing constraint optimization space vehicles adaptation models uncertainty handling supply chains supply chain management fault location genetic programming signal design cache storage feeds programming environments software performance program compilers mobile agents quality management wireless networks telecommunication network routing telecommunication network management wireless lan routing protocols educational technology education security distributed computing mobile communication degradation monte carlo methods circuit testing circuits particle swarm optimization chaos mobile handsets government fuzzy reasoning parallel programming availability concrete scalability physics circuit faults circuit simulation particle swarm optimisation state space methods radio frequency control engineering computing impedance mobile radio local area networks transport protocols access protocols software libraries learning load forecasting differential equations database systems taxonomy usability mechatronics communications technology terminology law finite element analysis resonance generators load modeling microcontrollers discrete event systems steel competitive intelligence transaction databases marketing and sales cultural differences program processors standards development guidelines personnel logic programming lattices receivers integrated circuit interconnections temperature sensors application specific integrated circuits logic gates integrated circuit design integrated circuit testing capacitors conductors power measurement temperature measurement iron storage management copper employment lead solids cmos integrated circuits digital signal processing chips input variables robot programming coils packet switching reflectivity fluctuations aging sensor phenomena and characterization

15 image matching image colour analysis indexing medical image processing histograms prototypes fault diagnosis standards cloud computing computational modeling electronic mail image retrieval speech bayes methods shape training application resource allocation unified modeling language performance evaluation ubiquitous computing technological innovation power engineering computing data privacy telecommunication traffic computer networks programming cryptography CS routing cities and towns user interfaces mobile communication search engines query processing computer science education field programmable gate arrays information science reliability resource management real time systems machine learning algorithms technology management measurement multi agent systems biological system modeling web sites performance analysis virtual reality information systems instruments materials security of data control systems radial basis function networks design engineeringeconomics conferences application software web services prediction algorithms organizations software engineering computer aided instruction fuzzy logic approximation methods grid computing computers buildings knowledge management software ip networks computational complexity sensor fusion backpropagation education laboratories scheduling engines information analysis cognition computer science games entropy markov processes ML image analysis data structures computer architecture motion estimation quality of service mobile computing internet vehicles neural networks image reconstruction companies collaboration decision making machine learning approximation theory principal component analysis educational institutions decision trees computational intelligence servers java probability matrix algebra medical signal processing computer vision protocols robustness history image motion analysis business probabilistic logic algorithm design and analysis image color analysis data models unsupervised learning neurons biomedical imaging xml image coding iterative methods humans remote sensing image segmentation learning clustering algorithms discrete wavelet transforms sensors electroencephalography time series analysis image recognition pixel artificial neural networks sampling methods image representation feature extraction artificial intelligence polynomials wavelet transforms cameras transforms face ontologies regression analysis lighting CV face detection object detection motion control intelligent robots face recognition data mining clocks filtering theory rotorshardware logic gates manufacturing video signal processing color image classification wireless sensor networks network topology gaussian processes legged locomotion image edge detection noisesupport vector machines probes manipulators object recognition trajectory radio frequency image resolution accuracy genetics visualization analytical models finite element analysis image sequences layout context edge detection databases mobile robots robotics and automation data analysis vibrations covariance matrix testing arrays vectors delay wheels indexes psychology semantics labeling helium assembly cancer estimation silicon text analysis kernel geophysical image processing pattern clustering parallel processing dictionaries diseases graph theory pattern classification wireless communication timing correlation position control vocabulary information retrieval robot sensing systems EE bioinformatics encoding data acquisition natural language processing hidden markov models service robots machine control geographic information systems statistical analysis support vector machine classification data visualisation failure analysis biology computing visual databases classification algorithms bayesian methods target tracking receivers pattern recognition synchronization natural languages speech recognition kalman filters calibration degradation semantic web detectors robot vision eigenvalues and eigenfunctions data visualization complexity theory proteins character recognition joints three dimensional displays permanent magnet motors data compression speech processing DM computer graphics multilayer perceptrons random access memory human computer interaction parameter estimation geometry maximum likelihood estimation tracking handwriting recognition spatial databases gradient methods information filtering teaching electronic commerce benchmark testing statistics libraries medical diagnostic imaging satellites image processing security monitoring information technology stress fuzzy control neural nets PR signal processing electrodes costs robots production bandwidth path planning lattices frequency rendering (computer graphics) knowledge based systems fuzzy neural nets robot kinematics temperature measurement approximation algorithms current measurement Fig 6. Hot words of recent 5 years publish ( ) 15

16 Birth Golden Age 1st AI Winter Boom 2nd AI Winter AI Renaissance BRAIN Initiative Watson Siri and Google Now Publish Deep Learning OWL Myspace Deep Blue defeated Kasparov Babel Fish MIT Cog project Google WWW Version spaces and Intel 8086 MIT AI Lab Perceptrons Dartmouth Conference Backpropagation expert systems ENIAC Turing Test Fuzzy Logic Lighthill Report Cray 1 IBM PC Soar Twitter Year Fig 7. Trend of annual publish since 1940

17 In this paper, due to the limitation of data source, we cannot distinguish the papers that are harbingers and milestones from the mediocrities which are only imitators or parody. The quantity of publish outweighed the quality. The innovativeness, inspiration and impact are the key values of a paper, which varies much between mileposts and imitators. In our review, due to the lack of evaluation criteria, each paper is considered equal in significance. The best effort of us has been put forward to address this awkward blemish. We performed our analysis mainly of the network property when trying to identify influential entities. An improvement could still be made if a citation map of papers is available. One may assign a significant value of papers due to their citation, or pagerank. This may improve the current situation in which quantity of publish is too much valued, which is also overwhelming in some parts of the world. Acknowledgment The work is partially supported by National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant No ), Chongqing Natural Science Foundation (Grant No. CSCT, 2010BA2003), Program for New Century Excellent Talents in University (Grant No. NCET ), Doctor Funding of Southwest University (Grant No. SWU110021). References [1] B. G. Buchanan, A (very) brief history of artificial intelligence, AI Magazine 26 (4) (2005) 53. [2] J. Haugeland, Artificial intelligence: The very idea, The MIT Press, [3] P. M. Churchland, P. S. Churchland, Could a. Machine Think?, Machine Intelligence: Perspectives on the Computational Model 1 (2012) 102. [4] J. R. Anderson, R. S. Michalski, R. S. Michalski, T. M. Mitchell, et al., Machine learning: An artificial intelligence approach, vol. 2, Morgan Kaufmann, [5] T. J. Sejnowski, Evolution of artificial intelligence, vol. 378, Nature Publishing Group, [6] H. Kitano, Intelligence in a changing world, Nature 447 (7143) (2007) [7] B. Meltzer, Clever computers, vol. 328, Nature Publishing Group, [8] D. Marr, Artificial intelligenceła personal view, Artificial Intelligence 9 (1) (1977) [9] J. Fox, Models of mind, vol. 353, Nature Publishing Group, [10] E. S. Brunette, R. Flemmer, C. L. Flemmer, A review of artificial intelligence, in: Autonomous Robots and Agents, ICARA th International Conference on, , doi: /icara , [11] R. Gregory, Heroes of AI, Nature 296 (1982)

18 [12] M. LLC, MS Windows NT Kernel Description, URL [13] CVE , IEEE, National Vulnerability Database, URL