GMMP 2015 MODULE DE FORMATION. Guide de monitorage sur l Internet 3ème partie: Analyse

Transcription

1 GMMP 2015 MODULE DE FORMATION Guide de monitorage sur l Internet 3ème partie: Analyse

2 QUESTION 21 L article traite d une femme en particulier ou d un groupe de femmes? 1. Oui 2. Non Passing sentence, Le reportage Judge porte Patrick sur Thomas la sentence QC told de Hamid: Nafees"You are without question Hamid, in jugé my coupable experience d avoir the most commis intelligent neuf man I have ever seen in the dock of a criminal court. "You, through hard work and devotion agressions to your course sexuelles of studies, sur rose des high patientes within entre your profession to become an enormously Le respected groupe de consultant femmes neurosurgeon agressées par at one of the great hospitals Hamid in sont our region." un point central dans ce The judge reportage. said everybody Elles in sont Hamid's décrites trial comme had spoken highly of his clinical skills, victimes but added: âgées "You entre were 25 brought et 65 ans. low by Coder a simple 1 failing - lust. "And you exercised your lust as a result of arrogance. You liked doing what you did, touching sexually your female patients, and you took the opportunity to do it because you could." The judge added of the offences: "This is the most extreme breach of "Instead you grossly abused them." A two-month trial heard that Hamid, of Russell Road, Moseley,

3 QUESTION 22 Le reportage met-il manifestement en évidence des problèmes touchant à l égalité ou à l inégalité entre les femmes et les hommes? 1. D accord. 2. En désaccord 3. Ni d accord ni en désaccord 4. Ne sais pas, ne parviens pas à me décider Passing sentence, Bien que Judge les paroles Patrick du Thomas juge soulignent QC told Hamid: la "You are without question in my experience the most intelligent man I have ever seen in the position dock of a de criminal pouvoir court. inégal "You, ayant through créé des hard work and devotion to conditions your course d agression of studies, rose sexuelle high par within un your profession to become an neurochirurgien enormously respected sur ses consultant patientes, neurosurgeon le reportage at one of the great hospitals in our region." n aborde pas le thème de l inégalité entre The judge femmes said everybody et hommes. in Hamid's Nous trial sommes had spoken highly of his clinical skills, désaccord but added: avec "You l affirmation were brought que low le by reportage a simple failing - lust. "And you exercised your lust as a result of arrogance. You liked doing what souligne you did, touching clairement sexually les thèmes your female liés à patients, l égalité and you took the opportunity ou à l inégalité to do it entre because femmes you could." et hommes. The judge Coder added of 2the offences: "This is the most extreme breach of "Instead you grossly abused them." A two-month trial heard that Hamid, of Russell Road, Moseley,

4 QUESTION 23 Le reportage remet-il clairement en question les stéréotypes de genre? 1. D accord. 2. En désaccord 3. Ni d accord ni en désaccord 4. Ne sais pas, ne parviens pas à me décider Passing sentence, Plusieurs Judge descripteurs Patrick Thomas parmi ceux QC told utilisés Hamid: "You are without question montrent in les my femmes experience comme the most des intelligent personnes man I have ever seen in the dock of a criminal court. "You, through hard work and devotion dociles, to your course soumises of studies, et requérant rose high être within sauvées your profession par to become an leur enormously médecin. respected Le reportage consultant ne transmet neurosurgeon pas at one of the great hospitals l idée de in our savoir region." si les femmes ont fait quelque The judge chose said everybody pour s opposer in Hamid's aux agressions trial had spoken ou si elles highly of his clinical skills, ont agi but pour added: envoyer "You were le médecin brought devant low by a les simple failing - lust. "And tribunaux. you exercised Le reportage your lust as décrit a result Hamid of arrogance. comme un You liked doing what you did, touching sexually your female patients, and you took the opportunity neurochirurgien to do it de because grande you réputation could." dans sa spécialité et ajoute qu il avait reçu plusieurs The judge reconnaissance added of the offences: ; sa carrière "This is the professionnelle most extreme breach of problems ressort and they et thought s oppose - with à sa your situation skills, présente abilities and de experience - you were criminel the person sexuel. who could Nous help sommes them with en désaccord the medical problems. "Instead avec you grossly l affirmation abused them." qui avance que ce reportage A two-month remet trial clairement heard that en Hamid, question of Russell les stéréotypes Road, Moseley, de Birmingham, genre. committed Coder the 2 offences by indecently touching patients,

5 QUESTION 24 Ce reportage mérite-t-il une analyse supplémentaire? 1. Oui 2. Non Court. The 51-year-old Il est clair was que cleared reportage by the jury ne of comporte further counts la of carried out by Hamid, perspective a highly d aucune regarded femme, and award-winning même s il se centre specialist neurosurgeon, sur at the le cas city's d une Queen agression Elizabeth sexuelle and Priory contre Hospitals. des femmes. Bien qu il soit compréhensible que l on Passing sentence, Judge Patrick Thomas QC told Hamid: "You are without question n ait in pas my experience mentionné the les most noms intelligent des femmes, man I elles have ever seen in the dock auraient of a criminal pu cependant court. "You, être through citées. hard Il est work fait and devotion to your course of studies, rose high within your profession to become an enormously plusieurs respected références consultant à la carrière neurosurgeon professionnelle at one of the great hospitals du in médecin, our region." malgré la sentence dictée contre lui pour le crime commis. Le reportage aurait été plus The judge said everybody in Hamid's trial had spoken highly of his clinical skills, but complet added: s il "You avait were inclus brought la perspective low by a simple des femmes, failing - lust. "And you en exercised particulier your des lust survivantes as a result of des arrogance. agressions, You liked doing what you desquelles did, touching nous sexually sommes your informés female patients, par les and you took the opportunity to do it because you could." commentaires du juge et de l auteur de l article. Le The judge added reportage of the offences: s avère "This intéressant is the most pour extreme une analyse breach of trust. "These ladies ultérieure. went to Coder see you 1because they had significant "Instead you grossly Inscrivez abused vos them." commentaires dans l espace A two-month trial prévu heard (Q. that 20) Hamid, si vous of avez Russell codé Road, 1 Moseley, ici.