1 The Effectiveness of Health Care Teams in the National Health Service Report Carol S. Borrill, Jean Carletta, Angela J. Carter, Jeremy F. Dawson, Simon Garrod, Anne Rees, Ann Richards, David Shapiro and Michael A. West Aston Centre for Health Service Organization Research, Aston Business School, University of Aston Human Communications Research Centre, Universities of Glasgow and Edinburgh Psychological Therapies Research Centre, University of Leeds
2 Contents Key Findings Acknowledgements Health Care Team Effectiveness Project: Summary Chapter 1 Chapter 2 Chapter 3 Chapter 4 Chapter 5 Chapter 6 Chapter 7 Chapter 8 Teamwork, Communication and Effectiveness in Health Care: A Review Page 1 Primary Health Care Team Research Methods and Sample Details Page 25 Primary Health Care Team Results from Survey and External Ratings Page 44 Qualitative Research: Developing Objectives and Effectiveness Measures for Primary Health Care Teams Page 57 Community Mental Health Teams Research Methods and Sample Details Page 78 Community Mental Health Teams Results from Survey and External Ratings Page 103 Community Mental Health Teams Results from Qualitative Research Page 121 Secondary Health Care Teams Research Methods and Sample Details Page 141 Chapter 9 Secondary Care Teams Ratings Page 157 Chapter 10 Meetings and Communication Research Methods Page 172 Chapter 11 Analysis of Communication in PHCT Teams Page 182 Chapter 12 Analysis of Communication in CHMT's Page 197 Chapter 13 Conclusions and Recommendations Page 215 Appendix I Survey Instruments/Rating Measures/Interview Schedules
3 Appendix II Appendix III Appendix IV Performance Knowing the way: Effectiveness in Primary Health Care Developing Effectiveness Measures for Primary Health Care Teams Training Programme Tools and Techniques for Assessing Bibliography
4 Acknowledgements Liaison Officers: Liz Meerabeau Sue Longsdate John Wilkinson Advisory Group Members: Debbie Mellors NHS Executive Sarah Connors NHS Executive Jim Ford NHS Executive Bonnie Sibbald NHS Executive Eileen Robertson NHS Executive Sheila Roberts Department of Health Terry Breugha University of Leicester Anne Netton University of Kent Thelma Sackman NHS Executive Research Team: Dr Carol Borrill January December 1999 Aston Business School Aston University Birmingham Sam Bedlingham June December 1999 City University London Jean Carletta January December 1999 Human Communication Research Centre Edinburgh
5 Christine Carmichael June February 1998 Institute of Work Psychology Sheffield University Sheffield Angela Carter January December 1999 Institute of Work Psychology Sheffield University Sheffield Jeremy Dawson July December 1999 Aston Business School Aston University Birmingham Simon Garrod January December 1999 Human Communications Research Centre Glasgow University Glasgow Heidi Frazer-Krauss January June 1997 Medical School Glasgow University Glasgow Anne Rees January June 1997 Psychological Therapies Research Centre Leeds University Leeds Anne Richards January December 1999 Psychological Therapies Research Centre Leeds University Leeds Carein Todd April May 1998 Institute of Work Psychology Sheffield University Sheffield David Shapiro April May 1998 Psychological Therapies Research Centre Leeds University Leeds Michael West January December 1999 Aston Business School Aston University Birmingham David Woods January June 1999 Institute of Work Psychology Sheffield University
6 Summary A primary prescription that policy makers and practitioners have offered for meeting the challenges facing the National Health Service is the development of multidisciplinary team working. The importance of team working in health care has been emphasised in numerous reports and policy documents on the National Health Service. One particularly emphasised the importance of team working if health and social care for people are to be of the highest quality and efficiency: "The best and most cost-effective outcomes for patients and clients are achieved when professionals work together, learn together, engage in clinical audit of outcomes together, and generate innovation to ensure progress in practice and service." Over the last thirty years this has proved very difficult to achieve in practice because of the barriers between professional groupings such as doctors and nurses. Other factors such as gender issues also influence team working. For example, G.P.s are predominantly men while the rest of the primary care service population is predominantly women; community mental health psychiatrists are predominantly men, whereas the rest of the population of community mental health teams is predominantly women, and in hospital settings the ranks of consultants continue to be largely made up of men. Other factors which impede the creation of effective multidisciplinary teams include multiple lines of management, perceived status differentials between different professional groups, and lack of organisational systems and structures for supporting and managing teams. The Health Care Team Effectiveness Project was commissioned by the Department of Health. The overall aim of the research described here was to determine whether and how multidisciplinary team working contributes to quality, efficiency and innovation in health care in the NHS.
7 The objectives of the research were to establish: which team member characteristics such as age, gender, occupational group, experience, qualifications, and team size, influence how well the teams work together; how team working processes, such as participation, reflexivity, communication, decision-making and leadership contribute to the effectiveness of teams, particularly the quality of health care and the development of innovative practice; The research programme was carried out over a three year period by a team of researchers based at the universities of Aston, Edinburgh, Glasgow, Leeds and Sheffield. During the course of the study information on team working was gathered from some 400 health care teams. This involved consulting over 7,000 NHS personnel and a large number of NHS clients. Five national workshops were held with key representatives from primary health care and community health care. A wide range of research methods was used, including questionnaire surveys, telephone interviews, in-depth interviews, observation, focus groups and video and audio tape recordings of meetings The research was carried out in two stages: quantitative data collection from 100 primary health care teams (PHCTs), 113 community health care teams (CMHTs) and 193 secondary health care teams (SHCTs), and in-depth work with a sub-sample of teams. Key findings Effectiveness Quality of teamworking is powerfully related to effectiveness of health care teams: The clearer the team's objectives The higher the level of participation in the team The higher the level of commitment to quality The higher the level of support of innovation. the more effective are health care teams across virtually all domains of functioning
8 Innovation Quality of teamworking is powerfully related to innovation of health care teams: The clearer the team's objectives The higher the level of participation in the team The higher the level of commitment to quality The higher the level of support of innovation.. the more innovative are health care teams across virtually all domains of functioning Mental Health Those working in teams have much better mental health than those working in looser groups or working individually. The benefits appear to be due to: Greater role clarity Better peer support Those working in teams are also buffered from the negative effects of organizational climate and conflict. The better the functioning of team with respect to Clarity of objectives Levels of participation Commitment to quality Support for innovation the better the mental health of team members across all domains of health care. Organisational performance There is a significant and negative relationship between the percentage of staff working in teams and the mortality in these hospitals, taking account of both local health needs and hospital size. Where more employees work in teams the death rate is significantly lower (calculated on the basis of the Sunday Times Mortality
9 Index, Dr Foster; deaths within 30 days of emergency surgery and deaths after admission for hip fracture) 1. Retention and turnover Within health care, those working in well functioning teams are more likely to stay working in their settings than those working in poorly functioning teams. Leadership In Community Mental Health and Primary Health Care, where there is no clear leader/co-ordinator or where there is conflict over leadership team objectives are unclear, and there are. Low levels of participation Low commitment to quality Low support for innovation Poor team member mental health Low levels of effectiveness and innovation Communication Communication, integration and regular meetings in PHC and CMC health care teams are associated with higher levels of effectiveness and innovation, yet the quality of meetings (particularly in Primary Health Care) is often poor. Professional diversity Diversity of professional groups in Primary Health Care is clearly linked to levels of team innovation. In newly formed Community Mental Health Teams, this relationship does not appear. The same findings emerged from research carried out with 85 breast cancer care teams 2. 1 This finding is based on research recently completed by the research team at the Aston Centre for Health Services Organisation Research (further details available from West or Borrill). 2 This finding is based on research recently completed by the research team at the Aston Centre for Health Services Organisational Research (further details available from West or Borrill).
10 Conclusions Systematic and revolutionary organizational change is necessary if the positive results of this research are to be implemented in practice. NHS organizations have to developed as team-based, rather than hierarchical. Structure, culture, work design, HRM and management have to accommodate and enable rather than impede team-based working. NHS employees should be trained in the KSAs for working in teams. NHS managers should be trained to manage team-based organizations.
11 Chapter 1 Teamwork, Communication and Effectiveness in Health Care: A Review The challenges of organising health care in the modern United Kingdom context are considerable. There are continual improvements in medical technologies, greater levels of knowledge and awareness amongst patient populations and increasing demands for the variety of sources of health care available within the National Health Service. The provision of free health care at the point of delivery to the population has become one of the most important issues in the national political agenda in the early part of the twenty-first century. At the same time the National Health Service has become a massively complex institution characterised by large organisations, repeated restructurings, and subject to a wide range of political and economic pressures. The response of the government has been to promise a huge increase in spending on the NHS; a key question to be answered in relation to this political agenda is how can we organise health care and achieve good, fair and cost effective services for the whole population. This report focuses on determining whether, and if so, how teamworking can help. In this first chapter we review the research evidence about the potential benefits of teamworking and the factors that influence the effectiveness of teams, focusing particularly upon their use in health care settings. We draw on empirical evidence from research conducted in the United Kingdom, mainland Europe, North America and Australia. The literature on team composition and the processes which influence team performance is briefly reviewed with particular emphasis on communication, decision-making and problem-solving. We then explore the influences of organisational context and leadership, before presenting the theoretical model which guided the research programme described in this report. First we consider what a team means. The activity of a group of people working co-operatively to achieve shared goals is basic to our species (Baumeister & Leary, 1995). The current enthusiasm for teamworking in health care reflects a deeper,
12 perhaps unconscious, recognition that this way of working offers the promise of greater progress than can be achieved through individual endeavour. Mohrman, Cohen, and Mohrman (1995) define a team as: a group of individuals who work together to produce products or deliver services for which they are mutually accountable. Team members share goals and are mutually held accountable for meeting them, they are interdependent in their accomplishment, and they affect the results through their interactions with one another. Because the team is held collectively accountable, the work of integrating with one another is included among the responsibilities of each member". Benefits of teamwork The belief that teamwork is the most effective way of delivering products and services has gained increasing ascendancy within diverse organisational settings (Guzzo & Shea, 1992; West, 1996). As organisations have grown in size and become structurally more complex, the need for teams of people to work together in co-ordinated ways to achieve objectives that contribute to the overall aims of organisations has become increasingly urgent. Mohrman et al. (1995) offer ten reasons for implementing team-based working in organisations: Teams are the best way to enact the strategy of organisations, because of the need for consistency between organisational environment, strategy and design (Galbraith, Lawler, & Associates, 1993). Teams enable organisations to speedily develop and deliver services cost effectively, while retaining high quality. Teams enable organisations to learn (and retain learning) more effectively (Senge, 1990). Cross-functional teams promote improved quality of services (Deming, 1986; Juran, 1989). Cross-functional teams can undertake effective process re-engineering (Davenport, 1993). Time is saved if activities, formerly performed sequentially by individuals, can be performed concurrently by people working in teams (Myer, 1993). Innovation is promoted within team-based organisations because of crossfertilisation of ideas (Senge, 1990; West & Pillinger, 1995).
13 Flat organisations can be monitored, co-ordinated and directed more effectively if the functional unit is the team rather than the individual (Galbraith, 1993, 1994). As organisations have grown more complex, so too have their information processing requirements; teams can integrate and link in ways individuals cannot (Lawrence and Lorsch, 1969, Galbraith, 1993, 1994). This approach to the delivery of services and products is not simply a managerial fad, since there is substantial empirical evidence that the introduction of teamwork can lead to increased effectiveness in the delivery of both quantity and quality of goods or services (Guzzo & Shea, 1992; Weldon & Weingart, 1993). Macy and lzumi (1993) conducted an analysis of 131 organisational change studies in order to determine their effectiveness. Those interventions with the greatest effects on organisational performance and 'the bottom-line' were team-related interventions. They also reduced turnover and absenteeism more than did other interventions, showing that team oriented practices can have broad positive effects in organisations. Other research by Kahleberg & Moody (1994), who studied over 700 work establishments, found that those in which teamwork was developed were more effective in their performance than those in which teams were not used. Finally, Applebaum and Batt (1994) offer similar evidence. They reviewed the results of a dozen surveys of organisational practices, as well as 185 case studies of innovative management practices. They too found compelling evidence that teams contribute to improved organisational effectiveness, particularly increasing efficiency and quality. Teamwork in health care The importance of teamworking in health care has been emphasised in numerous reports and policy documents on the National Health Service (NHS). One (NHSME, 1993) particularly emphasised the importance of teamworking if health and social care for people were to be of the highest quality and efficiency: "The best and most cost-effective outcomes for patients and clients are achieved when professionals work together, learn together, engage in clinical audit of outcomes together, and generate innovation to ensure progress in practice and service."
14 Some limited research has suggested the positive effects of multidisciplinary teamworking in health care. However, there are many difficulties inherent in comparing evaluation studies, which include teams having different objectives and organisation patterns, studies variously controlling for other concurrent changes in local services and the pre-existing variations in services and cultures (Jackson, Gater, Goldberg, Tantam, Loftus & Taylor, 1993). In terms of the delivery of care, teams have been reported to reduce hospitalisation time and costs, improve service provision, enhance patient satisfaction, staff motivation and team innovation. We review the literature relevant to each of these outcomes below. Reduced hospitalisation and costs Sommers and colleagues (2000) compared primary health care teams with physician care across 18 private practices, and concluded that primary health care teams lowered hospitalisation rates and reduced physician visits while maintaining function for elderly patients with chronic illness and functional deficits. Significant cost savings were born from reduced hospitalisation, which more than accounted for the costs of setting up the team and making regular home visits. Jones (1992) also reported that families who received primary health team care had fewer hospitalisations, fewer operations, less physician visits for illness and more physician visits for health supervision than control families. A similar pattern emerged for terminally ill patients, where their increased utilisation of home care services more than offset savings in hospital costs, such that there were average savings of 18% in hospital costs (Hughes, Cummings, Weaver, Manheim, Brown & Conrad, 1992). In another study in the U.S., Eggert and colleagues (1991) concluded that a team focussed case management system generated similar benefits for elderly, chronically ill patients. The team approach reduced total health care expenditures by 13.6%, when compared to an individualised case management system. The team combined earlier discharge, more timely nursing home placement and better-organised home support and care, to reduce patient hospitalisation by 26%. Similarly, the cost increases in ambulatory and nursing home care were offset by fewer and shorter stay hospital admissions and reduced home care utilisation. For patients with dementia in this study, the team model of case management reduced overall costs even further, by 41% (Zimmer, Eggert & Chiverton, 1990). At the end of the 27-month study, there were more team than control patients living at home and fewer in nursing homes. An
15 audit of the case managers' records highlighted more intense management activity in the team group, where patients were referred more frequently for medical evaluation, respite and day care. Team case managers had smaller caseloads, made more home visits and had more case conferences. Teams were more familiar with local community resources and were reported as being more responsive to patient crises. The team approach was reported to offer greater intensity of case management, which resulted in more efficient care provision in hospitals and home health services. Improved service provision Primary care teams appear to produce better detection, treatment, follow-up and outcome in hypertension (Adorian, Silverberg, Tomer & Wamosher, 1990). Specifically, nurses in England reported that working together in primary health care teams reduced duplication, streamlined patient care and enabled specialist skills to be used more cost-effectively (Ross, Rink & Furne, 2000). Jansson, Isacsson and Lindholm (1992) analysed the records of general practitioners and district carers over 6 years in Sweden. Care teams (GP, district nurse, assistant nurse) were introduced into one region but were absent in another comparative region. The care teams reported a large rise in the overall number of patient contacts and in the proportion of the population who accessed the district nurse. Concurrently, there was a reduction in emergency visits, which they attributed to better accessibility and continuity of care in the teams. Jackson and colleagues (1993) reported a similar pattern twelve months after the introduction of a community mental health team in England. They reported a threefold increase in the rate of inception to care, a doubling in the prevalence of treated psychiatric disorder and a reduction in demand on the hospital s outpatient services. It was suggested that the team was making specialist care more available to patients with severe mental illness who would not have previously received care from mental health services. The team also provided care in a timelier manner that was accessible and continuous. Enhanced patient satisfaction Hughes and colleagues (1992) compared the provision of hospital-based team home care and customary care for 171 terminally ill patients in a large U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs hospital. They noted increased access to home care services and improved patient and carer satisfaction with hospital-based team home care. Both
16 patients and caregivers of the team expressed significantly higher levels of satisfaction with continuous and comprehensive care at one month, and they continued to express higher levels of satisfaction at six months. The team program maintained patients at home for significantly more days than the control group, who were kept in hospital in general wards for longer. Patients of the team received almost twice as many home visits as the control group and visited the clinic significantly fewer times. Increased satisfaction by patients who had access to a primary health care team was reported to include a higher mean number of social activities, fewer symptoms and slightly improved overall health. These differences were noted in comparison to patients who only had access to a physician (Sommers et. al., 2000). Staff motivation Primary care teamworking has been reported to improve staff motivation (Wood, Farrow, & Elliott, 1994). In a study in Spain, Peiro, Gouzalez-Roma & Romos (1992) showed relationships between work team processes, role clarity, job satisfaction and leader behaviours. Effectiveness of teamwork was also related to job satisfaction and mental health of team members. Sommers and colleagues (2000) suggested that lower rates of hospitalisation for patients of primary health care teams were more likely to be found in teams where individual members were most satisfied with their working relationships. Innovation Teamwork is reputed to promote innovation in organisations including those in the health care sector. In order to promote organisational innovation, policy makers and practitioners are increasingly asking for clarification of the factors that determine innovation in teams. Many input and process variables have been demonstrated to predict innovation in teams. In relation to inputs, there is some evidence that heterogeneity of team composition is related to team innovation (Hoffman & Maier, 1961; McGrath, 1984; Jackson, 1996). West and Anderson (1996) carried out a longitudinal study of the functioning of top management teams in 27 hospitals and examined relationships between team and organisational factors and team innovation. Their results suggested that team processes best predicted the overall level of team innovation, while the proportion of innovative team members predicted the rated radicalness of innovations introduced.
17 Specifically, West and Wallace (1991) found that team collaboration, commitment to the team and tolerance of diversity were positively related to team innovativeness. By what means are these various benefits of teamworking in health care realised? Partly at least through their composition and through effective team processes such as communication, decision-making and problem-solving. We therefore briefly review research in these areas before turning to consider the influence of the organisations within which teams function. Team composition and Processes There is considerable agreement that heterogeneity of skills in teams performing complex tasks is good for effectiveness (e.g., Campion et. al., 1994; Guzzo & Dickson, 1996; Jackson, 1996; Millikan & Martins, 1996; Maznevski 1994). Heterogeneity of skills and knowledge automatically implies that each team member will bring a different knowledge perspective to the problem, a necessary ingredient for creative solutions (Sternberg & Lubart, 1990; West, 1997). However, teams that are diverse in task-related attributes are often diverse in individual attributes. Variation in individual characteristics can trigger stereotypes and prejudice (Jackson, 1996) which, via interteam conflict (Tajfel, 1978; Tajfel & Turner, 1979; Hogg & Abrams, 1988), can affect team processes and outcomes. As an example, Alexander, Lichtenstein and D Aunno (1996) found that individuals in multidisciplinary treatment teams in U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs hospitals, who were members of larger and more heterogeneous teams, reported poor team functioning. Physicians and social workers assessed team functioning more positively than did nurses. The greater the diversity of individual characteristics of team tenure, age and occupation within teams, the more negatively did team members assessed team functioning. Gender Gender is an important influence on communication within teams. Not only are men consistently more assertive in public situations and confrontations (Kimble, Marsh & Kiska, 1984; Mathison & Tucker, 1982), but also communication expectations differ for men and women. Sex-role stereotypes prescribe passive, submissive and expressive communication for women while men are expected to be active, controlling and less expressive communicators (LaFrance & Mayo, 1978). Punishment for violation of expectations (Jussim, 1986; Jussim, Coleman & Lerch,
18 1987; Jackson, Sullivan & Lodge, 1993) may influence both the perceptions of women in teams and their willingness to participate in team communication. Such considerations are vitally important in health care teams where women dominate in number, but men predominate in the highest status positions (in the present research, GPs and psychiatrists, for example). In support, Alexander, Lichtenstein and D Aunno (1996) reported that the greater the gender diversity, the more positive were team members assessment of how cohesively and harmoniously teams operated. Their research suggested that mixed gender teams included different orientations to work, namely a female focus on workplace processes and relationships and a male focus on tasks and outcomes. Team roles It is important that teams have the appropriate mix of clearly defined team roles. Jansson, Isacsson and Lindholm (1992) analysed the records of general practitioners and district carers over a six-year period across 2 districts in Sweden following the introduction of care teams into one region. They found that through the independent roles of nurses and doctors were retained in the primary health care teams, all team members interacted with the population in various situations, including home visits and complemented each other across different competencies. Team affective tone Another important, but more controversial approach to understanding work team processes and effectiveness, is offered by research on team affective tone. George (1990) suggests that if members of a team experience similar kinds of affective states at work (either negative or positive), then affect is meaningful not only in terms of their individual experiences, but also at a team level. A number of studies have demonstrated a significant relationship between team affective tone and behaviour such as absenteeism (George, 1989, 1990, 1995). George proposes that teams that are interested, strong, excited, enthusiastic, proud, alert, inspired, determined, attentive and active, enable cognitive flexibility, creativity and effectiveness (George, 1996). However, she argues that team affective tone may not exist for all teams, so it cannot be assumed a priori that it is a relevant construct for every team. George (1996) sees team affective tone and team mental models as having a reciprocal influence. So in a team with a negative affective tone, members would have different cognitive processes from those in a team with a positive affective tone, which then may influence team effectiveness.
19 There is some evidence that team mental models play an important role in team decision-making (Klimoski & Mohammed, 1994), impacting on aspects of team decision-making such as problem definition, speed and flexibility, alternative evaluation and implementation (Walsh & Fahey, 1986: Walsh, Henderson & Deighton, 1988). A team that has a high negative affective tone may tend to be more rigid when making decisions. The nature and outcomes of team decision-making are therefore likely to be affected by the interaction between team affective tone and team mental models. Communication The study of communication in teams has a long history in social psychology, but recent reviews by Guzzo & Dickenson (1996) and Guzzo and Shea (1992) reveal the paucity of thorough industrial and organisational research in this area. Blakar (1985) proposes five pre-conditions for effective communication in teams. Team members must have shared social reality within which the exchange of messages can take place, including a shared language base and perception. Team members must be able to decentre, to take the perspective of others into account in relation to both their affective and cognitive position (Redmond 1989, 1992). Team members must be motivated to communicate. There must be negotiated and endorsed contracts of behaviour (i.e. agreement among team members about how interactions take place). Finally, the team must attribute communication difficulties appropriately, so if one of the other preconditions is not being met, the team is able to correctly identify the problem and develop a solution. Several research studies in England have highlighted interprofessional communication problems within primary health care teams. West and Field (1995) and Field and West (1995) interviewed 96 members of primary health care teams and described factors that impacted upon teamworking and communication in health care. Structured time for decision-making, team cohesiveness and team-building all influenced communication within teams. They highlighted the failure of health care teams to set aside time for regular meetings to define objectives, clarify roles, apportion tasks, encourage participation and handle change. Other reasons for poor communication included differences in status, power, educational background, assertiveness of members of the team, and the assumption that the doctors would be the leaders (see also West & Pillinger, 1995; West & Slater, 1996).
20 Communication difficulties between different professional groups have been highlighted particularly. Bond, et. al., (1985) surveyed 161 pairs of General Practitioners (GPs) and health visitors, and 148 pairs of GPs and district nurses who had patients in common. They reported low levels of communication and collaboration between GPs and community nursing staff and suggested that GPs had a very poor understanding of the health visitor's role. Similarly, McClure (1984) describes low levels of communication in a survey of 48 health visitors and 45 district nurses attached to general practices. Community nurses reported that communication with practice staff was usually only about specific immediate patient issues rather than team objectives, strategies, processes and performance review. Health visitors were noted to be similarly unenthusiastic about progress in teamwork. Ross, Rink and Furne (2000) found that health visitors perceived teams as less effective. They suggested that health visitors were comparatively more defensive about the benefits of changing role boundaries and considered themselves less able to contribute to the teams as currently constituted. Cant and Killoran (1993) reached similar conclusions, based on their research study with 928 practice nurses, 682 health visitors and 679 district nurses. They argued that joint professional training and the instigation of regular team meetings were necessary to promote good communication. Cott (1997) used a social network analysis of 93 health care workers across 3 multidisciplinary long-term care teams to explore communication processes within teams. She concluded that higher status multi-professional members communicated most openly and worked fairly autonomously across loosely structured tasks, with low levels of authority. In contrast, hierarchical nursing sub-teams did not report high levels of information sharing. West and Slater (1996) reported that much of the potential benefit of teamwork was not being realised, with less than one in four health care teams building effective communication and teamworking practices (see also West & Poulton, 1997). In a similar vein, the Audit Commission report in 1992 drew attention to a major gap between the rhetoric and reality: "Separate lines of control, different payment systems leading to suspicion over motives, diverse objectives, professional barriers and perceived inequalities in status, all play a part in limiting the potential of multiprofessional, multi-agency teamwork... for those working under such
The research was carried out by: Carol Borrill, Michael West, Jeremy Dawson Aston Business School, Aston University. David Shapiro, Anne Rees, Ann Richards University of Leeds. Simon Garrod, Jean Carletta
The Relationship between Staff Satisfaction and Patient Satisfaction: Results from Wolverhampton Hospitals NHS Trust Dr. Carol Borrill Professor Michael West Matthew Carter Jeremy Dawson Aston Business
RCN Policy Unit Policy Statement 16/2006 Acute and Multidisciplinary Working The Royal College of Nursing of the United Kingdom and the Royal College of Physicians (London) September 2006 Royal College
1 NHS Staff Management and Health Service Quality Results from the NHS Staff Survey and Related Data Michael West 1, Jeremy Dawson 2, Lul Admasachew 2 and Anna Topakas 2 1 Lancaster University Management
Quick Guide For Administrators Based on TIP 52 Clinical Supervision and Professional Development of the Substance Abuse Counselor Contents Why a Quick Guide?...2 What Is a TIP?...3 Benefits and Rationale...4
Cooperation, collaboration, influence and authority in leadership and the nurse as health service manager in rural Western Australia Dr Jan Lewis Curtin University Perth 1 Background In Western Australia,
Quality in and Equality of Access to Healthcare Services Executive Summary European Commission Directorate-General for Employment, Social Affairs and Equal Opportunities Manuscript completed in March 2008
Nursing and Midwifery Council mentor domains and outcomes and the NHS Knowledge and Skills Framework Contents Preface 1 Introduction 2 Partnership Approach 3 Aims 4 The mentor and other practice education
NHS Highland area: Specialist dementia support for families, carers & communities Research Project Executive Summary Supported by Argyll & Bute Council, the Highland Council and NHS Highland 1. Introduction
Executive summary January 2016 Growing the health and well-being agenda: From first steps to full potential The CIPD is the professional body for HR and people development. The not-for-profit organisation
JOB DESCRIPTION NURSE PRACTITIONER TITLE OF POST: NURSE PRACTITIONER : GENERAL PRACTICE /OUT OF HOURS SALARY : To be negotiated HOURS OF EMPLOYMENT: To be agreed APPOINTMENT: Permanent contract RESPONSIBLE
Harness Care Cooperative Ltd Quality primary care services provided through local cooperation Company registration: 06584450 Job Description Job title: Nurse Practitioner /Lead Nurse ACCOUNTIBILITY The
SHEFFIELD TEACHING HOSPITALS NHS FOUNDATION TRUST C EXECUTIVE SUMMARY COUNCIL OF GOVERNORS 2 ND DECEMBER 2014 Subject: Supporting Director: Author: Status 1 NHS England Five Year Forward View A Summary
the Defence Leadership framework Growing Leaders at all Levels Professionalism Loyalty Integrity Courage Innovation Teamwork Foreword One of the founding elements of Building Force 2030, as outlined in
Would I Follow Me? An Introduction to Management Leadership in the Workplace This dynamic program clearly shows the right and wrong ways to deal with the very important human dimension of team performance.
JOB DESCRIPTION Post: Band: Responsible to: Accountable to: Community Palliative Care Clinical Nurse Specialist 7 (SAH adapted Agenda for Change) Team Leader Clinical Operational Manager Job Summary Work
ST LUKE S HOSPICE JOB DESCRIPTION: DAY HOSPICE LEAD/ CLINICAL NURSE PRACTITIONER DATE: MARCH 2015 WRITER: DEB HICKEY HEAD OF CARE SERVICES SUZANNE SALES CLINICAL NURSING SERVICES MANAGER TOTAL NUMBER 11
Learning Disabilities Nursing: Field Specific Competencies Page 7 Learning Disabilities Nursing: Field Specific Competencies Competency (Learning disabilities) and application Domain and ESC Suitable items
Good Practice Guidelines for Appraisal Dr Laurence Mynors Wallis Dr David Fearnley February 2010 1 Contents Page Introduction 3 Link between appraisal and revalidation 4 Preparation for the appraisal meeting
The Role of Front Line Managers in Bringing Policies to Life Sue Hutchinson, CESR Front line managers play a critical role in influencing employee attitudes and behaviours by the way in which they translate
Workforce Development Pathway 8 Supervision, Mentoring & Coaching A recovery-oriented service allows the opportunity for staff to explore and learn directly from the wisdom and experience of others. What
Child Care Occupational Standard MQF Level 5 CDC 501 Establish and develop working relationships CDC 502 Support policies, procedures and practice to safeguard children and ensure their inclusion and well-being
Standards of proficiency Operating department practitioners Contents Foreword 1 Introduction 3 Standards of proficiency 7 Foreword We are pleased to present the Health and Care Professions Council s standards
The National Health Plan for Young Australians An action plan to protect and promote the health of children and young people Copyright 1997 ISBN 0 642 27200 X This work is copyright. It may be reproduced
Policy Paper: Accessible allied health primary care services for all Australians March 2013 Contents Contents... 2 AHPA s call to action... 3 Position Statement... 4 Background... 6 Healthier Australians
Standards of proficiency Arts therapists Contents Foreword 1 Introduction 3 Standards of proficiency 7 Foreword We are pleased to present the Health and Care Professions Council s standards of proficiency
POSITION DESCRIPTION POSITION TITLE REPORTS TO AWARD/AGREEMENT/CONTRACT POSITION TYPE HOURS PER WEEK Nurse Unit Manager Business Director of Ambulatory and Continuing Care Professional Executive Director
DEVELOPING TEAM-BASED WORKING IN NHS TRUSTS Summary Report June 2009 Matthew Carter, Michael West, Jeremy Dawson, Joanne Richardson and Maria Dunckley 1 Project summary Providing high quality health care
1 Competencies for registered nurses Te whakarite i nga mahi tapuhi kia tiakina ai te haumaru a-iwi Regulating nursing practice to protect public safety December 2007 2007 2 Competencies for registered
CHAPTER 1: The Preceptor Role in Health Systems Management Throughout the nursing literature, the preceptor is described as a nurse who teaches, supports, counsels, coaches, evaluates, serves as role model
Standards for the School Social Worker [23.140] STANDARD 1 - Content The competent school social worker understands the theories and skills needed to provide individual, group, and family counseling; crisis
PNAE Paediatric Nursing Associations of Europe Paediatric Nurse Education in Europe A Position Statement by the Paediatric Nursing Associations of Europe (PNAE) Introduction The PNAE network carried out
Comments trom the Aberdeen City Joint Futures Brain Injury Group The Aberdeen City Joint Futures Brain Injury Group is made up of representatives from health (acute services, rehabilitation and community),
Performance Evaluation Report 2013 14 The City of Cardiff Council Social Services October 2014 This report sets out the key areas of progress and areas for improvement in The City of Cardiff Council Social
A Route Map to the 2020 Vision for Health and Social Care 02 A Route Map to the 2020 Vision for Health and Social Care Introduction This paper sets out a new and accelerated focus on a number of priority
Standards for specialist education and practice This document is now the UKCC s exclusive reference document specifying standards for specialist practice. Any previous documentation, as detailed below,
What are Cognitive and/or Behavioural Psychotherapies? Paper prepared for a UKCP/BACP mapping psychotherapy exercise Katy Grazebrook, Anne Garland and the Board of BABCP July 2005 Overview Cognitive and
Leicestershire Partnership Trust Leadership Development Framework 1 Leadership Development Framework Introduction The NHS in England is facing a period of substantial change in light of the recent Government
Finance Committee Inquiry into preventative spending Submission from Edinburgh Community Health Partnership Introduction and scope of evidence This paper represents the response from the Edinburgh Community
Living with severe mental health and substance use problems Report from the Rethink Dual Diagnosis Research Group August 2004 Executive Summary Introduction Mental health problems co-existing with alcohol
Impact of health care teams on patient outcomes THIS CLINICAL TRAINING INITIATIVE IS SUPPORTED BY FUNDING FROM THE AUSTRALIAN GOVERNMENT UNDER THE INCREASED CLINICAL TRAINING CAPACITY (ICTC) PROGRAM Interprofessional
1 IMPROVING DENTAL CARE AND ORAL HEALTH A CALL TO ACTION February 2014 Gateway reference: 01173 2 Background NHS dental services are provided in primary care and community settings, and in hospitals for
Australian ssociation Practice Standards for Social Workers: Achieving Outcomes of Social Workers Australian Association of Social Workers September 2003 Contents Page Introduction... 3 Format of the Standards...
Human Resources Values for Working Together and Professional Behaviours A message from the Vice-Chancellor The new Human Resources Strategy, Working Together: A Strategy for Success, in tandem with the
Team Working in Health and Social Care 13 th June 2006 Lynn Markiewicz Aston Organisation Development Aston Business School Workshop Aims Explore the links between team working and service user outcomes
IB position paper Holistic education: An interpretation for teachers in the IB programmes John Hare International International Baccalaureate Baccalaureate Organization Organization 2010 2010 1 Language
WHAT DOES THE PSYCHOLOGICAL THERAPIES HEAT TARGET MEAN TO YOU? NHS Boards are now half way through the first year of implementation of the HEAT target Deliver faster access to mental health services by
Course: To Err is Human Topic: Being an effective team player Summary Effective teamwork in health-care delivery can have an immediate and positive impact on patient safety. The importance of effective
Centre for Innovation in Health Management LEEDS UNIVERSITY BUSINESS SCHOOL POSTGRADUATE DEGREES 2015 Postgraduate Certificate Coproducing Health Delivered by: Centre for Innovation in Health Management
A Competency Based Curriculum for Specialist Training in Psychiatry Specialist Module in Old Age Psychiatry Royal College of Psychiatrists Royal College of Psychiatrists 2009 SPECIALIST IN THE PSYCHIATRY
Code of Conduct A Physician Assistant (now associate) (PA) is defined as someone who is: a new healthcare professional who, while not a doctor, works to the medical model, with the attitudes, skills and
Network organisation within WONCA Region Europe - ESGP/FM European Academy of Teachers in General Practice (Network within WONCA Europe) THE EUROPEAN DEFINITION OF GENERAL PRACTICE / FAMILY MEDICINE SHORT
Improving Emergency Care in England REPORT BY THE COMPTROLLER AND AUDITOR GENERAL HC 1075 Session 2003-2004: 13 October 2004 LONDON: The Stationery Office 11.25 Ordered by the House of Commons to be printed
Manager briefing Gender pay equity guide for managers GENDER P Y EQUITY Manager briefing Gender pay equity guide for managers Managers play a vital role in addressing pay equity as they are responsible
JOB DESCRIPTION JOB TITLE: RESPONSIBLE TO: LOCATION(S): JOB PROFILE: Advanced Nurse Practitioner Advanced Nurse Practitioner Professional Lead North Bristol Trust Southmead Hospital This role is to work
Managing Conflict and Stress M. En C. Eduardo Bustos Farías 1 Outline A Modern View of Conflict A Conflict Continuum Functional versus Dysfunctional Conflict Antecedents of Conflict Desired Outcomes of
People s views on priority areas for change Paul Farmer Chair, Mental Health Taskforce 20k respondents to Mind and Rethink Mental Illness online survey Five groups: People with lived experience Families
20% and No More: Barriers to Women s Advancement in Higher Education Administration Dr. Terrie Smith Director of Faculty Affairs, University of South Carolina President Elect, South Carolina Women in Higher
Graduate Profile BA (Hons/Ord) Learning Disability Nursing The following information, in conjunction with the graduate's individual practice portfolio and C.V., constitutes the graduate profile for the
Chapter Industrial and organisational psychology Michael P O'Driscoll and Paul J Taylor Psychology Department University of Waikato New Zealand Introduction Industrial and organisational (I/0) psychology
briefing september 2009 ISSUE 189 Seeing double: meeting the challenge of dual diagnosis Key points Dual diagnosis affects a third of mental health service users, half of substance misuse service users
RUTGERS SCHOOL PSYCHOLOGY PROGRAM PRACTICUM HANDBOOK Introduction School Psychology is a general practice and health service provider specialty of professional psychology that is concerned with the science
Organising and planning services for people with a personality disorder A NICE pathway brings together all NICE guidance, quality standards and materials to support implementation on a specific topic area.
National Standards for Safer Better Healthcare June 2012 About the Health Information and Quality Authority The (HIQA) is the independent Authority established to drive continuous improvement in Ireland
POSITION DESCRIPTION Position Title: Clinical Specialty Nurse Wound Care Date Produced/Reviewed: June 2012 Reviewed: Position Holder's Name : Position Holder's Signature :... Manager / Supervisor's Name
Consultation: Two proposals for registered nurse prescribing Submission Form Please read and refer to the consultation document Two proposals for registered nurse prescribing available on the Nursing Council
CHAPTER 5 STRATEGIC PLANNING AND SWOT ANALYSIS I skate where the puck is going to be, not where it has been. Wayne Gretzky K e y Terms and Concepts Force field analysis SWOT analysis Excerpted from Essentials
Policy Research Programme Summary Final Report Form 1. Project Details Project Title: Project Duration: (months) Organisational Culture in the NHS: A feasibility study to measure the impact on Older People
Education Module for Health Record Practice Module 7 - Administration and Management of the Health Record Department The health record officer must meet the leadership challenge in his/her quest to develop
Analyst Position Description September 4, 2015 Analysis Position Description September 4, 2015 Page i Table of Contents General Characteristics... 1 Career Path... 2 Explanation of Proficiency Level Definitions...
PEOPLE INVOLVEMENT AND THEIR COMPETENCE IN QUALITY MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS * Jarmila ŠALGOVIČOVÁ, Matej BÍLÝ Authors: Workplace: Assoc. Prof. Jarmila Šalgovičová, PhD., Prof. Matej Bílý, DrSC.* Institute of
Message from the Chief Executive of the RCM The Midwifery Leadership Competency Framework has been derived from both the NHS Leadership Qualities Framework and the Clinical Leadership Competency Framework.
Coast Guard Leadership Competencies Leadership competencies are the knowledge, skills, and expertise the Coast Guard expects of its leaders. The 28 leadership competencies are keys to career success. Developing
Resilient Individuals Resilient Organisations Professor Michael West Aston Organisation Development and Lancaster University Management School Healthcare People Management Association Conference Content
Your local specialist mental health services Primary Care Liaison Service B&NES Primary Care Mental Health Liaison service is a short-term support service to help people with mental health difficulties
MARCH 2011 Certificate IV in Frontline Management Ai Group is pleased to provide you with information regarding the Certificate IV in Frontline Management - BSB40807. BENEFITS OF TRAINING Effective training
1 Develop productive working relationships with colleagues Unit Summary What is the unit about? This unit is about developing working relationships with colleagues, within your own organisation and within
II. STANDARDS FOR THE SCHOOL SERVICE PERSONNEL CERTIFICATE Standards for the School Counselor [23.110] STANDARD 1 - Academic Development Domain The competent school counselor understands the learning process
Submission to the Parliament of Australia Senate Community Affairs Committee Enquiry into Health Policy, Administration and Expenditure September 2014 Introduction The Australian Women s Health Network
National Commission for Academic Accreditation & Assessment Standards for Quality Assurance and Accreditation of Higher Education Institutions November 2009 Standards for Institutional Accreditation in
Expected Competencies of graduates of the nursing program at Philadelphia University Background Educational programs are prepared within the context of the countries they serve. They are expected to respond
RCN INTERNATIONAL DEPARTMENT Royal College of Nursing (UK) consultation response to the European Commission s Green Paper on the European Workforce for Health. With a membership of just under 400,000 registered
BC Public Service Competencies Competencies that support LEADING PEOPLE For Executive and Directors: Motivating for Peak Performance Motivating for peak performance involves knowledge and skills in using
JOB DESCRIPTION ellenor Advanced Nurse Practitioner Specialist Palliative Care Responsible to Accountable to: Head of Adult Community Services Director of Patient Care General ellenor is a specialist palliative
Promotion, Transfer and Termination attachment one Developing and Implementing Succession Plans Contents WGEA Tool: Developing Succession Plans 3 Introduction 3 Developing and Implementing Succession Plans