Bad News for Disabled People:

Size: px
Start display at page:

Download "Bad News for Disabled People:"

Transcription

1 Strathclyde Centre for Disability Research and Glasgow Media Unit Bad News for Disabled People: How the newspapers are reporting disability In association with:

2 Contents PAGE 1. Acknowledgements 2 2. Authordetails 3 3. Mainfindings 4 4. Summary 6 Part2 5. Introduction MethodologyandDesign Contentanalysis Audiencereceptionanalysis Contentanalysis:Results Politicaldiscussionandcritiquesofpolicy Changesintheprofileofdisabilitycoverageand sympathetic portrayals Changesintheprofileofrepresentationsofthe undeserving disabilityclaimant Audiencereceptionanalysis Howisdisabilityreportedinthemedia Viewsondisabledpeople Viewsonbenefitsandbenefitclaimants Viewsongovernmentpolicy67 9. Conclusion References 73 Appendix1.Codingschedule 80 Appendix2.Detaileddescriptorsforcodingandanalysis 85 1

3 Acknowledgements ThisresearchwascommissionedbyInclusionLondonandtheirfinancial sponsorshipandadministrativebackingisgratefullyrecognised. Inparticularwewouldliketoacknowledgethehelpandcollaborative supportofannekanewhoprovideduswithveryvaluableandhelpful advicethroughouttheresearchandhadasignificantinputinthe draftingofthefinalreport. Wewouldalsoliketothankthefollowingresearcherswhoworkedinthe GlasgowMediaGroupandwhotirelessly,carefullyandpainstakingly undertookthecontentanalysisofthemedia: StevieDocherty,LouiseGaw,DanielaLatina,ColinMacpherson, HannahMillarandSarahWatson. WearegratefultoAllanSutherlandandJoFerriefortheircontributions tothedatacollection. Wewouldalsoliketothankallthefocusgroupmembersandinterview respondentswhotookpartinthestudy.withouttheirtimeand commitmentwewouldnothavebeenabletoproducethisreport. 2

4 Authordetails EmmaBriantisaresearchfellowintheGlasgowMediaGroup.Shehas recentlycompletedherphd,whichlookedatangloamericanrelations incontemporarywartimepropagandaandinformationoperations NickWatsonisProfessorofDisabilityResearchandDirectorofthe StrathclydeCentreforDisabilityResearchattheUniversityofGlasgow. Hispreviousresearchhasincludedworkondisabledchildrenand disabledchildhoods,disabilityandtechnology,disabilitytheoryand disabilityhistory. GregPhiloisProfessorofCommunicationsandSocialChangeand DirectoroftheGlasgowMediaGroup,UniversityofGlasgow.His previousresearchhascentredonmediacoverageofisrael Palestineand itseffectonaudienceunderstandingoftheconflict,mediapresentations industrialdisputesandtradeunionism,thefalklandswarandnorthern Ireland. InclusionLondonprovidespolicy,campaigningandstrategiccapacity buildingsupporttodeafanddisabledpeople'sorganisations(ddpos). InclusionLondonaimstoensureastrongcollectivevoicethatreflects diversityofdeafanddisabledlondonersandtheirorganisationsand addressesthestrategicissuesthatimpactonddpo'sabilitytosurvive andthrive.www.inclusionlondon.co.uk Contactdetails: InclusionLondon CANMezzanine 49 51EastRoad London N16AH LondonDeafandDisability Organisations CICCompanyregistrationno: ProfessorNickWatson StrathclydeCentreforDisability Research UniversityofGlasgow Glasgow G128RT 3

5 MainFindings InclusionLondoncommissionedtheGlasgowMediaGroupandthe StrathclydeCentreforDisabilityResearchtocarryoutastudytoanalyse changesinthewaythemediaarereportingdisabilityandhowithas impactedonpublicattitudestowardsdisabledpeople.incarryingout thestudytheycomparedandcontrastedmediacoverageofdisabilityin fivepapersin withasimilarperiodin2004 5andranaseriesof focusgroups.thestudyfound: Therehasbeenasignificantincreaseinthereportingofdisability intheprintmediawith713disabilityrelatedarticlesin comparedto1015inacomparableperiodin This increasehasbeenaccompaniedbyashiftinthewaythatdisability isbeingreportedandthereisnowincreasedpoliticisationof mediacoverageofdisabilityin comparedto2004 5; Therehasbeenareductionintheproportionofarticleswhich describedisabledpeopleinsympatheticanddeservingterms,and storiesthatdocumentthe reallife experiencesoflivingasa disabledpersonhavealsodecreased.someimpairmentgroups areparticularlylesslikelytoreceivesympathetictreatment: peoplewithmentalhealthconditionsandother hidden impairmentsweremorelikelytobepresentedas undeserving. Articlesfocusingondisabilitybenefitandfraudincreasedfrom 2.8%in2005/5to6.1%in2010/11.Whenthefocusgroupswere askedtodescribeatypicalstoryinthenewspapersondisability benefitfraudwasthemostpopularthemementioned. Thesearticlesareimpactingonpeople sviewsandperceptionsof disabilityrelatedbenefits.thefocusgroupsallclaimedthatlevels offraudweremuchhigherthantheyareinreality,withsome suggestingthatupto70%ofclaimantswerefraudulent. Participantsjustifiedtheseclaimsbyreferencetoarticlestheyhad readinnewspapers. 4

6 Thisstrengthoffraudasatabloidthemeconflictswiththereality oflevelsofincapacitybenefitfraudandfocusespublicperceptions ofresponsibilityforincapacitybenefitlevelsonclaimantsrather thanproblemsinlackoflabourmarketdemand,economicpolicies ordiscrimination. Therehasbeenanincreaseinthenumberofarticlesdocumenting theclaimed burden thatdisabledpeopleareallegedtoplaceon theeconomy withsomearticlesevenblamingtherecession itselfonincapacitybenefitclaimants; Articlesthatexplorethepoliticalandsocioeconomiccontextof disabilityarerareasarearticlesthatexploretheimpactthatthe proposedcutswillhaveondisabledpeople.therewasadecrease inreferencestodiscriminationagainstdisabledpeopleorother contextualisingissues; Therehasbeenasignificantlyincreaseduseofpejorative languagetodescribedisabledpeople,includingsuggestionsthat lifeonincapacitybenefithadbecomea LifestyleChoice.Theuse oftermssuchas scrounger, cheat and skiver wasfoundin18% oftabloidarticlesin2010/11comparedto12%in2004/5.there were54occurrencesofthesewordsin2004/5comparedto142in 2010/11.Thesechangesreinforcedtheideaofdisabledclaimants as undeserving. Disabledpeoplearefeelingthreatenedbythechangesintheway disabilityisbeingreportedandbytheproposedchangestothe theirbenefitsandtheirbenefitentitlements.thesetwoare combiningandreinforcingeachother. 5

7 Summary InclusionLondoncommissionedtheGlasgowMediaGroupandthe StrathclydeCentreforDisabilityResearchtocarryoutastudytoanalyse changesinthewaythenewsmediaarereportingdisabilityandhowit hasimpactedonpublicattitudestowardsdisabledpeople.thisresearch hadthreemainaims: Toexaminehowthemediaarecoveringdisabilityandto documentchangesinthiscoverage. Toexaminehowthisisimpactingonpublicattitudestodisabled people. Toconsidertheimpactthatanytrendsidentifiedintheresearch mayhaveonthelivesofdisabledpeople:forexample,inaffecting attitudestodisabledpeopleorsupportfororoppositiontocutsin benefitsaccessedbydisabledpeople. Inordertotrackchangesinstyleorcontentinmediacoverageofpolicy changerelatingtodisabilitybenefits,andthushighlightmediaresponses particulartotherecentcuts,asamplecoveragewasdrawnfor comparisonfromtwoperiods: ThesecondtermofTonyBlair s NewLabour Government ThecontemporaryConservative/LiberalDemocratCoalition Government Alargescaledetailedcontentanalysiswasconductedfocussingonfive popularnewspapers:thesun,themirror,theexpress,th and TheGuardian.Thiswoulddetermineifgovernmentattemptsat reconstructingdisabilityasaburdenimpactedonnewspapercoverage ofdisabilityissues.articlesmentioning disabled, disability, disabilities and incapacity wereobtainedfromlexisnexis,forthe followingtimeperiods: October2004toJanuary documents October2010toJanuary documents MarchtoApril documents 6

8 Thiscontentanalysiswassupplementedbyadetailedaudience receptionanalysis.weheldfocusgroupsofbetween6and8peoplein EnglandandinScotlandandthesewererecordedforsubsequent analysis. Findings Increasedcoverageofdisability Ouranalysishasshownthatmediacoverageondisabilityincreased dramaticallybetween2004 5and withover30%morearticles coveringdisabilityandthatthisincreasewasaccompaniedbyachange inthewaythatdisabilitywascovered.whilstdisablisttermssuchas cripple andthepresentationofdisabledpeopleassufferersorvictims decreasedbetweenthetwoperiodstheywerestillpresent,albeitonly TheSunusedtheword cripple inthe period. Thedatafromboththecontentanalysisandtheaudiencereception studiesareattimesconfusingandcontradictory.thereisevidenceto supporttheclaimthattherehasbeenanincreaseincoverageof disabilityasabenefitproblemandofdisabledpeopleasaburdenonthe stateandtherehasbeenanincreaseinthetotalnumberofarticlesin thiscategory.thisshiftisonethatwasrecognizedbymanyofourfocus grouprespondents.whenaskedtodescribeatypicalstoryondisability inthenewspaperstodaybenefitsandbenefitfraudwerebyfarthemost populartopicsmentioned.peoplealsohavewildlymistakenperceptions aboutlevelsoffraud.howeverwhilstgeneraldisapprovalofbenefit cheatswasastrongthemeinthefocusgroupspeoplewerequickto separateoutwhattheyfeltwere deserving disabledpeopleandfrauds. Disabledpeoplewereseenbyallourrespondentsasdeservingofstate support. Thepoliticizationofdisabilitybenefits Ourfindingssuggestthattherehasbeenanincreaseinthepoliticisation ofthemediacoverageofdisability,ashiftwhichreflectsthecoalition Government sagenda.muchofthemediaissupportiveofthechanges thecurrentgovernmentistryingtointroduceandarticlescriticalofthe Government sagendaweremuchlessprevalentin comparedto ,whenthethenLabourGovernmentattemptedtointroduce somesimilarcutsinservicesandbenefits.therewereofcourse 7

9 differencesinthewaythatvariousnewspapersreportedthesechanges, withtheguardianandthemirrorbeingmuchmorelikelytobecritical ofcoalitiongovernmentpoliciesthanthesun,expressormail.again therewasageneralfeelingofsupportforthispolicyshiftinthefocus groups,althoughthesupportwasnotoverwhelmingandsomeconcern wasexpressedabouthowthesechangeswerebeingimplementedand fearsaboutthosewhodeservedsupportbeingdeniedsuchsupport. DisabledPeopleandTriumphoverAdversity Sympathetic, reallife experiencesofdisabilitywerestrongly representedinboththeperiodsthatweexploredalthoughtherewasa significantdropin2010/11comparedto2004/5.thiswasalsothe secondmostcommonthemementionedinthefocusgroups.triumph overadversityandtherepresentationofdisabledpeopleasinspiring,as SuperCripples werealsofoundinbothperiods.againtherewasa largedropinthissortofcoverage.in2004 5,forexample,life experiencestoriesmadeupover15%ofthedailymail scoverageof disabilitycomparedtoonly7.7%ofcoveragein Inthetabloid pressingeneralsuchstoriesfellfrom29%to22%.theseshifts,whilst welcomeontheonehand,mightalsobeareflectiononthedesireof thesenewspaperstoreconstructdisabledpeopleasbenefitfrauds.itis hardtopresentdisabledpeopleasbothinspiringandatthesametime ascheatsandscroungers.thisthemewasalsopresentinmanyofthe focusgroups. Thereductioninstoriesrepresentingdisabledpeopleasvictimsandas suffererswasalsoaccompaniedbyareductioninthenumberofarticles describingdisabledpeopleasbeingingenuineneedofservicesor experiencinginadequateserviceprovision(afallfrom13%to9%). TheDeservingandNon deserving Linkedtothishasbeenamovebacktotherecreationandreentrenchmentoftheideaofthedeservingandnon deservingpoor. Whilsttherewasonlyamarginaldifferenceintheproportionofarticles thatdescribedincapacitybenefitrecipientsas undeserving 15.5%in comparedto15.9%in therewasalargeincreaseinthe actualnumberofsucharticles(127in comparedto81in2004 5).ForexamplewhiletheproportionofExpressarticlesdiscussing claimantsinthiswayfellfromapeakin2004 5of21.4%ofitsarticles (morethananyothertabloid),to15.7%ofitsarticlesinthesameperiod 8

10 of ;theactualnumberofthesearticlesitproducedincreasedby 26%(from31to42articles). Evidencefromthefocusgroupsinthisareaiscomplex.Whilstpeople werequicktoacceptthatfraudulentclaimantswereundeservingthe respondentsallfeltthatthestatehadadutytosupportdisabledpeople. Almostallthosewespoketoalsohaddirectexperienceofdisability eitherthroughaclosefamilymembersorclosefriends,manyofwhom hadtriedtogetbenefitsandhadfailed.oneparticipantforexample talkedabouthowhardithadbeenforhermother togetanybenefits. Theywereallawareofhowdifficultitistoactuallyqualifyforabenefit andwereawareofthelowlevelsofsupportdisabledpeoplereceived. DisabledPeopleasa Burden Theperiodin alsosawmorediscussionofdisabilitybenefitsin termsofbeingaclaimeddrainontheeconomyandaburdenonthe state(anincreaseinthetabloidsfrom22articlesin2004 5to37in ),withsomearticlesevenblamingtherecessionitselfon incapacitybenefitclaimants.thesunheavilyincreasedtheproportionof itsarticlesthatdefinedclaimantsas undeserving from18.8%during ,to26.9%inthesamethreemonthsin producingmore articlesonthisthemethananyothertabloid. Thesocialandpoliticalconsequencesofthecuts Debateofthepoliticalorsocialcontextinwhichdisabledpeoplefind themselvesbecamealmostentirelyabsentfromthetabloidmediaand explanationwasreducedtoindividualresponsibilityandweakened socialvalues.thefactthatthecutsarenotjustaffectingthosemaking fraudulentclaims,butarenegativelyimpactingondisabledpeople s liveswaslargelyignoredasweretheveryrealaffectsthattheproposed changesinbenefitswillhaveondisabledpeople.forexample,therewas anabsenceofcoverageoftheeffectsthatthereductionsinentitlement, benefitpaymentlevelsandtimelimitswillhavethatarebeingimposed evenonthosedefinedas genuine claimants.inarticlesthatattempted tojustifytheproposedchangestothebenefitssystemtherewassome attempttoreassurethepublicthat genuinely disabledpeoplewouldbe unaffected.therewasalargereductioninthenumberofarticlesin whichadominantthemewastheideathatdisabledpeopleare deserving claimants.whilein2004 5TheSunhadusedadominant deserving claimantthemein7.9%ofitsarticles,thisfellin to 9

11 0%.Similarly,TheExpressshowedafallfrom6.2%ofarticles,to1.1%in thecomparableperiodof TheDailyMaildropinthiscategory wasslight(1.4% 0.8%)astheyrarelyincludedthisthemeasdominantin anyperiodanyway.thesefindingscontrastgreatlywithboththe GuardianandTheMirrorbothofwhichcarriedarticlesthatexpressed concernovertheimpacttheproposedchangestodisabilitybenefitswill haveondisabledpeople. DisabledPeopleasCheats Thecontentanalysisalsonotedanincreaseinreferencestoincapacity benefitfraudinallpapers,reinforcingtheideathatdisabledpeopleare undeserving claimants.fraudarticlesincreasedfrom2.8%oftabloid coverageinoctober January2004 5to6.1%inthesameperiodin WhiletheproportionoffraudcoverageinTheExpressdoubled from2.1%to4.2%,thetotalnumberofarticleshadshotupfromsixin October January2004 5,to22articlesinthesameperiodof , morethananyotherpaperproduced.theproportionofsucharticlesin Th increasedfrom0.7%in2004 5,to3.8%inthesameperiodin ,andthenrosesteeplyto9.2%inMarch April.InTheSunfraud storiesalsoincreasedmarkedlyfromjust2%in2004 5to7.1%in Thiswasunderscoredbythelanguage.Outofthe180tabloidarticles acrossbothperiodsin (October JanuaryandMarch April combined)theword cheats wasusedin48articles, fraudster was usedin10articles, con in8articles, fiddle (thesystem)in8articles 1, aswellasmanyotherinventivesynonyms.thisstrengthoffraudasa tabloidthemeconflictswiththerealityoflevelsofincapacitybenefit fraud,whichthedepartmentforworkandpensionestimatesat2.4% forincapacitybenefitandlessthan1%fordisabilitylivingallowance. Disabilityasanequalityissue Articlesondiscriminationagainstdisabledpeopleandtheir marginalisationalsoshowedsignificantchangesbetweenthetwo periods.intheguardiantherewasadropof31.2%inoctober January ,to29.6%inthesameperiodin Acrossthissameperiod theproportionoftabloidarticleswhichmentioneddiscriminationor marginalisationofdisabledpeoplefellfrom19.5%to14.4%,thegreatest falloccurringintheexpress(from22.1%to11.6%). 1 Includingvariationsontheseie. conning / conned, fiddling / fiddled etc 10

12 Differenceswerealsonotedinthewaythatdifferentimpairmentgroups wererepresentedandthosewithaphysicalorsensoryimpairmentwere morelikelytoreceivesympathetictreatmentfromthepressthanother groups.mentalhealthwasmentionedinonly8ofthe25 deserving articleswhichmentionedadisabilityinoctober January2004 5,afigure thatdroppedto2/30inoctober January MentalIllnessesand conditionswhichareotherwise hidden (suchaschronicpain),or socially unsympathetic (suchasstd s,addictionorobesity),weremore likelytobepresentedas undeserving andpeoplewith depression and stress wereoftenportrayedasunworthyofbenefit.inarticlesthat exploredmentalhealthoftentabloidssuchasthedailymail,themirror, andthesunskirtedoverdetailsaboutaclaimant sbackgroundwhich mightprovidecontextandunderstandingofaparticularcase. Referencestolearningdisabilitieswerenotableintheirabsencefrom thisdebate. Disabledpeopleas Undeserving Claimants Twotoolswereidentifiedasfrequentlyusedinframingthenewsstories whichdefinedindividualcasesasthe undeserving claimantand reinforcingstatementsofoutrightcritiqueofthebenefitssystem. UseofPejorativeLanguage Theuseofpejorativetermstodescribedisabledpeople,increasedinall papersbetweenoctober January2004 5andthesameperiodin Itincreasedfrom12%oftabloidarticlesinOctober January to18%oftabloidarticlesfromthesameperiodin Therewere 54occurrencesofsuchwordsin2004/5comparedto142in2010/11.In TheGuardianthecomparablefigurerosefrom2.6%ofarticles,to3.2%. TheMirroralsoincreaseditsuseofpejorativelanguagefrom4.3%to 8.8%betweenthesetwoperiodsbutthegreatestincreasewasfoundin TheExpress,SunandMail.Termsusedincluded;scrounger,handout, workshyandcheats CharacterAttacksonClaimants Attacksonthecharacteroftheclaimantduringboth2004 5and October Januaryperiodssoughttoportraythemaswastefulor indulgent;with badhabits suchassmoking,drinking,sleepingaround orhavingafamilyconsidered toolarge (allactivitiesordinarily consideredamatterofprivateconscience). 11

13 Conclusion Thisreportpresentsastrongbodyofevidencetosuggestthattherehas beenasignificantchangeinthewaythatdisabilityisbeingreportedin muchofthepressintheunitedkingdomtoday.thecontentanalysis clearlydemonstratesthattherebeenalargeincreaseinthenumberof articlesinwhichdisabilityisthekeythemeandthatthishasbeen accompaniedbyasignificantshiftintheemphasisandinthewaythat thearticlesarebeingreported.thesefindingsarealsosupportedbythe audiencereceptionanalysis.thischangeinthefrequency,contentand toneofthearticlesin2010/11whencomparedtoasimilarperiodin 2004/5marksanewapproachtodisability. Thedetaileddriversforthesechangesarehardtoidentifyandcomplex. Threeofthenewspaperswesurveyedarestrongsupportersofthe CoalitionGovernmentandthesepapershaveallexpressedsupportfor thespendingcutsintroducedaspartofthecomprehensivespending ReviewtotackletheBudgetdeficit.Thefactthattheyaremuchmore reluctanttocriticisethecurrentgovernment spoliciesondisability comparedtosimilarattemptsintroducedbythelastlabourgovernment wouldsuggestthattheirapparentsupportfordisabledpeoplewasat thattimecontingent.theywere,itcouldbeargued,moreinterestedin usingdisabledpeopleasameanstoattackthelabourgovernmentthan theywereinactuallysupportingdisabledpeople. Thevitriolicapproachadoptedbyarticlesinsomeofthepaperstoday andthewaytheyhavereporteddisabilityanddisabledpeopleinthe periodfollowingthecomprehensivespendingreviewaddsfurther weighttotheseclaims.muchofthecoverageinthetabloidpressisat bestquestionableandsomeofitisdeeplyoffensive.theincreased focusonbenefitfraudwithoutlandishclaimsthatover70%ofpeopleon disabilitybenefitsarefraudsisanexampleofthistypeofreporting. Theseclaimsaremadeoverwhelminglywithoutevidenceandatno pointarethemediareportingtheverylowlevelsoffraudthatoccurs overallinrelationtothesebenefits.wewouldfurthercitetheuseof pejorativelanguage,thefailuretoexploretheimpactoftheproposed cutsondisabledpeople squalityoflife,thereluctancetocriticise governmentpolicyontheseissuesandthefrequentrepresentationof somedisabledpeopleasundeservingofbenefitsaspotentially contributingtowhatcouldbecomeahighlyinflammatorysituation. 12

14 Whilethereisasyetnodirectevidencetosupporttheclaimthatthese reportsareleadingtothereportedincreasesinhatecrimes,newspapers shouldtakemuchgreatercareinthisarea.theincreasedpejorative coverageofdisabilitymayhavealongtermeffectandfurtherworkwill beneededtomonitorthis. Theimpactsthesechangeshavehadonthewaythatdisabilityis perceivedbythepopulationisdifficulttodetermineprecisely.manyof theparticipantshadverycomplexandoftenconflictingviews.many,for example,believedthattherewasahighleveloffraudbutallparticipants alsohadpersonalknowledgeoffriendsorfamilymemberswhowerein receiptofadisabilitybenefitandalltalkedabouthowhardithadbeen forthemtoobtainthatbenefit.ontheotherhandtheyalsoknew,or claimedtoknow,peoplewhowerecommittingbenefitfraud.allofthe researchparticipantsmadeacleardistinctionbetweenthosewho deservedtoreceivebenefitsandthosewhodidnotandwhiletheywere veryquicktovilifyfraudulentclaimantstheywerealso,inthemain,very supportiveofdisabledpeople.thiscouldbeexpressedas:disabled peoplearenotfraudstersandfraudstersarenotdisabledpeople. Disabledpeoplethemselvesarefeelingtheeffectsofthiscoverageand itisimpactingontheirownfeelingsofsecurityandsafety.therewasa greatdealofconcernamongthedisabledparticipantsabouttheeffects thatupcomingbenefitchangeswillhaveontheirqualityoflife,ontheir abilitytoparticipateandalsoontheiracceptancebynon disabled people. Thelast20yearshaveseenmajorchangesinthewaythatsocietytreats disabledpeople.notonlyisdisabilitynowrecognizedasanequality issuebutitispartofthenewsingleequalityact(2010)andassuchhas equalfootingwithothergroupsfacingdiscriminationongroundssuchas gender,ethnicityandsexualorientation.recentchanges,representing manyyearsofcampaigningbydisabledpeople,haveculminated inarguablysomeofthemostadvancedequalitylegislationintheworld andkeyelementssuchastheequalitydutyplaceveryhighexpectations onpublicsectorbodies.theunconventionontherightsofpeople withdisabilitieshasbeensignedandratified.nolongeraredisabled peopleexpectedtolivetheirlivesininstitutionsasamatterofcourse. Thereis(forthemoment)apresumptionthatdisabledchildrenwillbe educatedinamainstreamschool,whiledirectpaymentsandother 13

15 formsofself directedsupportarenowawellestablishedpartof communitycarepackages.putsimply,disabledpeoplecanexpecttobe includedinthemainstreaminmostaspectsoftheirlivestoahitherto unknowndegree. Thisprogressisnotsetinstone,however.Inparticular,itmustbe stressedthatprogressonlegislationandrightsstandsincontrasttoa relativefailuretotransforminstitutionsandinstitutionalpractices.on theonehand,equalityfordisabledpeople,anideathatwasonceso contentiousandsodubious,isnowpartoftheequalitymainstream;on theotherhand,thedemandsforequalityhaveyettoberealisedin practice.thus,critiquesof,forexample,segregatededucation,exclusion fromwork,housing,denialoffamilylife,oftherighttosexual expression,toformrelationshipsandtobeparents,whichappearedso incendiarynotsolongago,arenowwidelyendorsed.howeverthis changeinattitudeshasbynomeansdoneawaywiththesepractices; whilsttherehasbeenachangeinthewaythatwetalkaboutdisability, disabledpeoplethemselvesstillfacewidespreaddiscriminationintheir daytodaylives.intheirrecentlypublishedtriennialreview,howfairis Britain?,theEqualityandHumanRightsCommissionprovidea substantialbodyofevidencetosupportthisclaimandshowhow, despiteover15yearsofanti discriminationlegislationdisabledpeople arestillconsiderablydisadvantagedwhencomparedtotheir nondisabledpeers. Thetenuousandcontingentnatureoftheprogressexperiencedby disabledpeoplesuggeststhatthesegainscanbeeasilylostor withdrawn.thereisadangerthatmuchofthereportingthatwediscuss inthisreportcouldlaythegroundworkfortheremovalofsomeofthe supportstructuresandprocessesthatarecurrentlyinplace.thisfear wasexpressedopenlyinoneofthefocusgroupsofdisabledpeopleand isonethatthepressshouldtakeseriously.bysimplyreplicatingthe government'spositionondisabilityanddisabilitybenefitwithout checkingeithertheirstatisticsorthebasisonwhichtheclaimismade thepartisanapproachtheyadopthasthedangeroffurtheraddingto theoppressiondisabledpeopleareexperiencing. 14

16 Part2 Introduction Thegeneralelectionin2010andsubsequentformationofthe Conservative/LiberalDemocraticCoalitionGovernmentisprovingto haveaconsiderableimpactondisabledpeople.therehasbeenmuch commentontheunprecedentedscaleofpublicspendingcutstowhich thegovernmentiscommitted(e.g.http://www.inclusionlondon.co.uk/all-inthis-together). Inparticular,thechangesinwelfarepoliciesthe governmentisintroducingorpreparingtointroducewillhitdisabled peopleharderthananyothergroup.testsonpeoplewhoreceive employmentsupportallowance(esa)carriedoutbyatos(introduced bythepreviousadministrationandcontinuedbythecurrentone)are seekingtoreducethenumbereligibleforthebenefit.theintroduction ofanewuniversalcreditbenefit,thechangeinindexationofuprating benefitsfromthehigherretailpriceindex(rpi)tothelowerconsumer PriceIndex(CPI)togetherwithchangestoentitlementtoDisabilityLiving Allowance(DLA)andarangeofotherbenefitsandservicecutswillall impactadverselyondisabledpeople.demosestimatethatdisabled peoplewilllose 9billioninwelfaresupportinthenextfiveyears(Wood andgrant2010). Notsurprisinglydisabledpeopleandtheirorganisationshaveexpressed considerableconcernabouthowthesechangeswillimpactondisabled people.therecentlypublishedtriennialreviewofequalityinbritain, HowFairisBritain,publishedbytheEqualityandHumanRights Commissionhighlightsthedisadvantageandinequalityexperiencedby disabledpeopleinallaspectsoflife.itisdifficulttoseehowthesecuts inentitlementtobenefitandsupportcandoanythingotherthanfurther disadvantageanalreadydisadvantagedgroup.theseconcernshave beenwelldocumented,forexampleintworeportspublishedbydemos (WoodandGrant2010,2011). Angerhasalsobeendirectedatthewaythatthemediaitselfhas reportedthesecutsandhaschangedthewaythatdisabilityand disabledpeoplearerepresentedanddiscussed.scopeandacoalitionof 15

17 50otherthirdsectororganisationshavesuggestedthatthischangehas playedaroleinincreasinghostilitytowardsdisabledpeople 2. Upuntilnowtherehasonlybeenanecdotalevidencetosupportthe claimthatthemediahavechangedthewaythattheyarereporting disability.theresearchthatthisreportpresentsaimstofillthatvoid. Bycarryingoutacontentanalysisofnewspapercoveragein2004/5with acomparableperiodin2010/11itshowshownewspaperreportinghas changedoverthetwoperiods

18 Methodology&Design Inmeetingtheaboveresearchobjectives,astructuredandpragmatic researchdesignwasdevelopedemployingbothqualitativeand quantitativemethodsandworkingwithinoursettimetableand resources.thisdesignwasflexibleenoughtorespondtoemergent trendsinthedataasneededandincorporatedarangeofmethods includinginterviews,focusgroups,contentanalysisandthecomparative casestudyapproach. ContentAnalysis ScopeoftheResearch&Sample Inordertotrackchangesinstyleorcontentinmediacoverageofpolicy changerelatingtodisabilitybenefits,andthushighlightmediaresponses particulartotherecentcuts,asamplecoveragewasdrawnfor comparisonfromtwoperiods: ThesecondtermofTonyBlair s NewLabour Government ThecontemporaryConservative/LiberalDemocratCoalition Government Alargescaledetailedcontentanalysiswasconductedfocussingonfive popularnewspapers:thesun,themirror,theexpress,th and TheGuardian.Thiswoulddetermineifgovernmentattemptsat reconstructingdisabilityasaburdenimpactedonnewspapercoverage ofdisabilityissues.articlesmentioning disabled, disability, disabilities and incapacity wereobtainedfromlexisnexis,forthe followingtimeperiods: October2004toJanuary documents(oncefiltered) October2010toJanuary documents(oncefiltered) Duplicates,storiesrelatingtoRepublicofIrelandandweekendeditions werefilteredfromthesample.pictureswerenotincludedintheanalysis butregionandeditionofthepaperwerenoted. 17

19 Twocontemporarychangesinpolicywerehighlightedintheearly planningstagesassignificantforafocusedanalysisofrecentmedia coverage: ThereplacementofDisabilityLivingAllowancewithPersonal IndependencePayment ThereplacementofIncapacityBenefitwithEmploymentSupport Allowance. Thereforetheperiodofstudywaslaterextendedtoincludetheperiod whenthesechangesweregoingthrough: MarchtoApril documents(oncefiltered) Therangeofdocumentaryevidenceincludednewsitems,features, opinion,reviews,sport,andletters. Coding Anexperiencedcodingteamofeightindividualswereemployedduring thecontentanalysisstage,supervisedbyprofessorgregphilointhe MediaGroup.Theresearchdesigndrewonexperiencegainedthrough anothersuccessful(departmentofhealth funded)study,intomental healthandthemedia.thepresentresearchbeganwithaprojectspecificbriefinginthemediagroupbriefedmembersofthecoding teamonthespecificaimsoftheprojectandtheirroleand responsibilitieswithinit.areliableandpurpose specificcodingschedule wasdevelopedforandbythecoders(seeappendix1),alongwith detaileddescriptors(seeappendix2).thiswasoverseenbyboth ProfessorPhiloandProfessorWatson,toensurecategorieswere generatedinaccordancewiththespecificaimsoftheresearch.the codingteamworkedmethodicallyaccordingtoagreedprocedure,and drewpracticalinsightsfromearlydatagathered.thesehighlighted emergentthemes,whichwereusedtofurtherinformthedesign,and ultimatelytoenrichlateranalysis.codersworkedcollaboratively, discussingexamplesandcheckingeachothersanalysistoensurea consistentapproach.inadditiontothis,themostexperiencedcoders actedasfinalcheckertomonitorforconsistentoutput. Thecodingschedulecategories(SeeAppendices1&2)weredevisedto identifyreferencesbothto: 18

20 Representationswhichreferenceddisabilityanditsuniquesocial context,andhowthisdiscoursechangedovertime. Politicalissuesraisedinthecoverage. Inordertoassesspotentialdifferencesinthecoverage,whenadisability wasmentionedthiswasnotedin3broadcategories: PhysicalandSensoryImpairments MentalHealth Learningdisabilities Amongotherthings,thiswashopedtorecordanypotentialdifferences innewspaperassessmentsof need,ordifferingportrayalsofthe legitimacyofclaimants(as deserving or undeserving ),thatmightbe attributedtotypesofconditions.allarticleswerecodedaccordingto howprominentathemewasinthearticle,andthesevariableswere measuredona5pointscale(rangingfroma baremention,toa dominanttheme inthearticle).bothimplicitandexplicitreferences werenoted,whentheseappearedintheheadline.specificexamplesof pejorativelanguagereferencingdisabilitybenefitclaimantsdirectlyor indirectlywerealsonotedtoenrichlateranalysis.inordertoidentify themostfrequentlycited voices acrossthebodyofarticles,references attributedtopoliticians(bypoliticalparty),charities,carersanddisabled people,amongotherkeycommentators,wereallrecorded.thecoding periodoccurredbetweenmarchandjune2011and,asmentioned above,theinitialscopeoftheprojectwasextendedtoincludecrucial coveragebetweenmarchandapril2011. Analysis AnalysisbeganinJulyandaresearcherexperiencedindataanalysiswas engagedduringthisstage.spsssoftwarewasusedtoidentifystatistical trendsinthedata. AudienceReceptionAnalysis Wealsocarriedoutanaudiencereceptionstudytodeterminehowthe reportingofdisabilityanddisabledpeoplewaswerebeinginterpreted bythegeneralpublicandhowitwasimpactingontheirperceptionsof 19

Identity Fraud: What about the Victim?

Identity Fraud: What about the Victim? Identity Fraud: What about the Victim? Research Findings Tim Pascoe Katy Owen Gemma Keats Martin Gill March 2006 Perpetuity Research & Consultancy International (PRCI) Ltd 148 Upper New Walk Leicester

More information

Taking control of employment support

Taking control of employment support Taking control of employment support October 2013 2 This paper was written by Neil Crowther and Liz Sayce. We are interested in stimulating debate and welcome feedback and discussion on the proposals October

More information

An independent review into the impact on employment outcomes of drug or alcohol addiction, and obesity. Call for evidence

An independent review into the impact on employment outcomes of drug or alcohol addiction, and obesity. Call for evidence An independent review into the impact on employment outcomes of drug or alcohol addiction, and obesity Call for evidence July 2015 Contents Foreword by Professor Dame Carol Black... 3 Introduction... 4

More information

Project PESSIS 2 Title: Social Dialogue in the Social Services Sector in Europe

Project PESSIS 2 Title: Social Dialogue in the Social Services Sector in Europe Project PESSIS 2 Title: Social Dialogue in the Social Services Sector in Europe Location Brussels Date 23 September 2014 Presenter/contact details: Jane Lethbridge, Director, Public Services International

More information

The Truth About Issue 2

The Truth About Issue 2 The Truth About Issue 2 What will Issue 2 actually do? The Big Business coalition which supports Issue 2 has the money to air a slick ad campaign. The Big Business Campaign is founded on the belief that

More information

Countering Fraud in Student Funding. Fiona Innes Head of Counter Fraud, Counter Fraud Services Department March 2016

Countering Fraud in Student Funding. Fiona Innes Head of Counter Fraud, Counter Fraud Services Department March 2016 Countering Fraud in Student Funding Fiona Innes Head of Counter Fraud, Counter Fraud Services Department March 2016 Content Introduction Background & Structure What we do How we do it Case Studies Consequences

More information

South East of Process Main Building / 1F. North East of Process Main Building / 1F. At 14:05 April 16, 2011. Sample not collected

South East of Process Main Building / 1F. North East of Process Main Building / 1F. At 14:05 April 16, 2011. Sample not collected At 14:05 April 16, 2011 At 13:55 April 16, 2011 At 14:20 April 16, 2011 ND ND 3.6E-01 ND ND 3.6E-01 1.3E-01 9.1E-02 5.0E-01 ND 3.7E-02 4.5E-01 ND ND 2.2E-02 ND 3.3E-02 4.5E-01 At 11:37 April 17, 2011 At

More information

Work Related Stress: Workplace Strategies

Work Related Stress: Workplace Strategies Work Related Stress: Workplace Strategies Workplace-related stress: Workplace Strategies Stress and struggle Workplace-related stress: Workplace Strategies 21 st century Diseases of the heart and mind

More information

Negativity, medicalization and awareness: a corpus-based discourse analysis of representations of mental illness in the British press (2011-2014)

Negativity, medicalization and awareness: a corpus-based discourse analysis of representations of mental illness in the British press (2011-2014) Negativity, medicalization and awareness: a corpus-based discourse analysis of representations of mental illness in the British press (2011-2014) Gillian Smith Methods Critical Discourse Analysis (Bloor

More information

REVENUES & BENEFITS SERVICE FRAUD PROSECUTION & SANCTION POLICY

REVENUES & BENEFITS SERVICE FRAUD PROSECUTION & SANCTION POLICY REVENUES & BENEFITS SERVICE FRAUD PROSECUTION & SANCTION POLICY August 2013 1. Introduction REVENUES & BENEFIT SERVICE FRAUD PROSECUTION & SANCTIONS POLICY 1.1 Rochdale Metropolitan Borough Council administers

More information

RUNNING HEAD: INSURANCE FRAUD: WHAT ARE THE COSTS? 1

RUNNING HEAD: INSURANCE FRAUD: WHAT ARE THE COSTS? 1 RUNNING HEAD: INSURANCE FRAUD: WHAT ARE THE COSTS? 1 Insurance Fraud: What Are the Costs? Sarah Smith Eastern Kentucky University April 20, 2016 INSURANCE FRAUD: WHAT ARE THE COSTS? 2 Insurance Fraud:

More information

Equality Impact Assessment: Changes to National Insurance Contribution Conditions. For Employment and Support Allowance and Jobseeker s Allowance

Equality Impact Assessment: Changes to National Insurance Contribution Conditions. For Employment and Support Allowance and Jobseeker s Allowance Equality Impact Assessment: Changes to National Insurance Contribution Conditions For Employment and Support Allowance and Jobseeker s Allowance Equality impact assessment for changes to National Insurance

More information

Fraud. Baldomero Gonzalez. Our reputation for excellence is no accident. TM

Fraud. Baldomero Gonzalez. Our reputation for excellence is no accident. TM Fraud Baldomero Gonzalez Workers Compensation Fraud It is estimated that ten percent of all claims, nearly $31 billion dollars, is paid annually in fraudulent workers compensation claims. Workers compensation

More information

Industrial Tribunals and The Fair Employment Tribunal Northern Ireland

Industrial Tribunals and The Fair Employment Tribunal Northern Ireland Industrial Tribunals and The Fair Employment Tribunal rthern Ireland Response to a claim to an Industrial Tribunal and/or The Fair Employment Tribunal in rthern Ireland www.employmenttribunalsni.co.uk

More information

Using the TUC Manifesto for Disability Equality. A guide for trade union activists

Using the TUC Manifesto for Disability Equality. A guide for trade union activists Using the TUC Manifesto for Disability Equality A guide for trade union activists Section one Why a manifesto? Trade unions campaign for a better future for all. The TUC s new Manifesto for Disability

More information

No Hiding Place. Insurance Fraud Exposed. September 2012

No Hiding Place. Insurance Fraud Exposed. September 2012 No Hiding Place Insurance Fraud Exposed September 2012 NO HIDING PLACE INSURANCE FRAUD EXPOSED 3 Executive summary Every hour of every day 15 fraudulent insurance claims are exposed in the UK. Insurance

More information

An update on ENABLE Scotland s Teacher Education campaign

An update on ENABLE Scotland s Teacher Education campaign Bridging the Training Gap An update on ENABLE Scotland s Teacher Education campaign www.enable.org.uk Bridging the Training Gap An update on ENABLE Scotland s Teacher Education campaign What s the campaign

More information

Industrial Tribunals and The Fair Employment Tribunal. Response to a claim to an Industrial Tribunal and/or The Fair Employment Tribunal

Industrial Tribunals and The Fair Employment Tribunal. Response to a claim to an Industrial Tribunal and/or The Fair Employment Tribunal Industrial Tribunals and The Fair Employment Tribunal Response to a claim to an Industrial Tribunal and/or The Fair Employment Tribunal www.employmenttribunalsni.co.uk ET3 (NI) Revised June 2009 To make

More information

A mule s life is a fool s life

A mule s life is a fool s life A mule s life is a fool s life Allowing your bank account to be used to send and receive funds for others can result in a criminal record. A mule s life is a fool s life. The bank account lies at the heart

More information

Parkinson s UK policy statement Control, choice and personalised services in health and social care

Parkinson s UK policy statement Control, choice and personalised services in health and social care Parkinson s UK policy statement Control, choice and personalised services in health and social care Choice doesn't seem to be on the table - there are very limited respite care facilities which makes 'having

More information

Construction Industry Scheme

Construction Industry Scheme Construction Industry Scheme The Construction Industry Scheme (CIS) sets out special rules for tax and national insurance (NI) for those working in the construction industry. Businesses in the construction

More information

Speaking Middle English. A study on the Middle Classes by BritainThinks

Speaking Middle English. A study on the Middle Classes by BritainThinks Speaking Middle English A study on the es by BritainThinks Introduction About BritainThinks Putting the people that matter at the heart of your thinking makes for better decisions, more effective communications

More information

Lifetime Community Rating

Lifetime Community Rating Here to help you Lifetime Community Rating We compare all four health insurance providers Health insurance from Aviva My cover. My way. deadline 1st may 2015! Lifetime Community Rating (LCR) 1st May 2015

More information

CHUBB GROUP OF INSURANCE COMPANIES

CHUBB GROUP OF INSURANCE COMPANIES CHUBB GROUP OF INSURANCE COMPANIES 202 Hall s Mill Road, Whitehouse Station, NJ 08889 Telephone 1-800-437-5114 Fax: (908)572-4036 HOW TO FILE A CLAIM In the event of a claim, written or verbal notice must

More information

Classification, Detection and Prosecution of Fraud on Mobile Networks

Classification, Detection and Prosecution of Fraud on Mobile Networks Classification, Detection and Prosecution of Fraud on Mobile Networks (1) Vodafone Ltd, The Courtyard, 2-4 London Road, Newbury, Berkshire, RG14 1JX, England (2) ICRI, KU Leuven, Tiensestraat 41, B-3000

More information

Olga Eisele. Series Editors: Katrin Auel and Resul Umit

Olga Eisele. Series Editors: Katrin Auel and Resul Umit Research Notes on Parliamentary Democracy 5/216 Democratic Deaf-icit? Looking at newspapers in Finland, Germany and the UK, it seems that citizens have very different chances to learn what their European

More information

Exploring organisational approaches to develop personalised employment support for people with Intellectual Disabilities

Exploring organisational approaches to develop personalised employment support for people with Intellectual Disabilities Exploring organisational approaches to develop personalised employment support for people with Intellectual Disabilities Martin Stevens and Jess Harris Social Care Workforce Research Unit King s College

More information

Demystifying Big Data. James Rawlins Senior Consultant

Demystifying Big Data. James Rawlins Senior Consultant Demystifying Big Data James Rawlins Senior Consultant What s the Big Idea? Objectives for the session Understand what is meant by Big Data Provide some context around what is Big Are we big? Understand

More information

THE FLORIDA. Rundown FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF FINANCIAL SERVICES

THE FLORIDA. Rundown FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF FINANCIAL SERVICES JEFF ATWATER CHIEF FINANCIAL OFFICER THE FLORIDA Rundown FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF FINANCIAL SERVICES MESSAGE FROM YOUR CFO Dear friends, For years now, I ve traveled across Florida to bring the news of our

More information

DEPARTMENT OF LABOUR

DEPARTMENT OF LABOUR DEPARTMENT OF LABOUR How to start up a learnership: A guide for employers Government has introduced a training programme called leanerships. Employers play a crucial role in the implementation of learnerships.

More information

I contribute to the running expenses of the vessel and receive a portion of the income are likewise not considered true "workers".

I contribute to the running expenses of the vessel and receive a portion of the income are likewise not considered true workers. QUEENSLAND GOVERNMENT RESPONSE TO THE RECOMMENDATONS OF THE FNANCE AND ADMNSTRATON COMMTTEE'S REPORT OF THE NQURY NTO THE OPERATON OF QUEENSLAND'S WORKERS' COMPENSATON SCHEME # Committee recommendation

More information

Life Insurance Law Firm Los Angeles

Life Insurance Law Firm Los Angeles Life Insurance Law Firm Los Angeles James T. Hudson is a California civil trial lawyer, specializing in insurance disputes. Mr. Hudson handles virtually all types of insurance claims: for disability income

More information

Managing Stress As A Cause of Sickness Absence. Elaine McCann

Managing Stress As A Cause of Sickness Absence. Elaine McCann Managing Stress As A Cause of Sickness Absence Elaine McCann Programme Agenda / Outline WHAT ACTIONS I WILLTAKE Negative impact of stress on our organisations Impact of our organisational culture on staff

More information

CARERS 10% 4,559 14,512 13% 42% 58% SHEFFIELD COMMUNITY KNOWLEDGE PROFILES HIDDEN CARERS. Sheffield residents providing unpaid care

CARERS 10% 4,559 14,512 13% 42% 58% SHEFFIELD COMMUNITY KNOWLEDGE PROFILES HIDDEN CARERS. Sheffield residents providing unpaid care SHEFFIELD COMMUNITY KNOWLEDGE PROFILES CARERS Updated: October 2015 57,373* Sheffield residents 10% Proportion of Sheffield s population who provide unpaid 4,559 Under 24 year olds residents 14,512 People

More information

Transition resources Welfare Benefits

Transition resources Welfare Benefits Transition resources Welfare Benefits A briefing for Parent Partnership Services July 2012 Introduction 1. This information sheet provides an overview of the key welfare benefits that are currently (May

More information

Architects Earnings. How do you compare?

Architects Earnings. How do you compare? Earnings. How do you compare? A Briefing Document on the latest research published by The Fees Bureau and distributed to members of the RIBA. 29 Earnings Survey shows architects earnings are up by 7 per

More information

White Paper Voice Fraud Monitoring

White Paper Voice Fraud Monitoring White Paper Voice Fraud Monitoring Executive Summary Voice Fraud is a growing concern in this country, with 98% of businesses which have experienced hacking also victims of Voice Fraud. The cost of the

More information

Supranational accreditation, trust and institutional autonomy

Supranational accreditation, trust and institutional autonomy Supranational accreditation, trust and institutional autonomy Alberto Amaral, Maria João Rosa, Diana Tavares 2008 IMHE General Conference Paris, 8-10 September Introduction Europe - supranational policy

More information

Equality and mental health: what the law means for your workplace

Equality and mental health: what the law means for your workplace Equality and mental health: what the law means for your workplace Equality and Mental Health 1 First published (December) 2011 by The Equality Authority Birchgrove House Roscrea Co. Tipperary and The Equality

More information

Tax Year 2015 Personal Exemptions and Deductions

Tax Year 2015 Personal Exemptions and Deductions 13-Nov-14 Tax Year 2015 Personal Exemptions and Personal Exemption: $4,000 : Single 6,300 1,550 9,250 1,550 12,600 1,250 : $1,050 : Single 10,300 11,850 13,400 0 children 13,250 14,800 16,350 1 child 17,250

More information

Carbon Brief poll on climate change and energy

Carbon Brief poll on climate change and energy Carbon Brief poll on climate change and energy 2017 online interviews by Opinium. Fieldwork: 29th to 31st Jan 2013 UK nationally representative sample ASK ALL SINGLE CHOICE S1. How did you vote in the

More information

Dyslexia in the Workplace Margaret Malpas Co-Chair of the British Dyslexia Association (BDA) and Founder of Malpas Flexible Learning Ltd

Dyslexia in the Workplace Margaret Malpas Co-Chair of the British Dyslexia Association (BDA) and Founder of Malpas Flexible Learning Ltd APPENDIX THREE Presentations from Field Experts Dyslexia in the Workplace Margaret Malpas Co-Chair of the British Dyslexia Association (BDA) and Founder of Malpas Flexible Learning Ltd Background Dyslexia

More information

Don t let your lifestyle disappear.

Don t let your lifestyle disappear. Don t let your lifestyle disappear. Pensions Protection Investments Income Protection Safeguard your lifestyle with the security of Income Protection by Friends First. www.friendsfirst.ie At Friends First,

More information

Your 10-point plan for coping with redundancy

Your 10-point plan for coping with redundancy The New Daily February 27, 2014 Melissa Mack Your 10-point plan for coping with redundancy http://thenewdaily.com.au/money/2014/02/28/10-point-plan-coping-redundancy/ Times are tough in the jobs market,

More information

Fee Policy and Bad Debt management procedure guide

Fee Policy and Bad Debt management procedure guide Fee Policy and Bad Debt management procedure guide There are many benefits for you and your customers by having a clear written fee policy. Details to consider including in your policies: Details of all

More information

The Security-Privacy tension: recent developments in the U.K. and elsewhere

The Security-Privacy tension: recent developments in the U.K. and elsewhere The Security-Privacy tension: recent developments in the U.K. and elsewhere James Davenport Hebron & Medlock Professor of Information Technology University of Bath (U.K.) 16 January 2014 Overall Thesis

More information

Mass Media C H A P T E R K E N B R O W N E. BROWNE for A2 AQA (2e) Unit 3.indd 167 09/10/2013 16:44

Mass Media C H A P T E R K E N B R O W N E. BROWNE for A2 AQA (2e) Unit 3.indd 167 09/10/2013 16:44 C H A P T E R 3 Mass Media K E N B R O W N E BROWNE for A2 AQA (2e) Unit 3.indd 167 09/10/2013 16:44 Contents Speci cation topics 169 Topic 1 169 What are the mass media? 169 Traditional and new media

More information

2nd Global Summit Healthcare Fraud: Prevention is better than cure. 25-26 October 2012 Beaumont Estate, Old Windsor, UK

2nd Global Summit Healthcare Fraud: Prevention is better than cure. 25-26 October 2012 Beaumont Estate, Old Windsor, UK 2nd Global Summit Healthcare Fraud: Prevention is better than cure 25-26 October 2012 Beaumont Estate, Old Windsor, UK The use of intelligence to prevent health insurance fraud in the UK Association of

More information

Statement of. Mark Nelsen. Senior Vice President, Risk Products and Business Intelligence. Visa Inc. House Ways & Means Subcommittee.

Statement of. Mark Nelsen. Senior Vice President, Risk Products and Business Intelligence. Visa Inc. House Ways & Means Subcommittee. Statement of Mark Nelsen Senior Vice President, Risk Products and Business Intelligence Visa Inc. House Ways & Means Subcommittee on Oversight Hearing on The Use of Data to Stop Medicare Fraud March 24,

More information

Could you spot a scammer?

Could you spot a scammer? Could you spot a scammer? Keeping you safe and secure Fraud can affect anyone whatever your background, age or experience And attempts can come in all shapes and sizes over the phone, on the internet or

More information

Comprehensive and versatile confirmation of identity and bank account details

Comprehensive and versatile confirmation of identity and bank account details Comprehensive and versatile confirmation of identity and bank account details Equifax Bank Account Verifier is a comprehensive and versatile service that quickly verifies a customer s identity and confirms

More information

City Of London Blames Increased Crash Claims on Legal System - A Biased London Free Press Article

City Of London Blames Increased Crash Claims on Legal System - A Biased London Free Press Article City Of London Blames Increased Crash Claims on Legal System - A Biased London Free Press Article Posting Date: 01 Apr 2011 The London Free Press has authored a rather biased article in its April 1st,

More information

Council Tax Relief. Brentwood Borough Councils local council tax support scheme. An equality impact assessment

Council Tax Relief. Brentwood Borough Councils local council tax support scheme. An equality impact assessment Council Tax Relief Brentwood Borough Councils local council tax support scheme An equality impact assessment This Equality Impact Assessment is based on the financial models adopted for consultation by

More information

Financial Service Division Operational Finance Unit. Council Tax Discretionary Relief Policy

Financial Service Division Operational Finance Unit. Council Tax Discretionary Relief Policy Financial Service Division Operational Finance Unit Council Tax Discretionary Relief Policy Version: Draft 2.0 Updated: September 2014 1 Contents 1) Introduction... 3 2) Legislative Powers... 3 3) Statement

More information

Civil Justice Council response to Insurance Task Force interim report. May 2015

Civil Justice Council response to Insurance Task Force interim report. May 2015 Civil Justice Council response to Insurance Task Force interim report May 2015 The CJC welcomes an initiative to combat insurance fraud, which is not always easy to detect, but is a crime, and does lead

More information

20 Days to a Better Customer Experience: Utilizing Touchpoint Teams to Improve Service. Kelly Magalsky October 2014

20 Days to a Better Customer Experience: Utilizing Touchpoint Teams to Improve Service. Kelly Magalsky October 2014 20 Days to a Better Customer Experience: Utilizing Touchpoint Teams to Improve Service Kelly Magalsky October 2014 Touchpoint Success Stories Why Customer Experience? Why Focus on Customer Experience?

More information

PER S ONAL B UD GETS I NFO PAC K. Live Life Your Way. A step-by-step guide to personal budgets. Adult Social Care Services live life your way

PER S ONAL B UD GETS I NFO PAC K. Live Life Your Way. A step-by-step guide to personal budgets. Adult Social Care Services live life your way PER S ONAL B UD GETS I NFO PAC K Live Life Your Way A step-by-step guide to personal budgets Adult Social Care Services live life your way 1 This booklet is about the support provided by Tower Hamlets

More information

Version 1.0. klm. General Certificate of Education June 2010. GCE Business Studies. Mark Scheme

Version 1.0. klm. General Certificate of Education June 2010. GCE Business Studies. Mark Scheme Version 1.0 klm General Certificate of Education June 2010 GCE Business Studies BUSS4 Mark Scheme Mark schemes are prepared by the Principal Examiner and considered, together with the relevant questions,

More information

Tax Fraud in Financial Services

Tax Fraud in Financial Services Tax Fraud in Financial Services Innocent Until Proven Careless? Nick Skerrett Stephen Gentle 30 September 2014 Contents Where are financial institutions exposed to fraud? Civil enforcement Statutory tax

More information

2. All references to Returning Officers in this code should be taken to refer to Counting Officers for referendums.

2. All references to Returning Officers in this code should be taken to refer to Counting Officers for referendums. Code of conduct for political parties, candidates, canvassers and campaigners on the handling of postal vote applications and postal ballot papers in England and Wales Introduction 1. Political parties,

More information

Public and Private Sector Pay

Public and Private Sector Pay Public and Private Sector Pay 2013 update Matthew Oakley October 2013 Overview Over 12% of GDP ( 180 billion) is spent on remunerating employees in the public sector. Our report Local Pay, Local Growth,

More information

Four Schools of Software Testing. bret@pettichord.com www.pettichord.com

Four Schools of Software Testing. bret@pettichord.com www.pettichord.com Four Schools of Software Testing bret@pettichord.com www.pettichord.com Workshop on Teaching Software Testing, Florida Tech, February 2003 Why Classify Testing Doctrines into Schools? Clarify why testing

More information

Business insurance and succession planning

Business insurance and succession planning Business insurance and succession planning BUSINESS INSURANCE AND SUCCESSION PLANNING Owning a business can be a very rewarding experience. But what happens if a business owner dies or falls seriously

More information

Employment Support Allowance

Employment Support Allowance Employment Support Allowance Employment Support Allowance This factsheet is part of our Benefits range. It is written for people who are deaf. We use the term people who are deaf to refer to people who

More information

Time limiting contributory Employment and Support Allowance to one year for those in the work-related activity group

Time limiting contributory Employment and Support Allowance to one year for those in the work-related activity group Time limiting contributory Employment and Support Allowance to one year for those in the work-related activity group Equality impact assessment October 2011 Equality impact assessment for time limiting

More information

Turning Accounts Payable from a Cost Center to a Revenue Generation

Turning Accounts Payable from a Cost Center to a Revenue Generation GAIN GLOBAL VISIBILITY OF CASH & RISK FOSTER CONNECTIVITY UNLOCK HIDDEN CASH DRIVE EFFICIENCIES & PRODUCTIVITY AVANTGARD Turning Accounts Payable from a Cost Center to a Revenue Generation Dawn Lothringer,

More information

Health Care Reform in Slovenia: challenges and opportunities

Health Care Reform in Slovenia: challenges and opportunities Health Care Reform in Slovenia: challenges and opportunities Charles Normand Edward Kennedy Professor of Health Policy and Management Chair of Steering Committee, European Observatory on Health systems

More information

Facts & Considerations From a Legal Perspective

Facts & Considerations From a Legal Perspective Long Term Care Insurance Facts & Considerations From a Legal Perspective Glenn R. Kantor, Esq. Corinne Chandler, Esq. Kantor & Kantor Attorneys at Law (877) 783-8686 www.kantorlaw.net GKantor@KantorLaw.net

More information

Serviced offices Space solutions

Serviced offices Space solutions Serviced offices Space solutions Forsyth Business Centres 1 Hong Kong, a magnet for world business Forsyth s ethos is based on excellent customer care and first class, cost effective service, with a personal

More information

Equality and mental health: how the law can help you

Equality and mental health: how the law can help you Equality and mental health: how the law can help you Equality and Mental Health 1 First published (December) 2011 by The Equality Authority Birchgrove House Roscrea Co. Tipperary and The Equality Authority

More information

Introduction 3. Scope of the Consultation 3. Background 3. Proposals for the Teachers Pension Scheme from April 2013 to March 2014 4

Introduction 3. Scope of the Consultation 3. Background 3. Proposals for the Teachers Pension Scheme from April 2013 to March 2014 4 Consultation on proposed increases in contributions for members of the Teachers Pension Scheme (TPS) in 2013-14; and the removal of provisions governing scheme valuations and cap and share arrangements

More information

Earned Income Tax Credit A Financial Assistance Tool for OCSE Families. Office of Child Support Enforcement WICSEC 2008 San Antonio, TX

Earned Income Tax Credit A Financial Assistance Tool for OCSE Families. Office of Child Support Enforcement WICSEC 2008 San Antonio, TX Earned Income Tax Credit A Financial Assistance Tool for OCSE Families Office of Child Support Enforcement WICSEC 2008 San Antonio, TX SPEC Mission Statement To assist taxpayers in satisfying their tax

More information

Technical claims brief

Technical claims brief QBE European Operations Technical claims brief Monthly update March 2013 Technical claims brief Monthly update March 2013 Contents News 1 Second UK wide discount rate consultation finally gets underway

More information

CCG1. Application for help with childcare costs 2015/16 NI/CCG1/1516/A

CCG1. Application for help with childcare costs 2015/16 NI/CCG1/1516/A CCG1 Application for help with childcare costs 2015/16 NI/CCG1/1516/A 1 Steps to getting a Childcare Grant (CCG) if you have dependent children in registered or approved childcare. Step 1 You need to complete

More information

VOLUNTEERS & EXPENSES

VOLUNTEERS & EXPENSES VOLUNTEERS & EXPENSES I N F O R M A T I O N S H E E T What do I need to know about? Best Practice Social Security Benefits Child Care Carers Taxation National Minimum Wage Volunteers who wish to donate

More information

management fee documentation

management fee documentation Issue 2010-02 www.bdo.ca the tax factor e-communications from the cra READ MORE p4 management fee documentation READ MORE p6 relief on US FBAR requirements READ MORE p8 Changes to the Tax Deferral on Publicly

More information

The UK s Whiplash Epidemic

The UK s Whiplash Epidemic The UK s Whiplash Epidemic The International Insurance Forum Motor Insurance: The Road Towards Profitability James Dalton, Director of General Insurance Policy Association of British Insurers 19 th April

More information

Foundation dentists application form

Foundation dentists application form Foundation dentists application form For all UK applications Important notes: Before completing this application form It is important that you have been given a copy of our key features document and your

More information

Government Crime Prevention Regulations. Richard Fraher VP & Counsel to the Retail Payments Office Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta

Government Crime Prevention Regulations. Richard Fraher VP & Counsel to the Retail Payments Office Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta Government Crime Prevention Regulations Richard Fraher VP & Counsel to the Retail Payments Office Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta The Big Disclaimers The views expressed in this presentation are those

More information

Entitlement to Social Welfare Payments. of Self-Employed persons. Presentation to the. Joint Oireachtas Committee. on Education and Social Protection

Entitlement to Social Welfare Payments. of Self-Employed persons. Presentation to the. Joint Oireachtas Committee. on Education and Social Protection Entitlement to Social Welfare Payments of Self-Employed persons. Presentation to the Joint Oireachtas Committee on Education and Social Protection 26 th March 2014. 1 ISME, the Irish Small & Medium Enterprises

More information

Doctors acting as health and welfare attorneys for their patients a guidance note

Doctors acting as health and welfare attorneys for their patients a guidance note BMA Ethics Doctors acting as health and welfare attorneys for their patients a guidance note February 2012 Summary box...1 Introduction...1 What is a Lasting Power of Attorney?...1 Health and Welfare Powers

More information

Do you agree with this proposal? Yes No

Do you agree with this proposal? Yes No Consultation Proposals - Part 1 Control of Entry (Pharmacy Applications) and Dispensing GP Practices: The stability of NHS services in remote and rural areas RESPONSE FROM RCGP SCOTLAND The Royal College

More information

Yield and. Protection. Anti-Fraud. Uncover insights you never thought were possible.

Yield and. Protection. Anti-Fraud. Uncover insights you never thought were possible. Home Home Yield and Anti-Fraud Protection Uncover insights you never thought were possible. Tax and welfare agencies worldwide strive to increase compliance, prevent improper payments and reduce errors.

More information

Regional Publications

Regional Publications Regional Publications Circulation Certificate January 2013 Evening Standard Setting the standard Key information Certificate type Print Metric type Circulation ABC headline 695,645 average per issue (100.00%

More information

The Manifesto of the ACC Futures Coalition

The Manifesto of the ACC Futures Coalition The Manifesto of the ACC Futures Coalition Introduction The ACC Futures Coalition consists of community groups, academics, organisations representing people who need support from ACC, health treatment

More information

prof.itplus Release Notes Addendum Changes to the Handling of Prompt Payment (Settlement) Discounts

prof.itplus Release Notes Addendum Changes to the Handling of Prompt Payment (Settlement) Discounts prof.itplus Release Notes Addendum Changes to the Handling of Prompt Payment (Settlement) Discounts 13 th March 2015 Addendum Contents Page 1.0 Overview... 3 2.0 Background & HMRC Guidance... 3 3.0 Outline

More information

Can t Pay Your Mortgage?

Can t Pay Your Mortgage? Can t Pay Your Mortgage? Helpful advice from the BSA and the Money Advice Trust Can t Pay Your Mortgage? Having problems paying your mortgage can be one of the most stressful and traumatic problems that

More information

operations@pay-net.net (this will be forwarded to the appropriate person)

operations@pay-net.net (this will be forwarded to the appropriate person) April, 2009 Welcome to our Forty Fourth Edition of Pay-Net s E-Newsletter. Previous editions of our E- Newsletter are available on our web site, www.pay-net.net, under the Employer Resources Newsletter

More information

Technical Note: Monthly Early Estimates of Income Support Lone Parent s (ISLP) and Employment and Support Allowance (ESA) and Incapacity Benefits

Technical Note: Monthly Early Estimates of Income Support Lone Parent s (ISLP) and Employment and Support Allowance (ESA) and Incapacity Benefits Technical Note: Monthly Early Estimates of Income Support Lone Parent s (ISLP) and Employment and Support Allowance (ESA) and Incapacity Benefits Client Groups Updated 11 November 2015 1 Technical Note:

More information

WHEN YOU NEED IT MOST

WHEN YOU NEED IT MOST A HELPING HAND WHEN YOU NEED IT MOST A Guide to Your One to One Personal Support Helping Hand: One to One Personal Support Introducing ROYAL LONDON Ever since we started as a Friendly Society over 150

More information

Enterprise Clubs. Equality Impact Assessment Version 2.1 (November 2011)

Enterprise Clubs. Equality Impact Assessment Version 2.1 (November 2011) Enterprise Clubs Equality Impact Assessment Version 2.1 (November 2011) Equality Impact Assessment for Enterprise Clubs Introduction 1. The Department for Work and Pensions has conducted the following

More information

FIBE 2009: Impact of Research. Stephen Watson AACSB International

FIBE 2009: Impact of Research. Stephen Watson AACSB International FIBE 2009: Impact of Research Stephen Watson AACSB International AACSB International Founded in 1916 by leading US business schools as a forum for management education Now has 559 accredited business schools

More information

Best Use of Direct Marketing

Best Use of Direct Marketing Best Use of Direct Marketing 2015 Nomination Form Nominations should be in respect of activity completed during the organisation s 2014 financial year. This award will recognise the campaign that demonstrates

More information

About Dogs for Depression

About Dogs for Depression Dogs for Depression Factsheet 1 2 About Dogs for Depression Dogs for Depression campaigns to raise awareness and understanding of the benefits of emotional support dogs and psychological assistance dogs

More information

Comcare Asbestos Related Compensation Claims & Workers Compensation Claim Management

Comcare Asbestos Related Compensation Claims & Workers Compensation Claim Management Records Authority 2010/00322036 Comcare Asbestos Related Compensation Claims & Workers Compensation Claim Management 2011 CONTENTS INTRODUCTION APPLICATION OF THIS AUTHORITY CONTACT INFORMATION AUTHORISATION

More information

Expert Witness Services for Personal Injury Lawyers

Expert Witness Services for Personal Injury Lawyers Advanced Assessments Ltd Expert witnesses and Psychologists A Member of the Strategic Enterprise Group 180 Piccadilly, London, W1J 9HP T: 0845 130 5717 Expert Witness Services for Personal Injury Lawyers

More information

Social Security Administration: Exchanging Electronic Health Information across the NwHIN 2/21/2012 1

Social Security Administration: Exchanging Electronic Health Information across the NwHIN 2/21/2012 1 Social Security Administration: Exchanging Electronic Health Information across the NwHIN 2/21/2012 1 Conflict of Interest Disclosure Debby Ellis Tina Le Diane Kistler Has no real or apparent conflicts

More information