arxiv:cond-mat/ v1 [cond-mat.mes-hall] 8 Apr 1997

Transcription

1 The Composite Fermion Hierarchy: Condensed States of Composite Fermion Excitations? arxiv:cond-mat/ v [cond-mat.mes-ha] 8 Apr 997 P. Sitko,2, K.-S. Yi 3, and J. J. Quinn,4 University of Tennessee, Knoxvie, Tennessee 37996, USA 2 Institute of Physics, Technica University of Wroc aw, Wyb. Wyspiańskiego 27, Wroc aw, Poand 3 Pusan Nationa University, Pusan , Korea 4 Oak Ridge Nationa Laboratory, Oak Ridge, Tennessee, 3783, USA (February, 2008) A composite Fermion hierarchy theory is constructed in a way reated to the origina Hadane picture by appying the composite Fermion (CF) transformation to quasipartices of Jain states. It is shown that the Jain theory coincides with the Hadane hierarchy theory for principa CF fiings. Within the Fermi iquid approach for few eectron systems on the sphere a simpe interpretation of many-quasipartice spectra is given and provides an expanation of faiure of CF hierarchy picture when appied to the hierarchica 4/ state. PACS numbers: Hm, Dx The Hadane hierarchy [,2] of fractiona quantum Ha states is obtained when quasipartice excitations of Laughin [3] ν = /m incompressibe states undergo condensation into new incompressibe (daughter) states. Jain [4] noted that certain hierarchy fractions appeared to be particuary stabe, and he introduced the composite Fermion (CF) picture which predicts incompressibe quantum iquid states at fiings ν = n(+2pn), where p =, 2, 3,..., and n = ±, ±2, ±3,.... By invoking eectron-hoe symmetry condensed CF states at fiing factor ν can be found. These two Jain sequences do not contain a odd denominator fractions which are present in the hierarchy theory. The missing odd denominator fractions can be generated by introducing an operator L whose appication to a Jain tria wavefunction increases the CF fiing factor by unity [5]. Because the appication of L to a FQH state weakens it enormousy, Jain and Godman suggest that to a first approximation L can be competey negected. Instead of constructing tria wavefunctions, Lopez and Fradkin [6] used the CF transformation to construct a conventiona many body description of the interactions, both Couomb and Chern-Simons gauge interactions, among the fuctuations beyond the mean fied. They considered ony states beonging to the principa Jain sequence, so it is uncear how the hierarchy of odd denominator fractions appears in their approach. The object of the present paper is to demonstrate how the hierarchy of CF states arises. It invoves appying the CF transformation to quasipartices (CF s in a partiay fied she) and assuming that mean fied theory adequatey describes the resuting state. The procedure is not at a obvious, since it essentiay divides the eectrons into different casses. Furthermore, the vaidity of mean fied theory rests on the assumption that the gap for creating new quasipartices is arge compared to their interaction. Direct comparison of the CF hierarchy predictions with numerica resuts for sma systems dispays

2 a number of cases in which this assumption fais. The state with fractiona fiing ν 0 has an average of ν0 fux quanta per eectron. Foowing Jain, we attach to each eectron an even number, 2p 0, of fux quanta oriented opposite to the appied magnetic fied. This gives an effective CF fiing factor ν0 given by (ν0) = ν0 2p 0. If ν0 is equa to an integer n, an integra number of CF eves (or shes) is fied, and the Jain sequence ν 0 = n ( + 2p 0 n ) is obtained. Negative ν0 indicates that the effective magnetic fied B seen by a CF is oriented opposite to the appied fied B. If ν0 is not an integer it can be written as ν0 = n +ν, where ν represents the fractiona fiing of the partiay fied CF she. We define partices in the partiay fied CF she as quasipartices of the incompressibe CF state with fiing ν0 = n [7]. If excitations between Landau eves are negigibe (and cosed shes give nothing but constant shift in energy) the owest energy sector is determined by the energy states of the partiay fied she [8,9]. The same prediction of the incompressibe states as for the anaogous partiay fied eectron she are found when the CF transformation is appied to quasipartices and (ν) = ν 2p. If ν is sti not an integer we can repeat the process which eads us to the sequence of the foowing equations: ν = 2p + (n + + ν + ). () From Eq. (), the origina fractiona eectron fiing ν 0, can be represented in a form of a continued fraction. If n = for every vaue of, this fraction can be put in the form equivaent to Hadane s [] (the particehoe symmetry can be additionay incuded at every step). The hierarchica incompressibe states are predicted when ν + = 0 at any step. If ν = 0, the principa Jain sequence is obtained. It is interesting to see how the Jain principa states arise in the Hadane picture (Eq. () with n + = ). Let us write the Hadane sequence in the foowing way ν = 2p + ( + ν + ). (2) Hence, even if a p = 0, the hierarchica fraction can be generated. After repeating procedure (2) with a p = 0 (except p 0 ) ti ν n+ = 0 (then ν n =, ν n = 2,..., and ν = n) we have for ν 0 : 2p = n 2p 0 n+. (3) Hence, the Jain fraction can be obtained within the sequence (2) and the Hadane hierarchy theory coincides with Jain s for the fraction (3) (the equivaence of different hierarchy schemes was considered in [0 2]). Setting n = in the sequence () does not omit any fraction; 2

3 simpy the higher vaues of n are obtained in the more compicated way. Let us consider a spherica system containing n QE quasieectrons at the th hierarchica eve. If those partices occupy one fied Landau she and there are extra partices in the partiay fied second Landau eve one finds for the owest anguar momentum she 2S + = n QE n QE + [,3]. A condensed state of these quasipartices is obtained when they fi an integra number of shes at the next step of the hierarchy (n QE +2 = 0); then we have additionay 2S + = (2p + + )(n QE + ). Combining these two reations we get: n QE = (2p + + 2)(n QE + ) (4) in agreement with Hadane [] (if quasihoes are produced then: n QE = 2p + (n QH + )). Thus, we identify Hadane even numbers as 2p + +2 for quasieectrons (2p + for quasihoes), the odd number is given by 2p 0 +. The construction of the Hadane hierarchy for quasieectrons without appying the CF transformation to them, i. e. p + = 0 (redefinition of the number of quasieectrons), eads to the Jain principa fraction (3), and the picture becomes identica to the origina Jain construction. We woud ike to note that our resut is not based on identifying the quasipartices as Bosons, rather our (equivaent to Hadane resuts) were obtained treating quasipartices as Fermions. Let s ook at a simpe exampe for N = 8 eectrons on a sphere. If the degeneracy of the owest eectron she is 2S 0 + = 9, then we can attach two fux quanta (oriented opposite to B) to each eectron to obtain 2S0 = 2S 0 2(N ) = 4. For a finite system we substract 2p 0 (N ) fux quanta to obtain the mean vaue of the fux seen be one CF. The owest CF she accomodate 2S0 + = 5 partices, the remaining three become quasieectrons in the next she. These CF excitations have anguar momentum QE = 3. The aowed vaues of the tota anguar momentum L = are obtained by addition of the anguar momenta of three Fermions in the QE = 3 she. In numerica cacuations these 3QE states are seen as the owest energy sector of the eight eectron spectrum for 2S 0 + = 9 (cf. Fig. A). The energy states can be obtained within the Fermi iquid she mode. We can ignore partices in the fied she and treat ony quasipartices introducing two-body Fermi iquid quasipartice interaction [7,9]. When we attach 2 fux quanta to each quasipartice we find new CFs with a new vaue 2SQE = 2S QE 2(N QE ) = 2. Thus the effective she for these quasieectrons can accomodate 2SQE + = 3 partices, exacty the number we have. Within the CF hierarchy, the fiing fraction is determined by 2p 0 = 2, n =, and ν (for quasieectrons) is given by 2p = 2, n 2 =, and ν 2 = 0. From Eq. () we find ν = 3 and ν0 = /4. This picture can be appied to any system consisting of 3

4 a finite number of eectrons on a spherica surface with a magnetic monopoe of strenght 2S at its center. For exampe, for the N = 6 and N = 8 eectron systems the hierarchy of condensed states for vaues of ν faing between and 2/7 is presented in Tabe I and Tabe II. The states in these tabes that are marked with stars are not states in the principa Jain sequence. They are hierarchica states which can be obtained by foowing Hadane s origina suggestion and treating the quasipartice excitations in the same way as the origina eectrons in the partiay fied eectron she were treated. In the Jain- Godman [5] terminoogy, these states are obtained with appication of the operator L. Of these states ony 6/7 and 6/9 states for N = 6 and ν = /7 and ν = 9/3 states for N = 8 have numericay observed the L = 0 ground state (but the gaps are very sma). It is worth noting that that at fiings of the form ν 0 = n 0 +ν, where n 0 is an integer and ν is an incompressibe fractiona fiing, incompressibe states shoud occur. The main advantage of the composite fermion theory is that it not ony predicts the ground states for the specific vaues of the magnetic fied (S) but it aso predicts the owest energy states for every vaue of S [9]. Furthermore, when the CF transformation and the MF approximation are appied to N Fermions of anguar momentum S, the resuting energy spectra are the same whether the Fermions are eectrons, CF quasieectrons or CF quasihoes. Figure gives the energy spectra of three quasieectrons in the anguar momentum shes of S QP = 3.0; 3.5; 4.0 (indicated as A, B, C in the figure). Figure 2 presents the cases of four quasieectrons for S QP = 3.5; 4.0; 4.5. Figures 3 and 4 are anaogous resuts for three and four quasihoe states. The crosses in these figures are the resuts of exact numerica diagonaization within the owest she (ony the owest energy sector is potted), the open circes are Fermi iquid theory resuts [9]. The CF mean fied approximation makes the foowing predictions for the owest energy states: For three Fermions of anguar momentum S = 3, an L = 0 ground state; for S = 3.5 a singe quasipartice in the L =.5 state; for S = 4.0 two quasipartices each with = 2 shoud give degenerate states L = 3. For the four Fermion systems, the S = 3.5 gives two quasipartices each with =.5 resuting in degenerate states L = 0 2; S = 4 gives a singe quasipartice with L = 2; and S = 4.5 gives an L = 0 ground state. We observe that whie CF predictions hod for quasihoes (with sma overap of the L = 0 2QP state with the higher energy states in Fig. 4A) they fai to describe ow ying quasieectron states (with one exception of L = 0 ground state in Fig. 2C). A simpe interpretation of the many-quasieectron spectra comes from noting that QE interaction VQE QE S (J) osciates with J (pair anguar momentum) exacty out of phase with the QH interaction [7] (for the same anguar momentum she S). Thus, to some extent, 4

5 the shifts in the QE energies due to QE QE interactions are opposite to those of QH s. We observe, in fact, that states which are highest energy states for quasieectrons are the owest energy states for quasihoes. The /3 quasihoe state, which is the 2/7 Jain state, is ceary observed (Fig. 3A, Fig. 4C). Hence, we can not expect the same for the /3 state of quasieectrons (4/ state) and the resuts for 3QE (Fig. A) and 4QE (Fig. 2C) spectra ceary show that, though there is an L = 0 ground state for N = 2. The quaitative simiarity of 3QE and 4QE spectra (Fig. and Fig. 2) to reversed 3QH and 4QH spectra (Fig. 3 and Fig. 4) for other vaues of S QE = S QH confirms our concusion. The authors woud ike to thank Geoff Canright for pointing out a reference and discussion. This work was supported in part by Oak Ridge Nationa Laboratory, managed by Lockheed Martin Energy Research Corp. for the US Department of Energy under contract No. DE-AC05-96OR K.S.Y. acknowedges support by the BSRI program of the Ministry of Education, Korea. P.S. acknowedges support by Committee for Scientific Research, Poand, grant PB 674/P03/96/0. [] F. D. M. Hadane, Phys. Rev. Lett. 5, 605 (983) [2] The Quantum Ha Effect, edited by R. E. Prange, S. M. Girvin, Springer-Verag New York 987 [3] R. B. Laughin, Phys. Rev. Lett. 50, 395 (983) [4] J. K. Jain, Phys. Rev. Lett. 63, 99 (989) [5] J. K. Jain and V. J. Godman, Phys. Rev. B 45, 255 (992) [6] A. Lopez and E. Fradkin, Phys. Rev. B 44, 5246 (99) [7] S. N. Yi, X. M. Chen, and J. J. Quinn, Phys. Rev. B 53, 9599 (996) [8] A. de-shait and I. Tami, Nucear She Theory, Academic Press, New York and London 963 [9] P. Sitko, S. N. Yi, K. S. Yi, and J. J. Quinn, Phys. Rev. Lett. 76, 3396 (996). [0] N. Read, Phys. Rev. Lett. 65, 502 (990) [] M. Greiter, Phys. Lett. B 336, 48 (994) [2] J. N. Ginocchio, W. C. Haxton, Phys. Rev. Lett. 77, 568 (996) [3] X. M. Chen and J. J. Quinn, Soid State Commun. 92, 865 (994) 5

6 TABLE I. N = 6 2S ν 6/7 2/3 2/5 6/7 /3 6/9 2/7 TABLE II. N = 8 2S ν 8/9 4/5 9/3 2/3 /7 /27 2/5 9/23 4/ 8/23 /3 8/25 4/3 9/3 2/7 FIG.. The spectra of three quasieectron systems for N = 8, 9, 0. The quasieectron interaction energy is given in units of e 2 /R, where R is the radius of the sphere. The N = 8 case (Fig. A) is predicted to be the 4/ state in the hierarchy theory. Circes represent Fermi iquid resuts and crosses are exact numerica energies. FIG. 2. The Fermi iquid spectra of four quasieectron systems for N = 0,, 2. The N = 2 case (Fig. 2C) corresponds to the 4/ hierarchica state. The resuts are obtained using interaction parameters found for systems of N = 8, 9, 0, respectivey. The agreement with the numerica resuts is expected to be simiar as that for 4QH spectra presented in Fig. 4. FIG. 3. The spectra of 3QH for S QH = 3.0; 3.5; 4.0 (N = 4, 5, 6). The Fig. 3A (S QH = 3.0) shows the 2/7 Jain state. FIG. 4. The spectra of 4QH for S QH = 3.5; 4.0; 4.5 (N = 4, 5, 6). The interaction parameters were obtained for systems of N = 6, 7, 8, respectivey. In Fig. 4C (S QH = 4.5) the spectrum of the 2/7 state is presented. The crosses not reated to circes come from higher energy states. 6

7 A B C Fig.

8 A B C Fig. 2

9 A B C Fig. 3

10 A B C Fig. 4