Exclusion from maintained schools, academies and pupil referral units in England

Transcription

1 Exclusion from maintained schools, academies and pupil referral units in England Statutory guidance for those with legal responsibilities in relation to exclusion January 2015

2 Contents Summary 3 About this guidance 3 Expiry or review date 3 What legislation does this guidance refer to? 3 Who is this guidance for? 4 Main points 4 1. The headteacher s power to exclude 6 2. The headteacher s duty to inform parties about an exclusion Informing parents about an exclusion Informing the governing body and local authority about an exclusion The governing body s and local authority s duties to arrange education for excluded pupils The governing body s duty to consider an exclusion The requirements on a governing body to consider an exclusion The process for considering the reinstatement of an excluded pupil Notifying people of the governing body s decision The headteacher s duty to remove a permanently excluded pupil s name from the school register The local authority s / academy trust s duty to arrange an independent review panel Arranging a date and venue Appointing panel members Appointing a clerk and the clerk s role Ensuring that panel members and clerks are trained Appointing an SEN expert The duties of independent review panel members, the clerk and the SEN expert in the conduct of an independent review panel The governing body s duty to reconsider an exclusion decision following a review The local authority s role in overseeing the transfer of funding following a permanent exclusion Statutory guidance to headteachers, governing bodies, independent review panel members and clerks on police involvement and parallel criminal proceedings 45 2

3 Summary About this guidance This document from the Department for Education provides a guide to the legislation governing the exclusion of pupils from maintained schools, pupil referral units, academy schools 1 and alternative provision academies 2 in England. It also provides statutory guidance. This means that recipients must have regard to this guidance when carrying out duties relating to the exclusion of pupils from school. Except where specifically stated, the legislation and statutory guidance apply in relation to all pupils attending a school 3, including those below or above compulsory school age, such as those attending nursery classes or sixth forms. Exclusion legislation places obligations in relation to the relevant person a parent or the pupil, where aged 18 or over. The definition of a parent for the purposes of the Education Act is broadly drawn. In addition to the child's birth parents, references to parents in this guidance include any person who has parental responsibility (which includes the local authority where it has a care order in respect of the child) and any person (for example, a foster carer) with whom the child lives. This guidance refers to parents throughout and where practicable it is expected that all those with parental responsibility should be engaged with the exclusions process. This guidance replaces the document of the same name published in September 2012 for schools in England and applies to exclusions that occur after 5 January Expiry or review date This guidance will next be reviewed in July What legislation does this guidance refer to? Section 51A of the Education Act 2002, as inserted by the Education Act 2011 The School Discipline (Pupil Exclusions and Reviews) (England) Regulations 2012 Sections 100 to 108 of the Education and Inspections Act Including free schools, studio schools and university technology colleges where these are constituted as an academy school under the Academies Act Including alternative provision free schools where these are constituted as an AP academy under the Academies Act School is used in this document to describe any school to which the guidance applies. Where the term academy is used it refers to any category of academy to which the guidance applies. 3

4 The Education (Provision of Full-Time Education for Excluded Pupils) (England) Regulations Who is this guidance for? This guidance is for: School leaders 5 and governing bodies 6 in maintained schools, pupil referral units (PRUs) academies and free schools; local authorities; academy trusts; independent review panel members and clerks; SEN experts appointed to assist independent review panels. This guidance does not apply to: independent schools (other than academy schools or AP academies), city technology colleges or city colleges for the technology of the arts (unless they have become academy schools), sixth form colleges or academies, which will have their own exclusion procedures. Local authorities are required to arrange educational provision for excluded pupils of compulsory school age from these institutions if they would not otherwise receive such education. Main points The overall legislation governing the exclusion process remains unchanged. Regulations have been amended to clarify that governing bodies duty to arrange education from the sixth day of a fixed period exclusion would be triggered by consecutive fixed period exclusions totalling more than five days. Statutory guidance has been updated in a small number of areas, in particular to provide greater confidence to headteachers on their use of exclusion and greater clarity to independent review panels and governing bodies on their consideration of exclusion decisions. Good discipline in schools is essential to ensure that all pupils can benefit from the opportunities provided by education. The government supports the decisions of headteachers and they should be confident in using exclusion where they consider it to be a lawful, reasonable and fair action. 4 As amended by the by the Education (Provision of Full-Time Education for Excluded Pupils) (England) (Amendment) Regulations Headteacher in this document also refers to the teacher in charge at a PRU and principals of academies. 6 Governing body in this document also refers to PRU management committees. In the case of academies, governing body should be read to the proprietor ( the academy trust ). 4

5 In considering whether to exclude a pupil, headteachers should weigh up the seriousness, or persistence, of the pupil s behaviour, together with the impact of not excluding the pupil on the school as a whole and the integrity of its behaviour policy. Whilst every effort should be made to identify pupils at risk of exclusion, and to put in place strategies to address problematic behaviour, adopting a blanket approach of never excluding pupils may undermine the school s ability to maintain discipline. Where a school has concerns about a pupil s behaviour it should try to identify whether there are any causal factors and intervene early in order to reduce the need for a subsequent exclusion. In this situation schools should consider requesting a multi-agency assessment that goes beyond the pupil s educational needs. They should also consider whether alternative provision would help improve the pupil s behaviour. Schools must not discriminate against pupils on the basis of protected characteristics, such as gender, sexual orientation, disability or race. All pupils must be treated fairly and lawfully. All children have a right to an education. Schools should take reasonable steps to set and mark work for pupils during the first five school days of an exclusion, and alternative provision must be arranged from the sixth day. There are benefits in arranging alternative provision to begin as soon as possible after an exclusion. Schools should have a strategy for reintegrating pupils that return to school following a fixed period exclusion, and for managing their future behaviour. Where parents (or the excluded pupil, if aged 18 or over) dispute the decision not to reinstate a permanently excluded pupil, they can ask for it to be reviewed by an independent review panel. Where there is an allegation of discrimination (under the Equality Act 2010) in relation to a fixed-period or permanent exclusion, parents can also make a claim to the First-tier Tribunal (for disability discrimination) or a County Court (for other forms of discrimination). Excluded pupils should be enabled and encouraged to participate at all stages of the exclusion process, taking into account their age and understanding. 5

6 1. The headteacher s power to exclude A guide to the law 7 1. The headteacher 8 of a school can exclude a pupil on disciplinary grounds 9. The behaviour of pupils outside school may be relevant and can be considered as grounds for an exclusion decision. 2. A pupil may be excluded for one or more fixed periods (up to a maximum of 45 school days in a single academic year 10 ), or permanently. In exceptional cases, usually where further evidence has come to light, a fixed period exclusion may, in effect, be extended by issuing a further fixed period exclusion or a subsequent permanent exclusion may be issued 11. It would, however, be unlawful to impose a fixed period exclusion for an indefinite period of time. 3. A fixed period exclusion does not have to be for a continuous period; for example, where pupils attend more than one school then the exclusion could relate only to the days on which they attend the school at which an incident occurred. A fixed period exclusion can also involve a part of the school day; for example, if pupils behaviour at lunchtime is disruptive, they may be excluded from the school premises for the duration of the lunchtime period. The legal requirements relating to exclusion, such as the headteacher s duty to notify parents, apply in all cases. Lunchtime exclusions are considered as half a school day for statistical purposes and also in determining whether a governing body meeting is triggered. 4. Any decision of a school, including exclusion, must be made in line with the principles of administrative law, i.e. the decision must be: lawful (with respect to the legislation relating directly to exclusions and a school s wider legal duties, including under the European Convention on Human Rights and the Equality Act 2010); rational; reasonable; fair and proportionate. 5. Headteachers must take account of their legal duty of care to a pupil when taking a decision to send a pupil home following an exclusion. 7 Section 51A Education Act 2002 and the School Discipline (Pupil Exclusions and Reviews) (England) Regulations Headteacher includes acting headteacher by virtue of section 579(1) of the Education Act The headteacher may withdraw an exclusion that has not been reviewed by the governing body. 10 This total includes exclusions from previous schools covered by the exclusion legislation. 11 In these circumstances the legal requirements relating to exclusion still apply, including duties to notify parties about the exclusion and the parents right to make representations about the exclusion. 6

7 6. When establishing the facts in relation to an exclusion the headteacher must apply the civil standard of proof and not the criminal standard of beyond reasonable doubt. This means that if something is more likely than not to have occurred ( on the balance of probabilities ) then the standard is met. 7. Under the Equality Act 2010 ( the Equality Act ), schools must not discriminate against, harass or victimise pupils because of their: gender, race, disability, religion or belief, or sexual orientation; because of a pregnancy / maternity; or because of a gender reassignment. For disabled children, this includes a duty to make reasonable adjustments to policies and practices. 8. The public sector equality duty means that, in carrying out their functions, schools must also have due regard to the need to: eliminate discrimination, harassment, victimisation and other conduct that is prohibited by the Equality Act; advance equality of opportunity between people who share a protected characteristic and people who do not; and foster good relations between people who share a protected characteristic and people who do not; in particular by having due regard to the need to tackle prejudice and promote understanding. 9. These duties must be taken into account when deciding whether to exclude a pupil. Schools must also ensure that their policies and practices do not indirectly discriminate against pupils by unfairly placing them at a greater risk of exclusion than others. Provisions within the Equality Act allow schools to take action to deal with particular disadvantages that may affect a specific group, where this can be shown to be a reasonable and proportionate way of dealing with such issues Headteachers and governing bodies must take account of their statutory duties in relation to special educational needs (SEN) when administering the exclusion process. This includes having regard to the SEN Code of Practice. 11. It is unlawful to exclude a pupil for a non-disciplinary reason. For example, it would be unlawful to exclude a pupil simply because he or she has additional needs or a disability that the school considers it is unable to meet, or for a reason such as: academic attainment / ability; the action of a pupil s parents; or the failure of a pupil to meet specific conditions before reinstatement, such as attend a reintegration meeting. Repeatedly disobeying a teacher s instructions to do school work could provide grounds for an exclusion decision. 12 Non-statutory advice from the Department for Education has been issued to help schools understand how the Equality Act affects them and how to fulfil their duties under the Act ( 7

8 12. Exclusion legislation does not provide for informal or unofficial exclusions, such as sending pupils home to cool off. Pupils of compulsory school age are entitled to a fulltime education. Removing a pupil from the school without a legal basis is unlawful, regardless of whether it occurs with the agreement of parents or carers. Any exclusion of a pupil, even for short periods of time, must be formally recorded. Formally arranged part-time timetables may be necessary as a temporary measure in exceptional circumstances to meet pupils needs but must not be used as a disciplinary sanction Schools have powers to direct pupils off-site for education to improve their behaviour 14. A pupil can also transfer to another school as part of a managed move where this occurs with the consent of the parties involved, including the parents. The threat of exclusion must never be used to influence parents to remove their child from the school. Statutory guidance on the decision to exclude 14. Headteachers should be confident in using exclusion where they deem it to be a lawful, reasonable and fair sanction. The use of exclusion should reflect the importance of good behaviour for the education and welfare of all pupils. In considering whether to exclude a pupil, headteachers should weigh up the seriousness, or persistence, of the pupil s behaviour, together with the impact of not excluding the pupil on the school as a whole and the integrity of its behaviour policy. Whilst every effort should be made to identify pupils at risk of exclusion, and to put in place strategies to address problematic behaviour, adopting a blanket approach of never excluding pupils may undermine the school s ability to maintain discipline. 15. It is for the headteacher to decide whether a child s behaviour warrants permanent exclusion, though this is a serious decision and should be reserved for: a serious breach, or persistent breaches, of the school's behaviour policy; or where a pupil s behaviour means allowing the pupil to remain in school would be detrimental to the education or welfare of the pupil or others in the school. 16. Allowing pupils an opportunity to present their case before taking the decision to exclude will help ensure that the decision is fair, although this may not always be 13 All pupils of compulsory school age are entitled to a full-time education, unless this would not be in their best interests because of health needs. Departmental advice on attendance ( is that, in very exceptional circumstances, there may be a need for a temporary part-time timetable to meet a pupil s individual needs but this must not be treated as a long-term solution. 14 Maintained schools power is provided by Section 29A of the Education Act Statutory guidance relating to this power is provided in guidance on alternative provision ( Academies can also place a pupil in another educational setting under general powers within their Articles of Association. 8

9 practicable. Headteachers should also take account of any contributing factors that are identified after an incident of poor behaviour has occurred; for example, where it comes to light that a pupil has suffered bereavement, has mental health issues or has been subject to bullying or other emotional stress. 17. Early intervention to address underlying causes of disruptive behaviour should include an assessment of whether appropriate provision is in place to support any SEN or disability that a pupil may have. Headteachers should also consider the use of a multiagency assessment for pupils who demonstrate persistent disruptive behaviour. Such assessments may pick up unidentified special educational needs but the scope of the assessment could go further, for example, by seeking to identify mental health or family problems. 18. Where a pupil has received multiple exclusions or is approaching the legal limit of 45 school days of fixed period exclusion in an academic year, headteachers should consider whether exclusion is providing an effective sanction. Statutory guidance on the exclusion of pupils from groups with disproportionately high rates of exclusion 19. The exclusion rates for certain groups of pupils are consistently higher than average. This includes: pupils with SEN, pupils eligible for Free School Meals, looked after children 15 and pupils from certain ethnic groups. The ethnic groups with the highest rates of exclusion are: Gypsy / Roma, Travellers of Irish Heritage, and Caribbean pupils. 20. In addition to the approaches on early intervention set out above, headteachers should consider what extra support might be needed to identify and address the needs of pupils from these groups in order to reduce their risk of exclusion. For example, schools might draw on the support of the local authority, or other professionals, to help build trust when engaging with families from Gypsy/ Roma or Traveller communities. Statutory guidance to headteachers on the exclusion of pupils with Education, Health and Care Plans (EHC plans) and looked after children 21. As well as having disproportionately high rates of exclusion, there are certain groups of pupils with additional needs who are particularly vulnerable to the impacts of exclusion. This includes pupils with Education, Health and Care Plans (EHC plans) 16 and 15 As defined in section 22 of the Children Act References to pupils with EHC plans include pupils with statements of SEN whilst they remain. 9

10 looked after children. Headteachers should, as far as possible, avoid permanently excluding any pupil with an EHC plan or a looked after child. 22. Schools should engage proactively with parents in supporting the behaviour of pupils with additional needs. In relation to looked after children, schools should cooperate proactively with foster carers or children s home workers, the local authority that looks after the child and its Virtual School Head. 23. Where a school has concerns about the behaviour or risk of exclusion of a child with additional needs, including a pupil with an EHC plan or a looked after child, it should, in partnership with others (including the local authority as necessary), consider what additional support or alternative placement may be required. This should involve assessing the suitability of provision for a pupil s SEN. Where a pupil has an EHC plan, schools should consider requesting an early annual review or interim / emergency review. 10

11 2. The headteacher s duty to inform parties about an exclusion 2.1 Informing parents about an exclusion A guide to the law Whenever headteachers exclude a pupil they must, without delay, notify parents of the period of the exclusion and the reasons for it. 25. They must also, without delay, provide parents with the following information in writing: the reasons for the exclusion; the period of a fixed period exclusion or, for a permanent exclusion, the fact that it is permanent; the parents right to make representations about the exclusion to the governing body (in line with the requirements set out in Section 4.1) and how the pupil may be involved in this; how any representations should be made; and where there is a legal requirement for the governing body to consider the exclusion, that parents have a right to attend a meeting, be represented at this meeting (at their own expense) and to bring a friend. 26. Written notification of the information in paragraph 25 can be provided by: delivering it directly to the parents; leaving it at their last known address; or by posting it to this address. 27. Where an excluded pupil is of compulsory school age the headteacher must also notify the pupil s parents of the days on which they must ensure that the pupil is not present in a public place at any time during school hours. These days would be the first five school days of an exclusion (or until the start date of any alternative provision where this is earlier). Parents who fail to comply with this duty without reasonable justification commit an offence and may be given a fixed penalty notice or prosecuted 18. The headteacher must notify the parents of the days on which their duty applies without delay and, at the latest, by the end of the afternoon session. 17 Section 51A Education Act 2002 and the School Discipline (Pupil Exclusions and Reviews) (England) Regulations Sections 103 to 105 Education and Inspections Act 2006 and the Education (Provision of Full-Time Education for Excluded Pupils) (England) Regulations

12 28. If alternative provision is being arranged then the following information must be included with this notice where it can reasonably be found out within the timescale: the start date for any full-time educational provision that has been arranged for the pupil during the exclusion; the start and finish times of any such provision, including the times for morning and afternoon sessions where relevant; the address at which the provision will take place; and any information required by the pupil to identify the person that he / she should report to on the first day. 29. Where this information on alternative provision is not reasonably ascertainable by the end of the afternoon session it may be provided in a subsequent notice, but it must be provided without delay and no later than 48 hours before the provision is due to start. The only exception to this is where alternative provision is to be provided before the sixth day of an exclusion, in which case the information can be provided with less than 48 hours notice with parents consent. 30. The information in paragraphs 28 and 29 must be provided in writing but can be given to parents by any effective method (paragraph 33 provides guidance on this issue). It may, but does not have to, be combined with the information in paragraph 28, where this complies with the legal time limits. 31. The failure of a headteacher to give notice of any required information by the required time does not relieve the head of the duty to serve the notice. A notice is not made invalid solely because it has not been given by the required time. Statutory guidance to headteachers on informing parents about an exclusion 32. When notifying parents about an exclusion, the headteacher should set out what arrangements have been made to enable the pupil to continue his / her education prior to the start of any alternative provision or the pupil s return to school, in line with the legal requirements and guidance in section For notifications under paragraphs 27 and 28, effective methods for providing the information may include: or text message; giving the notice directly to the parents; or sending the information home with the excluded pupil. Where information is sent home with a pupil, headteachers should consider sending a duplicate copy by an alternative method or confirming that the information has been received. 34. When notifying parents about an exclusion headteachers should draw attention to relevant sources of free and impartial information. Schools should ensure that these sources of information are checked regularly and updated as required. This information should include: 12

13 a link to this statutory guidance on exclusions ( a link to the Coram Children s Legal Centre ( ; and where considered relevant by the headteacher, links to other information, advice and support services, such as Traveller Education Services or the local parent partnership ( 35. Headteachers should ensure that information provided to parents is clear and easily understood. Where the parents first language is not English, consideration should be given, where practicable, to translating the letter or taking additional steps to ensure that the details of the exclusion and parents right to make representations to the governing body have been understood. 2.2 Informing the governing body and local authority about an exclusion A guide to the law The headteacher must, without delay, notify the governing body and the local authority of: a permanent exclusion (including where a fixed period exclusion is followed by a decision to permanently exclude the pupil); exclusions which would result in the pupil being excluded for more than five school days (or more than ten lunchtimes) in a term 20 ; and exclusions which would result in the pupil missing a public examination or national curriculum test. 37. For a permanent exclusion, if the pupil lives outside the local authority in which the school is located, the headteacher must also advise the pupil s home authority of the exclusion without delay. 38. For all other exclusions the headteacher must notify the local authority and governing body once a term. 19 Section 51A Education Act 2002 and the School Discipline (Pupil Exclusions and Reviews) (England) Regulations Where a school s academic year consists of three terms or fewer, term in this guidance means one of those terms. Where a school s academic year consists of more than three terms, then a reference to term means the period falling between: 31 December to Easter Monday; Easter Monday to 31 July; or 31 July to 31 December. 13

14 39. Notifications must include the reasons for the exclusion and the duration of any fixed period exclusion. 40. In addition, within 14 days of a request, governing bodies must provide to the Secretary of State and (in the case of maintained schools and PRUs) the local authority information about any exclusions within the last 12 months As set out in the Education (Information About Individual Pupils) (England) Regulations

15 3. The governing body s and local authority s duties to arrange education for excluded pupils A guide to the law For a fixed period exclusion of more than five school days, the governing body (or local authority in relation to a pupil excluded from a pupil referral unit) must arrange suitable full- time education for any pupil of compulsory school age. This provision must begin no later than the sixth school day of the exclusion. Where a child receives consecutive fixed period exclusions, these are regarded as a cumulative period of absence for the purposes of this duty. This means that if a child has more than five consecutive days of exclusion, then education must be arranged for the sixth school day of exclusion regardless of whether this is as a result of more than one fixed period exclusion For permanent exclusions, the local authority must arrange suitable full-time education for the pupil to begin no later than the sixth day of the exclusion. This will be the pupil's home authority in cases where the school is maintained by (or located within) a different local authority. 43. In addition, where a pupil has an Education, Health and Care Plan (EHC plan), the local authority must ensure that an appropriate full-time 24 placement is identified in consultation with the parents, who retain their rights to express a preference for a school that they wish their child to attend or make representations for a placement in any other school Local authorities must have regard to the relevant statutory guidance when arranging the education of looked after children Provision does not have to be arranged by either the school or local authority for pupils who are in the final year of compulsory education and do not have any further public examinations to sit. 22 Section 100 and 101 of the Education and Inspections Act 2006, section 19 of the Education Act 1996 and the Education (Provision of Full-Time Education for Excluded Pupils) (England) Regulations This requirement is clarified by the Education (Provision of Full-Time Education for Excluded Pupils) (England) (Amendment) Regulations The placement should be full-time unless the pupil s EHC plan indicates that the maximum number of hours education per week should be less. 25 Schedule 27 of the Education Act Latest guidance provided at 15

16 Statutory guidance on the education of pupils prior to the sixth day of an exclusion 46. It is important for schools to help minimise the disruption that exclusion can cause to an excluded pupil s education. Whilst the statutory duty on governing bodies or local authorities is to provide full-time education from the sixth day of an exclusion, there is an obvious benefit in starting this provision as soon as possible. In particular, in the case of a looked after child, schools and local authorities should work together to arrange alternative provision from the first day following the exclusion. 47. Where it is not possible, or appropriate, to arrange alternative provision during the first five school days of an exclusion, schools should take reasonable steps to set and mark work for pupils. Work that is provided should be accessible and achievable by pupils outside school. 16

17 4. The governing body s duty to consider an exclusion 4.1 The requirements on a governing body to consider an exclusion A guide to the law The governing body has a duty to consider parents representations about an exclusion. The requirements on a governing body to consider an exclusion depend upon a number of factors (a diagram illustrating these requirements is provided in Section 11). 49. The governing body of a maintained school may delegate their functions with respect to the consideration of an exclusion decision to a designated committee consisting of at least three governors Within 15 school days of receiving notice of the exclusion, the governing body must consider whether an excluded pupil should be reinstated in the case of: all permanent exclusions; all fixed period exclusions of pupils who have been excluded for more than 15 school days in the term 29, or who will have been as a result of the exclusion; and all fixed period exclusions that would result in a pupil missing a public examination or national curriculum test. 51. Where an exclusion would result in a pupil missing a public examination or national curriculum test there is a further requirement for the governing body, so far as is reasonably practicable, to consider the exclusion before the date of the examination or test. If this is not practicable, the chair of governors may consider the exclusion independently and decide whether or not to reinstate the pupil 30. In such cases parents still have the right to make representations to the governing body and must be made aware of this right. 27 Section 51A Education Act 2002 and the School Discipline (Pupil Exclusions and Reviews) (England) Regulations 2012, as well as the School Governance (Roles, Procedures and Allowances) (England) Regulations Academies must have robust systems of governance in place to ensure that the process for considering the exclusion decision is lawful, reasonable and a fair procedure is followed. 29 Where a school s academic year consists of three terms or fewer, term in this guidance means one of those terms. Where a school s academic year consists of more than three terms, then a reference to term means the period falling between: 31 December to Easter Monday; Easter Monday to 31 July; or 31 July to 31 December. 30 Where the chair is unable to make this consideration then the vice-chair may do so instead. 17

18 52. For all other fixed period exclusions where a pupil would be excluded for more than five school days in the term and their parents have made representations, the governing body must consider within 50 school days of receiving notice of the exclusion whether the excluded pupil should be reinstated. In the absence of any representations from the excluded child s parents, the governing body is not required to meet and cannot direct the reinstatement of the pupil. 53. Where a fixed period exclusion would not bring a pupil's total number of days of exclusion to more than five in the term, the governing body must consider any representations made by parents, but it cannot direct reinstatement and is not required to meet the parents. Statutory guidance to governing bodies on exclusions that would result in a pupil missing a public examination or national curriculum test 54. Whilst there is no legal imperative to allow an excluded pupil to return to school in order to take a public examination or test, the governing body should consider whether it would be appropriate to exercise discretion and allow the excluded pupil back on school premises for this purpose. 4.2 The process for considering the reinstatement of an excluded pupil A guide to the law Where the governing body is legally required to consider the reinstatement of a pupil the following parties must be invited to a meeting of the governing body and allowed to make representations: parents (and, where requested, a representative or friend); the headteacher; and a representative of the local authority (in the case of a maintained school or PRU) Section 51A Education Act 2002 and the School Discipline (Pupil Exclusions and Reviews) (England) Regulations Parents may invite a representative of the local authority to attend a meeting of an academy s governing body as an observer; that representative may only make representations with the governing body s consent. 18

19 56. The governing body must take reasonable steps to arrange the meeting for a date and time that is convenient to all parties, but in compliance with the relevant statutory time limits set out above. However, its decision will not be invalid simply on the grounds that it was not made within these time limits. 57. When arranging the meeting the governing body must also have regard to its duty to make reasonable adjustments for people who use the school and consider what reasonable adjustments should be made to support the attendance and contribution of parties at the meeting (for example where a parent or pupil has a disability in relation to mobility or communication that impacts upon his / her ability to attend the meeting or to make representations). 58. In deciding whether to reinstate the pupil, the governing body must consider not only the representations made but also the interests and circumstances of the excluded pupil, including the circumstances in which the pupil was excluded. It must also have regard to the interests of other pupils and people working at the school. 59. When establishing the facts in relation to an exclusion the governing body must apply the civil standard of proof and not the criminal standard of beyond reasonable doubt. This means that if something is more likely than not to have occurred ( on the balance of probabilities ) then the standard is met. In the light of its consideration, the governing body can either: uphold an exclusion; or direct reinstatement of the pupil immediately or on a particular date. 60. Where reinstatement is not practicable because, for example, the pupil has already returned to school following the expiry of a fixed period exclusion or the parents make clear they do not want their child reinstated, the governing body must, in any event, consider whether the headteacher's decision to exclude the child was justified based on the evidence. Statutory guidance to governing bodies in preparing for the consideration of an exclusion decision 61. The governing body s consideration should only be delayed where there are exceptional circumstances that prevent it from considering the exclusion within the statutory time limits. In these circumstances, the consideration should take place as soon as is practicable. 62. When arranging a meeting to consider the reinstatement of the excluded pupil, the governing body should: not discuss the exclusion with any party outside the meeting; 19

20 ask for any written evidence in advance of the meeting (including witness statements and other relevant information held by the school, such as those relating to a pupil s SEN); where possible, circulate any written evidence and information, including a list of those who will be present, to all parties at least five school days in advance of the meeting; allow parents and pupils to be accompanied by a friend or representative (where a pupil under 18 is to be invited as a witness, the governing body should first seek parental consent and invite the parents to accompany their child to the meeting); identify the steps it will take to enable and encourage the excluded pupil to attend the meeting and speak on his / her own behalf (such as providing accessible information or allowing them to bring a friend), taking into account the pupil s age and understanding 33 ; or how the excluded pupil may feed in his / her views by other means if attending the exclusion meeting is not possible. Statutory guidance to governing bodies on the consideration of an exclusion decision 63. The governing body should identify the steps it will take to ensure all parties will be supported to participate in its consideration and have their views properly heard. This is particularly important where pupils under 18 are speaking about their own exclusion or giving evidence to the governing body. 64. The governing body should ensure that clear minutes are taken of the meeting as a record of the evidence that was considered by governing body. These minutes should be made available to all parties on request. 65. The governing body should ask all parties to withdraw before making a decision. Where present, a clerk may stay to help the governing body by reference to his / her notes of the meeting and assist with the drafting of the decision letter. 66. In reaching a decision on whether or not to reinstate a pupil, the governing body should consider whether the decision to exclude the pupil was lawful, reasonable and procedurally fair, taking account of the headteacher s legal duties and the evidence that was presented to the governing body in relation to the decision to exclude. 67. The governing body should note the outcome of its consideration on the pupil's educational record, along with copies of relevant papers for future reference. 33 Under section 176 of the Education Act 2002 maintained schools and local authorities must have regard to statutory guidance on listening to and involving children and young people. 20

21 68. In cases where the governing body considers parents representations but does not have the power to direct a pupil s reinstatement, it should consider whether it would be appropriate to place a note of its findings on the pupil s educational record. 69. Claims of discrimination to the First-tier Tribunal or County Court can be made up to six months after the discrimination is alleged to have occurred. Where practicable, schools should retain records and evidence relating to an exclusion for at least six months in case such a claim is made. Statutory guidance to local authorities on their participation in the governing body s consideration of an exclusion 70. Where a local authority makes representations to the governing body about an exclusion it should act impartially and fairly. Care should be taken to avoid any perception that its role is to act on behalf of the school or the parents. The local authority s role is to provide evidence or advice on wider relevant issues; for example, it can provide advice on the use of exclusion by other schools that could inform a governing body s consideration of the handling of a particular case and whether the decision to exclude was reasonable. The local authority s role is not to prevent the lawful, reasonable and fair use of exclusion by a school. 71. The local authority s attendance would also support any future responsibility it may have to arrange suitable education for an excluded pupil, as well as its wider role in relation to education within the area. This would be particularly relevant where a local authority is attending as an observer but not making representations to the governing body. 4.3 Notifying people of the governing body s decision A guide to the law Where legally required to consider an exclusion decision, the governing body must notify parents, the headteacher and the local authority of its decision, and the reasons for it, in writing and without delay. Where the pupil resides in a different local authority from the one in which the school is located, the governing body must also inform the pupil's home authority. 34 Section 51A Education Act 2002 and the School Discipline (Pupil Exclusions and Reviews) (England) Regulations

22 73. In the case of a permanent exclusion where the governing body decide not to reinstate the pupil, the governing body s notification must also include the information below: that the exclusion is permanent; the parents right to ask for the decision to be reviewed by an independent review panel and the following information: the date by which an application for a review must be received (i.e. 15 school days from the date on which notice in writing of the governing body's decision was given to parents see paragraph 75); where and to whom an application for a review (and any written evidence) should be submitted; that any application should set out the grounds on which it is being made; that, regardless of whether the excluded pupil has recognised special educational needs, parents have a right to require the local authority / academy trust to appoint an SEN expert to attend the review; details of the role of the SEN expert; that parents must make clear if they wish a SEN expert to be appointed in any application for a review; and that parents may, at their own expense, appoint someone to make written and / or oral representations to the panel and that parents may also bring a friend to the review. That, in addition to the right to apply for an independent review panel, if parents believe that the exclusion has occurred as a result of discrimination then they may make a claim under the Equality Act 2010 to the First-tier Tribunal (Special Educational Needs and Disability), in the case of disability discrimination, or the County Court, in the case of other forms of discrimination. That a claim alleging discrimination under the Equality Act 2010 should be lodged within six months of the date on which the discrimination is alleged to have taken place, e.g. the day on which the pupil was excluded. 74. The governing body may provide the information in paragraphs 72 and 73 by: delivering it directly to parents; leaving it at their last known address; or by sending it by first-class post to this address. 75. Notice is deemed to have been given on the same day if it is delivered directly or on the second working day after posting by first class mail. Statutory guidance to governing bodies on providing information to parents following its consideration of an exclusion 76. The governing body should set out the reasons for its decision in sufficient detail to enable all parties to understand why the decision was made. 22

23 77. Where relevant, it will be for schools to confirm the details of where the parents application for an independent review panel should be sent. This is normally to the clerk of the independent review panel. 78. Parents should be informed that, if they believe it to be appropriate, they should include a reference about how they consider their child s special educational to be relevant to the exclusion. 79. In providing details of the role of the SEN expert, the governing body should refer to the statutory guidance provided to SEN experts in paragraphs 161 to 164 and clarify that there would be no cost to parents for this appointment. 80. Where the governing body decides to uphold an exclusion it should draw the attention of parents to relevant sources of free and impartial information that will allow them to make an informed decision on whether to seek a review of the decision and the process to be followed. Schools should ensure that these sources of information are checked regularly and updated as required. This information should be included in the letter notifying parents of a decision to uphold an exclusion and should include: a link to this statutory guidance on exclusions ( a link to guidance on making a claim of discrimination to the First-tier Tribunal ( a link to the Coram Children s Legal Centre ( ; and where considered relevant by the governing body, links to other information, advice and support services, such as Traveller Education Services or the local parent partnership ( 23

24 5. The headteacher s duty to remove a permanently excluded pupil s name from the school register A guide to the law The headteacher must remove a pupil from the school admission register if: 15 school days have passed since the parents were notified of the governing body s decision to uphold a permanent exclusion and no application has been made for an independent review panel; or the parents have stated in writing that they will not be applying for an independent review panel. 82. Where an application for an independent review panel has been made within 15 school days, the headteacher must wait until the review has been determined, or abandoned, before removing a pupil s name from the register. 83. Where a pupil s name is to be deleted from the school admission register because of a permanent exclusion the school must make a return to the local authority. The return must give the full name of the pupil, the address of any parents with whom the pupil normally resides and the ground upon which their name is to be deleted from the admission register (i.e. permanent exclusion). This return must be made as soon as the ground for deletion is met and no later than the deletion of the pupil s name. 84. Where a pupil s name is removed from the school s admission register and a discrimination claim is subsequently made, the First-tier Tribunal or County Court has the power to direct that the pupil should be reinstated. Statutory guidance to schools on marking attendance registers following exclusion 85. Whilst an excluded pupil s name remains on a school s admission register, the pupil should be marked on the attendance register using the appropriate code. Where alternative provision has been made that meets the requirements of the pupil registration regulations, and the pupil attends it, an appropriate attendance code, such as Code B (Education Off-site) or Code D (Dual Registration), should be used. Pupils not attending alternative provision should be marked absent using Code E The Education (Pupil Registration)(England) Regulations Additional information can be found in departmental advice on attendance for maintained schools, academies, independent schools and local authorities ( 24

25 6. The local authority s / academy trust s duty to arrange an independent review panel 6.1 Arranging a date and venue A guide to the law If parents apply for an independent review panel within the legal time frame, the local authority or (in the case of an academy) the academy trust must arrange for one at its own expense in order to review the decision of a governing body not to reinstate a permanently excluded pupil. 87. The legal time frame for an application is: within 15 school days of notice being given to the parents by the governing body of its decision to uphold a permanent exclusion (in accordance with the requirements in section 4.3); or if an application has not been made within this time frame, within 15 school days of the final determination of a claim made under the Equality Act 2010 alleging that the exclusion amounts to unlawful discrimination Any application made outside the legal time frame must be rejected by the local authority / academy trust. 89. The local authority / academy trust must not delay or postpone arranging an independent review panel if parents also make a claim of discrimination in relation to the exclusion to the First-tier Tribunal (Special Educational Needs and Disability) or the County Court Parents may request an independent review panel even if they did not make representations to, or attend, the meeting at which the governing body considered the exclusion. 37 Section 51A Education Act 2002 and the School Discipline (Pupil Exclusions and Reviews) (England) Regulations The First-tier Tribunal (Special Educational Needs and Disability) and County Court have the jurisdiction to hear claims of discrimination relating to exclusions under the Equality Act In such circumstances, the Tribunal or Court may decide to delay their consideration until after the independent review panel process has been completed. 25