INITIAL COST COMPARISON OF RIGID AND FLEXIBLE PAVEMENTS: UNDER DIFFERENT TRAFIC AND SOIL CONDITIONS
|
|
- Cecily Marsh
- 7 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 INITIAL COST COMPARISON OF RIGID AND FLEXIBLE PAVEMENTS: UNDER DIFFERENT TRAFIC AND SOIL CONDITIONS ABSTRACT T. Akakin Turkish Ready Mixed Concrete Association, Turkey Y. Engin Turkish Ready Mixed Concrete Association, Turkey S. Ucar Turkish Ready Mixed Concrete Association, Turkey In this paper, the economic analysis has been done on both flexible and rigid pavements. These cost analyses play a great role on the decision-making stages in selection of pavement types. In this analysis initial cost of rigid and flexible pavements have been determined for both flexible pavements and rigid pavements according to AASHTO 93 (American Association of State Highway and Transportation (1993) Guide for Design of Structures ) design guideline. The pavements were designed under different traffic conditions and different soil conditions. According to the output of design parameters the layer thicknesses and costs are calculated. KEY WORDS PAVEMENT / CONCRETE ROAD / COST COMPARISON / INITIAL COST 1. INTRODUCTION Initial cost is generally the major factor in deciding the type of the pavement in design. The planners often think that the flexible pavement is cheaper than the rigid pavements. In fact this is not always the case. In the last decade the price of bitumen which is the main ingredient of flexible pavement has increased because of the increase in crude oil prices. However the rigid pavement s main ingredient cement price is declining especially in Turkey. Government executives frequently have to choose between concrete and asphalt paving materials for roads and highways. In the last few years in asphalt which caused a dramatic escalation in asphalt prices reflected in a 250% increase during It is likely that once the economic recovery gains traction, large shortages may reappear, oil prices will rise and asphalt prices will resume their upward climb. From 2003 to 2008 oil prices increased nearly 300%. During the same period, liquid asphalt increased 250%. The increases in asphalt prices during this period were not only a result of rising oil prices, but also by changes in oil refining practices which has led to a reduction in heavy crude production and reduced supply. Global economic weakness has resulted in a 50% decline in oil prices during the past year. Despite reduced paving demand and lower oil prices, asphalt prices have declined only 12% from record high levels during the same period. Oil price scenario given in Figure 1. reflects significant changes in global energy demand. Emerging markets are increasingly becoming a major driver. Longer term world economic growth is expected to be characterized by developing and transitional economies adding new demand pressures on oil prices. By 2015 oil prices are conservatively expected to exceed $133 per barrel
2 reestablishing past peaks. Longer term projections made by the United States government suggest that oil prices may exceed $180 per barrel by Figure 1. Oil price scenario - Oil prices between and 2015 estimates (PCA) Figure 2. Change in ready Mixed Concrete Prices between in Turkey (USD/m3) However in this period the prices of concrete prices are nearly dormant. The price of concrete between is given in Figure 2 in USD. The concrete price in Turkey,with concrete pump price included, is about 40USD/m3. Taking these changes in the market into account in this analysis we compared the initial costs of asphalt and concrete pavements. 2. CALCULATIONS The pavement analysis is done according to AASHTO 1993 with the following conditions.
3 2.1. DESIGN METHODS In this research the design of rigid pavements and flexible pavements is done according to AASHTO The pavement layers are given in Figure 3 and Figure 4. Rigid pavement is designed according to AASHTO93 with layers ; concrete pavement and sub course of crushed stone. The principal criterions in the design of pavements are traffic and subgrade. The number of recurrences of an equivalent standard single axle load of 8.2 tonnes on the road within a selected period was derived from Annual Average Daily Traffic (AADT) values and taken as the traffic load in this study. This study examines 11 different categories of traffic. These categories were determined on the basis of the conditions on Turkish Highways and the number of recurrences of an equivalent standard single axle load of 8.2 tonnes within the selected period of analysis, that is T8,2 varies between 20 millions to 250 millions. Another important criterion in pavement design is the load bearing capacity of subgrade soil. In this study, the load-bearing capacity of four different soil types were used in analysis. Modulus of resilience values is ranged from 5000 to psi psi Figure 3. Flexible Cross-section 1. Width of driving lanes 9. stone sub layer 2. Shoulder width 10. Road Base (Subgrade soil) 4. Platform width 11. Backfill slope 5. Wearing course surfacing 12. Horizontal slope of road 6. Binder course surfacing 13. Shoulder slope 7. Bituminous course 14. Ditch slope 8. Plant mix and shoulder backfill course 15. Cut off slope Figure 4. Rigid Cross-section 1. Width of driving lanes 11. Backfill slope 2. Shoulder width 12. Horizontal slope of road 4. Platform width 13. Shoulder slope 5. Concrete pavement 14. Ditch slope 6. stone sub layer 15. Cut off slope 10. Road Base (Subgrade soil)
4 2.2. PAVEMENT PROPERTIES Geometrical Properties Cost analyses for one type of flexible pavement and two types of rigid pavement were made for 11 different traffic categories. The geometrical properties of the road for which cost analysis was made are as follows: Length of road: 1000 m Platform width: 12 m Total shoulder width: 5 m Width of driving lanes: 7 m (2 lanes) In the rigid pavement, both the course of concrete pavement and the course continue without any change into the shoulders. In the flexible pavement a plant mix backfill layer takes the place of the hot bituminous course in the shoulders while wear and binder courses continue into the shoulder. Dowels and tie-rods are used in the joints of jointed unreinforced concrete pavements. Three longitudinal joints are placed over the total road width, with one between the two lanes and two where driving lanes meet the shoulders. Transverse joints shall be cut at an average of every 5 m as contraction joints. Joints are sawed down 1/3 joint thickness and a fiber is placed, coated up to 15 mm and sealed with cold joint sealer. Dowels are placed at an average of every 30 cm in transverse joints. Dowels are flat, S220a class, 25mm diameter and 60 cm long. While tie-rods are ribbed, S420a class, 12mm diameter and 80 cm long and are placed every 80 cm in longitudinal joints. Dowels are coated with bitumen to prevent both adhesion with concrete and corrosion. The following parameters are chosen for flexible and rigid pavement 1. Reliability a. Reliability level in percent (R) %50 b. Combined standard error (So) Serviceability a. Initial serviceability index (pi) 4.5 b. Terminal serviceability index (pf) 3 The 1993 AASHTO Guide offers the following relationship between k-values from a plate bearing test and resilient modulus (MR): The results according top AASHTO 1993 can be found in Tables 1-8 and the cost analysis can be found in Figures Material Properties Following are the specifications of the concrete we decided to use in road pavement: Strength: C40 (fck=40 MPa), Cement dosage: 375 kg/m3, Water/cement ratio: 0.41, Maximum aggregate size: 30 mm, Consistency: S1 (between 0-5 cm). As for the flexible pavement, the specifications of the material chosen are as follows: Bitumen type: AC 60/70, Bitumen weight ratio for wear coarse: 5.35%, Bitumen weight ratio for hot bituminous : 4%. Using the variables above with the equation solver provided by Washington University at below Figure 5 and Figure 6 we solved the layer thicknesses for variable sub and traffic loads.
5 Figure 5. Washinton University computer program for Rigid Design
6 Figure 6. Washinton University computer program for Rigid Design 3. RESULTS The pavement thicknesses are calculated with the parameters above and the results are given for Rigid, asphalt pavements for different subsoil conditions and different traffic load is given in below Table 1-8 the thickness layers and the cost of the 1 km road are given in Figures The costs are calculated with 2009 prices for the works done for each pavement type for each work. As given in short form in Table 9.
7 Table 1. Layer thicknesses for Flexible for 5.000psi subgrade Surface Bituminous Base Graded crushed stone Table 2. Layer thicknesses for Flexible for psi subgrade Surface Bituminous Base Table 3. Layer thicknesses for Flexible for psi subgrade ) Surface Bituminous Base Table 4. Layer thicknesses for Flexible for psi subgrade Surface Bituminous Base
8 Table 5. Layer thicknesses for Rigid for k=250pci with dowel bar Concrete Table 6. Layer thicknesses for Rigid for k=500pci with dowel bar Concrete Table 7. Layer thicknesses for Rigid for k=750pci with dowel bar Concrete Table 8. Layer thicknesses for Rigid for k=1000pci with dowel bar Concrete
9 Table 9. Cost of works Analysis: Concrete Meas. Unit: M3 Code Pose No Definition Unit Quantity Unit Cost Cost (TL) Turkish Lira CONCRETE MIX COMPONENTS SUB-TOTAL M3 67,71 Preparation of Concrete Mix (400 M3 /day capacity) SUB-TOTAL M3 35,5 PAVING AND LEVELLING CONCRETE (400 M3 /Day) 7 1 m3 Total = 110,2 OTHER WORKS OF Analysis:: CONCRETE PAVEMENT Meas. Unit: M2 (JPCP) CURING CONCRETE SUB-TOTAL M2 0,86 OPENING JOINTS SUB-TOTAL M2 2,19 PLACEMENT OF JOINT FILLER SUB-TOTAL M2 4,06 JOINT REINFORCEMENTS SUB-TOTAL M2 5 1 m2 Total = 12,12 Analysis:: Wear Course Construction Meas. Unit: TON 1 Ton Total = 96,5 Analysis:: Binder Course Construction Meas. Unit: TON 1 Ton Total = 88,2 Analysis:: Analysis:: Bituminous Base Course Construction Plantmix Base Course Construction Meas. Unit: TON 1 Ton Total = 81,33 Meas. Unit: TON 1 Ton Total = 36,12 Analysis:: Construction of Sub Meas. Unit: TON 1 Ton Total = 31,25 Analysis:: Construction of Sand-Gravel Sub Meas. Unit: TON 1 m3 Total = 14,74
10 Figure 7. Concrete and Asphalt pavement cost analysis for 5000psi subgrade soil Figure 8. Concrete and Asphalt pavement cost analysis for psi subgrade soil
11 Figure9. Concrete and Asphalt pavement cost analysis for psi subgrade soil Figure 10. Concrete and Asphalt pavement cost analysis for psi subgrade soil With the increase of traffic load the pavement thicknesses increase and the cost of the road increases gradually in all cases. For 5.000psi, psi and psi sub asphalt pavement is expensive for all traffic loads. As the traffic load increases the asphalt pavement cost increases even more. Also, with the decrease in the sub strength the asphalt pavement cost increases more. The cost of asphalt pavement for 5.000psi sub soil cost is 60% more then the cost of the road for psi sub for 250 millions cycle of traffic load. However the concrete pavement cost for 5.000psi sub and psi sub remains the same.
12 So we can conclude that concrete pavement is less effected by the sub conditions and asphalt pavement is effected more and layer thicknesses increase with the decrease in sub conditions and traffic loads. And concrete pavements should be chosen with high traffic loads or even low traffic loads with low sub strength. Figure 11. Initial cost of asphalt and concrete pavements (PCA) Asphalt pavement price increases not in only in Turkey but globally. The initial bid paving cost of a new road for asphalt pavement is also increasing around the world with increasing asphalt prices. The price change of asphalt and concrete pavement is given in Figure 11. PCA calculated for a one mile standard two lane roadway, asphalt had a $120,000 cost advantage over a concrete paved road in 2003 roughly a 30% advantage. With 2009 prices concrete paved roads, has an $82,000 cost advantage over asphalt paved roads. And with 2010 prices concrete roads are $58,500 cheaper per one mile standard two lane roadway. In the longer term oil prices are expected to reach more than $180 per barrel by 2030 according to the Energy Information Agency (EIA). So comparative initial bid costs will increasingly favour concrete paved roads. PCA estimates by 2015 concrete paved roads will enjoy a $500,000 initial bid cost advantage over asphalt for a one mile standard two lane roadway roughly a 41% savings.
13 Figure 12. Life cycle cost comparison of asphalt and concrete pavement (PCA) Even with concrete s sustainability advantages, some estimates of life-cycle costs favours asphalt over concrete. PCA calculates concrete paved roads enjoyed more than an $185,000 advantage over an asphalt paved road during fiscal 2009 roughly a 25% savings. PCA estimates concrete s life cycle cost advantage per one mile standard two lane roadway will increase to more than $730,000 roughly a 45% savings by fiscal CONCLUSIONS As seen in Table 1-8 and Figure 7-10, construction cost for rigid pavements are cheaper then flexible pavements, in contrast to what is generally thought. However with the strength increase in subgrade the asphalt pavement costs and rigid pavement costs get closer. With increasing petrol prices the cost of asphalt pavements will be even higher. So concrete pavement should be highly considered in choosing the pavement types. REFERENCES UCAR Selcuk; AKAKIN Tümer, ENGIN Yasin, (2007) Cost Comparison of Rigid and Flexible s : Applications in Turkey ERMCO Seville Congress June 2007 American Association of State Highway and Transportation (1993) Guide for Design of Structures Update: Paving, The New Realities, Portland Cement Association, 16 July 2009,
The AASHO Road Test site (which eventually became part of I-80) at Ottawa, Illinois, was typical of northern climates (see Table 1).
Página 1 de 12 AASHO Road Test The AASHO Road Test, a $27 million (1960 dollars) investment and the largest road experiment of its time, was conceived and sponsored by the American Association of State
More informationFinal Report Evaluation of I-Pave Low Volume Road Design Software
Final Report Evaluation of I-Pave Low Volume Road Design Software May 2015 Michael I Darter, William R. Vavrik, Dinesh Ayyala 2015 2014 Applied Research Associates, Inc. 1 Objectives 1. Obtain all documentation
More informationAPPENDIX B. I. Background Information
APPENDIX B GUIDELINES FOR IDENTIFYING AND REPAIRING LOCALIZED AREAS OF DISTRESS IN AC PAVEMENTS PRIOR TO CAPITAL PREVENTIVE MAINTENANCE OR REHABILITATION REPAIRS I. Background Information A. AC Pavement
More informationC. Section 014510 TESTING LABORATORY SERVICE.
SECTION 014500 QUALITY CONTROL PART 1 GENERAL 1.01 RELATED REQUIREMENTS A. Drawings and General Provisions of Contract, including General and Special Conditions and other Division 1 Specification Sections,
More informationSECTION 3.3 - PAVEMENT DESIGN
SECTION 3.3-3.3.1 GENERAL 3.3.2 SUBSURFACE DRAINAGE 3.3.3 DETERMINATION OF DESIGN TRAFFIC 3.3.4 SUBGRADE EVALUATION 3.3.5 PAVEMENT THICKNESS 3.3.5.1 GRANULAR PAVEMENTS WITH THIN BITUMINOUS SURFACING 3.3.5.2
More informationSECTION 311 PLACEMENT AND CONSTRUCTION OF CEMENT TREATED SUBGRADESOIL CEMENT BASE COURSE
PLACEMENT AND CONSTRUCTION OF CEMENT TREATED SUBGRADESOIL CEMENT BASE COURSE 311.1 DESCRIPTION: This item shall consist of a cement treated subgrade base course composed of a mixture of local soil, portland
More informationQuality control: Annex-A.
Quality control: Quality of the constructed work has been checked by our staff as per frequency and provision mentioned section 900 in MoRT&H and as per provision mentioned in Concession Agreement. The
More informationModern Techniques for Concrete Pavement Design
Modern Techniques for Concrete Pavement Design Robert Rodden, P.E. Director of Technical Services & Product Development American Concrete Pavement Association km of Paved Roadway by Country 5.000.000 4.500.000
More informationTraffic volumes adopted for pavement designs are based on the parameters contained in Section 7 of this report.
11. Pavements 11.1 Pavement design Preliminary pavement designs have been developed for the highway travel lanes (through carriageways), the inner and outer shoulders, on and off ramps and service roads.
More informationSection 300 Base Courses
Table of Contents 1. Importance of Base Courses... 300-1 2. Types of Bases... 300-3 A. Cement Treated Permeable Base Course... 300-3 B. Bituminous Concrete Base Courses... 300-6 C. Superpave Asphalt HMA
More informationSECTION 4Aggegate Subbase
The contractor shall moist-cure the completed Lime Treated Subbase for a minimum of days before allowing any traffic on the compacted surface. The contractor shall be responsible for repairing any damages
More informationSECTION III-06 Surfacing Page 1 Revised 3/2/10. See the DESIGN GUIDELINES in Section I-06 for requirements for cross slope of the roadway.
Page 1 Revised 3/2/10 See the DESIGN GUIDELINES in Section I-06 for requirements for cross slope of the roadway. For New/Reconstruction projects: The cross slope of the driving lanes range from 1.5% to
More informationPAVEMENT STRUCTURE DESIGN GUIDELINES
PAVEMENT STRUCTURE DESIGN GUIDELINES Technical Circular T- 01/15 (Replaces Technical Circular T-01/04) Final Update: Jan. 26, 2015 Geotechnical, Materials and Pavement Engineering TABLE OF CONTENTS 1.0
More informationSECTION 623 CONCRETE BONDING COMPOUND, EPOXY MORTAR AND EPOXY POLYMER CONCRETE OVERLAY SECTION 623.10 CONCRETE BONDING COMPOUND.
SECTION 623 CONCRETE BONDING COMPOUND, EPOXY MORTAR AND EPOXY POLYMER CONCRETE OVERLAY SECTION 623.10 CONCRETE BONDING COMPOUND. 623.10.1 Description. This work shall consist of preparing the surface,
More informationPorous Pavement Alternatives Cost Analysis
Porous Pavement Alternatives Cost Analysis Prepared by Century West Engineering for Metro This cost analysis compares the construction costs of six different types of pavement for three different scenarios.
More informationSPECIAL NOTE FOR ASPHALT WATERPROOFING MIX FOR BRIDGE-DECK OVERLAYS AND ADJACENT APPROACHES
SPECIAL NOTE FOR ASPHALT WATERPROOFING MIX FOR BRIDGE-DECK OVERLAYS AND ADJACENT APPROACHES 1. DESCRIPTION. Asphalt Waterproofing Mix (AWM) is a highly elastomeric, polymermodified, impermeable asphalt
More informationINTRODUCTION TO CONCRETE PAVEMENTS
INTRODUCTION TO CONCRETE PAVEMENTS Abstract Arvo Tinni Tinni Management Consulting February 2013 This paper describes the experiences and design methodologies for concrete pavements in Australia. It is
More informationSECTION 334 (Pages 243-266) is deleted and the following substituted: SECTION 334 SUPERPAVE ASPHALT CONCRETE
334 SUPERPAVE ASPHALT CONCRETE. (REV 12-20-04) (FA 1-6-05) (7-05) SECTION 334 (Pages 243-266) is deleted and the following substituted: SECTION 334 SUPERPAVE ASPHALT CONCRETE 334-1 Description. 334-1.1
More informationAPPENDIX B WARRANTY PERFORMANCE INDICATOR TABLES FOR VARIOUS END PRODUCTS
B-1 APPENDIX B WARRANTY PERFORMANCE INDICATOR TABLES FOR VARIOUS END PRODUCTS B-2 TABLE B1 Performance indicators for HMAC pavement (continued on next page) B-3 TABLE B1 (Continued) (continued on next
More informationT2: Reduce overall transport cost by cost effective road rehabilitation and maintenance
PROJECT REPORT PR/INT/277/04 Dynamic Cone Penetrometer tests and analysis Technical Information Note By Colin Jones Sector: Theme: Project Title: Project Reference: Transport T2: Reduce overall transport
More informationOhio Department of Transportation Division of Production Management Office of Geotechnical Engineering. Geotechnical Bulletin PLAN SUBGRADES
Ohio Department of Transportation Division of Production Management Office of Geotechnical Engineering Geotechnical Bulletin GB 1 PLAN SUBGRADES Geotechnical Bulletin GB1 was jointly developed by the Offices
More informationUnit Price Averages Reports
Unit Price Averages Reports 12/7/2015 UNIT PRICE AVERAGES REPORT Disclaimer The information provided in the following Unit Price Averages Report is only for the use of Alberta Infrastructure & Transportation
More informationGUIDELINES FOR MINE HAUL ROAD DESIGN
GUIDELINES FOR MINE HAUL ROAD DESIGN Dwayne D. Tannant & Bruce Regensburg School of Mining and Petroleum Engineering Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering University of Alberta 2001 SMART Surface
More informationRehabilitation by cracking and seating of concrete pavement optimized by FWD analysis
Rehabilitation by cracking and seating of concrete pavement optimized by FWD analysis H. C. Korsgaard & J. P. Pedersen Carl Bro Pavement Consultants, Kokbjerg 5, DK6000 Kolding M. Rasmussen Copenhagen
More informationPavement Design. Guest Lecturer Dr. Sirous Alavi, P.E. SIERRA TRANSPORTATION. 1005 Terminal Way, Suite 125 Reno, Nevada 89502
Pavement Design Guest Lecturer Dr. Sirous Alavi, P.E. SIERRA TRANSPORTATION ENGINEERS,, INC. I 1005 Terminal Way, Suite 125 Reno, Nevada 89502 Topics Introduction Design Factors Pavement Types Fundamentals
More informationConstruction Management Program
Use and Limitation: The Sponsor may use this document as a guide in preparing a construction management program for their specific project. Sponsors and Consultants are cautioned that the provision of
More informationReinforcement HUESKER. HaTelit. Engineering with geosynthetics
HUESKER Engineering with geosynthetics rhuesker HUESKER HUESKER HUESKER HUESKER HUESKERr SKER HUESKER HUESKER Asphalt HUESKER HUESKER HUESKERHUES Reinforcement - the answer to reflective cracking in asphalt
More informationImpacts of Increased Loading Due to Heavy Construction Traffic on Thin Pavements
Impacts of Increased Loading Due to Heavy Construction Traffic on Thin Pavements Author: Harry Sturm, P. Eng. Stantec Consulting Ltd. 16-77 Mississauga Road Mississauga, ON L5N 7G2 Phone: (95) 817-296
More informationCW 3110 SUB-GRADE, SUB-BASE AND BASE COURSE CONSTRUCTION TABLE OF CONTENTS
December 2014 CW 3110 SUB-GRADE, SUB-BASE AND BASE COURSE CONSTRUCTION TABLE OF CONTENTS 1. DESCRIPTION... 1 1.1 General... 1 1.2 Definitions... 1 1.3 Referenced Standard Construction Specifications...
More informationWATERPROOFING FOR CONCRETE STRUCTURES
MANUAL OF CONTRACT DOCUMENTS FOR ROAD WORKS VOLUME 1 SPECIFICATION FOR ROAD WORKS SERIES 2000 WATERPROOFING FOR CONCRETE STRUCTURES Contents Clause Title Page 2001 General 2 2002 Protection of Bridge Deck
More informationSECTION 55 PIPE FOR STORM DRAINS AND CULVERTS (FAA D-701)
SECTION 55 PIPE FOR STORM DRAINS AND CULVERTS (FAA D-701) 55-1 GENERAL The Contractor shall perform all work required by the plans for construction of pipe for storm drains, precast polymer trench drains
More informationAGREGADOS RECICLADOS MITOS Y REALIDADES
The Production and Use of Recycled Concrete in the USA Thomas Van Dam, Ph.D., P.E., FACI Principal Engineer CTL Group Introduction In the United States, concrete is the most commonly used recycled material
More informationChapter 7: Pavement Rehabilitation 7-1 Asphalt Pavement Overlays 7-1 Surface Preparation Methods 7-2 Concrete Pavement Preparation 7-3 Recycling
7-1 Asphalt Pavement Overlays 7-1 Surface Preparation Methods 7-2 Concrete Pavement Preparation 7-3 Recycling Asphalt Pavements 7-7 Chapter 7 Pavement Rehabilitation Pavement rehabilitation can be accomplished
More informationFly Ash Slurry Injection (FASI) of Bituminous Thermal Cracks
Fly Ash Slurry Injection (FASI) of Bituminous Thermal Cracks Schedule What is Fly Ash Slurry Injection (FASI) Thermal Cracks and Why They Depress Pavement Rehab Strategies Special Provisions Upcoming Projects
More informationRural Road Maintenance Handbook Module 16 Rural Road Maintenance Cost Estimate
After fulfilling Module 16, you will be able to: Understand the structure of cost estimating sheets and the steps to establish a cost estimate for rural road maintenance Establish cost estimate Self -
More informationThe Most Advanced Name in Drainage Systems. Geotextile Products
The Most Advanced Name in Drainage Systems Geotextile Products ADS MEETs YOUR Geotextile NEEDS Advanced Drainage Systems, Inc. (ADS) single wall and N12 dual wall pipe have become the industry standard
More informationGreening our Roads. Approach
Greening our Roads Approach To create a Sustainable Future for the world, by achieving Resource Extension economically, by reducing usage of limiting resources and extending life cycle Ensuring Green Roads
More informationUSE OF HIGHLY POLYMER MODIFIED HMA (HiMA) Ohio Asphalt Paving Conference Columbus, Ohio February 4, 2015 Bob Kluttz, Kraton Polymers
USE OF HIGHLY POLYMER MODIFIED HMA (HiMA) Ohio Asphalt Paving Conference Columbus, Ohio February 4, 2015 Bob Kluttz, Kraton Polymers Outline Introduction SBS and Highly Modified Asphalt Material Properties
More informationHow To Retaining Wall Guide
How To Retaining Wall Guide Before you start: Consents and Engineering Building Consent Retaining walls over 1.5m high will require a building consent from the Local Body Council. Walls that carry extra
More informationConstruction Specifications for Keyhole Pavement Coring and Reinstatement
F I N A L Construction Specifications for Keyhole Pavement Coring and Reinstatement Gas Technology Institute 1700 S. Mount Prospect Rd. Des Plaines, Illinois 60018 www.gastechnology.org Version 13 October
More informationSTATE OF OHIO DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION SUPPLEMENTAL SPECIFICATION 888 PORTLAND CEMENT CONCRETE PAVEMENT USING QC/QA.
STATE OF OHIO DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION SUPPLEMENTAL SPECIFICATION 888 PORTLAND CEMENT CONCRETE PAVEMENT USING QC/QA October 21, 2011 888.01 General 888.02 Materials 888.03 Concrete Proportioning 888.04
More informationConstruction Specification for Concrete Curb and Concrete Curb and Gutter
Engineering & Construction Services Division Standard Specifications for Road Works TS 3.50 April 2015 for Concrete Curb and Table of Contents TS 3.50.01 SCOPE... 3 TS 3.50.02 REFERENCES... 3 TS 3.50.03
More informationInterlocking Concrete Pavement as an Alternative to Asphalt Concrete for Howard Road, Westley, California
Interlocking Concrete Pavement as an Alternative to Asphalt Concrete for Howard Road, Westley, California By Matt Machado, PE, LS, MBA Public Works Director for Stanislaus County and Ron Illium, PE Regional
More informationCHAPTERS 600 670 PAVEMENT ENGINEERING CHAPTER 600 GENERAL ASPECTS
HIGHWAY DESIGN MANUAL 600-1 May 7, 2012 CHAPTERS 600 670 PAVEMENT ENGINEERING CHAPTER 600 GENERAL ASPECTS Topic 601 - Introduction Pavement engineering involves the determination of the type and thickness
More informationPermeable Interlocking Concrete Pavements. The Stormwater Problem
Permeable Interlocking Concrete Pavements The Stormwater Problem 1 Stormwater Management Objectives Water Quantity Accommodate water volumes & peak flows Water Quality Control pollutant levels A Low Impact
More informationCase Studies - Concrete Overlays
Case Studies - Concrete Overlays Lessons Learned - Concrete Overlays Purdue Road School March 6, 2013 Today s Topic 1. Overlays 2. New Full-depth 3. Pervious 4. Roller Compacted 5. Full Depth Patching
More informationTesting and appraisal of Lucobit polymer effect as an additive on asphalt mixture performance
Abstract Testing and appraisal of polymer effect as an additive on asphalt mixture performance Hamid Sabbagh mollahosseini*,golazin Yadollahi**, Ershad Amoosoltani*** *, ***Executive of Engineering and
More informationResurfacing Concrete. Page 1 of 5
Resurfacing Concrete Materials List QUIKRETE Concrete Resurfacer (No. 1131) (see calculator on page 5 for quantity needed) QUIKRETE Concrete and Stucco Wash (No. 8601) QUIKRETE Concrete Sealer (No. 8800)
More informationNorthEast Transportation Training and Certification Program (NETTCP) Course Registration Form
(NETTCP) Course Registration Form Interim Certification (Cost $300 members / $425 non-members) HMA Plant Technician* HMA Paving Inspector* Soils & Aggregate Inspector* Soils & Aggregate Lab Technician*
More informationSeptember 1, 2003 CONCRETE MANUAL 5-694.900 CONCRETE PAVEMENT REHABILITATION 5-694.900
September 1, 2003 CONCRETE MANUAL 5-694.900 5-694.901 GENERAL CONCRETE PAVEMENT REHABILITATION 5-694.900 Concrete Pavement Rehabilitation is an extremely valuable tool of the Minnesota Department of Transportation
More informationSECTION 36 - CAST-IN-PLACE CONCRETE PIPE (CIPCP) TABLE OF CONTENTS
SECTION 36 - CAST-IN-PLACE CONCRETE PIPE (CIPCP) TABLE OF CONTENTS Section Page 36-1 GENERAL... 36.1 36-2 PIPEMAKING EQUIPMENT... 36.1 36-3 TRENCH EXCAVATION... 36.1 36-4 SPECIAL FOUNDATION TREATMENT...
More informationPAVEMENT REHABILITATION using BITUMEN STABILISATION STATE OF THE ART
PAVEMENT REHABILITATION using BITUMEN STABILISATION STATE OF THE ART 23 rd Road Pavement Forum Fern Hill Hotel, Tweedie, KZN Wednesday 9 th May 2012 Dave Collings UCD Technology LOUDON INTERNATIONAL THE
More informationSection 500 Rigid Pavement
Table of Contents 1. Reinforced or Plain Cement Concrete Pavements, Reinforced or Plain Cement Concrete Pavement (RPS), and Protective Coating for Cement Concrete Pavement... 500-1 2. Pavement Relief Joint...
More informationUSE OF A DIGITAL SURVEY VEHICLE FOR PAVEMENT CONDITION SURVEYS AT AIRPORTS. Paul W. Wilke, P.E. Applied Research Associates, Inc.
USE OF A DIGITAL SURVEY VEHICLE FOR PAVEMENT CONDITION SURVEYS AT AIRPORTS Paul W. Wilke, P.E. Applied Research Associates, Inc. August 11, 2014 Words: 3,280 Figures: 3 Tables: 0 Photographs: 3 ABSTRACT
More informationLa Nueva AASHTO Guia de Diseno de Pavimentos Hormigon
La Nueva AASHTO Guia de Diseno de Pavimentos Hormigon Michael I. Darter Emeritus Prof. Civil Engineering, University of Illinois & Applied Research Associates, Inc. USA October 2012 Cordoba, Argentina
More informationOtta Seal BACKGROUND GENERAL DESCRIPTION DESIGN ASPECTS. Category : Technical Information/On-carriageway/
Otta Seal Category : Technical Information/On-carriageway/ BACKGROUND An Otta seal is a thin bituminous seal comprising graded gravel or crushed aggregate containing all sizes and either a cut-back or
More informationSUPPLEMENTAL SPECIFICATIONS CROSS SLOPE VERIFICATION:
September 22, 2009 Updated November 16, 2009 SUPPLEMENTAL SPECIFICATIONS CROSS SLOPE VERIFICATION: 1. DESCRIPTION: The cross slopes of the roadway are to be constructed as detailed in the plans and within
More informationLIFE-CYCLE COST COMPARISON FOR MUNICIPAL ROAD PAVEMENTS
LIFE-CYCLE COST COMPARISON FOR MUNICIPAL ROAD PAVEMENTS HEIN, David K., P.Eng. Applied Research Associates, Inc., 5401 Eglinton Avenue West, Suite 105, Toronto, ON, CANA- DA, M9C 5K6. Tel: 416-621-9555
More informationADVANTAGES OF STEEL FIBRE REINFORCED CONCRETE IN INDUSTRIAL FLOORS
ADVANTAGES OF STEEL FIBRE REINFORCED CONCRETE IN INDUSTRIAL FLOORS Murugesan M 1, Dashrath Rajpurohit 2 1 Assistant General Manager, Civil & Structural, Larsen & Toubro Technology Services, Tamilnadu,
More informationQUALITY ASSURANCE PROGRAM (QAP) City Rohnert Park
QUALITY ASSURANCE PROGRAM (QAP) City Rohnert Park The purpose of this program is to provide assurance that the materials incorporated into the construction projects are in conformance with the contract
More informationSoftware Development (PAKPAVE) for Flexible Pavement Design
Software Development (PAKPAVE) for Flexible Pavement Design Rafi Ullah Khan, Muhammad Imran Khan and Afed Ullah Khan Abstract In today s world, the road and surface failure of the flexible pavement has
More informationCONSTRUCTION AND PERFORMANCE OF ULTRATHIN ASPHALT FRICTION COURSE
NCAT Report No. 97-5 CONSTRUCTION AND PERFORMANCE OF ULTRATHIN ASPHALT FRICTION COURSE by Prithvi S. Kandhal Larry Lockett September 1997 CONSTRUCTION AND PERFORMANCE OF ULTRATHIN ASPHALT FRICTION COURSE
More informationInstallation PowerPoint for Grasscrete Formers
Installation PowerPoint for Grasscrete Formers 1 This document describes the two single-use tools utilized to create the Grasscrete product. The original Former is a vacuum formed light gauge plastic mold
More informationConcrete Pavement Rehabilitation: Repairing Florida One Slab At A Time
: Repairing Florida One Slab At A Time 2012 FTBA Conference Andre Sutherland, P.E. FDOT District 2 Jacksonville Construction Contents Describe Scope Characteristics Sequence of operation for slab removal
More informationSession 7: Retrofitted Edge Drains 7.1
Session 7: Retrofitted Edge Drains 7.1 Learning Outcomes 1. List benefits of drainage 2. List components of edge drain systems 3. Describe recommended installation procedures 4. Identify typical construction
More informationVILLAGE OF LOMBARD CONTRACT DOCUMENT NUMBER ST-09-06 BID PROPOSAL
VILLAGE OF LOMBARD CONTRACT DOCUMENT NUMBER ST-09-06 BID PROPOSAL I/We hereby agree to furnish to the Village of Lombard all necessary materials, equipment, and labor, to complete the North Industrial
More informationHIGHWAYS DEPARTMENT GUIDANCE NOTES ON ROAD SURFACE REQUIREMENTS FOR EXPRESSWAYS AND HIGH SPEED ROADS
HIGHWAYS DEPARTMENT GUIDANCE NOTES ON ROAD SURFACE REQUIREMENTS FOR EXPRESSWAYS AND HIGH SPEED ROADS Research & Development Division RD/GN/032 June 2007 1. Purpose ROAD SURFACE REQUIREMENTS FOR EXPRESSWAYS
More informationAggregates for Path Construction
Aggregates for Path Construction Technical Information Note No. 7 October 2011 About Sustrans Sustrans makes smarter travel choices possible, desirable and inevitable. We re a leading UK charity enabling
More informationPavement Patching Repair for AC and PCC Pavement Surfaces. Vern Thompson www.crafco.com
Pavement Patching Repair for AC and PCC Pavement Surfaces Vern Thompson www.crafco.com Overview and Objective New Methods For Pavement Patching-Overview What are they How they are applied New Methods Secti
More informationSolutions Library Solution 4: Permeable Pavement
SOILS TREES RAINGARDENS Solutions Library Solution 4: "Think like water. Go with the flow." -Frances Kato, Issaquah School District Student 59 60 How Works? Explanation of Diagram The most significant
More informationJoint Rehabilitation. Driving Forces for Concrete Pavement Joint Repairs
Long Life Concrete Pavement Joint Performance Joint Rehabilitation Gary Fick, Trinity Construction Management Services, Inc. Representing the National CP Tech Center Driving Forces for Concrete Pavement
More informationSTUDY OF THE BEHAVIOUR OF BITUMINOUS MIXTURES RESISTANT TO FUEL
STUDY OF THE BEHAVIOUR OF BITUMINOUS MIXTURES RESISTANT TO FUEL INTRODUCTION Evaluation of the performance of asphalt mixtures applied on wearing courses of road and airport pavements when subjected to
More informationPavement Rehabilitation Using Hot Mix Asphalt. - National Perspective -
Pavement Rehabilitation Using Hot Mix Asphalt - National Perspective - Rehabilitation Process Evaluate Existing Pavement and Conditions Evaluate Options Construct Project Monitor Performance Evaluate Existing
More informationJuly 2005 Technical Memorandum: UCPRC-TM-2005-12. Authors: D. Jones and J. Harvey PREPARED FOR: PREPARED BY:
July 2005 Technical Memorandum: UCPRCTM200512 Relationship Between DCP, Stiffness, Shear Strength and RValue Authors: D. Jones and J. Harvey Partnered Pavement Research Program (PPRC) Contract Strategic
More informationGRADATION OF AGGREGATE FOR CONCRETE BLOCK
GRADATION OF AGGREGATE FOR CONCRETE BLOCK Although numerous papers have been written concerning the proper gradation for concrete mixes, they have generally dealt with plastic mixes, and very little published
More informationSD95-16-G2. SD Department of Transportation Office of Research. Rural Road Design, Maintenance, and Rehabilitation Guide
SD95-16-G2 SD Department of Transportation Office of Research Rural Road Design, Maintenance, and Rehabilitation Guide Prepared by ERES Consultants, Inc. 505 West University Champaign, IL 61820-3915 September
More informationI-66 Pavement Rehabilitation
I-66 Pavement Rehabilitation Fall Asphalt Conference Richmond, VA David Shiells, P.E. Virginia Department of Transportation David White Superior Paving Corporation October 2, 2012 Project Location 2 Goal
More informationFor more information, please contact: W. David Lee, Administrator, Statewide Planning and Policy Analysis Florida Department of Transportation 605
For more information, please contact: W. David Lee, Administrator, Statewide Planning and Policy Analysis Florida Department of Transportation 605 Suwannee Street MS 28 Tallahassee, Florida 32399 (850)
More informationGuide for Design and Construction of New Jointed Plain Concrete Pavements (JPCPs)
DIVISION OF DESIGN Office of Pavement Design Pavement Design & Analysis Branch Guide for Design and Construction of New Jointed Plain Concrete Pavements (JPCPs) January 9, 2008 i TABLE OF CONTENTS 1.0
More informationThin Whitetopping Application at Williamsburg Regional Airport and Other Thin Whitetopping Airport Applications.
Thin Whitetopping Application at Williamsburg Regional Airport and Other Thin Whitetopping Airport Applications. Author: Gary L. Mitchell, P.E. Director Airports, American Concrete Pavement Association
More informationPerformance of Edge Drains in Concrete Pavements in California
Performance of Edge Drains in Concrete Pavements in California Biplab B. Bhattacharya, 1 Michael P. Zola, 2 Shreenath Rao, 3 Karl Smith, 4 Craig Hannenian 5 ABSTRACT The California Department of Transportation
More informationCAPITAL PREVENTIVE MAINTENANCE
CAPITAL PREVENTIVE MAINTENANCE 2003 EDITION April 8, 2010 CONSTRUCTION AND TECHNOLOGY DIVISION Attention Manual Holders This manual is to remain with the assigned user. If the user relocates within the
More informationState of Illinois Department Of Transportation CONSTRUCTION INSPECTOR S CHECKLIST FOR STORM SEWERS
State of Illinois Department Of Transportation CONSTRUCTION INSPECTOR S CHECKLIST FOR STORM SEWERS While its use is not required, this checklist has been prepared to provide the field inspector a summary
More informationPavement Rehabilitation Selection Rehabilitation Techniques
Pavement Rehabilitation Selection Rehabilitation Techniques Bituminous Pavement Rehabilitation Techniques Overlays Bituminous Concrete Pre-overlay Treatments Mill and Overlay Mill and Inlay Recycling Options
More informationMesh Track. Fast planning and execution of road renovations. Investing in a solution that is durable and as hard as steel
Mesh Track Fast planning and execution of road renovations Investing in a solution that is durable and as hard as steel 1 Table of Contents 03 Durability & speed 04 Professionals on Mesh Track 06 Asphalt
More informationChapter 8 Design of Concrete Mixes
Chapter 8 Design of Concrete Mixes 1 The basic procedure for mix design is applicable to concrete for most purposes including pavements. Concrete mixes should meet; Workability (slump/vebe) Compressive
More informationEQUIPEMENTS DE MAINTENANCE. Road maintenance
EQUIPEMENTS DE MAINTENANCE Road maintenance There are many road maintenance techniques. The treatment of cracks and potholes, the creation of joints are all different works needing specific equipment.
More informationNevada DOT Cold In-Place Recycling Federal Highway Administration National Review Close out meeting, August 25, 2005
Nevada DOT Cold In-Place Recycling Federal Highway Administration National Review Close out meeting, August 25, 2005 Purpose The purpose of this review is to capture for technical deployment the most advanced
More informationCHAPTER 8 ROAD SURFACE PROPERTIES
CHAPTER 8 ROAD SURFACE PROPERTIES 230 8.1 Introduction: The road user desires a road surface where he can drive safe and comfortable. This requires a pavement structure with enough stiffness, a fast run-off
More informationDESIGN OF CONTAINER YARD AT PORT OF BALBOA. Houston, TX 77077; PH (281) 940-6420; email: carlos.ospina@abam.com
DESIGN OF CONTAINER YARD AT PORT OF BALBOA Carlos E. Ospina, PhD, PE, MASCE; 1 Viswanath K. Kumar, PE, MASCE; 2 and Jorge Puente, PE, MASCE 3 1 Senior Project Engineer, BergerABAM, 2000 South Dairy Ashford
More informationAsphalt in Railway Tracks
Airfield uses of asphalt Asphalt in Railway Tracks Ref: (3)2-03-00.015 European Asphalt Pavement Association P.O. Box 175 3620 AD Breukelen, The Netherlands www.eapa.org info@eapa.org October 2003 2 Contents
More informationGuidelines for Durable Driveways, Carports Patios, Walks, Garage Floors
Guidelines for Durable Driveways, Carports Patios, Walks, Garage Floors The Right Concrete Mix Placing and Finishing Joints Correctly Spaced Curing for Durability "Concrete durability is the ability to
More informationHIGHWAYS DEPARTMENT GUIDANCE NOTES ON THE USE OF WATERPROOFING MEMBRANES ON CONCRETE BRIDGE DECKS
HIGHWAYS DEPARTMENT GUIDANCE NOTES ON THE USE OF WATERPROOFING MEMBRANES ON CONCRETE BRIDGE DECKS Research & Development Division RD/GN/033 June 2008 THE USE OF WATERPROOFING MEMBRANES ON CONCRETE BRIDGE
More informationSPECIFICATION FOR PIPE SUBSOIL DRAIN CONSTRUCTION
SPECIFICATION FOR PIPE SUBSOIL DRAIN CONSTRUCTION 1. SCOPE Pipe subsoil drains shall be constructed in accordance with this specification and in conformity with the lines, grades and cross-sections shown
More informationDesign and Construction of Roller-Compacted Concrete Pavements for Container Terminals. David R. Luhr PhD PE *
Design and Construction of Roller-Compacted Concrete Pavements for Container Terminals David R. Luhr PhD PE * Program Manager, Portland Cement Association, PO Box 5895, Cary, NC 27511; PH 919-462-0840;
More informationasphalt applications Construction and surfacing of footways and cycleways using asphalt mpa asphalt Asphalt Information Service
asphalt applications 11 Construction and surfacing of footways and cycleways using asphalt Asphalt Information Service mpa asphalt November 2009 Mineral Products Association Introduction The main use of
More informationLecture Notes CT 4860 Structural Pavement Design. Design of Flexible Pavements
Lecture Notes CT 4860 Structural Pavement Design Design of Flexible Pavements Prof.dr.ir. A.A.A. Molenaar Delft, March 2007 Table of contents Preface 3 1. Introduction 4 2. Major defect types in flexible
More informationDIVISION 300 BASES SECTION 304 AGGREGATE BASE COURSE DESCRIPTION MATERIALS CONSTRUCTION REQUIREMENTS
304.06 DIVISION 300 BASES SECTION 304 AGGREGATE BASE COURSE DESCRIPTION 304.01 This work consists of furnishing and placing one or more courses of aggregate and additives, if required, on a prepared subgrade.
More informationPavement Thickness. esign and RCC-Pave Software. Roller-Compacted Concrete Pavement: Design and Construction. October 24, 2006 Atlanta, Georgia
Roller-Compacted Concrete Pavement: Design and Construction Pavement Thickness esign and RCC-Pave Software Gregory E. Halsted, P.E. Pavements Engineer Portland Cement Association October 24, 2006 Atlanta,
More informationEvaluation of Cement Treated Base Courses
Evaluation of Cement Treated Base Courses Technical Assistance Report Number 00-1TA by Kevin J. Gaspard, P.E. Louisiana Transportation Research Center Louisiana Department of Transportation and Development
More information