ON THURSTONE'S MODEL FOR PAIRED COMPARISONS AND RANKING DATA


 Aldous Spencer Hill
 10 months ago
 Views:
Transcription
1 ON THUSTONE'S MODEL FO PAIED COMPAISONS AND ANKING DATA Alber MaydeuOlivares Dep. of Psychology. Universiy of Barcelona. Paseo Valle de Hebrón, Barcelona (Spain). Summary. We invesigae by means of a simulaion sudy wheher sandard srucural equaion modeling echniques are suiable for esimaing an unresriced Thursonian model o: (a) muliple judgmen paired comparisons daa, and (b) ranking daa. We poin ou ha Thursone's (197) original model is no a proper model for muliple judgmen paired comparisons daa as i assigns ero probabiliy o all inransiive paired comparisons paerns. To fi muliple judgmen paired comparisons daa one mus employ Takane's (1987) exension of Thursone's original model, or alernaively, a Thursonian correlaion srucure model, which we inroduce. We found ha for some models as few as 100 observaions suffice o obain accurae parameer esimaes, sandard errors and goodness of fi ess when 7 simuli are modeled (1 binary variables). For oher models, however, sample sies of 1000 observaions are needed. All in all, he procedure invesigaed appears o be an aracive choice o esimae hese models. Keywords: limied informaion, comparaive daa, random uiliy models. 1. Inroducion In 197 Thursone suggesed a class of models for fiing paired comparison daa ha has been highly influenial in he lieraure (see Bock & Jones, 1968). In 1931 Thursone suggesed his model could also be suiable for ranking daa (afer rankings are ransformed ino paired comparisons). Thursone's model is simply a mulivariae normal densiy wih an srucured mean vecor and covariance marix ha has been dichoomied. Thus, i is somewha naural o consider is esimaion using exising procedures for srucural equaion modeling for dichoomous variables (Muhén, 1978, 1993). In his paper we invesigae how well an unresriced Thursonian model for paired comparisons and ranking daa can be esimaed using srucural equaion modeling procedures for dichoomous variables. To do so, we firs inroduce Thursone's original model using marix noaion. Using his noaion, i is easy o see ha Thursone's original model is a proper model for ranking daa bu i is no a proper model for muliple judgmen paired comparisons daa. Nex, we 519
2 inroduce wo modificaions of Thursone's model ha address his problem. We conclude our presenaion wih some simulaion resuls o illusrae he performance of srucural equaion modeling procedures o esimae hese models.. Thursone's model Thursone (197) inroduced a model for paired comparisons characeried by hree assumpions: 1. Whenever a pair of simuli is presened o a subjec i elicis a coninuous preference (uiliy funcion, or in Thursone's erminology, discriminal process) for each simulus.. The simulus whose value is larger a he momen of he comparison will be preferred by he subjec. 3. These unobserved preferences are normally disribued in he populaion. We assume each individual from a random sample responds o all possible n( n 1) n = paired comparisons, where n denoes he number of simuli being compared. This has been ermed muliple judgmen sampling procedure (Bock & Jones, 1968). Thus, we obain a ñdimensional vecor of binary variables y from each responden such ha 1 if objec i is chosen yi, j= (1) 0 if objec j is chosen for all pairs {i, j}. Then, leing denoe he ndimensional vecor of coninuous ~ N µ, Σ, we wrie preferences in Thursone's model such ha ( ) y * = A, () where A is a ñ n design marix where each column corresponds o one of he simuli, and each row o one of he paired comparisons. For example, when n = 4, A is Finally, A =. (3)
3 y i, j 1 if yi, j 0 = 0 if yi, j< 0 (4) These equaions describe in marix noaion Thursone's (197) model applied o muliple judgmen sampling paired comparisons daa. To analye ranking daa, Thursone (1931) suggesed ransforming each ranking paern ino a vecor of ñ binary variables using 1 if objec i is ranked above objec j yi, j= (5) 0 if objec i is ranked below objec j and applying his model for paired comparisons daa o hese daa. Under Thursone's model he probabiliy of any paired comparisons paern is ( y µ * Σ * ) * * Pr yi, j = φn :, dy (6) y y i, j µ = A µ y * Σ * = AΣ y A (7) where φn ( ) denoes a ñvariae normal densiy funcion and is he mulidimensional recangular region formed by he produc of inervals i, j ( ) ( ) 0, if yi, j= 1 =. (8),0 if yi, j = 0 We can perform a change of variable of inegraion in (6) and sandardie y * using * * = D( y µ y * ) = ( Diag ( Σ * y )) As a resul, µ * = 0 and τ = µ = µ y * 1 D. (9) D DA Ρ = Σ = ( Σ ) D D D A A D (10) * * y where τ denoes a vecor of hresholds τ i,j, and he offdiagonal elemens of Ρ * are erachoric correlaions. As a resul, (6), can be equivalenly rewrien as where inervals * * Pr yi, j = n( :, Ρ * φ 0 ) d (11) i, j is now a mulidimensional recangular region formed by he produc of 51
4 i, j ( τ i j ) ( τ i j),, if yi, j= 1 =. (1),, if yi, j = 0 Equaions (10), (11), and (1) define in fac a class of models as µ and Σ can be resriced in various ways. Takane (1987) provides an excellen overview of resriced Thursonian models. Here we shall concenrae on he unresriced Thursonian model, a model where only minimal idenificaion resricions are imposed on µ and Σ. A very ineresing feaure of Thursone's original model is ha since A is of rank n  1, Σ * has rank n 1. As a resul, Thursone's model assigns ero probabiliies y o all he ñ  n! inransiive paired comparisons paerns (hose paerns ha do no correspond o ranking paerns). Thus, Thursone's model is no a plausible model for muliple judgmen paired comparisons daa, bu i may be a suiable model for ranking daa (MaydeuOlivares, 1999). 3. Thursonian models appropriae for muliple judgmen paired comparisons We now describe wo differen soluions o he problem of specifying a Thursonian model ha assigns nonero probabiliies o all ñ binary paerns. 3.1 The ThursoneTakane model Takane (1987) proposed adding a random error o each paired comparison so ha * = + y A e. Furhermore, he assumed ha N µ, Σ 0 e 0 0 Ω (13) where Ω is a diagonal marix wih elemens ω i, j. Under his model, he probabiliy of any paired comparisons paern is given also by (6) and (8) bu now µ * = A µ y and Σ * = AΣ y A + Ω. Furhermore, performing he change of variable of inegraion (9), we can wrie hese paern probabiliies as (11) and (1) where insead of (10) we have = DA Ρ * = ( Σ + Ω ) τ µ D A A D (14) Takane (1987) also proposed an ineresing special case of his model in which i is assumed ha Ω = ω I. 5
5 3. Thursonian correlaion srucure models The Thursone and ThursoneTakane models are mean and covariance srucure models in he sense ha hey impose consrains on he mean vecor and covariance marix of y *. However, as only he binary choices are observed, he covariance marix of y * can only be esimaed from a correlaion marix. Moreover, o esimae he parameers of hese models one mus resor o pre and posmuliply he covariance srucure by he inverse of a diagonal marix of modelbased sandard deviaions. This resuls in complex nonlinear resricions on he hresholds and erachoric correlaions. An alernaive soluion o he problem of specifying a proper model for muliple judgmen paired comparison daa wihin a Thursonian framework is o specify resricions on he means and correlaions of y * while leaving he srucure for he variances of y * unspecified. Now, he mean and covariance srucures for y * implied by Thursone's model are µ * = A µ y and Σ * = AΣ y A. Thus, we shall assume µ * = A µ y. Also, by parsimony we shall assume Ρ = Off ( AΣ ) y * A, where Off( ) denoes he resricions imposed on he offdiagonal elemens of a correlaion marix. Tha is, we assume ha he resricions on he correlaions among y * have he same funcional form as he resricions of Thursone's model on he covariances among y *. Then, he probabiliy of any paired comparisons paern under his Thursonian mean and correlaion srucure model is ( y µ * Ρ * ) n * * Pr yl = φn :, dy (15) y y l = 1 wih limis of inegraion (8). These paern probabiliies are unchanged when we ransform y * * * using = y µ y *. As a resul, µ * = 0 and = A Ρ ( Σ ) τ µ = Off A * A (16) where now he paern probabiliies are given by (11), (1) and (16). This model is more resricive han he ThursoneTakane model. However, unlike (14), he resricions in (16) are linear. 4. Limied informaion esimaion and esing We shall now discuss minimal idenificaion resricions for he models jus described. These minimal idenificaion resricions yield unresriced models. Given he comparaive naure of he daa, in all cases i is necessary o se he locaion of he elemens of µ and he locaion of he elemens in each of he rows (columns) of Σ. Arbirarily, we se µ n = 0 and Σ = Ρ (a marix wih ones along is diagonal). In addiion, in he Thursonian ranking model i is necessary o fix 53
6 one of he elemens of Ρ (Dansie, 1986). Arbirarily, we se ρ = nn, 1 0. Also, in he ThursoneTakane model, if Ω is assumed o be diagonal i is necessary o se he locaion for is elemens; arbirarily we se ωn = 1. Alernaively, if Ω = ω I is assumed, we impose he consrain ω = 1. Now, we collec he observed paired comparisons paerns in a ñway binary coningency able. We have seen ha he models under consideraion assume ha he coningency able arises by dichoomiing a ñdimensional mulivariae sandard normal densiy according o a se of hresholds while imposing consrains given by Eq. (10), (14), and (16) on he hresholds and erachoric correlaions. Muhén (1978, 1993) has proposed well esablished mehods for esimaing dichoomied mulivariae normal srucural models from he univariae and bivariae marginals of he coningency able. Here, we invesigae wheher Muhén's (1993) approach is suiable for hese ype of models by means of a simulaion sudy. In his esimaion procedure, firs each hreshold is esimaed separaely from he univariae marginals of he coningency able via. Then, each of he erachoric correlaions of he coningency able is esimaed separaely from he bivariae marginals of he coningency able given he esimaed hresholds. Finally, he model parameers are esimaed from he esimaed hresholds and erachoric correlaions using an unweighed leas squares (ULS) funcion. His mehod yields asympoically correc sandard errors and ess of he srucural resricions imposed by he model on he hresholds and erachoric correlaions. The laer are obained by adjusing he minimum of he ULS fiing funcion by is mean (T s ) or by is mean and variance (T a ). ecenly, MaydeuOlivares (001) has proposed a similar adjusmen o he sum of squared residuals o he univariae and bivariae margins of he able, which gives us a limied informaion es of he overall resricions imposed by he model on he coningency able. The degrees of freedom available for esing when fiing paired comparisons models is n ( n + 1) r = q, where q is he number of model parameers. When fiing ranking daa i is necessary o adjus for he number of redundancies among he n univariae and bivariae marginals which arise from having n! srucural empy cells in he coningency able. The number of degrees of freedom in his n ( n + 1 n 1 ) x case is r = q (MaydeuOlivares, 1999). x= We provide in Table 1 he simulaion resuls obained in esimaing a model for 7 simuli. Hence ñ = 1 binary variables were modeled. Sample sie was 500. The rue parameers were µ = ρ = ( 0.5,0, 0.5,0,0.5, 0.5,0 ), ( 0.8,0.7,0.6,0.8,0.7,0.6,,0.8,0.7,0.6) 54
7 where ρ denoes he elemens below he diagonal in Ρ. In he ThursoneTakane model where Ω was assumed o be diagonal, we used as rue values Ω = I replicaions were used for each of he hree models esimaed. In his able we poin ou he larges relaive bias (in %) observed in he parameer esimaes and sandard errors. We also provide he empirical rejecion raes for he es saisics a α = They should be as close as possible o Finally, we also provide he value of D KS, he KolmogorovSmirnov onesample es. The null hypohesis of a chisquare disribuion for he empirical disribuion of he es saisic is rejeced a α = 0.05 if D KS > As can be seen in his able, for his paricular choice of rue generaing values and sample sie: 1. The performance of he ess saisics considered depends on he model. In all cases he mean and variance adjused es saisics of overall resricions mached well is reference chisquare disribuion as indicaed by D KS.. Accurae parameer esimaes and sandard errors (larges relaive bias < 10 %) were obained for all models bu for he ThursoneTakane model when Ω is assumed o be diagonal. Table 1. Simulaion resuls model maximum relaive bias (%) D KS saisic ( a α = 0.05) par. esimaes sandard errors srucur. ess overall ess µ Ρ Ω µ Ρ Ω T s T a T s T a (A) Thursone's <1 < (13.9).3 (4.) 7.9 (6.3) 1. (6.4) (B) TT, Ω diagonal (5.5) 1.8 (.) 7.8 (3.0) 0.8 (5.6) (C) TT, Ω = ω I (6.1).1 (.4) 8.5 (5.) 0.9 (5.0) (D) correlaion sruc. <1 < (9.4). (3.8) 7.8 (4.6) 1.1 (4.3) In Thursone's model we fixed ρ 7,6 =.6 (he rue value) o calculae relaive bias Thursone's model was fied o ranking daa, he oher hree models o paired comparisons TT, ThursoneTakane model;, rejecion rae in %, should be close o Addiional simulaion sudies wih hese rue generaing values reveal ha accurae parameer esimaes, sandard errors and goodness of fi ess can be obained for model (B) wih 1000 observaions, wih model (A) wih 300 observaions, and wih models (C) and (D) wih as few as 100 observaions. 55
8 5. Discussion and conclusions Classical esimaion procedures for Thursonian models (e.g., Bock & Jones, 1968) esimae he model parameers using only he univariae means of he binary variables. These procedures are clearly unsaisfacory because: 1. The sample means are no independen. Sandard errors and ess of he goodness of fi of he model compued under an independence assumpion will be incorrec.. Unresriced Thursonian models and many resriced models are no idenified from univariae informaion only. However, any Thursonian model can be idenified as soon as bivariae informaion is employed. We have shown ha using univariae and bivariae informaion i is possible o obain accurae parameer esimaes, sandard errors and ess of goodness of fi o Thursonian models for paired comparisons and ranking daa wih very small samples, even in large models. We have also poined ou ha Thursone's original model is suiable for ranking daa, bu ha i is no a proper model for muliple judgmen paired comparisons daa. We have discussed wo classes of classes of Thursonian models suiable for hese daa: a correlaion srucure model, and a covariance srucure model (he ThursoneTakane model). These wo models are no equivalen because he ThursoneTakane model is no scale invarian. Alhough he choice beween a Thursonian covariance vs. a correlaion srucure model should be subsanively moivaed, i is also imporan o consider model fi and esimaion issues in choosing beween hese models. eferences Bock,.D. & Jones, L.V. (1968). The measuremen and predicion of judgmen and choice. San Francisco: HoldenDay. Dansie, B.. (1986) Normal order saisics as permuaion probabiliy models. Applied Saisics, 35, MaydeuOlivares, A. (1999). Thursonian modeling of ranking daa via mean and covariance srucure analysis. Psychomerika, 64, MaydeuOlivares, A. (001). Limied informaion esimaion and esing of Thursonian models for paired comparison daa under muliple judgmen sampling. Psychomerika, 66, Muhén, B. (1978). Conribuions o facor analysis of dichoomous variables. Psychomerika, 43, Muhén, B. (1993). Goodness of fi wih caegorical and oher non normal variables. In K.A. Bollen & J.S. Long [Eds.] Tesing srucural equaion models (pp ). Newbury Park, CA: Sage. Takane, Y. (1987). Analysis of covariance srucures and probabilisic binary choice daa. Communicaion and Cogniion, 0, Thursone, L.L. (197). A law of comparaive judgmen. Psychological eview, 79, Thursone, L.L. (1931). ank order as a psychological mehod. Journal of Experimenal Psychology, 14,
4. The Poisson Distribution
Virual Laboraories > 13. The Poisson Process > 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 4. The Poisson Disribuion The Probabiliy Densiy Funcion We have shown ha he k h arrival ime in he Poisson process has he gamma probabiliy densiy
More informationResearch Question Is the average body temperature of healthy adults 98.6 F? Introduction to Hypothesis Testing. Statistical Hypothesis
Inroducion o Hypohesis Tesing Research Quesion Is he average body emperaure of healhy aduls 98.6 F? HT  1 HT  2 Scienific Mehod 1. Sae research hypoheses or quesions. µ = 98.6? 2. Gaher daa or evidence
More informationEconomics 140A Hypothesis Testing in Regression Models
Economics 140A Hypohesis Tesing in Regression Models While i is algebraically simple o work wih a populaion model wih a single varying regressor, mos populaion models have muliple varying regressors 1
More informationTEMPORAL PATTERN IDENTIFICATION OF TIME SERIES DATA USING PATTERN WAVELETS AND GENETIC ALGORITHMS
TEMPORAL PATTERN IDENTIFICATION OF TIME SERIES DATA USING PATTERN WAVELETS AND GENETIC ALGORITHMS RICHARD J. POVINELLI AND XIN FENG Deparmen of Elecrical and Compuer Engineering Marquee Universiy, P.O.
More informationFakultet for informasjonsteknologi, Institutt for matematiske fag
Page 1 of 5 NTNU Noregs eknisknaurviskaplege universie Fakule for informasjonseknologi, maemaikk og elekroeknikk Insiu for maemaiske fag  English Conac during exam: John Tyssedal 73593534/41645376 Exam
More informationLecture 18. Serial correlation: testing and estimation. Testing for serial correlation
Lecure 8. Serial correlaion: esing and esimaion Tesing for serial correlaion In lecure 6 we used graphical mehods o look for serial/auocorrelaion in he random error erm u. Because we canno observe he u
More informationCointegration: The Engle and Granger approach
Coinegraion: The Engle and Granger approach Inroducion Generally one would find mos of he economic variables o be nonsaionary I(1) variables. Hence, any equilibrium heories ha involve hese variables require
More informationAn empirical analysis about forecasting Tmall airconditioning sales using time series model Yan Xia
An empirical analysis abou forecasing Tmall aircondiioning sales using ime series model Yan Xia Deparmen of Mahemaics, Ocean Universiy of China, China Absrac Time series model is a hospo in he research
More informationANALYSIS AND COMPARISONS OF SOME SOLUTION CONCEPTS FOR STOCHASTIC PROGRAMMING PROBLEMS
ANALYSIS AND COMPARISONS OF SOME SOLUTION CONCEPTS FOR STOCHASTIC PROGRAMMING PROBLEMS R. Caballero, E. Cerdá, M. M. Muñoz and L. Rey () Deparmen of Applied Economics (Mahemaics), Universiy of Málaga,
More informationMultiple Structural Breaks in the Nominal Interest Rate and Inflation in Canada and the United States
Deparmen of Economics Discussion Paper 0007 Muliple Srucural Breaks in he Nominal Ineres Rae and Inflaion in Canada and he Unied Saes Frank J. Akins, Universiy of Calgary Preliminary Draf February, 00
More informationINVESTIGATION OF THE INFLUENCE OF UNEMPLOYMENT ON ECONOMIC INDICATORS
INVESTIGATION OF THE INFLUENCE OF UNEMPLOYMENT ON ECONOMIC INDICATORS Ilona Tregub, Olga Filina, Irina Kondakova Financial Universiy under he Governmen of he Russian Federaion 1. Phillips curve In economics,
More informationThe General Method of Moments (GMM) using MATLAB: The practical guide based on the CKLS interest rate model
The General Mehod of Momens (GMM) using MATLAB: The pracical guide based on he CKLS ineres rae model Kamil Kladívko 1 Deparmen of Saisics and Probabiliy Calculus, Universiy of Economics, Prague kladivk@vse.cz
More informationA Note on Using the Svensson procedure to estimate the risk free rate in corporate valuation
A Noe on Using he Svensson procedure o esimae he risk free rae in corporae valuaion By Sven Arnold, Alexander Lahmann and Bernhard Schwezler Ocober 2011 1. The risk free ineres rae in corporae valuaion
More informationJournal Of Business & Economics Research September 2005 Volume 3, Number 9
Opion Pricing And Mone Carlo Simulaions George M. Jabbour, (Email: jabbour@gwu.edu), George Washingon Universiy YiKang Liu, (yikang@gwu.edu), George Washingon Universiy ABSTRACT The advanage of Mone Carlo
More informationA dynamic probabilistic modeling of railway switches operating states
A dynamic probabilisic modeling of railway swiches operaing saes Faicel Chamroukhi 1, Allou Samé 1, Parice Aknin 1, Marc Anoni 2 1 IFSTTAR, 2 rue de la Bue Vere, 93166 NoisyleGrand Cedex, France {chamroukhi,same,aknin}@ifsar.fr
More informationMTH6121 Introduction to Mathematical Finance Lesson 5
26 MTH6121 Inroducion o Mahemaical Finance Lesson 5 Conens 2.3 Brownian moion wih drif........................... 27 2.4 Geomeric Brownian moion........................... 28 2.5 Convergence of random
More informationTime variant processes in failure probability calculations
Time varian processes in failure probabiliy calculaions A. Vrouwenvelder (TUDelf/TNO, The Neherlands) 1. Inroducion Acions on srucures as well as srucural properies are usually no consan, bu will vary
More informationChapter 4. Properties of the Least Squares Estimators. Assumptions of the Simple Linear Regression Model. SR3. var(e t ) = σ 2 = var(y t )
Chaper 4 Properies of he Leas Squares Esimaors Assumpions of he Simple Linear Regression Model SR1. SR. y = β 1 + β x + e E(e ) = 0 E[y ] = β 1 + β x SR3. var(e ) = σ = var(y ) SR4. cov(e i, e j ) = cov(y
More informationVector Autoregressions (VARs): Operational Perspectives
Vecor Auoregressions (VARs): Operaional Perspecives Primary Source: Sock, James H., and Mark W. Wason, Vecor Auoregressions, Journal of Economic Perspecives, Vol. 15 No. 4 (Fall 2001), 101115. Macroeconomericians
More informationRenewal processes and Poisson process
CHAPTER 3 Renewal processes and Poisson process 31 Definiion of renewal processes and limi heorems Le ξ 1, ξ 2, be independen and idenically disribued random variables wih P[ξ k > 0] = 1 Define heir parial
More informationChapter 7: Estimating the Variance of an Estimate s Probability Distribution
Chaper 7: Esimaing he Variance of an Esimae s Probabiliy Disribuion Chaper 7 Ouline Review o Clin s Assignmen o General Properies of he Ordinary Leas Squares (OLS) Esimaion Procedure o Imporance of he
More informationMeasuring macroeconomic volatility Applications to export revenue data, 19702005
FONDATION POUR LES ETUDES ET RERS LE DEVELOPPEMENT INTERNATIONAL Measuring macroeconomic volailiy Applicaions o expor revenue daa, 1970005 by Joël Cariolle Policy brief no. 47 March 01 The FERDI is a
More informationChapter 8: Regression with Lagged Explanatory Variables
Chaper 8: Regression wih Lagged Explanaory Variables Time series daa: Y for =1,..,T End goal: Regression model relaing a dependen variable o explanaory variables. Wih ime series new issues arise: 1. One
More informationFourier Series Solution of the Heat Equation
Fourier Series Soluion of he Hea Equaion Physical Applicaion; he Hea Equaion In he early nineeenh cenury Joseph Fourier, a French scienis and mahemaician who had accompanied Napoleon on his Egypian campaign,
More informationA Robust Exponentially Weighted Moving Average Control Chart for the Process Mean
Journal of Modern Applied Saisical Mehods Volume 5 Issue Aricle 005 A Robus Exponenially Weighed Moving Average Conrol Char for he Process Mean Michael B. C. Khoo Universii Sains, Malaysia, mkbc@usm.my
More informationChapter 8 Student Lecture Notes 81
Chaper Suden Lecure Noes  Chaper Goals QM: Business Saisics Chaper Analyzing and Forecasing Series Daa Afer compleing his chaper, you should be able o: Idenify he componens presen in a ime series Develop
More informationCointegration Analysis of Exchange Rate in Foreign Exchange Market
Coinegraion Analysis of Exchange Rae in Foreign Exchange Marke Wang Jian, Wang Shuli School of Economics, Wuhan Universiy of Technology, P.R.China, 430074 Absrac: This paper educed ha he series of exchange
More informationLecture 12 Assumption Violation: Autocorrelation
Major Topics: Definiion Lecure 1 Assumpion Violaion: Auocorrelaion Daa Relaionship Represenaion Problem Deecion Remedy Page 1.1 Our Usual Roadmap Parial View Expansion of Esimae and Tes Model Sep Analyze
More informationGraphing the Von Bertalanffy Growth Equation
file: d:\b1732013\von_beralanffy.wpd dae: Sepember 23, 2013 Inroducion Graphing he Von Beralanffy Growh Equaion Previously, we calculaed regressions of TL on SL for fish size daa and ploed he daa and
More informationImpact of Debt on Primary Deficit and GSDP Gap in Odisha: Empirical Evidences
S.R. No. 002 10/2015/CEFT Impac of Deb on Primary Defici and GSDP Gap in Odisha: Empirical Evidences 1. Inroducion The excessive pressure of public expendiure over is revenue receip is financed hrough
More informationDYNAMIC ECONOMETRIC MODELS Vol. 7 Nicolaus Copernicus University Toruń 2006. Ryszard Doman Adam Mickiewicz University in Poznań
DYNAMIC ECONOMETRIC MODELS Vol. 7 Nicolaus Copernicus Universiy Toruń 26 1. Inroducion Adam Mickiewicz Universiy in Poznań Measuring Condiional Dependence of Polish Financial Reurns Idenificaion of condiional
More informationRepresenting Periodic Functions by Fourier Series. (a n cos nt + b n sin nt) n=1
Represening Periodic Funcions by Fourier Series 3. Inroducion In his Secion we show how a periodic funcion can be expressed as a series of sines and cosines. We begin by obaining some sandard inegrals
More informationCOMPUTATION OF CENTILES AND ZSCORES FOR HEIGHTFORAGE, WEIGHTFORAGE AND BMIFORAGE
COMPUTATION OF CENTILES AND ZSCORES FOR HEIGHTFORAGE, WEIGHTFORAGE AND BMIFORAGE The mehod used o consruc he 2007 WHO references relied on GAMLSS wih he BoxCox power exponenial disribuion (Rigby
More informationDYNAMIC MODELS FOR VALUATION OF WRONGFUL DEATH PAYMENTS
DYNAMIC MODELS FOR VALUATION OF WRONGFUL DEATH PAYMENTS Hong Mao, Shanghai Second Polyechnic Universiy Krzyszof M. Osaszewski, Illinois Sae Universiy Youyu Zhang, Fudan Universiy ABSTRACT Liigaion, exper
More informationChapter 7. Response of FirstOrder RL and RC Circuits
Chaper 7. esponse of FirsOrder L and C Circuis 7.1. The Naural esponse of an L Circui 7.2. The Naural esponse of an C Circui 7.3. The ep esponse of L and C Circuis 7.4. A General oluion for ep and Naural
More informationThe naive method discussed in Lecture 1 uses the most recent observations to forecast future values. That is, Y ˆ t + 1
Business Condiions & Forecasing Exponenial Smoohing LECTURE 2 MOVING AVERAGES AND EXPONENTIAL SMOOTHING OVERVIEW This lecure inroduces imeseries smoohing forecasing mehods. Various models are discussed,
More informationPROFIT TEST MODELLING IN LIFE ASSURANCE USING SPREADSHEETS PART TWO
Profi Tes Modelling in Life Assurance Using Spreadshees, par wo PROFIT TEST MODELLING IN LIFE ASSURANCE USING SPREADSHEETS PART TWO Erik Alm Peer Millingon Profi Tes Modelling in Life Assurance Using Spreadshees,
More informationHouse Price Index (HPI)
House Price Index (HPI) The price index of second hand houses in Colombia (HPI), regisers annually and quarerly he evoluion of prices of his ype of dwelling. The calculaion is based on he repeaed sales
More informationGLAS Team Member Quarterly Report. June , Golden, Colorado (Colorado School of Mines)
GLAS Team ember Quarerly Repor An Nguyen, Thomas A Herring assachuses Insiue of Technology Period: 04/01/2004 o 06/30//2004 eeings aended Tom Herring aended he eam meeing near GSFC a he end of June, 2004.
More informationRelative velocity in one dimension
Connexions module: m13618 1 Relaive velociy in one dimension Sunil Kumar Singh This work is produced by The Connexions Projec and licensed under he Creaive Commons Aribuion License Absrac All quaniies
More informationIssues Using OLS with Time Series Data. Time series data NOT randomly sampled in same way as cross sectional each obs not i.i.d
These noes largely concern auocorrelaion Issues Using OLS wih Time Series Daa Recall main poins from Chaper 10: Time series daa NOT randomly sampled in same way as cross secional each obs no i.i.d Why?
More informationForecasting Malaysian Gold Using. GARCH Model
Applied Mahemaical Sciences, Vol. 7, 2013, no. 58, 28792884 HIKARI Ld, www.mhikari.com Forecasing Malaysian Gold Using GARCH Model Pung Yean Ping 1, Nor Hamizah Miswan 2 and Maizah Hura Ahmad 3 Deparmen
More informationThomas G. Stephan*, Raimond Maurer** and Martin Dürr* *) Deutscher Investment Trust (DIT),Frankfurt/Main
A Muliple Facor Model for European Socks Thomas G. Sephan*, Raimond Maurer** and Marin Dürr* *) Deuscher Invesmen Trus (DIT),Frankfur/Main **) Johann Wolfgang Goehe Universiy of Frankfur/Main, Chair for
More informationA Probability Density Function for Google s stocks
A Probabiliy Densiy Funcion for Google s socks V.Dorobanu Physics Deparmen, Poliehnica Universiy of Timisoara, Romania Absrac. I is an approach o inroduce he Fokker Planck equaion as an ineresing naural
More informationThe Transport Equation
The Transpor Equaion Consider a fluid, flowing wih velociy, V, in a hin sraigh ube whose cross secion will be denoed by A. Suppose he fluid conains a conaminan whose concenraion a posiion a ime will be
More informationSupplementary Appendix for Depression Babies: Do Macroeconomic Experiences Affect RiskTaking?
Supplemenary Appendix for Depression Babies: Do Macroeconomic Experiences Affec RiskTaking? Ulrike Malmendier UC Berkeley and NBER Sefan Nagel Sanford Universiy and NBER Sepember 2009 A. Deails on SCF
More informationTEACHER NOTES HIGH SCHOOL SCIENCE NSPIRED
Radioacive Daing Science Objecives Sudens will discover ha radioacive isoopes decay exponenially. Sudens will discover ha each radioacive isoope has a specific halflife. Sudens will develop mahemaical
More informationTesting the linearity of a time series. Some Monte Carlo and Empirical Tests
Tesing he lineariy of a ime series. Some Mone Carlo and Empirical Tess By Efsraios Tserkezos (Corresponding auhor). Mahemaical Modelling in new Technologies and Economy Posgraduae Programme. Applied Mahemaics
More informationPermutations and Combinations
Permuaions and Combinaions Combinaorics Copyrigh Sandards 006, Tes  ANSWERS Barry Mabillard. 0 www.mah0s.com 1. Deermine he middle erm in he expansion of ( a b) To ge he kvalue for he middle erm, divide
More informationStatistical Analysis with Little s Law. Supplementary Material: More on the Call Center Data. by SongHee Kim and Ward Whitt
Saisical Analysis wih Lile s Law Supplemenary Maerial: More on he Call Cener Daa by SongHee Kim and Ward Whi Deparmen of Indusrial Engineering and Operaions Research Columbia Universiy, New York, NY 1799
More informationSPEC model selection algorithm for ARCH models: an options pricing evaluation framework
Applied Financial Economics Leers, 2008, 4, 419 423 SEC model selecion algorihm for ARCH models: an opions pricing evaluaion framework Savros Degiannakis a, * and Evdokia Xekalaki a,b a Deparmen of Saisics,
More informationA Reexamination of the Joint Mortality Functions
Norh merican cuarial Journal Volume 6, Number 1, p.166170 (2002) Reeaminaion of he Join Morali Funcions bsrac. Heekung Youn, rkad Shemakin, Edwin Herman Universi of S. Thomas, Sain Paul, MN, US Morali
More informationThe Relationship between Stock Return Volatility and. Trading Volume: The case of The Philippines*
The Relaionship beween Sock Reurn Volailiy and Trading Volume: The case of The Philippines* Manabu Asai Faculy of Economics Soka Universiy Angelo Unie Economics Deparmen De La Salle Universiy Manila May
More informationMathematics in Pharmacokinetics What and Why (A second attempt to make it clearer)
Mahemaics in Pharmacokineics Wha and Why (A second aemp o make i clearer) We have used equaions for concenraion () as a funcion of ime (). We will coninue o use hese equaions since he plasma concenraions
More informationMath 201 Lecture 12: CauchyEuler Equations
Mah 20 Lecure 2: CauchyEuler Equaions Feb., 202 Many examples here are aken from he exbook. The firs number in () refers o he problem number in he UA Cusom ediion, he second number in () refers o he problem
More informationCHARGE AND DISCHARGE OF A CAPACITOR
REFERENCES RC Circuis: Elecrical Insrumens: Mos Inroducory Physics exs (e.g. A. Halliday and Resnick, Physics ; M. Sernheim and J. Kane, General Physics.) This Laboraory Manual: Commonly Used Insrumens:
More informationThe option pricing framework
Chaper 2 The opion pricing framework The opion markes based on swap raes or he LIBOR have become he larges fixed income markes, and caps (floors) and swapions are he mos imporan derivaives wihin hese markes.
More informationMortality Variance of the Present Value (PV) of Future Annuity Payments
Morali Variance of he Presen Value (PV) of Fuure Annui Pamens Frank Y. Kang, Ph.D. Research Anals a Frank Russell Compan Absrac The variance of he presen value of fuure annui pamens plas an imporan role
More informationPart 1: White Noise and Moving Average Models
Chaper 3: Forecasing From Time Series Models Par 1: Whie Noise and Moving Average Models Saionariy In his chaper, we sudy models for saionary ime series. A ime series is saionary if is underlying saisical
More informationINDEPENDENT MARGINALS OF OPERATOR LÉVY S PROBABILITY MEASURES ON FINITE DIMENSIONAL VECTOR SPACES
Journal of Applied Analysis 1, 1 (1995), pp. 39 45 INDEPENDENT MARGINALS OF OPERATOR LÉVY S PROBABILITY MEASURES ON FINITE DIMENSIONAL VECTOR SPACES A. LUCZAK Absrac. We find exponens of independen marginals
More informationValue at Risk part II. Weighted Historical Simulation. BRW Approach. HW Approach
Value a Risk par II Weighed Hisorical Simulaion Chuang I  Yuan Deparmen of Finance, NCCU Weighed Hisorical Simulaion 3 BRW Approach 4 Boudoukh, Richardson and Whielaw (Risk, 998) Hull and Whie (JR, 998)
More informationA Brief Introduction to the Consumption Based Asset Pricing Model (CCAPM)
A Brief Inroducion o he Consumpion Based Asse Pricing Model (CCAPM We have seen ha CAPM idenifies he risk of any securiy as he covariance beween he securiy's rae of reurn and he rae of reurn on he marke
More informationA Generalized Bivariate OrnsteinUhlenbeck Model for Financial Assets
A Generalized Bivariae OrnseinUhlenbeck Model for Financial Asses Romy Krämer, Mahias Richer Technische Universiä Chemniz, Fakulä für Mahemaik, 917 Chemniz, Germany Absrac In his paper, we sudy mahemaical
More information4.8 Exponential Growth and Decay; Newton s Law; Logistic Growth and Decay
324 CHAPTER 4 Exponenial and Logarihmic Funcions 4.8 Exponenial Growh and Decay; Newon s Law; Logisic Growh and Decay OBJECTIVES 1 Find Equaions of Populaions Tha Obey he Law of Uninhibied Growh 2 Find
More informationComplex Fourier Series. Adding these identities, and then dividing by 2, or subtracting them, and then dividing by 2i, will show that
Mah 344 May 4, Complex Fourier Series Par I: Inroducion The Fourier series represenaion for a funcion f of period P, f) = a + a k coskω) + b k sinkω), ω = π/p, ) can be expressed more simply using complex
More informationWATER MIST FIRE PROTECTION RELIABILITY ANALYSIS
WATER MIST FIRE PROTECTION RELIABILITY ANALYSIS Shuzhen Xu Research Risk and Reliabiliy Area FM Global Norwood, Massachuses 262, USA David Fuller Engineering Sandards FM Global Norwood, Massachuses 262,
More informationState Machines: Brief Introduction to Sequencers Prof. Andrew J. Mason, Michigan State University
Inroducion ae Machines: Brief Inroducion o equencers Prof. Andrew J. Mason, Michigan ae Universiy A sae machine models behavior defined by a finie number of saes (unique configuraions), ransiions beween
More informationStability. Coefficients may change over time. Evolution of the economy Policy changes
Sabiliy Coefficiens may change over ime Evoluion of he economy Policy changes Time Varying Parameers y = α + x β + Coefficiens depend on he ime period If he coefficiens vary randomly and are unpredicable,
More informationExponentially Weighted Moving Average Control Charts with TimeVarying Control Limits and Fast Initial Response
Exponenially Weighed Moving Average Conrol Chars wih TimeVarying Conrol Limis and Fas Iniial Response Sefan H. Seiner Dep. of Saisics and Acuarial Sciences Universiy of Waerloo Waerloo, Onario N2L 3G1
More information... t t t k kt t. We assume that there are observations covering n periods of time. Autocorrelation (also called
Supplemen 13B: DurbinWason Tes for Auocorrelaion Modeling Auocorrelaion Because auocorrelaion is primarily a phenomenon of ime series daa, i is convenien o represen he linear regression model using as
More informationKernfachkombinationen: Investmentanalyse. Portfoliomanagement (Volatility Prediction)
Kernfachkombinaionen: Invesmenanalyse Porfoliomanagemen (Volailiy Predicion) O. Univ.Prof. Dr. Engelber J. Dockner Insiu für Beriebswirschafslehre Universiä Wien A0 Brünnersrasse 7 Tel.: [43] () 4773805
More informationSupply Chain Management Using Simulation Optimization By Miheer Kulkarni
Supply Chain Managemen Using Simulaion Opimizaion By Miheer Kulkarni This problem was inspired by he paper by Jung, Blau, Pekny, Reklaii and Eversdyk which deals wih supply chain managemen for he chemical
More informationA Note on the Impact of Options on Stock Return Volatility. Nicolas P.B. Bollen
A Noe on he Impac of Opions on Sock Reurn Volailiy Nicolas P.B. Bollen ABSTRACT This paper measures he impac of opion inroducions on he reurn variance of underlying socks. Pas research generally finds
More informationMarkov Models and Hidden Markov Models (HMMs)
Markov Models and Hidden Markov Models (HMMs (Following slides are modified from Prof. Claire Cardie s slides and Prof. Raymond Mooney s slides. Some of he graphs are aken from he exbook. Markov Model
More information1. The Currency Composition of Foreign Reserves
Inroducion Cenral banks hold foreign reserves o faciliae inernaional rade and as a mean of financing exchange rae inervenions in he foreign exchange marke. Reserves can herefore be hough of as a buffer
More informationChapter 6. First Order PDEs. 6.1 Characteristics The Simplest Case. u(x,t) t=1 t=2. t=0. Suppose u(x, t) satisfies the PDE.
Chaper 6 Firs Order PDEs 6.1 Characerisics 6.1.1 The Simples Case Suppose u(, ) saisfies he PDE where b, c are consan. au + bu = 0 If a = 0, he PDE is rivial (i says ha u = 0 and so u = f(). If a = 0,
More informationExample: scheduling using EDF
EDA/DIT6 RealTime Sysems, Chalmers/GU, 0/0 ecure #4 Updaed February, 0 RealTime Sysems Specificaion Implemenaion Dynamic scheduling  Earliesdeadlinefirs scheduling Processordemand analysis Verificaion
More informationRC Circuit and Time Constant
ircui and Time onsan 8M Objec: Apparaus: To invesigae he volages across he resisor and capacior in a resisorcapacior circui ( circui) as he capacior charges and discharges. We also wish o deermine he
More information11/6/2013. Chapter 14: Dynamic ADAS. Introduction. Introduction. Keeping track of time. The model s elements
Inroducion Chaper 14: Dynamic DS dynamic model of aggregae and aggregae supply gives us more insigh ino how he economy works in he shor run. I is a simplified version of a DSGE model, used in cuingedge
More informationMultiFactor CoxIngersollRoss Models of the Term Structure: Estimates and Tests From a Kalman Filter Model. RenRaw Chen* and Louis Scott**
MuliFacor CoxIngersollRoss Models of he Term Srucure: Esimaes and Tess From a Kalman Filer Model By RenRaw Chen* and Louis Sco** July 993 Revised July 995 Revised Ocober 998 Revised February 00 Revised
More informationPRICING OF ZEROCOUPON AND COUPON CAT BONDS
APPLICATIONES MATHEMATICAE 3,3 (23), pp. 35 324 Krzyszof Burnecki (Wrocław) Grzegorz Kukla (Wrocław) PRICING OF ZEROCOUPON AND COUPON CAT BONDS Absrac. We apply he resuls of Baryshnikov, Mayo and Taylor
More informationRESTRICTIONS IN REGRESSION MODEL
RESTRICTIONS IN REGRESSION MODEL Seema Jaggi and N. Sivaramane IASRI, Library Avenue, New Delhi11001 seema@iasri.res.in; sivaramane@iasri.res.in Regression analysis is used o esablish a relaionship via
More information3 RungeKutta Methods
3 RungeKua Mehods In conras o he mulisep mehods of he previous secion, RungeKua mehods are singlesep mehods however, muliple sages per sep. They are moivaed by he dependence of he Taylor mehods on he
More information4 Convolution. Recommended Problems. x2[n] 1 2[n]
4 Convoluion Recommended Problems P4.1 This problem is a simple example of he use of superposiion. Suppose ha a discreeime linear sysem has oupus y[n] for he given inpus x[n] as shown in Figure P4.11.
More informationA Simplified Model for Evaluating Software Reliability at the Developmental Stage
A Simplified Model for Evaluaing Sofware Reliabiliy a he Developmenal Sage Shelbi Joseph Division of Informaion Technology School of Engineering Cochin Universiy of Science and Technology Cochin, India
More informationUse SeDuMi to Solve LP, SDP and SCOP Problems: Remarks and Examples*
Use SeDuMi o Solve LP, SDP and SCOP Problems: Remarks and Examples* * his file was prepared by WuSheng Lu, Dep. of Elecrical and Compuer Engineering, Universiy of Vicoria, and i was revised on December,
More informationShapebased Similarity Query for Trajectory of Mobile Objects
1 Shapebased Similariy Query for Trajecory of Mobile Objecs uaka anagisawa Junichi Akahani Tesuji Saoh NTT Communicaion Science Laboraories, NTT Corporaion {yuaka,akahani,saoh}@cslab.kecl.n.co.jp hp://www.kecl.n.co.jp/scl/sirg/
More information6.5. Modelling Exercises. Introduction. Prerequisites. Learning Outcomes
Modelling Exercises 6.5 Inroducion This Secion provides examples and asks employing exponenial funcions and logarihmic funcions, such as growh and decay models which are imporan hroughou science and engineering.
More informationDIFFERENCING AND UNIT ROOT TESTS
DIFFERENCING AND UNIT ROOT TESTS In he BoxJenkins approach o analyzing ime series, a key quesion is wheher o difference he daa, i.e., o replace he raw daa {x } by he differenced series {x x }. Experience
More informationYTM is positively related to default risk. YTM is positively related to liquidity risk. YTM is negatively related to special tax treatment.
. Two quesions for oday. A. Why do bonds wih he same ime o mauriy have differen YTM s? B. Why do bonds wih differen imes o mauriy have differen YTM s? 2. To answer he firs quesion les look a he risk srucure
More informationEmergence of FokkerPlanck Dynamics within a Closed Finite Spin System
Emergence of FokkerPlanck Dynamics wihin a Closed Finie Spin Sysem H. Niemeyer(*), D. Schmidke(*), J. Gemmer(*), K. Michielsen(**), H. de Raed(**) (*)Universiy of Osnabrück, (**) Supercompuing Cener Juelich
More informationEconometrica Supplementary Material
Economerica Supplemenary Maerial SUPPLEMENT TO INFERRING LABOR INCOME RISK AND PARTIAL INSURANCE FROM ECONOMIC CHOICES : APPENDIXES (Economerica, Vol. 82, No. 6, November 2014, 2085 2129) BY FATIH GUVENEN
More informationDensity Dependence. births are a decreasing function of density b(n) and deaths are an increasing function of density d(n).
FW 662 Densiydependen populaion models In he previous lecure we considered densiy independen populaion models ha assumed ha birh and deah raes were consan and no a funcion of populaion size. Longerm
More informationTheoretical Analysis of Inverse Weibull Distribution
Theoreical Analysis of Inverse Weibull Disribuion M. SUAIB KAN Deparmen of saisics The Islamia universiy of Bahawalpur. email: skn_8@yahoo.com G.R PASA Deparmen of saisics Bahauddin Zakariya Universiy
More information2.5 Life tables, force of mortality and standard life insurance products
Soluions 5 BS4a Acuarial Science Oford MT 212 33 2.5 Life ables, force of moraliy and sandard life insurance producs 1. (i) n m q represens he probabiliy of deah of a life currenly aged beween ages + n
More informationModeling VIX Futures and Pricing VIX Options in the Jump Diusion Modeling
Modeling VIX Fuures and Pricing VIX Opions in he Jump Diusion Modeling Faemeh Aramian Maseruppsas i maemaisk saisik Maser hesis in Mahemaical Saisics Maseruppsas 2014:2 Maemaisk saisik April 2014 www.mah.su.se
More informationWorking Paper No. 482. Net Intergenerational Transfers from an Increase in Social Security Benefits
Working Paper No. 482 Ne Inergeneraional Transfers from an Increase in Social Securiy Benefis By Li Gan Texas A&M and NBER Guan Gong Shanghai Universiy of Finance and Economics Michael Hurd RAND Corporaion
More informationThe Greek financial crisis: growing imbalances and sovereign spreads. Heather D. Gibson, Stephan G. Hall and George S. Tavlas
The Greek financial crisis: growing imbalances and sovereign spreads Heaher D. Gibson, Sephan G. Hall and George S. Tavlas The enry The enry of Greece ino he Eurozone in 2001 produced a dividend in he
More informationPrincipal components of stock market dynamics. Methodology and applications in brief (to be updated ) Andrei Bouzaev, bouzaev@ya.
Principal componens of sock marke dynamics Mehodology and applicaions in brief o be updaed Andrei Bouzaev, bouzaev@ya.ru Why principal componens are needed Objecives undersand he evidence of more han one
More informationNovelty and Collective Attention
ovely and Collecive Aenion Fang Wu and Bernardo A. Huberman Informaion Dynamics Laboraory HP Labs Palo Alo, CA 9434 Absrac The subjec of collecive aenion is cenral o an informaion age where millions of
More information