1 The Role of Quality Evaluation in Seed Production as Exemplified by Soybean Seed Production Francisco Carlos Krzyzanowski, Ph.D. Embrapa Soybean
2 SEED CERTIFICATION SYSTEM STANDARDS To reach them, several parameters should be followed such as: Genetic and Physical Purity Physiological Quality Seed Health All this three parameters require a very good Seed Testing Laboratory (Personnel and Equipment).
3 Genetic Purity It is the basis to reach high cultivar quality in seed production.
4 Soybean Breeder Seed Basic steps 1. Selection of typical plants of the required breeding line or cultivar in a field plot seeded for this purpose, known as: plant selection block PSB. 2. Usually for soybean the PSB is composed by 8 lines of 12 meters length.
5 Plant Selection Block PSB
6 Plant Selection Usually 400 to 500 plants are selected based on agronomic standard such as: plant height, cycle, leaf format, pubescence and pod colors at the time of maturity.
7 Each plant is threshed individually and its seeds are kept in individual bag. The seeds are evaluated for the following characteristics (genetic descriptor): seed colour, size and format, hilum colour, shape and peroxidase activity. Any atypical plant (seed bag) is discarded..
8 Seed colour
9 Seed size and format
10 Hilum colour
11 Hilum colour seeds from same soybean plant
12 Soybean Breeder Seed Basic steps 3. Progeny line Seeds coming from each selected plant gives origin to one Progeny Line. 40 seeds are sown in a single row of 3 meters length. A total of 300 or 400 lines spaced 0,5 meter wide is the first stage of breeder seed production. All plants are evaluated according to agronomic characteristics of line or cultivar.
13 Progeny line
14 Soybean Breeder Seed Basic steps 3. Progeny line Seeds coming from each selected plant gives origin to one Progeny Line. 40 seeds are sown in a single row of 3 meters length. A total of 300 or 400 lines spaced 0,5 meter wide is the first stage of breeder seed production. All plants are evaluated according to agronomic characteristics of line or cultivar. A line with any atypical plant is discarded.
15 Basic steps Soybean Breeder Seed 3. Progeny line Each approved line is harvested and threshed individually and seeds are evaluated again for genetic characteristics as previously described.
16 Soybean Breeder Seed Basic steps 3. Progeny block Each line gives origin to one Progeny block. In each block are sown 4 lines of 25 meters length spaced every 0,5 meter between them. The remaining seeds of each line are combined to form a bulk and are seeded around the area occupied by the blocks, for purpose of comparing the blocks for plant cycle, height due to soil effect (fertility).
17 Progeny Block
18 Soybean Breeder Seed Basic steps 3. Progeny block If there is some variation in the block for the traits such as: cycle, colour of flower and pubescence, plant height, leaf format, the whole block is discarded.
19 Soybean Breeder Seed Basic steps 3. Progeny block The homogeneous blocks which are considered identical are harvested and threshed individually, their seeds are again compared among the different blocks, based on morphological parameters (genetic descriptor).
20 Soybean Breeder Seed Basic steps 3. Progeny block / genetic seeds Genetic seeds are originated from joining of the homogeneous and identical progeny blocks.
21 Soybean Breeder Seed Peroxidase Activity Another resource to be used in conjunction with morphological traits is the Peroxidase Activity Test. The peroxidase enzyme occurs in most living tissues. It is widely distributed in the plant kingdom, being related to:
22 Soybean Breeder Seed Peroxidase Enzyme 1. Regulating the level of Indol Acetic Acid (IAA), 2. Mechanisms of resistance to diseases, 3. Regulation of membrane permeability, 4. Cell wall formation, 5. Seed dormancy when involved in controlling the entry of oxygen.
23 Soybean Breeder Seed Peroxidase Enzyme The action of peroxidase enzyme in the seed coat of soybean seed can divide the lines and cultivars into two groups with high activity, designated as positive reaction, and low activity, characterized as negative reaction.
24 Soybean Breeder Seed Peroxidase Test Test procedure For each line or cultivar, eight repetitions of one seed is used. Remove one slice of the seed coat, being careful not to let any fragment of the embryonic axis or cotyledons adhere to it, and place it in a test tube along with 10 drops of a 5% solution of Guaiacol.
25 Soybean Breeder Seed Peroxidase Test Test procedure After 10 minutes add one drop of hydrogen peroxide 40 volumes. After 30 to 40 seconds the colour appears or not, this being more evident after few minutes.
26 Soybean Breeder Seed Peroxidase Test Test procedure Cultivars with high peroxidase activity in the seed coat, present Reddish Brown Colour, designated as positive reaction. Cultivars of low activity showing no colour change characterize negative reaction.
27 Soybean Breeder Seed / Peroxidase Test Test procedure Seed coat removal
28 Soybean Breeder Seed / Peroxidase Test Test procedure Seed coat removal
29 Soybean Breeder Seed / Peroxidase Test Test procedure Seed coat removal
30 Soybean Breeder Seed / Peroxidase Test Test procedure Staining
31 Soybean Breeder Seed / Peroxidase Test Test procedure Staining - 10 drops of a 5% solution of Guaiacol.
32 Soybean Breeder Seed / Peroxidase Test Test procedure Staining - one drop of hydrogen peroxide 40 volumes.
33 Soybean Breeder Seed / Peroxidase Test Test procedure Staining - Reddish Brown Colour
34 Soybean Breeder Seed / Peroxidase Test Test procedure Staining - Reddish Brown Colour
35 Soybean Breeder Seed What could be another resource if there is uncertainty about the overall genetic purity of the block. It can still be analysed based on their genetic profile or DNA through the use of Molecular Markers.
37 Soybean Breeder Seed / Molecular Markers The evaluation of genetic purity of the soybean seeds based on DNA molecular markers is conclusive, since they do not suffer from environmental influences, and the data obtained are reproducible and stable.
38 Soybean Breeder Seed / Molecular Markers Microsatellite molecular markers are indicated for this type of analyses to be highly polymorphic in soybean, highly reproducible and codominant..
40 Soybean Breeder Seed Microsatellite molecular markers Satt 179 Satt 181
41 Physical Purity Genetic seed must be free of weed seeds. It means that the seed field has to be clean.
42 Physiological Quality Along with the germination test, the tetrazolium test is one of the most powerful tools to assist in identifying the levels of viability and vigour of soybean seed. The tetrazolium test provides a vigour index, and reveals the causes of seed weakness, such as mechanical damage, field and storage deterioration, stink bug damage, and damage to heat and frost.
43 WEATHERING DAMAGE
44 Determined by the exposure of seeds to high temperature associated with alternate wetting-drying cycles before harvest. rainfall relative humidity dew
47 Weathering Field deterioration due to seed moisture fluctuation. Hilum Rain Rain RH RH RH 15% MC 19% MC 14% MC RH 18% MC 13% MC
48 Weathering Field deterioration due to seed moisture fluctuation.
49 Consequences presence of wrinkles yield reduction higher susceptibility to mechanical damage reduction in germination and vigour
51 Deterioration due to weathering identified by the Tetrazolium test.
52 Evolution of Weathering Damage in Soybean Seed During Storage Danos por umidade na classe 3 (%) Weathering damage - TZ class 3 ( %) High Alto vigor vigour Y 33,9761 0, X R 2 0, 5622 Médio Medium Y 43,5595 0, X R 2 0, Storage period (days) Tempo de armazenamento (dias) CV - Embrapa 48 Source: Moreano (2009) - UEM
70 Clorox test for estimating mechanical damage Seed without apparent damage Seed with apparent damage
71 Clorox test for estimating mechanical damage Seed with apparent damage
72 Clorox test for estimating mechanical damage Repetition 1 Repetition 2
73 Clorox test for estimating mechanical damage Repetition 1 Repetition 2
74 Screen test for estimating mechanical damage
75 Screen test for estimating mechanical damage
76 clorox test (%) hipoclorito (%) Mechanical damage Screen test X Clorox test 60 Seven Soybean Crops 1998 a 2004 to SAFRAS - SOJA - COMPLETO colhedoras sementes quebradas (%) 1705 harvest broken seeds (%)
77 vigour vigor (%) Mechanical damage Screen test X Vigour 120 Seven Soybean Crops 1998 a 2004 to SAFRAS - SOJA - COMPLETO colhedoras harvest sementes quebradas (%) broken seeds (%)
78 vigour vigor (%) Mechanical Damage Clorox Test X Vigour 100 Seven Soybean Crops 1998 a to SAFRAS - SOJA - COMPLETO harvest 1720 colhedoras hipoclorito (%) clorox test (%)
79 Mechanical damage identified by tetrazolium test.
80 Mechanical damage identified by tetrazolium test.
81 Sanitary seed quality - Phomopsis
82 Sanitary seed quality - Coletotrichum
83 Sanitary seed quality - Fusarium
84 SEED TESTING LABORATORY THE HUB OF A SEED QUALITY CONTROL PROGRAM STORAGE PRE - SALE PROCESSING PRE SOWING STL DRYING PRE HARVEST HARVEST RECEPTION
85 INTERNACIONAL SEED TESTING ASSOCIATION - ISTA TECHNICAL COMMITTEES RULES FOR TESTING SEEDS LABORATORY ACCREDITATION AND PROFICIENCY TESTING SYSTEM WORKSHOPS ANNUAL MEETING ISTA CONGRESS SEED SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY SEED TESTING INTERNATIONAL ISTA provides the knowledge for quality evaluation in seed production.
Humidtropics Kiboga/Kyankwanzi Soybean production training Makerere University and Humidtropics collaboration Soybean Seed production Training of Kiboga-Kyankwanzi platform members in Soybean Seed Production
Introduction to Seed Testing (Methodology and Terminology) The main purposes of seed testing are to: Study the physiological quality of seed Study seed procurement of the species Seed tests are based on
PROPAGATION OF ALBIZIA JULIBRISSIN Natural dispersal of Albisia julibri.ssin seeds take place during late fall and into winter. Pods, which develop in clusters, are firmly attached to the tree and require
Challenges in On farm Drying and Storage of Soybean for Seed in Modern Bin Systems Griffiths G. Atungulu University of Arkansas Division of Agriculture Introduction Commercial practice allows seed to dry
Enzyme Activity of Peroxidase Overview In lab this week we will investigate the activity of an enzyme called peroxidase. Each experiment will be conducted by a group of four students. All members of the
Post harvest Seed Storage/handling Dilip Gokhale ae STAK Conference, Nairobi, 15 May 2009 Seed Storage Definition i i of Seed Storage: Seeds are considered to be in storage from the moment seed reach to
73 MEASURING QUALITY OF TREE SEED B.S.P. Wang Canadian Forestry Service Petawawa National Forestry Institute INTRODUCTION As we have advanced into the phase of intensive forest management recently, the
Using Molecular Markers in Plant enetics Research Unlocking genetic potential for increased productivity Molecular Markers Researchers at Pioneer blaze a new genetic trail. Identifying molecular markers
Vigor and Seed Performance Mark A. Bennett Seed Biology Program Dept. of Horticulture and Crop Science Ohio State University Columbus, OH 43210-1086 firstname.lastname@example.org Seed vigor introduction and history
STORAGE AND TESTING OF FORAGE SEEDS IN THE TROPICS H.F. Chin INTRODUCTION Studies on the storage and testing of tropical forage seeds are lacking particularly in developing countries. This is evidenced
PEACH TREE PHYSIOLOGY David W. Lockwood Department of Plant Sciences & Landscape Systems University of Tennessee Knoxville, TN 37996 D. C. Coston Agricultural Experiment Station Oklahoma State University
Blossom Drop and Reduced Fruit Set in Tomato Monica Ozores-Hampton and Fnu Kiran and Gene McAvoy A tomato flower has both male (stamens) and female (pistil) parts within the same flower The yellow stamens
Harvesting, Drying, and Storing Malting Barley To Get Market Premiums Maltsters will pay premiums for malting barley that has been harvested in good condition and stored properly. Bright barley with good
A Few Video Tips for Shooting a Welcome Video Script Tips: Your Welcome Video will be a reusable learning object. Therefore, your script should avoid mentioning "time-sensitive" information, such as the
Harvesting Dry Bean John Nowatzki, NDSU Extension Agricultural Machine Systems Specialist Estimating Dry Bean Yield Dry bean yields can be estimated by knowing the number of seeds per pod, pods per plant
Table 3. List of descritors for maize Descriptor Descriptor Descriptor state Recording stage Remarks number 1 Accession number 2 Total no. of leaves Record the total number of At flowering leaves per plant
Farm to Fork Dr. Clifford Hall Clifford.Hall@NDSU.edu Dr. Hall is an Associate Professor of Food Sciences at North Dakota State University, Fargo, North Dakota, and a Member of the Bean Institute Editorial
Changes in Viability, Vigour and Chemical Composition of Soybean Seeds Stored Under the Humid Tropical Conditions V. Arulnandhy and Y.D.A. Senanayake Postgraduate Institute of Agriculture University of
Importance of Quality Grain to Produce Quality Malt Paul Schwarz and Richard Horsley Plant Sciences North Dakota State University Why is Quality important? Let s consider why is malt used in brewing Malt
Science 7 Unit D: Plants for Food & Fibre Topic 3 Plant Reproduction and Breeding pp. 115-130 WORKBOOK Name: Read p. 115 people choose specific plants with particular characteristics and encourage them
Soybean Soybean A-1174 oybean QUICK GUIDE Growth and Management D.A. McWilliams D.R. Berglund G.J. Endres North Dakota State University University of Minnesota Growth, development and yield of soybeans
Soybean Growth and Development Palle Pedersen Soybean Extension Agronomist Department of Agronomy Iowa State University University Extension 515-294-9905 www.soybeanmanagement.info Extension Publication
Saintbridge Allotment Gardens Association July 2015 newsletter In July the allotment looks at its best with a wide range of crops coming ready for harvest including; courgettes, cucumber, runner beans,
CAC/RCP 51-2003 Page 1 of 8 CODE OF PRACTICE FOR THE PREVENTION AND REDUCTION OF MYCOTOXIN CONTAMINATION IN CEREALS, INCLUDING ANNEXES ON OCHRATOXIN A, ZEARALENONE, FUMONISINS AND TRICOTHECENES CAC/RCP
Growth, Dry Matter Production and Seed Yield of Indian Mustard (Brassica juncea L.) in the Mediterranean Environment of South Western Australia C.P. Gunasekera 1, L.D. Martin 1, G. H. Walton 2 and K.H.M.
Journal of Stress Physiology & Biochemistry, Vol. 9 No. 4 2013, pp. 289-298 ISSN 1997-0838 Original Text Copyright 2013 by Azadi, Younesi ORIGINAL ARTICLE The Effects of Storage on Germination Characteristics
ALABAMA AGRICULTURAL & MECHANICAL UNIVERSITY SMALL FARMERS RESEARCH CENTER FACT SHEET Production Risk Any production related activity or event that is uncertain is a production risk. Agricultural production
SEPTEMBER 2009 PRIMEFACT 892 Common diseases of strawberries L Ullio Cleanfresh Project, Intensive Horticulture, Sydney Markets Leaf scorch Leaf scorch is common on older leaves and at the end of season,
New Directions and Changing Faces for the USDA Sunflower Genetics Research Programs Brent Hulke, Ph.D. Research Geneticist Brent s background Grew up on dairy farm in southern MN Agronomy BS from South
A3681 Alfalfa germination & growth Dan Undersander Paul Vassalotti Dennis Cosgrove Understanding alfalfa germination and growth is important to matching management decisions to alfalfa development. Knowledge
HYBRID SORGHUM SEED CERTIFICATION STANDARDS (1988) I. Application and Amplification of General Certification Standards A. The General Seed Certification Standards, as adopted by the association are basic
Supplemental Black Light Effect on Brassica rapa Authors' Names Redacted Abstract Sunlight provides ultra-violet (UV) rays for outdoor plants. Over time, more UV rays are apparent through destruction of
BREEDING CANOLA IN CANADA FOR A CHANGING MARKET Greg Buzza Advanta Seeds, Winnipeg, Canada. The plant breeders aim is to produce a variety, a cultivar, a hybrid, or in other words a product. This product
Women in Agriculture Training manual for female extension educators Seeds introduction and selection Introduction Part of the fun of growing your own vegetables is choosing from the thousands of varieties
BREEDING, GENETICS, AND PHYSIOLOGY Development of Hybrid Rice Cultivars G.L. Berger, G. Lee, Z.B. Yan, X. Sha, K.A.K Moldenhauer, J.T. Hardke, C.E. Wilson Jr., and C.W. Deren ABSTRACT In 2013, hybrid rice
Research Roadmap for the Future National Grape and Wine Initiative March 2013 Objective of Today s Meeting Our mission drives the roadmap Our Mission Drive research to maximize productivity, sustainability
Environmental Factors Environmental factors light, temperature, water, and soil greatly influence plant growth and geographic distribution. These factors determine the suitability of a crop for a particular
Cooperative Extension Service The University of Georgia College of Agricultural and Environmental Sciences HARVESTING, DRYING AND STORAGE SOYBEANS Paul E. Sumner, Extension Engineer Producing a high-quality
Strawberry Leaf Spot Cathy Heidenreich and Bill Turechek Introduction - Leaf spot is one of the most common and widespread diseases of strawberry. Mycosphaerella fragariae is also the cause of black seed
CHAPTER 1 A VIEW OF LIFE 1.1 How to Define Life Living things are called organisms. Organisms are often hard to define because they are so diverse; however, they share many common characteristics: 1. Living
Sample Liver Enzyme Lab Design Aspect 1: Research Question This lab will be driven by the research question, Do changes in temperature have an effect on the activity of the enzyme catalase? Pearson Baccalaureate:
DATA QUALITY IN SAFETY ASSESSMENT OF GE CROPS: ISSUES AND CHALLENGES VIBHA AHUJA BIOTECH CONSORTIUM INDIA LIMITED SAFETY ASSESSMENT OF GE CROPS Applications for the commercial approval of a GM crop are
Chapter 34 Diseases and Their Control In This Chapter Keywords Diseases After learning the information in this chapter, you will be able to: 1. List the causes of disease symptoms. 2. Describe how fungi,
The BioAg Alliance: Unleashing the Potential of Microbial Solutions in Agriculture Novozymes & Monsanto JOINT MEDIA ANNOUNCEMENT DECEMBER 10, 2013 Forward-Looking Statements As It Pertains to Novozymes:
A good start to the rice-production season begins with the selection of the rice cultivar to grow and the seed source. The varietal choice toxicity occurrence, and the degree of water control. Seed production
Introduction to Plant Propagation Glenn T. Sako Assistant County Extension Agent CTAHR, UHM Purposes for Plant Propagation Multiply the number of a species Perpetuate a species Maintain the youthfulness
Seed longevity in storage is a function of: Type of species Initial seed quality (production and conditioning) Storage environment Species can display orthodox or recalcitrant seed behavior. Orthodox seeds
DROUGHT TOLERANT CORN STEVE PADGETTE JOHN GOETTE CHAN MAZOUR Forward Looking Statements Certain statements contained in this presentation are "forward-looking statements," such as statements concerning
Plant and Soil Science I Levels: Grades 9-12 Units of Credit: 1.00 CIP Code: 02.0411 Core Code: 30-02-00-00-080 Prerequisite: None Skill Test: # 140 COURSE DESCRIPTION Students will develop knowledge and
Soybean Physiology: How Well Do You Know Soybeans? Shaun Casteel, Purdue University Soybean Extension Specialist www.soybeanstation.org 2010-11, Purdue University - 1 Vegetative Growth Stages Reproductive
Using Nitrate-N Petiole Sap-Testing For Better Nitrogen Management in Vegetable Crops Gerald E. Brust IPM Vegetable Specialist University of Maryland Introduction Vegetables have a relatively high nitrogen
A South American point of view Roberto Campos Pura Natura, Argentina EUSTAS 6 th Stevia Symposium Leuven, July 3 rd and 4 th I. Area of cultivation II. Environment III. Production of seedlings IV. Planting
AFTER JUNE 1, 2015 ITEM 165 HYDRO-MULCH SEEDING (FOR EROSION CONTROL AND STABILIZATION) 165.1 Description. This Item shall govern for furnishing all labor, materials, equipment, supplies, supervision and
By Virgil Schmittt, ISU Extension Field Agronomist 1514 Isett Avenue Muscatine, IA 52761-4629 563-263-5701 Covering the Iowa counties of Cedar, Clinton, Des Moines, Henry, Jackson, Louisa, Muscatine, and
21. Heterosis, inbreeding depression, various theories of Heterosis Heterosis and Inbreeding Depression Cross pollinated species and species reproducing asexually are highly heterozygous. When these species
SEMINAR ON DUS TESTING Geneva, March 19, 2010 Developing authority s test guidelines from UPOV Test Guidelines PROCEDURES IN BRAZIL Document prepared by : Luís Pacheco SNPC/MAPA - Brazil SERVIÇO NACIONAL
Sugarcane Biology, Yield, and Potential for Improvement Paul H. Moore USDA, ARS, US Pacific Basin Agriculture Research Center (retired) Hawaii Agriculture Research Center (current) Kunia, HI USA Outline
Name Pre-Lab: Plant Structure and Growth 1. Explain the difference between determinate and indeterminate growth. What regions in plants have the perpetual embryonic tissue that allows for continuous growth?
PS1-7 - 6121 Influence of storage condition on seed quality of maize, soybean and sunflower B. Šimic 1,*, A. Sudaric 1, I. Liovic 1, I. Kalinovic 2, V. Rozman 2, J. Cosic 2 Abstract The study was aimed
Soybean Marketing & Production College, Minneapolis, MN Peter Kyveryga, Ph.D. Operations Manager of Analytics On-Farm Network, Iowa Soybean Association Technical Editor-Precision Agriculture of the Agronomy
Turf-Tec ph Meter Test soil ph in the mat, thatch and above and below the root zone. ph can be checked, 0" to 4" inch level right on the turfgrass area. Simply insert probe to desired depth, allow to stand
FACILITATOR GUIDE ACQUIRE AN INTRODUCTORY KNOWLEDGE OF THE SEED INDUSTRY A Unit Standard for the Seed Industry Unit Standard 114658 NQF Level 2 Credits: 4 Compiled by: Lorraine Coetzee, Michael Zingel,
Scientist Guide Let s Talk About the Weather Introduction Agriculture is highly dependent on the weather. Ever since the first seed was sown, farmers have been watching the sky and hoping for good weather.
INTRODUCTION Factors Affecting Enzyme Activity The chemical reactions occurring in living things are controlled by enzymes. An enzyme is a protein in the cell which lowers the activation energy of a catalyzed
Certified Reference Material AOCS 0906-E Report of the certification process for MON89034 Corn Certified Reference Materials G. Clapper and R. Cantrill AOCS, Urbana, IL, USA Phone: +1-217-359-2344; Fax:
Jeremiah K.S. Dung Hermiston Agricultural Research and Extension Center Oregon State University Species of Pectobacterium and Dickeya Formerly known as soft rot Erwinias P. carotovorum subspecies P. atrosepticum
Purdue University Department of Agronomy Applied Crop Production Research Update Updated May 2016 URL: http://www.kingcorn.org/news/timeless/seedingrateguidelines.pdf Yield Response of Corn to Plant Population
Author: T.S.Nicholl Manchester, UK. Email: TSNicholl@WebbyBoy.co.uk Growing Virginia Tobacco. How to grow your own tobacco in the UK. 1 Contents Copyright.... 2 The cost of growing in the UK (The Tax Man)....
Q uiz for week 3 readings: 1. The database on the Organic Weed management Website contains the following sections except: A. Picture B. Ecology C. Management D. Description 2. The weed quackgrass can reproduce
The Huntington Library, Art Collections, and Botanical Gardens How Sweet It Is: Enzyme Action in Seed Germination Overview This experiment is intended to familiarize students with the macromolecule starch,
1 ST EUROPEAN SORGHUM CONGRESS WORKSHOP INNOVATIVE RESEARCH TOWARDS GENETIC PROGRESS SEED BREEDING: QUALITY AS AN ASSET Maximising results through genetic diversity, innovation and seed quality Christophe
Chapter 24 Reproduction of Seed Plants Section 24 1 Reproduction With Cones and Flowers (pages 609 616) This section describes the reproductive structures of gymnosperms and angiosperms. It also explains
How Much Does Acid Rain Hinder the Growth Height of Brassica rapa Plants Without Other Environmental Stressors? Author(s) Redacted Abstract: Brassica rapa plants are one of many plants in the environment
Corn Information for Corn Growers Vernon G. James Research and Extension Center, Plymouth, NC 27962 Irrigation Management in Corn Ron Heiniger Cropping Systems Specialist North Carolina State University
EVALUATION OF BLACKLINE HYPERSENSITIVE CULTIVARS Janet Caprile, Chuck Leslie, Gale McGranahan, Mysore Sudarshana ABSTRACT The purpose of this trial is to evaluate blackline resistant cultivars developed