1 Interpretive case studies Analysis Generalisations 3rd hour: Master project INF 5220, October 18th 2006 Margunn Aanestad
2 Interpretive case studies In-depth, longitudinal study of one event/organisation/process a case Investigates a phenomena in its real-life context (Yin, 1994) Case studies are common in the interpretive tradition focus on human interpretation and meaning. (Human behaviour and the reasons behind it) Interviews: main data source Cases using ethnographic methods vs. traditional cases.
3 Walsham (2002): Walsham (2002) Interpretive case studies in IS Philosophical basis of interpretative studies shared with ethnography: Status of data The importance of thick descriptions Not reporting facts, but one s interpretations of other people s interpretations Not aiming to produce truth or social laws, but still generalizable findings
4 Walsham (2002) Three ways to use theory: 1. As an initial guide to design and data collection (Build on previous knowledge, theory as sensitizing device ) 2. As part of an iterative process of data collection and analysis (Initial theories being expanded, revised or abandoned 3. As a final product of the research
5 Example 1 Walsham (1995) used Pettigrew s content, context and process framework to look at IS strategy/implementation Research questions generated: What IS strategic approaches had the organization adopted? (content) What was the position of this organization in its sector and country? (context) How had the organization tried to implement its stated strategy and with what success? (process)
6 Example 2: Structuration Theory (See Giddens also Walsham 1993): Three dimensions of meaning, norms and power Structures are produced or reproduced in action Emphasis also on unintended consequences of intentional action
7 Example 2 Theoretical guidance to formulation of interview questions: What do you understand this technology is aimed to do? (meaning) Does this technology require you to do your job in a different way? (norms) Who has required you to use this technology and what are their motives? (power) What changes in your work, and that of others in the organization, has resulted from the use of this technology? (production). What has stayed the same? (reproduction) Did any unexpected things occur in the use of the technology? And what happened as a consequence? (unintended consequences)
8 Walsham and Sahay (1999) Example of interpretive case study Walsham and Sahay: GIS in India. From a Specical Issue of MISQ on Intensive Research Longitudinal study: 3 years ( ) + historical reconstruction ( ). 5 field trips, interviews as main data source (note details given), but also systems demonstrations, archival data, informal contact, workshop. Describes gaining access, working with data, the role as researchers (p ).
9 Role of theory Walsham and Sahay (1999) The theoretical basis of our study evolved over time in response to both our deepened understanding gained through the collection of the field data and our changing ideas concerning appropriate theory.. (p. 41) Initially: Structuration theory + social construction of technology (SCOT), then (used in this paper): actor-network theory
10 Walsham and Sahay (1999) Implications for GIS practice Research questions: p. 40 Has GIS been implemented successfully for real application in district-level administraion? If not, why is this the case? What can be done about it? Page 55 onwards seeks to answer the third research question Formulated for different levels: For GIS implementation at district-level in India Potential relevance for GIS for decentralized management in other developing countries General implications for GIS practice
11 Walsham and Sahay (1999) Implications for Intensive IS Research Reflections on how to conduct and write intensive research studies (or interpretive case studies) Three criteria for convincing texts: Authenticity Plausibility Criticality Discusses also the way the paper evolved (two different versions) (More in-depth discussion of these aspect next time)
12 Analysis Walsham and Sahay (1999) Hidden process in most accounts of research Ongoing process, not just after data collection. Analytic writing, try out forms/representations of your data Geoff Walsham: In addition to field notes, I normally write a personal comment on the interview and the interviewee. I also generate sets of initial themes from my field notes as a basis for reflection, theorising, and interaction with my coresearchers (if any) See table 3 in Walsham and Sahay sets of themes that emerged after interviews during field visits
13 Silverman (2005), p. 153 Ask key questions about your data What are the main units in your data and how do they relate to one another? Which categories are used by the people you study? What are the contexts and consequences of your subjects use of categories? Do your own experiences in the field provide you with other research topics?
14 Silverman (2005) p From coding to interpretation Data reduction: Selecting, focusing, simplifying, abstracting and transforming raw data. Data display: Organized assembly of information that permits conclusions drawing Conclusion drawing/verification: Beginning to decide what things means, noting regularities, patterns, explanations, possible configurations, causal flows and propositions Testing the provisional conclusions for their plausibility, their sturdiness, their confirmability
15 Walsham on analysis: Best tool for analysis is your own mind and that of others So read your data carefully and then read it again Make data/theory links Try your ideas on others through working papers, conversations, seminars
16 Analysis Data-driven versus theory-driven analysis Data-driven: Silverman s examples in chapter 11 and 12, close to grounded theory. Theory-driven: when a case study is (re)- interpreted according to a theoretical framework: Walsham and Sahay (ANT) Hanseth et al. Reflexive Standardisation (Complexity Theory/ANT)
17 Theorizing from data Silverman (2005) p.105 How to theorize about data: Resist the temptation to rush to explanations, don t begin with Why questions. Ask what and how. Look at timings of peoples behaviour/actions or at processes of change Look at the context of your data Compare with other relevant data (or divide your data into different sets and compare them) Think of implications, how findings are related to broader categories Explore relations between models, theories.
19 On generalizability: Silverman (2005) p.136 Generalizability is (a) word that should be reserved for surveys only. What can be analyzed instead is how the researcher demonstrates that the analysis relates to things beyond the material at hand. extrapolation better captures thte typical procedure in qualitative research (Alaatusaari, 1995, cited in Silverman, p. 136)
20 On generalizability: Silverman (2005) p.108 Howard Becker: Tricks of the Trade. How to think about your research while you re doing it, University of Chicago Press, Advice when you try to generalize: Tell me what you ve found out, but without using any of the identifying characteristics of the actual case.
21 Walsham (2002) Generalizations Explanations are not predictions Four types of generalizations: Development of concepts Generation of theory Drawing of specific implications Contribution of rich insights Some examples of the types (used by Walsham):
22 Walsham (2002) 1) Development of Concepts Zuboff (1988) - concept of informate Walsham (2004) - concept of knowledge communities: are a complex network of sense-readers and sense-givers, taking action, reflecting on it, making representations based on their tacit knowing, reading others representations, and taking further action in turn
23 Walsham (2002) 2) Generation of Theory Theories of organizational consequences of IT Orlikowski and Robey (1991) Jones and Nandhakumar (1993) Walsham (2004): A basic model of communication with a sociological complement
24 Walsham (2002) 3) Drawing of Specific Implications Relationship between design and development and business strategy - Walsham and Waema (1994) Walsham (2004): on incentives and disincentives for knowledge sharing ; on forms of representation etc.
25 4) Contribution of Rich Insight Walsham (2002) Suchman (1987) - limits of machine intelligence; differences between plans and practical actions Walsham (2004) - weaknesses of the knowledge as object literature; deep meaning of tacit knowledge
26 Group discussions Three papers: Markus Bardram and Bossen Walsham and Sahay 1. Do you see traces of the analysis process? 2. What kind(s) of generalisations made? 3. What is the level of ambition for the generalisations?
27 Flyvebjerg (1991) Generalizations from one case? Flyvebjerg: five common misunderstandings: Theoretical knowledge is more valuable than practical knowledge One cannot generalise from a single case The case study is most useful for generating hypotheses The case study contains a bias towards verification It is often difficult to summarize different case studies More recent text in English: Flyvebjerg, B. Five Misunderstandings about Case Study Research, Qualitative Inquiry, vol. 12, no. 2, April 2006, p
28 Flyvebjerg (1991) 1) Theoretical or practical knowledge? Cases, examples provides the type of context-dependent learning that is required for people to develop from rulebased beginners to virtouso experts. In the study of human affairs, there appears to exist only context-dependent knowledge. There does not and probably cannot exist predictive theory in social science.
29 Flyvebjerg (1991) 2) Generalize from a single case? It depends on the case and how it is chosen (Falsification finding black swans, critical cases). Carefully chosen experiments, cases and experience were also critical to the development of physics More discoveries have arisen form intense observations than from statistics applied to large groups. (Formal) generalization (as aim, ideal) is overrated as a source of scientific development, while the power of the example is underrated
30 Flyvebjerg (1991) 3) Only for generating hypothesis? Builds on previous point -> cases can also be used to test hypotheses Generalisation dependent on case selection: Atypical, extreme cases may reveal more information than representative cases More important to clarify deeper causes and their consequences than to describe the symptoms of the problem and how frequently they occur. Extreme/deviant cases, maximum variation cases, critical cases, paradigmatic cases
31 Flyvebjerg (1991) 4) Verification bias? Is there a tendency to confirm the researcher s preconceived notions? This problem is relevant for all methods Many field studies report revision of initial assumptions Geertz: The field is itself a powerful disciplinary force, assertive, demanding, even coercive.
32 Flyvebjerg (1991) 5) Cases are difficult to summarize Strong narrative element difficult to summarize into propsitions or theory. The case story is itself the result. Is summarizing and generalizing always desirable?..the value of the case study, the contextual and interpenetrating forces, is lost when one tries to sum up in large and mutually exclusive categories Payback: a sensitivity to issues that cannot be gained from theory. Summarizing can even be counter-productive to learning Rather important: keep open the case study, maintain the rich ambiguity of reality
33 Optional readings Geertz Latour Schultze Geertz and Latour: theory strongly informs account, but is invisible. Geertz: challenging functionalist anthropology with his interpretive view Latour: Actor-Network Theory ontology is the structuring device for the account Schultze: self-reflexive/confessional accounts (for next lecture)
34 Geertz (1972) Paradigmatic case: Deep Play The (illegal) Balinese tradition of cock fighting illustrates social structures: For it is only apparently cocks that are fighting there. Actually, it is men. Page 4: The Fight a description of the procedures, rules and actions (Practices) Page 6: Odd and Even Money describes the betting procedures. (Institutions) Page 7: Playing with Fire the notion of depth, Geertz argument for the social significance of these matches (Symbols)
35 Latour: Circulating Reference.. Paying close attention to the details of scientific practice Case: Amazon study, soil sampling to detect transition between rain forest and savannah What are the actions that transforms pieces of nature into scientific facts or statements? A chain of transformations Latour s general program: challenging the discourse of science showing the disjunction between accounts of praxis and the ethnographic data science in action not ready-made science.
Action Research / Case Studies October 10th Feed-back on 1 draft of research proposals Silverman (8, 9, 10) Presentation on Action Research by group 1 INFO The lectures (slides) are up on the INF5220 page
Case Study Method About this Document: This document deals with the basics dealing with the case study method. The primary work which has been used for this document is the book called The Case Study Method
Scientific Method Contents Dissertation and research Choice of subject and statement of problem Scientific Methods Scientific Techniques Dissertation Layout Sources, Literature and Footnotes Seminar organisation
Quality in qualitative research October 31st Feedback on your revised research proposals. Continuation of discussion on generalizations. Presentation by Lars, Renate and Jan (Group 6) on "evaluating case
How can qualitative research help? MICHAEL SHANAHAN BMBS MPH PHD FAFOEM FRACP The research methods we are generally taught in our training Randomised trials Epidemiological research Cohort studies Case
What Is a Case Study? Mitchell (1983) defined a case study as a detailed examination of an event (or series of related events) which the analyst believes exhibits (or exhibit) the operation of some identified
COM 365: INTRODUCTION TO COMMUNICATION RESEARCH METHODS Unit Test 3 Study Guide The test will cover the introductory materials from Chapters 7, 8, 9, & 10 in the Frey, Botan, & Kreps text as well as any
Qualitative Research. What is qualitative research? The goal of qualitative research is the development of concepts which help us to understand social phenomena in natural (rather than experimental) settings,
Fundamentals of Qualitative Research Joan LaFrance AIHEC NARCH Meeting Dinѐ College June 25, 2015 What is Qualitative Research The meaning is socially constructed by individuals in their interaction with
Programme Syllabus for Master of Science in Management 120 higher education credits Second Cycle Established by the Faculty Board of the School of Business, Economics and Law, University of Gothenburg,
Measurement and measures Professor Brian Oldenburg Learning objectives 1. To identify similarities/differences between qualitative & quantitative measures 2. To identify steps involved in choosing and/or
1. Which of the following best describes a paradigm? A. A worldview B. A research methodology C. A theory D. An argument 2. Which of the following people coined the term "paradigm shift"? A. Thomas Kuhn
Research Design Service London Writing a Qualitative Research Proposal When to use qualitative methods Qualitative methods should be used when the aim is to: Investigate complex phenomena that are hard
WHAT IS ETHNOGRAPHY IN SOCIOLOGY? James Rhodes Department of Sociology What is ethnography? In its most characteristic form...[ethnography] involves the ethnographer participating, overtly or covertly,
MANUAL for Dissertation Writers Doctor of Psychoanalysis (Psya.D.) Doctor of Psychoanalysis (Psya.D.) in Psychoanalysis and Culture INTRODUCTION The doctoral dissertation is an integral part of both Psya.D.
Event Marketing in IMC 44 CHAPTER THREE: METHODOLOGY 3.1. Introduction The overall purpose of this project was to demonstrate how companies operating in emerging markets can successfully organize activities
The case study approach; how to design a good interview guide and make arrangements for interviews Arild Holt-Jensen Professor, University of Bergen Norway What is a case study? Misunderstandings related
1 2 Research Strategies Basic oppositions Survey research versus Case study quantitative versus qualitative The whole gamut Experiment Survey Archival analysis Historical research Case study 3 Basic Conditions
Prepared for the Course Team by Martyn Hammersley CONTENTS Associated study materials 1 Introduction 2 Case studies and surveys 3 Case studies and experiments 4 Conclusion References Acknowledgements 1
Programme syllabus for the Master s Programme in International Administration and Global Governance 120 higher education credits Second Cycle Confirmed by the Faculty Board of Social Sciences 2015-05-11
What is Grounded Theory? Dr Lynn Calman Research Fellow School of Nursing, Midwifery and Social Work Grounded theory The aim of grounded theory is: to generate or discover a theory (Glaser and Strauss,
Critical Realism Critical realism offers an ontology that can conceptualize reality, support theorizing, and guide empirical work in the natural and human sciences. It views reality as complex and recognizes
PSYCHOLOGY PROGRAM LEARNING GOALS AND OUTCOMES BY COURSE LISTING Psychology 1010: General Psychology Learning Goals and Outcomes LEARNING GOAL 1: KNOWLEDGE BASE OF PSYCHOLOGY Demonstrate familiarity with
Critical appraisal of qualitative research Slides by Sarah Lawson 1 Learning objectives Understand the principles of critical appraisal and its role in evidence based practice Be aware of the key elements
Department of Geography GEO 271 Everything is related to everything else, but near things are more related than distant things. - Waldo Tobler s First Law of Geography 1.1 Research in Geography [Meaning
Unified View of Science and Technology Education: Technoscience and Technoscience Education 1 SUVI TALA Department of Physical Sciences, POB 64, FIN-00014 University of Helsinki, Finland E-mail: email@example.com
Sample Size and Grounded Theory S. B. Thomson 1 Abstract Interviews are one of the most frequently used method of data collection and grounded theory has emerged as one of the most commonly used methodological
Qualitative Data Analysis Module No POLS 305 Level 5 Credits 5 Pre-requisite Social Science Research Methods Student study hours Module leader Email Phone Number Office 60 hrs approx. 20 hrs lecture and
College of Arts and Sciences: Social Science and Humanities Outcomes Communication Information Mgt/ Quantitative Skills Valuing/Ethics/ Integrity Critical Thinking Content Knowledge Application/ Internship
Philosophy of Science and Research Methods in IS Rudy Hirschheim E.J. Ourso College of Business Louisiana State University firstname.lastname@example.org http://projects.bus.lsu.edu/faculty/rudy Philosophy of Science Timeline
Programme Curriculum for Master Programme in International Marketing and Brand Management 1. Identification Name of programme Scope of programme Level Programme code Master Programme in International Marketing
CHAPTER 3 Research Design and Research Methods Overview This chapter uses an emphasis on research design to discuss qualitative, quantitative, and mixed methods research as three major approaches to research
Research Methods: Qualitative Approach Sharon E. McKenzie, PhD, MS, CTRS, CDP Assistant Professor/Research Scientist Coordinator Gerontology Certificate Program Kean University Dept. of Physical Education,
INTERNATIONAL OFFICE MASTERS IN ENTREPRENEURIAL MANAGEMENT YEAR 1 - FOUNDATION/ CORE - 80 CREDITS SEMESTER 1 SEMESTER 2 The entrepreneurial business (12) This module introduces you to the field of entrepreneurship,
PhD in Information Studies Goals The goals of the PhD Program in Information Studies are to produce highly qualified graduates for careers in research, teaching, and leadership in the field; to contribute
Thematic Connections: With the emergence of the Common Core State Standards and new legislation overhauling the teacher evaluation process in many states, schools are confronted with two important measures
Qualitative Data Collection and Analysis In this lecture Overview of observations, diary studies, field studies Interviewing in detail Interviews that are done incorrectly are lost data Externalizing and
Study Skills Multiple Choice Tests & Exams Mount Allison University Challenges in Preparing for Multiple Choice Tests & Exams Anxiety Time-constraints Volume of material covered Misconceptions about the
Evaluating the Evidence: Lessons from Ethnography Susan Elliott Sim Department of Computer Science University of Toronto Abstract There are many disciplines that have well-defined theoretical foundations
City University of Hong Kong Information on a Course offered by Department of Information Systems with effect from Semester A in 2012 / 2013 Part I Course Title: Course Code: Course Duration: Qualitative
School of Advanced Studies Doctor Of Management In Organizational Leadership/information Systems And Technology The mission of the Information Systems and Technology specialization of the Doctor of Management
Research Philosophies Importance and Relevance 0. INTRODUCTION When undertaking research of this nature, it is important to consider different research paradigms and matters of ontology and epistemology.
Characteristics of Effective and Sustainable Teaching Development Programs for Quality Teaching in Higher Education This presentation will address the following conference aim/question: What are the contextual
Comparison of Comparison of The following seven tables provide an annotated template to guide you through the comparison of research designs assignment in this course. These tables help you organize your
Case Studies Dewayne E Perry ENS 623 email@example.com Adapted from Perry, Sim & Easterbrook,Case Studies for Software Engineering, ICSE 2004 Tutorial 1 What is a case study? A case study is an empirical
Description of the supplementary subject in Globalisation and Development The provisions of the academic regulations The academic regulations for the supplementary subject in Globalisation and Development
Early Stage Research Training: Epistemology & Ontology in Social Science Research Dr Arwen Raddon Centre for Labour Market Studies (firstname.lastname@example.org) College of Social Science Generic Skills Training
Interview studies Contents 1 Introduction... 1 2 Applications of interview study designs... 2 3 Outline of the design... 3 4 Strengths and weaknesses of interview study designs... 6 5 References... 7 1
METHODS 2 FILMIC APPROACHES: PHOTO, VIDEO INF5220 February 9 th, 2016 Guri Verne, Design group (based on Sisse Finken s lecture notes) FEEDBACK OBSERVATION I Good work doing an effort, reflecting! Well
Elite interviews By Andras Bozoki Central European University Who are the elite members? those with close proximity to power; those who decide on, or influence, policymaking processes; positional and/or
Graduate Courses 700 INTRODUCTION TO RESEARCH AND THEORY IN COMMUNICATION STUDIES I (3). Prerequisite, admission to graduate program or permission of the chair. Considers theory and philosophy in the study
Gender Sensitive Data Gathering Methods SABINA ANOKYE MENSAH GENDER AND DEVELOPMENT COORDINATOR GRATIS FOUNDATION, TEMA, GHANA email@example.com Learning objectives By the end of this lecture, participants:
Course Code Main field of study INFM03 Informatics; Information Systems Course Title Master (One Year) Degree Course Research Methods and Degree Project Essay Higher education credits (hec) 30 Level Progression
Undergraduate Psychology Major Learning Goals and Outcomes i Goal 1: Knowledge Base of Psychology Demonstrate familiarity with the major concepts, theoretical perspectives, empirical findings, and historical
THE UNIVERSITY OF EDINBURGH PROGRAMME SPECIFICATION M.A. Honours in Psychology and Business Studies1 1) Awarding Institution: University of Edinburgh 2) Teaching Institution: University of Edinburgh 3)
Semi-structured interviews 3 rd December 2014 Prof. Edwin van Teijlingen BU Graduate School Aim of this session: introduce various ways of conducting interviews with qualitative methods; outline strength
Journal of US-China Public Administration, October 2014, Vol. 11, No. 10, 831-838 doi: 10.17265/1548-6591/2014.10.003 D DAVID PUBLISHING Using Qualitative Research in Accounting and Management Studies:
What is Psychology? chapter 1 Overview! The science of psychology! What psychologists do! Critical and scientific thinking! Correlational studies! The experiment! Evaluating findings What is psychology?
Dr Roy Ramphal (UNISA) It is a process that involves obtaining scientific knowledge by means of various objective methods and procedures. Objective means that these methods and procedures do not rely on
Learning Goals and Objectives SCU Core Curriculum Beneath are learning goals and objectives for each area of the Core curriculum. The learning objectives along with course assignments and activities that
School of Advanced Studies Doctor Of Health Administration The mission of the Doctor of Health Administration degree program is to develop healthcare leaders by educating them in the areas of active inquiry,
RESEARCH: DESIGN AND METHODS (II) Division for Postgraduate Studies (DPGS) Post-graduate Enrolment and Throughput Program Dr. Christopher E. Sunday and Dr Brian van Wyk From last meeting. Difference between
Critical Appraisal and Interpretation of Qualitative Evidence Focus of this presentation Critically appraising a qualitative paper using the Critical Appraisal Skills Programme (CASP) worksheet for qualitative
Programme Syllabus for Master of Science in Management 120 higher education credits Second Cycle Established by the Faculty Board of the School of Business, Economics and Law, University of Gothenburg,
Grounded Theory Contents 1 Introduction... 1 2 Applications of grounded theory... 1 3 Outline of the design... 2 4 Strengths and weaknesses of grounded theory... 6 5 References... 6 1 Introduction This
1 Doctor of Education - Higher Education The University of Liverpool s Doctor of Education - Higher Education (EdD) is a professional doctoral programme focused on the latest practice, research, and leadership
The Posthuman Anthropologist: Integrating Ethnography with Artificial Intelligence to Forecast Political Crises in Asia Paper presented at the European Association of Social Anthropologists Conference,
IHTE-1800 Research methods: Case and action research Sari Kujala, spring 2007 Contents Introduction Case study research - What it is? When to apply? - Process - Improving the quality Action study - What
Qualitative methodology PSDR Project Development Workshop P.N.Campus, Pokhara 15-16 April 2012 Jens Seeberg Examples of research suitable for qualitative methods Research that delves in depth into complexities
Ethnography as Method in Social Sciences 17 June 2010 ICTD Summer School Began as a project complementing colonialism First chair 1908 Academic curiosity?... Of course but.. To understand other cultures.
The role of theory in research Division for Postgraduate Studies (DPGS) Post-graduate Enrolment and Throughput Program Dr. Christopher E. Sunday Outline Some definitions of theory. Some characteristics
QUALITATIVE RESEARCH DESIGNS: A CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK DR. PRASHANT KUMAR ASTALIN Department of education, DDE, Madurai kamaraj university, Madurai-625021, india. Abstract The design of qualitative research
Research Methods Family in the News Can you identify some main debates (controversies) for your topic? Do you think the authors positions in these debates (i.e., their values) affect their presentation
More on analysis + Going Online: Social Media and Social Groups INF5220 April 24th 2015 Guri Verne, Design group (Based on Sisse Finken s lecture notes) Analysis starts early Analysis starts early in the
2) Qualitative Sampling Techniques Training Course in Sexual and Reproductive Health Research Geneva 2012 Dr. Khalifa Elmusharaf MBBS, PGDip, FRSPH, PhD researcher Health System & Policy RCRU / UMST Objective
Theoretical Sensitivity Theoretical sensitivity is a term frequently associated with grounded theory. t is in fact, the title of the book written on this method by Glaser (1978). But, just what is theoretical