An Examination of the Long-Tail Hypothesis in Online News Market: The Case of Google News
|
|
- Gary Jackson
- 3 years ago
- Views:
From this document you will learn the answers to the following questions:
Did a major redesign of Google News result in a greater or less stories per page?
Who was the thesis submitted to?
What did Hengyi Zhu do to the distribution of the link frequency for each domain?
Transcription
1 i Wesleyan University The Honors College An Examination of the Long-Tail Hypothesis in Online News Market: The Case of Google News by Hengyi Zhu Class of 2015 A thesis submitted to the faculty of Wesleyan University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the Degree of Bachelor of Arts with Departmental Honors in Mathematics-Economics Middletown, Connecticut April, 2015
2 ii Table of Contents Table of Contents Acknowledgements ii iii Abstract 1 Chapter 1. Introduction News Industry and News Aggregators The Long-tail This Thesis 10 Chapter 2. Literature Review 12 Chapter 3. Applying Long Tail Hypothesis to the Online News Market Data Summary Statistics Empirical Models and Results 33 Chapter 4. Long Tail Hypothesis at the Company Level Data Summary Statistics Empirical Models and Results 59 Chapter 5. Conclusion 62 References 64
3 iii Acknowledgements I thank my thesis advisor, Professor Christiaan Hogendorn, who mentored me for two summers and through my senior year. Without the opportunities you provided and your patience as well as encouragement, I cannot see myself starting and completing this thesis. I thank my MECO advisor, Professor Gilbert Skillman. Not only did your advice help me through my studies at Wesleyan and beyond, your classes enlightened me so much that I shall be forever grateful. I thank Manolis Kaparakis, the director of Quantitative Analysis Center, for your earnest support and devotion to teaching. Your presence is such an important part of my Wesleyan experience. I thank Professor David Constantine from the Mathematics department. Your rigorous and intellectually stimulating teaching style helped me wade through many mathematics challenges. I take this opportunity to express gratitude to the entire faculty in both the Mathematics and Economics departments. I have learned and grown so much in my four years at Wesleyan with your help. Thanks to my thesis writing tutor, Kerry Nix. Without your help, time, and patience, this thesis would not be the same as it is today. Thanks to my friends and family. You are always of paramount importance to me. Your support and love have kept me thriving. I love you all.
4 1 Abstract The emergence of digital technologies has transformed the news industry, and news aggregators have become the most popular news destinations online. This thesis analyzes how online news aggregators affect the online news distribution over time. Specifically, it examines the distribution of the link frequency for each domain appearing on Google News over different periods of time and tests the long tail hypothesis, which states that the tail of the link frequency distribution should be getting longer and fatter over the years. Since most major news websites are now owned by a small group of companies, I incorporate ownership information into this analysis. I found that although more and more small and niche news websites are getting linked from Google News, each receives links only a limited number of times. The long tail hypothesis is not fully supported at the domain level; over time, the tail is only lengthened, but not fattened. Moreover, domain characteristics affect a domain s link frequency. Analyzing the link frequency distribution at the owner level, I found that with ownership aggregation the tail becomes even thinner.
5 2 Chapter 1. Introduction 1.1 News Industry and News Aggregators The emergence of digital technologies has transformed the news industry. As shown in Figure 1.1, more and more Americans are getting news online, and newspapers and television are declining in popularity as news sources (Pew Research Center, 2012). Figure 1.1: Where Americans Get News (Pew Research Center, 2012) Within the realm of online news, news aggregators are news sites that do not produce much original content, but rather curate content created by others using a combination of human editorial judgment and computer algorithms. In a typical news aggregator page, each news entry is presented with a title, a brief description, the name of the original content creator, and
6 3 perhaps photographs from the original article; to access the full article, users may click through the portal and go to the web site of the original content creator. As shown in Figure 1.2 news aggregators have become so popular that more than 50% of people identify a news aggregator as their top source of news (Pew Research Center, 2012). 1 News aggregators were the top three most popular news websites in January 2015, leading by a large margin (ebiz, 2015). Figure 1.2: Where do People Get News Online (Pew Research Center, 2012) News aggregators can be divided into a few different types, despite all serving the same purpose of news aggregation (Athey & Mobius, 2012). Pure aggregators, such as Google News, generally do not make any payments or have any formal relationship with the original content providers; instead, they 1 Figures add to more than 100% because of multiple responses.
7 4 create pages by crawling 2 the web and using algorithms as well as editorial judgments to organize the content. There are only a few rare cases in which Google News has a direct commercial relationship with the news source. For example, Google News had a relationship with the Associated Press, when Google primarily showed content from the Associated Press, as analyzed by Chiou and Tucker (2011). In contrast, sites like Yahoo! News and MSN primarily present content from contractual partners. Sites like the Huffington Post use a hybrid strategy of curating blogs and aggregating news from other sources. Opinions on news aggregators vary widely. One side accuses news aggregators of stealing traffic from news sites. Rupert Murdoch, owner of News Corp. and The Wall Street Journal stated, The people who simply just pick up everything and run with it steal our stories, we say they steal our stories they just take them. That's Google, that's Microsoft, that's Ask.com, a whole lot of people... they shouldn't have had it free all the time, and I think we've been asleep. Meanwhile, news aggregators contend that they actually drive traffic to news sites. In Google s comment on FTC discussion 2010, a Google spokesperson argues that "Google makes it easy for users to find the 2 Web crawlers are software that discover publicly available webpages. Crawlers look at webpages and follow links on those pages, much like you would if you were browsing content on the web. The crawl process begins with a list of web addresses from past crawls and sitemaps provided by website owners. As crawlers visit these websites, they look for links for other pages to visit.
8 5 news they are looking for and to discover new sources of information... We send more than four billion clicks each month to news publishers." 3 Since revenue for newspapers has been diminishing due to a decline in print subscriptions and advertising revenue, some Newspapers have been implementing paywalls, which prevent Internet users from accessing webpage content without a paid subscription on their websites to increase their revenue. If you are browsing a news website to which you are not subscribed, you might not be able to read the full stories of your choice. However, despite the debate I mentioned earlier, Google News has worked with most subscription-based news services to ensure that the first article seen by a Google News user does not require a subscription. Although this first article can be seen without subscribing, any further clicks on the article page will prompt the user to log in or subscribe to the news site The Long-tail In an earlier era, the blockbuster strategy or the winner takes all society were prominent features (Frank & Cook, 1995). Those strategies favor an application of the Pareto principle, which dictates that 80% of the total revenue is generated by about 20% of the total product line (Koch, 2001). 3 FED. TRADE COMM N, FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION STAFF DISCUSSION DRAFT: POTENTIAL POLICY RECOMMENDATIONS TO SUPPORT THE REINVENTION OF JOURNALISM (2010), (hereinafter DISCUSSION DRAFT). 4 If First Click Free isn't a feasible option for the news website, Google will display the "subscription" label next to the publication name of all sources that greet its users with a subscription or registration form.
9 6 Such strategies lead to economies driven by hits. Alternatively, a long tail 5 view has been trending over recent years. According to this view, total sales revenues of products in the tail, which online retail space makes more easily accessible, are worth more and more, and approach the sales revenues of the hits. An article named The Long Tail was published in Wired in October 2004, and its author Chris Anderson later turned it into a New York Times bestselling book The Long Tail: Why the Future of Business is Selling Less of More in Three main observations led Anderson to the idea of long tail: (1) the tail of available variety is far longer than we realize; (2) it s now within reach economically; (3) all those niches, when aggregated, can make up a significant market (Anderson, 2006, p. 10). Amazon.com serves as an example: about 30% of its total sales come from products not available in the largest offline retail stores. Amazon has successfully sold enough of the nonhits to establish a marketplace that has not been explored before. According to Anderson, at least three forces are behind the aforementioned phenomena: democratizing the tools of production, cutting the costs of consumption by democratizing distribution, and connecting supply and demand (Anderson, 2006, pp ). The first force, democratizing the tools of production, entails bringing in more producers and therefore products, lengthening the tail 5 The tail refers to the tail of a quantity versus rank plot. Sample graphs are in the following pages.
10 7 (Figure 1.3). Improved digital technology enables individuals to do what until just a few years ago only professionals could. Millions of people now have the capacity to make short films or albums, or publish their thoughts to the world. For instance, in the music industry, the number of new albums released grew a phenomenal 36 percent in 2005 to 60,000 titles (up from 44,000 in 2004), largely due to the ease with which artists can record and release their own music. With the available universe of content growing faster than ever, the tail extends rightward. Figure 1.3: Democratize the Tools of Production (Anderson, 2006, pp.54) The second force, democratizing distribution, cuts the costs of consumption and fattens the tail (Figure 1.4). The Internet makes it cheaper to reach more people. Aggregators such as Amazon, ebay, itunes and Netflix provide cheap and easy access to the content being produced to users who might not have access to those goods from traditional distribution channels. With consumers better access to niches, the tail fattens.
11 8 Figure 1.4: Democratize the Tools of Distribution (Anderson, 2006, pp.55) The third force, connecting supply and demand, introduces consumers to these newly available goods (Figure 1.5). Connecting supply and demand can take the form of anything from Google s wisdom-of-crowds search, itunes recommendations, word-of-mouth, blogs, to customer reviews. As a result, consumers experience lowered search costs 6 of finding niche content; thus, demand is driven down the tail. 6 Search costs refer to anything that gets in the way of finding what you want. Some are monetary while some are not. Nonmonetary search costs include wasted time or hassle in consumption.
12 9 Figure 1.5: Connect Supply and Demand (Anderson, 2006, pp.56) In economics terms, the three forces of the long tail, which traditional firms do not possess because of the constraints of physical products and limited shelf space, allow Internet firms and ecommerce stores to cut production costs, distribution costs, and search costs so as to bundle a huge inventory of hits and niches. With the help of information technologies, the forces that underline such long tails have been harnessed for competitive advantage (Huang & Wang, 2014). When news media went online, they achieved new efficiencies in manufacturing, distribution, and connecting supply and demand. The unique capacities of Internet provide a foundation for a possible long tail economy for online news. The Internet contributes to the long tail economy for online news by lowering production costs, distribution costs, and search costs, parallel to the three forces of the long tail.
13 This Thesis The news aggregator of interest for this thesis is Google News. As a pure aggregator, Google News crawls the web and use algorithms to organize its content. Google explains its algorithms in its patent document. 7 The major factors considered by its ranking algorithm include: volume of production from a news source, length of articles, the importance of coverage by the news source, the Breaking News Score, the Human opinion of the news source, audience and traffic, staff size, numbers of news bureaus, the "breadth" of the news source, the global reach of the news sources, and writing style. This enumeration, especially the first few criteria, shows that Google intends to favor large legacy media over smaller or niche news websites. However, based on the forces for the long tail hypothesis, there is the possibility that the long tail hypothesis can also be applied to the online news market. In other words, the small and lesser-known news sites may be benefiting more from Google News over the years. To address this question, this thesis uses data of Google News content since its launch in 2002, analyzes the distribution of the link frequency for each domain over different periods of time and tests the long tail hypothesis that the tail of the link frequency distribution is getting longer and fatter over the years. 7 Systems and methods for improving the ranking of news articles US A1
14 11 Different sections, such as top stories, U.S., World, Sports, Business, Technology, and Entertainment, make up a typical Google News page. A typical Google News page during my period of study is shown in Figure 1.6. A user is directly presented with the top story section and part of the sidebar on the right called the small section. The user need to scroll down the page in order to view the other sections. A domain s frequent appearance in one of the sections indicates an intrinsic characteristic of the domain. For example, if a domain appears frequently in the Entertainment section, this domain is most likely concentrated on covering entertainment news. I will control for those domain characteristics in the tests of the link frequency distribution. Figure 1.6: Sample Google News page (May 3, 2012) retrieved from Archive.org Most major news websites are now owned by a small group of companies. In the highly competitive media industry, consolidation with the ensuing economies of scale is widely seen as a necessary condition for
15 12 survival (DellaVigna & Hermle, 2014). Numerous mergers have left the news industry dominated by large companies, producing an industry in which the major players are highly integrated. The Columbia Journalism Review website features a dataset of major media companies and their subsidiaries. If a news website from my Google News data is listed here, it belongs to one of those major media companies. I will also analyze how this ownership information affects my tests of the long tail hypothesis. Chapter 2 of this thesis is literature review. Chapter 3 analyzes the long-tail hypothesis at the domain level, controlling for domain characteristics. Chapter 4 incorporates the ownership information and examines the long tail at company s level. Chapter 5 concludes. Chapter 2. Literature Review Many papers have been written that either apply the long tail hypothesis to different industries, especially for the industries with improved digital technology, or test the validity of the forces behind the long tail hypothesis. Elberse and Oberholzer-Gee (2007) study the distribution of sales in the U.S. home video industry for the 2000 to 2005 period, and find a long tail effect; the number of titles that sell only a few copies every week increases almost twofold. At the top end of the distribution, most hits draw smaller
16 13 audiences. At the tail end, they find that there is a rapidly increasing number of titles that never, or very rarely, sell the long tail appears incredibly flat. Brynjolfsson, Hu and Smith (2010) analyze the change in shape of Amazon s sales distribution curve from 2000 to 2008, and how the change impacts the resulting consumer surplus gains from increased product variety in the online book market. They find that the long tail has grown longer over time, with niche books accounting for a larger share of total sales. Their analyses suggest that by 2008, niche books accounted for 36.7% of Amazon s sales, and the consumer surplus generated by niche books increased at least five fold between 2000 and The increase in consumer surplus suggests that Amazon s long tail is likely to be a permanent shift instead of a shortlived phenomenon. Also, while previous research has assumed a constant slope between the log of sales and the log of sales rank, they find that the sales of a book drops at a faster rate than a log-linear curve indicates and the slope becomes steeper as a book s sales rank increases, suggesting that there may be forces that limit Amazon s ability to sell books that are extremely niche. Brynjolfsson, Hu and Simester (2011) examine the forces behind the long tail phenomenon. They first use data collected from a multichannel retailer and present empirical evidence that the Internet channel exhibits a significantly less concentrated sales distribution when compared with traditional channels. Then, they control for the differences in product availability between channels, and show that consumer s usage of Internet search and discovery tools, such as recommendation engines, are associated
17 14 with an increased share of niche products. They conclude that the Internet s long tail is not solely due to the increase in product selection but also partly a reflection of lower search costs on the Internet. Their research validates the first 8 and third 9 forces of the long tail hypothesis introduced in Chapter 1. Peltier and Moreau (2012) use a database of monthly sales of comic books and literature books in France over the period 2003 to 2007, and show that firstly, bestsellers got smaller market shares online than offline, contrary to medium- and low-sellers. Secondly, both online and offline sales shift from the head of the distribution to the tail with increasing magnitude over the period. Thirdly, the long tail appears to be more than just a short-lived phenomenon caused by the specific preferences of early adopters of e- commerce. These three results suggest that online information and distribution tools, whose use increased over the period 2003 to 2007, do have an impact on book distribution and on consumers' purchase decisions. While online sales accounted for only 4% of overall sales in 2007, according to their data, those sales are experiencing strong growth that the advent of the digital book will reinforce. Bourreau, Gensollen, Moreau and Waelbroeck (2013) use data from a survey of 151 French record companies conducted in 2006 to test the long tail hypothesis at the level of the firm. Specifically, they test whether record companies that have adapted to digitization at various levels (artists, 8 Democratizing the tools of production. 9 Connecting supply and demand.
18 15 scouting, distribution, and promotion) release more new albums without having higher overall sales. They consider two types of output: a commercial output (albums sales) and a creative output (number of new albums released). Their results suggest that adaptation to digitization had a strong and positive impact on the production of new albums (the creative output), but no effect on sales (the commercial output). Their result is in line with the long tail hypothesis in the sense that they are selling less of more ; digitization enhanced the creativity of record companies, leading digitized music labels to release more new albums, but this did not result in higher sales for those labels. Huang and Wang (2014), using survey, third-party traffic metrics, and content analysis, found that the traffic performance of online news sites was significantly impacted by long tail forces, but the impact had not transferred to the news sites financial performance. Online news institutions have responded to the changing market trend of segmentation and niches by deploying a long tail economy in terms of content, service, and participation variety through the aid of information and Internet technologies. However, despite carrying out the long tail model, online news institutions are still encountering the difficulty of turning web traffic into real profit and revenue. As presented above, applying the long tail hypothesis to different industries yields mixed results. The notion of the long-tail hypothesis also differs slightly for different researchers; a tail can be lengthened or shortened, fattened or flattened. For this thesis, a longer tail requires the tail being both
19 16 lengthened and fattened. Although there are no studies focusing specifically on Google News and the long tail phenomenon, many have studied Google News and aggregation. These studies provide insights on Google News as a news aggregator. Athey and Mobius (2012) analyze the impact of news aggregators on the quantity and composition of internet news consumption. They perform a case analysis of an example in which Google News added local content to their news home page for users who chose to enter their location. Using a dataset of user browsing behavior, they compare users who adopt the localization feature, which includes adding a Local news section, to a sample of control users. They find that users who adopt the localization feature subsequently increase their usage of Google News, which in turn leads to additional consumption of local news. This result suggests that the inclusion of local content by Google News had mixed effects on local outlets: it increased their traffic, especially in the short run, but it also increased the reliance of users on Google News as a source of news, and increased the dispersion of user attention across outlets. In other words, more users go to Google News instead of visiting news website directly; they also get re-directed to news websites that they would not have otherwise visited. Jeon and Esfahani (2012), in one of the few theoretical papers in this field, consider how news aggregators affect the quality choices of newspapers competing on the Internet. To provide a micro-foundation for the role of the aggregator, they build a model of multiple issues in which newspapers choose
20 17 their quality on each issue. The model captures both business-stealing and readership-expansion effects of the aggregator. They find that the presence of aggregator leads newspapers to specialize their news coverage, and changes quality choices from strategic substitutes to strategic complements. The aggregator is beneficial for consumers, where as it may harm newspapers. However, even if the aggregator harms newspapers, each newspaper may prefer to keep its link with the aggregator. Chapter 3. Applying Long Tail Hypothesis to the Online News Market 3.1 Data Archive.org, also called the Wayback Machine, is a digital archive of the World Wide Web and other information on the Internet created by the Internet Archive, a non-profit organization based in San Francisco, California. Creators Brewster Kahle and Bruce Gilliat originated the Internet Archive Wayback Machine in It was officially launched in 2001 and is maintained with content from Alexa Internet. The service enables users to see archived versions of web pages across time. For instance, a user can search and view an achieved webpage as it appeared on Feb 15, 2004 and as it appeared the following day.
21 18 Kahle and Gilliat founded Alexa Internet in The name Alexa was chosen to pay homage to the Library of Alexandria, drawing a parallel between the largest repository of knowledge in the ancient world and the potential of the Internet to become a similar store of knowledge. Alexa's operation includes archiving of webpages as they are crawled. This database served as the basis for the creation of the Internet Archive accessible through the Wayback Machine. Aside from web crawling, Alexa collects data on browsing behavior from those who have the Alexa Toolbar installed and transmits it to the Alexa website, where it is stored and analyzed, and forms the basis for the company's web traffic reporting. Amazon acquired Alexa in 1999 for approximately 250 million U.S. dollars in Amazon stock. Currently, Alexa is a purely analytics-focused company that competes with other web analytics services, such as Compete.com and Quantcast. According to Archive.org s webpage, most of Wayback Machine s archived web data comes from its own crawls or from Alexa Internet s crawl. Both of those automated crawls tend to find sites that are well linked from other sites. Besides that, some sites are harder to archive than others, and the reasons are as follows. Firstly, Archive.org respects robot exclusion headers. 10 Secondly, JavaScript elements are often hard to archive. Thirdly, if a website requires the crawler to contact the originating server in order to work, it will fail when archived. Moreover, the archive contains crawls of the Web completed by Alexa Internet; if Alexa does not know about a site, it will not be 10 One can exclude its website from being crawled by including a robot exclusion header.
22 19 archived. Finally, if there are no links to a website, the robot will not find the site. In 2006, Internet Archive launched Archive-It, a subscription service that allows institutions to build and preserve collections of digital content. Archive-It partners can harvest, catalog, manage, and browse their archived collections. All data created using the Archive-It service is hosted and stored by the Internet Archive. Archive-It is very flexible; one can harvest material from the Web using ten different frequencies ranging from daily to annually. Partners develop their own collections and have complete control over which content to archive within those collections. Both Archive-It and Archive.org serve to archive the Internet, but use different methods. Archive.org archives the internet through its automated crawls, while Archive-It allows the owners of websites to decide how they want their websites archived. In October 2013, a save page feature for the Wayback Machine was launched so that every user can archive pages on demand. Web pages archived by this feature will be available almost immediately after the user clicks the save page button on archive.org/web, provided the site allows crawlers. 11 Once a page is saved, one cannot differentiate whether it was archived by automated crawls or through the save page feature. Automated crawls, Archive-It, and the save page feature are the three main methods 11 As mentioned earlier, the presence of a robot exclusion header will prevent a page from being crawled.
23 20 Internet Archive uses to preserve the Internet, though it predominately uses the first method. As of March 2015, 456 billion web pages have been saved. The Archive s goal is to index the whole World Wide Web without any judgments about which pages are worth saving. The potential importance of the Archive for longitudinal and historical Web research leads to the need to evaluate the biases of its coverage. Thelwall and Vaughan (2004) found that there is significant bias in terms of both rates of inclusion in the Archive and length of time of inclusion by country. However, the Internet Archive is naturally biased by link structures rather than by countries: historical factors have caused the first to map onto the second. Therefore, it is reasonable to believe that there will also be intra-national and other biases that are related to site age and link structures. Caution must be advised in interpreting findings of such studies, unless methods can be devised to bypass these problems. Among those billions of archived web pages, about 14 thousand are archives of Google News (news.google.com). Google News was launched in The Wayback Machine therefore covers the entire history of Google News. Figure 3.1 presents the frequency of scrapes of Google News archived from September 2002 to the end of Before May 2004, Google News pages were rarely saved, usually fewer than 5 times per month. In June 2004, the frequency suddenly picked up: pages were archived for more than half of the days in each month, and there were sometimes even multiple pages per day. This pattern continued into late 2006, and then the frequency dropped
24 21 again. During 2007 and 2008, the amount of pages archived per month varied greatly, but overall there was a decrease in the total amount archived. Then, there was a recovery in year 2009, Google News was saved once almost every day for the entire year as well as the first half of Later, there was a slight dip in the second half of 2010 that continues into However, starting mid-2011, multiple pages per day were saved and the frequency was getting higher and higher; this pattern persists today and recently about 10 to 20 pages are archived every day; the number seems to keep growing. Figure 3.1: Frequency of scrapes of Google News archived on Archive.org from September 2002 to the end of 2013
25 22 Since a website will be crawled more frequently if it is well-linked from other sites, the frequency of the Google News archives can be a proxy for how well-linked Google News was over the years, and its popularity. In June 2011, there was a major redesign of Google News resulting in a greater number of stories per page; the timing of the redesign accords with the time of increased archiving frequency. For the analysis of this chapter, I will use a dataset that I created from saved pages available at Archive.org. I was able to parse the HTML codes of those archived Google News pages from 2002 to 2013 and collect desired information with a Python package called Beautiful Soup. By analyzing how those HTML codes are structured and navigating through the parse trees generated by Beautiful Soup, I located and parsed out information such as date, time, section on the page, position under the section, title, URL link, and so on for each news entry appeared on Google News. Google News went through many design changes, both major and minor. Due to its changes, I made about 20 scripts. Taken altogether, they scraped all of the thousands of pages archived since The total number of observations for this data set is greater than one million. Since this data set generated from Archive.org is concerned with only the archives of one website, the Google News, and the archives were made entirely within the U.S., the previously discussed biases based on rate of inclusion and length of inclusion of the country in the archive do not apply.
26 23 Because Google News pages were archived at inconsistent frequency, the number of unique days per month with scrapes available varies, as shown in Table 3.1. To minimize the bias created by this uneven spread of data across time, I designed and implemented the following sample selection method: first, I divide my data into six-month periods and include in this data a maximum of one page per day. For consistency, I chose the page that is closest to 4pm for each available day 12. Then, I keep only the periods for which each month inside that period has more than 10 unique days with scrapes available. After, I randomly select 10 scrapes from each month and combine 12 month into one period, resulting a total of 7 periods, as shown in Table 3.1. Therefore, in each period, there is identical amount of scrapes; more specifically, there are 120 scrapes per period. By doing so, I lose a large number of observations, but I am able to make my data more evenly spread out across time. Those periods, ranging from 2004 to 2013, become time dummies in my analysis. Therefore, the gaps in between will not affect my analysis. Number of days Table 3.1 : Number of unique days per month with scrapes available Year Month Time Dummy Number of days Year Month Time Dummy / / / / / / / / / / / / / / 12 I choose 4pm since it is usually considered a prime news viewing time.
27 / / / / / / / / / / Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / Period / Period / Period / Period / Period / Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period 4
28 Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Period 7 The following Table 3.2 shows a sample line of data (presented vertically here due to spatial constraint). The first item is a timestamp. The second item describes its position in WayBack s daily scrape sequence (No. 1, No. 2, No. 3 ). The third item shows to which section on the Google News page the observation belongs. The fourth item indicates the exact position under that section, in this case the third story within the first story block. The fifth is the news story s title. Sixth is the name of the news source. Seventh, I
29 26 have the full link to the original story and eighth is the domain name extracted from the full link. With more than a million observations in this format, I can count the number of times each domain appeared during each period of time. The resulting domain link frequency variable is one of the main variables I use in my analysis. Table 3.2 : Sample line of Google News data (08/16/09 18:33:21) No.2 Wayback scrape of the day Health 1_3 Connecticut To Make Swine Flu Vaccine Available Hartford Courant Summary Statistics Table 3.3 shows the number of unique domains per period. Although each period features the same amount of scrapes, the resign of Google News pages resulted in an increase in observations in the later periods. In this sample, there are a total of 5220 unique domains. Breaking the sample into periods, the number of unique domains in each period adds up to This suggests that there are 4135 occurrences of a domain appearing multiple times across different periods. Table 3.3: Number of unique domains by period Total 5220 Period Period Period Period Period Period Period
30 27 Table 3.4 presents the summary statistics of the number of links per domain by period. While I have a total of 5220 unique domains, for each period, I only count the domains that appear in that period. Therefore, the minimum number of links per domain by period is 1. For the earlier periods, 25%-50% of domains feature only 1 link, and the percentage is even larger for the later periods, as indicated by the 1 st quantile, median and 3 rd quantile statistics. Notice that the 3 rd quantile statistic is very low at 4 or 5 for all time periods; this suggests that the majority of domains have only a small number of links on Google News during each 12-month period. The numbers of links for the top domains are very large, relatively speaking, lifting the mean to a level well above not only the median but also the 3 rd quantile. Table 3.4: Summary of the link frequency by period Period Min 1 st Median Mean 3 rd Max quantile quantile Total Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Table 3.5, which lists the number of domains that exceeds a specific link frequency level, offers a more detailed picture of the distribution of link frequency. Over the entire sample, the first column indicates a domain s link frequency at a certain percentile (for instance, the domain at 60% percentile
31 28 has 2 links). Cells in each column contain the number of domains exceeding the corresponding link frequency level in each period. The absolute numbers of links shift with the number of unique domains for each period. From the percentage table I can see that, in later periods, there are relatively more domains with only one link and also relatively more domains that appear frequently (more than six times in each period). Table 3.5: The link frequency in link frequency quantiles by period Level of links Period 1 Period 2 Period 3 Period 4 Period 5 Period 6 Period 7 All domains (N=9,355) In absolute value > > Q0.60: > Q0.70: > Q0.80: > Q0.90: > Q0.95: > Q0.99: > In percentage > > Q0.60: > Q0.70: > Q0.80: > Q0.90: > Q0.95: > Q0.99: > Table 3.6, which shows the number of domains responsible for certain percentage of total number of links in each period, reinforces the results from previous tables. The majority of domains have only one link in each period;
32 29 however, the links from those domains constitute less than 10% of total links in any period. About 70% of all links in each period are from the top 5% domains. From those statistics, I can see that there is only a lengthened tail in the sense that that there are many small and less popular news websites (the domains with only one or two links). However, the tail is not fattened; those news sites are not receiving enough exposure in total to compare with the hit news websites to be truly considered part of a long tail (lengthened and fattened). Table 3.6: Number of domains responsible for certain percentage of total number of links Period 1 Period 2 Period 3 Period 4 Period 5 Period 6 Period 7 All domains (N=9,355) Number of links Number of domains In absolute value >= >= >= >= >= In percentage >= >= >= >= >= After counting the number of links for each domain, I rank the domains by the link frequency. Domains with the same link frequencies are
33 30 assigned the same frequency rank. Table 3.7 shows summary statistics of the link frequency rank. Once again, I can see that a majority of domains are tied at the bottom ranks. Table 3.7: Summary of the link frequency rank by period Period Min 1 st Median Mean 3 rd Max quantile quantile Total Period Period Period Period Period Period Period Figure 3.2 shows the relationship between the log of link frequency and the log of link frequency rank for each domain in each period. Similar to the findings of Brynjolfsson, Hu and Smith (2010), the slope between the log of link frequency and the log of link frequency rank is not constant. It drops at a faster rate than a log-linear curve indicates and the slope becomes steeper as the rank increases, suggesting a cluster of a few dominant domains and a relatively short tail. The fitted lines will be discussed later.
34 31 Figure 3.2: Scatterplot of log of the link frequency vs. log of the link frequency rank 13 The following tables are concerned with the domain characteristics. A top-level domain is one of the domains at the highest level in the hierarchical Domain Name System of the Internet. For example, in the domain name the top-level domain is com. Com means top level domain for commerce; uk is the top level domain for the United Kingdom; net means the top level domain originally for network providers and org is the top level domain for non-profit organizations. The top level domains listed in Table 3.8 appear frequently in my data sample; the vast majority are com domains. The 13 The log of the link frequency is on the y-axis; the log of the link frequency rank is on the x- axis.
35 32 other top level domains only appear a few times in each period so that they will not affect my analysis. I will test the effect of having those top level domains as one of the domain characteristics. Table 3.8: Difference in top level domain by period Top level com uk net org domain Period 1 (1111) Period 2 (919) Period 3 (841) Period 4 (943) Period 5 (1745) Period 6 (1967) Period 7 (1829) As mentioned earlier, a domain s frequent appearance in one of the sections is an indication of its intrinsic characteristic. A story usually falls into one of these sections: top stories, small section, business, entertainment, health, sci/tech, sports, U.S. or World. 14 The nature of most of these categories is self-explanatory; small section describes stories on Google s sidebar, on the right side of each Google News page. 15 If a domain only appears once or twice in an entire period, there are simply too few observations to merit a frequent appearance in any section. Therefore, I created a subset of my sample for domains with at least 5 or more links in each period. Then, for each of these domains, I calculate the frequency in which it appears in each section. Table 3.9 is the summary statistics of the 14 Because of differences in page design, sometimes there are stories appeared under a section that does not belong to my list; however, those cases are rare. 15 In the HTML code of Google News pages, Google named the sidebar the small section.
36 33 frequency of domain s appearance in each section. As for each section there are many domains with zero link, I exclude those domains from each section. In later analysis, I introduce a dummy defining top stories as having appearance frequency greater than the mean in that section, similarly for the other sections. Table 3.9: Summary of domain's section characteristic (percentage) (none-zero) Section Min 1st quantile Median Mean 3rd quantile Max Top Stories Small Section Business Entertainment Health Sci/Tech Sports U.S World Empirical Models and Results First, adopting the method of Brynjolfsson, Hu, and Smith (2010), I estimate the log-linear relationship between domain frequency and domain frequency rank on Google News. The linear model I use is: ln(link frequency) = ββ 0 + ββ 1 ln(link rank) I run this regression for each period. Domains with the same link frequencies are assigned the same frequency rank. The results are reported in Table 3.10.
37 34 Table 3.10: Regression result simple regression I see that the slope of the log of link frequency rank is getting steeper over time 16 so that as a domain s link frequency rank increases, its link frequency drops faster for the later periods. However, the relationship between link frequency and link rank appears log-concave, not log-linear, as discussed earlier. I follow by running OLS regression with quadratic terms. The regression model I use is: ln(link frequency) = ββ 0 + ββ 1 ln(link rank) + ββ 2 ln(link rank)^2 16 Scatterplots featuring this relationship with fitted lines were previously shown as Figure 3.2.
38 35 Again, I run this regression for each period. The results are reported in Table Table 3.11: Regression result OLS regression with quadratic terms This set of regression offers a more detailed picture. The fit is better than the previous simple regression as R 2 increases for each period. From the linear term I observe that the head of the distribution is getting fatter; in the later periods, the top ranked domains get more links because of the higher coefficients on lrank. As I move to the right of the distribution, the number of
39 36 links received by those less-favorably ranked websites drops more quickly in the later period. This confirms the findings from the summary statistics. I observe the tail lengthening over time, in the sense that there are an increasing amount of small or niche websites getting linked to Google News over time; however, each of these small or niche websites is featured only a few times, while the large and top-ranked news websites get even greater exposure. In other words, the tail is lengthened but not fattened. Therefore, my results fail to support the long tail hypothesis, as the small and lesserknown news sites are receiving disproportionately less exposure than the top players from Google News. In order to further explore the difference in link frequency for domains with different link frequency rank and test the effect of domains characteristics, I follow a quantile regression model used in a similar situation by Elberse and Oberholzer-Gee (2007). In a quantile regression model, a specified conditional quantile of the outcome variable is expressed as a linear function of observed covariates. By examining multiple quantiles, I can observe how the distribution changes with covariates, allowing richer inferences. Quantile regression cannot be achieved by simply segmenting the response variable into subsets according to its unconditional distribution and then doing least squares fitting on these subsets. It is not a form of truncation on the dependent variable; instead, quantile regression can be achieved through optimization (Koenker & Hallock, 2001). They explain that just as I
40 37 can define the sample mean as the solution to the problem of minimizing a sum of squared residuals, I can define the median as the solution to the problem of minimizing a sum of absolute residuals. The symmetry of the piecewise linear absolute value function implies that the minimization of the sum of absolute residuals must equate the number of positive and negative residuals, thus assuring that there are the same number of observations above and below the median. Since the symmetry of the absolute value yields the median, minimizing a sum of asymmetrically weighted absolute residuals simply giving differing weights to positive and negative residuals would yield the quantiles. 17 I estimate models of the following general form: QQ θθ (yy xx) = xx ββ(θθ) Where QQ θθ (yy xx) donates the θθ tth quantile of the distribution of y, the log of link frequency in each period for each domain, given a vector x of covariates. To identify the emergence of a long tail in this setting, the covariates include a set of time dummies for each period. To control for the domain characteristics, the covariates also include a set of domain characteristics dummies. Table 3.12 shows the result of a series of quantile regressions of the log of link frequency against only the time dummies. All models omit a dummy for Period 1 since it is the base period. The intercept term is the mean of the link frequency in each quantile and coefficients for each period dummy 17 More detailed calculations can be found in Koenker & Hallock (2001).
Internet and the Long Tail versus superstar effect debate: evidence from the French book market
Applied Economics Letters, 2012, 19, 711 715 Internet and the Long Tail versus superstar effect debate: evidence from the French book market St ephanie Peltier a and Franc ois Moreau b, * a GRANEM, University
More informationTHE INTERNET AND THE NEWS MEDIA
THE INTERNET AND THE NEWS MEDIA Susan Athey Based on: The Impact of the Internet on the News Media with Emilio Calvano and Joshua Gans The Impact of Targeting Technology on Online Advertising Markets with
More informationChapter 27: Taxation. 27.1: Introduction. 27.2: The Two Prices with a Tax. 27.2: The Pre-Tax Position
Chapter 27: Taxation 27.1: Introduction We consider the effect of taxation on some good on the market for that good. We ask the questions: who pays the tax? what effect does it have on the equilibrium
More informationTable of Contents. 2010 Brightcove, Inc. and TubeMogul, Inc Page 2
Table of Contents Table of Contents... 2 Background... 3 Methodology... 3 Key Findings... 4 Platform Usage... 6 Video Stream Trend Data... 6 Player Loads Q1 2010... 8 Video Uploads Q1 2010... 10 Engagement,
More informationThe Economics of Digitization: An Agenda for NSF. By Shane Greenstein, Josh Lerner, and Scott Stern
The Economics of Digitization: An Agenda for NSF By Shane Greenstein, Josh Lerner, and Scott Stern This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License. To view a
More informationThe State of Coupons and the Role of Mobile How Consumers Leverage Mobile to Save
The State of Coupons and the Role of Mobile How Consumers Leverage Mobile to Save February 2016 KEY FINDINGS This study of 10,843 consumers uncovered four key findings around how shoppers use coupons for
More informationMarketing Mix Modelling and Big Data P. M Cain
1) Introduction Marketing Mix Modelling and Big Data P. M Cain Big data is generally defined in terms of the volume and variety of structured and unstructured information. Whereas structured data is stored
More informationStudy Guide #2 for MKTG 469 Advertising Types of online advertising:
Study Guide #2 for MKTG 469 Advertising Types of online advertising: Display (banner) ads, Search ads Paid search, Ads on social networks, Mobile ads Direct response is growing faster, Not all ads are
More informationTHE SME S GUIDE TO COST-EFFECTIVE WEBSITE MARKETING
THE SME S GUIDE TO COST-EFFECTIVE WEBSITE MARKETING Learn how to set your website up to convert visitors into sales and drive traffic to your website using online advertising. A publication by: Introduction
More informationPredicting Box Office Success: Do Critical Reviews Really Matter? By: Alec Kennedy Introduction: Information economics looks at the importance of
Predicting Box Office Success: Do Critical Reviews Really Matter? By: Alec Kennedy Introduction: Information economics looks at the importance of information in economic decisionmaking. Consumers that
More informationSimple linear regression
Simple linear regression Introduction Simple linear regression is a statistical method for obtaining a formula to predict values of one variable from another where there is a causal relationship between
More informationPredict the Popularity of YouTube Videos Using Early View Data
000 001 002 003 004 005 006 007 008 009 010 011 012 013 014 015 016 017 018 019 020 021 022 023 024 025 026 027 028 029 030 031 032 033 034 035 036 037 038 039 040 041 042 043 044 045 046 047 048 049 050
More informationWebsite Audit Reports
Website Audit Reports Here are our Website Audit Reports Packages designed to help your business succeed further. Hover over the question marks to get a quick description. You may also download this as
More informationMobile Strategy and Design
Mobile Strategy and Design A Guide for Publishers December 5, 2011 www.xtenit.com US: 01.877.XTENIT.1 International: 01.212.646.9070 Overview This paper outlines mobile strategies and deployment guidelines
More informationBritepaper. How to grow your business through events 10 easy steps
Britepaper How to grow your business through events 10 easy steps 1 How to grow your business through events 10 easy steps As a small and growing business, hosting events on a regular basis is a great
More informationSession 7 Bivariate Data and Analysis
Session 7 Bivariate Data and Analysis Key Terms for This Session Previously Introduced mean standard deviation New in This Session association bivariate analysis contingency table co-variation least squares
More informationCALCULATIONS & STATISTICS
CALCULATIONS & STATISTICS CALCULATION OF SCORES Conversion of 1-5 scale to 0-100 scores When you look at your report, you will notice that the scores are reported on a 0-100 scale, even though respondents
More informationChapter-1 : Introduction 1 CHAPTER - 1. Introduction
Chapter-1 : Introduction 1 CHAPTER - 1 Introduction This thesis presents design of a new Model of the Meta-Search Engine for getting optimized search results. The focus is on new dimension of internet
More informationAlgorithms and optimization for search engine marketing
Algorithms and optimization for search engine marketing Using portfolio optimization to achieve optimal performance of a search campaign and better forecast ROI Contents 1: The portfolio approach 3: Why
More informationEconomics of Strategy (ECON 4550) Maymester 2015 Applications of Regression Analysis
Economics of Strategy (ECON 4550) Maymester 015 Applications of Regression Analysis Reading: ACME Clinic (ECON 4550 Coursepak, Page 47) and Big Suzy s Snack Cakes (ECON 4550 Coursepak, Page 51) Definitions
More informationHow Video Rental Patterns Change as Consumers Move Online
How Video Rental Patterns Change as Consumers Move Online Alejandro Zentner, Michael D. Smith, Cuneyd Kaya azentner@utdallas.edu, mds@cmu.edu, cckaya@utdallas.edu This Version: October 2012 Acknowledgements:
More informationSocial Media & Internet Marketing :: Menu of Services
Social Media & Internet Marketing :: Menu of Services Social Networking Setup & Manage Company profiles on major social networks; Facebook, Linkedin and Twitter (includes custom background) see info below
More informationPRODUCTION. 1The Surplus
1The Surplus 2 The US economy produces an amazing number of different products: thousands of different foods, countless movies, dozens of different type cars, hundreds of entertainment products, dozens
More informationSucceed in Search. The Role of Search in Business to Business Buying Decisions A Summary of Research Conducted October 27, 2004
Succeed in Search The Role of Search in Business to Business Buying Decisions A Summary of Research Conducted October 27, 2004 Conducted with the Assistance of Conducted by Gord Hotchkiss Steve Jensen
More informationPredicting Flight Delays
Predicting Flight Delays Dieterich Lawson jdlawson@stanford.edu William Castillo will.castillo@stanford.edu Introduction Every year approximately 20% of airline flights are delayed or cancelled, costing
More informationDrop Shipping ebook. What s the Deal with Drop Shipping?
What s the Deal with Drop Shipping? How would you like to start an online store with minimal upfront investment and be able to run your business from anywhere in the world? Better yet, have someone else
More informationINTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF RESEARCH IN COMPUTER APPLICATIONS AND ROBOTICS ISSN 2320-7345
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF RESEARCH IN COMPUTER APPLICATIONS AND ROBOTICS ISSN 2320-7345 RESEARCH ON SEO STRATEGY FOR DEVELOPMENT OF CORPORATE WEBSITE S Shiva Saini Kurukshetra University, Kurukshetra, INDIA
More informationChapter 3 Productivity, Output, and Employment
Chapter 3 Productivity, Output, and Employment Multiple Choice Questions 1. A mathematical expression relating the amount of output produced to quantities of capital and labor utilized is the (a) real
More informationSEARCH ENGINE MARKETING 101. A Beginners Guide to Search Engine Marketing
SEARCH ENGINE MARKETING 101 A Beginners Guide to Search Engine Marketing June 2015 What is Search Engine Marketing? You ve heard the word before or simply the term SEM. Your co-workers mention it. You
More information! Giving the subscribers a choice of watching streaming content or receiving quickly delivered DVDs by mail.
Netflix s Business Model and Strategy in renting Movies and TV Episodes Reed Hastings, founder and CEO, launched Netflix as an online rental movie service in 1999. Netflix is a company that distributes
More information2013 Retailer ecommerce Study
2013 Retailer ecommerce Study shopatron.com Executive Summary The retail industry has changed significantly over the last decade, and it is continuing to evolve. As a veteran technology provider in the
More informationChapter 10. Key Ideas Correlation, Correlation Coefficient (r),
Chapter 0 Key Ideas Correlation, Correlation Coefficient (r), Section 0-: Overview We have already explored the basics of describing single variable data sets. However, when two quantitative variables
More informationExtreme Computing. Big Data. Stratis Viglas. School of Informatics University of Edinburgh sviglas@inf.ed.ac.uk. Stratis Viglas Extreme Computing 1
Extreme Computing Big Data Stratis Viglas School of Informatics University of Edinburgh sviglas@inf.ed.ac.uk Stratis Viglas Extreme Computing 1 Petabyte Age Big Data Challenges Stratis Viglas Extreme Computing
More informationMarketing & Site Recommendations
Marketing & Site Recommendations GoReaderGo LLC www.goreadergo.com Site Optimisation & Marketing Strategies Reference: xxxxxx Date: December 2014 Version: 1.0 Page 1 Table of Contents Table of Contents
More informationAnalyzing the Elements of Real GDP in FRED Using Stacking
Tools for Teaching with Analyzing the Elements of Real GDP in FRED Using Stacking Author Mark Bayles, Senior Economic Education Specialist Introduction This online activity shows how to use FRED, the Federal
More informationGoogle Product. Google Module 1
Google Product Overview Google Module 1 Google product overview The Google range of products offer a series of useful digital marketing tools for any business. The clear goal for all businesses when considering
More informationChristopher Seder Affiliate Marketer
This Report Has Been Brought To You By: Christopher Seder Affiliate Marketer TABLE OF CONTENTS INTRODUCTION... 3 NOT BUILDING A LIST... 3 POOR CHOICE OF AFFILIATE PROGRAMS... 5 PUTTING TOO MANY OR TOO
More informationWeek 3&4: Z tables and the Sampling Distribution of X
Week 3&4: Z tables and the Sampling Distribution of X 2 / 36 The Standard Normal Distribution, or Z Distribution, is the distribution of a random variable, Z N(0, 1 2 ). The distribution of any other normal
More informationBeating the NCAA Football Point Spread
Beating the NCAA Football Point Spread Brian Liu Mathematical & Computational Sciences Stanford University Patrick Lai Computer Science Department Stanford University December 10, 2010 1 Introduction Over
More informationBest Practice Search Engine Optimisation
Best Practice Search Engine Optimisation October 2007 Lead Hitwise Analyst: Australia Heather Hopkins, Hitwise UK Search Marketing Services Contents 1 Introduction 1 2 Search Engines 101 2 2.1 2.2 2.3
More informationPayPal Integration Guide
PayPal Integration Guide Table of Contents PayPal Integration Overview 2 Sage Accounts Setup 3 Obtaining API credentials from PayPal 4 Installing Tradebox Finance Manager 5 Creating a connection to PayPal
More informationANSWERS TO END-OF-CHAPTER QUESTIONS
ANSWERS TO END-OF-CHAPTER QUESTIONS 9-1 Explain what relationships are shown by (a) the consumption schedule, (b) the saving schedule, (c) the investment-demand curve, and (d) the investment schedule.
More informationDownloaded from UvA-DARE, the institutional repository of the University of Amsterdam (UvA) http://hdl.handle.net/11245/2.122992
Downloaded from UvA-DARE, the institutional repository of the University of Amsterdam (UvA) http://hdl.handle.net/11245/2.122992 File ID Filename Version uvapub:122992 1: Introduction unknown SOURCE (OR
More informationMichelle Light, University of California, Irvine EAD @ 10, August 31, 2008. The endangerment of trees
Michelle Light, University of California, Irvine EAD @ 10, August 31, 2008 The endangerment of trees Last year, when I was participating on a committee to redesign the Online Archive of California, many
More informationDigital Marketing, How To Guide for American Express Merchants
Digital Marketing, How To Guide for American Express Merchants americanexpress.com.au/merchant How to promote yourself online and successfully grow your business in the digital world 1 Contents 1. Introduction
More informationArchiving the Social Web MARAC Spring 2013 Conference
Archiving the Social Web MARAC Spring 2013 Conference April 2013 Lori Donovan Partner Specialist Internet Archive About Internet Archive We are a Digital Library Mission Statement: Universal access to
More informationGutenberg 3.2 Ebook-Piracy Report
Gutenberg 3.2 Ebook-Piracy Report What does piracy cost the publishers? Ersatzraten (replacement rates) Manuel Bonik Dr. Andreas Schaale Pic. from ref. [1] Berlin, September 2012 Prologue The report Gutenberg
More informationLecture 13/Chapter 10 Relationships between Measurement (Quantitative) Variables
Lecture 13/Chapter 10 Relationships between Measurement (Quantitative) Variables Scatterplot; Roles of Variables 3 Features of Relationship Correlation Regression Definition Scatterplot displays relationship
More informationIntroduction to Inbound Marketing
Introduction to Inbound Marketing by Kevin Carney of Inbound Marketing University Page 1 of 20 InboundMarketingUniversity.biz InboundMarketingUniversity Published by Inbound Marketing University No part
More informationLinear Programming for Optimization. Mark A. Schulze, Ph.D. Perceptive Scientific Instruments, Inc.
1. Introduction Linear Programming for Optimization Mark A. Schulze, Ph.D. Perceptive Scientific Instruments, Inc. 1.1 Definition Linear programming is the name of a branch of applied mathematics that
More informationManagerial Economics Prof. Trupti Mishra S.J.M. School of Management Indian Institute of Technology, Bombay. Lecture - 13 Consumer Behaviour (Contd )
(Refer Slide Time: 00:28) Managerial Economics Prof. Trupti Mishra S.J.M. School of Management Indian Institute of Technology, Bombay Lecture - 13 Consumer Behaviour (Contd ) We will continue our discussion
More informationLecture 2. Marginal Functions, Average Functions, Elasticity, the Marginal Principle, and Constrained Optimization
Lecture 2. Marginal Functions, Average Functions, Elasticity, the Marginal Principle, and Constrained Optimization 2.1. Introduction Suppose that an economic relationship can be described by a real-valued
More informationThe fundamental question in economics is 2. Consumer Preferences
A Theory of Consumer Behavior Preliminaries 1. Introduction The fundamental question in economics is 2. Consumer Preferences Given limited resources, how are goods and service allocated? 1 3. Indifference
More informationStudy Questions for Chapter 9 (Answer Sheet)
DEREE COLLEGE DEPARTMENT OF ECONOMICS EC 1101 PRINCIPLES OF ECONOMICS II FALL SEMESTER 2002 M-W-F 13:00-13:50 Dr. Andreas Kontoleon Office hours: Contact: a.kontoleon@ucl.ac.uk Wednesdays 15:00-17:00 Study
More informationcprax Internet Marketing
cprax Internet Marketing cprax Internet Marketing (800) 937-2059 www.cprax.com Table of Contents Introduction... 3 What is Digital Marketing Exactly?... 3 7 Digital Marketing Success Strategies... 4 Top
More information2010 Brightcove, Inc. and TubeMogul, Inc Page 2
Background... 3 Methodology... 3 Key Findings... 4 Online Video Streams... 4 Engagement... 5 Discovery... 5 Distribution & Engagement... 6 Special Feature: Brand Marketers & On-Site Video Initiatives...
More informationMicrosoft Advertising adcenter Campaign Analytics Getting Started Guide
Microsoft Advertising adcenter Campaign Analytics Getting Started Guide Contents Introduction... 3 What is Microsoft Advertising adcenter Campaign Analytics?... 3 Useful terms... 3 Overview... 4 Get Started...
More informationSEO MADE SIMPLE. 5th Edition. Insider Secrets For Driving More Traffic To Your Website Instantly DOWNLOAD THE FULL VERSION HERE
SEO MADE SIMPLE 5th Edition Insider Secrets For Driving More Traffic To Your Website Instantly DOWNLOAD THE FULL VERSION HERE by Michael H. Fleischner SEO Made Simple (Fifth Edition) Search Engine Optimization
More informationMaster of Science in Marketing Analytics (MSMA)
Master of Science in Marketing Analytics (MSMA) COURSE DESCRIPTION The Master of Science in Marketing Analytics program teaches students how to become more engaged with consumers, how to design and deliver
More information7 AGGREGATE SUPPLY AND AGGREGATE DEMAND* Chapter. Key Concepts
Chapter 7 AGGREGATE SUPPLY AND AGGREGATE DEMAND* Key Concepts Aggregate Supply The aggregate production function shows that the quantity of real GDP (Y ) supplied depends on the quantity of labor (L ),
More information1 Which of the following questions can be answered using the goal flow report?
1 Which of the following questions can be answered using the goal flow report? [A] Are there a lot of unexpected exits from a step in the middle of my conversion funnel? [B] Do visitors usually start my
More informationMobile Commerce for Multichannel Retailers
White Paper An Introduction to Mobile Commerce for Multichannel Retailers This paper is written for retailers who have some experience in ecommerce and want to find out more about the growth and opportunities
More informationThe Long Road to Conversion:
Microsoft s Atlas Institute The Long Road to Conversion: The Digital Purchase Funnel By Andrew Martin, Microsoft s Atlas Institute Introduction Most marketers are familiar with the concept of the purchase
More informationWhere Is Interactive Marketing Heading?
Trend Report Changhee Han _ chang.han@cheil.com Chakyung Bae _ chakyung.bae@cheil.com 2013 ad:tech London Where Is Interactive Marketing Heading? ad:tech is an international seminar on interactive marketing
More informationTelevision Advertising is a Key Driver of Social Media Engagement for Brands TV ADS ACCOUNT FOR 1 IN 5 SOCIAL BRAND ENGAGEMENTS
Television Advertising is a Key Driver of Social Media Engagement for Brands TV ADS ACCOUNT FOR 1 IN 5 SOCIAL BRAND ENGAGEMENTS Executive Summary Turner partnered with 4C to better understand and quantify
More informationII. DISTRIBUTIONS distribution normal distribution. standard scores
Appendix D Basic Measurement And Statistics The following information was developed by Steven Rothke, PhD, Department of Psychology, Rehabilitation Institute of Chicago (RIC) and expanded by Mary F. Schmidt,
More informationASSIGNMENT 4 PREDICTIVE MODELING AND GAINS CHARTS
DATABASE MARKETING Fall 2015, max 24 credits Dead line 15.10. ASSIGNMENT 4 PREDICTIVE MODELING AND GAINS CHARTS PART A Gains chart with excel Prepare a gains chart from the data in \\work\courses\e\27\e20100\ass4b.xls.
More informationStrategic Online Advertising: Modeling Internet User Behavior with
2 Strategic Online Advertising: Modeling Internet User Behavior with Patrick Johnston, Nicholas Kristoff, Heather McGinness, Phuong Vu, Nathaniel Wong, Jason Wright with William T. Scherer and Matthew
More informationHIGH SCHOOL MASS MEDIA AND MEDIA LITERACY STANDARDS
Guidelines for Syllabus Development of Mass Media Course (1084) DRAFT 1 of 7 HIGH SCHOOL MASS MEDIA AND MEDIA LITERACY STANDARDS Students study the importance of mass media as pervasive in modern life
More informationMcKinsey Problem Solving Test Practice Test A
McKinsey Problem Solving Test Practice Test A 2013 APTMetrics, Inc. 1 Instructions McKinsey Problem Solving Test Practice Test Overview and Instructions This practice test has been developed to provide
More informationElasticity. I. What is Elasticity?
Elasticity I. What is Elasticity? The purpose of this section is to develop some general rules about elasticity, which may them be applied to the four different specific types of elasticity discussed in
More informationPrinciples of Economics: Micro: Exam #2: Chapters 1-10 Page 1 of 9
Principles of Economics: Micro: Exam #2: Chapters 1-10 Page 1 of 9 print name on the line above as your signature INSTRUCTIONS: 1. This Exam #2 must be completed within the allocated time (i.e., between
More informationInventory Management Intelligent Insights ebook
Intelligent Insights Into Inventory Levels Across Sales Channels Improves Efficiencies & Drives Sales Inventory Management Intelligent Insights ebook Business Intelligence for Multichannel Inventory Management
More informationSo today we shall continue our discussion on the search engines and web crawlers. (Refer Slide Time: 01:02)
Internet Technology Prof. Indranil Sengupta Department of Computer Science and Engineering Indian Institute of Technology, Kharagpur Lecture No #39 Search Engines and Web Crawler :: Part 2 So today we
More informationwebinars creating blog posts customer quotes CONTENT MARKETING for MINISTRIES video tutorials lead strategy inform sharing A publication of
creating webinars customer quotes blog posts CONTENT MARKETING for MINISTRIES 1 1 video tutorials lead strategy sharing inform A publication of Content Marketing 101 Whether you ve attended a webinar,
More informationThis unit will lay the groundwork for later units where the students will extend this knowledge to quadratic and exponential functions.
Algebra I Overview View unit yearlong overview here Many of the concepts presented in Algebra I are progressions of concepts that were introduced in grades 6 through 8. The content presented in this course
More informationAnnex 8. Market Failure in Broadcasting
Annex 8 Market Failure in Broadcasting 202 Review of the Future Funding of the BBC Market Failure in the Broadcasting Industry An efficient broadcasting market? Economic efficiency is a situation in which
More informationIncrease Online Sales. Site Search. Whitepaper
Whitepaper Increase Online Sales by Improving Ecommerce Site Search Online retailers can reduce abandons and increase conversions by meeting customer demand for accurate, relevant website searches. April
More informationThe Effects of Start Prices on the Performance of the Certainty Equivalent Pricing Policy
BMI Paper The Effects of Start Prices on the Performance of the Certainty Equivalent Pricing Policy Faculty of Sciences VU University Amsterdam De Boelelaan 1081 1081 HV Amsterdam Netherlands Author: R.D.R.
More informationLinear Programming. Solving LP Models Using MS Excel, 18
SUPPLEMENT TO CHAPTER SIX Linear Programming SUPPLEMENT OUTLINE Introduction, 2 Linear Programming Models, 2 Model Formulation, 4 Graphical Linear Programming, 5 Outline of Graphical Procedure, 5 Plotting
More informationCredit Card Market Study Interim Report: Annex 4 Switching Analysis
MS14/6.2: Annex 4 Market Study Interim Report: Annex 4 November 2015 This annex describes data analysis we carried out to improve our understanding of switching and shopping around behaviour in the UK
More informationCustomer Life Time Value
Customer Life Time Value Tomer Kalimi, Jacob Zahavi and Ronen Meiri Contents Introduction... 2 So what is the LTV?... 2 LTV in the Gaming Industry... 3 The Modeling Process... 4 Data Modeling... 5 The
More informationHP WebInspect Tutorial
HP WebInspect Tutorial Introduction: With the exponential increase in internet usage, companies around the world are now obsessed about having a web application of their own which would provide all the
More informationLECTURE 1 SERVICE INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
LECTURE 1 SERVICE INVENTORY MANAGEMENT Learning objective To discuss the role of service inventory and types of inventories in service sector 10.1 Service Inventory A Service product can be viewed as a
More informationLast Updated: 08/27/2013. Measuring Social Media for Social Change A Guide for Search for Common Ground
Last Updated: 08/27/2013 Measuring Social Media for Social Change A Guide for Search for Common Ground Table of Contents What is Social Media?... 3 Structure of Paper... 4 Social Media Data... 4 Social
More information10 Tips on How to Plan a Successful Internet Business. Robert Rustici
10 Tips on How to Plan a Successful Internet Business Robert Rustici 1. Define Your Business Type - Going Outside of the Box Will Cost You When planning to create an Internet Business there are three common
More informationBranding and Search Engine Marketing
Branding and Search Engine Marketing Abstract The paper investigates the role of paid search advertising in delivering optimal conversion rates in brand-related search engine marketing (SEM) strategies.
More informationOFFICIAL VOICES.COM USER GUIDE A CLIENT S GUIDE TO GETTING STARTED AT VOICES.COM. Go to Voices.com
OFFICIAL VOICES.COM USER GUIDE A CLIENT S GUIDE TO GETTING STARTED AT VOICES.COM 1 Table of Contents Welcome to Voices.com 3 Your Profile 6 Inbox 7 Job Postings 8 Job Offers 10 Payments 13 Help 15 Go For
More informationthe Median-Medi Graphing bivariate data in a scatter plot
the Median-Medi Students use movie sales data to estimate and draw lines of best fit, bridging technology and mathematical understanding. david c. Wilson Graphing bivariate data in a scatter plot and drawing
More informationHow Media Drive Online Success: Increasing Web Traffic and Search
How Media Drive Online Success: Increasing Web Traffic and Search As consumer activity on the web increases, marketers are making the Internet a more important element in their marketing plans, seeking
More informationTop 12 Website Tips. How to work with the Search Engines
Top 12 Website Tips 1. Put your website at the heart of your marketing strategy 2. Have a clear purpose for your website 3. Do extensive SEO keyword research 4. Understand what your online competitors
More informationState of the Web Address: Navigating the Ever-Changing Web
State of the Web Address: Navigating the Ever-Changing Web Presented by Mike Mazzuca, Web Presence Advisor www.officite.com 1 Who is Officite? Headquarters: Downers Grove, IL Founded: 2002 30,000+ Practice
More informationPIM for Search Engine Optimization
White Paper PIM for Search Engine Optimization 5 Ways to Supercharge your SEO with PIM This document contains Confidential, Proprietary and Trade Secret Information ( Confidential Information ) of Informatica
More informationGoogle Analytics Guide
Google Analytics Guide 1 We re excited that you re implementing Google Analytics to help you make the most of your website and convert more visitors. This deck will go through how to create and configure
More informationInvesting in Bond Funds:
: What s in YOUR bond fund? By: Bruce A. Hyde and Steven Saunders Summary Investors who rely primarily on duration in choosing a bond fund may inadvertently introduce extension risk to their bond portfolio.
More informationImmigration Law Firm GUCL: Updating Traditional Marketing and Combining SEO to Broaden Reach
Immigration Law Firm GUCL: Updating Traditional Marketing and Combining SEO to Broaden Reach (Zhu, Jia Li Lily) July, 2010 Immigration Law Firm GUCL Updating Traditional Marketing and Combining SEO to
More informationAre Lottery Players Affected by Winning History? Evidence from China s Individual Lottery Betting Panel Data
Are Lottery Players Affected by Winning History? Evidence from China s Individual Lottery Betting Panel Data Jia Yuan University of Macau September 2011 Abstract I explore a unique individual level lottery
More informationThe Effect of Dropping a Ball from Different Heights on the Number of Times the Ball Bounces
The Effect of Dropping a Ball from Different Heights on the Number of Times the Ball Bounces Or: How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Ball Comment [DP1]: Titles, headings, and figure/table captions
More informationEVALUATION OF THE PAIRS TRADING STRATEGY IN THE CANADIAN MARKET
EVALUATION OF THE PAIRS TRADING STRATEGY IN THE CANADIAN MARKET By Doris Siy-Yap PROJECT SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF MASTER IN BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION Approval
More informationPresentation Details: Mobile Marketing, SEO & Visibility: Why You Should Care. Presented To: AMADC
Presentation Details: Mobile Marketing, SEO & Visibility: Why You Should Care Presented To: AMADC Mobile Changed Everything! Mobile Changed Everything! Going Mobile 1. What is Mobile? 2. Why Mobile? 3.
More information