1 DEÜ MÜHENDİSLİK FAKÜLTESİ FEN VE MÜHENDİSLİK DERGİSİ Cilt: 9 Sayı: sh Mayıs 007 SEISMIC PERFORMANCE ASSESSMENT OF REINFORCED CONCRETE STRUCTURES (BETONARME YAPILARIN SİSMİK PERFORMANSININ DEĞERLENDİRİLMESİ) Taner UÇAR*, Mustafa DÜZGÜN** ABSTRACT/ÖZET In this study, determination of the performance levels of structural systems by the Capacity Spectrum Method and the Displacement Coefficients Method, which are used to determine performance levels of structures by considering structural capacity obtained from pushover analysis is intended. For this purpose, five-storey reinforced concrete 3D frame system structures having the same floor plan are considered in the analysis. Also, to observe the differences in the performance levels, a sample structure having same story heights in the first phase and then first story height is increased in order to examine the weak story irregularity is taken into consideration. s are designed in accordance with Turkish Standards (TS 500) and the Turkish Earthquake Code. Life safety (LS) structural performance level is chosen as a target for the sample structures under a design earthquake that may be exceeded in a 50-year period with 10 percent probability. The capacity curves of the sample structures are obtained from pushover analysis and their performance levels are determined by the Capacity Spectrum Method and the Displacement Coefficients Method. Bu çalışmada yapı sistemlerinin artımsal itme analizi ile belirlenen yapısal kapasitesini esas alan ve yapıların performans seviyesinin belirlenmesinde kullanılan Kapasite Spektrumu Yöntemi ve Deplasman Katsayıları Yöntemi ile performans seviyelerinin belirlenmesi amaçlanmıştır. Bu amaçla, kat planları aynı olan beş katlı betonarme çerçeveli sistemli yapılar dikkate alınmıştır. Ayrıca performans seviyelerindeki farklılıkları görmek üzere seçilen yapının önce tüm katları aynı yükseklikte tasarlanmış, daha sonra zemin kat yükseklikleri arttırılarak ortaya çıkan zayıf kat düzensizliğinin etkisi irdelenmeye çalışılmıştır. Yapılar, TS 500 ve DBYBHY 007 kuralları çerçevesinde tasarlanmıştır.kullanılan yapı sistemleri için 50 yıllık süreç içinde aşılma olasılığı %10 olan tasarım depremi etkisi altında can güvenliği (CG) performans seviyesi hedeflenmiştir. Artımsal itme analizi ile yapıların kapasite eğrileri elde edilmiş ve Kapasite Spektrumu Yöntemi ve Deplasman Katsayıları Yöntemi ile performans seviyeleri belirlenmiştir. KEYWORDS/ANAHTAR KELİMELER Pushover analysis, Capacity spectrum method, Displacement coefficients method, Performance level Artımsal itme analizi, Kapasite spektrumu yöntemi, Deplasman katsayıları yöntemi, Performans seviyesi *Dokuz Eylül Üniversitesi, Mimarlık Fakültesi, Mimarlık Bölümü, İZMİR **Dokuz Eylül Üniversitesi, Mühendislik Fakültesi, İnşaat Mühendisliği Bölümü, İZMİR
2 Sayfa No: 64 T. UÇAR, M. DÜZGÜN 1. INTRODUCTION Various analysis methods, both elastic (linear) and inelastic (nonlinear), are available for the analysis of reinforced concrete structures. The methods that take part in codes and used for analyses of structures under lateral loads, are generally based on linear-elastic behaviour of structures under earthquake effects. In linear-elastic analysis of structural systems, elastic earthquake forces are reduced according to defined reduction factor, which varies based on typical inelastic response of structural systems. Although an elastic analysis gives a good indication of the elastic capacity of structures and indicates where first yielding will occur, but it can not predict failure mechanism of structure and account for redistribution of forces during the progressive yieldings (ATC 40, 1996). The damages and the economical losses during the last major earthquakes (Loma Prieta earthquake and Northridge earthquake), introduced a new approach in seismic design of structures called Performance Based Design and Evaluation. In performance based design and evaluation of structures under earthquake effects, it is necessary to determine the nonlinear behaviour of structures. Both nonlinear time history analysis and nonlinear static analysis procedures are used for this objective. The most basic inelastic analysis method, known as the Time History Analysis, is considered very complex and impractical for general use. For this reason, nonlinear static analysis methods have become popular. The central focus of the nonlinear static analysis methods is the generation of the capacity curve or pushover curve. This curve represents lateral displacement as a function of the force applied to the structure. The use of nonlinear static analysis methods for design and evaluation helps engineers to understand better how structures will behave when subjected to major earthquakes, where it is assumed that the elastic capacity of the structure will be exceeded (ATC 40, 1996). The most common used nonlinear static analysis procedures for the evaluation of the performance levels of structures are the Capacity Spectrum Method, which uses the intersection of the capacity curve with a reduced response spectrum to estimate the maximum displacement and the Displacement Coefficients Method, which provides a direct numerical process for calculating the displacement demand.. CONCEPTUAL DEVELOPMENT OF THE CAPACITY SPECTRUM METHOD Application of the Capacity Spectrum Method requires both the demand response spectra and structural capacity curves to be plotted in the spectral acceleration vs. spectral displacement format which is known as Acceleration-Displacement Response Spectra (ADRS). In order to convert a spectrum from the traditional spectral acceleration, S a vs period, T format found in the building code to ADRS format, it is necessary to determine the value of S di for each point on the curve, S ai, T i (Figure 1). This can be done by Equation 1 (ATC 40, 1996). S di T = Sai (1) 4π In order to use the Capacity Spectrum Method, it is also necessary to convert the capacity curve obtained from pushover analysis in terms of base shear, V T and roof displacement, δ max to the capacity spectrum (Figure ). Capacity spectrum is the representation of the capacity curve in ADRS format. This transformation can be done by using Equation and Equation 3.
3 Fen ve Mühendislik Dergisi Sayfa No: 65 S a S a T 0 S a T i S ai S ai S S a d Figure1. Response spectra in traditional and ADRS format VT / W = () α 1 1 T 0 δmax = (3) PF φ roof,1 In Equation and Equation 3, the coefficients α 1 and PF 1 are calculated as follows in Equation 4 and Equation 5. T i N (w iφi,1 / g) i= 1 α 1 = (4) N N (w i / g) (w iφ i,1 / g) i= 1 i= 1 N (w iφi,1 / g) i= 1 PF = 1 (5) N (w iφ i,1/ g) i= 1 In these equations, S a is spectral acceleration, S d is spectral displacement, PF 1 is modal participation of the first natural mode, α 1 is modal mass coefficient for the first natural mode, N is the uppermost level in the main portion of the structure, W is total building weight (dead weight of building plus likely live loads), W i /g is mass assigned to level i, φ i, 1 is amplitude of mode 1 at level i and φ roof, 1 is normalized amplitude of mode 1 at roof level. T S di S d V T Capacity Curve S a Capacity Spectrum V i S ai δ i (δ max ) S di Figure. Conversion of capacity curve to capacity spectrum S d
4 Sayfa No: 66 T. UÇAR, M. DÜZGÜN After the representation of response spectra and capacity curves in ADRS format, an initial performance (maximum acceleration a pi and displacement d pi ) point is selected. This may be based on equal-displacement approximation as shown in Figure 3 or any other point based on engineering judgment (FEMA 440, 004). S a Equal Displacement Approximation a pi d pi Capacity Spectrum For Figure 3. Selection of initial performance point Initial ADRS Demand Spectrum With %5 Damping S d Another step in the Capacity Spectrum Method is the construction of bilinear representation of capacity spectrum. A bilinear representation of the capacity spectrum is needed to estimate the effective damping and appropriate reduction of spectral demand. This bilinearezation defines the initial period, T 0, yield displacement, d y, and yield acceleration, a y (Figure 4). By using the values obtained from bilinear representation of capacity spectrum, the values of post-elastic stiffness, α, and ductility, μ, can be calculated as follows in Equation 6 and Equation 7 (FEMA 440, 004). S a T 0 Capacity Spectrum For a pi a i Area 1 Area Bilinear Representation Of Capacity Spectrum S d d y d pi Figure 4. Bilinear representation of capacity spectrum
5 Fen ve Mühendislik Dergisi Sayfa No: 67 a pi a y d pi d y α = a y d y (6) d pi µ = d (7) y By using the calculated values of post-elastic stiffness and ductility, the corresponding effective damping, β eff, and the corresponding effective period, T eff, can be calculated. Effective viscous damping values for all hysteretic model types and alpha values have the following form, where β 0 is hysteretic damping (FEMA 440, 004): 3 β = A( µ 1) + B( µ 1 + β for μ < 4.0 (8a) eff ) eff = C + D( µ 1) + β0 0 β for 4.0 μ 6.5 (8b) F( µ 1) 1 Teff β eff = E + β 0 F( 1) T for μ > 6.5 (8c) µ 0 Values of the coefficients in these equations for effective damping of the hysteretic model type are given in Table 1 (FEMA 440, 004). Table 1. Coefficients to be used in equations 8a, 8b, 8c for effective damping Hysteretic Model Stiffness Degrading α (%) A B C D E F Effective period values for all hysteretic model types and alpha values have the following form (FEMA 440, 004): 3 T = G( µ 1) + H( µ 1) + 1T for μ < 4.0 (9a) eff eff [ ] 0 [ I + J( µ 1) 1] T 0 T = + for 4.0 μ 6.5 (9b) ( µ 1) Teff = K T 0 for μ > 6.5 (9c) 1+ L( µ ) Values of the coefficients in the equations for effective period of the hysteretic model type are shown in Table (FEMA 440, 004). Using the effective damping, β eff, B(β eff ) which is used to adjust spectral acceleration ordinates, is calculated (FEMA 440, 004). 4 B = (10) 5.6 lnβ eff (%) Spectral acceleration ordinates are adjusted with the equation given below (FEMA 440, 004).
6 Sayfa No: 68 T. UÇAR, M. DÜZGÜN (Sa )%5 (Sa ) β = (11) B( β ) eff Table. Coefficients to be used in equations 9a, 9b, 9c for effective period Hysteretic Model Stiffness Degrading α (%) G H I J K L The estimated maximum displacement, d i, is determined by using the intersection of the radial effective period, T eff, with the ADRS adjusted for β eff. The estimated maximum acceleration, a i, corresponds to d i on the capacity curve (Figure 5). The estimated maximum displacement, d i, is compared with the initial assumption. If it is within acceptable tolerance (0.95d pi d i 1.05d pi ), the performance point corresponds to a i and d i. If it is not within the acceptable tolarance, the procedure mentioned above is repeated. S a T 0 T eff Capacity Spectrum For a i a pi Initial Demand Spectrum Reduced Demand Spectrum Figure 5. Determination of estimated maximum displacement using direct iteration The obtained a i and d i values are converted to base shear and maximum roof displacement by using the following equations. V = S W (1) T α 1 max a δ = PF φ S (13) 1 roof,1 d d pi d i To determine the performance level of a structure, the structure is statically pushed to the performance point. Comparing the maximum displacement value and internal forcedeformation states with the limit values, the performance level of the structure can be determined (İrtem and Türker, 00) (Figure 6). S d
7 Fen ve Mühendislik Dergisi Sayfa No: 69 Shear Force Immediate Occupancy Life Safety Collapse Prevention Moment Immediate Occupancy Life Safety Collapse Prevention Roof Displacement (δ max ) Plastic Rotation (θ p ) Figure 6. Determination of performance level 3. THE DISPLACEMENT COEFFICIENTS METHOD The Displacement Coefficients Method provides a direct numerical process for calculating the displacement demand. It does not require converting the capacity curve into spectral coordinates. The nonlinear force-displacement relationship between base shear and displacement shall be replaced with an idealized relationship to calculate the effective lateral stiffness, K e, and effective yield strength, V y, of the structure. This relationship shall be bilinear, with initial slope K e and post yield slope K s. Line segments on the idealized force-displacement curve shall be located using an iterative graphical procedure that approximately balances the area above and below the curve. The effective lateral stiffness, K e, shall be taken as the secant stiffness calculated at the base shear force corresponding to 60% of the effective yield strength of the structure (ATC 40, 1996) (Figure 7). The effective fundamantal period in the direction under consideration shall be based on the idealized force-displacement curve and can be calculated in accordance with the Equation 14. K i T e = Ti (14) K e where T i is elastic fundamental period in the direction under consideration calculated by elastic dynamic analysis, T e is effective period of the structure, K i is elastic lateral stiffness of the structure in the direction under consideration and K e is effective lateral stiffness of the structure in the direction under consideration. The target displacement shall be calculated in accordance with Equation 15 (FEMA 440, 004). Te δ T = C0C1CSa g (15) 4π In this equation C 0 is modification factor to relate spectral displacement of an equivalent single degree of freedom system to the roof displacement of multi degree of freedom system. C 0 can be taken as the first modal participation factor ( PF1 φ roof, 1) at the level of the control node, the modal participation factor at the level of the control node is calculated using a shape vector corresponding to the deflected shape of the structure at the target displacement or the appropriate value from Table 3.
8 Sayfa No: 70 T. UÇAR, M. DÜZGÜN Shear Force (V T ) Capacity Curve K i V y 0.60V y A 1 K s A 3 A 1 A +A 3 A K e δ y δ t (target displacement) Figure 7. Idealization of capacity curve (δ max ) Number of Stories Table 3. Values for modification factor C 0 Shear Buildings Other Buildings Any Load Pattern Triangular Load Pattern Uniform Load Pattern C 1 is the modification factor which relates expected maximum inelastic displacements to displacements calculated for linear elastic response. C 1 can be determined from Equation 16. R 1 C1 = 1+ (16) ate where T e is the effective fundamental period of the single degree of freedom model of the structure in seconds and R is the strength ratio computed with Equation 17. The constant, a, is equal to 130, 90 and 60 for the site classes B, C and D, respectively. Sa R = Cm Vy / W (17) C m is the effective mass factor from Table 4. C m shall be taken as 1.0 if the fundamental period, T, is greater than 1.0 second. For periods greater than 1.0 sec., C 1 may be assumed to be 1.0. C is the modification factor to represent the effect of pinched hysteretic shape, stiffness degradation and strength deterioration on maximum displacement response. It is recommended that the C coefficient to be as follows. 1 R 1 C = 1+ (18) 800 T C 1 may be assumed to be equal to 1.0 for periods greater than 0.7 sec.
9 Fen ve Mühendislik Dergisi Sayfa No: 71 No. of Stories Concrete Moment Frame Table 4. Values for effective mass factor C m Concrete Shear Wall Concrete Pier- Spandrel Steel Moment Frame Steel Concentric Braced Frame Steel Eccentric Braced Frame Other CASE STUDIES To determine the performance levels, five-storey reinforced concrete 3D frame system structures having the same floor plan are considered in the analyses. To observe the differences in the performance levels, the above mentioned five-storey reinforced concrete structure is taken into consideration with the same story heights (story height=3m) and then in the second phase, the first story height (first story heights=5m) is increased intentionally to examine the weak story irregularity. Two five-storey reinforced concrete 3D frame system structures are designed geometrically and materially in accordance with TS 500 and the Turkish Earthquake Code (TS500, 000; DBYBHY, 007). Life safety structural performance level is chosen as a target for the sample structures under a design earthquake that may be exceeded in a 50-year period with 10 percent probability (DBYBHY, 007). In the study; the five-storey reinforced concrete 3D frame system structure with the same story heights is symbolized as RC 5.1., the five-storey reinforced concrete 3D frame system structure with the increased first story height is symbolized as RC 5... The floor plan of the structures considered in the analyses are given in Figure A 5 m 5 m 5 m 5 m B C D E 5 m 5 m 5 m 5 m Figure 8. Floor plan for the RC 5.1. and the RC 5.. The parameters used in the design of the five-storey reinforced concrete 3D frame system structures and the dimensions of structural members are given in Table 5.
10 Sayfa No: 7 T. UÇAR, M. DÜZGÜN Table 5. The parameters used in the design of the five-storey reinforced concrete 3D frame system structures and the dimensions of the structural members Five-storey Reinforced Concrete 3D Frame System s (RC 5.1. and RC 5..) Earthquake Zone 1 Effective Ground Acceleration Coefficient, A Soil Z Importance Coefficient, I 1 Structural System Behaviour Coefficient, R 8 Concrete C0 Steel S40 Slab Thickness (cm) 1 Dimensions of Beams (cm) [In all stories] 5x50 Dimensions of Columns (cm) [In all stories] 50x Pushover Curves of The s To obtain the pushover curves of the structures SAP 000 Structural Analysis Programme is used (CSI SAP 000 V-8.1.5, 00). In pushover analyses of the structures, plastic hinge hypothesis is taken into consideration. In that hypothesis, it is assumed that plastic deformations are considered to gather in sections called plastic hinge and other parts of system behave linear elastic. For effective stiffness values, the values given in FEMA 356 are used. In the performance evaluations of the structures, limit values for different performance levels given in FEMA 356 in terms of plastic hinge rotation are taken into consideration (FEMA 356, 000). Capacity curves obtained from the pushover analyses are presented in Figure 10 for the sample structures. RC 5.1. RC 5.. Figure 10. Capacity curves of the five-storey reinforced concrete 3D frame system structures The results obtained from the Capacity Spectrum Method For the sample structures are presented below. In Table 7, δ max is the displacement value and V T is the shear force value at the calculated performance point.
11 Fen ve Mühendislik Dergisi Sayfa No: 73 Table 7. Performance point values of the structures obtained by the Capacity Spectrum Method T eff Β eff S a S d δ max V T PF1f roof,1 α 1 (sec) (%) (g) (cm) (cm) (kn) RC RC By performing the calculation steps of the Displacement Coefficients Method, the performance point of the sample structures are determined and the corresponding values of that point are given in Table 8. Table 8. Performance point values of the structures obtained by the Displacement Coefficients Method δ max V T C 0 C 1 C S a (g) T e (sec) (cm) (kn) RC RC Determination of Performance Levels of the s The performance levels of the sample structures are determined by both using the Capacity Spectrum Method and the Displacement Coefficients Method. The numbers of plastic hinges occurred in structural members, the maximum plastic hinge rotations, the maximum story drifts and the performance levels which are determined with the two methods, are given below Determination of Performance Levels by Using the Capacity Spectrum Method To evaluate the performance levels of the sample structures, the structures are statically pushed to the target displacement value, which was determined by the Capacity Spectrum Method. The numbers of plastic hinges in beams and columns, the maximum plastic hinge rotations in the performance point and the maximum total drifts of the structures statically pushed to the performance point are given in Table 10, Table 11 and Table 1 respectively. Table 10. The numbers of plastic hinges according to performance levels Plastic Hinge Numbers According To Performance Levels Beam Column <IO IO-LS LS- CP >CP <IO IO-LS LS- CP RC RC Table 11. The maximum plastic hinge rotations Maximum Plastic Hinge Rotation Values (rad) Beam Column RC RC >CP
12 Sayfa No: 74 T. UÇAR, M. DÜZGÜN Table 1. The maximum story drifts Maximum Story Drift (%) Performance Level RC IO-LS RC IO-LS According to the values given in Table 10, Table 11 and Table 1, the performance levels of the sample structures are determined. The performance level of the five-storey reinforced concrete 3D frame system structure with the same story heights (RC 5.1.) is found to be between the Immediate Occupancy and the Life Safety. For the five-storey reinforced concrete 3D frame system structure with the increased first story height (RC 5..), the performance level between the Life Safety and the Collapse Prevention is obtained Determination of Performance Levels by Using the Displacement Coefficients Method To evaluate the performance levels of the sample structures, the structures are statically pushed to the target displacement value, which was determined by the Displacement Coefficients Method. The numbers of plastic hinges in beams and columns, the maximum plastic hinge rotations in the performance point and the maximum total drifts of the structures statically pushed to the performance point are given in Table 13, Table 14 and Table 15 respectively. Table 13. The numbers of plastic hinges according to performance levels Plastic Hinge Numbers According To Performance Levels Beam Column <IO IO-LS LS-CP >CP <IO IO-LS LS- >CP CP RC RC Table 14. The maximum plastic hinge rotations Maximum Plastic Hinge Rotation Values (rad) Beam Column RC RC Table 15. The maximum story drifts Maximum Story Drift (%) Performance Level RC IO-LS RC IO-LS Using the values given in Table 13, Table 14 and Table 15, the performance levels of sample structures are determined. The performance level of the five-storey reinforced concrete 3D frame system structure with the same story heights (RC 5.1.) is found to be between the Immediate Occupancy and the Life Safety. For the five-storey reinforced
13 Fen ve Mühendislik Dergisi Sayfa No: 75 concrete 3D frame system structure with the increased first story height (RC 5..), the performance level between the Life Safety and the Collapse Prevention is obtained. 5. CONCLUSIONS In this study, it is intended to determine the performance levels of structural systems under earthquake effects by using the Capacity Spectrum Method and the Displacement Coefficients Method, which are both used to determine performance levels of structures by considering structural capacity obtained from pushover analysis. For this purpose, five-storey reinforced concrete 3D frame system structures having the same floor plan are considered in the analyses. To observe the differences in the performance levels, the above mentioned fivestorey reinforced concrete structure is taken into consideration having the same story heights in the first phase and then the first story height is increased intentionally in order to examine the weak story irregularity. Two five-storey reinforced concrete 3D frame system structures are designed geometrically and materially in accordance with TS 500 and the Turkish Earthquake Code. Life safety structural performance level is chosen as a target for the sample structures under a design earthquake that may be exceeded in a 50-year period with 10 percent probability. Considering the performance levels for the sample structures obtained by the Capacity Spectrum Method and the Displacement Coefficients Method, it can be said that the mentioned two methods gives nearly the same performance levels. According to the performance evaluation with the Capacity Spectrum Method and the Displacement Coefficients Method, the five-storey reinforced concrete 3D frame system structure with the same story heights (RC 5.1.) can easily get the Life Safety performance level under the design earthquake. For the five-storey reinforced concrete 3D frame system structure with the weak story irregularity (RC 5..), the obtained performance levels are worse than the performance levels of the five-storey reinforced concrete 3D frame system structure having the same story heights (RC 5.1.). In the sample structure with the weak story irregularity, the values of plastic hinge rotations in beams and columns (especially in the first story colums) and the story drifts are increased. Considering the results obtained from this study, the earthquake behaviour of the structure with the weak story irregularity is in the negative aspect. In case with weak story irregularity, the total earthquake force that the structure can resist, which is called the seismic capacity of the structure, is decreased. REFERENCES ATC 40 (1996): ATC 40 Seismic Evaluation and Retrofit of Concrete Buildings (V.1), Washington DC. CSI SAP 000 V (00): Integrated Finite Element Analysis and Design of s Basic Analysis Reference Manual, Computer and s Inc., Berkeley, California. DBYBHY (007): Deprem Bölgelerinde Yapılacak Binalar Hakkında Yönetmelik, İnşaat Mühendisleri Odası İzmir Şubesi Yayını, Bayındırlık ve İskan Bakanlığı. FEMA 356 (000): FEMA 356 Prestandart and Commentary For The Seismic Rehabilitation Of Buildings, Washington DC. FEMA 440 (004): FEMA 440 Improvement of Nonlinear Static Seismic Analysis Procedures, Washington DC.
14 Sayfa No: 76 T. UÇAR, M. DÜZGÜN İrtem E., Türker K. (00): Yapıların Deprem Yükleri Altındaki Lineer Olmayan Davranışının Belirlenmesinde Kullanılan Statik Yöntemlerin Karşılaştırılması, Balıkesir Üniversitesi IV. Mühendislik-Mimarlık Sempozyumu, sf TS 500 (000): TS500 Betonarme Yapıların Tasarım ve Yapım Kuralları, Türk Standartları Enstitüsü.
ASCE 41 Seismic Rehabilitation of Existing Buildings Presentation Topics: 1. How to define a Rehabilitation Objective per ASCE 41. 2. Data Collection and Testing. 3. Analysis Requirements. 4. Modeling.
SEISMIC RETROFITTING OF STRUCTURES RANJITH DISSANAYAKE DEPT. OF CIVIL ENGINEERING, FACULTY OF ENGINEERING, UNIVERSITY OF PERADENIYA, SRI LANKA ABSTRACT Many existing reinforced concrete structures in present
CHALLENGE JOURNAL OF STRUCTURAL MECHANICS 1 (4) (2015) 161 167 Seismic performance evaluation of an existing school building in Turkey Hüseyin Bilgin * Department of Civil Engineering, Epoka University,
Volume, Special Issue, ICSTSD Behaviour of Steel Bracing as a Global Retrofitting Technique Miss S. S. Nibhorkar M. E (Structure) Scholar, Civil Engineering Department, G. H. Raisoni College of Engineering
IABSE ANNUAL MEETING, LONDON, 19 TH SEPTEMBER 2011 SEISMIC APPROACH DESIGN COMPARISON BETWEEN IBC AND ITALIAN DM2008 Ing. Luca Zanaica Senior Structural Engineer Ing. Francesco Caobianco Senior Structural
ISET Journal of Earthquake Technology, Paper No. 454, Vol. 42, No. 2-3, June-September 25, pp. 21-46 SEISMIC RETROFITTING OF REINFORCED CONCRETE BUILDINGS USING TRADITIONAL AND INNOVATIVE TECHNIQUES Giuseppe
Non-linear behavior and seismic safety of reinforced concrete structures K. Girgin & E. Oer Istanbul Technical University, Faculty of Civil Engineering, Istanbul, Turkey Keywords: Reinforced concrete structures,
Paper No. 682 PERFORMANCE BASED SEISMIC EVALUATION AND RETROFITTING OF UNSYMMETRICAL MEDIUM RISE BUILDINGS- A CASE STUDY Jimmy Chandra, Pennung Warnitchai, Deepak Rayamajhi, Naveed Anwar and Shuaib Ahmad
Rehabilitation of a 1985 Steel Moment- Frame Building Gregg Haskell, a) M.EERI A 1985 steel moment frame is seismically upgraded using passive energy dissipation, without adding stiffness to the system.
AN IMPROVED SEISMIC DESIGN APPROACH FOR TWO-COLUMN REINFORCED CONCRETE BENTS OVER FLEXIBLE FOUNDATIONS WITH PREDEFINED DAMAGE LEVELS ABSTRACT: T. Yılmaz 1 ve A. Caner 2 1 Araştırma Görevlisi, İnşaat Müh.
SEISMIC DESIGN Various building codes consider the following categories for the analysis and design for earthquake loading: 1. Seismic Performance Category (SPC), varies from A to E, depending on how the
EVALUATION OF SEISMIC RESPONSE - FACULTY OF LAND RECLAMATION AND ENVIRONMENTAL ENGINEERING -BUCHAREST Abstract Camelia SLAVE University of Agronomic Sciences and Veterinary Medicine of Bucharest, 59 Marasti
European Online Journal of Natural and Social Sciences 2015; Vol.3, No.3 Special Issue on New Trends in Architecture, Civil Engineering, and Urban Studies ISSN 1805-3602 www.european-science.com The Effect
Seismic Evaluation and Retrofitting of RC Building by Using Energy Dissipating Devices S. I. Khan 1, Prof. P. O. Modani 2 1(Department of Civil Engineering, B.N.C.O.E, Pusad) 2(Assist. Professor Department
Prof. Oral Buyukozturk Massachusetts Institute of Technology Outline 1 1.054/1.541 Mechanics and Design of Concrete Structures (3-0-9) Outline 1 Introduction / Design Criteria for Reinforced Concrete Structures
EXAMPLE CALCULATIONS to the Requirements of BC3: 2013 NOTE 1. Whilst every effort has been made to ensure accuracy of the information contained in this design guide, the Building and Construction Authority
10NCEE Tenth U.S. National Conference on Earthquake Engineering Frontiers of Earthquake Engineering July 21-25, 2014 Anchorage, Alaska REVISION OF GUIDELINE FOR POST- EARTHQUAKE DAMAGE EVALUATION OF RC
CONVEGNO SISMA ED ELEMENTI NON STRUTTURALI Approcci, Stati Limite e Verifiche Prestazionali Bologna 24 ottobre 2014 PROGETTO DI ELEMENTI NON STRUTTURALI SOGGETTI AD AZIONI SISMICHE G. Michele Calvi IUSS
SEISMIC RETROFIT DESIGN CRITERIA British Columbia Ministry of Transportation June 30, 2005 Prepared by: Recommended by: Approved by: Don Kennedy, P.Eng., Associated Engineering (BC) Sharlie Huffman, P.
VISUALIZATION OF NONLINEAR SEISMIC BEHAVIOR OF THE INTERSTATE 5/14 NORTH CONNECTOR BRIDGE Robert K. Dowell Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering San Diego State University Abstract This paper
Hybrid simulation evaluation of the suspended zipper braced frame Tony Yang Post-doctoral scholar University of California, Berkeley Acknowledgements: Andreas Schellenberg, Bozidar Stojadinovic, Jack Moehle
Performance-based Evaluation of the Seismic Response of Bridges with Foundations Designed to Uplift Marios Panagiotou Assistant Professor, University of California, Berkeley Acknowledgments Pacific Earthquake
Project Structural Conditions Survey and Seismic Vulnerability Assessment For SFCC Civic Center Campus 750 Eddy Street San Francisco, California 94109 Prepared For San Francisco Community College District
ABSTRACT SUAREZ, VINICIO A. Implementation of Direct Displacement-Based Design for Highway Bridges. (Under the direction of Dr. Mervyn Kowalsky). In the last decade, seismic design shifted towards Displacement-Based
DESIGN OF SLABS Department of Structures and Materials Engineering Faculty of Civil and Environmental Engineering University Tun Hussein Onn Malaysia Introduction Types of Slab Slabs are plate elements
Structural Retrofitting For Earthquake Resistance Ruben Boroschek WHO Disaster Mitigation in Health Facilities University of Chile email@example.com www.hospitalseguro.cl The following paper is part
SEISMIC CAPACITY OF EXISTING RC SCHOOL BUILDINGS IN OTA CITY, TOKYO, JAPAN Toshio OHBA, Shigeru TAKADA, Yoshiaki NAKANO, Hideo KIMURA 4, Yoshimasa OWADA 5 And Tsuneo OKADA 6 SUMMARY The 995 Hyogoken-nambu
ETABS Integrated Building Design Software Concrete Frame Design Manual Computers and Structures, Inc. Berkeley, California, USA Version 8 January 2002 Copyright The computer program ETABS and all associated
Structural Dynamics of Linear Elastic Single-Degree-of-Freedom (SDOF) Systems SDOF Dynamics 3-1 This set of slides covers the fundamental concepts of structural dynamics of linear elastic single-degree-of-freedom
1 A Case Study Comparing Two Approaches for Applying Area Loads: Tributary Area Loads vs Shell Pressure Loads By Dr. Siriwut Sasibut (Application Engineer) S-FRAME Software Inc. #1158 13351 Commerce Parkway
NIST GCR 0-97-9 Applicability of Nonlinear Multiple-Degree-of-Freedom Modeling for Design NEHRP Consultants Joint Venture A Partnership of the Applied Technology Council and the Consortium of Universities
Working Group 7: Earthquake Resistant Structures Geneva, 25 September 2015 Seismic Assessment and Retrofitting of Structures: Eurocode8 Part3 and the Greek Code on Seismic Structural Interventions Prof.
International Journal of Civil Engineering and Technology (IJCIET) Volume 6, Issue 10, Oct 2015, pp. 46-61 Article ID: IJCIET_06_10_005 Available online at http://www.iaeme.com/ijciet/issues.asp?jtype=ijciet&vtype=6&itype=10
Using Spring-Mass Models to Determine the Dynamic Response of Two-Story Buildings Subjected to Lateral Loads S.T. De la Cruz, M.A. Rodríguez & V. Hernández Autonomous University of Ciudad Juárez, Ciudad
EFFECT OF CFRP RETROFIT RETROFITTING TING APPLICATION ON SEISMIC BEHAVIOR OF HISTORIC MONUMENTAL BUI BUILD LDIING NGS S AT CAPPADOCIA REGI REGION OF TURKEY Baki OZTURK T. SENTURK and C. C. YILMAZ NIGDE
Chapter 8. Flexural Analysis of T-s 8.1. Reading Assignments Text Chapter 3.7; ACI 318, Section 8.10. 8.2. Occurrence and Configuration of T-s Common construction type.- used in conjunction with either
Earthquake Yoshimura: Engineering Control and of Engineering Seismic Drift Seismology Demand for Reinforced Concrete Buildings with Weak First Stories 7 Volume 4, Number, September 3, pp. 7 3 Control of
Reading Assignment SLAB DESIGN Chapter 9 of Text and, Chapter 13 of ACI318-02 Introduction ACI318 Code provides two design procedures for slab systems: 13.6.1 Direct Design Method (DDM) For slab systems
Journal of Civil Engineering (IEB), 34 (1) (26) 1-14 Optimum proportions for the design of suspension bridge Tanvir Manzur and Alamgir Habib Department of Civil Engineering Bangladesh University of Engineering
TECHNICAL NOTE On Cold-Formed Steel Construction 1201 15th Street, NW, Suite 320 W ashington, DC 20005 (202) 785-2022 $5.00 Design of Diagonal Strap Bracing Lateral Force Resisting Systems for the 2006
CONTRASTING DISPLACEMENT DEMANDS OF DUCTILE STRUCTURES FROM TOHOKU SUBDUCTION TO CRUSTAL EARTHQUAKE RECORDS Abstract Peter Dusicka 1 and Sarah Knoles 2 With the impending Cascadia subduction zone event
DESIGN OF SLABS Dr. G. P. Chandradhara Professor of Civil Engineering S. J. College of Engineering Mysore 1. GENERAL A slab is a flat two dimensional planar structural element having thickness small compared
Document No. :: IITK-GSDMA-EQ1-V1. Final Report :: A - Earthquake Codes IITK-GSDMA Project on Building Codes Review of Code Provisions on Design Seismic Forces for Liquid Storage Tanks by Dr. O. R. Jaiswal
Seismic retrofit of non-ductile concrete and masonry walls by steelstrips bracing Mustafa Taghdi, Michel Bruneau, & Murat Saatcioglu Ottawa Carleton Earthquake Engineering Research Centre Department of
Concrete Frame Design Manual Turkish TS 500-2000 with Turkish Seismic Code 2007 For SAP2000 ISO SAP093011M26 Rev. 0 Version 15 Berkeley, California, USA October 2011 COPYRIGHT Copyright Computers and Structures,
International Journal of Civil Engineering and Technology (IJCIET) Volume 7, Issue 2, March-April 2016, pp. 45-66, Article ID: IJCIET_07_02_004 Available online at http://www.iaeme.com/ijciet/issues.asp?jtype=ijciet&vtype=7&itype=2
Energy Dissipation Properties of Infilled RC Frames Retrofitted with CFRP * Principal Investigator: Assist. Prof. Dr. E. Yuksel, Istanbul Technical University, Istanbul. Ph.D. Student: H. Ozkaynak, Istanbul
Graphic User Interface Graphic User Interface Modeling Features Bridge Applications Segmental Bridges Cable Bridges Analysis Features Result Evaluation Design Features 02 07 13 17 28 34 43 48 2 User Interface
Chapter 3 DESIGN AND CONSTRUCTION FEATURES IMPORTANT TO SEISMIC PERFORMANCE To satisfy the performance goals of the NEHRP Recommended Seismic Provisions, a number of characteristics are important to the
NIST GCR 10-917-5 NEHRP Seismic Design Technical Brief No. 4 Nonlinear Structural Analysis For Seismic Design A Guide for Practicing Engineers Gregory G. Deierlein Andrei M. Reinhorn Michael R. Willford
Retrofitting By Means Of Post Tensioning Khaled Nahlawi 1 Abstract An analytical program was prepared to retrofit the Holy Cross Church in Santa Cruz, California. An inelastic analysis was perfonned on
FOUNDATION DESIGN Proportioning elements for: Transfer of seismic forces Strength and stiffness Shallow and deep foundations Elastic and plastic analysis Foundation Design 14-1 Load Path and Transfer to
Laterally Loaded Piles 1 Soil Response Modelled by p-y Curves In order to properly analyze a laterally loaded pile foundation in soil/rock, a nonlinear relationship needs to be applied that provides soil
International Journal of Civil Engineering and Technology (IJCIET) Volume 7, Issue 1, Jan-Feb 216, pp. 113-127, Article ID: IJCIET_7_1_1 Available online at http://www.iaeme.com/ijciet/issues.asp?jtype=ijciet&vtype=7&itype=1
The World Congress on Advances in Structural Engineering and Mechanics (ASEM' + ) Seoul, Korea, 8- September, Nonlinear Static Procedures on the Seismic Assessment of Existing Plan Asymmetric Buildings
ENERGY DISSIPATION DEVICES IN BRIDGES USING HYDRAULIC DAMPERS by E.A. Delis Bridge Engineer, Seismic Specialist Caltrans, Division of Structures Sacramento, CA 95816 R.B. Malla Assistant Professor University
Seismic Isolated Hospital Design Practice in Turkey: Erzurum Medical Campus J. Kubin, D. Kubin, A. Özmen, O.B. Şadan, E. Eroğlu Prota Engineering Design and Consultancy Services Inc. H. Sucuoğlu, S. Akkar
International Journal of Civil Engineering and Technology (IJCIET) Volume 7, Issue 3, May June 2016, pp. 373 384, Article ID: IJCIET_07_03_038 Available online at http://www.iaeme.com/ijciet/issues.asp?jtype=ijciet&vtype=7&itype=3
FALL 2013 C C Reinforced Concrete Design CIVL 4135 ii 1 Chapter 1. Introduction 1.1. Reading Assignment Chapter 1 Sections 1.1 through 1.8 of text. 1.2. Introduction In the design and analysis of reinforced
Building Project using Post-Tensioning Paulo Marques 1 Resume Nowadays building flexibility is an aspect to be taken into account at the idealization and project stages. The number of buildings that throughout
13 th World Conference on Earthquake Engineering Vancouver, B.C., Canada August 1-6, 2004 Paper No. 3292 DESIGN DRIFT REQUIREMENTS FOR LONG-PERIOD STRUCTURES Gary R. Searer 1 and Sigmund A. Freeman 2 SUMMARY
Session 5D: Benefits of Live Load Testing and Finite Element Modeling in Rating Bridges Douglas R. Heath P.E., Structural Engineer Corey Richard P.E., Project Manager AECOM Overview Bridge Testing/Rating
Analysis of seismic response control for long-span cable-stayed bridge under traveling wave input * QI ing-jun, LI iao-jun 2 ( Associate Professor, School of Civil Engineering, Shandong Jianzhu University,
This document downloaded from vulcanhammer.net since 1997, your source for engineering information for the deep foundation and marine construction industries, and the historical site for Vulcan Iron Works
New approaches in Eurocode 3 efficient global structural design Part 1: 3D model based analysis using general beam-column FEM Ferenc Papp* and József Szalai ** * Associate Professor, Department of Structural
Development of Seismic-induced Fire Risk Assessment Method for a Building AI SEKIZAWA National Research Institute of Fire and Disaster 3-14-1, Nakahara, Mitaka, Tokyo 181-8633, Japan firstname.lastname@example.org
EFFECTS ON NUMBER OF CABLES FOR MODAL ANALYSIS OF CABLE-STAYED BRIDGES Yang-Cheng Wang Associate Professor & Chairman Department of Civil Engineering Chinese Military Academy Feng-Shan 83000,Taiwan Republic
Inelastic Design Response Spectra Developed by statistical processing of actual nonlinear spectra for ground motions, hysteretic characteristics, ξ and damage indices of interest. η plastic /g µ=3 Constant
Retrofitting of RCC Structure WIH Strengthening of Shear Wall with External Post Tensioning Cables Yogesh Ghodke, G. R. Gandhe Department of Civil Engineering, Deogiri Institute of Engineering and Management
Presented at the DLSU Research Congress 15 Analyzing the Effectiveness of the Turnbuckle Exterior Post Tensioning as a Structural Retrofitting Method Using SAP Bernardo Lejano 1, Kenneth Toral 2,*, Dustin
Approximate Analysis of Statically Indeterminate Structures Every successful structure must be capable of reaching stable equilibrium under its applied loads, regardless of structural behavior. Exact analysis
Cover Introduction In regard to precast concrete systems, the addition of two new categories of Seismic Force Resisting Systems (SFRS) in IBC 2006 has created some confusion about whether to specify intermediate
Research & development Earthquake tragedy and application of seismic isolation, energy dissipation and other seismic control systems to protect structures in China 90% of the Chinese territory is seismic.
Critical Facility Round Table October 16, 2003 San Francisco Seismic Risk for Data Centers David Bonneville Senior Principal Degenkolb Engineers San Francisco, California Presentation Outline Seismic Risk
ANALYSIS OF BUILDING STRUCTURES WITH SOFT STORIES A THESIS SUBMITTED TO THE GRADUATE SCHOOL OF NATURAL AND APPLIED SCIENCES OF ATILIM UNIVERSITY BY MEHMET ALPER ALTUNTOP IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS
International Journal of Civil Engineering and Technology (IJCIET) Volume 6, Issue 11, Nov 215, pp. 1-1, Article ID: IJCIET_6_11_1 Available online at http://www.iaeme.com/ijciet/issues.asp?jtype=ijciet&vtype=6&itype=11
Finite Element Formulation for Plates - Handout 3 - Dr Fehmi Cirak (fc286@) Completed Version Definitions A plate is a three dimensional solid body with one of the plate dimensions much smaller than the
Finite Element Formulation for Beams - Handout 2 - Dr Fehmi Cirak (fc286@) Completed Version Review of Euler-Bernoulli Beam Physical beam model midline Beam domain in three-dimensions Midline, also called