1 Increasing IT Efficiency in a Dynamic Datacenter with a Virtualized Storage Solution End to End Efficiency Delivered by Microsoft Server Virtualization and Compellent Storage Virtualization Solution Blueprint Published: April 2010 Abstract: This white paper provides a blueprint for a highly efficient and dynamic datacenter using Microsoft and Compellent technologies. The solution is enabled by Microsoft Virtualization and the Compellent Storage Center SAN solution.
2 Increasing IT Efficiency in a Dynamic Datacenter with a Virtualized Storage Solution ii Copyright The information contained in this document represents the current view of Microsoft Corporation on the issues discussed as of the date of publication. Because Microsoft must respond to changing market conditions, it should not be interpreted to be a commitment on the part of Microsoft, and Microsoft cannot guarantee the accuracy of any information presented after the date of publication. This White Paper is for informational purposes only. MICROSOFT MAKES NO WARRANTIES, EXPRESS, IMPLIED OR STATUTORY, AS TO THE INFORMATION IN THIS DOCUMENT. Complying with all applicable copyright laws is the responsibility of the user. Without limiting the rights under copyright, no part of this document may be reproduced, stored in or introduced into a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means (electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise), or for any purpose, without the express written permission of Microsoft Corporation. Microsoft may have patents, patent applications, trademarks, copyrights, or other intellectual property rights covering subject matter in this document. Except as expressly provided in any written license agreement from Microsoft, the furnishing of this document does not give you any license to these patents, trademarks, copyrights, or other intellectual property Microsoft Corporation. All rights reserved. Microsoft, Windows, Windows Server, Hyper-V, Forefront, PowerShell, Active Directory, SharePoint, and SQL Server are either registered trademarks or trademarks of Microsoft Corporation in the United States and/or other countries. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.
3 Increasing IT Efficiency in a Dynamic Datacenter with a Virtualized Storage Solution iii Contents Executive Summary...4 Introduction...5 Key Concepts...6 Virtualization... 6 Server Virtualization... 6 Storage Platform for Server Virtualization... 6 Storage Virtualization... 7 Storage Efficiencies... 7 Dynamic Block Architecture... 7 Automated Tiered Storage... 7 Thin Provisioning... 8 Dynamic Datacenter Components...8 Microsoft Technologies... 8 Windows Server 2008 R2 Hyper-V... 8 Windows Server Failover Clustering... 9 System Center Virtual Machine Manager...10 Compellent Technologies...11 Compellent Storage Center SAN solution...11 Compellent Storage Virtualization...12 Hyper-V Integration...13 Storage Center Command Set for Microsoft Windows PowerShell...13 Virtualized versus Physical Datacenter Study Infrastructure Comparison...15 Study Conclusions...17 Blueprint Virtualization Preparation Planning...20 Integration...20 Conclusion Additional Information... 21
4 Increasing IT Efficiency in a Dynamic Datacenter with a Virtualized Storage Solution 4 Executive Summary Server virtualization has become the cornerstone technology used to increase efficiencies and add dynamic capabilities to the datacenter. Complemented with storage virtualization, the efficiencies can be increased even more dramatically. Together, they are the key to a highly efficient and dynamic datacenter. This white paper provides a blueprint for a highly efficient and dynamic datacenter enabled by using Microsoft virtualization and the Compellent Storage Center SAN solution. Microsoft virtualization is an end-to-end strategy that can profoundly affect nearly every aspect of the IT infrastructure management lifecycle. It can drive greater efficiencies, flexibility, and cost effectiveness throughout an organization. Adding the Compellent Storage Center SAN solution to a Microsoft virtualized environment helps to efficiently manage the data lifecycle, automatically improve storage use, and increase server performance. Compellent s advanced storage virtualization is integrated with Hyper-V and Windows PowerShell. This integration amplifies the benefits of server virtualization and reduces management overhead. The Compellent SAN virtualization strategy significantly lowers storage infrastructure costs, reduces power and cooling costs by up to 93 percent, and recovers any size volume to any server in seconds. The Compellent Storage Center SAN solution is built on an advanced virtualization engine that creates a smart, shared pool of storage resources. It uses Fluid Data architecture that enables the Compellent SAN to actively manage data at a more granular level. This Fluid Data architecture significantly lowers storage infrastructure costs, reduces power and cooling costs by up to 93 percent 1, and recovers any size volume to any server in seconds. A comprehensive virtualization strategy truly has the power to transform the IT infrastructure. Virtualization can be used to accelerate application deployments and ensure the availability of the system, application, and data. In addition, a good virtualization strategy can simplify server and desktop shutdown and rebuilding for testing and development. These virtualization capabilities reduce risk, cut costs, and improve the agility of the entire IT environment. The key benefits that an enterprise can attain when deploying the blueprint provided in this paper include: Hardware cost reduction Server utilization improvement Energy and space requirement reduction Server availability increase Application performance improvement 1 See Compellent s white paper Compellents s Green Advantage Extending the Life of Data Centers with an Energy-Efficient SAN, November 2007 at:
5 Increasing IT Efficiency in a Dynamic Datacenter with a Virtualized Storage Solution 5 Server provisioning and management overhead reduction New service rollout acceleration This paper is written for those who have a working knowledge of Microsoft Windows Server 2008 R2 and virtualized Windows Server environments. This paper also assumes that the reader has a basic understanding of storage virtualization, replication, and clustering terminology. Introduction Datacenter efficiency is a large concern for Information Technology (IT) management as demands for services continue to increase while budgets continue to be reduced. Supporting growth and maintaining availability per the service level agreements while mitigating the risks to critical data, systems, applications, and the computing infrastructure in the event of a system outage or a complete disaster presents an ongoing challenge from both a technological and a business perspective. Organizations must consistently find solutions that not only meet application and data requirements for capacity, performance, and availability, but also have proven return on investment and cost reduction capabilities. The approach that companies traditionally take to address this issue is to provide a separate server and storage for each application. For critical applications, this strategy can require multiple servers for redundancy or scaling. Unfortunately, this approach dramatically increases the footprint that the IT department must manage. Large footprints require large IT staffs and more energy to maintain. In addition, rent and hardware costs skyrocket while licensing becomes much less efficient. When launching a new application in this scenario, spec development, software purchase and installation as well as new server preparation can easily take over a month to accomplish. The growing number of servers significantly hinders standardization and requires a continuously increasing spare part inventory. With each application and hosting server standing on its own, different tools are often required for each. This makes overall management, automation, and reporting very difficult. In order to service a system, downtime must be scheduled. This requires IT to take the system down manually which reduces system availability. This is required for every system update or hardware change. In addition, because of rising power bills, cooling problems, usage limits imposed by local utilities, or requirements to deploy additional servers without expanding an existing datacenter or building a new one, energy efficiency is a top concern for IT managers. To address energy efficiency, IT managers must look at a variety of issues ranging from the smallest piece of silicon to the entire datacenter. To effectively address the increasing datacenter efficiency concerns, many companies have chosen to virtualize their environments.
6 Increasing IT Efficiency in a Dynamic Datacenter with a Virtualized Storage Solution 6 Virtualization has been a game changer for many companies. It has enabled companies that previously were unable to afford to deploy dynamic capabilities into the datacenter to begin implementing these efficient solutions. Key Concepts The basis of this blueprint is the virtualization of the datacenter. In order to successfully apply this blueprint, a basic understanding of the virtualization concepts and storage efficiency technologies is necessary. Virtualization Server virtualization is a hot trend in the IT world because of the many business and technical benefits it can provide over the near and long term. There are many types of virtualization strategies that can be utilized in the datacenter, but for the purpose of this paper, the focus is on server virtualization, the storage platform for server virtualization, and storage virtualization. Server Virtualization Virtualization has been a game changer for many companies. It has allowed companies that previously were unable to afford to deploy dynamic capabilities into the datacenter to begin implementing these efficient solutions. By enabling organizations to run multiple operating systems and applications on a single physical server versus multiple physical machines, server virtualization can help organizations reduce hardware, energy, and management overhead significantly. Server virtualization is also a key building block of a dynamic IT infrastructure which is all about efficiency, resiliency, and agility. From an application perspective, server virtualization enables organizations to consolidate workloads. This increases resource utilization and lowers capital and operational costs. In addition, server virtualization can help organizations improve application performance, availability, management, and agility. The more agile the IT environment is, the more an organization is able to meet changing business and application requirements. Storage Platform for Server Virtualization The type of storage platform that organizations deploy to support a virtualized server environment is very important. For example, in advanced scenarios that take full advantage of the availability and flexibility of virtualization, external shared storage is required. In addition, the right storage system platform should ensure low latency for maximum performance, provide scalable capacity and bandwidth as application demands change, and automatically balance application workloads as needed. To support the dynamic Hyper-V virtualized environment, the storage platform must make it easy to create, size, and move storage volumes as required. Also, because server consolidation through virtualization places multiple applications on a single server, high availability features become increasingly important for both the servers and the shared storage. Finally, the right storage platform should also give organizations the ability to virtualize their storage environments by pooling the disk resources required to optimize and protect the application environment.
7 Increasing IT Efficiency in a Dynamic Datacenter with a Virtualized Storage Solution 7 Note: Storage platform for server virtualization is different than storage virtualization. Storage platform for server virtualization refers to externally shared storage that is optimized to better serve a virtualized server environment. Storage virtualization, on the other hand, refers to the process of abstracting logical storage from physical storage. This abstraction process provides numerous advantages and capabilities such as thin provisioning or dynamic snapshots that are not available to storage that is not virtualized. Storage Virtualization By abstracting the logical storage from the physical storage, the dynamic datacenter gains many advantages including the ability to migrate data while maintaining concurrent user access. Utilization can also be increased using thin provisioning services that eliminate allocated, but unused capacity. This enables administrators to allocate any size virtual volume upfront, but only consume the actual physical capacity when the data is written by the application. Also with storage virtualization, there are fewer points of management. The multiple independent storage devices that might be scattered over a network appear to be a single consolidated storage device that can be managed centrally. Storage Efficiencies The Compellent Storage Center SAN solution uses some unique technologies that require further explanation in order for the reader to understand the efficiencies gained. Dynamic Block Architecture Using Compellent s Dynamic Block Architecture, Storage Center intelligently optimizes data movement and access at the block level. Dynamic Block Architecture records and tracks specific information for almost every block of data so that the SAN knows how each block is being used. This metadata enables Compellent to more intelligently store, recover, and manage the data. This architecture delivers built-in intelligence and automation that optimize the provisioning, placement, and data protection. Automated Tiered Storage Compellent provides the only SAN that intelligently classifies and migrates data at the block-level to the optimal tier. Automated Tiered Storage with Fast Track dynamically places the most frequently used data on the fastest, or outer, tracks of each drive. This technology creates a system that requires fewer drives to manage existing data creating big benefits in terms of cost savings, management, and power consumption without sacrificing performance. The result is that the storage is automatically in tune with the application needs. Using Automated Tiered Storage with solid-state drives can reduce both storage costs and administration time while optimizing performance and utilization.
8 Increasing IT Efficiency in a Dynamic Datacenter with a Virtualized Storage Solution 8 Using Automated Tiered Storage also reduces overall storage costs up to 80 percent by storing inactive data on lower cost SATA or serial attached SCSI (SAS) drives. This lowers drive counts and significantly lowers power and cooling costs. The built-in intelligence eliminates manual data classification and migration, and can be implemented in a few minutes with automatic drive recognition and installation. The savings over traditional storage systems can be showcased using the boardroom-ready Hero Reports provided by Compellent Enterprise Manager software. Thin Provisioning With traditional storage systems, administrators must purchase, allocate and manage capacity upfront, all while speculating where to place storage resources and create large, underutilized volumes with long term growth built in. This practice leaves the majority of disk space allocated yet unused, and only available to specific applications. Compellent's thin provisioning technology, called Dynamic Capacity, delivers the highest storage utilization possible by eliminating allocated but unused capacity. Dynamic Capacity completely separates storage allocation from utilization, enabling users to allocate any size virtual volume upfront, yet only consume actual physical capacity when the data is written by the application. And, with Compellent s Thin Import and Free Space Recovery, the benefits of Dynamic Capacity can be extended to convert legacy volumes into thin provisioned data or to optimize space utilization in Windows environments. Dynamic Datacenter Components A highly efficient and dynamic datacenter can be created by combining Microsoft and Compellent technologies. This section discusses the relevant technologies required. Microsoft Technologies Microsoft virtualization is an end-to-end strategy that can profoundly affect nearly every aspect of the IT infrastructure management lifecycle. It can drive greater efficiencies, flexibility, and cost effectiveness throughout an organization. A standard Microsoft virtualization implementation is typically structured using the Windows Server 2008 R2 Hyper-V role to enable virtualization and Windows Clustering to handle high availability and disaster recovery requirements. System Center Virtual Machine Manager (SCVMM) is typically used to simplify virtualization management. Windows Server 2008 R2 Hyper-V Hyper- V is the hypervisor- based virtualization technology from Microsoft that is integrated into all Windows Server 2008 R2 operating systems. As a virtualization solution, Hyper- V enables users to take maximum advantage of the server hardware by providing the capability to run multiple operating systems (in virtual machines) on a single physical server. The availability of Hyper- V as a role in a mainstream Windows operating system provides several key advantages:
9 Increasing IT Efficiency in a Dynamic Datacenter with a Virtualized Storage Solution 9 Features Built in technology Broad device driver support SMP support Host high availability Shared storage high availability Easy VM migration Volume Shadow Copy Service (VSS) support Easy extensibility Simplified integrated management Benefits Enables enterprises to easily leverage virtualization benefits without adopting a new technology. The new 64- bit micro- kernelized hypervisor architecture leverages the broad device driver support in the Windows Server 2008 R2 parent partition to extend support to a broad array of servers, storage, and devices. Supports Symmetric Multiprocessors (SMP) in virtual machines (VM). Windows Server Failover Cluster provides high availability to VMs to minimize unplanned downtime. Microsoft MPIO dynamically routes input/output (I/O) to the best path and protects against connection failures at any point between a Hyper-V host and shared storage including NICs/adapters, switches, or array ports. Provides live migration capability to support business continuity during planned and unplanned downtime and over distances. Robust host- based VM backup is enabled by leveraging the existing Windows VSS-based infrastructure. Easy extensibility is provided using the standards-based Windows Management Instrumentation (WMI) interfaces and APIs. Due to tight integration into the Microsoft System Center family of products, customers have end-to- end physical and virtual infrastructure management capability for Hyper- V environments. Table 1: Hyper-V features Windows Server Failover Clustering Failover clustering in Windows Server 2008 R2 helps to ensure that mission-critical applications and services, such as and line-of-business applications, are available when required. Some important capabilities of WSFC for high availability and disaster recovery include:
10 Increasing IT Efficiency in a Dynamic Datacenter with a Virtualized Storage Solution 10 Features No single subnet limitation Configurable heartbeat timeouts Common toolset Automated failover VSS support Benefits Enables cluster nodes to communicate across network routers. Connecting nodes with VLANs is no longer required. Heartbeat timeouts are configurable to extend geographically dispersed clusters over greater distances. Decrease heartbeat timeouts to detect failures faster and take recovery actions for quicker failover. Provides a similar management experience to managing a local cluster. Provides an automatic failover if a complete disaster occurs in one site. Provides VSS support to back cluster settings. Automation support Cross-site replication tool compatibility Provides automation support for Windows 2008 R2 with PowerShell. Provides mirrored storage between stretched locations in addition to seamless integration with partner hardware or software-based data replication solutions. Table 2. Windows Server Failover Clustering features System Center Virtual Machine Manager Microsoft System Center Virtual Machine Manager (SCVMM) 2008 R2 is enterprise- class management software that enables administrators to easily and effectively manage both physical and virtual environments from a single management console. This software helps to reduce the complexity and the time required to use multiple consoles typically associated with managing an IT infrastructure. The key capabilities of SCVMM 2008 R2 include: Features Enterprise- class management suite Intelligent VM placement System Center Operations Manager 2007 Integration Native P2V/V2V Migration Benefits Manages both Hyper- V and VMware ESX virtualization environments. Provides support for the intelligent placement of VMs. Integrates with System Center Operations Manager 2007 to provide the ability to proactively manage both virtual and physical environments through a single console by leveraging PRO. Provides native capability for
11 Increasing IT Efficiency in a Dynamic Datacenter with a Virtualized Storage Solution 11 physical- to- virtual migrations and virtual- to- virtual migrations. Failover integration Automation Quick storage migration Integrates with Failover Clustering to support high availability and the live migration of VMs. Provides easy automation capabilities leveraging Windows PowerShell. Provides the ability to migrate running VMs from hosts with local disks to hosts with high availability and failover cluster configurations, and then back as needed using the Save State functionality to minimize downtime. Compellent Technologies Table 3. System Center Virtual Machine Manager features Compellent is a leading provider of enterprise-class network storage solutions for dynamic data needs. Compellent s dynamic data technology is called Fluid Data Storage which is the basis of the Compellent Storage Center solution. The Storage Center solution is a powerful data movement engine with intelligent software application features. It supports an open hardware platform providing a fluid data storage solution. Enabled by dynamic architecture, Fluid Data Storage actively and intelligently manages data at a granular level to cut cost, time, and risk. The intelligent software further places enterprise virtualized storage capabilities within reach of any organization, regardless of the scale of the implementation. The powerful suite of applications optimizes utilization, automates tiered storage, simplifies replication, provides storage management efficiency, and accelerates data recovery. Compellent Storage Center SAN solution The Compellent Storage Center SAN outshines other storage solutions because it provides: Unique architecture that manages the data inside the volume. Scalable hardware that eliminates the need for a forklift upgrade. Powerful software that optimizes utilization, automates replication, and accelerates data recovery. Core system technology with essential storage features that are traditionally considered to be add-ons. A single interface that manages the entire solution. In addition, Compellent technologies also provide the following benefits: Significant storage cost reduction and equipment life extension.
12 Increasing IT Efficiency in a Dynamic Datacenter with a Virtualized Storage Solution percent storage management time reduction as reported by Compellent customers. Continuous data availability. 93 percent automatic power and cooling cost reduction 2. Compellent Storage Virtualization Compellent is built on an advanced virtualization engine that creates a shared pool of storage resources. Administrators can change, shift, or dynamically scale this virtualized pool without disruption. The system processes multiple requests in parallel to improve system performance and utilization. This shared pool of resources eliminates the guesswork of capacity planning and simplifies storage provisioning for any number of servers. In fact, administrators can quickly and easily create hundreds of virtual volumes to support any Windows Server 2008 R2 with Hyper-V platform and optimize the placement of virtual applications without wasting time, money, or disk space. The benefits of moving to a Compellent virtualized storage solution include the following: Purchase only needed storage: Modular hardware architecture and advanced thin provisioning capabilities enable companies to scale performance and capacity for Windows applications incrementally as needed. Recover at the block level: Compellent s Data Instant Replay enables SQL Server, Exchange Server, and Hyper-V users to recover data in seconds. Backup without causing a backlog: Take replays of Windows based server volumes without taking applications offline. Use Replay Manager and Data Instant Replay with VSS to ensure consistent Windows data even if the server application is running. Simplify storage management: Automated Tiered Storage tracks blocks inside the volume and migrates inactive data to less expensive storage. In Exchange, this means more mailboxes are provided for less money. Compellent s Dynamic Block Architecture enables program-based storage provisioning and management with Virtual Disk Service. Reclaim storage space: Uncover important information in the data center by recycling data blocks of information deleted at the file level using Compellent s Free Space Recovery. Increase system uptime: Keep critical applications online with fault-tolerant server connectivity using Multi-Path I/O. Recover quickly in SQL Server, Exchange, and Hyper-V environments using Volume Shadow Copy Service. Maximize application performance: Match storage performance to individual program I/O needs using Compellent s Fast Track Technology. Increase critical SQL Server application performance with Fast Track. Fast Track reserves the fastest portion of each drive for the most frequently used data, such as log files. 2 See Compellent s white paper Compellent s Green Advantage Extending the Life of Data Centers with an Energy-Efficient SAN, November 2007 at:
13 Increasing IT Efficiency in a Dynamic Datacenter with a Virtualized Storage Solution 13 Hyper-V Integration Compellent s advanced storage virtualization is the perfect complement to Hyper-V servers, enabling companies to amplify the benefits of server virtualization from the datacenter to the desktop. The benefits of combining advanced storage virtualization from Compellent with Microsoft server virtualization include: Easy deployment and Hyper-V server management Small footprint, big impact: Automatic LUN masking simplifies storage provisioning for any number of virtual servers. Thin provisioning minimizes capacity planning and maximizes disk utilization. Storage virtualization shrinks the data center without sacrificing performance. Server management revolution: Easily deploy Hyper-V servers with a six-click Boot from SAN wizard. Test patches and roll out multiple virtual servers in minutes. Virtual process automation: Leverage PowerShell functions to further automate backend storage functions and bring new levels of customization to the data center. Increase availability, not cost or complexity Backup without a backlog: Implement unlimited server volume replays without taking applications offline using the Replay Manager intelligent snapshot coordinator with Windows technologies. Dynamically add or change storage attributes without impacting applications. Replicate more and spend less: Space efficient thin replication and block level architecture enable companies to affordably adopt replication for more virtual servers and leverage low cost IP lines. Rapid set up and recovery: Six-click replication set up requires no advanced training or staff. Predefine recovery volumes, boot remote Hyper-V servers from the SAN or recover any volume to any server within minutes. Reduce energy costs up to 93 percent Purchase, power and cool only the storage required: Modular architecture scales as companies grow, maximizing disk utilization and minimizing energy consumption. Decrease disk count and increase performance: Automated tiered storage intelligently places blocks of data on the ideal disk tier to reduce the need for high powered drives and free up high performance spindles for the most demanding virtual applications. Extend equipment life: Increased efficiency maximizes current resources reducing upgrades to power and cooling systems and delaying facility expansions. Storage Center Command Set for Microsoft Windows PowerShell Compellent Technologies Storage Center Command Set for Microsoft Windows PowerShell is designed to automate the management and recovery of Compellent data storage and Windows enterprise environments including Windows Server 2008 R2
14 Increasing IT Efficiency in a Dynamic Datacenter with a Virtualized Storage Solution 14 Hyper-V platforms. Compellent is one of the first SAN vendors to integrate Windows PowerShell. Combining PowerShell scripting with the efficiency of virtualized storage enhances and simplifies server and storage management. For example, an enterprise deploying 50 new servers typically must image all the servers, provision storage volumes, create new user accounts and configure snapshots for backup and recovery. This process can be highly repetitive and manual. With Compellent s Command Set, administrators can create scripts with PowerShell commands to automate all the steps required to significantly reduce time and effort. Virtualized versus Physical Datacenter Study Moving from a physical to a virtual datacenter infrastructure has many advantages that have been discussed earlier in this paper. However, in order to understand the overall advantage of this move, this section provides the design for a virtual and a non-virtual Microsoft small business environment for comparison. The designs for both scenarios are based on industry best practices, Microsoft guidance, and deployment calculators. However, the important point is that both the virtual and non-virtual infrastructures are designed to support the same small business environment. The basic system design for a 500 user small business environment is provided in the following table. Environment Non Virtualized Virtualized Server ProLiant DL360 G6 ProLiant DL370 G6 ProLiant DL580 G5 ProLiant DL580 G5 Exchange Mailbox 2 Pooled Exchange CAS/Hub Transport 2 Pooled Active Directory 3 Pooled Web/SharePoint 6 Pooled CRM 2 Pooled SQL Server 2 Pooled Backup 1 Pooled File Servers 2 Pooled Forefront 2 Pooled Development/Test 2 2 Pooled Total physical servers 26 3 Table 4. Small business environment with 500 user server count
15 Increasing IT Efficiency in a Dynamic Datacenter with a Virtualized Storage Solution 15 To simplify the comparison, three HP ProLiant servers, the DL360 G6, DL370 G6, and the DL580 G5 were selected so that the pricing could be easily verified and readers could substitute their own infrastructure requirements and pricing. This selection was made for simplification and should not be considered an exclusive endorsement of HP equipment. There are two configurations of the ProLiant DL 580, a virtualized and a non virtualized configuration that are significantly different. The configuration and characteristics of these servers are provided in the following table. Environment Non Virtualized Virtualized Server/SAN ProLiant DL360 G6 ProLiant DL370 G6 ProLiant DL580 G5 ProLiant DL580 G5 Compellent Storage Center Rack U Hourly watts Hourly BTU Disk total Disk type 146GB 10K SAS 300GB 10K SAS 146GB 15K SAS 146GB 15K SAS 12 x 450GB 15K SAS 12 x 1TB 7.2K SAS Memory (GB) Processer cores Hardware cost $6,831 $13,300 $17,556 $37,394 $123,079 OS cost $2,444 $2,444 $2,444 $7,310 OS edition Enterprise Enterprise Enterprise Datacenter Server total Total hardware cost $307,883 $257,191 Infrastructure Comparison Table 5. Virtual and non virtual environment equipment configuration The system as summarized in the previous table supports a typical small business environment with 500 users. This system includes Microsoft Exchange, Web and
16 Increasing IT Efficiency in a Dynamic Datacenter with a Virtualized Storage Solution 16 SharePoint servers, Microsoft Dynamics CRM, Microsoft SQL Server, backup, file servers, Microsoft Forefront, and a development or test environment. It is designed with clustered servers for high availability that require an additional redundant physical server each in the case of the non-virtual environment. Because an advanced virtualized infrastructure requires shared storage, a Compellent Storage Center SAN was added to that environment. Even though the two infrastructures support the exact same small business environment, they are very different from each other as shown in the following table. While the number of physical servers was reduced by 88.5 percent in the virtual environment, they were replaced with more powerful servers to handle the load. In addition, the virtual environment is much more memory intensive as it requires an 84.6 percent increase in RAM while the CPU memory requirement is reduced in the virtual environment by 60 percent. Physical cost: Non virtual Virtual Change Physical servers % Required rack U % Including SAN Disk total % Memory total % CPU total % Hardware cost without OS Daily power usage: $244,339 $235,261 Including SAN -3.7% Hourly watts used % Hourly BTUs used % Annual electric bill at $0.11 cost per KW $13,061 $6, % Licensing: OS cost $63,544 $21, % Overall cost: Year 1 $320,944 $263, % Table 6. Virtual verus non virtual infrastructure study result summary
17 Increasing IT Efficiency in a Dynamic Datacenter with a Virtualized Storage Solution 17 Once the environment was virtualized, shared storage became necessary. This added the cost of a SAN to the environment. This cost was somewhat offset by the 75.5 percent reduction in the storage disk requirement. The addition of the SAN also added 10 U s to the existing 12 U s of rack space required for the three physical servers that supported the virtual environment increasing the total to 22 U s. The SAN includes two controllers at 3 U s each and two disc enclosures of 2 U s each. With significant differences between the two environments, the total equipment cost for each was about the same with a 3.7 percent price advantage going to the virtual environment. However, the advantages are more obvious when comparing the ongoing space, power, and licensing costs. As seen in the previous table, power costs are reduced by almost half and the infrastructure footprint is reduced by 58.5 percent. This rent reduction figure and/or rack cost was not considered in the final numbers as the benefit varies greatly depending on an organization s situation. However, when calculated, the savings would strengthen the advantages of virtualization. What the table does not show is the time saved while managing the environment. For example, all 147 physical disks have to be managed and provisioned individually in the physical environment. In the virtual environment, the disks are managed centrally. When space begins to run out, another disk is simply added to the storage pool. Because so much time is saved with the virtual infrastructure in place, more can be done with significantly less. Study Conclusions The 17.8 percent cost savings alone achieved by moving to a virtual environment is significant. However, even if there were no upfront cost savings, the dynamic capabilities provided by the virtual environment enable significant advantages that justify the conversion. For example, the centralized storage component enables data progression, thin provisioning, and centralized storage management. Server virtualization enables Hyper-V and SCVMM to be managed by a centralized server. Server utilization improvement reduces the amount of servers that need to be managed. In addition, space, power, and cooling requirements are reduced. Best of all, virtualization enables faster upgrades or service rollouts that can be done in minutes rather than weeks. Blueprint The blueprint provided in this section is for a 500 user virtualized datacenter. The intention here is to provide a starting point for the reader to modify their environment for the specific needs of their organization. Again, the design was based on industry best practices, Microsoft guidance, and deployment calculators. The following figure provides the basic design.
18 Increasing IT Efficiency in a Dynamic Datacenter with a Virtualized Storage Solution 18 Figure 1: 500 user Compellent and Microsoft Hyper-V virtualized SMB environment This entire infrastructure is built on top of three servers and a SAN. The servers need to be powerful or at least equivalent to the HP Proliant DL580 G5. Each server is configured with 16 cores and 96 GB of memory with four 146 GB 15K SAS disks. The Compellent Storage Center SAN is configured with dual controllers and two disk enclosures containing 24 disks, half of the disks are 450 GB SAS 15K and half are 1TB SAS 7.2K. The SAN is connected by Fibre Channel or iscsi depending on the needs of the organization. The physical servers are each running Windows Server 2008 R2 and are clustered using a Failover Cluster. This creates the physical server pool that can be divided up as needed to support each virtual server. The server pool is centrally managed using Microsoft System Center. After shared storage is created with the Compellent Enterprise Manager, SCVMM is used to create the individual virtual servers. Please see the previous tables 4 and 5 for a complete breakdown of the individual servers to create and how to configure them. The high availability configuration requirements are listed in the following table. As each server is clustered, it should be noted that most pairs of servers signify a single cluster failover pair with the exception of Active Directory and Exchange which both have their own replication. Also, in the case of Active Directory, the third server is necessary to support the development and test environment. It is also important to note that the backup server is redundant by definition and only requires a single server.
19 Increasing IT Efficiency in a Dynamic Datacenter with a Virtualized Storage Solution 19 Server Exchange: Mailbox Exchange: CAS/Hub Transport Active Directory Web/SharePoint CRM SQL Server Backup File servers Forefront Development/Test High availability configuration Two individual servers Two individual servers Three individual servers including two servers to support the production environment and one server to support the development and test environment. Six servers configured as three single cluster failover pairs. Two servers configured as a single cluster failover pair. Two servers configured as single cluster failover pair. One server to handle backup. Two servers configured as single cluster failover pair. Two servers configured as single cluster failover pair. Four servers configured as two single cluster failover pairs. Table 7. High availability configuration Virtualization Preparation When an organization is ready to move to a virtualized dynamic datacenter environment, careful planning is important. This is the time that expert help is critical for the success of the venture. In addition, once a dynamic virtual datacenter is established, the way that the organization takes advantage of the dynamic capabilities must be considered.
20 Increasing IT Efficiency in a Dynamic Datacenter with a Virtualized Storage Solution 20 Planning Very few organizations start from scratch with their IT design and therefore the existing infrastructure must be considered when moving to a virtual datacenter. For this purpose, Microsoft and Compellent created some preliminary planning tools to help ease the process. The tools evaluate the existing infrastructure to determine if there are components that can be repurposed into the new virtual design and what additional hardware is required. For example, the Microsoft Assessment and Planning (MAP) Toolkit is a powerful inventory, assessment, and reporting tool that can securely assess IT environments for various platform migrations and virtualization without the use of software agents. These are great tools to start planning and budgeting for the move to virtualization, however, organizations should contact their hardware vendor to help finalize the planning process. Please see the following links for more planning tool information: Compellent TCO tool: Microsoft Virtualization Planning Tools: Integration Many of the dynamic capabilities are simply part of the virtualized environment such as Live Migration, thin provisioning, or dynamic LUN expansion. But the dynamic datacenter can be automated or customized even further using Microsoft Windows PowerShell. For this purpose, Compellent created the Storage Center Command Set for Microsoft Windows PowerShell. The Storage Center Command Set for PowerShell comprises more than 60 cmdlets for streamlining tasks such as: Microsoft Exchange environment storage creation. High availability cluster node storage mapping. Quick data recovery, speed testing, development, and deployment when booting new servers from the Compellent SAN. Automatic migration, cloning, and monitoring for hundreds of VMs across a virtualized data center. Rapid VM provisioning that can be fully integrated with SCVMM in a matter of seconds. For more information about using the Storage Center Command Set for PowerShell, please see:
Enterprise Storage Solution for Hyper-V Private Cloud and VDI Deployments using Sanbolic s Melio Cloud Software Suite April 2011 Executive Summary Large enterprise Hyper-V deployments with a large number
Optimized Storage Solution for Enterprise Scale Hyper-V Deployments End-to-End Storage Solution Enabled by Sanbolic Melio FS and LaScala Software and EMC SAN Solutions Proof of Concept Published: March
ENTERPRISE STORAGE WITH THE FUTURE BUILT IN Breakthrough Efficiency Intelligent Storage Automation Single Platform Scalability Real-time Responsiveness Continuous Protection Storage Controllers Storage
Microsoft Cross-Site Disaster Recovery Solutions End-to-End Solutions Enabled by Windows 2008 Failover Clustering, Hyper-V, and Partner Solutions for Data Replication Published: December 2009 Introduction:
Introduction By leveraging the inherent benefits of a virtualization based platform, a Microsoft Exchange Server 2007 deployment on VMware Infrastructure 3 offers a variety of availability and recovery
T E C H N I C A L B R I E F The Benefits of Virtualizing Aciduisismodo Microsoft SQL Dolore Server Eolore in Dionseq Hitachi Storage Uatummy Environments Odolorem Vel Leveraging Microsoft Hyper-V By Heidi
Windows Server 2008 R2 Hyper-V Live Migration White Paper Published: August 09 This is a preliminary document and may be changed substantially prior to final commercial release of the software described
DELL Dell Microsoft Windows Server 2008 Hyper-V TM Reference Architecture VIRTUALIZATION SOLUTIONS ENGINEERING September 2008 1 THIS WHITE PAPER IS FOR INFORMATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY, AND MAY CONTAIN TYPOGRAPHICAL
STORAGE CENTER DATASHEET STORAGE CENTER Go Beyond the Boundaries of Traditional Storage Systems Today s storage vendors promise to reduce the amount of time and money companies spend on storage but instead
Using EonStor FC-host Storage Systems in VMware Infrastructure 3 and vsphere 4 Application Note Abstract This application note explains the configure details of using Infortrend FC-host storage systems
Microsoft Collaboration Brief April 2010 Best Practices for SAP on Hyper-V Authors Josef Stelzel, Sr. Developer Evangelist, Microsoft Corporation email@example.com Bernhard Maendle, Architect, connmove
WHITE PAPER I FEBRUARY 2010 Fluid Storage: Driving Flexibility in the Center Eight Must Have Technologies for the IT Director. Fluid Storage: Driving Flexibility in the Center I WHITE PAPER 1 EXECUTIVE
Data center virtualization A Dell Technical White Paper August 2011 Lay the foundation for impressive disk utilization and unmatched data center flexibility Executive summary Many enterprise IT departments
OPTIMIZING EXCHANGE SERVER IN A TIERED STORAGE ENVIRONMENT WHITE PAPER NOVEMBER 2006 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Microsoft Exchange Server is a disk-intensive application that requires high speed storage to deliver
Microsoft Private Cloud Fast Track Microsoft Private Cloud Fast Track is a reference architecture designed to help build private clouds by combining Microsoft software with Nutanix technology to decrease
Providing High Availability and Disaster Recovery in a Multi-Site Virtual Environment End to End Solution Enabled by Microsoft Virtualization, HP P4000 iscsi SAN Solution, and Citrix Essentials for Microsoft
DATA CENTER VIRTUALIZATION WHITE PAPER SEPTEMBER 2006 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Many enterprise IT departments have attempted to respond to growth by adding servers and storage systems dedicated to specific applications,
Fluid Data Storage: Driving Flexibility in the Data Center Eight Must-Have Technologies for the IT Director A Dell Technical White Paper Dell Compellent THIS WHITE PAPER IS FOR INFORMATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY,
Windows Server 2008 R2 Hyper-V Live Migration Table of Contents Overview of Windows Server 2008 R2 Hyper-V Features... 3 Dynamic VM storage... 3 Enhanced Processor Support... 3 Enhanced Networking Support...
EMC Virtual Infrastructure for Microsoft Applications Data Center Solution Enabled by EMC Symmetrix V-Max and Reference Architecture EMC Global Solutions Copyright and Trademark Information Copyright 2009
What s New with VMware Virtual Infrastructure Virtualization: Industry-Standard Way of Computing Early Adoption Mainstreaming Standardization Test & Development Server Consolidation Infrastructure Management
STORAGE CENTER WITH STORAGE CENTER DATASHEET THE BENEFITS OF UNIFIED AND STORAGE Combining block and file-level data into a centralized storage platform simplifies management and reduces overall storage
EMC Backup and Recovery for Microsoft SQL Server 2008 Enabled by EMC Celerra Unified Storage Applied Technology Abstract This white paper describes various backup and recovery solutions available for SQL
Virtualization with Microsoft Windows Server 2003 R2, Enterprise Edition Microsoft Corporation Published: March 2006 Abstract Virtualization in the volume server market is starting to see rapid adoption
Dell High Availability Solutions Guide for Microsoft Hyper-V www.dell.com support.dell.com Notes and Cautions NOTE: A NOTE indicates important information that helps you make better use of your computer.
Session Code: VIR311 Deploying Windows Server 2008 Hyper-V and System Center Virtual Machine Manager 2008 Best Practices Agenda Discuss Hyper V deployment strategies Discuss System Center Virtual Machine
Server Consolidation with SQL Server 2008 White Paper Published: August 2007 Updated: July 2008 Summary: Microsoft SQL Server 2008 supports multiple options for server consolidation, providing organizations
Dell Compellent Storage Center SAN & VMware View 1,000 Desktop Reference Architecture Dell Compellent Product Specialist Team THIS WHITE PAPER IS FOR INFORMATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY, AND MAY CONTAIN TYPOGRAPHICAL
Online Transaction Processing in SQL Server 2008 White Paper Published: August 2007 Updated: July 2008 Summary: Microsoft SQL Server 2008 provides a database platform that is optimized for today s applications,
Smart Storage and Modern Data Protection Built for Virtualization Dot Hill Storage Arrays and Veeam Backup & Replication Software offer the winning combination. Veeam and Dot Hill Solutions Introduction
7 Ways Compellent Optimizes ware Virtualization WHITE PAPER I MARCH 2010 7 Ways Compellent Optimizes ware Virtualization I WHITE PAPER 1 INTRODUCTION Increasingly, enterprises are turning to server virtualization
RED HAT ENTERPRISE VIRTUALIZATION FOR SERVERS: COMPETITIVE FEATURES RED HAT ENTERPRISE VIRTUALIZATION FOR SERVERS Server virtualization offers tremendous benefits for enterprise IT organizations server
Microsoft Corporation Published: May 2006 Abstract Today s business climate is more challenging than ever and businesses are under constant pressure to lower costs while improving overall operational efficiency.
Complete Storage and Data Protection Architecture for VMware vsphere Executive Summary The cost savings and agility benefits of server virtualization are well proven, accounting for its rapid adoption.
SQL Server Storage Best Practice Discussion Dell EqualLogic What s keeping you up at night? Managing the demands of a SQL environment Risk Cost Data loss Application unavailability Data growth SQL Server
Microsoft SQL Server Enabled by EMC Celerra and Microsoft Hyper-V Copyright 2010 EMC Corporation. All rights reserved. Published February, 2010 EMC believes the information in this publication is accurate
Introducing Markus Erlacher Technical Solution Professional Microsoft Switzerland Overarching Release Principles Strong emphasis on hardware, driver and application compatibility Goal to support Windows
High Availability with Windows Server 2012 Release Candidate Windows Server 2012 Release Candidate (RC) delivers innovative new capabilities that enable you to build dynamic storage and availability solutions
Self-Service Provisioning and the Private Cloud Using Microsoft Server Virtualization and Dell Compellent Storage Virtualization to Improve Delivery of Infrastructure as a Service Solution Overview Published:
Benefits of the Hyper-V Cloud For more information, please contact: Email: firstname.lastname@example.org Ph: 888-821-7888 Canadian Web Hosting (www.canadianwebhosting.com) is an independent company, hereinafter
Reducing the Cost and Complexity of Business Continuity and Disaster Recovery for Email Harnessing the Power of Virtualization with an Integrated Solution Based on VMware vsphere and VMware Zimbra WHITE
Windows Server 2012 授 權 說 明 PROCESSOR + CAL HA 功 能 相 同 的 記 憶 體 及 處 理 器 容 量 虛 擬 化 Windows Server 2008 R2 Datacenter Price: NTD173,720 (2 CPU) Packaging All features Unlimited virtual instances Per processor
THREE MUST HAVES FOR THE VIRTUAL DATA CENTER POSITION PAPER JANUARY 2009 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Traditionally, data centers have attempted to respond to growth by adding servers and storage systems dedicated
NETAPP WHITE PAPER A Customer Blueprint: Improving Efficiency and Availability Using Microsoft Hyper-V and NetApp Storage Microsoft Solutions Engineering, NetApp Microsoft Virtualization Solutions, Microsoft
Enabling the Always-On Enterprise Clustering Windows File Servers for Enterprise Scale and High Availability By Andrew Melmed Director of Enterprise Solutions, Sanbolic, Inc. April 2012 Introduction Microsoft
Server and Storage Virtualization: A Complete Solution A SANRAD White Paper copyright SANRAD 2008 SANRAD Inc. www.sanrad.com Server and Storage Virtualization: A Complete Solution A SANRAD Whitepaper Server
DATASHEET VERITAS Storage Foundation 4.3 for Windows Advanced Volume Management Technology for Windows In distributed client/server environments, users demand that databases, mission-critical applications
HBA Virtualization Technologies for Windows OS Environments FC HBA Virtualization Keeping Pace with Virtualized Data Centers Executive Summary Today, Microsoft offers Virtual Server 2005 R2, a software
Building robust private cloud services infrastructures By Brian Gautreau and Gong Wang Private clouds optimize utilization and management of IT resources to heighten availability. Microsoft Private Cloud
Virtual Fibre Channel for Hyper-V Virtual Fibre Channel for Hyper-V, a new technology available in Microsoft Windows Server 2012, allows direct access to Fibre Channel (FC) shared storage by multiple guest
Windows Embedded Security and Surveillance Solutions Windows Embedded 2010 Page 1 Copyright The information contained in this document represents the current view of Microsoft Corporation on the issues
Maximize virtual desktop ROI without risking service levels HP 3PAR storage technologies for desktop virtualization Solution brief Desktop virtualization pushes the cost, efficiency, and management benefits
Configuration Management in the Data Center Using Microsoft System Center Published: May 2008 For the latest information, please see http://www.microsoft.com/systemcenter Contents Executive Summary...1
Dell High Availability Solutions Guide for Microsoft Hyper-V R2 A Dell Technical White Paper THIS WHITE PAPER IS FOR INFORMATIONAL PURPOPERATING SYSTEMS ONLY, AND MAY CONTAIN TYPOGRAPHICAL ERRORS AND TECHNICAL
Microsoft Hyper-V Server 2008 R2 Getting Started Guide Microsoft Corporation Published: July 2009 Abstract This guide helps you get started with Microsoft Hyper-V Server 2008 R2 by providing information
EMC Virtual Infrastructure for Microsoft Applications Data Center Solution Enabled by EMC Symmetrix V-Max and Reference Architecture EMC Global Solutions Copyright and Trademark Information Copyright 2009
Complete protection for your information-driven enterprise Overview Symantec NetBackup provides a simple yet comprehensive selection of innovative clients and agents to optimize the performance and efficiency
CA ARCserve Replication and CA ARCserve High Availability r16 CA ARCserve Replication and CA ARCserve High Availability Deployment Options for Microsoft Hyper-V Server TYPICALLY, IT COST REDUCTION INITIATIVES
Fluid Data storage: A fully virtualized foundation for the IT stack A Dell Technical White Paper February 2010 A C-level look at the business impact of virtualization Executive overview In today s challenging
What s new in Hyper-V 2012 R2 Carsten Rachfahl MVP Virtual Machine Rachfahl IT-Solutions GmbH & Co KG www.hyper-v-server.de Thomas Maurer Cloud Architect & MVP itnetx gmbh www.thomasmaurer.ch Before Windows
An Oracle White Paper November 2010 Oracle Real Application Clusters One Node: The Always On Single-Instance Database Executive Summary... 1 Oracle Real Application Clusters One Node Overview... 1 Always
THE FUTURE IS FLUID. INTRODUCING FLUID DATA TM FROM COMPELLENT. We ve created a revolutionary enterprise storage solution that automates the movement and management of data throughout its lifecycle, so
Leveraging Virtualization for Disaster Recovery in Your Growing Business Contents What is Disaster Recovery?..................................... 2 Leveraging Virtualization to Significantly Improve Disaster
Best Practices for Managing Storage in the Most Challenging Environments Sanjay Srivastava Senior Product Manager, Symantec The Typical Virtualization Adoption Path Today, 20-25% of server workloads are
Poster Companion Reference: Hyper-V and Failover Clustering Introduction This document is part of a companion reference that discusses the Windows Server 2012 Hyper-V Component Architecture Poster. This
What Is Microsoft Private Cloud Fast Track? MICROSOFT PRIVATE CLOUD FAST TRACK is a reference architecture for building private clouds that combines Microsoft software, consolidated guidance, and validated
Cloud Optimize Your IT Windows Server 2012 The information contained in this presentation relates to a pre-release product which may be substantially modified before it is commercially released. This pre-release
IBM DS5020 Express Manage growth, complexity, and risk with scalable, high-performance storage Highlights Mixed host interfaces support (Fibre Channel/iSCSI) enables SAN tiering Balanced performance well-suited
Selling Compellent NAS: File & Block Level in the Same System Chad Thibodeau Agenda Session Objectives Feature Overview Technology Overview Compellent Differentiators Competition Available Resources Questions
How Customers Are Cutting Costs and Building Value with Microsoft Virtualization Introduction The majority of organizations are incorporating virtualization into their IT infrastructures because of the
Microsoft and Citrix: Joint Virtual Desktop Infrastructure (VDI) Offering Architectural Guidance July 2009 The information contained in this document represents the current view of Microsoft Corporation
Best Practices Best Practices for Installing and Configuring the Hyper-V Role on the LSI CTS2600 Storage System for Windows 2008 Installation and Configuration Guide 2010 LSI Corporation August 13, 2010
The VMware Administrator s Guide to Hyper-V in Windows Server 2012 Brien Posey Microsoft MVMP @Veeam About today s webinar Thought leadership content from an industry expert This webinar is recorded and
Veritas Storage Foundation High Availability for Windows by Symantec Simple-to-use solution for high availability and disaster recovery of businesscritical Windows applications Data Sheet: High Availability
Advanced virtualization management for Hyper-V and System Center environments www.citrix.com Introduction Microsoft Hyper-V provides a dynamic, reliable and scalable virtualization platform enabling cost
Contributions for this vendor neutral technology paper have been provided by Blade.org members including NetApp, BLADE Network Technologies, and Double-Take Software. June 2009 Blade.org 2009 ALL RIGHTS
Integration of Microsoft Hyper-V and Coraid Ethernet SAN Storage White Paper June 2011 2011 Coraid, Inc. Coraid, Inc. The trademarks, logos, and service marks (collectively "Trademarks") appearing on the
Features Comparison: Hyper-V Server and Hyper-V February 2012 The information contained in this document relates to a pre-release product which may be substantially modified before it is commercially released.
RED hat ENTERPRISE VIRTUALIZATION FOR SERVERS 2.2: FEATURE matrix Red hat enterprise virtualization for servers Server virtualization offers tremendous benefits for enterprise IT organizations server consolidation,
Top 10 Reasons to Virtualize VMware Zimbra Collaboration Server with VMware vsphere white PAPER Email outages disrupt a company s ability to conduct business. Issues as diverse as scheduled downtime, human
Whitepaper NexentaConnect for VMware Virtual SAN Full Featured File services for Virtual SAN Table of Contents Introduction... 1 Next Generation Storage and Compute... 1 VMware Virtual SAN... 2 Highlights
Reference Architecture EMC PERFORMANCE OPTIMIZATION FOR MICROSOFT FAST SEARCH SERVER 2010 FOR SHAREPOINT Optimize scalability and performance of FAST Search Server 2010 for SharePoint Validate virtualization
Windows Server 2008 Hyper-V Backup and Replication on EMC CLARiiON Storage Applied Technology Abstract This white paper provides an overview of the technologies that are used to perform backup and replication