EAST ORANGE SCHOOL DISTRICT WHITNEY HOUSTON ACADEMY FACILITY ENERGY REPORT 215 DODD STREET EAST ORANGE, NEW JERSEY

Transcription

1 EAST ORANGE SCHOOL DISTRICT WHITNEY HOUSTON ACADEMY 215 DODD STREET EAST ORANGE, NEW JERSEY FACILITY ENERGY REPORT

2 East Orange School District Whitney Houston Academy Energy Audit TABLE OF CONTENTS I. HISTORIC ENERGY CONSUMPTION/COST... 2 II. FACILITY ENERGY USE INDEX (EUI)... 9 III. FACILITY DESCRIPTION IV. MAJOR EQUIPMENT LIST V. ENERGY CONSERVATION MEASURES VI. ADDITIONAL RECOMMENDATIONS Appendix A ECM Cost & Savings Breakdown Appendix B New Jersey Smart Start Program Incentives Appendix C Portfolio Manager Statement of Energy Performance Appendix D Major Equipment List Appendix E Investment Grade Lighting Audit Appendix F Renewable / Distributed Energy Measures Calculations Concord Engineering Group, Inc. 1C15143 August 31, 2015 FINAL Page 1 of 35

3 East Orange School District Whitney Houston Academy Energy Audit I. HISTORIC ENERGY CONSUMPTION/COST The energy usage for the facility has been tabulated and plotted in graph form as depicted within this section. Each energy source has been identified and monthly consumption and cost noted per the information provided by the Owner. Electric Utility Provider: Electric Utility Rate Structure: Third Party Supplier: Natural Gas Utility Provider: Utility Rate Structure: Third Party Supplier: Fuel Oil Utility Provider: Utility Rate Structure: Public Service Electric & Gas General Lighting & Power (GLP) Direct Energy Public Service Electric & Gas General Service Gas (GSG) South Jersey Energy Co. National Terminal, Inc. Time of Delivery Price The electric usage profile represents the actual electrical usage for the facility. The electric utility measures consumption in kilowatt-hours (KWH) and maximum demand in kilowatts (KW). One KWH usage is equivalent to 1000 watts running for one hour. One KW of electric demand is equivalent to 1000 watts running at any given time. The basic usage charges are shown as generation service and delivery charges along with several non-utility generation charges. Rates used in this report reflect the historical data received for the facility. The gas usage profile within each facility report shows the actual natural gas energy usage for the facility. The gas utility measures consumption in cubic feet x 100 (CCF), and converts the quantity into Therms of energy. One Therm is equivalent to 100,000 BTUs of energy. The oil usage profile shows the actual oil consumption for the facility. The oil provider measures consumption in gallons. One Gallon of #2 oil is equivalent to 140,000 BTUs of energy. Concord Engineering Group, Inc. 1C15143 August 31, 2015 FINAL Page 2 of 35

4 East Orange School District Whitney Houston Academy Energy Audit ELECTRIC USAGE SUMMARY Utility Provider: PSE&G Rate: GLP Meter No: Account No: Third Party Utility Provider: Direct Energy TPS Meter / Acct No: - Table 1 Electricity Billing Data MONTH OF USE CONSUMPTION KWH DEMAND KW TOTAL BILL May-14 36, $5,724 Jun-14 7, $1,318 Jul-14 5, $1,117 Aug-14 5, $2,276 Sep-14 6, $975 Oct-14 6, $917 Nov-14 7, $1,082 Dec-14 7, $1,133 Jan-15 8, $1,258 Feb-15 6, $1,082 Mar-15 7, $1,098 Apr-15 8, $1,331 Totals 116, Max $19,311 AVERAGE DEMAND 25.3 KW average AVERAGE RATE $0.166 $/kwh Note: There are several estimated meter readings for this facility's electric utility bills, with many not properly adjusted to actual readings. Given the inaccuracies in utility billing it is likely this facility consumes more energy than reported. Concord Engineering Group, Inc. 1C15143 August 31, 2015 FINAL Page 3 of 35

5 East Orange School District Whitney Houston Academy Energy Audit Figure 1 Electricity Usage Profile Concord Engineering Group, Inc. 1C15143 August 31, 2015 FINAL Page 4 of 35

6 East Orange School District Whitney Houston Academy Energy Audit Table 2 Natural Gas Billing Data NATURAL GAS USAGE SUMMARY Utility Provider: PSE&G Rate: GSG Meter No: Account No: Third Party Utility Provider: South Jersey Energy Co. TPS Meter No: - MONTH OF USE CONSUMPTION (THERMS) TOTAL BILL May $ Jun $34.63 Jul $49.88 Aug $98.20 Sep $41.05 Oct $36.77 Nov $90.59 Dec $42.82 Jan $90.16 Feb $16.40 Mar $73.33 Apr $ TOTALS 1, $1, AVERAGE RATE: $1.06 $/THERM Concord Engineering Group, Inc. 1C15143 August 31, 2015 FINAL Page 5 of 35

7 East Orange School District Whitney Houston Academy Energy Audit Figure 2 Natural Gas Usage Profile Concord Engineering Group, Inc. 1C15143 August 31, 2015 FINAL Page 6 of 35

8 East Orange School District Whitney Houston Academy Energy Audit FUEL OIL USAGE SUMMARY Table 3 Fuel Oil Billing Data Utility Provider: National Terminal, Inc. Point of Delivery ID: - Rate: Based on Time of Delivery Price MONTH OF USE CONSUMPTION (GALLONS) TOTAL BILL Mar-14 10, $33, Apr $2, May $0.00 Jun $0.00 Jul $0.00 Aug $0.00 Sep $0.00 Oct-14 1, $3, Nov-14 5, $13, Dec-14 8, $17, Jan-15 13, $24, Feb-15 14, $29, TOTALS 54, $124, AVERAGE RATE: $2.28 $/Gallon Concord Engineering Group, Inc. 1C15143 August 31, 2015 FINAL Page 7 of 35

9 East Orange School District Whitney Houston Academy Energy Audit Figure 3 Fuel Oil Usage Profile Concord Engineering Group, Inc. 1C15143 August 31, 2015 FINAL Page 8 of 35

10 East Orange School District Whitney Houston Academy Energy Audit II. FACILITY ENERGY USE INDEX (EUI) Energy Use Index (EUI) is a measure of a building s annual energy utilization per square foot of building. This calculation is completed by converting all utility usage consumed by a building for one year, to British Thermal Units (BTU) and dividing this number by the building square footage. EUI is a good measure of a building s energy use and is utilized regularly for comparison of energy performance for similar building types. Building Benchmarking data is collected and analyzed within the Commercial Building Energy Consumption Survey (CBECS), performed by the Energy and Information Administration (EIA). Building data is grouped by function types and tabulated, from which a median site and source energy intensity is determined. The national median or PEER Group Comparable in this instance is the middle value of the national population meaning half the buildings use more energy, and half use less. The PEER Group EUI allows us to compare the relative efficiency of the audited building to that of an average building with the same or similar primary function (i.e. group type). Source use differs from site usage when comparing a building s energy consumption with the national average. Site energy use is the energy consumed by the building at the building site only. Source energy use includes the site energy use as well as all of the losses to create and distribute the energy to the building. Source energy represents the total amount of raw fuel that is required to operate the building. It incorporates all transmission, delivery, and production losses, which allows for a complete assessment of energy efficiency in a building. The type of utility purchased has a substantial impact on the source energy use of a building. The EPA has determined that source energy is the most comparable unit for evaluation purposes and overall global impact. Both the site and source EUI ratings for the building are provided to understand and compare the differences in energy use. The site and source EUI for this facility is calculated as follows: Building Site EUI Electric Usage in kbtu Fuel Usage in kbtu Building Square Footage Building Source EUI Electric Usage in kbtu SS Ratio Fuel Usage in kbtu SS Ratio Building Square Footage Concord Engineering Group, Inc. 1C15143 August 31, 2015 FINAL Page 9 of 35

11 East Orange School District Whitney Houston Academy Energy Audit Table 3 Energy Use Index Summary ENERGY USE INTENSITY CALCULATION SITE SITE- SOURCE BUILDING USE ENERGY TYPE ENERGY SOURCE ENERGY kwh Therms Gallons kbtu RATIO kbtu ELECTRIC 116, , ,243,623 NATURAL GAS 1, , ,490 FUEL OIL 54, ,592, ,668,102 TOTAL 8,101,086 9,030,214 *Site - Source Ratio data is provided by the Energy Star Performance Rating Methodology for Incorporating Source Energy Use document. AUDITED BUILDING PEER COMPARISON BUILDING TYPE K-12 School K-12 School BUILDING AREA 103,000 SQUARE FEET BUILDING SITE EUI kbtu/sf/yr 58.2 kbtu/sf/yr BUILDING SOURCE EUI kbtu/sf/yr kbtu/sf/yr 38% More Efficient than PEER Comparison Concord Engineering Group, Inc. 1C15143 August 31, 2015 FINAL Page 10 of 35

12 East Orange School District Whitney Houston Academy Energy Audit III. FACILITY DESCRIPTION The Whitney Houston Academy is located at 215 Dodd Street in East Orange, New Jersey. This 103,000 SF facility was originally built in The facility is a 3-story building with a basement level and two mezzanine levels. The school is comprised of classrooms, offices, an auditorium, a gym, a cafeteria, storage rooms, restrooms, and utility rooms. Occupancy Profile The school is in use 8:00 am till 3:00 pm, 5 days a week, with staff staying after hours for cleaning and some student activities. There are approximately 69 employees and 367 students which occupy the facility. Building Envelope Exterior walls for the building are masonry brick faced construction with drywall interior. The windows throughout the facility are in poor condition. Typical windows are single-pane operable with aluminum frames. The roof is a combination of A-Frame Style with wood trusses, wood sheathing, a vapor barrier, and tar shingles that comprises the main central structure; and then flat built up roofing on the gymnasium, auditorium, and east and west classroom wings. HVAC Systems The Houston Academy is primarily conditioned by a heating only central steam system, with limited air conditioning being provided by individual window air conditioning and thru-wall units. The steam heating plant consists of two Bethlehem Corporation Continental fire-tube boilers. The boilers are oil-fired rated at 60 gallons per hour of fuel input, or approximately 8,400 MBH. These boilers are 1977 vintage, and given their age are estimated to have an efficiency of 68%. Steam is produced by the boilers at 5 PSI. Fuel oil is stored in an approximately 2,000 gallon tank located outside. There is a large condensate receiving station located in the boiler room that had a significant leak, resulting in much of the return being dumped down the drain. We recommend repairing or replacing the receiving station if the boiler plant is to remain. The steam heating is distributed to radiators, cabinet heaters, unit ventilators and some baseboard throughout the classrooms, offices, hallways, gymnasium, cafeteria, and auditorium. The classrooms fitted with air conditioning have window units that range in capacity from ¾ to 1 ½ tons and range from 3 to 10 years of age. The main office and principals office has thru-wall packaged terminal heat pump units, which are primarily used for cooling. The units provide one ton of cooling with an efficiency of 9.3 EER. Concord Engineering Group, Inc. 1C15143 August 31, 2015 FINAL Page 11 of 35

13 East Orange School District Whitney Houston Academy Energy Audit Exhaust System The school facility has general exhaust fans located on the roof with fractional horsepower motors, and a utility exhaust set located in the 3 rd floor attic space. HVAC System Controls The building is controlled by a pneumatic system operating off a time clock. Rooms have pneumatic thermostats with limited occupant controllability. The building has one compressor located in the boiler room with one 1.65 kilowatt motor. The boilers are also controlled by a Heat-Timer panel located in the boiler room. Domestic Hot Water Domestic hot water for the building is supplied by a single natural gas fired HTP water heater. The unit is rated at 125 MBH with a 72 gallon storage tank. The unit has an estimated thermal efficiency of 80% based on input and recovery ratings. Plumbing System The Whitney Houston Academy utilizes sinks rated at 2.2 gallons per minute. Additionally, water closets and urinals located in the restroom areas have a rating of 1.6 and 1.0 gallons per flush, respectively. Kitchen Equipment The kitchen equipment at the facility consists of two (2) electric ovens 24.5 kw each, three (3) reach-in refrigerators, and two (2) reach in freezers. Miscellaneous Equipment Typical classrooms each had three to four computers, if not more, along with a standard television, and smart board system. Lighting Refer to the Investment Grade Lighting Audit Appendix for a detailed list of the lighting throughout the facility and estimated operating hours per space. Concord Engineering Group, Inc. 1C15143 August 31, 2015 FINAL Page 12 of 35

14 East Orange School District Whitney Houston Academy Energy Audit IV. MAJOR EQUIPMENT LIST The equipment list contains major energy consuming equipment that through implementation of energy conservation measures could yield substantial energy savings. The list shows the major equipment in the facility and all pertinent information utilized in energy savings calculations. An approximate age was assigned to the equipment in some cases if a manufactures date was not shown on the equipment s nameplate. The ASHRAE service life for the equipment along with the remaining useful life is also shown in the Appendix. Refer to the Major Equipment List Appendix for this facility. Concord Engineering Group, Inc. 1C15143 August 31, 2015 FINAL Page 13 of 35

15 East Orange School District Whitney Houston Academy Energy Audit V. ENERGY CONSERVATION MEASURES Energy Conservation Measures are developed specifically for this facility. The energy savings and calculations are highly dependent on the information received from the site survey and interviews with operations personnel. The assumptions and calculations should be reviewed by the owner to ensure accurate representation of this facility. The following ECMs were analyzed: Table 1 ECM Financial Summary ENERGY CONSERVATION MEASURES (ECM's) ECM NO. DESCRIPTION NET INSTALLATION COST A ANNUAL SAVINGS B SIMPLE PAYBACK (Yrs) SIMPLE LIFETIME ROI ECM #1 Interior Lighting Upgrades $61,295 $7, % ECM #2 Exterior Lighting Upgrades $1,590 $ % ECM #3 Lighting Controls Upgrades $1,640 $ % ECM #4 Steam Trap Replacement $29,000 $6, % ECM #5 Fuel Oil to Natural Gas Conversion $45,000 $43, % ECM #6 Boiler Replacement $605,000 $60, % ECM #7 Plug Load Controls $7,100 $ % RENEWABLE ENERGY MEASURES (REM's) ECM NO. DESCRIPTION NET INSTALLATION COST ANNUAL SAVINGS SIMPLE PAYBACK (Yrs) SIMPLE LIFETIME ROI REM #1 25 kw Solar Array $118,957 $9, % Notes: A. Cost takes into consideration applicable NJ Smart StartTM incentives. B. Savings takes into consideration applicable maintenance savings. Concord Engineering Group, Inc. 1C15143 August 31, 2015 FINAL Page 14 of 35

16 East Orange School District Whitney Houston Academy Energy Audit Table 2 ECM Energy Summary ECM NO. DESCRIPTION ENERGY CONSERVATION MEASURES (ECM's) ANNUAL UTILITY REDUCTION ELECTRIC DEMAND (KW) ELECTRIC CONSUMPTION (KWH) NATURAL GAS (THERMS) FUEL OIL (GALLONS) ECM #1 Interior Lighting Upgrades , ECM #2 Exterior Lighting Upgrades 1.0 3, ECM #3 Lighting Controls Upgrades ECM #4 Steam Trap Replacement ,932 ECM #5 Fuel Oil to Natural Gas Conversion ,468 54,620 ECM #6 Boiler Replacement ,312 54,620 ECM #7 Plug Load Controls ECM NO. DESCRIPTION RENEWABLE ENERGY MEASURES (REM's) ELECTRIC DEMAND (KW) ANNUAL UTILITY REDUCTION ELECTRIC CONSUMPTION (KWH) NATURAL GAS (THERMS) FUEL OIL (GALLONS) REM #1 25 kw Solar Array , Concord Engineering Group, Inc. 1C15143 August 31, 2015 FINAL Page 15 of 35

17 East Orange School District Whitney Houston Academy Energy Audit Table 3 ECM Emissions Summary ENERGY CONSERVATION MEASURES (ECM's) ECM NO. DESCRIPTION GREENHOUSE GAS EMISSIONS REDUCTION CO 2 EMISSIONS (LBS) NO X EMISSIONS (LBS) SO 2 EMISSIONS (LBS) ECM #1 Interior Lighting Upgrades 71, ECM #2 Exterior Lighting Upgrades 4, ECM #3 Lighting Controls Upgrades ECM #4 Steam Trap Replacement 65, ECM #5 Fuel Oil to Natural Gas Conversion 328,812 (704) 0 ECM #6 Boiler Replacement 517,841 (555) 0 ECM #7 Plug Load Controls Notes: A. Emissions Reduction based on NJCEP published factors for electric & gas. Concord Engineering Group, Inc. 1C15143 August 31, 2015 FINAL Page 16 of 35

18 East Orange School District Whitney Houston Academy Energy Audit Table 4 Facility Project Summary FACILITY PROJECT SUMMARY TABLE ENERGY CONSERVATION MEASURES ANNUAL ENERGY SAVINGS ($) PROJECT COST ($) SMART START INCENTIVES CUSTOMER COST SIMPLE PAYBACK Interior Lighting Upgrades $7,772 $69,715 $8,420 $61, Exterior Lighting Upgrades $509 $1,930 $340 $1, Lighting Controls Upgrades $86 $1,700 $60 $1, Steam Trap Replacement $6,685 $29,000 $0 $29, Fuel Oil to Natural Gas Conversion $43,478 $45,000 $0 $45, Boiler Replacement $60,603 $605,000 $0 $605, Plug Load Controls $109 $7,100 $0 $7, Total Project $75,764 $714,445 $8,820 $705, Note the measure totals in this table do not take into account interactive effects of measures; see Method of Analysis Section III in Executive Report for further explanation. NOTE: Since Concord Engineering also suggests upgrading to new natural gas boilers, only one of these measures should be implemented, as they conflict with each other. Concord recommends replacing the boilers in their entirety over converting the existing boilers at the facility to natural gas. This project does not qualify for additional incentives through the Pay for Performance Program; please see the Installation Funding Options section for additional program options. Concord Engineering Group, Inc. 1C15143 August 31, 2015 FINAL Page 17 of 35

19 East Orange School District Whitney Houston Academy Energy Audit ECM #1: Interior Lighting Upgrades Description: The majority of the interior lighting throughout the Whitney Houston Academy is provided by 2x4 and 1x4 fluorescent fixtures with newer generation 700 Series 32W T8 lamps and T12 lamps in addition to various CFL and incandescent A-lamp bulbs. It is recommended that all fixtures within the building be replaced with LED equivalent tube lamps and screw-in bulbs due to their efficiency and low power usage. This ECM includes replacing and retrofitting all of the interior lighting throughout the school with new LED type lamps and fixtures. It is recommended that the School District consult with a lighting engineer prior to retrofitting or replacing interior fixtures to ensure code required minimum light levels will be met. Energy Savings Calculations: The Investment Grade Lighting Audit Appendix outlines the hours of operation, proposed new fixtures/retrofits, costs, savings, and payback periods for each set of interior fixtures in the school. LIGHTING UPGRADE SAVINGS SUMMARY DESCRIPTION SAVINGS Electric Demand Savings (kw) 28.0 Electric Usage Savings (kwh) 46,817 Electric Cost Savings ($) $7,772 Maintenance Savings and Project Costs: No maintenance cost savings were estimated for this measure. Project Costs are based off RS Means Unit Cost Data and Vendor quotes. Concord Engineering Group, Inc. 1C15143 August 31, 2015 FINAL Page 18 of 35

20 East Orange School District Whitney Houston Academy Energy Audit Energy Savings Summary: ECM #1 - ENERGY SAVINGS SUMMARY Installation Cost ($): $69,715 NJ Smart Start Equipment Incentive ($): $8,420 Net Installation Cost ($): $61,295 Maintenance Savings ($/Yr): $0 Energy Savings ($/Yr): $7,772 Total Yearly Savings ($/Yr): $7,772 Estimated ECM Lifetime (Yr): 15 Simple Payback 7.9 Simple Lifetime ROI 90.2% Simple Lifetime Maintenance Savings $0 Simple Lifetime Savings $116,580 Internal Rate of Return (IRR) 9% Net Present Value (NPV) $31, Concord Engineering Group, Inc. 1C15143 August 31, 2015 FINAL Page 19 of 35

21 East Orange School District Whitney Houston Academy Energy Audit ECM #2: Exterior Lighting Upgrade Description: The exterior lighting at the school includes exterior building lighting. The exterior of the building is currently lit by PAR lamps and high pressure sodium wall packs, with the area around the school lit by pole mounted high pressure sodium lamps. Concord Engineering recommends upgrading all of the exterior lighting to an energy-efficient lighting system that includes LED wall packs and LED bulb replacements. Energy Savings Calculations: A detailed Investment Grade Lighting Audit can be found in Investment Grade Lighting Audit Appendix that outlines the proposed retrofits, costs, savings, and payback periods. LIGHTING UPGRADE SAVINGS SUMMARY DESCRIPTION SAVINGS Electric Demand Savings (kw) 1.0 Electric Usage Savings (kwh) 3,069 Electric Cost Savings ($) $509 Maintenance Savings and Project Costs: No maintenance cost savings were estimated for this measure. Project Costs are based off RS Means Unit Cost Data and Vendor quotes. Concord Engineering Group, Inc. 1C15143 August 31, 2015 FINAL Page 20 of 35

22 East Orange School District Whitney Houston Academy Energy Audit Energy Savings Summary: ECM #2 - ENERGY SAVINGS SUMMARY Installation Cost ($): $1,930 NJ Smart Start Equipment Incentive ($): $340 Net Installation Cost ($): $1,590 Maintenance Savings ($/Yr): $0 Energy Savings ($/Yr): $509 Total Yearly Savings ($/Yr): $509 Estimated ECM Lifetime (Yr): 15 Simple Payback 3.1 Simple Lifetime ROI 380.6% Simple Lifetime Maintenance Savings $0 Simple Lifetime Savings $7,642 Internal Rate of Return (IRR) 32% Net Present Value (NPV) $4, Concord Engineering Group, Inc. 1C15143 August 31, 2015 FINAL Page 21 of 35

23 East Orange School District Whitney Houston Academy Energy Audit ECM #3: Interior Lighting Controls Upgrade Description: Sometimes lights in a school are left on unnecessarily. In many cases the lights may be left on because of the inconvenience to manually switch lights off when a room is left or on when a room is first occupied. In some instances lights might be left on due to the misconception that it is better to keep the lights on rather than to continuously switch lights on and off. Although increased switching reduces lamp life, the energy savings outweigh the lamp replacement costs. The payback timeframe for when to turn the lights off is approximately two minutes. If the lights are expected to be off for at least a two minute interval, then it pays to shut them off. Lighting controls come in many forms. Sometimes an additional switch is adequate to provide reduced lighting levels when full light output is not needed. Occupancy sensors detect motion and will switch the lights on when the room is occupied. Occupancy sensors can either be mounted in place of a current wall switch, or on the ceiling to cover large areas. In addition, daylight control systems can be implemented using daylighting control systems that dim the electric lighting in response to interior daylight levels. The light output of the fluorescent lamps (T8) is varied by using electronic dimming ballasts. Photosensors, typically mounted in the ceiling, are used to measure the quantity of daylight in the space then determine the amount of dimming required to maintain adequate lighting levels in the total space. The U.S. Department of Energy sponsored a study to analyze energy savings achieved through various types of building system controls. The referenced savings is based on the Advanced Sensors and Controls for Building Applications: Market Assessment and Potential R&D Pathways, document posted for public use April The study has found that buildings have the potential to achieve significant energy savings through the use of building controls. The average energy savings are as follows based on the report: Occupancy Sensors for Lighting Control 20% - 28% energy savings. Savings resulting from the implementation of this ECM for energy management controls are estimated to be 20% of the total light energy controlled by occupancy sensors. This ECM includes installation of ceiling or switch-mount sensors for the teacher s lounge, offices, and restrooms. Sensors shall be manufactured by Sensorswitch, Watt Stopper or equivalent. The Investment Grade Lighting Audit Appendix of this report includes the summary of lighting controls which can be implemented in this ECM and outlines the proposed lighting/daylighting controls, costs, savings, and payback periods. The calculations adjust the lighting power usage by the applicable percent savings for each area that includes lighting controls. Concord Engineering Group, Inc. 1C15143 August 31, 2015 FINAL Page 22 of 35

24 East Orange School District Whitney Houston Academy Energy Audit Energy Savings Calculations: Energy Savings % Savings Controlled Light Energy kwh/yr Savings. Energy Savings $ kwh kwh Ave Elec Cost LIGHTING CONTROLS SAVINGS SUMMARY DESCRIPTION SAVINGS Electric Demand Savings (kw) 0.0 Electric Usage Savings (kwh) 521 Electric Cost Savings ($) $86 Maintenance Savings and Project Costs: No maintenance cost savings were estimated for this measure. Project Costs are based off RS Means Unit Cost Data and Vendor quotes. Energy Savings Summary: ECM #3 - ENERGY SAVINGS SUMMARY Installation Cost ($): $1,700 NJ Smart Start Equipment Incentive ($): $60 Net Installation Cost ($): $1,640 Maintenance Savings ($/Yr): $0 Energy Savings ($/Yr): $86 Total Yearly Savings ($/Yr): $86 Estimated ECM Lifetime (Yr): 15 Simple Payback 19.1 Simple Lifetime ROI -21.3% Simple Lifetime Maintenance Savings $0 Simple Lifetime Savings $1,290 Internal Rate of Return (IRR) -3% Net Present Value (NPV) ($613.34) Concord Engineering Group, Inc. 1C15143 August 31, 2015 FINAL Page 23 of 35

25 East Orange School District Whitney Houston Academy Energy Audit ECM #4: STEAM TRAP REPLACEMENT PROGRAM Description: Steam traps are required for the proper operation of steam distributions systems. Traps are mechanical devices installed on steam pipes to remove condensate from steam flow. Unfortunately steam traps have a tendency to leak. On average 20% of steam traps are leaking in existing installations. Steam traps only have an average life of five (5) years. This ECM would replace approximately one hundred three (103) balanced pressure thermostatic steam traps. Where repairing is not feasible, the thermostatic traps will be replaced. Schedule 80 piping and extra heavy fittings will be used, and all piping and fittings between the unions will be replaced along with the steam traps. In addition, a complete steam trap survey will be performed along with tagging and implementing a 3-year, revolving, steam trap maintenance program. Energy Savings Calculations: Trap Steam Loss Quantity Estimated Annual Annual Orifice lb/hr of Quantity Steam Loss Steam Loss Cost Steam Trap Sizes Diamter (in) (15 PSI) Traps Failed lbs Gallons Savings 3/4" Trap 3/8" ,860 2,932 $6,685 TOTAL ,860 2,932 $6,685 Maintenance Savings and Project Costs: STEAM TRAP LOSS CALCULATION No maintenance cost savings were estimated for this measure. However we recommend the district institute a regular scheduled trap maintenance program. Project Costs are based off RS Means Unit Cost Data and Vendor quotes. Concord Engineering Group, Inc. 1C15143 August 31, 2015 FINAL Page 24 of 35

26 East Orange School District Whitney Houston Academy Energy Audit Energy Savings Summary: ECM #4 - ENERGY SAVINGS SUMMARY Installation Cost ($): $29,000 NJ Smart Start Equipment Incentive ($): $0 Net Installation Cost ($): $29,000 Maintenance Savings ($/Yr): $0 Energy Savings ($/Yr): $6,685 Total Yearly Savings ($/Yr): $6,685 Estimated ECM Lifetime (Yr): 15 Simple Payback 4.3 Simple Lifetime ROI 245.8% Simple Lifetime Maintenance Savings $0 Simple Lifetime Savings $100,275 Internal Rate of Return (IRR) 22% Net Present Value (NPV) $50, Concord Engineering Group, Inc. 1C15143 August 31, 2015 FINAL Page 25 of 35

27 East Orange School District Whitney Houston Academy Energy Audit ECM #5 Fuel Conversion to Natural Gas Description: The Whitney Houston Academy currently uses fuel oil to fire the boilers at the facility. Concord Engineering recommends converting to natural gas. While the conversion of existing equipment over to natural gas may not save energy, it will reduce energy costs. This ECM would replace the fuel oil used to fire the boilers with natural gas at Whitney Houston Academy. It is recommended new dual fuel burners being installed on the boiler to be primarily fired off natural gas. It is also recommended the district consult with the utility company to ensure adequate gas pressure is available at the site to support operation of the boilers. Since Concord Engineering also suggests upgrading to new natural gas boilers, only one of these measures should be implemented, as they conflict with each other. Concord recommends replacing the boilers in their entirety over converting the existing boilers at the facility to natural gas. Energy Savings Calculations: Fuel conversion does not take into account any change in boiler efficiency. Fuel Usage kbtu Fuel Usage Units Fuel Conversion Factor Btu Unit Natural Gas Usage therm Fuel Usage kbtu 1 therm 100 kbtu Concord Engineering Group, Inc. 1C15143 August 31, 2015 FINAL Page 26 of 35

28 East Orange School District Whitney Houston Academy Energy Audit FUEL CONVERSION ANALYSIS ECM INPUTS EXISTING PROPOSED SAVINGS Natural Gas Description Fuel Oil Conversion Existing Fuel Oil Usage (Gallons) 54,620 0 Fuel Oil Conversion (Btu/Gal) 140, ,000 Natural Gas (Btu/therm) 100, ,000 Fuel Usage (kbtu) 7,646,800 7,646,800 Fuel Oil #2 ($/Gallon) $2.280 $2.280 Natural Gas ($/therm) $1.060 $1.060 ENERGY SAVINGS CALCULATIONS Fuel Oil #2 Usage (Gallons) 54, ,620 Natural Gas Usage (Therm) 0 76,468 (76,468) Energy Cost ($) $124,534 $81,056 $43,478 COMMENTS: Concord Engineering Group, Inc. 1C15143 August 31, 2015 FINAL Page 27 of 35

29 East Orange School District Whitney Houston Academy Energy Audit Maintenance Savings and Project Costs: No maintenance cost savings were estimated for this measure. Project Costs are based off RS Means Unit Cost Data. Energy Savings Summary: ECM #5 - ENERGY SAVINGS SUMMARY Installation Cost ($): $45,000 NJ Smart Start Equipment Incentive ($): $0 Net Installation Cost ($): $45,000 Maintenance Savings ($/Yr): $0 Energy Savings ($/Yr): $43,478 Total Yearly Savings ($/Yr): $43,478 Estimated ECM Lifetime (Yr): 15 Simple Payback 1.0 Simple Lifetime ROI % Simple Lifetime Maintenance Savings $0 Simple Lifetime Savings $652,170 Internal Rate of Return (IRR) 97% Net Present Value (NPV) $474, Concord Engineering Group, Inc. 1C15143 August 31, 2015 FINAL Page 28 of 35

30 East Orange School District Whitney Houston Academy Energy Audit ECM #6: Boiler Replacement Description: The Whitney Houston School has two Bethlehem Corporation Continental fire-tube boilers. The boilers are oil-fired rated at 60 gallons per hour of fuel input, or approximately 8,400 MBH. These boilers are 1977 vintage, and given their age are estimated to have an efficiency of 68%. By converting the boilers to natural gas and installing new boilers substantial energy and cost savings could be realized. This ECM would install two Weil-McLain H Series gas/oil steam boiler rated at 8,660 MBH input to replace the two existing boilers. The owner should consult a professional engineer prior to installation of this measure to verify load requirements and consult with the utility regarding adequate gas pressure. Energy Savings Calculations: BTU Bldg Heat Re quired Existing Fuel Use Units Heating Eff. % Fuel HeatValue Units Pr oposed Heating Gas Usage Energy Cost Heating Gas Usage Bldg Heat Re quired BTU BTU Heating Eff. % Fuel Heat Value Therm $ Therm Therms Ave Fuel Cost Concord Engineering Group, Inc. 1C15143 August 31, 2015 FINAL Page 29 of 35

31 East Orange School District Whitney Houston Academy Energy Audit BOILER REPLACMEENT/CONVERSION CALCULATIONS ECM INPUTS EXISTING PROPOSED SAVINGS ECM INPUTS Oil Fired Steam Steam NG Existing Fuel Oil Use (Gal) 54,620 Boiler Efficiency (%) 68.0% 85.6% 18% Nat Gas Heat Value (BTU/Therm) 139, ,000 Equivalent Building Heat Usage (MMBTUs) 5,163 5,163 Gas Cost ($/Therm) $1.06 $1.06 Oil Cost ($/Gallon) $2.28 $2.28 ENERGY SAVINGS CALCULATIONS ECM RESULTS EXISTING PROPOSED SAVINGS Natural Gas Usage (Therms) 0 60,312-60,312 Fuel Oil Usage (Gallons) 54, ,620 Energy Cost ($) $124,534 $63,930 $60,603 COMMENTS: Boiler Efficiency Based on age of boiler and IBR Rating Maintenance Savings and Project Costs: No maintenance cost savings were estimated for this measure. Project Costs are based off RS Means Unit Cost Data. Concord Engineering Group, Inc. 1C15143 August 31, 2015 FINAL Page 30 of 35

32 East Orange School District Whitney Houston Academy Energy Audit Energy Savings Summary: ECM #6 - ENERGY SAVINGS SUMMARY Installation Cost ($): $605,000 NJ Smart Start Equipment Incentive ($): $0 Net Installation Cost ($): $605,000 Maintenance Savings ($/Yr): $0 Energy Savings ($/Yr): $60,603 Total Yearly Savings ($/Yr): $60,603 Estimated ECM Lifetime (Yr): 25 Simple Payback 10.0 Simple Lifetime ROI 150.4% Simple Lifetime Maintenance Savings 0 Simple Lifetime Savings $1,515,080 Internal Rate of Return (IRR) 9% Net Present Value (NPV) $450, Concord Engineering Group, Inc. 1C15143 August 31, 2015 FINAL Page 31 of 35

33 East Orange School District Whitney Houston Academy Energy Audit ECM #7: Plug Load Management Description: The Whitney Houston Academy has many types of plug in type equipment from computer monitors, copiers/printers, window air conditioning units, and other office equipment. As technology continues to advance and be integrated into society and the work environment, the devices in most instances require electrical power either a battery or power outlet. The increase in use of these devices is contributing vastly to the increase in electric usage at facilities and according to a study performed by the California Energy Commission can account for more than 20% of electricity use. In most instances these devices are left plugged in and sometimes on continuously whether occupants are present or not leading to a significant amount of wasted energy. By managing these loads with intelligent outlet receptacles facility and energy management staff can reduce the consumption of these devices and better control energy waste. The installation of a plug load management system with wireless controlled outlets will enable facility staff and energy managers to control the power draw of these systems during unoccupied periods. For cost estimating purposes a total of 50 outlets would be controlled by this system, further refinement of this number should be performed before installation. The basis of this measure is a Bert plug load management system with a network interface control system. Energy Savings Calculations: Data published by the DOE s Energy and Information Administration Commercial Buildings Consumption Survey states energy use breakouts for various types of buildings. This survey data was used to estimate the building energy consumption associated with Office Type Equipment. Savings are based on a ten (10%) percent reduction of the electric usage associated with interior equipment usage. Concord Engineering Group, Inc. 1C15143 August 31, 2015 FINAL Page 32 of 35

34 East Orange School District Whitney Houston Academy Energy Audit PLUG LOAD MANAGEMENT SAVINGS CALCULATIONS ECM INPUTS EXISTING PROPOSED SAVINGS Plug Load Usage Electric (kbtu) 22,342 20,108 2,234 Savings Percentage % Electric Site Conversion (kwh/kbtu) Electric Cost ($/kwh) $0.166 $0.166 ENERGY SAVINGS CALCULATIONS ECM RESULTS EXISTING PROPOSED SAVINGS Electric Usage (kwh) 6,548 5, Energy Cost ($) $1,087 $978 $109 COMMENTS: Energy Savings Summary: ECM #7 - ENERGY SAVINGS SUMMARY Installation Cost ($): $7,100 NJ Smart Start Equipment Incentive ($): $0 Net Installation Cost ($): $7,100 Maintenance Savings ($/Yr): $0 Energy Savings ($/Yr): $109 Total Yearly Savings ($/Yr): $109 Estimated ECM Lifetime (Yr): 15 Simple Payback 65.1 Simple Lifetime ROI -77.0% Simple Lifetime Maintenance Savings $0 Simple Lifetime Savings $1,635 Internal Rate of Return (IRR) -14% Net Present Value (NPV) ($5,798.77) Concord Engineering Group, Inc. 1C15143 August 31, 2015 FINAL Page 33 of 35

35 East Orange School District Whitney Houston Academy Energy Audit REM #1: 25 kw Solar System Description: Whitney Houston Academy has available roof space that could accommodate solar arrays. Based on the available area a 25 kilowatt solar array could be installed. The array will produce approximately 29,640 kilowatt-hours annually that will reduce the overall electric usage of the facility by 25%. The owner should consult a structural engineer prior to installing any solar array to insure the roof can accommodate the additional weight. Energy Savings Calculations: See Renewable / Distributed Energy Measures Calculations Appendix for detailed financial summary and proposed solar layout areas. Financial results in table below are based on 100% financing of the system over a fifteen year period. Energy Savings Summary: REM #1 - ENERGY SAVINGS SUMMARY Installation Cost ($): $118,957 NJ Smart Start Equipment Incentive ($): $0 Net Installation Cost ($): $118,957 SREC Revenue ($/Yr): $4,491 Energy Savings ($/Yr): $4,920 Total Yearly Savings ($/Yr): $9,411 Estimated ECM Lifetime (Yr): 15 Simple Payback 12.6 Simple Lifetime ROI 18.7% Simple Lifetime Maintenance Savings $67,359 Simple Lifetime Savings $141,164 Internal Rate of Return (IRR) 2.2% Net Present Value (NPV) ($6,609.43) Concord Engineering Group, Inc. 1C15143 August 31, 2015 FINAL Page 34 of 35

36 East Orange School District Whitney Houston Academy Energy Audit VI. ADDITIONAL RECOMMENDATIONS The following recommendations include no cost/low cost measures, Operation & Maintenance (O&M) items, and water conservation measures with attractive paybacks. These measures are not eligible for the Smart Start Buildings incentives from the office of Clean Energy but save energy none the less. A. Chemically clean the condenser and evaporator coils periodically to optimize efficiency. Poorly maintained heat transfer surfaces can reduce efficiency 5-10%. B. Maintain all weather stripping on windows and doors. C. Clean all light fixtures to maximize light output. D. Provide more frequent air filter changes to decrease overall system power usage and maintain better IAQ. E. Turn off computers when not in use. Ensure computers are not running in screen saver mode. F. Replace any old CRT Monitors with LED/LCD Type Monitors, which can draw as much as a quarter the power of an equivalent CRT monitor. G. Ensure outside air dampers are functioning properly and only open during occupied mode. H. Repair/Replace the large condensate receiving station if the boiler plant is to remain Concord Engineering Group, Inc. 1C15143 August 31, 2015 FINAL Page 35 of 35

37 Appendix Energy Audit APPENDIX A Concord Engineering Group, Inc.

38 APPENDIX A 1 of 1 ECM COST & SAVINGS BREAKDOWN CONCORD ENGINEERING GROUP East Orange School District - Whitney Houston Academy ECM ENERGY AND FINANCIAL COSTS AND SAVINGS SUMMARY ECM NO. DESCRIPTION MATERIAL INSTALLATION COST LABOR REBATES, INCENTIVES NET INSTALLATION COST YEARLY SAVINGS ECM LIFETIME LIFETIME ENERGY SAVINGS ENERGY MAINT. / SREC TOTAL (Yearly Saving * ECM Lifetime) LIFETIME MAINTENANCE SAVINGS (Yearly Maint Svaing * ECM Lifetime) LIFETIME ROI (Lifetime Savings - Net Cost) / (Net Cost) SIMPLE PAYBACK (Net cost / Yearly Savings) INTERNAL RATE OF RETURN (IRR) NET PRESENT VALUE (NPV) ($) ($) ($) ($) ($/Yr) ($/Yr) ($/Yr) (Yr) ($) ($) (%) (Yr) ($) ($) ECM #1 Interior Lighting Upgrades $44,752 $24,963 $8,420 $61,295 $7,772 $0 $7, $116,575 $0 90.2% % $31, ECM #2 Exterior Lighting Upgrades $1,550 $380 $340 $1,590 $509 $0 $ $7,642 $ % % $4, ECM #3 Lighting Controls Upgrades $1,150 $550 $60 $1,640 $86 $0 $86 15 $1,290 $0-21.3% % ($613.34) ECM #4 Steam Trap Replacement $16,500 $12,500 $0 $29,000 $6,685 $0 $6, $100,275 $ % % $50, ECM #5 Fuel Oil to Natural Gas Conversion $25,000 $20,000 $0 $45,000 $43,478 $0 $43, $652,170 $ % % $474, ECM #6 Boiler Replacement $325,000 $280,000 $0 $605,000 $60,603 $0 $60, $1,515,080 $ % % $450, ECM #7 Plug Load Controls $5,000 $2,100 $0 $7,100 $109 $0 $ $1,635 $0-77.0% % ($5,798.77) REM RENEWABLE ENERGY AND FINANCIAL COSTS AND SAVINGS SUMMARY REM #1 25 kw Solar Array $71,374 $47,583 $0 $118,957 $4,920 $4,491 $9, $235,273 $112, % % $44, Notes: 1) The variable Cn in the formulas for Internal Rate of Return and Net Present Value stands for the cash flow during each period. 2) The variable DR in the NPV equation stands for Discount Rate 3) For NPV and IRR calculations: From n=0 to N periods where N is the lifetime of ECM and Cn is the cash flow during each period.

39 Appendix Energy Audit APPENDIX B Concord Engineering Group, Inc.

40 Appendix B Page 1 of 6 Concord Engineering Group, Inc. 520 BURNT MILL ROAD VOORHEES, NEW JERSEY PHONE: (856) FAX: (856) SmartStart Building Incentives The NJ SmartStart Buildings Program offers financial incentives on a wide variety of building system equipment. The incentives were developed to help offset the initial cost of energy-efficient equipment. The following tables show the current available incentives from July 1, 2015 to June 30, 2016, further details including how to apply, forms, and calculated incentive values can be found the Clean Energy Website. ( Electric Chillers Constant Speed: Base: $8 - $30 per ton Performance Add: $2 - $2.25 per ton Water-Cooled Chillers Variable Speed: Base: $12 - $44 per ton Performance Add: $2 - $4.00 per ton Constant Speed: Base: $20 per ton Performance Add: $3.50 per ton Air-Cooled Chillers Variable Speed: Base: $90 - $92 per ton Performance Add: $4.00 per ton Energy Efficiency must comply with ASHRAE Gas Absorption Chillers (Indirect & Direct-Fired) Gas Cooling $185 - $450 per ton Desiccant Systems $1.00 per cfm gas or electric Electric Unitary HVAC Unitary AC and Split Systems $73 - $92 per ton Air-to-Air Heat Pumps $73 - $92 per ton Water-Source Heat Pumps $81 per ton Packaged Terminal AC & HP $65 per ton Central DX AC Systems $40- $72 per ton Dual Enthalpy Economizer Controls $250 Occupancy Controlled Thermostat (Hospitality & Institutional Facility) $75 per thermostat A/C Economizing Controls < 5 tons $85/unit; >5 tons $170/unit Energy Efficiency must comply with ASHRAE

41 Appendix B Page 2 of 6 Hot Water Gas Fired Boilers < 300 MBH Hot Water Gas Fired Boilers MBH Hot Water Gas Fired Boilers > MBH Hot Water Gas Fired Boilers > MBH Gas Heating Non-Condensing: $0.95 per MBH, Minimum $400 per unit Condensing: $2.00 per MBH, Minimum $1000 per unit Non-Condensing: $1.75 per MBH Condensing: $2.20 per MBH Minimum $1000 per unit Non-Condensing: $1.50 per MBH Condensing: $2.20 per MBH Non-Condensing: $1.30 per MBH Condensing: $2.00 per MBH Steam, Except Natural Draft, Gas fired Boilers < 300 MBH $1.40 per MBH, Minimum $400 per unit Steam, Except Natural Draft, Gas fired Boilers MBH $1.20 per MBH Steam, Except Natural Draft, Gas fired Boilers > MBH $1.20 per MBH Steam, Except Natural Draft, Gas fired Boilers > MBH $1.00 per MBH Steam, Natural Draft < 300 MBH $1.40 per MBH, Minimum $300 per unit Steam, Natural Draft MBH $1.00 per MBH Steam, Natural Draft > MBH $0.90 per MBH Steam, Natural Draft > MBH $0.70 per MBH All Types Gas Fired Boilers > 4000 MBH (Calculated through Custom Measure Path) Gas Furnaces $400 per unit, AFUE 95% Boiler Economizing Controls $1,200 - $2,700 Low Intensity Infrared Heating $300 - $500 per unit Natural Gas Water Heating Gas Water Heaters 50 gallons, 0.67 energy factor or better $50 per unit Gas-Fired Water Heaters > 50 gallons $ $2.00 per MBH Gas-Fired Booster Water Heaters $17 - $35 per MBH Gas Fired Tankless Water Heaters $300 per unit

42 Appendix B Page 3 of 6 Ground Source Heat Pumps $450 per ton, EER 16 Closed Loop $600 per ton, EER 18 $750 per ton, EER 20 Energy Efficiency must comply with ASHRAE Variable Frequency Drives Variable Air Volume $65 - $155 per hp Chilled-Water Pumps 20 hp $60 per VFD rated hp Rotary Screw Air Compressors 25 hp $5,250 to $12,500 per drive Centrifugal Fan Applications on Constant Volume HVAC Systems $80 per VFD rated hp, maximum $6,000 per drive Cooling Towers 10 hp $60 per VFD rated hp Boiler Fans > 5 HP $65 to $155 per hp Boiler Feed Water Pumps > 5 HP $60 to $155 per hp Commercial Kitchen Hood up to 50 HP Retrofit $55 $300 per hp New Hood $55 - $250 per hp Prescriptive Lighting T-8 reduced Wattage (28w/25w 4, 1-4 lamps) $10 per fixture Lamp & ballast replacement For retrofit of T-8 fixtures by permanent de-lamping & new reflectors (Electronic ballast replacement required) $5 per fixture T-5 and T-8 High Bay Fixtures $25 - $150 per fixture HID 100w Replace with new induction fixture. (must be 30% less watts/fixture than HID system) HID 100w Retrofit with induction lamp, power coupler and generator (must be 30% less watts/fixture than HID system) $70 per fixture $50 per fixture

43 Appendix B Page 4 of 6 Prescriptive Lighting - LED LED Architectural Floor and Spot Luminaires $50 per fixture LED Bollard Fixtures $50 per fixture LED Display Case Lighting $30 per display case LED Fuel Pump Canopy $100 per fixture LED High-Bay and Low-Bay Fixtures for Commercial & Industrial Bldgs. $150 per fixture LED High-Bay-Aisle Lighting LED Linear Ambient Luminaires (Indirect, Indirect/Direct, Direct/Indirect, Direct) LED Linear Replacement Lamps (2 & 4 only) Luminaires for Ambient Lighting of Interior Commercial Spaces (1x4, 2x2, 2x4 New Fixtures and Retrofit Kits) LED Outdoor Pole/Arm-Mounted Area and Roadway Luminaries $150 per fixture 2 Fixtures - $20/fixture 3 Fixtures - $30/fixture 4 Fixtures - $45/fixture 6 Fixtures - $60/fixture 8 Fixtures - $75/fixture $5 per lamp 1x4 LED - $15 per fixture 2x2 LED - $15 per fixture 2x4 LED - $25 per fixture $100 per fixture LED Outdoor Pole/Arm-Mounted Decorative Luminaries $50 per fixture LED Outdoor Wall-Mounted Area Luminaries $100 per fixture LED Parking Garage Luminaries $100 per fixture LED Retrofit Kits for Large Outdoor Pole / Arm-Mounted Area and Roadway Luminaires LED Refrigerator/Freezer case lighting replacement of fluorescent in medium and low temperature display case LED Shelf-Mtd. Display & Task Lights $150 per fixture $30 per 4 foot $42 per 5 foot $65 per 6 foot $15 per linear foot

44 Appendix B Page 5 of 6 LED Stairwell and Passageway Luminaires $40 per fixture LED Track or Mono-Point Directional Lighting Fixtures LED Wall-Wash Lights EnergyStar Commercial Lighting Fixtures EnergyStar Screw and Pine-Based Bulbs $30 per fixture $30 per fixture $5 to $10 per fixture $5 to $10 per lamp Lighting Controls Occupancy Sensors Wall Mounted (Existing Facilities Only) $20 per control Remote Mounted (Existing Facilities Only) $35 per control Daylight Dimming Controls $45 per fixture controlled Occupancy Based hi-low Dimming Control Occupancy Sensor Remote Mounted High-Bay (Existing Facilities Only) $35 per fixture controlled $35 per control Refrigeration Doors/Covers Energy-Efficient Doors/Covers for $100 per door Installation on Open Refrigerated Cases Aluminum Night Curtains for Installation on Open Refrigerated Cases $3.50 per linear foot Refrigeration Controls Door Heater Controls $50 per control Electric Defrost Controls $50 per control Evaporator Fan Controls $75 per control Novelty Cooler Shutoff $50 per control Refrigerator / Freezer Case Premium Efficiency Motors $40 per ECM for replacement of Fraction ECM Motor < 1 HP existing shaded-pole motor

45 Appendix B Page 6 of 6 Combination Oven/Steamer (Electric) Combination Oven/Steamer (Natural Gas) Convection Oven (Electric) Convection Oven (Natural Gas) Rack Oven (Natural Gas) Conveyor Oven (Natural Gas) Fryer (Electric) Fryer (Natural Gas) Large Vat Fryer (Electric) Large Vat Fryer (Natural Gas) Griddle (Electric) Griddle (Natural Gas) Steam Cooker (Electric) Steam Cooker (Natural Gas) Insulated Holding Cabinets Glass Door Refrigerators Solid Door Refrigerators Glass Door Freezers Solid Door Freezers Ice Machines Dishwashers Performance Lighting Custom Electric and Gas Equipment Incentives Custom Measures Food Service Equipment Other Equipment Incentives $1,000/oven $750/oven $350/oven $500/oven $1,000/single oven, $2,000/double oven $500/small deck $750/large deck $200/vat $749/vat $200/vat $500/vat $300/griddle $125/griddle $1,250/steamer $2,000/steamer $200 to $300/unit $75 to $150/unit $50 to $200/unit $200 to $1,000/unit $100 to $600/unit $50 to $500/unit $400 to $1,500/unit $1.00 per watt per SF below program incentive threshold, currently 5% more energy efficient than ASHRAE for New Construction and Complete Renovation not prescriptive $0.16 KWh and $1.60/Therm of 1st year savings, or a buy down to a 1 year payback on estimated savings. Minimum required savings of 75,000 KWh or 1,500 Therms and an IRR of at least 10%.

46 Appendix Energy Audit APPENDIX C Concord Engineering Group, Inc.

47 ENERGY STAR Data Verification Checklist 74 ENERGY STAR Score 1 Whitney Houston Academy Registry Name: Whitney Houston Academy Primary Function: K-12 School Gross Floor Area (ft²): 103,000 Built: 1873 For Year Ending: 04/30/2015 Date Generated: 08/13/ The ENERGY STAR score is a 1-to-100 assessment of a building s energy efficiency as compared with similar building nationwide, adjusting for climate and business activity. Property & Contact Information Property Address Whitney Houston Academy 215 Dodd Street East Orange, New Jersey Property ID: Property Owner East Orange School District 199 4th Avenue, 5th Floor East Orange, NJ ( ) - Primary Contact Racquel Ferguson 199 4th Avenue, 5th Floor East Orange, NJ (973) racquel.ferguson@eastorange.k12.nj.us 1. Review of Whole Property Characteristics Basic Property Information 1) Property Name: Whitney Houston Academy Is this the official name of the property? If No, please specify: 2) Primary Function: K-12 School Is this an accurate description of the primary use of this property? 3) Location: 215 Dodd Street East Orange, New Jersey Is this correct and complete? 4) Gross Floor Area: 103,000 ft² Yes Yes Yes Yes No No No No Page 1 of 9