Commitment Beyond Numbers
|
|
- Veronica Briggs
- 8 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 3109CorneliusDrive Bloomington,IL pinnacleactuaries.com RooseveltC.Mosley,FCAS,MAAA Principal&ConsultingActuary June8,2015 Mr.CharlesRaimi DeputyCorporationCounsel CityofDetroitLawDepartment 2WoodwardAvenue,Suite500 Detroit,Michigan48226 DearChuck: AttachedisthereportdetailingtheestimatedsavingsbasedontheproposedPIPreforms.Ithasbeena pleasureworkingwithyouinthedevelopmentofthisreport. Pinnacleremainsavailabletoansweranyquestionsorprovideanyclarificationsasneeded. ThankYou, Roosevelt RooseveltC.Mosley,FCAS,MAAA PrincipalandConsultingActuary CommitmentBeyondNumbers
2 June8,2015 RooseveltC.Mosley,Jr,FCAS,MAAA CorneliusDrive Bloomington,IL pinnacleactuaries.com CommitmentBeyondNumbers
3 3109CorneliusDrive Bloomington,IL pinnacleactuaries.com June8,2015 TableofContents Contents TableofContents...1 Scope...2 ReliancesandLimitations...2 DistributionandUse...2 Data...3 ProjectBackground...4 ReformProposal#1:PIPBenefitLimitsandPreferredProviderAgreements...5 IntroducePIPBenefitLimits...5 PreferredProviderAgreement...5 ReformProposal#2:HighDeductibleOption...7 TotalEstimatedSavings ReformOption#1...7 TotalEstimatedSavings ReformOption#2...8 MoreRecentData...9 Conclusion...10 IndexofAttachments...12 CommitmentBeyondNumbers
4 Scope TheCityofDetroit(TheCity)engagedPinnacleActuarialResources,Inc.(Pinnacle)toperforma feasibilitystudyforaproposedcitysponsoredinsurancecompany(dinsurance)thatwillsellnofault insurancetovehicleownersindetroit.theinitialphaseoftheprojectwasforpinnacletoreview availableinsurancedataandproposedlegislativechangestothemichigannofaultlawthatwould applytotheproposednewinsurer,andtoestimatethepremiumsavingsthatcouldbeachievedbased onthelawchanges. Basedonthefindingsintheinitialphaseandtheoutcomeoftheproposedlegislativechanges, PinnaclewouldthenassistTheCitywithdevelopmentoftheratingandunderwritingplanforD Insuranceaswellasprojectedfinancialresultsandcapitalrequirements. Thisreportoutlinesthecalculationoftheestimatedsavings. ReliancesandLimitations Indevelopingthisreport,PinnaclehasreliedprimarilyupondataandinformationsuppliedbyTheCity andtheinsuranceresearchcouncil(irc).werelieduponthegeneralaccuracyofthisdataand informationwithoutindependentverification.however,wedidreviewcertainelementsofthisdata andinformationforreasonablenessandconsistencywithourknowledgeoftheinsuranceindustryand theclaimsprocess.wealsovalidatedthatthedataprovidedwasconsistentwithothersourcesof publiclyavailableinformation.anyerrorsoromissionsinthedataprovidedcouldhaveamaterial effectonouranalysisoftheprojectedsavings. TheanalysisoftheIRCclaimexperiencewasforclaimsthatoccurredin2012.Assuch,anyprojection oftheresultsofthisdataintothecurrentclaimsenvironmentinvolvesestimatesoftheimpactof differencesinthelegalandmedicalenvironmentnowasopposedto2012.therefore,anysuch projectionsaresubjecttoeconomicandstatisticalvariation.noassurancescanbeofferedthatthe resultsofthisclaimstudywillberepresentativeoftoday sconditions. Otherreliancesandlimitationsandspecificassumptionsanddataadjustmentsarecitedinthisreport andintheattachedexhibitsthatareanintegralpartofthisreport. DistributionandUse ThisreportandtheopinionsexpressedhereinhavebeenpreparedforTheCity sinternaluseandfor thesupportofthecity slegislativeeffortstoauthorizeinsurerstoselladinsuranceproductonly. FurtherdistributionofthisreportisnotallowedwithouttheexpresswrittenconsentofPinnacle. Upongrantingofsuchrequest,thereportmustbereleasedinitsentirety,andallrecipientsmustbe madeawarethatpinnacleistheauthorofthisreportandisavailabletoansweranyquestions. 2 P age PinnacleActuarialResources,Inc.
5 Pinnacledoesnotassumeanyliabilityforthereliancesofthirdpartiesontheconclusionsofthis report. Anythirdpartiesreceivingthereportshouldrecognizethatthefurnishingofthisreportisnota substitutefortheirownduediligenceandshouldplacenorelianceonthisreportorthedatacontained hereinthatwouldresultinthecreationofanydutyorliabilitybypinnacletothethirdparty. AnyreferencetoPinnacleinrelationtothisreportinanyaccountsorotherpublicdocumentsorany verbalreferenceissuedbythecityisnotauthorizedwithoutourpriorconsent. Data Duringthecourseofthisreview,Pinnaclehasreliedonthefollowingdataandinformationreceived fromthecityandtheirc: 1. DraftDInsurancelegislationdatedMay20, AutoInjuryInsuranceClaims:CountrywidePatternsinTreatment,CostandCompensation, 2014Edition PersonalInjuryProtection(PIP)andBodilyInjury(BI)InformationforMichigan, NewYork,Florida,NewJerseyandMassachusettsforclaimsthatwereclosedin CitizensResearchCouncilofMichigan,October2013report MedicalCostsofNoFault Insurance. 4. MichiganChamberofCommerce,April2011studytitled"TheHighCostsofMichigan'sNoFault AutoInsuranceCausesandImplicationsforReform." 5. MichiganAutomobileInsurancePlacementFacilityBaseRateseffectiveJanuary1, IndependentStatisticalServicesAutomobileExperiencePremiumData,calendaryear2013 TheIRCdataincluded5,095claims.Theclaimsbreakdownbystateisshownbelow. NumberofClaims State BI PIP GrandTotal Florida 1, ,805 Massachusetts Michigan NewJersey NewYork ,072 GrandTotal 2,212 2,883 5,095 FromthisIRCdatabase36BIclaimsand55PIPclaimsoccurredinDetroit.Duetothelimitednumberof PIPclaimsintheIRCdatabase,reformsavingsestimateswerecalculatedforallIRCPIPclaimsin MichiganaswellasseparatelyforclaimsthatoccurredintheCityofDetroitonlyasareasonability checkforsavingsestimates. 3 P age PinnacleActuarialResources,Inc.
6 ProjectBackground Bylaw,Michigandriversmustbuyfirstpartymedicalinsurance(alsoreferredtoasPersonalInjury ProtectionorPIP)andresidualliabilitycoverage(BodilyInjuryandPropertyDamage,BIPD).Drivers arenotlegallyrequiredtobuycollisionandcomprehensivecoverage,butthesecoveragesarerequired bylienholdersifadriverhasacarloan. StatisticaldatafiledwiththeMichiganDepartmentofInsuranceandFinancialServices(DIFS)through theindependentstatisticalservice(iss)bysomeofthelargestcarinsurancewritersinmichigan, includingallstate,autoclub,andstatefarm,showsthatin2013,theaverageannualpolicypremium forpip,bipd,andcollisionandcomprehensivecoverageindowntowndetroitwas$2, thiswas doubletheaverageannualpremiuminwesternoaklandcounty.itshouldbenotedthatthisaggregate dataisnotadjustedtoreflectthedifferenceinthespecificcoveragespurchasedbetweenthetwo areas.issdataalsoshowsthatabout2/3ofpolicyholdersindetroitpurchasefullcoverage,while almost100%ofpolicyholdersinthedetroitsuburbspurchasefullcoverage. TosupportinitiativesoftheMayor soffice,thecitywouldliketoenactlegislationauthorizingthecity tocontractwithinsurancecarrierstoofferdinsurancecoverage.thiscoveragewouldbeofferedata lowerratethancurrentlyavailableinthemarketplace.thiswouldbeaccomplishedbyintroducing reformstothemichiganinsurancelawsthatwouldbeapplicableonlytothecityownedinsurance company.theproposedreformshavebeendevelopedbythemayor sofficeandareasfollows: 1. ReformProposal#1:Thefirstreformproposalconsistsoftwoelements. a. Introducea$25,000/$250,000limit:Currently,PIPbenefitsareunlimited.Thischange tothelawwouldallowinsuredstopurchasepipbenefitswithaspecifiedlimitof $25,000,exceptincasesofnecessarycriticalcare,whichwouldbeadditionalcoverage withalimitof$250,000peroccurrence. b. Allowinsurerstonegotiatepreferredproviderarrangementsandpreauthorization:This wouldallowdinsurancetocreatealimitedprovidernetwork.exceptforemergency services,theinsurermayrequireaclaimanttoobtainproducts,treatment,services, accommodations,orrehabilitativeoroccupationaltherapyortrainingprovidedfor underthisactfromaproviderorsupplierthatispartofthelimitedprovidernetwork. Theclaimantmayalsoneedtoobtainpreauthorization. 2. ReformProposal#2 HighDeductibleOption:Thisoptionwouldincorporateahighdeductible optionintothecurrentunlimitedpipbenefitprogram. Theattachedexhibitsanddiscussionbelowshowtheexpectedimpactoninsurancelossesifthese reformsareimplemented. 4 P age PinnacleActuarialResources,Inc.
7 ReformProposal#1:PIPBenefitLimitsandPreferredProviderAgreements IntroducePIPBenefitLimits Currently,PIPbenefitsinMichiganareunlimited.Oneofthereformsbeingproposedisthe introductionofpipbenefitlimits.specifically,thelegislativechangesbeingproposedare: 1. $25,000limitperpersonforbenefitspayableformedicalexpenses,worklossandreplacement services. 2. Anadditionalamountnottoexceed$250,000intheaggregate,onlyforcriticalcareforthe personnamedinthequalifyingnofaultpolicy,theperson'sspouse,andarelativeofeither domiciledinthesamehousehold,whoareinjuredinasinglemotorvehicleaccidentduringthe policyterm.criticalcaremeanstreatmentrenderedatanacutecarehospitalortraumacenter immediatelyfollowingthemotorvehicleaccident,necessarytosavethepatient slifeortreat lifethreateningorpermanentlydisablinginjuries,untilthepatientisstabilized.apatientis stabilizedwhenthepatientcansafelybedischargedortransferredtoanotheracutecare hospitalortraumacenter,rehabilitationorotherfacility,regardlessofwhetherthepatientis, infact,dischargedortransferredatthattime.aqualifyinginsurershallhavetherightto contestthechargesofanacutecarefacilityunderthissectiontotheextenttheinsurercan presentcompetentevidenceshowingthatthefacility schargesrelatetopoststabilization services. Toestimatethesavingsforthisreform,Pinnacleappliedthe$25,000benefitlimittotheindividualPIP claimsprovidedintheircdatabase.priortotheapplicationofthelimit,themedicalnoncriticalcare paidclaimamountsweredecreasedbytheestimatedsavingsfromthepreferredprovideragreement reform(discussedbelow).aftertheapplicationofthe$25,000limit,iftherewerepaidlossespresent ontheclaimforemergencyroomdoctorsorambulancecare,theseamountswereaddedtothe lossesthatwouldbepaidunderthereformsubjecttothe$250,000limit. TheestimatedsavingstotheoverallPIPcostssolelyfromtheapplicationofthebenefitlimitsis62.1% fordetroit. PreferredProviderAgreement Thisproposedchangewouldallowaninsurertocreatealimitedprovidernetwork.Exceptfor emergencyservices,theinsurermayrequireaclaimanttoobtainproducts,treatment,services, accommodations,orrehabilitativeoroccupationaltherapyortrainingprovidedforunderthisactfrom aproviderorsupplierthatispartofthelimitedprovidernetwork.theclaimantmayalsoneedto obtainpreauthorizationfornonemergencyservices. 5 P age PinnacleActuarialResources,Inc.
8 ThelimitedprovidernetworkandpreauthorizationwouldaddresstwosignificantissuesrelatedtoPIP coverageindetroit.thefirstisthatthechargeformedicalprocedurespaidunderpipissignificantly higherthanthechargeformedicalprocedurespaidunderworker scompensationormedicare.the secondrelatestooveruseandpotentialabuseofpipcoverage. Formanycommonmedicalprocedures,Michiganmedicalproviderschargenofaultinsurerstwoto fivetimesmorethanrateschargedforthesameprocedurebymedicare. 1 Atableofmedical proceduresandassociatedreimbursementsundernofault,medicareandworker scompensationis showninattachment1. Inaddition,nofaultpremiumsinMichiganmayalsobeinflatedbyoveruseofbenefits,thefilingof fraudulentorexcessiveclaims,andlegalfeesgeneratedbyexcessivelitigation.typicalpatternsof fraudoroveruseinvolvehardtoverifyinjuriesandlargenumbersofvisitstoprovidersofalternative medicaltherapies. 2 TheproblemofoveruseisparticularlyacuteinDetroit,where 1. theaveragefrequencyofpipclaimsindetroitistwicethefrequencyinthesuburbs(12per 1,000exposuresvs.6per1,000exposures), 2. averageseverityofpipclaimsindetroitisroughlytwicetheaverageseverityinthesuburbs ($59,000vs$30,000),and ThecreationofaclosednetworkwithpreauthorizationwillprovidetheDInsurancecarrierwiththe abilitytonegotiaterateswithmedicalproviders,tolimitexcessiveorunnecessarytreatmentandavoid litigation.therefore,webelievethattheultimateratesnegotiatedwouldmoveinthedirectionofthe Worker scompensationschedule.ascanbeseeninattachment1,worker scompensationmedical providerreimbursementsare11%77%lowerthanreimbursementsunderpipbasedonthetypeof medicalprocedure. PinnaclealsoperformedasearchforstudiesthatestimatedthecostsavingsassociatedwithPreferred Providersystems.ThoughmanyofthestudiesaresomewhatdatedbecausePreferredProvideroptions wereintroducedroughly15 20yearsago,PinnacledidfindastudybyTheRobertWoodJohnson Foundation 3 thatprovidedsavingsestimatesfromintroducingappo.theestimatedsavingsfromthis studywere12 14%. 1 CitizensResearchCouncilofMichigan,October2013report"MedicalCostsofNoFaultAutomobileInsurance,"p.7. 2 MichiganChamberofCommerce,April2011studytitled"TheHighCostsofMichigan'sNoFaultAutoInsuranceCauses andimplicationsforreform,"p RobertWoodJohnsonFoundation. PreferredProviderOrganizations AreTheyBetteratKeepingHealthCostsDown? January1, P age PinnacleActuarialResources,Inc.
9 Tounderstandthepotentialsavingsbasedonimplementationofpreauthorization,thusdecreasing fraudandoverutilization,pinnaclereviewedthestatisticsrelatedtopipfraudinotherstates.inthe IRCdata,therearedatafieldsthatindicatewhetheraclaimwasreferredtoanotheragencyforfurther investigation.foraspecificclaim,thisfieldindicateswhetherornotaclaimwasreferredtothe insurancecompany sspecialinvestigativeunit(siu),lawenforcement,prosecutorsorthenational InsuranceCrimeBureau(NICB).Inaddition,Pinnaclereviewedtheseverityofclaimsthatwerereferred forfurtherinvestigationversusthosethatwerenotreferred. Attachment2showstheclaimreferralratesbyNoFaultstateandtheseverityofnonreferredvs. referredclaims.forpip,thereferralratesformichiganwere5.4%andfordetroitwere20%.theother statesrangedinreferralrateswere1.9%10.6%.theseverityfornonreferredclaimsformichigan wasabout62%lowerthantheseverityforreferredclaims.fordetroit,thenonreferredseveritywas 71%lowerthantheseverityforreferredclaims.Fortheotherstates,thedifferenceinseverities rangedfrom8.4%35%lowerfornonreferredclaims.asaresult,forpipwecanseethatthereis potentialforsavingsbasedontheseveritydifferencesofreferredvs.nonreferredclaims.assumingan estimated25%decreaseinseverity,forexample,translatesintoestimatedsavingsforpipof10.5%,as showninattachment3. Basedonthiscombinationofpotentialsavings,weareestimatinga20%losscostsavingsfrom implementingalimitedprovidernetworkandpreauthorization.thisestimatedsavingsappliedonlyto themedicalportionofthelossespaidandassumingnootherchangeswouldresultina13.9% estimateddecreaseinoverallpiplosscosts.seeattachment4formoredetails. ReformProposal#2:HighDeductibleOption ThisoptionwouldallowinsuredstopurchasePIPbenefitssubjecttoadeductible.Pinnacleestimated thesavingsfromseveraldeductibleoptions$1,000,$2,500and$5,000.forthisoption,theinsured wouldberesponsibleformedicalcostsuptheamountofthedeductible. Toestimatethesavingsfromtheseoptions,Pinnacleappliedthedeductibletoeachoftheindividual claimsintheircdata.ascanbeseeninattachment5,savingsforthecityofdetroitrangedfrom3% to13%baseduponthedeductibleselected. TotalEstimatedSavings ReformOption#1 AscanbeseeninAttachment6,thecombinedestimatedlosssavingsforthelimitedprovidernetwork andthepipbenefitlimitforthecityofdetroitisestimatedtobe64.5%ofpipclaimcosts.thereason thetotalsavingsdoesnotequaltheproductoftheindividualsavingsestimatesisduetothe overlappingimpact.becauseofthe$25,000pipbenefitlimit,theimpactofthelimitedprovider networkisdampenedsignificantly. 7 P age PinnacleActuarialResources,Inc.
10 ThetotalestimatedpremiumsavingsforthePIPreformsisshowninAttachment7A. Toestimatethesavings,Pinnaclebeganwiththe2013averagepremiumbycoverageinDetroit MetropolitanInner(Territory36)ascalculatedfromtheAutomobileExperienceDatafromISS.We thenappliedtheestimatedlosssavingspercentages(adjustedasdescribedbelow)basedonthe reformsdiscussed.theoverallestimatedpremiumsavingsforafullcoveragepolicywouldbe25.8%, whiletheestimatedsavingsforaliabilityonlypolicywouldbeabout45.9%. Thecostestimatesinthisreportaregenerallystatedintermsoftheimpactonclaimlosses.Theimpact onclaimlossescannotbeusedinterchangeablywithpremiumsavings.thisisbecauseaportionofthe insurancecompanies expensesisforgeneraloverhead(rent,utilities,etc.)andwouldnotdecrease proportionatelytothelosscosts.basedonthe2013bestsaggregatesandaveragespublication, PrivatePassengerAutomobileLiabilitygeneralandotheracquisitionexpensesrepresent14.2%ofthe industrywidewrittenpremium(this14.2%doesnotincludeagents commissions,premiumtaxesand otherpremiumrelatedexpenses).toestimatethepremiumsavingscorrespondingtothecostsavings showninthisreport,itisnecessarytoreducethelosssavingsbyafactorof.858.thusa64.5%cost savingsequatestoanapproximate55.3%premiumsavings. Thesavingscalculatedassumethatcurrentratesareadequate.TotheextentthatcurrentPIPratesare inadequate,itislikelythatthepremiumsavingscouldbelower.wewouldalsoemphasizethatthe abovepercentagesavingsareaveragesforpipcoverageonly.itispossiblethatactualsavingscould varybyareaofdetroit,andalsobytheageandotherratingcharacteristicsofthecovereddrivers(s), drivingrecords,typeandageofcar,levelandtypeofcoverageandotherfactors. Inaddition,thesesavingsestimatesassumenochangetothetortthresholdinMichiganandthusno associatedincreaseinliabilitycosts.totheextentthattheliabilitythresholdchangesasaresultofthe PIPbenefitlimitsandmoreliabilityclaimsarefiled,thiswouldleadtoanincreaseinliabilityclaim costs. TotalEstimatedSavings ReformOption#2 AscanbeseeninAttachment5,theestimatedlosssavingsforthehighdeductibleoptionfortheCity ofdetroitisestimatedtobe313%ofpipclaimcostsdependingonthelimitchosen.theestimated savingsgeneratedbyapplyingthebenefitlimitstoallclaimsinmichiganare518%ofpipclaimcosts. ThetotalestimatedpremiumsavingsforthePIPreformsisshowninAttachment8Aand8C.The overallestimatedpremiumsavingsforafullcoveragepolicyfora$1,000deductiblewouldbe1.2%, whiletheestimatedsavingsforaliabilityonlypolicywouldbeabout2.2%.forthe$5,000deductible, theestimatedfullcoveragesavingsare5.1%,andtheliabilityonlyestimatedsavingsare9.1%. 8 P age PinnacleActuarialResources,Inc.
11 MoreRecentData Asdiscussedabove,Pinnacle sanalysisfocuseson2013isspremiumdatathatsuggestsan average Detroitautoinsurancevehiclepremiumin2013was$2,250.Thatinformationexcludestheeffectsof citizensofdetroitwhodrivewithoutinsurance.thecityhasprovidedanecdotalevidencethatin2015, manycitizensofdetroit,includingthosewithgooddrivingrecords,paypremiumsmuchhigherthan $2,250. PinnaclehasobtainedrecentinformationfromtheMichiganAutomobileInsurancePlacementFacility (Facility).TheFacilityactsasaninsureroflastresortforindividualswhocannotsecurenofault coverageintheopenmarket.thefacilitysetsits baserate premiumsastheaverageofthetopfive insurancecarriersinthestate.baseratesrepresentthepremiumschargedpriortotheapplicationof anydiscountsorsurcharges.mostdriversseekingcoveragefromthefacilitywillpaypremiumshigher thanthebaseratesasaresultofunderwritingfactorssuchasage,drivingrecord,mileage,etc. TheFacility smostrecentannualbaserateaveragepremiumdatafordetroitisasfollows: Coverage BodilyInjuryLiability $468 PropertyDamageLiability 48 PropertyProtection 142 PersonalInjuryProtection 4,134 Collision($100Deductible) 1,126 Comprehensive($100Deductible) 310 Total $6,228 PremiumsPerYear Usingthisdata,andassuminga55.3%savingsonthePIPpremium(basedonReformOption1PIP limitoption),theownerwouldsaveapproximately$2,286bringingthepremiumdownfrom$6,228to $3,940 anallcoveragesavingsonthepolicyof37%. Dependingontheageandvalueofthevehicle,itmightbeeconomicallywiseforanownertoselecta largerdeductibleforcollisionandcomprehensivecoverageorelectnottoobtaincollisionand comprehensivecoverage.ifcollisionandcomprehensivecoverageiseliminated,theannualpremium underthecurrentnofaultlawwouldbe$4,792.a55.3%savingsonpipwoulddecreasethepriceof thepolicydownto$2,504,oradecreaseof48%.thedetailsareshowninattachment7b. TheestimatedsavingsforReformOption2basedontheMAIPFbaseratesareshownin8Band8D.For the$1,000deductibleoption,thefullcoveragesavingsare1.8%andtheliabilityonlysavingsare2.3%. 9 P age PinnacleActuarialResources,Inc.
12 Usingthe$5,000deductibleoption,thefullcoveragesavingsare7.3%andtheliabilityonlysavingsare 9.5%. TheCityhasalsoprovidedtoPinnaclethefollowing2015hypotheticalrateexampleasanexampleof thetypesofsavingsthatcanbeachieved.thehypotheticalcasestudycomesfromamajorauto insurerthatoffersinsurancepremiumquotationsonline.arepresentativeofthecityenteredthe followingdetails: AnaddressinnortheastDetroitinthe48225zipcode 2005ChevyMalibu 10,000milesdriverperyear Vehicleusedtocommutetoworkandforpleasure Basiccoverageincludingthemandatorynofaultinsurancecoveragestogetherwith comprehensive(theft)andcollisioncoveragewith$1,000deductibles. Thefollowingquotationwasprovidedforaoneyearpolicy: Coverage BodilyInjuryLiability $260 PropertyDamageLiability 24 PropertyProtection 60 PersonalInjuryProtection 3,332 Collision 1,042 Comprehensive 234 Total $4,952 PremiumPerYear Usingthisexample,andassuminga55.3%costsavingsonthePIPpremium,theownerwouldsave approximately$1,844reducingthepremiumfrom$4,952to$3,108. Iftheownerinthisexampleelectednottoobtaincollisionandcomprehensivecoverage,theannual premiumundercurrentnofaultlawwouldbe$3,676.a55.3%savingsonpipwouldproduceasavings of$1,844,decreasingthepriceofthepolicyto$1,832.detailsareshowninattachment7c. Conclusion Asshownabove,implementingreformthatlimitsPIPbenefitswillprovidesignificantpremiumsavings tothecitizensofdetroit.themostsignificantchangeswouldbeachievedwiththeimplementationof 10 P age PinnacleActuarialResources,Inc.
13 ReformOption#1.Whiletheactualsavingswouldvarydependingonthespecificpolicycircumstances, theestimatedaveragesavingsfromthisoptionwouldadecreaseinpremiumsof25.8%forafull coveragepolicy,and45.9%foraliabilityonlypolicy. 11 P age PinnacleActuarialResources,Inc.
14 IndexofAttachments 1. LimitedProviderNetworkSavingsEstimate 2. PIPFraudReferralRates 3. PotentialSavingsfromFraudMitigation 4. PreferredProviderCostSavingsEstimate 5. HighDeductibleOptionSavingsEstimate 6. PIPLimitandLimitedProviderNetworkSavingsEstimate 7. PremiumSavingsCalculation PIPLimitandLimitedProviderNetworkOption a. SavingsEstimatesBasedon2013ISSAveragePremiums b. SavingsEstimatesBasedon2015MAIPFBaseRates c. SavingsEstimatesBasedonHypotheticalQuoteExample 8. PremiumSavingsCalculation HighDeductibleOption a. SavingsEstimatesBasedon2013ISSAveragePremiums,$1,000DeductibleOption b. SavingsEstimatesBasedon2015MAIPFBaseRates,$1,000DeductibleOption c. SavingsEstimatesBasedon2013ISSAveragePremiums,$5,000DeductibleOption d. SavingsEstimatesBasedon2015MAIPFBaseRates,$5,000DeductibleOption 12 P age PinnacleActuarialResources,Inc.
15 Attachment1 CityofDetroit InsuranceReformPricing MedicalProcedureReimbursementAmounts Procedure Code NoFault Reimbursement Detroit Medicare Reimbursement PotentialSavings Medicare Reimbursement Description WorkComp Therapeuticexercisesforstrength(each15minutes);usuallychargedby PhysicalTherapist % 47.6% Chiropracticmanipulativetreatment,spinal,34regions % 33.0% Manualtherapy(each15minutes)physicaltherapy % 37.5% Electricalstimulationphysicaltherapy % 65.6% Massage(each15minutes)physicaltherapy % 37.1% Emergencydepartmentvisit;severemedicalcomplexity % 61.6% Emergencydepartmentvisit;moderatemedicalcomplexity % 69.4% Chiropracticmanipulativetreatment,spinal,12regions % 38.1% Officevisit,establishedpatient;typically15minutes % 14.5% Mechanicaltractionphysicaltherapy % 63.5% Ultrasound(each15minutes)physicaltherapy % 74.8% Officevisit,establishedpatient;typically25minutes % 11.5% Therapeuticactivities,improvefunctionalperformance(each15minutes); generallychargedbyoccupationaltherapists % 19.8% Neuromuscularreeducation(each15minutes)physicaltherapy % 45.8% Xray,spine,cervical;2or3views % 66.2% CTScanNeck 1, % 77.0% MRINeck 3, % 76.4% MRILowBack 3, % 76.6% CTScanPelvis 1, % 73.9% XRaySpine % 66.1% SurgeryShoulder 2, % 66.5% Work Comp Source:MitchellDecisionPoint;CRCCalculations
16 Attachment2 CityofDetroit InsuranceReformPricing PreferredProviderOrganization PersonalInjuryProtection ClaimReferralRate State Total SIU Other Company NICB State Fraud Local Police Prosecutor Other Non Referred Severity Referred Severity Florida 3.8% 3.2% 0.0% 0.4% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.3% 7,330 8,001 Massachusetts 1.9% 1.9% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 3,608 5,547 Michigan 5.4% 4.1% 0.9% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.4% 14,121 36,844 NewJersey 10.6% 10.4% 0.2% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 16,000 20,655 NewYork 7.0% 6.1% 0.9% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 8,743 12,827 Detroit 20.0% 18.2% 1.8% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 17,880 61,477 Difference 8.4% 35.0% 61.7% 22.5% 31.8% 70.9%
17 Attachment3 CityofDetroit InsuranceReformPricing FraudInvestigation PersonalInjury Protection Stateof Michigan Cityof Detroit (1) EstimatedIncreaseinClaimReferralRate 0.0% 0.0% (2) EstimatedDecreaseinSeverityforReferredClaims 25.0% 25.0% (3) IRCTotalPaidLossesforReferredClaims 1,105, ,247 (4) IRCTotalPaidLosses 7,969,097 1,613,067 (5) SavingsasaPercentageofTotalLosses 3.5% 10.5% Notes (1) EstimateBasedonIRCFraudAnalysisExhibit (2) EstimateBasedonIRCFraudAnalysisExhibit (3) IRC:AutoInjuryInsuranceClaims:CountrywidePatternsinTreatment,Costs,andCompensation,2014Edition (4) IRC:AutoInjuryInsuranceClaims:CountrywidePatternsinTreatment,Costs,andCompensation,2014Edition (5) [[(2)*(3)]/(4)]+(1)
18 Attachment4 CityofDetroit InsuranceReformPricing PreferredProvider Stateof Michigan Cityof Detroit (1) PPOSavingsEstimate 20.0% (2) TotalPIPMedicalPaid 4,559,642 1,120,411 (3) IRCTotalPaidLosses 7,969,097 1,613,067 (4) PIPSavingsasaPercentageofTotalLosses 11.4% 13.9% Notes (1) EstimatedImpactofPreferredProviderandPreauthorization (2) IRC:AutoInjuryInsuranceClaims:CountrywidePatternsinTreatment,Costs,andCompensation,2014Edition (3) IRC:AutoInjuryInsuranceClaims:CountrywidePatternsinTreatment,Costs,andCompensation,2014Edition (4) [(1)*(2)]/(3)
19 Attachment5 CityofDetroit InsuranceReformPricing HighDeductibleOption DeductibleImpact Deductible Stateof Michigan Cityof Detroit 1, % 3.1% 2, % 7.1% 5, % 12.8%
20 Attachment6 CityofDetroit InsuranceReformPricing Impactof25,000PIPLimit/$250,000EmergencyCareLimitandLimitedProviderNetwork StateofMichigan (1) OriginalPaidLosses 7,969,097 (2) RevisedPaidLosses 3,646,820 (3) SavingsEstimate 54.2% CityofDetroit (4) OriginalPaidLosses 1,613,067 (5) RevisedPaidLosses 572,548 (6) SavingsEstimate 64.5% (1) IRC:AutoInjuryInsurancePIPClaimsData (2) EstimatedRevisedLossesAssuming$25,000PIPLimit/$250,000LimitforEmergencyCareandLimitedProviderNetwork (3) (2)/(1)1 (4) IRC:AutoInjuryInsurancePIPClaimsData (5) EstimatedRevisedLossesAssuming$25,000PIPLimit/$250,000LimitforEmergencyCareandLimitedProviderNetwork (6) (5)/(4)1
21 Attachment7A CityofDetroit InsuranceReformPricing EstimatedSavings$25,000/$250,000LimitOptionUsing2013ISSAveragePremiums (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) 2013ISSAverage TotalLoss Estimated Premium EstimatedNew Coverage Premium Savings Savings Premium BI $ % 0.0% PD $ % 0.0% PIP $1, % 55.3% PPI $ % 0.0% Collision $ % 0.0% Comprehensive $ % 0.0% Estimated Overall Percentage Savings FullCoverage $2, $1, % LiabilityOnly $1, $ % (1) IndependentStatisticalService,Inc,AutomobileExperience,AveragePremiumsforDetroitMetropolitanInner(Territory36) (2) Attachment5 (3) (3)*0.858(PortionofPremiumsthatareVariable) (4) (1)*[1+(3)] (5) [(4)Total/(1)Total]1
22 Attachment7B CityofDetroit InsuranceReformPricing EstimatedSavings$25,000/$250,000LimitOptionUsing2015MAIPFBaseRates (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) 2015MAIPFBase TotalLoss Estimated Premium EstimatedNew Coverage Rates Savings Savings Premium BI $ % 0.0% PD $ % 0.0% PIP $4, % 55.3% PPI $ % 0.0% Collision $1, % 0.0% Comprehensive $ % 0.0% Estimated Overall Percentage Savings FullCoverage $6, $3, % LiabilityOnly $4, $2, % (1) MichiganAutoInsurancePlacementFacilityBaseRates,010115,Territory3637 (2) Attachment5 (3) (3)*0.858(PortionofPremiumsthatareVariable) (4) (1)*[1+(3)] (5) [(4)Total/(1)Total]1
23 Attachment7C CityofDetroit InsuranceReformPricing EstimatedSavings$25,000/$250,000LimitOptionUsingHypotheticalRateQuote (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) HypotheticalQuote TotalLoss Estimated Premium EstimatedNew Coverage AnnualPremium Savings Savings Premium BI $ % 0.0% $ PD $ % 0.0% $24.00 PIP $3, % 55.3% $1, PPI $ % 0.0% $60.00 Collision $1, % 0.0% $1, Comprehensive $ % 0.0% $ Estimated Overall Percentage Savings FullCoverage $4, $3, % LiabilityOnly $3, $1, % $1, (1) MichiganAutoInsurancePlacementFacilityBaseRates,010115,Territory3637 (2) Attachment5 (3) (3)*0.858(PortionofPremiumsthatareVariable) (4) (1)*[1+(3)] (5) [(4)Total/(1)Total]1
24 Attachment8A CityofDetroit InsuranceReformPricing EstimatedSavingsHighDeductibleOptionUsing2013ISSAveragePremiums $1,000DeductibleOption (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) 2013ISSAverage TotalLoss Estimated Premium EstimatedNew Coverage Premium Savings Savings Premium BI $ % 0.0% $ PD $ % 0.0% $19.24 PIP $1, % 2.7% $1, PPI $ % 0.0% $44.20 Collision $ % 0.0% $ Comprehensive $ % 0.0% $ Estimated Overall Percentage Savings FullCoverage $2, $2, % LiabilityOnly $1, $1, % (1) IndependentStatisticalService,Inc,AutomobileExperience,AveragePremiumsforDetroitMetropolitanInner(Territory36) (2) Attachment4($1,000DeductibleOptionSavings) (3) (3)*0.858(PortionofPremiumsthatareVariable) (4) (1)*[1+(3)] (5) [(4)Total/(1)Total]1
25 Attachment8B CityofDetroit InsuranceReformPricing EstimatedSavingsHighDeductibleOptionUsing2015MAIPFBaseRates $1,000DeductibleOption (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) 2015MAIPFBase TotalLoss Estimated Premium EstimatedNew Coverage Rates Savings Savings Premium BI $ % 0.0% $ PD $ % 0.0% $48.00 PIP $4, % 2.7% $4, PPI $ % 0.0% $ Collision $1, % 0.0% $1, Comprehensive $ % 0.0% $ Estimated Overall Percentage Savings FullCoverage $6, $6, % LiabilityOnly $4, $4, % (1) IndependentStatisticalService,Inc,AutomobileExperience,AveragePremiumsforDetroitMetropolitanInner(Territory36) (2) Attachment4($1,000DeductibleOptionSavings) (3) (3)*0.858(PortionofPremiumsthatareVariable) (4) (1)*[1+(3)] (5) [(4)Total/(1)Total]1
D Insurance: City of Detroit Insurance Company Feasibility Study
D Insurance: City of Detroit Insurance Company Feasibility Study June 8, 2015 Roosevelt C. Mosley, Jr, FCAS, MAAA rmosley@pinnacleactuaries.com 309.807.2330 3109 Cornelius Drive Bloomington, IL 61704 309.807.2300
More informationPresentation on Personal Injury Protection (PIP) Insurance
Presentation on Personal Injury Protection (PIP) Insurance Senate Banking & Insurance Committee April 2, 2013 Sandra Starnes Director, Property & Casualty Product Review Part I: Implementation of HB 119
More informationRentersPLUS Move In Special
$500.00 $658.00 $125.00 Security Deposit Insurance is for $500.00 of coverage and is a non refundable premium. Move In Savings of $375.00 by Choosing Security Deposit Insurance. $288.00 $750.00 $908.00
More informationCHOICES: Insurance Rate Comparison Search Systems. Auto Insurance. Instructions/User Guide
CHOICES: Insurance Rate Comparison Search Systems Auto Insurance Instructions/User Guide April 2014 Table of Contents Step 1 Select an Example... 3 Step 2 Select by County or Company... 4 By County...
More informationColorado Auto Premiums Continue to Drop Since No-Fault Sunset
Colorado Market Outlook 2007 represents the best Colorado auto insurance market for consumers in more than a decade: Premiums have plummeted more than 32% from to 2007 for the majority of drivers with
More informationDriving Michigan: An Agenda To Reform Michigan s No-Fault system
Insurance Institute of Michigan Driving Michigan: An Agenda To Reform Michigan s No-Fault system No one has to lose anything if consumers are given more insurance coverage options. It s not a partisan
More informationPersonal Automobile. November 5, 2013. Sandra Starnes, Director
Personal Automobile Insurance Coverage Senate Banking & Insurance Committee November 5, 2013 Sandra Starnes, Director Property & Casualty Product Review Product PART ONE Personal Automobile Insurance Coverage
More informationSafeco Insurance Company of America Motorcycle Program Rate Manual State of Massachusetts
Safeco Insurance Company of America Motorcycle Program Rate Manual State of Massachusetts RATING ALGORITHM Part 1 Part 4 Part 5 Part 6 Part 5 Part 3 Part 12 Part 2 Part 8 Part 9 Part 7 Part 11 Part 10
More informationCabinet Presentation Personal Injury Protection. August 2011
Cabinet Presentation Personal Injury Protection Tallahassee, Florida August 2011 1 Types of Auto Insurance Systems No Fault 10 States Economic damages from injuries sustained in an auto accident are covered
More informationa consumers guide to No-Fault Automobile Insurance in Michigan
a consumers guide to No-Fault Automobile Insurance in Michigan No-Fault Automobile Insurance in Michigan The Michigan no-fault system was adopted in 1973 to increase the level of benefits paid to injured
More informationEconomic Education for Consumers Chapter 14 Study Guide Automobile and Home Insurance: Sharing the Risk
Economic Education for Consumers Chapter 14 Study Guide Automobile and Home Insurance: Sharing the Risk Section 14-1 Insurance Basics Define Risk Management. Define Shared Risk. How do insurance companies
More informationPrepared By: Chris Longino, Field Information Analyst, Central Florida Major Medical Fraud Task Force. Background. Personal Injury Protection (PIP)
Date: Regarding: Florida Personal Injury Protection (PIP) (External Dissemination) Prepared By: Chris Longino, Field Information Analyst, Central Florida Major Medical Fraud Task Force Background Personal
More informationNo Fault/PIP/First Party Medical States
Delaware Listed on Policy Primary 15/30 ; Added benefits, up to $100,000 based on coverage purchased Florida -Fault & Owned and insured Medical Payments under the. If after 90 days of "residency" is established,
More informationFIS-PUB 0077 (6/13) Number of copies printed: 10,000 / Legal authorization to print: PA 145 of 1979 / Printed on recycled paper
DIFS is an equal opportunity employer/program. Auxiliary aids, services and other reasonable accommodations are available upon request to individuals with disabilities. FIS-PUB 0077 (6/13) Number of copies
More informationCHAPTER 2 THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN NO-FAULT INSURANCE AND DRIVER BEHAVIOR
-5- CHAPTER 2 THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN NO-FAULT INSURANCE AND DRIVER BEHAVIOR Under a traditional tort system, at-fault drivers are liable for the economic and noneconomic damages they inflict on third
More informationMarch 20, 2014 734-953-2779. MCCA sets 2014 2015 Insurance Company Assessment
MICHIGAN CATASTROPHIC CLAIMS ASSOCIATION 17584 LAUREL PARK DRIVE NORTH, LIVONIA, MI 48152 (734) 953-2779 FAX: (734) 953-9511 WEBSITE: www.michigancatastrophic.com FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE Contact: Gloria
More informationRegarding: 2012 Questionable Claim Referral Analysis for Palm Beach, Broward, and Miami-Dade Counties
Date: Regarding: 212 Questionable Claim Referral Analysis for Palm Beach, Broward, and Miami-Dade Counties Prepared By: Kathy Novak, Senior Field Information Analyst (Public Dissemination) 212 Questionable
More informationANALYSIS AS REPORTED FROM COMMITTEE. Senate Bill 288 (Substitute S-3 as reported) Sponsor: Senator Virgil Smith Committee: Insurance
LIMITED-BENEFITS NO-FAULT POLICY S.B. 288 (S-3): ANALYSIS AS REPORTED FROM COMMITTEE Senate Bill 288 (Substitute S-3 as reported) Sponsor: Senator Virgil Smith Committee: Insurance Date Completed: 7-20-15
More informationSubmitted by Lorilee A Medders, PhD November 4, 2011
Personal Injury Protection (PIP) in the State of Florida Evaluation of Data Collected by the Florida Office of Insurance Regulation (OIR) In Response to April 2011 PIP Data Call Submitted by Lorilee A
More informationNEW JERSEY AUTO INSURANCE BUYER S GUIDE. Chris Christie Governor. Kim Guadagno Lt. Governor. Commissioner
NEW JERSEY AUTO INSURANCE BUYER S GUIDE Chris Christie Governor Kim Guadagno Lt. Governor Commissioner WHERE DO I START?... 1 UNDERSTANDING YOUR POLICY... 2-6 Types of Coverages Standard and Basic Policies
More informationNEW JERSEY AUTO INSURANCE BUYER S GUIDE. Jon S. Corzine Governor. Steven M. Goldman Commissioner
NEW JERSEY AUTO INSURANCE BUYER S GUIDE Jon S. Corzine Governor Steven M. Goldman Commissioner WHERE DO I START?... 1 UNDERSTANDING YOUR POLICY... 2-6 Types of Coverages Standard and Basic Policies What
More informationOffice of Insurance Regulation
Talking Points Update PIP/No-Fault House Insurance Committee October 18, 2005 Mr. Chairman, members, thank you for the opportunity to provide you with some comments today. Mr. Chairman your staff did an
More informationHow To Get Insurance For A Car
Personal and Business Auto Table of Contents p. 1 of 5 Unit 1 - Introducing Auto Insurance pp. 7-41 Problems associated with auto accidents and insurance The large number of auto incidents High Cost of
More informationNew Jersey Pre Signature Series to Signature Series Changes
Pre Signature Series Signature Series Key Differences AAA Loyal Member AAA Membership This discount is calculated based on the membership tenure of the policyholder provided they are an active member of
More informationWHERE TO GET MORE INFORMATION AND HELP
WHERE TO GET MORE INFORMATION AND HELP This Buyer's Guide is intended to provide general information to help you make coverage choices. It is not a substitute for the policy language, which governs. Additional
More informationCauses of the Invisible Red Line. Vernal Newson Detroit Police Department
Causes of the Invisible Red Line Vernal Newson Detroit Police Department An applied research project submitted to the department of Interdisciplinary Technology as part of the School of Police Staff and
More informationHow To Determine A Class Of Auto Insurance In Massachusetts
Mass Auto Category Placement Rule Placement Variables ƒ Prior Insurance ƒ Years with Massachusetts Homeland Insurance Company or the Prior Carrier ƒ Quote Date ƒ Lapse in Insurance Coverage in the last
More informationCOMMERCIAL PPA EDITION
NEW JERSEY AUTO INSURANCE BUYER S GUIDE COMMERCIAL PPA EDITION For Individually Owned Private Passenger Automobiles Written on Commercial Insurance Policies WHAT S INSIDE WHERE DO I START?...PAGE 2 UNDERSTANDING
More informationDate: 09/22/2010 Regarding: Questionable Medical Claims Report 2008, 2009, and 2010 (1 st Half) Prepared By: Joel McCloskey, Senior Strategic Analyst
Date: 09/22/2010 Regarding: Questionable Medical Claims Report 2008, 2009, and 2010 (1 st Half) Prepared By: Joel McCloskey, Senior Strategic Analyst This ForeCAST (SM) Report analyzes questionable medical
More informationMarch 22, 2016 734-953-2779. MCCA sets 2016 2017 Insurance Company Assessment
MICHIGAN CATASTROPHIC CLAIMS ASSOCIATION 17584 LAUREL PARK DRIVE NORTH, LIVONIA, MI 48152 (734) 953-2779 FAX: (734) 953-9511 WEBSITE: www.michigancatastrophic.com FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE Contact: Gloria
More informationNEW JERSEY AUTO INSURANCE BUYER S GUIDE *C00179480010000001* PL-50074 (03-12) Page 1 of 9 000001/00000 S1347I03 7668 07/23/12
NEW JERSEY AUTO INSURANCE BUYER S GUIDE *C00179480010000001* 000001/00000 S1347I03 7668 07/23/12 PL-50074 (03-12) Page 1 of 9 WHAT S INSIDE WHERE DO I START?... UNDERSTANDING YOUR POLICY... Types of Coverage
More informationNEW JERSEY AUTO SUPPLEMENT
AGENCY AGENCY CUSTOMER ID: NEW JERSEY AUTO SUPPLEMENT NAMED INSURED(S) POLICY NUMBER EFFECTIVE DATE CARRIER NAIC CODE NEW JERSEY AUTO INSURANCE BUYER'S GUIDE New Jersey Department of Banking and Insurance
More informationNEW JERSEY AUTO INSURANCE, BUYER S GUIDE
NEW JERSEY AUTO INSURANCE, BUYER S GUIDE BG-NJ (1/14) WHAT'S INSIDE WHEREDOISTART?...1 UNDERSTANDING YOUR POLICY...2 Types of Coverages Standard and Basic Policies What are Limits and Deductibles? UNDERSTANDING
More informationNew Jersey AUTO INSURANCE
New Jersey AUTO INSURANCE Buyer s Guide Chris Christie Governor Kim Guadagno Lt. Governor Ken Kobylowski Commissioner NJM Insurance Group offers personal auto insurance in the voluntary market through
More informationNEW JERSEY AUTO INSURANCE
NEW JERSEY AUTO INSURANCE BUYER S GUIDE Chris Christie Governor Kim Guadagno Lt. Governor Richard J. Badolato Acting Commissioner NJM Insurance Group offers personal auto insurance in the voluntary market
More informationMichigan Catastrophic Claims Association (MCCA) Update as of: April 14, 2015
RICK SNYDER GOVERNOR STATE OF MICHIGAN DEPARTMENT OF INSURANCE AND FINANCIAL SERVICES LANSING ANNETTE E. FLOOD DIRECTOR Michigan Catastrophic Claims Association (MCCA) Update as of: April 14, 2015 What
More information1. What types of damages could you cause while you are driving?
Bellwork 1-9-15 Never lend your car to anyone to whom you have given birth. Erma Bombeck, Humor Writer 1. What types of damages could you cause while you are driving? 2. Do you know how much auto body
More informationMedical Costs of No-Fault Automobile Insurance
Medical Costs of No-Fault Automobile Insurance Jeffrey Guilfoyle, President Nicole Bradshaw, Research Associate Citizens Research Council of Michigan www.crcmich.org Independent Research CRC is a privately
More informationFlorida No-Fault Law Reform. CAS Antitrust Notice. Background - Example. 1 August 10, 2012 [Enter presentation title in footer] Copyright 2007
Presented by Iva Yuan FCAS, MAAA Casualty Loss Reserve Seminar Denver, CO September 6-7, 2012 CAS Antitrust Notice The Casualty Actuarial Society is committed to adhering strictly to the letter and spirit
More informationFlorida No-Fault Auto Insurance: A Historical Primer
Florida No-Fault Auto Insurance: A Historical Primer Auto Insurance Fraud Strike Force Board Meeting Tallahassee, FL January 24, 2013 Lynne McChristian, Florida Representative Insurance Information Institute
More informationNEW JERSEY AUTO INSURANCE BUYER S GUIDE
NEW JERSEY AUTO INSURANCE BUYER S GUIDE AD9460ARR-0704 American Bankers Insurance Company of Florida American Bankers Insurance Company of Florida 11222 Quail Roost Drive, Miami, FL 33157-6596 NEW JERSEY
More informationKeeping your money in your pocket, where it belongs.
Keeping your money in your pocket, where it belongs. Captain David Lindsay 610 East Burgess Rd, Pensacola, Fl 32506 Phone: 850-453-7802 David.Lindsay@MyFloridaCFO.com Our Mission and Vision The Division
More information2002 PROPERTY AND CASUALTY TARGET MARKET CONDUCT EXAMINATION ATLANTA CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY (ATLANTA CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANIES)
2002 PROPERTY AND CASUALTY TARGET MARKET CONDUCT EXAMINATION OF ATLANTA CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY (ATLANTA CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANIES) BY THE FLORIDA OFFICE OF INSURANCE REGULATION DATE FILED: 04/17/03
More informationMount Vernon Fire Insurance Company. Antique Auto Program
I. AGE There is not a vehicle age requirement for an offer of coverage under this filing. II. POLICY TERM Policy term is for one (1) year. III. LIABILITY COVERAGES A. Compulsory Bodily Injury/Property
More informationPrivate Passenger Automobile. Analysis of No-Fault Legislative Reforms. Michigan. On Behalf of the Insurance Institute of Michigan
Private Passenger Automobile Analysis of No-Fault Legislative Reforms Michigan On Behalf of the Insurance Institute of Michigan by Michael J. Miller, FCAS, MAAA EPIC Consulting, LLC June 2007 Private Passenger
More informationAntitrust Notice. Overview. Massachusetts Personal Auto Insurance. Why make change? Challenges of change. Unique features of the Plan.
Antitrust Notice The Casualty Actuarial Society is committed to adhering strictly to the letter and spirit of the antitrust laws. Seminars conducted under the auspices of the CAS are designed solely to
More informationMichigan No Fault Law Essential Knowledge for Hospital and Medical Office Personnel
Michigan No Fault Law Essential Knowledge for Hospital and Medical Office Personnel Why Learn About No-Fault? A Presentation for Third Party Payer Day Mt. Pleasant, Michigan November 21, 2014 Robert E.
More informationRATING INFORMATION NEW JERSEY
PERSONAL AUTO PP 03 75 07 09 RATING INFORMATION NEW JERSEY Your auto has been classified under a six digit numerical code (for example, 8110) as indicated on the policy Declarations Page. The information
More informationOntario Application for Automobile Insurance
Ontario Application for Automobile Insurance Driver's Form (O.A.F. 2) Notice to Applicant This is your Application for Automobile Insurance. Check it carefully and notify your Broker/Agent of any errors
More informationCORPORATE ID: 1760-818 19-527 WILLIAM PENN HOUSE 515 E CAPITOL ST SE WASHINGTON DC 20003
CORPORATE ID: 001213544 1760-818 19-527 WILLIAM PENN HOUSE 515 E CAPITOL ST SE WASHINGTON DC 20003 A N N U A L R E N E W A L C E R T I F I C A T E POLICY NUMBER 1760-818 - ARC FIRST NAMED INSURED PRODUCER
More informationWHAT HAPPENS AFTER A FLORIDA CAR ACCIDENT?
WHAT HAPPENS AFTER A FLORIDA CAR ACCIDENT? This free EBook provides answers to car accident victims most frequently asked questions. This EBook does not provide actual legal advice, as every accident and
More informationABCD F I N A N C I A L
Surcharge Disclosure Statement ABCD F I N A N C I A L COUNTRY Preferred Insurance CompanyA P.O. Box 64035 St. Paul, MN 55164-0035 Your policy is rated using past experience (accidents and convictions)
More informationST. PAUL PROTECTIVE INSURANCE COMPANY Hartford, CT NEW JERSEY AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE STANDARD POLICY COVERAGE SELECTION FORM
ST. PAUL PROTECTIVE INSURANCE COMPANY Hartford, CT NEW JERSEY AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE STANDARD POLICY COVERAGE SELECTION FORM Name: Policy #: This Coverage Selection Form is for a STANDARD POLICY. See Buyer
More informationRRA Insurance Premium Pay Me Back Instructions
RRA Insurance Premium Pay Me Back Instructions Page 1 of 6 Pay Me Back Claims Fill out the Pay Me Back claim form entirely. 1. Name must match your former employer s records (no middle initial). 2. Fill
More informationAn Analysis of. Profitability and Pricing. In the. Michigan Auto Insurance Market
An Analysis of Profitability and Pricing In the Michigan Auto Insurance Market Jay Angoff Mehri & Skalet, PLLC 1250 Connecticut Avenue N.W. Washington, DC 20036 July 2014 Table of Contents Executive Summary...
More informationAn Analysis of. Profitability and Pricing. In the. Michigan Auto Insurance Market
An Analysis of Profitability and Pricing In the Michigan Auto Insurance Market Jay Angoff Mehri & Skalet, PLLC 1250 Connecticut Avenue N.W. Washington, DC 20036 July 2014 Table of Contents Executive Summary...
More informationInsurance Companies Website Glossary of Common Terms Shopping for Automobile Insurance Worksheet III
1 2 Table of Contents Page 4 Page 6 Page 8 Page 10 Page 12 Page 14 Page 15 Page 16 Page 17 Page 18 Page 19 Page 21 Page 24 Page 25 Page 26 Automobile Insurance Eligibility Mandatory No-Fault Automobile
More informationCAR INSURANCE: The Consumer s Guide
CAR INSURANCE: The Consumer s Guide Table of Contents Introduction / 03 Why do I need Car Insurance? / 04 Do all states require you to purchase liability insurance? / 05 What are the different types of
More informationABCD F I N A N C I A L
Surcharge Disclosure Statement ABCD F I N A N C I A L COUNTRY Casualty Insurance CompanyA P.O. Box 64035 St. Paul, MN 55164-0035 Your policy is rated using past experience (accidents and convictions) as
More informationSpecial Investigations Unit (SIU) Reference Manual
Citizens Property Insurance Corp. This page intentionally left blank. 12/30/2013 Citizens Property Insurance Corp Page 2 Table of Contents In this reference manual This reference manual contains the following
More information2:08-cv-12533-DPH-PJK Doc # 67 Filed 03/26/13 Pg 1 of 7 Pg ID 2147 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF MICHIGAN SOUTHERN DIVISION
2:08-cv-12533-DPH-PJK Doc # 67 Filed 03/26/13 Pg 1 of 7 Pg ID 2147 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF MICHIGAN SOUTHERN DIVISION OLD REPUBLIC INSURANCE COMPANY, v. Plaintiff, MICHIGAN CATASTROPHIC
More informationMichigan Catastrophic Claims Association (MCCA) Updated April 15, 2010
JENNIFER M. GRANHOLM GOVERNOR STATE OF MICHIGAN OFFICE OF FINANCIAL AND INSURANCE REGULATION DEPARTMENT OF ENERGY, LABOR & ECONOMIC GROWTH STANLEY SKIP PRUSS, DIRECTOR KEN ROSS COMMISSIONER Michigan Catastrophic
More informationTop 10 Market Conduct. Property & Casualty - 2014
Top 10 Market Conduct Property & Casualty - 2014 Agenda A look at the Top 10 Additional compliance concerns Some fine data Trends & best practices Top 10-2014 Failure to acknowledge, pay, investigate or
More informationWorkshop of the Americas for Decisions on Traffic Safety and Education. Plenary Session IX: Financing Activities, Plans, and Programs
Workshop of the Americas for Decisions on Traffic Safety and Education Plenary Session IX: Financing Activities, Plans, and Programs Paying the Cost: Legal Responsibility, Participation of the Private
More informationASSEMBLY BANKING AND INSURANCE COMMITTEE STATEMENT TO SENATE COMMITTEE SUBSTITUTE FOR. SENATE, No. 63 STATE OF NEW JERSEY DATED: MAY 5, 2003
ASSEMBLY BANKING AND INSURANCE COMMITTEE STATEMENT TO SENATE COMMITTEE SUBSTITUTE FOR SENATE, No. 63 STATE OF NEW JERSEY DATED: MAY 5, 2003 The Assembly Banking and Insurance Committee reports favorably
More information21st Century Pinnacle Insurance Company STANDARD POLICY COVERAGE SELECTION FORM
21st Century Pinnacle Insurance Company STANDARD POLICY COVERAGE SELECTION FORM Name: Quote/Policy number: This Coverage Selection Form is for a STANDARD POLICY, see Buyer's Guide, page 3. A BASIC POLICY
More informationdomicile, including but not limited to Personal Injury Protection (PIP) and Personal Property insurance (PPI), must be carried.
Independent Contractor Insurance Requirements Sample provided by Paul Hanson Partners Specialty Insurance Solutions This document should be reviewed with your broker and attorney and modifications for
More informationPUBLIC AUTO INSURANCE APPLICATION- PENNSYLVANIA
A. GENERAL STRATFORD INSURANCE COMPANY WESTERN WORLD INSURANCE COMPANY PUBLIC AUTO INSURANCE APPLICATION- PENNSYLVANIA Applicant's Name: Phone #: Contact Person: Address: Garaging Location(s) if different:
More informationYour Guide to Automobile Insurance
Your Guide to Automobile Insurance For Michigan Consumers Department of Insurance and Financial Services (DIFS) Toll-Free Consumer Assistance Line 877-999-6442 www.michigan.gov/difs Table of Contents Page
More informationPERSONAL INJURY PROTECTION ROUNDTABLE
PERSONAL INJURY PROTECTION ROUNDTABLE RECOMMENDATIONS November 2010 R. Terry Butler, Esq. Florida Insurance Consumer Advocate Representing Alex Sink Chief Financial Officer State of Florida 1 TABLE OF
More informationOFFICE OF INSURANCE REGULATION Property and Casualty Product Review
OFFICE OF INSURANCE REGULATION Property and Casualty Product Review NOTIFICATION OF PERSONAL INJURY PROTECTION BENEFITS YOUR PERSONAL INJURY PROTECTION RIGHTS AND BENEFITS UNDER THE FLORIDA MOTOR VEHICLE
More informationUnderstanding Florida s PIP Laws
Understanding Florida s PIP Laws Bacen & Jordan, P.A. Renee Jordan, Esq. 4801 South University Drive Suite 3100 Davie, FL 33328 (954) 961-5511 rjordan@bacenjordan.com PIP = No Fault!! No Fault are first
More informationHow To Stop Insurance Fraud In Florida
1 Insurance Fraud in Tampa Area is; Easier than ordering a Pizza? Part 3, The Final part The PIP Looter Clinics in Tampa Bay www.thefraudalertteam.com Insurance fraud is booming in Tampa Bay. PIP, personal
More informationIMPACT ANALYSIS OF HB 119
IMPACT ANALYSIS OF HB 119 August 20, 2012 Pinnacle Actuarial Resources, Inc. 2817 Reed Road, Suite 2 Bloomington, IL 61704 2 Purpose and Scope Pinnacle Actuarial Resources, Inc. (Pinnacle) was retained
More informationNO-FAULT INSURANCE IN OTHER STATES
79172 Prepared by the North Dakota Legislative Council staff for the Transportation Committee November 2005 NO-FAULT INSURANCE IN OTHER STATES Saskatchewan has had no-fault insurance since 1946 and Puerto
More informationALLIANCE OF NONPROFITS FOR INSURANCE RISK RETENTION GROUP P.O. Box 8546, Santa Cruz, CA 95061 P: (800) 359-6422 F: (831) 459-0853
COMMERCIAL LINES COMMON POLICY DECLARATIONS PRODUCER: POLICY NUMBER: 2012-26938 Nonprofit Insurance Advisors 2314 University Ave W Suite 20 Saint Paul, MN 55114 RENEWAL OF NUMBER: 2011-26938 NAME OF INSURED
More informationOFFICE OF INSURANCE REGULATION Property and Casualty Product Review
OFFICE OF INSURANCE REGULATION Property and Casualty Product Review NOTIFICATION OF PERSONAL INJURY PROTECTION BENEFITS YOUR PERSONAL INJURY PROTECTION RIGHTS AND BENEFITS UNDER THE FLORIDA MOTOR VEHICLE
More informationAUTOMOBILE APPLICATION FOR INSURANCE FOR NON-TRUCKING USE (BOBTAIL)
National Casualty Company Home Office: Madison, Wisconsin Scottsdale Insurance Company Home Office: One Nationwide Plaza Columbus, Ohio 43215 Scottsdale Indemnity Company Home Office: One Nationwide Plaza
More informationState of Florida End of Session (2012)
House Bill 511 (Hudson) An Act Relating to Workers Compensation: Summary: Authorizes authorized physician who is also dispensing physician to dispense & fill prescriptions; prohibits DFS, employer, or
More informationA Survey of Federal and State Actions to Counter Misclassification Fraud
A Survey of Federal and State Actions to Counter Misclassification Fraud Presented to: Washington Joint Legislative Taskforce on the Underground Economy in the Construction Industry September 10, 2008
More informationHow To Get A Car Insured
2013 COMMERCIAL LINES OOPS! (OFTEN OVERLOOKED POLICY SECTIONS) SPONSORED BY The policy says WHAT???!!! The OOPS!!! Commercial Lines OOPS Often Overlooked Policy Sections Michael C. D Orlando, CIC, LIA,
More informationKentucky Retirement Systems Health Benefits. Mike Burnside, Executive Director National Conference of State Legislators July 28, 2010
Kentucky Retirement Systems Health Benefits Mike Burnside, Executive Director National Conference of State Legislators July 28, 2010 Kentucky Retirement Systems Kentucky Retiree Health Plan Statutory changes
More informationThe Florida Senate POTENTIAL IMPACT OF MANDATING BODILY INJURY LIABILITY INSURANCE FOR MOTOR VEHICLES. Interim Project Summary 98-03 November 1998
The Florida Senate Interim Project Summary 98-03 November 1998 Committee on Banking and Insurance Senator Mario Diaz-Balart, Chairman POTENTIAL IMPACT OF MANDATING BODILY INJURY LIABILITY INSURANCE FOR
More informationAGENT CHECK-WRITING AUTHORITY INSTRUCTION MANUAL
AGENT CHECK-WRITING AUTHORITY INSTRUCTION MANUAL Notice: Nothing in this manual is intended, or should be interpreted or construed, as a modification, change or waiver of the provisions of any policy of
More informationR. Terry Butler, Esq. Florida Insurance Consumer Advocate. Representing Alex Sink Chief Financial Officer State of Florida
PERSONAL INJURY PROTECTION ROUNDTABLE RECOMMENDATIONS November 2010 R. Terry Butler, Esq. Florida Insurance Consumer Advocate Representing Alex Sink Chief Financial Officer State of Florida TABLE OF CONTENTS
More informationNO-FAULT INSURANCE & FRAUD PREVENTION S.B. 248 (S-3) & 249: (REVISED) SUMMARY AS PASSED BY THE SENATE
NO-FAULT INSURANCE & FRAUD PREVENTION S.B. 248 (S-3) & 249: (REVISED) SUMMARY AS PASSED BY THE SENATE Senate Bill 248 (Substitute S-3 as passed by the Senate) Senate Bill 249 (as passed by the Senate)
More informationRisk Management Division Municipal Manager Anchorage: Performance. Value. Results.
Risk Management Division Anchorage: Performance. Value. Results. Purpose Minimize the financial impact and loss of Human resources, from known and unknown events and accidents. Core Services Process auto
More informationHow To Fight Insurance Fraud In Minnesota
Minnesota Insurance Fraud Summit Executive Summary October 16, 2012 Bloomington, Minnesota The National Insurance Crime Bureau (NICB) and the Insurance Federation of Minnesota (IFM) co-sponsored an Insurance
More informationTown of Littleton Policy on Group Health and Life Insurance Coverage for Active Employees and Retirees
[HISTORY: Adopted 3-22-2010; Amended 7-13-2015 Purpose This policy details the terms under which the Town provides life and health insurance coverage to its employees and retirees in accordance with adopted
More informationThe Florida Senate. Issue Brief 2012-203 August 2011 PERSONAL INJURY PROTECTION (PIP) Statement of the Issue. Discussion
Committee on Banking and Insurance Statement of the Issue The Florida Senate Issue Brief 2012-203 August 2011 PERSONAL INJURY PROTECTION (PIP) Under the state s no-fault law, owners or registrants of motor
More informationArkansas. Insurance Department AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE. Mike Beebe Governor. Jay Bradford Commissioner
Arkansas Insurance Department AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE Mike Beebe Governor Jay Bradford Commissioner A Message From The Commissioner The Arkansas Insurance Department takes very seriously its mission of consumer
More informationMedical Claims. How to File a Medical Claim. Coordination of Benefits. Explanation of Benefits Instructions and Sample
Medical Claims How to File a Medical Claim Coordination of Benefits Explanation of Benefits Instructions and Sample 07/01/2005 Visit our Website at http://mutualofomaha.com 1 How to File a Medical Claim
More informationIndiana University Peer Institution Benefits Comparison July 2009 Health Care Plans
Indiana Peer Institution Benefits Comparison July 2009 Summary of comparison with Big 10 universities and/or large employers: Most IU peers also provide healthcare benefits to part time employees (IU provides
More informationYour Auto Insurance Policy ONTARIO. is Changing
Your Auto Insurance Policy ONTARIO is Changing Your auto insurance policy is changing Your Ontario auto insurance benefits are changing to make your premiums more affordable and provide you with greater
More informationAuto Insurance. No-Fault: Michigan's Unique Auto Insurance Law. Personal Injury Protection (PIP)
No-Fault: Michigan's Unique Auto Insurance Law Michigan is generally recognized as having the most efficient and effective auto insurance laws in the United States. In the U.S., there are two systems that
More informationIndustry Standard Claims Reporting Data and Claims Management
Industry Standard Claims Reporting Data and Claims Management 2008 CAS PREDICTIVE MODELING SEMINAR Molly Bhattacharyya, Ph.D October 2008 Discussion topics Predictive Analytics and Claims Data Issues Industry
More informationCOMMERCIAL AUTOMOBILE/TRUCKERS APPLICATION
National Casualty Company Home Office: Madison, Wisconsin Adm Office: 8877 Gainey Center Dr. Scottsdale, Arizona 85258 Scottsdale Insurance Company Home Office: One Nationwide Plaza Columbus, Ohio 43215
More informationBUSINESS AUTO DECLARATIONS
COMMERCIAL AUTO B CA DS 03 01 12 Issuing Company: Tri-State Insurance Company of Minnesota Policy No.: Previous Policy No.: BUSINESS AUTO DECLARATIONS ITEM ONE NAMED INSURED AND ADDRESS AGENCY NAME AND
More informationMarket Conduct Examination
Market Conduct Examination RUTGERS CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY AND RUTGERS ENHANCED INSURANCE COMPANY CHERRY HILL, NEW JERSEY STATE OF NEW JERSEY DEPARTMENT OF BANKING AND INSURANCE Office of Consumer Protection
More informationMichigan No-Fault Law: What You Don t Know Can Hurt You
Why Learn About No-Fault? Michigan No-Fault Law: What You Don t Know Can Hurt You Third Party Payer Day Mt. Pleasant, Michigan October 30, 2015 Robert E. Dice, Jr., Esq. Dice Law PLLC 25925 Telegraph Rd.
More information