1 Using a scientific approach to teach physics Carl Wieman, Univ. of Colorado I) Data on effectiveness of traditional physics teaching. II) Useful results/principles from research on effective learning. III) Some examples of technology that make it easier to implement these principles. (CU physics & chem ed. research, W. Adams, K. Perkins, Kara Gray, Linda Koch, Jack Barbera, Sarah McKagan, N. Finkelstein, Steve Pollock,... $$ NSF, Kavli, Hewlett)
2 Science education different, more important purpose than in the past. Not just for scientists Survival of world. Wise decisions by citizenry on global (technical) issues. Workforce in High-Tech Economy. Need to make science education effective and relevant for large fraction of population! and diverse!
3 Essence of an "effective education". Transform how think-- Think about and use science like a scientist.
4 How to teach physics: (I used many years) Think very hard about subject, get it figured out very clearly. Explain it to students, so they will understand with same clarity.?????????????????????????????????????????? grad students
5 Why, after 17 yrs of success in classes, do students come into lab so clueless about physics? 2-4 years later, leave as expert physicists??? Approach as science problem. What do we know about how people learn, particularly science?
6 II. Some data on effectiveness of traditional approach to physics teaching. lecture, textbook homework problems, exams (most data from intro university physics) 1. Retention of information from lecture. 2. Conceptual understanding. 3. Beliefs about science.
7 1. Lecturing and retention I. Redish- interviewed students as came out of lecture. "What was the lecture about?" unable to say anything but vaguest generalities II. Rebello and Zollman- had 18 students answer six questions, then told them to get answers to these 6 questions from following 14 minute lecture. (Commercial video, highly polished) Most questions, less than one student able to get answer from listening to lecture. III. Wieman and Perkins- 15 minutes after nonobvious fact told to students in lecture with illustration, gave simple multiple choice test to see if remembered. ~10% get correct (even in phys. dept. colloq.)
8 2. Conceptual understanding. Learned in traditional intro physics course? Force Concept Inventory-basic concepts of force and motion Traditional Lecture 14 courses Fraction of unknown basic concepts learned Lecturer quality, class size, institution,...doesn't matter!
9 2. Conceptual understanding (cont). electricity Eric Mazur (Paired problems) Most students can calculate currents and voltages in complex circuit. A 12 V 8 V 2 Ω 1 Ω 1 Ω B BUT, not predict brightness of bulbs when switch closed. Solving test problems, but not like expert!
10 3. Beliefs about physics and problem solving (measured)* Novice Content: isolated pieces of information to be memorized. Expert Content: coherent structure of concepts. Handed down by an authority. Unrelated to world. Problem solving: pattern matching to memorized arcane recipes. Describes nature, established by experiment. Prob. Solving: Systematic concept-based strategies. Widely applicable. nearly all physics courses more novice ref. Redish et al, CU work--adams, Perkins, MD, NF, SP, CW *adapted from D. Hammer
11 Science Education Research Conclusions 1: Not easy to know what students actually are (and are not) learning. Most students "learning" rote memorization of facts and problem solving recipes, not useful understanding. most also learning that physics is uninteresting and irrelevant
12 III. What does research tell us about principles that are important for more effective learning? Three generally applicable examples a. cognitive load b. role of attitudes and beliefs c. developing expert competence
13 Results when put into practice 1. Retention of information from lecture 10% after 15 minutes >90 % after 2 days 2. Conceptual understanding gain 25% 65% 3. Beliefs about physics and problem solving significant drop small improvement
14 examples-- using research on how people learn a. Cognitive load-- best established, most ignored. Mr Anderson, May I be excused? My brain is full.
15 a. Cognitive load-- every bit more costs. ~7 items short term memory, process 4 ideas at once. Typical class, MUCH more than brain can process.
16 b. Importance of student beliefs about science and science problem solving Our new beliefs survey (CLASS.colorado.edu) (similar to MPEX but more general) Strongly Disagree Strongly Agree I think about the physics I experience in everyday life. After I study a topic in physics and feel that I understand it, I have difficulty solving problems on the same topic. <10 minutes, Give online pre- and post- instruction (>10,000 stds) Score agree (% favorable) or disagree with expert view Lots of data! Beliefs content learning Beliefs choice of major/retention Teaching practices students beliefs
17 b. Teaching practices and beliefs Course Type Phys-I (alg) Phys-I (calc) Dominant student population pre-meds sci. & eng. Beliefs (%favorable) Overall Pre 60% 64% Post 51% 58% Decline in beliefs ~all intro physics courses (also chem.) # students % expert-like
18 Teaching practices and beliefs Avoid decline if minimal effort to explicitly address beliefs. (Rutgers much more substantial) pre post Phys I premeds 56% 58% Phys I sci & eng 64% 66% Why is this worth learning? How does it connect to real world? Why does this make sense? How connects to things you already know? Interesting new result- students know expert beliefs and problem solving approaches, but don t accept as valid. (particularly women)
19 c. Research on developing expert competence or? just pouring in more facts can hinder rather than help New ways of thinking--require active mental construction. Built on prior thinking. To develop, needs to be explicit part of learning process
20 How to teach science: Think very hard about subject, figure out very clearly. Explain it to students, so they understand with same clarity. me vs students massively heavier cog. load novice beliefs about why to learn, how to learn. no organizational structure general principle people learn by creating own understanding. Effective teaching: facilitate by guiding that creation.
21 III. Some technology that can help implement principles.* a. student personal response systems b. interactive simulations * work from Col. sci. ed. research group
22 III. Some technology that can help. ( when used properly) Personal electronic response systems--facilitate active thinking and useful guidance. Relatively cheap. PERS ( clickers ) "Jane Doe picked B" individual #
23 15 minutes after telling and showing students how wooden back of violin is what produces sound they hear responses (%) 84% students click in responses, then display histogram 10% 3% 3% 0% A B C D E
24 clickers- Used properly transforms classroom. Dramatically improved engagement, discourse, number (x4) and distribution of questions. Not automatically helpful-- Only require students to commit to an answer (accountability + peer anonymity+ fast feedback) Key to educational effectiveness use guided by how people learn Clicker questions and associated discussion: Focus students on processing ideas, organize and apply Communication and feedback (student-instructor, student-student) student consensus-group discussions (& listen in)
25 Interactive simulations phet.colorado.edu Physics Education Technology Project (PhET) Wide range of physics topics and some chem., well tested, free online or download. Run in regular web-browser. Use in lecture, lab, homework. (often better than reality!) balloon and sweater laser supported by: Hewlett Found., Kavli, NSF, Univ. of Col., and A. Nobel
26 examples: balloon and sweater moving man wave on string each illustrate a unique pedagogically valuable characteristic of interactive simulations
27 Research on design and effectiveness of simulations. (Wendy Adams, Kathy Perkins, Noah F., et al) 1. Substantial improvement on concept questions when used in lecture vs real demos or static images. 100 standing wave on string sim demo % right Q1 real demo Q2
28 CCK Students learn to build and understand real circuits better with sim than with real equipment! Finkelstein et al Phy. Rev. PER 1,1 real world not necessarily best pedagogically, experts and novices see very differently. Need to be very sophisticated to see simplicity.
29 Summary: Need new, more effective approach to science ed. Solution: Approach teaching as a science Practices and principles based on good data Effective use of technology Disseminate and copy what works. Good Refs.: NAS Press How people learn, "How students learn" Mayer, Learning and Instruction (ed. psych. applied) Redish, Teaching Physics (Phys. Ed. Res.) Wieman and Perkins, Physics Today (Nov. 2005) CLASS belief survey: CLASS.colorado.edu phet simulations: phet.colorado.edu
Nobel Prize Carl Wieman UBC & CU Data!! and many other subjects Colorado physics & chem education research group: W. Adams, K. Perkins, K. Gray, L. Koch, J. Barbera, S. McKagan, N. Finkelstein, S. Pollock,
Carl Wieman Stanford University Department of Physics and Grad School of Education need all students, future scientists or not, to be able to think about science more like scientists results & implications,
Transforming Physics Education By using the tools of physics in their teaching, instructors can move students from mindless memorization to understanding and appreciation. Carl Wieman and Katherine Perkins
Research-Based Design Features of Web-based based Simulations Wendy Adams, Kathy Perkins, Noah Finkelstein, Sam Reid, Michael Dubson, Noah Podolefsky and Carl Wieman University of Colorado, Boulder Ron
A SURVEY TO ASSESS THE IMPACT OF TABLET PC-BASED ACTIVE LEARNING: PRELIMINARY REPORT AND LESSONS LEARNED Edward Price Department of Physics California State University San Marcos San Marcos, CA, USA firstname.lastname@example.org
International Journal of Humanities and Social Science Vol. 1 No. 7 [Special Issue June 2011] Transformative Learning: Shifts in Students Attitudes toward Physics Measured with the Colorado Learning Attitudes
Laptops and Diesel Generators: Introducing PhET Simulations to Teachers in Uganda Sam McKagan, JILA, University of Colorado and NIST Submitted June 24, 2008; Revised February 11, 2009 In early 2008 I had
The Effect of Animation on Students' Responses to Conceptual Questions Melissa Dancy: North Carolina State University email@example.com Aaron Titus: North Carolina A&T State University firstname.lastname@example.org
DUNC.ch02.p005-011.v1 8/3/04 4:52 PM Page 5 2 Why Use a Classroom Response System? Key Points Limitations of traditional lectures Engaging students in peer discussions Learning gains you can expect Attitude
AP Psychology Course Syllabus and Survival Guide Mr. Koch email@example.com 651 982 8550 Course website: http://hs.forestlake.k12.mn.us/staff_sites/dan_koch_home/koch_ap_psychology/ Wiki page:
Educational Technology in Introductory College Physics Teaching and Learning: The Importance of Students Perception and Performance Jean Chen, Assistant Director, Office of Institutional Research University
Students experiences of the use of classroom response systems in class discussion M. S. Herbert Department of Physics University of the Western Cape 1 This presentation discusses the results of a survey
Real Time Physics and Interactive Lecture Demonstration Dissemination Project - Evaluation Report Michael C. Wittmann Department of Physics University of Maryland College Park MD 20742-4111 I. Introduction
A Hybrid-Online Course in Introductory Physics Homeyra R. Sadaghiani California State Polytechnic University, Pomona, USA firstname.lastname@example.org INTRODUCTION The recent demand and interest in developing
Designing a PER-Based Introductory Physics Lab Nick Corak Honors Thesis Defense Presentation 12/2/10 Acknowledgements PER Groups UMd UC-Boulder UW UMinn Honors Committee Dr. Black Dr. Davis Dr. Kubasko
CWSEI & CU-SEI July 30, 2008 Teaching Expert Thinking (by Wendy Adams and Carl Wieman, CU-SEI and UBC-CWSEI, and Dan Schwartz, Stanford School of Education) Experts and novices differ: The study of differences
The Essentials of Critical Care Orientation (ECCO) Program's Impact on New Graduate Nurses' Critical Thinking Development Sigma Theta Tau International s 21 st International Nursing Research Congress Mahmoud
What is the Value of Course-Specific Learning Goals? By Beth Simon and Jared Taylor The authors examined student and faculty opinions regarding the use of detailed learning goals in three courses. Students
www.sciencemag.org/cgi/content/full/332/6031/862/dc1 Supporting Online Material for Improved Learning in a Large-Enrollment Physics Class Louis Deslauriers, Ellen Schelew, Carl Wieman* *To whom correspondence
Reinventing college physics for biologists: Explicating an epistemological curriculum Edward F. Redish and David Hammer Departments of Physics and Curriculum and Instruction, University of Maryland, College
Colorado Learning Assistant Program Overview 2010 Colorado Learning Assistant Program Overview-1 LA Program Overview The Learning Assistant (LA) Model 1 at the University of Colorado at Boulder uses the
Essays on Teaching Excellence Toward the Best in the Academy Volume 21, Number 4, 2009-10 A publication of The Professional & Organizational Development Network in Higher Education (www.podnetwork.org).
Leveraging three types of instructional technologies to maximize student learning Emily Springfield, MS Ed, University of Michigan Session Objectives Learn to categorize learning technologies by function
Anatomy of a wave partner activity: One person is a reporter and the other is the artist. The artist tries to draw what the reporter describes. Rules are important but the result is kids learn the parts
Tutor s Creed As tutors, we are responsible for improving the skills of our peers. As tutors, we will consider the body of work presented at the session in the following manner: First, we will impart to
Virtual Labs in the Online Biology Course: Student Perceptions of Effectiveness and Usability Tracey A. Stuckey Mickell Department of Educational Technology, Research & Assessment Northern Illinois University
1 A new model for post-secondary education, the Optimized University Carl Wieman Dept. of Physics University of Colorado and University of British Columbia I. Introductory caveats. This article is discussing
AP Psychology Rancho Bernardo High School Instructor: Mike Inumerable Why take AP Psych? There are many reasons to take this course, but for starters, read this December 2013 article from a teen writer
Title: Transforming a traditional lecture-based course to online and hybrid models of learning Author: Susan Marshall, Lecturer, Psychology Department, Dole Human Development Center, University of Kansas.
Advanced Placement Psychology Course Syllabus and Survival Guide Mr. Korek O1-HO3-072006 Purpose of the Course The purpose of the Advanced Placement course in Psychology is to introduce students to the
INTEGRATION OF CRITICAL THINKING PRINCIPLES INTO THE CURRICULUM OF SECONDARY SCHOOLS: LITHUANIA S CASE Research report Author Daiva Penkauskienė June 2010 Supported by a grant of from Foundation Open Society
How to prepare for the PHR/SPHR exam with the SHRM Learning System Online Chat Transcript February 28, 2013. Q. How successful has the flashcard study been to others preparing the exam? A. We do recommend
Flipping the Classroom By Cynthia J. Brame, CFT Assistant Director Flipping the classroom has become something of a buzzword in the last several years, driven in part by high profile publications in The
A physics department s role in preparing physics teachers: The Colorado Learning Assistant model Valerie Otero, Steven Pollock, and Noah Finkelstein University of Colorado, Boulder, Colorado 80309 In response
Identity and Needs in the Modern World: Roles of Orality and Literacy 15 th Inuit Studies Conference, Paris, Oct. 26, 2006 An overarching goal in Inuit communities is to maintain Inuit culture as a dynamic
2011 International Conference on Computer Science and Information Technology (ICCSIT 2011) IPCSIT vol. 51 (2012) (2012) IACSIT Press, Singapore DOI: 10.7763/IPCSIT.2012.V51.127 An Investigation on Learning
More accessible, streamlined access to digital learning content that fits the way instructors and students want to work A look at the WileyPLUS/Blackboard integrated experience across a number of disciplines
A guide for instructors interested in transforming a course, and their instruction, to use research-based principles and improve student learning. UBC and CU Science Educa.on Ini.a.ves This work is licensed
ENHANCING CONCEPTUAL UNDERSTANDING WITH CLASSROOM RESPONSE SYSTEMS Sophia Cheng Science Education Section, EDB What is Classroom Response System (CRS)? Clickers, Personal Response System (PRS), Interactive
Website: Designlearning.org Example of a Well-Designed Course in Nursing Name: Dr. Vickie Hughes Name of Institution: Appalachian State University 1. Specific Context The subject matter: Research The title
STUDENT LEARNING SUPPORT TUTORIAL PRODUCED BY THE CENTER FOR TEACHING AND FACULTY DEVELOPMENT CLASS PARTICIPATION: MORE THAN JUST RAISING YOUR HAND CHAPTER 1: LEARNING THROUGH CLASS PARTICIPATION CLASS
How to Succeed in 3 rd and 4 th Year Computer Science Classes Dr. Beth Simon Science Learning and Teaching Fellow Computer Science Department email@example.com PhD in CS Why listen to me? Computer Architecture:
Learner-Centered Teaching Elizabeth Normandy Teaching and Learning Center Learner-Centered Teaching Learner-centered teaching focuses attention on what the student is learning, how the student is learning,
Problem Solving; Understanding and evaluating the many component skills, processes and beliefs. Wendy Adams University of Colorado, Boulder Introduction Most important aspect of University science education
Preparing graduate students to be educators Edward Price a) Department of Physics California State University, San Marcos San Marcos, CA 92096 Noah Finkelstein b) Department of Physics University of Colorado
AP Psychology 2013 2014 Ms. Samuelson Per 6 Contact Ms. S firstname.lastname@example.org Wscacademy.org The school s website has a homework tracking system that will send email reminders to students and
Transition Unit Design and Discovery NCCA An Chomhairle Náisiúnta Curaclaim agus Measúnachta National Council for Curriculum and Assessment t Area of Study Taster (with link to Creativity, Work and Future)
McGraw-Hill LearnSmart Effectiveness Study Evaluating the adaptive learning tool s impact on pass and retention rates and instructional efficiencies at seven U.S. universities EMBRACING TECHNOLOGY TO ACHIEVE
Fall 2012 Q530 Programming for Cognitive Science Aimed at little or no programming experience. Improve your confidence and skills at: Writing code. Reading code. Understand the abilities and limitations
So You Want To Go To Econ Grad School... Tim Salmon Department of Economics Florida State University October 2006 I get asked a number of questions each year by students who are considering economics graduate
Evidence-Based Claims and Belief Andrew P. Martin University of Colorado Copyright 2015 Contents Practical Overview 2 Pedagogical Overview 3 Learning Goals 4 Instructor Preparation Prior to Class 5 Description
The Big Idea Boost Your Mind Power Week by Week Bill Lucas The human mind is so complex that it was believed to be like empty vessels waiting to be filled with facts and figures. But with the advent of
Best Practices in Online Teaching In 2006 Curtis Bonk in his article entitled The Future of Online Teaching and Learning in Higher Education: The Survey Says made reference to something called a perfect
Using Peer Instruction as a Teaching Strategy Highlights from the Summer 2012 AAPT New Faculty Workshop Ronald E. Kumon Department of Physics Kettering University 23 October 2012 Overview Peer Instruction
CHAPTER 6 Instructional Implications: Some Effective Teaching Methods In theory, there is no difference between theory and practice. But in practice, there is. Jan L. A. van de Snepscheut quoted in [Fripp
Engage to Excel: A National Mandate for Science Education Jo Handelsman Yale University Goals for Today Know the findings and recommendations of Engage to Excel Know the type of evidence on which active
Research, Innovation and Reform in Physics Education David E. Meltzer Department of Physics and Astronomy Iowa State University Supported in part by the National Science Foundation Collaborator Mani K.
Instructional & Motivational Strategy Plan Anthony Saba Dr. Lisa Dawley Edtech 512: Online Course Design 10/18/2009 2 Table of Contents Instructional Strategy Plan... 3 Orientation to Learning... 3 Instructional
Creating Futures University of Colorado Boulder Transforming Math and Science Learning for Every Student: more Why don t American students like science and math? Could it be that too often science is taught
Instructor: Office: Office Hrs: Jeff Stone, Ph.D. Phone: 626-2438 email: 436 Psychology Department Weds 1-4pm and by appointment email@example.com PSYCHOLOGY 461a The Social Psychology of Attitudes
Getting the Most out of ATI www.atitesting.com What is ATI? ATI is an online resource that will be used throughout the nursing program to help you learn about nursing practice as well as help prepare you
MAKING ON-LINE SCIENCE COURSE MATERIALS EASILY TRANSLATABLE AND ACCESSIBLE WORLDWIDE: CHALLENGES AND SOLUTIONS Wendy. K. Adams, Department of Physics, University of Colorado, Boulder, Colorado 80309, USA
Expanding the Use of Classroom Response Systems (CRS): CRS Integration with In- Class Group Activities in Large Classrooms Dr. Leilani Arthurs, Research Associate and Science Teaching Fellow, Department
What it takes to be a World Class Industrial Engineer I have been asked to comment tonight on what it takes to be a World Class Industrial Engineer? Dr. Chen gave me a light assignment. Now I know what
Presentation Skills and Teamwork:! Part II: Review and Discussion! Dr. S. Gibson & Dr. S. Boogert! Second Year post exam bonanza, June 2013! Outline!! Organization for talks!! Voting!! Examples of talks!!
Dr. Joanne Broggy* & Dr. Jennifer Johnston *Projects Officer Teaching and Learning (Science) National Centre for Excellence in Mathematics and Science Teaching and Learning (NCE-MSTL) Email: Joanne.Broggy@ul.ie
Learning From Lectures: A Guide to University Learning Learning Services University of Guelph Table of Contents Student Guide:... 3 University Lectures... 3 Preparing for Lectures... 4 Laptop Pros & Cons...
Study Abroad Pre- Course Classes Internationalize Campuses In a recent poll taken by the United States senate, 87% of students in the United States between the ages of 18 and 24 could not locate Iraq on
ResearchILD Website Creating Strategic Classrooms: Empowering Students to Learn How to Learn Lynn Meltzer, Ph.D. President & Director of Research, ResearchILD Director of Assessment, ILD Associate in Education,
DEEPER LEARNING COMPETENCIES April 2013 Deeper learning is an umbrella term for the skills and knowledge that students must possess to succeed in 21 st century jobs and civic life. At its heart is a set
Psy 212- Educational Psychology Practice Test - Ch. 1 1) Use of the "common sense" approach to teaching is viewed by educational psychologists as A) inappropriate unless supported by research. B) the main
Utilizing Lecture Videos on Blackboard The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly Dr. Tim Smith Chemistry, Computer, & Physical Sciences October 2012 % DWF (Fail Rate) 45.0 40.0 35.0 35.0 F2F vs. Online Success Rate
Integrated Skills in English ISE II Reading & Writing exam Sample paper 2 Your full name: (BLOCK CAPITALS) Candidate number: Centre: Time allowed: 2 hours Instructions to candidates 1. Write your name,
PEDAGOGY OF EFFECTIVE CLICKER USE AND CONSTRUCTING GOOD CLICKER QUESTIONS Colleen Holcomb The Teaching and Learning Center 212 Capen Hall 645.7700 firstname.lastname@example.org Workshop Overview What are clickers
SURVEY A high school uses student surveys in every class to gather instructional feedback for teachers. Data from multiple formative surveys and online endof-course surveys combine to help teachers improve
Psychology 2510: Survey of Abnormal Psychology (Section 2) Fall 2015 Instructor: Julianne Gray Ludlam, Ph.D. Class Location: Psychology Building 313 Class Time: MWF, 9:00-9:50 AM CST Office Location: 25
RICHARD STOCKTON COLLEGE OF NJ Business Continuity Planning Emergency Response Preparedness Continuity of Class Meetings and Instructional Delivery This document has been created to assist faculty in making
1 SYLLABUS PSYCHOLOGY 4SC6: SCIENCE COMMUNICATION Department of Psychology, Neuroscience, and Behaviour McMaster University 2014-2015 Course Meeting Information: Wednesdays 4:30-6:30pm in PC316 (class);
Science 265 Fun with Tape! Challenge At the end of this lab you are to answer the question that follows. Please keep it in mind as you explore static electricity today and test it out when you get home.
ON APPLYING TO GRADUATE SCHOOL IN PSYCHOLOGY * Admission to a graduate program in psychology can be quite competitive. High quality programs are, of course, more competitive than lower quality programs.
PSYCHOLOGY 1115 - Section M01 Mixed Mode Spring Semester 201110 Fundamentals of Psychology I MW 11:30 - A130 ***You are responsible for all information in this syllabus!*** Instructor: Dr. Jennifer Poole,