1 Commitment to Meaning: A Reframing of Agency in Games Karen Tanenbaum School of Interactive Arts & Technology Simon Fraser University nd Ave, Surrey, BC V3T0A3 Joshua Tanenbaum School of Interactive Arts & Technology Simon Fraser University nd Ave, Surrey, BC V3T0A3 ABSTRACT This paper examines the concept of agency within games and proposes a shift from the notion of agency as representing choice or freedom to one of agency as representing commitment to meaning. This conception of agency is aimed at understanding the pleasures of engaging with narratively rich games, and helps to address the tension between player choice and authorial intent. We draw on what speech act theory says about how trust, meaning and communication are achieved in human conversation, applying these notions to interactive storytelling. This new perspective on agency provides us with a better analytical tool for understanding the relationship between interaction and narrative pleasure, and provides a useful metric for designers of story-rich games. Keywords Game Studies, Agency, Game Design, Interactive Storytelling, Speech Act Theory 1. INTRODUCTION The role of narrative in games has been the subject of much debate. One of the central points of this debate positions game narrative as being inherently in conflict with the player s desire to act within the game world. This so-called tension between narrative and interaction has given rise to a vast array of design techniques, intended to either control the actions of the player via various guidance strategies or to shape the evolution of the story via intelligent drama managers.[21, 25-28] The problem with this approach is that it is rooted in a problematic assumption: that unrestricted self-agency is a core pleasure of game experiences. This assumption construes the player as an agent of chaos within the game world: an uncontrollable variable which must be continually corrected for. Espen Aarseth writes: In the adventure games where there is a conflict between narrative and ludic aesthetics, it is typically the simulation that, on its own, allows actions that the story prohibits, or which make the story break down. Players exploit this to invent strategies that make a mockery of the author s intentions.  This is a difficult stance to design from because it places story designers in a position where they must be designing against the assumed preferences and desires of their players rather than for them. The problem of agency is not insurmountable, but it may not be solvable through a brute force application of more realistic modeling or more intelligent programming techniques. Without an understanding of the pleasures of play and story and the assumptions surrounding player preferences, it will be impossible to engineer a way to a solution. Instead, we propose that a solution lies in the careful examination of the idea of agency itself, in order to better understand how to design for pleasurable and meaningful gameplay experiences that also partake of the pleasures of narrative. This paper examines the concept of agency within games and proposes a shift from the notion of agency as representing choice or freedom to one of agency as representing commitment. By expanding the definition of agency in this direction, we can start to better understand game experiences where a player has limited or restricted actions, but remains fully engaged with the game. This new perspective also allows us to challenge some of the assumptions about what players want from their play experiences, especially where narrative is concerned. We are not arguing that there is no pleasure to be found in the types of playful and unrestricted interactions afforded by many current games, especially those loosely categorized as sandbox games (such as Rock Star s Grand Theft Auto  series or Bethesda s Elder Scrolls  series). Instead we are suggesting that when play and story intersect, agency is better understood as a commitment to meaning, instead of a desire to act freely. This new perspective on agency builds upon our previous work in exploring the utility of treating interactive narrative and game experiences as improvised performances between the player and the experience designer . Most interactive drama theories have an idealized notion of the interactor as a performer in the story; however, most state of the art interactive storytelling systems are designed around the assumption that participants will act selfishly and in contradictory ways. This results in games and storytelling systems which exert various levels of control on the actions of the player in order to bring them in line with the story. In our previous paper, we proposed using the social contract between participants in an improvisational scene as a model for designing interactive dramas. If we can conceive of the relationship between the author and the interactor as one of equal participants in an improvisation, then the issue of interactor agency becomes one of performer responsibilities it is necessary to reframe agency as a shared property of all participants in an interactive drama . In that paper, we Digital Arts and Culture, Permission to make digital or hard copies of all or part of this work for personal or classroom use is granted without fee provided that copies are not made or distributed for profit or commercial advantage and that copies bear this notice and the full citation on the first page. To copy otherwise, or republish, to post on servers or to redistribute to lists, requires prior specific permission from the author. Digital Arts and Culture, December 12 15, 2009, Irvine, California, USA.
2 suggested a new direction for thinking about agency, but did not develop the notion fully. In this paper, we discuss the notion of agency as it has been used in academic discussions within the fields of game studies and new media studies. We also look at more informal treatments of agency from the game design community and popular game culture. We propose our new definition of agency and elaborate on the notions of commitment and meaning in order to explore the implications of this definition for designers and theorists. 2. AGENCY 2.1 Academic Definitions Agency as Choice Perhaps the most well known definition of agency comes from Janet Murray, who describes it as the satisfying power to take meaningful action and see the results of our decisions and choices . Murray identifies agency as one of the central pleasures of interacting with digital environments (along with immersion and transformation), but is careful to qualify her definition, reminding the reader that interactors can only act within the possibilities that have been established by the writing and programming." This clause is important to Murray, as she is invested in the notion of the author/designer as a privileged role, distinct from the creative roles available to interactors. More recently, Salen and Zimmerman write: Playing a game means making choices and taking actions. All of this activity occurs within a game-system designed to support meaningful kinds of choice-making.  Like Murray, Salen and Zimmerman describe a relationship between making choices and taking actions, placing the emphasis on player activity. Both definitions also have some notion of meaningful actions, which we will return to later in this paper. Mateas and Stern provide a more instrumental approach to agency, building on Murray but proposing a more restricted definition. A player in an interactive drama becomes a kind of author, and contributes both materially to the plot and formally to elements at the level of character on down. But these contributions are constrained by the material and formal causes (viewed as affordances by the author of the interactive drama). Hopefully, if these constraints are balanced, the constrained freedom of the player will be productive of agency . Mateas and Stern view agency as arising from the ways in which the design of the game experience constrains and affords actions. They divide the potential constraints in an experience into two categories: material constraints (such as the functional limitations of the interactive system) and formal constraints (the possibilities motivated by the dramatic probability in the plot ). Thus the potential for player agency is largely determined by the design of the system. It has been more than a decade since Murray published her definition of agency, and in that time one of the things that has changed most dramatically in games has been the rise of simulated worlds in which no author or designer could possibly anticipate all of the actions that a player might take. Assuming that the design of the game will limit the actions of the player also fails to account for the well documented possibility of the player deliberately subverting the design of the digital environment, either by exploiting bugs or by hacking and patching the game. While the possibility of the interactor acting outside the parameters or expectations defined by the author did exist at the writing of Hamlet on the Holodeck, it was much less prevalent then it has since become. Today, not only is it possible for unanticipated and emergent player actions to occur, in many games it is expected. These expectations have given rise to a shift in the notion of agency, away from choice and toward freedom Agency as Freedom None of the above definitions of agency talk about providing the player with unlimited freedom to act. If anything, each of these definitions provides room for agency to operate within highly constrained parameters. However, many discussions of agency, especially those from theorists who identify as ludologists, overlook this, instead construing agency as freedom from restrictions. Perhaps the most extreme variation on this comes from Gonzalo Frasca, who completely disassociates agency from narrative meaning. He writes: the more freedom the player is given, the less personality the character will have. It just becomes a cursor for the player s actions.  Frasca goes on to describe a variation on the game The Sims  in which players have control over the behavioral algorithms that govern the character s actions, directly challenging definitions of agency that incorporate any pre-existing authorial constraints. Barry Atkins suggests that the pleasures of play are rooted in a sort of cause and effect relationship in which the player is actively testing the boundaries of the simulation. He writes: Video games prioritize the participation of the player as he or she plays, and that player always apprehends the game as a matrix of future possibility. The focus, always, is not on what is before us or the what happens next of traditionally unfolding narrative but on the what happens next if I that places the player at the center of experience as its principle creator, necessarily engaged in an imaginative act  This notion of agency construes the player as creative investigator whose central interest is in uncovering new responses from the system. The player, in this case, is primarily interested in taking actions, and experiencing their outcomes. At some level, this idea of unrestricted agency has been idealized within the academic community, as when Rushkoff writes: I d place my renaissance bet on the gamers perspective: the very notion that our world is open source, and that reality itself is up for grabs. For, more than anyone else, a real gamer knows that we are the ones creating the rules.  This idea of creating the rules, along with Frasca s suggestion to give the player control over the behavior algorithms, pushes the notion of agency to the point where the distinction between player and designer collapses. Nowhere is this notion of agency more prevalent than within the game design community. 2.2 Agency in Design and Gamer Culture Outside of academic discussions, there is a thriving discourse on the design of games that is comprised primarily of working game designers and some vocal communities of game players. It is
3 within this domain that we find some of the most hardline approaches to agency as well as some of the most interesting alternative framings Agency as Freedom II Shortly after Murray published Hamlet on the Holodeck, game designer and theorist Ernest Adams wrote...the player and her actions are the most important things in the game. In computer gaming you subordinate the player to the plot at your own peril. It s not our job to tell stories. It s our job to build worlds in which players can live a story of their own creation . This lionization of pure simulation, similar to the academic definitions discussed in 2.1.2, has persisted within games culture. In 2008, Steve Gaynor, another prominent designer and blogger, wrote: The player is an agent of chaos, making the medium ill-equipped to convey a pre-authored narrative with anywhere near the effectiveness of books or film the game designer's role is to provide the player with an intriguing place to be, and then give them tools to perform interactions they'd logically be able to as a person in that place to fully express their agency within the gameworld that's been provided. In pursuit of these values, the game designer's highest ideal should be verisimilitude of potential experience.  In this treatment of agency, there is no attempt at limiting agency through a series of designed constraints. The pleasure that is being designed for here is one of unrestricted action. We see evidence of this design philosophy at work in the ways in which the current generation of games relies more on simulation than on linear scripting. They focus on enhancing player enjoyment by expanding the range of available choices, construing agency as the freedom to act upon the world without restriction. The ultimate game from this perspective becomes nothing more than an empty game engine wherein players are invited to build their own rules, worlds, characters and stories. While there is undoubtedly some appeal in this notion (as the success of community moddable games such as Neverwinter Nights , and interactive toys such as The Sims  can attest), it is not the same as engaging in a fictional world constructed by someone else, and this notion of agency does not help understand the pleasures of interacting with authored content. The problem with this approach is that all meaningful content in a game world involves a restriction of the player s freedom at some level. The moment a designer chooses to place walls and textures in an environment, or to simulate human characters, the freedom of the player has been limited and constrained. In fact, as Chris Crawford has pointed out, the ultimate interactive narrative software system already exists: Microsoft Word . If the goal of game design was to make games that were simply toys, bereft of meaning or message, this notion of unrestricted agency would be sufficient. However, we need constraints in order to make interactive experiences meaningful and pleasurable. Most formal definitions of games rely on the presence of rules and constraints in order to define and bound the play experience [17, 31]. The notion of unrestrained agency conflicts with a game designer s ability to make games with stories or processes that require specific actions and responses from the player. The notion of agency as freedom needlessly forces an opposition between player agency and the designer s ability to author a compelling work, be that work primarily ludic or narrative in nature Agency as Illusion In spite of the freedom-based rhetoric that the design community has constructed around agency, there are plenty of examples of ways in which games limit player actions in order to support a richer experience. Some games, such as God of War II  and Kingdom Hearts , do this by introducing quicktime events or other mechanics of interaction which afford the illusion of agency but serve as a mechanism for limiting player choices. While the term illusion of agency has a negative flavor, it has also been noted within the gaming community that this illusion is often quite convincing. In a recent column for the popular gaming magazine The Escapist Anthony Burch describes a number of game experiences where the illusion of agency provides players with powerful play experiences, in spite of their ultimate inability to affect the outcome of the game events. Here's how it works: Present players with a scenario, and actively trick them into believing they have more control over the events than they actually do. The experience will have the emotional impact the designer intended, and players will (mistakenly) believe that they were in complete control the entire time. It sounds difficult, dishonest and more than a little cheap. But when it works? It can be nothing short of goddamned magical . Burch provides two examples of games in which this approach is effective. In his first example, Half-Life 2: Episode 2 , he describes a climactic scene in which the player must defend a base from an onslaught of alien striders. [Figure 1] In order to provide the desired emotional arc, the designers carefully stage the pace at which the aliens progress through the base, modifying the density of the enemies and the efficacy of the AI resistance on the player s side. The stated goal of this design is for the player to feel a sense of heroic effort without actually being able to fail the mission (except through exceptionally bad play). In this example, taking control over the outcome out of the hands of the player is used to craft a more intense play experience and a more intense narrative experience. Figure 1. Defending the White Forest base against Striders in Half Life 2: Episode 2
4 The other example given by Burch is even more telling. He describes a sequence at the end of Metal Gear Solid 4  in which the hero, Old Snake, must traverse a tunnel filled with deadly microwave radiation in order to prevent the destruction of the planet. [Figure 2] The microwave tunnel sequence is widely regarded as one of the most powerful and emotional moments in contemporary games; a quick search of the Playstation 3 forums or of the many YouTube videos in which the sequence may be viewed reveals hundreds of players talking about how they cried during it [4, 5]. Figure 2. Solid Snake struggling through the microwave tunnel in Metal Gear Solid 4 What makes this sequence remarkable is how little control the player has over any aspect of the experience. In it, the player is told that he must maneuver Snake down the tunnel quickly or he will die. As the character moves through the gauntlet of microwaves, the top half of the screen shows the final moments of a climactic battle in another location. Suddenly, there is a flash of sparks from the wall of the tunnel and Snake collapses to the floor. A voice over the radio implores Don t give up on me, Snake! and the player is prompted to tap the Triangle button on the controller in order to keep Snake moving forward. Over the next moments of gameplay this escalates: Snake grows ever more crippled, the corridor becomes more and more hazardous, and the prompting from the system demands ever increasing button mashing in order to move the character forward. Burch describes the final moments of the sequence, writing: Snake goes down again, presumably for the last time. He inches forward pathetically, just barely crawling as his health meter speeds down to its last few millimeters of life. The triangle button animation appears for a moment "press it, or he'll die!" but disappears once you press the button even faster, even harder. Then it appears again, the animation running twice as fast as before, sending a clear message: As fast as you were pressing it before, you're not pressing it fast enough now for Christ's sake, press triangle faster or everyone you love is going to die.  This sequence leads the player to buy into the drama and the desperation of the situation. Through carefully arranged cues the player is invited to frantically mash a single button in order to advance the game. The beauty and irony of this is that even this limited set of interactive possibilities to rapidly push the button or not is not actually required by the system. Snake's ever-decreasing health bar cannot possibly reach zero before the end of the corridor so long as you press the triangle button once every few seconds. In purely mechanical terms, you might as well be holding a DVD player remote that has been jury rigged to only continue playing a film if the viewer presses "play" every so often . Even when a player s actions have no real impact on the world in the sense that there is nothing she could have done that would have yielded a different result players nevertheless come out of the experience feeling as if their actions were meaningful and the game was enjoyable. This leads us to the question: is this a violation of the player s agency, or simply another form of agency? In order to begin answering this question we must first consider the different types of game players, and the different sources of pleasure that motivate players. 2.3 Agency and Player Types One of the sources of these problematic assumptions about agency is a tendency to group all players under a unified heading, to assume that there is a singular ur-gamer that represents the stereotypical audience for all games. There is, however, a rich body of literature that is focused on understanding the different personality types, drives, motivating factors, and preferences distinguish individual players from each other. The classic treatment of player types comes from Richard Bartle, who proposed four different player archetypes for participants in MUDs. The Bartle player types include: Achievers: Achievers regard points-gathering and rising in levels as their main goal, and all is ultimately subservient to this. Killers: Killers get their kicks from imposing themselves on others. Socialisers: Socialisers are interested in people, and what they have to say. The game is merely a backdrop, a common ground where things happen to players. Explorers: Explorers delight in having the game expose its internal machinations to them. They try progressively esoteric actions in wild, out-of-the-way places, looking for interesting features (i.e. bugs) and figuring out how things work.  It is possible to see a range of pleasures across Bartle s typology. The pleasures of action are certainly represented, but equally prevalent are pleasures of discovery, socialization, and advancement. From this early parsing of player preferences, it should be evident that there is no singular game player. Bateman and Boon take a different approach to player preferences. Their book takes the Meyers-Briggs personality typing system and applies it to game playing, reducing it from 16 personality types down to four game playing archetypes. The Meyers-Briggs typology is comprised of four sets of dichotomies, which may be recombined into 16 possible permutations. These include Extroversion vs. Introversion; Sensing vs. Intuition; Thinking vs. Feeling; and Judging vs. Perceiving. Bateman and Boon draw on the last two dichotomies to structure their typology of player types. These four player types include:
5 Conqueror (Thinking & Judging): Conqueror play involves winning and beating the game. [Primary pleasure is goal oriented challenge.] Manager (Thinking & Perceiving): Manager play revolves around a strategic or tactical challenge. [Primary pleasure is process oriented challenge.] Wanderer (Feeling & Perceiving): [The Wanderer] is looking for enjoyment, or a unique experience. They won t play a game they aren t enjoying and, in fact, stop playing the moment it ceases to be fun. [Primary pleasure is aesthetic and emotional play.] Participant (Feeling & Judging): [Participants] want to participate either in the story the game is offering or with other players in some emotional context. [Primary pleasure is narrative and social play.]  They further subdivide these categories into hardcore and casual versions of each play style, which are also associated with a specific Meyers-Briggs type. In this typology, only one player type would derive pleasure from the abovementioned notion of unrestricted agency: the Wanderer. The other play styles, while operating within the pleasures of limited agency, all rely on either the structure of rules or the structure of story to provide the pleasure. Craig Lindley performs a survey of player preferences in the course of his analysis of the relationship between narrative structures and computer games. He examines folk typologies that have arisen from players of tabletop role playing games (RPGs) and live action role playing games (LARPs). One typology in particular stands out, in that it parses player preferences into categories that speak directly to the concerns raised above. The Threefold Model from John Kim parses player preferences into three contracts, or shared play styles in which players have roughly agreed on the same core values and pleasures in their play: Dramatist: is the style which values how well the ingame action creates a satisfying storyline. Gamist: is the style which values setting up a fair challenge for the players The challenges may be tactical combat, intellectual mysteries, politics, or anything else. Simulationist: is the style which values resolving ingame events based solely on game-world considerations, without allowing any meta-game concerns to affect the decision.  By parsing the pleasures of gaming into these three categories, Kim provides a useful distinction for the analysis of the constituent pleasures of play. Lindley writes, of these categories: The mechanics of a computer game may realize the designed formal structures at all three levels, but players may be more or less free to play creatively in a style of their preference, in tune or at odds with the design emphasis in the computer game artifact.  As a model for agency, this is an interesting approach in that it does not say anything about designing for player freedoms. Instead, it proposes that the preferences of the individual player will determine the extent to which he engages or subverts the structures of the game experience. Lindley goes on to discuss three different modes of behavior that describe how players engage with the dramatic and narrative aspects of games. The audience: passive reception of a narrative, i.e. being told a story; this is the model implicit within the use of predefined cut scenes in commercial computer games to convey story elements designed by the game developers The performer: active performance of a character role within an unfolding story; further distinctions here might be made in terms of the degree to which the role and/or the story are predefined, as opposed to being created by the performer prior to or during the performance The immersionist: immersion of the player in the character, i.e. the player/character distinction is dissolved into a unified persona within the game world; here too there is a question of the degree of character predefinition required to encourage immersion.  These modes represent a continuum of activity that a player may engage in, while still remaining attentive to the narrative demands of the game. Unlike the ludological arguments about narrative that attempt to frame story as a passive mode of experience that is isolated from the dynamics of the play activity, these three player roles identify ways in which gamers actively engage in game narratives. Looking at all of the above player typologies, it becomes possible to assemble a type of player with a very different set of desires from those described in section This new aggregate player type is concerned with participating in a fictional world where her decisions and actions are incorporated meaningfully into that fiction. This player is less concerned with limitless but meaningless freedom, and is instead interested in some systematic reification of the meanings which she is performing as an inhabitant of this world. In order to serve this kind of player, we propose a redefinition of agency as the process by which participants in an interaction commit to meaning. 3. AGENCY REDEFINED Our proposed understanding of agency is not meant to suggest new ways of designing games, but rather new ways of understanding how and why existing games work, and new ways of talking about the design of games. It is also not meant to be a universal definition of agency, but rather a definition that applies for a particular subset of narrative-oriented games and the pleasures associated with navigating them. To explore this definition of agency as a committing to meaning further, we examine the notions of both commitment and meaning and their implications for game play and game design. 3.1 Commitment Central to this definition is the notion of commitment ; an idea that has its roots in speech act theory and the philosophy of AI. Winograd & Flores, in their critique of artificial intelligence from a phenomenological perspective, argue that machines can never be intelligent because they cannot commit to meanings in the way that human interactors do . Each language act or utterance in a conversation between two or more people has consequences for
6 the participants, typically related to actions they are about to take or will undertake in the future. Speech act theory categorizes an utterance in terms of its illocutionary point, with each kind of point entailing different commitments or attempting to achieve different goals . See Table 1 for definitions and examples of each type. Table 1. Categories of Illocutionary Point Type Definition Example Assertive: Commits the speaker to the truth of the statement Directive: Attempts to get the listener to do something. Commissive: Expressive: Commits the speaker to future action. Expresses the speaker s psychological state Declaration: Brings reality into alignment with the content of the statement It is raining outside Can you close the door? I will rescue the princess. I am excited about this quest I now pronounce you man & wife Commitment as entailed by the illuctionary point of an utterance is critical to establishing trust and communication between actors, as seen in improvisational theater as well as everyday conversation. People who make assertive statements that are shown to be false, or who make commissive utterances that they do not follow through on will be judged untrustworthy and unreliable. In our previous paper, we argued for a way of thinking about gaming not as players interacting with a system but as performers improvising within a story. Under this conception, designers and performers are in a type of conversation with each other, mediated by the game. By looking at the ways in which human conversation creates meaning and commits speakers to action, we can gain an interesting perspective on how we might design a game system which provides similarly satisfying ways to engage and commit. Perhaps equally importantly, by looking at ways in which this dialogue breaks down in popular games we can learn important lessons about designing games that support commitment. Tanenbaum and Bizzocchi provide a case study of this process in action, in their close reading of the opening sequence of Oblivion . In the opening sequence, the player diegetically creates a character by playing through an opening dungeon. At the end of this sequence, the game recommends a class, based on the observed play style and choices of the player.[figure 3] Over the course of their close reading, the authors identify a number of ways in which the actions of the player fail to result in appropriate responses from the system. We can understand this breakdown as a situation in which the illocutionary point of the player s actions the communicative commitment embodied in the play is not meaningfully interpreted or responded to by the system. For example, when the player selects a race and a gender, she is making a commissive act because the specialization of the races commits the player to a specific play style for the rest of the game. Similarly, if the player traverses the dungeon entirely in stealth mode, she is making an expressive act about her psychological state. In both of these cases, Tanenbaum and Bizzocchi discovered that the system fails to properly interpret these commitments, ignoring the first entirely and misrepresenting the second . Some games are more careful about mapping commitments to outcomes in a way that is clear to the player. In Mass Effect  much of the gameplay revolves around lengthy branching dialogue trees. [Figure 4] However, the player is seldom given access to the actual dialogue that is to be performed by the character. Instead, she is presented with a selection of abstracted and abbreviated conversation options to choose from. Each of these options translates into a much longer utterance on the part of the main character, Commander Shepard. Figure 4. The Dialogue Wheel in Mass Effect Figure 3 Oblivion  attempts to interpret the commitments of the player and recommend a class. In this interaction, there are two kinds of commitment present: a directive act in which the player indicates to Shepard which type of response she wants the character to speak, and more opaque act where the game system responds with an utterance that might use any kind of illocutionary point in order to advance the story. Noah Wardrip Fruin writes that this makes conversation feel a bit less first person sometimes more as though we re influencing Shepard (the player character) than playing as Shepard.  For the most part, this two stage relationship between the communicative commitments of the player and of the character works seamlessly. The player commits to a general flavor of communication, which is then executed by the character within the predefined conversation possibilities. Occasionally, however, there will be a mismatch: the player will instruct Commander
7 Shepard in what she believes will result in one type of communication, only to receive something unexpected in response. One player describes this on the Mass Effect forums For the most part, I loved the dialogue wheel... but I'd be lying if I said there weren't a few occasions where I selected a response intending for my character to behave or say something a certain way... only to have them either say or (in worse situations) do something I neither intended or wanted to happen One case example was when I was tracking the guy who'd gone off to create a cult of biotics. When I confronted him, I highlighted a response that I thought would probe or provoke him a bit... but instead once I selected the response, I drew a weapon and shot his head off.  The communicative commitments of the player may not always align with those of the game designer, as this example shows. For the most part, the game avoids this issue by consistently locating positive and negative responses in their own quadrant of the user interface, providing the player with additional cues as to what each dialogue option is going to expand into. These two examples begin to show how we can use this notion of commitment to understand player commitments and the way in which player and designer are engaged in a conversation with each other via the game story. The other half of our definition looks at the notion of meaning. 3.2 Meaning Focusing on the idea of meaning allows us to shift the emphasis in an interaction away from the outcome of a choice, and towards the intent which underlies that choice. Most of the definitions of agency discussed in section include some notion of meaning, but this is often overlooked in favor of construing agency as freedom. Paul Dourish says that interaction is not simply about what people do in the world, but about how those actions accomplish meaningful events . It is more important to provide the player with the ability to take a single, meaningful action than a dozen trivial ones. Thus, in a sandbox game, such as Grand Theft Auto III , the player may have a very freeform experience of driving, committing crimes, and resisting arrest. There may be limitless permutations of these activities with enough variation and emergent moments to support hours of unique play, however there is a comparatively small range of meanings to which that player is committing. She may either commit crimes or obey the law; she may follow the structured quests or she may ignore them, in which case the world remains static. Salen & Zimmerman view meaning as emerging as a result of discernable systematic responses to interactor behavior. They write that design is the process by which a designer creates a context to be encountered by a participant, from which meaning emerges and that The meaning of an action in a game resides in the relationship between action and outcome Meaningful play occurs when the relationships between actions and outcomes in a game are both discernable and integrated into the larger context of the game  Meaningful choices, then, are the ones in which the illocutionary commitments entailed by the utterance/action are real: the player is held accountable for what they have committed to. Simulational fidelity alone may afford unrestricted player actions, but is not sufficient for meaningful play. It is important to recognize this property of meaningful behaviors as one which can (and should) be applied to the design and operation of the game world as well as the actions of the player within it. In discussing expressive autonomous agents, Phoebe Sengers introduces the notion of action-expression instead of action-selection, arguing that it is more important to do the thing right than do the right thing . By this, Sengers means that agent behaviors in a simulation should be understood and described in terms of what they signify rather than their instrumental components. We can understand this argument as one in which an intelligent system s emphasis is no longer on the actions which are taken within it, but on the expressed meanings of those actions. In some cases, committing to meaning may even involve sacrificing the ability to chose, or engaging in actions where there are no choices to be made. The Metal Gear Solid IV  microwave tunnel scene is powerfully affective because it demands that the player commit to the story, not because she has any choice or actual control over what is happening. By pushing the triangle button over and over, she is continually asserting that she is committing to moving Snake down the hallway, to pushing through the character s pain, to finishing the mission. This is not a nuanced or sophisticated narrative meaning, but it is a potent one, and thus, she emerges from the microwave tunnel feeling like she just completed a significant task: an ordeal in which ten years of game storytelling have culminated, and over which she has triumphed. As one fan writes: Ok that hallway that was like a microwave scene was **bleep**ing amazing. It was so dramatic. You could see snake in so much pain through the seering heat as his suit was melting away. And you almost felt like you were struggling just like snake was, because you had to press the traingle button so fast. Than you have the split screen on the top where everything is going on and seems like everyone is out of luck and is about to die and it makes you want to make it even more. But im am just in awww. I have never seen such a movie like dramatic scene playable in a video game. Definetly my favorite part of the game [sic] . This is a perfect example of the player committing to the narrative meaning of the game even when there are no strategic choices available: in this moment of play, the commitments of the player and the meanings represented by the game system come into parity with each-other. We see this as an important form of agency. At a purely cognitive level, the player chooses to engage in this fiction, and to allow the drama of the moment to create the belief that her actions have meaningfully advanced the story. Similarly, a recent study by Roberts et al looked at using principles of Influence Theory from social psychology as a way of guiding player behavior in an interactive narrative . By adding carefully crafted influence statements to the story, the authors were able to increase the number of people who selected one specific action over another. Crucially, in the post-study questionnaire, players who got the control story and players treated with the influenced stories showed no differences in terms of reported agency or feelings of manipulation. Despite having their actions manipulated and controlled in this way, their engagement with the story and their own commitment and feeling of agency was unaffected.
8 4. CONCLUSIONS Throughout this paper, we have examined the notion of agency, looking at its use in academic and games industry discourse and then proposing our own definition. This definition, that agency is the process by which participants in an interaction commit to meaning, is particularly well suited to interactions with narrative and story-based games. This understanding of agency proposes that game designers should strive to create game and narrative experiences in which the player can demonstrate commitment to the experience, and, crucially, where that meaningful commitment is reinforced by the game s behavior. Agency is not about selecting between options in this case, but is instead about expressing intent, and receiving a satisfying response to that intent. Commitment in this sense might be a purely cognitive process, or it might involve player actions. There is already substantial evidence in games that this type of agency has the potential to create play experiences that are emotionally powerful. Quicktime events and other game mechanics whereby players must take action by pressing a button or performing a specific action may not afford any meaningful choices to the player, but they have the ability to bring the commitments of the player and the commitments of the game into parity with each-other. Rather than being an illusion of agency, then, such mechanics are in fact the vehicle for agency: the way by which player shares in the story creation with the game designer. Framing an interactive narrative as a conversation between the player and the designer allows us to use the notion of illocutionary points as a way to think about different kinds of commitments. By reframing agency in this manner, we hope to provide a basis for the design and analysis of game interactions that supports richer, more meaningful experiences. One happy consequence of this definition is that it re-imagines the player and designer as collaborators in the game experience. By conceptualizing game design as a conversation in which different meaningful communications are being exchanged, we move away from the problematic notion of the player desiring only to subvert the intentions of the designer. We propose that designers take this definition as an argument to redirect their efforts away from facilitating player freedom and towards facilitating meaningful expression. 5. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS Thanks to Jim Bizzocchi, Magy Seif El-Nasr, and Marek Hatala for intellectual and financial support in the development of the ideas presented here. 6. REFERENCES  "Coach Jon", Dialogue Wheel, in Mass Effect Community Forums2007. Bioware: &forum=123.  Aarseth, E.J., Genre Trouble: Narrativsm and the Art of Simulation, in First Person: New Media As Story, Performance, and Game, N. Wardrip-Fruin and P. Harrigan, Editors. 2004, The MIT Press. Cambridge, Massachusetts; London, England. pp  Adams, E., Three Problems for Interactive Storytellers, in The Designer's Notebook, Gamasutra, Editor Gamasutra: blems/026_three_problems.htm.  Anonymous, Microwave Hallway *Spoiler*, in PlayStation.com Forums2008. Sony Computer Entertainment America Inc.: oard.id=mgs&message.id=  Anonymous, Metal Gear Solid 4 Guns of the Patriots - The Microwave Hall, in YouTube  Atkins, B., What Are We Really Looking at?: The Future- Orientation of Video Game Play. Games and Culture, (2):  Bartle, R., Hearts, Clubs, Diamonds, Spades: Players Who Suit MUDs. The Journal of Virtual Environments, (1)http://www.brandeis.edu/pubs/jove/HTML/v1/bartle.htm l  Bateman, C. and Boon, R., 21st Century Game Design. Game Development Series, ed. 2006, Hingham, MA: Charles River Media.  Bethesda Softworks, The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion, ZeniMax Media Inc.:  BioWare, Neverwinter Nights, Atari:  BioWare, Mass Effect, Microsoft Game Studios:  Burch, A., String Theory: The Illusion of Videogame Interactivity, The Escapist 195/5910-String-Theory-The-Illusion-of-Videogame- Interactivity.  Crawford, C., The Art of Interactive Design. 2003, San Francisco, CA: No Starch Press  Dourish, P., Where the Action Is: The Foundations of Embodied Interaction. 2001, Cambridge: MIT Press. Physical Copy (book).  Frasca, G., Rethinking agency and immersion: video games as a means of consciousness raising. Digital Creativity, (3):  Gaynor, S., Being There, in Fullbright: the Progress Journal of One Video Game Designer  Juul, J., Half-Real: Video Games between Real Rules and Fictional Worlds. 2005, Cambridge, Massachusetts: The MIT Press  Kim, J., The Threefold Model FAQ,  Kojima Productions, Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots, Konami:  Lindley, C.A., Story and Narrative Structures in Computer Games, in Developing Interactive Narrative Content: sagas/sagasnet reader, Bushoff and Brunhild, Editors. 2005, High Text. Munich.
9  Mateas, M., An Oz-Centric Review of Interactive Drama and Believable Agents. Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA. /CMU-CS html.  Mateas, M. and Stern, A., Interaction and Narrative, in The Game Design Reader: A Rules of Play Anthology, E. Zimmerman and S. Katie, Editors. 2006, The MIT Press. Cambridge, Massachusetts; London, England. pp  Maxis, The Sims, Electronic Arts:  Murray, J., Hamlet on the Holodeck: the future of narrative in cyberspace. Anonymous. Vol. 1997, Cambridge, Massachusetts: The MIT Press  Nelson, M.J., Mateas, M., Roberts, D.L., and Isbell Jr, C.L., Declarative Optimization-Based Drama Management in Interactive Fiction. IEEE Computer Graphics and Applications, (3):  Riedl, M., Saretto, C.J., and Young, R.M. Managing interaction between users and agents in a multi-agent storytelling environment, in Proceedings of the second international joint conference on Autonomous agents and multiagent systems. 2003: &coll=&dl=acm&cfid= &cftoken=  Roberts, D., Furst, M., and Isbell, C., Using Influence and Persuasion to Shape Player Experience, in Sandbox 2009: The 4th ACM SIGGRAPH Conference on Video Games2009. ACM Press: New Orleans, Louisiana. pp  Roberts, D.L. and Isbell, C.L., Desiderata for Managers of Interactive Experiences: A Survey of Recent Advances in Drama Management, in First Workshop on Agent-Based Systems for Human Learning and Entertainment2007. AAMAS: Honolulu, Hawaii. pp.  Rockstar North, Grand Theft Auto III, Rockstar Games:  Rushkoff, D., Renaissance Now! The Gamers' Perspective, in Handbook of Computer Game Studies, J. Raessens and J. Goldstein, Editors. 2005, The MIT Press. Cambridge Massachusetts.  Salen, K. and Zimmerman, E., Rules of Play: Game Design Fundamentals. 2004, Cambridge, MA; London, England: MIT Press  SCE Studios Santa Monica, God of War II, Sony Computer Entertainment:  Sengers, P., Do the Thing Right: An Architecture for Action-Expression, in Autonomous Agents1998. Minneapolis MN USA. pp.  Squaresoft, Kingdom Hearts, Square Electronic Arts/ Disney Interactive:  Tanenbaum, J. and Bizzocchi, J., You Must Be An Experienced Thief: Intelligent Personalization in Oblivion, in The 2nd Annual Canadian Gaming Studies Association Conference2008. Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada. pp.  Tanenbaum, J. and Tanenbaum, K. Improvisation and Performances as Models for Interacting with Stories, in ICIDS. 2008:  Valve Corporation, Half Life 2: Episode 2, Valve Corporation:  Wardrip-Fruin, N., Mass Effect: Am I the Player Character?, in Grand Text Auto  Winograd, T. and Flores, F., Understanding Computers and Cognition: A New Foundation for Design. 1986, Norwood, New Jersey: Ablex Publishing Corporation. Physical Copy (book).
Teaching Game Development: At the Intersection of Computer Science and Humanities & Arts David Finkel, Mark Claypool, Michael A. Gennert Department of Computer Science Fred Bianchi, Dean O Donnell, Patrick
Neomancer: An Exercise in Interdisciplinary Academic Game Development Michael Katchabaw Department of Computer Science The University of Western Ontario London, Ontario, Canada Tel: +1 519-661-4059 firstname.lastname@example.org
A New Undergraduate Major: Interactive Media and Game Development David Finkel, Mark Claypool, Michael A. Gennert Department of Computer Science Fred Bianchi, Dean O Donnell, Patrick Quinn Department of
1 Design Principles for Video Games as Learning Engines James Paul Gee Mary Lou Fulton Presidential Professor of Literacy Studies Regents Professor Arizona State University email@example.com The literature
CITS4242: Game Design and Multimedia Lecture 2: Game Design What is Game Design? Game design includes developing and considering the following aspects of a game: - Concept - Genre - Setting (often including
topics: game design documents design document references: cisc3665 game design fall 2011 lecture # IV.1 game development documentation notes from: Game Design: Theory & Practice (2nd Edition), by Richard
Level Design Characters vs Levels Characters and levels are essentially the main user interface of your game. Levels present the challenge or problem to solve, Characters present the tools to solve them.
Engagement and motivation in games development processes Engagement and motivation in games development processes Summary... 1 Key findings... 1 1. Background... 2 Why do we need to engage with games developers?...
Approaches to Apologetics By John McClean Matthias Media (The Briefing #119; www.matthiasmedia.com.au/briefing). Used with permission. A poverty stricken student reaches the end of her financial resources
BIBLE STUDY (Genesis 2:15-17; 3:1-18) What s This Passage All About? The book of Genesis is about beginnings the beginning of the world, the beginning of humankind, and the beginning of our relationship
Introduction to Game Design and Development Playing: Galaxy Trucker Watching: The Big Bang Theory Reading: Master Thesis! Listening: Slayer Game Design: What is it? Game Design is Design Design is concerned
h t t p : / / u w p. a a s. d u k e. e d u / w s t u d i o Visual Rhetoric/Visual Literacy: Writing About Film This handout discusses ways to approach film as a visual medium. It offers suggestions for
The Ontology of Cyberspace: Law, Philosophy, and the Future of Intellectual Property by David R. Koepsell, Peru, Illinois: Open Court Publishing, 2000, ISBN 0-8126-9423-6, (Price $26.95); Paper: ISBN 0-8126-9537-2,
Your Image of the Child: Where Teaching Begins by Loris Malaguzzi These comments are translated and adapted from a seminar presented by Professor Loris Malaguzzi in Reggio Emilia, Italy, June 1993. There
Worlds Without Words Ivan Bretan firstname.lastname@example.org Jussi Karlgren email@example.com Swedish Institute of Computer Science Box 1263, S 164 28 Kista, Stockholm, Sweden. Keywords: Natural Language Interaction, Virtual
Game Design Fundamental theory Fundamental theory Why theory? Why is fundamental theory important? It provides a structure to think in Thinking about game design without a structure is inefficient As if
Barriers to Entry: Designing Player Access in Video Games William Ryan Indiana University 1900 E. 10th Street firstname.lastname@example.org ABSTRACT Video games can be sources of pleasure and frustration. For many
The CMI Content MarketING FRAMEWORK 7 Building Blocks to Success Your company is probably already exploring the role that compelling content can play in your own marketing programs just as many other companies
Preproduction in the Game Development Process From Proposal to Prototype Instructor Sara R. Farr Preproduction At this point, you already have an approved game proposal outlining your game. Preproduction
COMMUNICATION COMMRC 0005 INTERVIEWING AND INFORMATION GATHERING 3 cr. Students are introduced to the fundamental principles of interviewing, including the interpersonal communication process, the structure
Lesson 8 Descriptive Essays Description is not a distinct mode of writing, like expository, narrative, and persuasive, but the ability to write descriptively is essential to a host of writing genres. Many
Agile Contract Options By Allan Kelly, Director & Consultant Agile Contract Options One question frequent questions asked about Agile methods is: "How do you sign a contract based on Agile working?" The
Core Analysis Frame: Fiction D24 These questions will help you understand any story you read. For more advanced, in-depth analysis of each element, use the following frames: Setting Plot Author s Craft
Instructor: Dr. Brian Ballentine Office: 211 Colson URL: community.wvu.edu/~bdb026/306 Hours: T 1:00 3:00 E-mail: email@example.com W 1:00 3:00 [To] claim that there is no difference between
Architecture Artifacts Vs Application Development Artifacts By John A. Zachman Copyright 2000 Zachman International All of a sudden, I have been encountering a lot of confusion between Enterprise Architecture
Guidelines for Integrative Core Curriculum Themes and Perspectives Designations The purpose of this document is to provide guidelines for faculty wishing to have new or existing courses carry Themes and
Michelle Light, University of California, Irvine EAD @ 10, August 31, 2008 The endangerment of trees Last year, when I was participating on a committee to redesign the Online Archive of California, many
THE CMI CONTENT MARKETING FRAMEWORK 7 Building Blocks to Success Your company is probably already exploring the role that compelling content can play in your own marketing programs just as many other companies
Overcoming Fear of Speaking in Public Snake Oil Therapy Business Meeting Ice Breaker Human Resources Marketing and Product Development Brainstorming Sales Training 1. Overcoming Fear of Speaking in Public
Story and Narrative Structures in Computer Games 1 Craig A. Lindley Department of Technology, Art and New Media, Gotland University, Cramergatan 3, SE-621 57 Visby, Sweden firstname.lastname@example.org Abstract
University Press Scholarship Online You are looking at 1-9 of 9 items for: keywords : game spaces Introduction mitpress/9780262141017.003.0007 This introductory chapter presents an overview of the main
Harvard College Program in General Education Faculty of Arts and Sciences Harvard University A Guide to Writing in Ethical Reasoning 15 A Guide to Writing in Ethical Reasoning 15 Professor Jay M. Harris
Motivations of Play in Online Games Nick Yee, Department of Communication, Stanford University (in press in CyberPsychology and Behavior) Abstract An empirical model of player motivations in online games
RACK911 Labs Year in Review May 6, 014 The security of the hosting industry has always been a concern of RACK911 and in May of 013 we decided to take a more proactive role by creating a new brand called
» WHITE PAPER IS IT POSSIBLE THAT WHAT YOU LEARNED ABOUT COACHING IS WRONG? SOMETIMES DIFFERENT IS BETTER THE TRUTH ABOUT WHO TO COACH & HOW TO ASSESS THEIR PERFORMANCE Tom Stanfill, CEO ASLAN Training
The Swap Puzzle Age group: Abilities assumed: Time: 7 adult Nothing Size of group: 8 to 30 50-60 minutes, Focus What is an algorithm? Testing Efficiency of algorithms Computational Thinking: algorithmic
Ludology: Psychology of fun Ludology The fundamental purpose of games is fun! So what makes them fun, exactly? Remembering from last time nobody wants to make a bad game. ( go to shaqfu.com) Famous game
Game Development Doron Nussbaum COMP 3501 - Game Development 1 What is a game? Doron Nussbaum COMP 3501 - Game Development 2 Books/Movie vs. Game Good books have Place Era Plot Characters Relationships
ART A. PROGRAM RATIONALE AND PHILOSOPHY Art education is concerned with the organization of visual material. A primary reliance upon visual experience gives an emphasis that sets it apart from the performing
Lecture 2: ActionScript 3 and Game Design Promise Get you up to speed on Flash Tell you about an interesting experiment Teach basics of game design 2 Outline Updates Flash / ActionScript 3 What is a game?
Jefferson Township Public Schools Technology Curriculum Video Production II: Television Studio Grades 10, 11 & 12 August 2011 Video Production II Curriculum 2011 Page 2 TABLE OF CONTENTS JEFFERSON TOWNSHIP
An Introduction to Design Thinking PROCESS GUIDE Empathize To create meaningful innovations, you need to know your users and care about their lives. WHAT is the Empathize mode Empathy is the centerpiece
San José State University Writing Center www.sjsu.edu/writingcenter Written by Jacqueline Goodwin Personal Narrative Essays This handout will help you begin your personal narrative essay assignment with
Education as Degrees and Certificates What is Undergraduate Education? K. P. Mohanan For many people, being educated means attending educational institutions and receiving certificates or degrees. This
By: James Iannelli RI Reputation Management www.reputationmanagementri.com (401) 316-2931 1 Introduction As a business owner, you already know that managing a business is a LOT of work; from keeping the
Farres, L. G. (2000). A mental training tool: Implementing an effective mental skills training program. BC Coach s Perspective, 4(4), 14-17. A Mental Training Tool: Implementing an Effective Mental Skills
J. T. M. Miller, Department of Philosophy, University of Durham 1 Methodological Issues for Interdisciplinary Research Much of the apparent difficulty of interdisciplinary research stems from the nature
Best Practices in Teaching Writing Charles Whitaker, Ph.D. Following is a list of selected teaching practices that are well recognized in the profession as being effective in helping students develop as
This, is Blade Stepper, a modern spin on the classic 3-reel mechanical slot machine. As a leader in gaming, we must always be thinking of new ways to connect with our players and create products that resonate
Organizing and Managing a Book Discussion Group This guide was adapted for CCH s April California Stories Uncovered campaign from a book discussion guide developed by the Washington Center for the Book
Definitions of Games and Play Magic Circle Rules as Limitations and Affordances Foundations of Interactive Game Design Prof. Jim Whitehead January 10, 2007 Creative Commons Attribution 2.5 creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.5/
This includes: 1. Leader Preparation 2. Lesson Guide GOD S BIG STORY Week 1: Creation God Saw That It Was Good 1. LEADER PREPARATION LESSON OVERVIEW Exploring the first two chapters of Genesis provides
Chapter 3: The Play The Play is: Starting point for theatrical production Entity that remains intact after production Blueprint for production or for reader s imagination The play may serve as the basis
COGNITIVE & K Critical and Creative Thinking: Students combine and apply artistic and reasoning skills to imagine, create, realize and refine artworks in conventional and innovative ways. The student will
The Five Fundamentals of a Successful FCR Program April 2012 Executive Summary Industry analysts agree that First Contact Resolution (FCR) is the best way to measure the effectiveness of your contact center.
Why Your Job Search Isn t Working 6 mistakes you re probably making and how to fix them I t s easy to think that your lack of success in finding a new job has nothing to do with you. After all, this is
Ratings, Audiences, & Failed Shows TELEVISION RATINGS Before the Show Airs A New Season TV networks test programs Subjects view pilots or season finales for current shows in theaters. Meters record their
Why Islam I think Islam is the most misunderstood religion in the world. Not just by non-muslims, but by Muslims as well. Mainly, non-muslims information on Islam is based on what they see on television
EXECUTIVE MASTER IN CORPORATE COMMUNICATION Increasing corporate value in today s complex digital world through reputation management and communication with stakeholders. COURSE DESCRIPTION At a Glance
1 Sample Student Essay and Prompt Directions for applicant: Imagine that you are teaching a class in academic writing for first-year college students. In your class, drafts are not graded. Instead, you
SIMULATION GAMES ARE POWERFUL PLAYFUL INTERVENTIONS. WE COME ACROSS SIMULATIONS OFTEN, IN ALL FORMS AND SHAPES. IVO WENZLER, SENIOR EXECUTIVE (PARTNER) AT ACCENTURE AND ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR AT THE DELFT
What Is Gender at Work s Approach to Gender Equality and Institutional Change? Our work is underpinned by a commitment to transform institutions. We posit a conceptual framework that connects rights with
Digital Culture & Education (DCE) Publication details, including instructions for authors http://www.digitalcultureandeducation.com/ Book review of Nick Montfort and Ian Bogost (2009). Racing the Beam:
Game Design From Concepts To Implementation Game Structure Different (?) games Different (?) games They are all different, but they are all games! hence which are the common traits? Formal el.: 1. Players
RETHINKING DIGITAL SELLING BEST PRACTICES FOR MAXIMIZING RESULTS AND ROI Guiding Principles For Rethinking Your Digital Selling Strategy It s been nearly four years since reps started using tablet-based
Cartooning and Animation Middle School Course Title Cartooning and Animation MS Course Abbreviation CART/ANIM MS Course Code Number 200603 Special Notes General Art is a prerequisite, or department permission
What people who attend Linton Sellen s Leadership Training have to say: Excellent course, couldn t have been better. Training content and knowledge and delivery are exceptional. I've been to many management
1.2 Reading Informational Text Students read, understand, and respond to informational text with emphasis on comprehension, making connections among ideas and between texts with focus on textual evidence.
0 P a g e BECAUSE YOUR REPUTATION IS AT RISK! YOUR REPUTATION IS AT RISK! REPUTATION MANAGEMENT 727 479-2991 1 P a g e Table of Contents Online Reputation Management... 2 What is online reputation management?...
Game Controllers: A Critical Discussion of Input Devices in Game Design Lindsay Johnson Miami University email@example.com Abstract Game design is a process with a focus primarily on creating an engaging
Course Overview Video Games and Education Syllabus MSTU 4039.001 Jessica Hammer This course is called Video Games in Education, taught by Jessica Hammer. We will meet every Monday from 3pm until 4:40pm.
FORM ACMA B13 Criteria for a Children s Program The following information focuses on the criteria of suitability for children (CTS 6) against which the (ACMA) assesses applications for C (Children s) and
SEO Guide for Front Page Ranking Introduction This guide is created based on our own approved strategies that has brought front page ranking for our different websites. We hereby announce that there are
Self-Screening for Aspiring Traders A.E. Brockwell June 8, 2010 If you are reading this, it is because you are considering taking up trading as a professional or semi-professional activity. That is, you
1 Introduction Project 2: Character Animation Due Date: Friday, March 10th, 11:59 PM The technique of motion capture, or using the recorded movements of a live actor to drive a virtual character, has recently
Testing, What is it Good For? Absolutely Everything! An overview of software testing and why it s an essential step in building a good product Beth Schechner Elementool The content of this ebook is provided
Security challenges for internet technologies on mobile devices - Geir Olsen [firstname.lastname@example.org], Senior Program Manager for Security Windows Mobile, Microsoft Corp. - Anil Dhawan [email@example.com],
1 Are important and authentic Teachers members of our family? By Carlo Ricci Abstract In this paper I would like to share an episode that happened in one of my graduate classes where we expanded the definition
B2C Marketing Automation Action Plan 10 Steps to Help You Make the Move from Outdated Email Marketing to Advanced Marketing Automation Introduction B2C marketing executives are increasingly becoming more
1. Target Keyword: Digital publishing Page Title: Extend your Mobile Reach with ASO for Apps There are hundreds of millions of active mobile app users currently. Together they've downloaded over 50 billion
LOVE AND PASSION- THE ULTIMATE RELATIONSHIP PROGRAM COMPANION WORKBOOK No matter how much we love our children, no matter how close we are to our Creator, no matter how important our work is, ultimately,
Best Hand Wins: How Poker Is Governed by Chance Vincent Berthet During the last several years, poker has grown in popularity so much that some might even say it s become a social phenomenon. Whereas poker
ON EXTERNAL OBJECTS By Immanuel Kant From Critique of Pure Reason (1781) General Observations on The Transcendental Aesthetic To avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to explain, as clearly as possible,
Intro to Graphic Design Essential Questions Unit 1: Traditional Tools Why is it important to sketch your ideas away from the computer instead of sketching on the computer and believing your solution is
Page 1 of 16 Business Plan Spirit Guardian & The Spiritguardian TM Project The Spiritguardian TM Online Project Spiritguardian1@yahoo.com Page 2 of 16 I. Table of Contents Contents I. Table of Contents...
The Complete Project Manager Building the Right Set of Skills for Greater Project Success Randall L. Englund Englund Project Management Consultancy Page # 1 The Complete Project Manager Page # 2 We are
Basics of Web Design, introduction to web site design and web page design skills This section provides basic skills for web site design and designing good usable web pages, through insight insight into
User Stories Applied for Agile Software Development Mike Cohn Boston San Francisco New York Toronto Montreal London Munich Paris Madrid Capetown Sydney Tokyo Singapore Mexico City Chapter 2 Writing Stories
TOP 12 MISTAKES THAT SALESPEOPLE MAKE A Special Report Our Business Is Improving Yours 1457 North US Highway 1, Suite 24 Ormond Beach, FL 32174 Tel: 386-898-0007 Int l: 800-403-9379 Fax: 386-898-0004 www.learningoutsourcegroup.com
Cooper provides training in all aspects of our unique User Experience Design methodology through our Cooper U educational program. Every Cooper U class is taught by our senior designers to ensure you benefit
Spring 2012 Influencing Your Audience 6 Tactics to Make Your Messages More Persuasive By Ken O Quinn Author of: Perfect Phrases for Business Letters and Founder of WritingWithClarity.com Influencing Your
Television Drama Genre codes and conventions Audience pleasures and responses Television drama is one of the longest running and most popular of television genres, mainly because it cuts across a range
Dramatic & Stylistic Features of An Inspector Calls Well-made play In many respects, An Inspector Calls fulfils the criteria of the well-made play. The well-made play was invented by Eugene Scribe (1791-1861).