Understanding the Brazilian Economic Growth Regime: A Kaleckian Approach. Bruno Thiago Tomio FAE Blumenau. Resumo


 Denis Stewart
 1 years ago
 Views:
Transcription
1 Underanding he Brazilian Economic Growh Regime: A Kaleckian Approach Bruno Thiago Tomio FAE Blumenau Reumo Denro da economia pókeyneiana, uma da erene principai é formada por auore que conam com o eudo e ideia elaborada pelo economia polonê Michal Kalecki. A abordagem Kaleckiana é caracerizada por preocupaçõe com crecimeno econômico e diribuição de renda, enre oura caraceríica meno imporane para o preene eudo. O modelo Kaleckiano báico de diribuição e crecimeno ó permie economia wageled. Baeado no eudo de Bhaduri e Marglin (1990), modelo de crecimeno Kaleckiano aprimorado foram eimado para diero paíe deenolido e algun em deenolimeno. Permiindo não omene regime wageled ma, da mema forma, regime profiled, noo aanço dee modelo reularam na aual dicuão obre reulado empírico. Io conraa o coneno na frene eórica, como apona Laoie (2011). Uando a écnica de equação única, ee arigo demonra que o regime de crecimeno econômico no Brail é wageled, domeicamene e como uma economia abera. Políica pública êm ido ane influenciada foremene pela economia orodoxa, com um foco no regime de mea de inflação. Io êm falhado em proer um crecimeno econômico eáel, egualiário e uenáel. Políica que ejam mai realia ão precia para irar o Brail dea iuação, io é, um regime de crecimeno é neceário. The auhor i graeful o Eckhard Hein and Treor Ean for commening on an earlier erion of hi paper. The uual diclaimer i alo applied here; he ole reponible for any remaining miake i he auhor. 1
2 Abrac ihin pokeyneian economic, one of he main rand i compoed by auhor ha rely on he udie and idea elaboraed by he polih economi Michal Kalecki. The Kaleckian approach i characerized by concern oer economic growh and income diribuion, among oher characeriic le imporan for he preen udy. The Kaleckian canonical model of diribuion and growh only allow for wageled economie. Baed on he udy of Bhaduri and Marglin (1990), improed Kaleckian growh model hae been eimaed for eeral deeloped counrie and a few deeloping counrie. By allowing no only wageled regime bu a well profiled regime, newer deelopmen of hi model hae reuled in an ongoing dicuion of he empirical reul. Thi conra he conenu on he heoreical fron, a poined ou by Laoie (2011). Uing a ingleequaion echnique, hi aricle how ha he economic growh regime in Brazil i found o be wageled, domeically and a an open economy. Policymaking ha raher been rongly influenced by orhodox economic, wih a focu on he inflaionargeing regime. Thi ha failed o proide a able, equiable, and uainable economic growh. Policie ha are more realiic are needed o ge Brazil ou of hi iuaion, i.e. an economic growh regime i needed. 1. Inroducion The ile of hi paper clearly ell much abou i. The aim i o earch for a deep underanding of he Brazilian growh regime from a Kaleckian perpecie. Howeer, no ju hi main goal i a he cope, oher goal are par of hi endeaor oo. The idea for hi reearch ared appearing during he Macroeconomic and Growh and Diribuion coure augh by Prof. Dr. Eckhard Hein. Indeed, hee coure hae demonraed ha here i a grea lieraure on empirical analyi of he economic growh regime from a pokeyneian perpecie for deeloped counrie, bu no for deeloping counrie. Conference and he Berlin Summer School promoed by he Reearch Nework Macroeconomic and Macroeconomic Policie (FMM) helped o reinforce hi idea. The heoreical Kaleckian growh and diribuion model, which omeime i called a neokaleckian oo, ha reached a conenu on i elaboraion, neerhele, empirical udie hae no arried a hi age ye (Laoie, 2011, p. 24). Lack of udie on Brazil and an ongoing debae hae been he main moiaion for hi reearch. The Kaleckian approach o growh and diribuion i one of he main rand of Po Keyneianim (Laoie, 2011, p. 19). Thi branch or approach derie from he economic hinking of Michal Kalecki, an economi from Polland, who wa alo an economerician and inpired many early economeric udie on Keyneian heory (Laoie, 2009, p. 5). Hi heory make a naural liaion beween Marx and Keyne, and alo beween he economi of boh rand (Sardoni, 2011, p.118). An eenial feaure of he PoKeyneian chool of hough i ha he economy i demandled, i.e. upply merely adap o demand (Laoie, 2009, p. 15). Thi i a he core of Kalecki and Keyne heorie of effecie demand, which are ery imilar. Po Keyneianim ha anoher key characeriic ha i hiorical and dynamic ime, a well a he feaure belonging o heerodox economic (Laoie, 2009, p. 15). 1 Kaleckian growh heory accoun for hee feaure and, according o Laoie (2009, p. 24) goe ery well wih economeric, ince Kalecki himelf wa an economerician. 1 See Chaper 1 of Laoie book (2009) for an indeph explanaion. 2
3 The following chaper are diided a follow. Chaper 2 i keen o preen he baic Kaleckian diribuion and growh model a well a he Bhaduri and Marglin conribuion (1990) o hi model and i open economy deriaion. Nex, in he hird Chaper, he empirical analyi, i.e. economeric udy, i elaboraed. Policy implicaion of he reul found in he empirical model and he idea of he Kaleckian approach are pu forward in he fourh chaper. Laly, concluding remark are done in he final chaper. 2. Kaleckian diribuion and growh model According o Laoie (2011, p. 24), here i a conenu on he heoreical framework of Kaleckian growh and diribuion model, alhough no on empirical ground. Thi ecion ar wih he demonraion of a canonical Kaleckian model, ha i, a baic model. Afer hi inroducion o he model, a ecion i deoed o he conribuion of Bhaduri and Marglin (1990) o he Kaleckian approach; hi aricle i ofen referred o a he eminal paper (Hein and Vogel, 2008), which i reponible for he recen upurge of empirical udie wihin hi opic. The chaper conclude wih an aemen of he open economy model. ha i aimed here i o build on hi heoreical framework an empirical analyi o Brazil. 2.1 Canonical model I eem ha he fir model uing he Kaleckian approach o growh heory wa deeloped by del Mone (1975) in an aricle wrien in Ialian. Howeer, he main earlier baic erion of hi model are Rowhorn (1981) and Du (1984) (Du, 2012). The model deeloped by he laer i ued o exrac he canonical model for hi udy; wha follow i all baed on Du (1984) 2, and any ue of differen ource i going o be iible. Firly, a uual, ome aumpion are e o demonrae he modu operandi of he Kaleckian approach, and hen iue relaed o diribuion and growh are illuraed. For implificaion, only one indurial good i produced in he economy. In hi proce, capial and labor are fairly he ame and are he unique facor of producion. I i alo aumed ha, ia a Leonief producion funcion, here are conan reurn of cale and capial and laboroupu raio are fixed (boh raio are denoed and l, repeciely). In a paricular way, hee fixed coefficien migh be inerpreed a he exiing rigidiie in echnology for facor ubiuion, ha i, in pecial for ome underdeeloped economie, he choice of echnique are eleced eparaely of price. In he modeled economy, here i no problem of lack of worker ince here i eiher unemployed people or people may be employed ju o urial in a ecor ha doe no inerac wih he indurial ecor. Money wage i fixed, accouning a lea an amoun for ubience, and he labor upply i perfecly elaic. The implicaion of he laer i ha he demand for labor deermine he acual leel of employmen of i (L), in order ha L ly (1) where Y i oupu. A he ock of capial a a cerain period i he reul of pa inemen, and he exience of exce capaciy of capial i aumed in hi model, he acual employmen of capial (K) i gien by K Y (2) 2 I i relean o noice ha Du (1984) baed hi model o fi he characeriic of hi home counry, India (underdeeloped counry), which ui well he Brazilian cae oo. 3
4 Equaliy in equaion (2) would mean ha he economy i a he full capaciy leel of oupu. For he pricing equaion, i i conidered oligopoliic compeiion, in which he price leel (p) i e by applying a markup (m) 3 on uni prime co (wl), where w i he fixed money wage. Therefore, we hae p ( 1 m) wl (3) The markup i aumed conan a a cerain poin of ime and reflec he degree of monopoly power, which, following Du (1987), relae o he rae of concenraion of he indurial ecor and oher iue relaed o he organizaion of indurie. There are wo aumpion incorporaed o he markup pricing equaion. The fir refer o priceeing profile of firm in hi oligopoliic marke. Secondly, firm end o ignore capial co, hey raher e heir price relying on a markup oer prime co; hi i explained by he aumpion of exce capaciy in he indurial ecor. Coninuing wih he model, equaion (3) implie he equaion for he rae of profi (r): r mwly/pk (4) Two group are accouned in he model framework: worker and capiali. The former group pend all hey receie a wage (Kalecki, 1937). The laer, inead, conume and ae a conan par of heir income. Therefore, he equaion for oal conumpion demand in conenu wih he preened aumpion i hown a pc wl ( 1 ) rpk (5) where i he porion capiali ae. Een hough firm are managed by capiali, heir inemen and conumpion deciion are independenly conidered in hi baic model. Inemen (I) depend on he rae of profi and capaciy uilizaion 4, which may be wrien a I/K a br cu (6) where a, b and c are poiie conan. The fir one (a) i he wellknown parameer for Keyne animal piri 5. A for he role of he rae of profi and he hird conan (c) enering equaion (6), when firm expec a higher profi hey are more willingly o ine. Neerhele, he model aume expeced and curren aerage rae of profi o be equal. A far a he econd one i concerned, here i a poiie relaion beween u (Y/K), which i he capaciy uilizaion meaured a a raio of curren oupu o poenial full capaciy oupu, and inemen. Thi econd erm may be inegraed o he fir or hird erm if i i argued ha deired capaciy uilizaion i aken a a conan or a funcion of he rae of profi. Thi i rue if firm conider ariaion in demand o eablih heir deired rae of capaciy uilizaion. Thu, when he curren u i aboe he deired leel, firm will ine o enlarge heir capial ock, and iceera i rue. Laly, he drier of change in oupu i aggregae demand, and he equilibrium in he modeled economy i gien a Y C I (7) 3 Some noaion may differ lighly from he ource (Du, 1984) for an eaier comprehenion. 4 According o Du (2011b, p. 141), hi model preened in Du (1984) along wih he one preened in Rowhorn (1981) exclude lagged inemen, o curren and aimed inemen are alway he ame. The ame model imply ha here i diincion beween hor and longrun. 5 Michal Kalecki and Joan Robinon, one of hi follower, were rong criic of Keyne General Theory (Keyne, 1936). A main diagreemen of boh i found on heir opinion abou he animal piri; albei agreeing wih lo of Kalecki argumen, Robinon ood a a upporer of i, whil he former wa hi own man (Harcour and Krieler, 2011, p. 160). 4
5 ih he inuiion o how how hi equilibrium i achieed, here i nohing beer han a figure o faciliae he explanaion. Figure 1 i almo he ame a he one preened by Du (1984); he erion preened here applie differen noaion and doe no include any demonraion of change in parameer. A a cerain poin of ime, he equilibrium i hown by hi figure, conidering boh markup and capial ock a gien: Figure 1. Modeled economy in horrun equilibrium Source: Adaped from Fig. 1 in Du (1984). There are four main line hown in hree quadran: in he upper righ, AN and OM; in he lower righ, OR; and, lower lef, OP. From (4) and (3), he poiie relaion beween he rae of profi and oupu gie r m / 1 mu (8) ih a gien markup and capial (K), a r rie, oupu alo increae (boh are poiiely relaed). Thi relaion i hown wih he line ON in he lower righ quadran. Moing clockwie, in he lower lef quadran, equaion (1) i ploed (line OP). Moreoer, by ubiuing (8) in (6), I/K become a funcion of r and gie he line AN: I/K a b c1 m /mr (9) which aer ha I ha woided effec: i i affeced firly by a rie in r, which affec i direcly, and econdly, ia an implied increae in he capaciy uilizaion rae. In he ame quadran a AN, he line OM demonrae real aing (S) diided by capial (K) a a funcion of he rae of profi (r) and reul from (5), producing S/K r (10) Thu, he equilibrium require ha I/K S/K g (11) 5
6 which derie from (7) muliplied by p, changing for p from (3) and pc from (5), and employing (1) and (4). The poin of inerecion of he line AN and OM gie hi equilibrium poin, which correpond o he alue I 1 /K or S 1 /K, r 1, Y 1 and L 1. Price (p) i independenly deermined from hi, and wih w gien, i imply come from (3). The equilibrium alue for he ariable r, Y and I/K are gien by r a/ b c 1 m /m (12) m /m a/ b c Y 1 1 m /mk (13) b c m /ma/ b c I/K a 1 1 m /m (14) Two characeriic mu peri o hold he equilibrium a rue: on he one hand, line AN and OM inerecion mu occur in he poiie quadran o he equilibrium exi, and on he oher, AN mu be flaer han OM o gie abiliy i. The wo fulfill hee condiion when a 0 (15) m/ m b c a 1 (16) which enure ha here i exce capaciy in he model. Condiion in (16) implie ha he reacion of aing o he deciion ariable hould be exceed, or equal o, he reponiene of inemen. Finally, regarding income and diribuion wihin hi model, he implicaion for each one of boh clae, capiali and worker, are conidered. A for he labor hare (or wage hare), wl/pq, a rie in ω improe income diribuion. Plugging in (1) and (3), he labor hare become 1/ (1 m) (17) Then i i clear ha income diribuion in he baic model i deermined uniquely by he markup; a decreae in m lead o an improemen in income diribuion. For he oher half of he opic, growh rae (g) may be imply defined a he rae of increae in capial ock, ince depreciaion of capial i no conidered in he model. Thu, hi implie g I/K (18) From equaion (8) and wih a gien m, i can be noed ha he rae of increae of Y and K are he ame, meaning ha g meaure a well he rae of change in oal oupu. Since ( I/K )/ m 0, hen g/ m 0 hold oo. Moreoer, following Du (2011a, pp. 667), here are hree main feaure of hi baic model ha mu be noed. Fir, by he increae of animal piri (alo known a auonomou demand), he line AN hif upward, which lead o higher equilibrium alue of g, r and u 6, and wih no change in real wage. Second, a higher aing rae of capiali () creae wha i known by he paradox of hrif (Keyne, 1936), ery probably becaue of he meaning of hi word (ha i, pruden ue of money and good). Thi paradox implie a roaion in he line OM, which yield maller equilibrium alue for he growh rae of he economy (g), rae of profi (r) and he rae of capaciy uilizaion (u). The hird feaure i called he paradox of co (Rowhorn, 1981): by reducing he markup (m), a higher real wage i achieed, wih a higher wage hare and a lower profi hare 7. From equaion (8) and wih a gien 6 here u i equal o Y/K and implying a new equaion, when K diide boh ide in equaion (13): m /m a/ b c u 1 1 m /m. 7 The profi hare (π) i equal o one minu he wage hare. 6
7 rae of profi, a higher capaciy uilizaion i implied by he reducion in m, which implie a well an upward hif in AN. hen hi line goe up, a higher g and r are achieed. Finally, increae in co lead o higher rae of growh and profi. Neerhele, noe ha hi only hold for he whole economy, no for a ingle firm (Laoie, 2009, p. 119). 2.2 Bhaduri and Marglin conribuion From Bhaduri and Marglin paper (1990), many empirical udie hae appeared due o he allowance of no only wageled growh, which i he only oucome of he canonical model, bu alo profiled growh. In addiion, here i a widepread ariey of economeric and empirical reearch on hi Kaleckian approach becaue Kalecki himelf wa an economerician, making he model more uiable o look for empirical eidence (Laoie, 2009, p. 24). One of he main change of in hi eminal paper relie on a new inemen funcion, which i deermined by animal piri, capaciy uilizaion and he profi hare (inead of he rae of profi). Therefore, he new equaion i gien by I/K a bu c (19) Ju noe ha he rae of profi i deermined by he profi hare, he capaciy uilizaion and he capialoupu raio ( r u / ) (Hein and Vogel, 2008). Since hi model i a deriaion from he baic model, he preiou analyi made for he canonical remain almo unchanged. Excep for ome iue ha are going o be preened on he following. Firly, here are new equilibrium (*) alue for g and u, which can be wrien a * a c u π (20) b π ( a c ) * * g (21) π b where σ i he aing rae (preiouly hown in equaion (10)). Fir of all, he erm a in equaion (20) doe no need necearily o be poiie (>0), in comparion wih he baic model, in which i wa a main condiion for abiliy. Bu he numeraor ill need o be poiie, herefore, if a happen o be negaie he oher erm (cπ) ha o greaer han i o mainain a poiie numeraor. Thi i implied by he abiliy condiion of hi model, ha i, he lope of he σ need o exceed he lope of g. 8 Here come ino play maybe he mo imporan oucome of hi model, i.e. differen ype of demand and growh regime. Howeer, hi reearch only focue on he laer. To how he differen concep, le u ar by differeniaing boh equaion (20) and (21) wih repec o he profi hare, repeciely: 1 cb a u 2 (22) π b 8 1 g 1 If u, hen he abiliy condiion implie ha 0 b 0. I i beyond he cope of hi u u reearch o go ino deph in he dicuion of abiliy iue (for hi, ee Hein e al., 2011). 7
8 1 cb a g b c 2 (23) π b Thu, able 1 how he implicaion of hi model wih regard o differen ype of demand and growh regime. Table 1. Diinc concep of he effec on aggregae demand (u) and growh rae (g) Concep Verbal definiion Equaion ageled aggregae demand Capaciy uilizaion and profi hare u (agnaionim) are inerely relaed 0 Profiled aggregae demand Capaciy uilizaion and profi hare u (exhilaraionim) are poiiely relaed 0 Capial accumulaion rae or he g ageled growh growh rae and profi hare are 0 inerely relaed Capial accumulaion rae or he g Profiled growh growh rae and profi hare are 0 poiiely relaed Source: Adaped from Table 8.1 in Blecker (2002, p. 134). The able ill leae aide ha for he aggregae demand concep here i he diincion beween cooperaie and conflicie iuaion. More on how he reearch i conduced o accoun he claificaion of he growh regime in Brazil i going o be preened in he end of hi chaper, and furhermore, on he empirical par wih he eimaion raegy. 2.3 Open economy model The baic model and he new inemen funcion deried from he conribuion of Bhaduri and Marglin (1990) hae already been demonraed. In order o fulfill he explanaion of he heoreical model in order o carry i o he empirical analyi, he remaining miing par i o expand he model o capure foreign aciiy. To achiee o, he following i baed on he heoreical model hown in Hein and Vogel (2009). Fir of all, i i aumed a exogenou ariable: he price of foreign good, he nominal exchange rae, and he rae of expeced and foreign profi. Nex, he good marke equilibrium i going o incorporae expor and impor (he difference beween he former and he laer gie he ne expor). Therefore, planned aing (S) i equal o ne inemen (I) and ne expor (NX): S I X M I NX (24) hen equaion (24) i normalized by he real capial ock (K), i become quie imilar o equaion (11) bu wih differen noaion and he addiion of ne expor. g (25) where he good marke equilibrium i gien by he aing rae (σ = S/K), he accumulaion rae (g = I/K) and he ne expor rae (η = NX/K). Inead of ju aing ou of profi (preiouly capiali aing, ), worker aing ( ) are alo included. The following equaion i obained when conidering: [I] he profi hare i relaed o domeic demand, i.e. profi plu wage ( Π / Π Π / Y ), [II] he relaion beween oupu and poenial oupu i he 8
9 9 capaciy uilizaion (u = Y/Y P ), and [III] capialpoenial oupu raio a he capial ock diided by poenial oupu ( = K/Y P ). 9 u K Π Y Π K ) ( (26) Coninuing wih he remaining componen of equaion (24), he inemen funcion i he one preiouly hown, or raher, i i equaion (19). The ne expor rae i negaiely affeced by domeic demand and poiiely influenced by inernaional compeiiene, which i, in hi cae, he real exchange rae (e r ) 10 : u ψe r (27) The aing rae mu repond more elaically o change in capaciy uilizaion, he endogenou ariable, han he rae of accumulaion and he ne expor rae ogeher, in order ha abiliy of he good marke equilibrium hold in he model. Thi may be wrien a b u u g u 1 0 (28) Only on hee equilibrium, able good marke equilibrium and change in diribuion may be conidered. Conequenly, new equilibrium alue for he growh rae, g, and capaciy uilizaion, u, are gien a b e c a u r 1 * (29) c b e c a b a g r 1 * (30) Accordingly, capaciy uilizaion gie he equilibrium wih he gien producie capaciie and capial accumulaion how he expanion of poenial oupu or producie capaciie. hen differeniaed wih repec o he profi hare, boh equaion (29) and (30) yield, repeciely, b e u c u r 1 / / (31) b e b bu c c g r 1 / / / / (32) The repone of he capaciy uilizaion and accumulaion rae o change in he profi hare can be eparaely decribed becaue here i no an abolue effec in boh. For equaion (31), when profi are priileged by rediribuion, he numeraor how hree main effec. The fir affec i poiiely by he inemen demand (c), he econd i a negaie effec by mean of he conumpion demand [ u / ], and, laly, he nex effec relie on he ne expor, 9 Variable u and differ lighly from par 2.1 and 2.2, neerhele, a longer explanaion would how ha hey are he ame and hee change do no modify he main concluion. 10 Since he real exchange rae i no added o he empirical analyi of he curren udy, furher analyi of i i no pu forward in hi reearch. Alhough i i ued by Araújo e al. (2011) o analyze economic growh regime in Brazil, here i ill ambiguiy on how he exchange rae affec he profi hare (ee Hein and Vogel, 2008).
10 bu i i unknown in which direcion i could ake [ e / r ] 11. Regarding equaion (32), ery imilar iuaion o he one ju preened i found. In brief, hree effec on i numeraor: a poiie effec ia higher uni profi [ c / ], an indirec negaie or poiie effec ia c / bu / ] and anoher indirec capaciy uilizaion and conumpion demand [ poiie or negaie effec hrough ne expor [ b / ]. In a imple way, hi i he analyi of he equilibrium alue, and I hall gie a beer idea of wha hi reearch i aiming. In PoKeyneian economic, he economy i demanddeermined. Thi empirical aemen of he growh regime in Brazil coni in analyzing he reul of a change in diribuion on conumpion, inemen and ne expor (aggregae demand componen), and a a reul on GDP growh. ihou giing deeper deail, becaue hi i preened nex on chaper 4, he main equaion for hi udy i Y Y C Y I Y NX Y (33) Ju o gie a broad idea, according o hi equaion, he economic growh regime i: Y Y Y Y wageled, if 0, or, profiled, if 0. The eimaion raegy of how o find if Brazilian economic growh i wage or profiled i preened in deail in he chaper 4. Neerhele, before ha he lieraure reiew confine he udie ha hae analyzed Brazil uing imilar mehod. 3. Lieraure reiew I eem ha he fir aemp o deermine a growh regime uing Bhaduri and Marglin approach (1990) i a paper by Bowle and Boyer (1995), in which hey apply he ingle equaion mehod (Hein and Vogel, 2009). Indeed, ince hen, here ha been an increae in he number of udie eing empirically he exience of differen ype of growh regime for many deeloped counrie 12 and only a few deeloping counrie. The mo plauible explanaion for hi dicrepancy i daa aailabiliy. hile for deeloped counrie daa for hi kind of udy i widely aailable, accouning for greaer period of ime, which i required for nonpuriou imeerie economeric, here i grea lack of enough and official daa for almo all deeloping counrie. Sill, reearcher find a way o gaher good and reliable daa o look for he growh regime of deeloping counrie. A for Brazil, o my knowledge, here a lea hree main paper/udie: Bruno (2003), Araújo e al. (2011), Onaran and Galani (2011). Thi lieraure reiew coni in examining he reul and he economeric rucure/mehod of hee udie. Thee hree paper aim o how he ineracion beween diribuion, aggregae demand and accumulaion wih economeric ool. All earch anwering he queion of wheher he demandled growh regime in Brazil i wageled or profiled, and hey all ue ingle equaion model. The fir udy examined here, and maybe he fir aemp o claify economerically he growh regime in Brazil, i Bruno (2003). The auhor propoe an analyi baed no only on economeric eidence, bu alo on macroeconomic daa, which he elaborae by himelf uing daa upplied by official Brazilian ource. Depie he fac ha he paper doe no gie any e r 11 See Hein and Vogel (2008) for more deail on he indeerminae effec of he hird effec. 12 For a recen lieraure reiew for deeloped economie, uing ingle equaion model, check Hein and Vogel (2008). 10
11 informaion on he economeric mehod, i only how he final reul, i i a pioneer udy. Neerhele, i lack of robune in i reul oo becaue he auhor elaboraed he regreion wih few oberaion (le han 20 in one cae, in he period from ). By diiding i period ino hree, he main reul may be ummarized a follow: [I] from 1945 o 1974, wageled growh (reul obained wihou any economeric eimaion), [II] from 1970 o 1990, profiled growh, and, [III] from 1991 o 2001, wageled growh. The finding accomplihed by he auhor are ummarized in Table 2, joinly wih a ummary of he main finding by he oher wo paper. Bruno (2003) and Araújo e al. (2011) hae almo idenical heoreical model and eimaion raegy, maybe becaue he former auhor i a coauhor of he laer. Apparenly, he laer how more robune in heir economeric model, ha i o ay, a lea i preen a ignifican number of oberaion (he period i , bu wih quarerly daa, inead of annually daa a preened by he former). hile conidering a cloed economy, wageled growh i found for Brazil, howeer, when he model incorporae an open economy body, accumulaion regime i profiled. Thi paper ha alo problem wih ranparency; i i no poible o idenify he mehod ued o eimae he equaion, or furher informaion abou i. In Onaran and Galani (2011), i i ery explici he raegy boh applied o heir ingle equaion approach. Errorcorrecion model (ECM) or eimaion in fir difference are ued, in order o make heir reul more robu. In addiion, lag are added, bu when hey urned o be inignifican, hey were excluded. I need o be menioned ha hey alo encounered problem while gahering daa. Alike he oher wo paper aeed aboe, all funcion are almo he ame, bu he ne expor funcion. The laer accoun for uni labor co and foreign and domeic good price; i i called he epwie approach 13. Laly, i eem ha he reul uffer from inufficien degree of freedom, maybe inalidaing or weakening he reul. Table 2. Oeriew of empirical udie on diribuion and growh in Brazil Auhor Funcion Growh regime Bruno (2003) Araújo e al. (2011) Onaran and Galani (2011) Saing: Inemen: Ne expor: Saing: Inemen: Ne expor: Conumpion: Inemen: Ne expor: S = f(π, ) I/K = f(r 1, u 1 ) NX = f(π 1, u 1, e 1 ) S = f(π, ) I/K = f(r 1, u 1 ) NX = f(π 1, u 1, e 1 ) S = f(π, ) I/K = f(y, π) NX epwie 12 Profiled ( ) ageled ( ) ageled (cloed ec.) Profiled (open ec.) [ ] * ageled (cloed ec.) Profiled (open ec.) [ ] * Source: Auhor own elaboraion. Noe: Column named Funcion how he ariable ha were ued o reach he final claificaion. * For Araújo e al. (2011), quarerly daa, and for Onaran and Galani (2011), annual. Finally, depie imilar reul for Araújo e al. (2011) and Onaran and Galani (2011), Bruno (2003) obained differen reul for he recen year (from 1991 o 2001). A lea if differ from he laer becaue hey apply ery imilar period, bu wih lighly differen equaion. In Bruno (2003), only he rae of profi i aiically ignifican for hi period, excluding he aing and ne expor funcion. I i quie difficul o deal wih he comparion of hee udie wihou geing ino he deail of he robune of heir eimaion. If hi reearch were o conider only eimaion wih enough degree of freedom in he regreion, no much 13 More deail abou hi approach can be found in Sockhammer e al. (2009). 11
12 would be lef o conider. Nonehele, hi udy conider hem alid, and, a a reul, hey are going o be compared wih he finding in he nex chaper. Ju noe ha he hree are udie only publihed on conference and een, o he be of my knowledge. Therefore, hey are conidered work in progre, bu indeed hae conribued o expand he debae of differen demandled growh regime in deeloping counrie. Thu, hi reearch aim i o ry o bring more fuel o hi debae, epecially, and almo uniquely, for he Brazilian cae. In he nex chaper, an exploraion of he empirical analyi employed for Brazil in hi udy i preened. 4. Empirical analyi for Brazil In hi chaper, he core of hi reearch i locaed. No ha he oher chaper are le imporan, on he conrary, hey are ery imporan oo becaue wihou hem here would be no empirical model or implicaion of he finding here. I i ju ha here lie he ronge conribuion o he debae abou differen growh regime in a PoKeyneian (Kaleckian) approach, and, wih pecial imporance, an analyi baed on a deeloping counry, which i quie rare in he academic lieraure of hi opic. There are wo main ecion in hi chaper. The goal of he fir one i o deail he mehod applied in hi empirical analyi. Thi i where he eimaion raegy i aeed, and economeric e, e.g. uni roo and coinegraion e, are compued. Nex, ecion 4.2 how he final eimaion of he elaboraed model for each funcion of he aggregae demand and conclude wih he ype of demandled growh regime found for Brazil. Before coninuing o he nex ecion, Table 3 diplay full informaion abou he daa gahered for hi reearch, which accoun for he period Table 3. Variable noaion, decripion, and ource Noaion Decripion Source Y GDP, real IPEA (2012) C Final conumpion, real IPEA (2012) I Inemen, real IPEA (2012) NX Ne expor, real (equal o Expor minu Impor) IPEA (2012) π Profi hare Marquei (2011) age Marquei (2011) Π Profi Marquei (2011) Y f Foreign GDP, real (equal o US GDP) BEA (2012) Noe: C, I and NX were obained a a hare of GDP. Then, hee ariable were conered o real ariable by muliplying hem by Y. The profi hare (π) i equal o one (1) minu he wage hare. I i no ye publihed, bu i wa obained direcly from he auhor (Marquei, 2011). age () were calculaed by imply muliplying Y by he wage hare; profi (Π) were calculaed a minu Y. Finally, Y f i equal o he GDP of he bigge rade parner for Brazil, which i, in hi cae, he US. Due o daa aailabiliy, he GDP of he European Union wa no added o i, hi would imply a ignifican lo in oberaion. I need o be reed ome auxiliary informaion on he calculaion of he wage hare by Marquei (2011). The daa upplied by him i an updae of he daa found in Marquei e al. (2010). The focu of hi aricle i he profi rae, howeer, from i decompoiion i poible o obain he profi hare. More deail on he way hey calculaed and creaed hi daabae are in he Appendix of Marquei e al. (2010). In Figure 2, a imeerie plo of he ariable i preened. 12
13 Figure 2. Plo of he ariable ued in he empirical analyi, Source: Elaboraed by he auhor uing daa upplied by he ource decribed in Table 3. Noe: For all ariable alue are in Brazilian real (R$), excep for he profi hare (π), ne expor a a hare of domeic GDP, and foreign GDP (Y f ), which are, repeciely, raio and in billion of US dollar (US$). Beide he profi hare and he ne expor a a hare of GDP, all ariable how an upward rend from 1956 o In addiion, depie he uniform riing moemen of ariable Y, C and Y f, alhough wih ome maller ocillaion hroughou he period, oher ariable how more abrup break and deere furher commen. A for inemen i concerned, here wa a boom in inemen from he lae 1950 unil he beginning of he Thi wa moly due o he proce of impor ubiuion indurializaion (ISI), which fir focued on indurial good and laer on inermediae good, while deeloping a well he infrarucure in Brazil, e.g. maie public inemen in energy producion (Marquei e al., 2010; Baer, 2008, p. 385). High inflaion ranferred inemen from radiional ecor (agriculure and indury) o erice in he 1980 (Baer, 2008, p. 391). The 1980 alo accouned for he deb crii, wih ubanial drop in he amoun of domeic and foreign aing (Baer, 2008, p. 89). In he lae 1980 and he early 1990, i wa a period of hyperinflaion and increae in conumpion 13
14 pending fueled newer inemen. I i noeworhy ha due o he flow of moneary reource from he producie ecor of he economy o he domeic financial yem (i hare in he GDP more han doubled in he 1980), a harp drop in inemen occurred in he beginning of he 1990 (Baer, 2008, p. 119). Thi period of hyperinflaion affeced and agnaed profi (Π) in hi ame period. In fac, much of he analyi done for he inemen i alo applicable for he oher ariable ha how break in he upward rend. The launch of he Real Plan (Plano Real) releaed a new currency and opped he hyperinflaionary proce. A hi ime, he profi hare regained he loe caued by inflaion in he preiou period, and remain able o far, a around The ceae of high inflaion came wih a co. Becaue of he fully neoliberal agenda adoped, Brazilian economy failed o regain he dynamim (Marquei e al., 2010) demonraed in he middle of he weny cenury. In Lula goernmen (ook office in 2003), inemen and wage how a rapid increae. Srong commimen o orhodox policie, which made enrepreneur happy o coninue ineing ha foered wage, and income policie conribued o he ucce of Lula erm 14. Neerhele, hi approach of growing he pie o rediribue laer wa problemaic (ee Baer, 2008, p. 174). La bu no lea, a few word on he ne expor. In he ISI period, Brazil ended o ban impor of any good, and by doing hi, i waned o upply i domeic marke wih anyhing i needed. In hi period, expor, and inernaional rade in general, were negleced, puing he counry in a riky balanceofpaymen poiion. From he end of he 1960 unil he early year of 1980, exchange rae problem and an ouwardlooking policy, aiming a more open economy, caued maie inflow of impor (primary maerial, inermediae and capial good, ha were being forbidden by he ISI program). During he 1980, in order o eae he effec of he deb crii, expororiened policie were pu in acion; many impor rericion were alo lifed. All oer he 1990, flucuaion and defici were eemed becaue of he reopening of he economy (Baer, 2008, pp ). A boom in commodiy price, mainly drien by China growh, mark he beginning of he wenyfir cenury. The urplu ared collaping wih an increae in impored good. Finally, hee are ju commen o gie a broad idea, wihou going ino he deail of he conequence for income diribuion, on wha happened in he Brazilian economy during hee year. 15 Nex ecion carrie on wih ome deail on he mehod ha i going o be applied in he model eimaion. 4.1 Mehod Baically, he mehod followed i called he ingle equaion approach. A ery clear explanaion of he deail of hi approach can be found in he Appendix of Hein and Vogel (2009), and hi par of hi udy follow hi paper and Hein and Vogel (2008). Thi reearch follow heir explanaion o demonrae how he ype of growh regime i deried from a demandled growh and diribuion model. ihin hi line, each componen in he righ ide of equaion (33) i eimaed eparaely; laer hey are ummed up, afer calculaing he parial effec, o reach an anwer abou he claificaion of he growh regime. Thi differ from imulaion model ha accoun for poible deficiencie relaed o he fac ha in ingle equaion model he ineracion beween he demand componen are lef aide (Hein and Vogel, 2009). Neerhele, he ingle 14 Preiden Lula wa reeleced in 2006 and ayed in power unil Check Baer (2008) for a ery deailed and criical aemen of he economic hiory of Brazil. 14
15 equaion approach ha been widely ued in he lieraure, a i wa menioned in he lieraure reiew. Le u ar howing again he equaion (33) o moe on: Y Y C Y I Y NX Y (33) Following he reaon oulined earlier on he Kaleckian diribuion and growh model, he expeced ign for each componen of hi equaion are: C Y I Y NX Y Y Y 0, 0, (?)? (33a) In he end, here are wo poible reul for he growh regime, hown a Y Y Y Y I 0wage led II 0profi led (33b) Before coninuing o he final oupu of he model eimaion and he compuaion and explanaion of he parial effec for each componen, uni roo are compued o check wheher he imeerie ariable are aionary or no. The e applied i he Augmened DickeyFuller e; ince a mall number of lag were e (only 1) 16, if he e wa compued wih no lag, hence i i a DickeyFuller e. The reaon for hi i ha he ofware 17 ued e down from he maximum lag order and chooe he be reul (ee Table 4 for he reul). Logarihm are added o linearize he ariable and o obain in he reul change in percenage. Table 4. Uni roo e Leel Difference Variable Specif. Sa. Lag Sig. Specif. Sa. Lag Sig. Order log(y) c, c * I(1) log(c) c, c *** I(1) log(i) c, c *** I(1) NX/Y c * I(0) π c c *** I(1) log() c, c *** I(1) log(π) c, c ** I(1) log(y f ) c, c *** I(1) Noe: In he column Specif. (Specificaion), c and are noaion for conan and rend, repeciely. For e aiic (Sa.), ADF (Augmened DickeyFuller) e aiic are hown when one (1) lag i added, and DF (DickeyFuller) e aiic when none (0) lag i added. In Sig. (Significance), *, **, and *** and for 10%, 5% and 1% leel of aiical ignificance, correpondingly. Leel how he e applied o he ariable in leel, and Difference for ariable differeniaed one ime. The order of inegraion i diplayed in he la column. The null hypohei for he uni roo e i ha here i preence of uni roo a he null hypohei. Conequenly, by no rejecing he null hypohei, he erie i no aionary and i mu be differeniaed once o become aionary, hu eliminaing puriou regreion. The order of inegraion (I) ae how many ime he erie wa differeniaed (Brook, 2008, p. 319 and 326). The only ariable ha wa no differeniaed, and i aionary in leel, i he profi hare. For he remaining ariable, he uni roo e ay ha hee ariable become aionary in fir difference, when he null hypohei in he uni roo e i rejeced. ih aionary ariable, he regreion are no going o preen puriou reul caued by he preence of uni 16 There i no ingle rule for he lag choice (ooldridge, 2009, p. 633). 17 The compuaional ofware operaed i grel erion 1.9.6, aailable a hp://grel.ourceforge.ne/. 15
16 roo, unle hey how a longrun relaionhip. To ole hi problem, Engle and Granger (1987) propoed a e for coinegraion, which i he idea behind hi longrun moemen in harmony beween he imeerie ariable (Balagi, 2011, pp ). In order o aoid hi problem, hi e i compued and, when i he cae, an errorcorrecion model i eimaed o deal wih i Model eimaion The fir equaion o be eimaed i he conumpion funcion. Conumpion i a funcion of profi ( Π ) and wage (); ince he ariable are in logarihm, elaiciie are hown a reul. Oher repreenaion are: C f ( Π, ) (34) log C conan dlog Π dlog d 1 2 (35) where ε i he reidual of he eimaed equaion. Since he ariable are I(1), a coinegraion e wa compued o check for a poible longrun relaionhip (reul are hown in Table 5). Table 5. Coinegraion e for he conumpion funcion Te Te aiic () Criical alue (c) Reul EngleGranger No coinegraion ( > c) Noe: Criical alue for hi e are aken from Paeron (2000, p. 332). The null hypohei (H 0 ) and for no coinegraion. Then, if i larger han c, H 0 canno be rejeced. ihou coinegraion, he model hall be eimaed in fir difference, wihou implying any drawback (Table 6 diplay he reul for hi eimaion). Table 6. Regreion reul for he conumpion equaion Variable Coefficien Sandard error palue (ig.) Conan α (***) α (***) AdjuedR Daiic Addiional e Te Saiic palue Deciion Auocorrelaion No auocorrelaion hie e No homokedaiciy BreuchPagan No homokedaiciy ARCH(2) No heerokedaiciy RESET Righ pecificaion Noe: Significan wih *, **, and *** denoe 10%, 5% and 1% leel of aiical ignificance, correpondingly. All andard e performed for he regreion of he conumpion funcion poin o robu reul. Howeer, he coefficien are only howing he elaiciie. For example, α 1 how 18 Furher deail and proof of hi e and oher economeric procedure are no a he cope of hi reearch. Thi reearch obained reul by auming ha he weaker e of imeerie aumpion pu by ooldridge (2009, pp ) hold a rue. 16
17 ha if profi increae by one percenage poin, here i an increae of around 0.46% in conumpion. Similarly, he ame increae in wage would increae conumpion by 0.48%. Since hi i ju an elaiciy, e.g. 2 C C/, he parial effec mu be calculaed o obain he conribuion of conumpion in GDP growh wih repec o a change in he profi hare. Thi i done uing he equaion gien a C Y C C 1 2 (36) Π where C, Π and are he mean of he imeerie conumpion, profi and wage, repeciely. Table 7 how he calculaion gradually o reach he reul for he conumpion equaion. Table 7. Calculaion of he parial effec for he conumpion funcion C/Π C/ α 1 (C/Π) α 2 (C/) ( C/Y)/ π hen here i a one percenage poin change in he profi hare (i.e. a rediribuion from wage o profi), a reducion of 0.27% in he GDP growh conribuion of conumpion i found. Anoher remark i ha he propeniy o conume ou of wage i ignificanly higher han he propeniy o conume ou of profi, which confirm Bhaduri and Marglin conribuion (1990) (Hein and Vogel, 2008). Thi alo confirm he expecaion of he Kaleckian growh and diribuion model pu a he end of chaper 2. Onaran and Galani (2011) find a imilar reul for conumpion: I i a negaie alue bu much maller han he one find by hi reearch. Paper by Bruno (2003) and Araújo e al. (2011) may no be confroned wih he reul found now, ince hey do no calculae he parial effec. The econd equaion eimaed i he inemen funcion. Inemen i a funcion of he log of GDP, a a proxy for capaciy uilizaion (Y ) and he profi hare (π). In he ame way, a repreened in Hein and Vogel (2008), he rae of inere would hae o be included, bu hi i no poible for Brazil due o he lack of ufficien daa. Thu, fir aemp by hi reearch ued he following equaion: I f ( Y, ) (37) log I conan dlog Y d d 1 2 (38) All ariable in equaion (37) are I(1), conequenly, Table 8 how he reul for he EngleGranger coinegraion e. Table 8. Coinegraion e for he inemen funcion Te Te aiic () Criical alue (c) Reul EngleGranger No coinegraion ( > c) Noe: Check Table 5 for he deail of hi e. The e reul doe no yield a reul ha how he preence of coinegraion, ha i o ay, ariable are no moing ogeher in an upward rend. Reul of regreion baed on equaion (38) did no preen any plauible reul, een when lag of he independen and dependen ariable are added. Therefore, inead of he profi hare, hi udy changed i for he profi, a i wa already pu ino pracice by Hein and Vogel (2008, 2009) and Sockhammer e al. (2009). Thi approach may be gien a I f ( Y, Π) (39) log I conan dlog Y dlog Π d 2 1 (40) 17
18 Same a for he preiou inemen equaion, coinegraion e hae o be compued becaue he ariable are no aionary in leel, and reul are in Table 9. Table 9. Coinegraion e for he inemen funcion, ariable in equaion (39) Te Te aiic () Criical alue (c) Reul EngleGranger Coinegraed ( < c) Noe: Check Table 5 for he deail of hi e. To correc for he preence of coinegraion, an errorcorrecion model wa eimaed, according o he explanaion in Brook (2008, pp ). Unforunaely, he oucome of he regreion did no how any reul ha fi he heoreical model. Laly, an alernaie model wa eimaed, uing a he dependen ariable inemen a a raio of GDP. (I/Y) (Hein and Vogel, 2009). The final eimaed equaion ake he following form, and reul are repored in Table 10: I I 1 conan 1dlog Y 2d 3 4d 1 Y Y 1 (41) Table 10. Regreion reul for he final inemen equaion Variable Coefficien Sandard error palue (ig.) Conan β (**) β β (***) β AdjuedR Daiic Addiional e Te Saiic palue Deciion Auocorrelaion No auocorrelaion hie e No homokedaiciy BreuchPagan No homokedaiciy ARCH(4) No homokedaiciy RESET Righ pecificaion Noe: According o he RESET e, he pecificaion of he model i only adequae if a 5% leel of aiical ignificance i conidered. The dependen ariable i aionary in leel. Significan wih *, **, and *** denoe 10%, 5% and 1% leel of aiical ignificance, correpondingly I i no poible o calculae he parial effec of a change in he profi hare on he GDP growh conribuion of inemen becaue he profi hare i no aiically ignifican in he final model. Neerhele, reul how ha a one percenage poin increae in he GDP would increae he paricipaion of inemen in he GDP by 0.12%. Normally, increae in he profiabiliy of firm, meaured a he profi hare or profi, would hae a poiie effec in inemen (Hein and Vogel, 2009). Thi relaionhip i no found in hi reearch, neiher by Onaran and Galani (2011). Bruno (2003) and Araújo e al. (2011) find ignifican reul for hi equaion bu heir mehod are queionable. I eem ha due o rucural change in he Brazilian economy, ome break in he imeerie could change he reul. Anoher imporan deerminan ha migh be lacking o make he regreion work i he rae of inere. ih one of highe real inere rae in he world, enrepreneur would no ine in Brazil wihou 18
19 conidering hee co. Finally, none of boh uggeion o ole he problem in he inemen equaion wa aken in accoun here becaue here wa no enough aailable daa o do o. The ne expor funcion i he la equaion eimaed. A demonraed earlier, he main ariable (dependen) i he ne expor a a raio of GDP. Thi ariable i aionary in leel, bu he oher ariable (independen) in equaion 42 need o be differeniaed once o become aionary. Therefore, any coinegraion e i inalidaed. A hown in Hein and Vogel (2009), he ne expor are a funcion of foreign GDP 19 and he profi hare. A oulined in he heoreical model, he parial effec of a change in he profi hare on he GDP conribuion of he ne expor preen an unknown ign; on he one hand, i may be poiie, and on he oher, negaie. NX f NX 1 conan Y Y Y Y 1d log 1 2d 3d log (42) Thi equaion repreen he one ha gae he be and more plauible reul of he aemp. Among hee, regreion uing he ne expor a he dependen ariable were ried, a well a expor and impor a a raio of GDP eimaed eparaely a dependen ariable. In addiion, for he independen ariable, lagged ariable were added o achiee beer reul (hee maneuer follow he ame ource menioned earlier). In Table 11, he reul for he eimaion of he ne expor funcion are diplayed. Table 11. Regreion reul for he final nex expor equaion Variable Coefficien Sandard error palue (ig.) Conan χ (**) χ (*) χ (**) χ (***) AdjuedR Daiic Addiional e Te Saiic palue Deciion Auocorrelaion No auocorrelaion hie e No homokedaiciy BreuchPagan No heerokedaiciy ARCH(4) No heerokedaiciy RESET Righ pecificaion Noe: Een wihou preening auocorrelaion, he model wa eimaed o correc for i and heerokedaiciy o aoid any wih he addiion of one lag of he dependen ariable. Check noe on Table 6 for more deail on he procedure. The dependen ariable i aionary in leel. The reul are a expeced: [I] here i a negaie relaionhip beween ne expor and domeic GDP (lagged effec), when he laer increae by one percenage poin he former decreae by 0.13%; and [II] foreign demand i poiiely relaed wih ne expor, one percenage poin growh in he former rie he laer by 0.21%. Again, a for he conumpion funcion, all e confirm ha he reul are robu. The parial effec of he profi hare on he 19 Thi i gien by he oupu (GDP) of he bigge Brazilian rade parner. Oher regreion ried o add he GDP of he European Union and Argenina, boh on he op 3 of he bigge rade parner, bu none aemp howed reaonable reul. 19
20 growh inpu of he ne expor o GDP need o accoun for he lagged endogenou ariable, which can be obained wih hi equaion (Hein and Vogel, 2008): NX Y 2 (43) 1 4 Equaion (43) i equal o Howeer, when confroned wih he reul obained by Onaran and Galani (2011), hey find a poiie relaionhip beween ne expor and he profi hare; in hi reearch, he conrary i found. In he preened heoreical model, here i only one poible meaning for hi reul: he indirec effec of ne expor in equaion (32) i negaie (he erm i [ b e r / ]). There may alo be ome oher explanaion for hi negaie relaionhip. One explanaion for hi i ha during hi period many mulinaional companie hae inalled heir faciliie in Brazil no ju o profi from he expanding domeic marke, bu alo o obain cheap reource o expor good (Amal e al., 2009). Therefore, a an expor plaform for foreign companie, a negaie relaion beween domeic profi hare and ne expor i poible. Exchange rae oeraluaion, i.e. he Duch dieae (BreerPereira, 2010, p. 148), rapid financial liberalizaion (Caralho, 2008, p. 138), or inernaional compeiion, may be able o explain hee finding oo; a deeper analyi of hi would be neceary and i i no poible o do i a hi reearch, bu i would be a grea uggeion for fuure reearch. In concluion, wih all equaion eimaed and he parial effec aken, i i poible o claify he economic growh regime in Brazil from a Kaleckian perpecie. In Table 12, he parial effec of change in he profi hare on he GDP conribuion of conumpion, inemen and ne expor are added. Table 12. Final effec Equaion Value C ( Y ) ( Y I ) ( Y NX ) Y ( Y ) Noe: No ignifican reul wa found for he inemen equaion. From boh domeic and open economy perpecie, he demandled economic growh and conribuion model for Brazil i characerized a wageled. I i a quie rong final effec; an increae of one percenage poin in he profi hare decreae GDP by around 0.80%. Following a imilar comparion, he domeic effec of an increae of he profi hare by 1% reduce GDP by 0.27%. Thee finding conradic he reul found by Onaran and Galani (2011), in which Brazil i profiled. The reul obained by Araújo e al. (2011) for he open economy i alo conradiced, howeer, for he domeic analyi boh udie claify Brazil a wageled. For he pioneer udy of Bruno (2003), he reul are parially differen oo; on he one hand, Brazil i profiled in he period from 1970 up o 1990, neerhele, on he oher hand, Brazilian economy i wageled in a more recen period, from 1991 o In he nex chaper, policy implicaion are drawn upon hee finding. 5. Policy implicaion I i clear ha afer ucceie crie Brazil ha implemened policie o aoid inflaion a any co. Unil oday, economic policy ha a rong focu in conrolling inflaion; hi fear dae from 20
21 hyperinflaion ime. Thi approach o conrol inflaion a he co of economic growh and income diribuion ha caued imbalance in eeral macroeconomic indicaor. A heerodox aemp o conrol hi problem wa ried in 1986, wih conrol of price and wage policie, howeer, hi failed (Baer, 2008, p. 111). Inflaion canno be only economic policy e by he goernmen (BreerPereira, 2011). The orhodoxy ha ha reigned for o long in Brazil i no creaing he economic deelopmen ha i would be poible wih policie ha are more realiic. Kalecki defended ha he Sae mu hae an acie role in he economy (López G. and Aou, 2011, p. 191), and Brazil ha failed o do o, leaing he economy in he hand of he marke. Een recenly wih he elecion of he former rade union leader Preiden Lula, he hope of change in economic policie hae been defeaed by he fear (Arei e al., 2007, p. 63) of loing he uppor of financial marke and neoliberal iniuion. ha Brazil really need i an economic growh regime, no an inflaionargeing regime (Arei e al., 2007, p. 63). Bu he hope i no dead ince Brazilian are geing more job and more income in Preiden Dilma erm. Higher minimum wage and low unemploymen are a way o gie ciizen a decen life, howeer, here i ill a lo o be done o hae a real deelopmen agenda (Balar, 2011, p. 71 and 74). hen bank are geing record profi year afer year and he real ecor of he economy ruggle o cach up and preen minimal economic deelopmen (for a counry wih he ize of Brazil), omehing i wrong. Indeed, financialiaion in Brazil ha negaiely affeced nonfinancial firm inemen (Branco, 2010). Powerful financial marke and iniuion and independen cenral bank hae gien he financial ecor a main role in he economy; hi conradic Kalecki analyi where he acie role mu be done by he real ecor, wih he financial ecor being paie (Arei and Skue, 2004, p. 25). A more acie goernmen could ep in and deelop an indurial policy a well a wih an income diribuion policy o bring back he acie role of he real ecor of he economy, he producie ecor. Thi i crucial for creaing real wealh and a more dignified ociey for eery Brazilian. The empirical reul for Brazil pu hi counry in a poiion for wageled policie. Alhough Kaleckian growh and diribuion model do no leae aide key feaure of Po Keyneian economic, like fundamenal uncerainy and pahdependency, for example, a cerain fuure mu be foreeen o elaborae policie. I could be aid ha in hi ene policymaking i more ar han cience, hee model go again he idea ha unfeered marke wih no goernmen inerenion o achiee an ideal (i.e. equiable, uainable, and able) rae of growh (Du, 2010, p. 76). ageled policie would imply a growh raegy wih rediribuion of income from capiali (profi) o worker (wage). Therefore, hi ype of raegy need o regulae more he financial ecor wih prolabor diribuion a a conequence of ocial and labor marke policie (Laoie and Sockhammer, 2011). Thi would be ery complex due o he deeprooed inequaliy creaed by he paern of demand expanion from 1950 unil 1980, ha i, an expanion creaed by expene on luxury produc made feaible by an increaing income concenraion in he elie and middle cla (Oreiro e al., 2010). Afer 1980, orhodoxy preailed and could no impoe a raegy o reduce compleely hee harm. ih a crii come he be opporuniie, a people normally ay. Thu, maybe hi i he righ ime o eablih an economic growh regime wih wageled policie. 6. Concluion In he fir par (chaper 2), an oeriew and inroducion o he canonical Kaleckian growh and diribuion model wa preened. There are wo main feaure of hi model ha conradic 21
How has globalisation affected inflation dynamics in the United Kingdom?
292 Quarerly Bullein 2008 Q3 How ha globaliaion affeced inflaion dynamic in he Unied Kingdom? By Jennifer Greenlade and Sephen Millard of he Bank Srucural Economic Analyi Diviion and Chri Peacock of he
More informationINVESTIGATION OF THE INFLUENCE OF UNEMPLOYMENT ON ECONOMIC INDICATORS
INVESTIGATION OF THE INFLUENCE OF UNEMPLOYMENT ON ECONOMIC INDICATORS Ilona Tregub, Olga Filina, Irina Kondakova Financial Universiy under he Governmen of he Russian Federaion 1. Phillips curve In economics,
More informationMorningstar Investor Return
Morningsar Invesor Reurn Morningsar Mehodology Paper Augus 31, 2010 2010 Morningsar, Inc. All righs reserved. The informaion in his documen is he propery of Morningsar, Inc. Reproducion or ranscripion
More informationSAMPLE LESSON PLAN with Commentary from ReadingQuest.org
Lesson Plan: Energy Resources ubject: Earth cience Grade: 9 Purpose: students will learn about the energy resources, explore the differences between renewable and nonrenewable resources, evaluate the environmental
More information6.003 Homework #4 Solutions
6.3 Homewk #4 Soluion Problem. Laplace Tranfm Deermine he Laplace ranfm (including he region of convergence) of each of he following ignal: a. x () = e 2(3) u( 3) X = e 3 2 ROC: Re() > 2 X () = x ()e d
More information4. International Parity Conditions
4. Inernaional ariy ondiions 4.1 urchasing ower ariy he urchasing ower ariy ( heory is one of he early heories of exchange rae deerminaion. his heory is based on he concep ha he demand for a counry's currency
More informationTwoGroup Designs Independent samples ttest & paired samples ttest. Chapter 10
TwoGroup Deign Independen ample e & paired ample e Chaper 0 Previou e (Ch 7 and 8) Ze z M N e (oneample) M N M = andard error of he mean p. 989 Remember: = variance M = eimaed andard error p. 
More informationHeat demand forecasting for concrete district heating system
Hea demand forecaing for concree diric heaing yem Bronilav Chramcov Abrac Thi paper preen he reul of an inveigaion of a model for horerm hea demand forecaing. Foreca of hi hea demand coure i ignifican
More informationThe International Investment Position of Jamaica: An Estimation Approach
WP/04 The Inernaional Invemen Poiion of Jamaica: An Eimaion Approach Dane Docor* Economic Informaion & Publicaion Deparmen Bank of Jamaica Ocober 2004 Abrac Thi paper eek o inroduce he inernaional invemen
More informationFortified financial forecasting models: nonlinear searching approaches
0 Inernaional Conference on Economic and inance Reearch IPEDR vol.4 (0 (0 IACSIT Pre, Singapore orified financial forecaing model: nonlinear earching approache Mohammad R. Hamidizadeh, Ph.D. Profeor,
More information11/6/2013. Chapter 14: Dynamic ADAS. Introduction. Introduction. Keeping track of time. The model s elements
Inroducion Chaper 14: Dynamic DS dynamic model of aggregae and aggregae supply gives us more insigh ino how he economy works in he shor run. I is a simplified version of a DSGE model, used in cuingedge
More informationPROFIT TEST MODELLING IN LIFE ASSURANCE USING SPREADSHEETS PART TWO
Profi Tes Modelling in Life Assurance Using Spreadshees, par wo PROFIT TEST MODELLING IN LIFE ASSURANCE USING SPREADSHEETS PART TWO Erik Alm Peer Millingon Profi Tes Modelling in Life Assurance Using Spreadshees,
More informationA Comparative Study of Linear and Nonlinear Models for Aggregate Retail Sales Forecasting
A Comparaive Sudy of Linear and Nonlinear Model for Aggregae Reail Sale Forecaing G. Peer Zhang Deparmen of Managemen Georgia Sae Univeriy Alana GA 30066 (404) 6514065 Abrac: The purpoe of hi paper i
More informationGraphing the Von Bertalanffy Growth Equation
file: d:\b1732013\von_beralanffy.wpd dae: Sepember 23, 2013 Inroducion Graphing he Von Beralanffy Growh Equaion Previously, we calculaed regressions of TL on SL for fish size daa and ploed he daa and
More informationChapter 8: Regression with Lagged Explanatory Variables
Chaper 8: Regression wih Lagged Explanaory Variables Time series daa: Y for =1,..,T End goal: Regression model relaing a dependen variable o explanaory variables. Wih ime series new issues arise: 1. One
More information2.4 Network flows. Many direct and indirect applications telecommunication transportation (public, freight, railway, air, ) logistics
.4 Nework flow Problem involving he diribuion of a given produc (e.g., waer, ga, daa, ) from a e of producion locaion o a e of uer o a o opimize a given objecive funcion (e.g., amoun of produc, co,...).
More informationSubsistence Consumption and Rising Saving Rate
Subience Conumpion and Riing Saving Rae Kenneh S. Lin a, HiuYun Lee b * a Deparmen of Economic, Naional Taiwan Univeriy, Taipei, 00, Taiwan. b Deparmen of Economic, Naional Chung Cheng Univeriy, ChiaYi,
More informationWhy Do Real and Nominal. InventorySales Ratios Have Different Trends?
Why Do Real and Nominal InvenorySales Raios Have Differen Trends? By Valerie A. Ramey Professor of Economics Deparmen of Economics Universiy of California, San Diego and Research Associae Naional Bureau
More informationRepresenting Periodic Functions by Fourier Series. (a n cos nt + b n sin nt) n=1
Represening Periodic Funcions by Fourier Series 3. Inroducion In his Secion we show how a periodic funcion can be expressed as a series of sines and cosines. We begin by obaining some sandard inegrals
More informationA Note on Using the Svensson procedure to estimate the risk free rate in corporate valuation
A Noe on Using he Svensson procedure o esimae he risk free rae in corporae valuaion By Sven Arnold, Alexander Lahmann and Bernhard Schwezler Ocober 2011 1. The risk free ineres rae in corporae valuaion
More informationYTM is positively related to default risk. YTM is positively related to liquidity risk. YTM is negatively related to special tax treatment.
. Two quesions for oday. A. Why do bonds wih he same ime o mauriy have differen YTM s? B. Why do bonds wih differen imes o mauriy have differen YTM s? 2. To answer he firs quesion les look a he risk srucure
More informationChapter 2 Kinematics in One Dimension
Chaper Kinemaics in One Dimension Chaper DESCRIBING MOTION:KINEMATICS IN ONE DIMENSION PREVIEW Kinemaics is he sudy of how hings moe how far (disance and displacemen), how fas (speed and elociy), and how
More informationEmpirical heuristics for improving Intermittent Demand Forecasting
Empirical heuriic for improving Inermien Demand Forecaing Foio Peropoulo 1,*, Konanino Nikolopoulo 2, Georgio P. Spihouraki 1, Vailio Aimakopoulo 1 1 Forecaing & Sraegy Uni, School of Elecrical and Compuer
More informationChapter 7. Response of FirstOrder RL and RC Circuits
Chaper 7. esponse of FirsOrder L and C Circuis 7.1. The Naural esponse of an L Circui 7.2. The Naural esponse of an C Circui 7.3. The ep esponse of L and C Circuis 7.4. A General oluion for ep and Naural
More informationWhy Did the Demand for Cash Decrease Recently in Korea?
Why Did he Demand for Cash Decrease Recenly in Korea? Byoung Hark Yoo Bank of Korea 26. 5 Absrac We explores why cash demand have decreased recenly in Korea. The raio of cash o consumpion fell o 4.7% in
More informationCHAPTER 11 NONPARAMETRIC REGRESSION WITH COMPLEX SURVEY DATA. R. L. Chambers Department of Social Statistics University of Southampton
CHAPTER 11 NONPARAMETRIC REGRESSION WITH COMPLEX SURVEY DATA R. L. Chamber Deparmen of Social Saiic Univeriy of Souhampon A.H. Dorfman Office of Survey Mehod Reearch Bureau of Labor Saiic M.Yu. Sverchkov
More informationState Machines: Brief Introduction to Sequencers Prof. Andrew J. Mason, Michigan State University
Inroducion ae Machines: Brief Inroducion o equencers Prof. Andrew J. Mason, Michigan ae Universiy A sae machine models behavior defined by a finie number of saes (unique configuraions), ransiions beween
More informationPrice elasticity of demand for crude oil: estimates for 23 countries
Price elasiciy of demand for crude oil: esimaes for 23 counries John C.B. Cooper Absrac This paper uses a muliple regression model derived from an adapaion of Nerlove s parial adjusmen model o esimae boh
More informationOn the Connection Between MultipleUnicast Network Coding and SingleSource SingleSink Network Error Correction
On he Connecion Beween MulipleUnica ework Coding and SingleSource SingleSink ework Error Correcion Jörg Kliewer JIT Join work wih Wenao Huang and Michael Langberg ework Error Correcion Problem: Adverary
More informationII.1. Debt reduction and fiscal multipliers. dbt da dpbal da dg. bal
Quarerly Repor on he Euro Area 3/202 II.. Deb reducion and fiscal mulipliers The deerioraion of public finances in he firs years of he crisis has led mos Member Saes o adop sizeable consolidaion packages.
More informationAnswer, Key Homework 2 David McIntyre 45123 Mar 25, 2004 1
Answer, Key Homework 2 Daid McInyre 4123 Mar 2, 2004 1 This prinou should hae 1 quesions. Muliplechoice quesions may coninue on he ne column or page find all choices before making your selecion. The
More informationThe Real Business Cycle paradigm. The RBC model emphasizes supply (technology) disturbances as the main source of
Prof. Harris Dellas Advanced Macroeconomics Winer 2001/01 The Real Business Cycle paradigm The RBC model emphasizes supply (echnology) disurbances as he main source of macroeconomic flucuaions in a world
More informationNew Evidence on Mutual Fund Performance: A Comparison of Alternative Bootstrap Methods. David Blake* Tristan Caulfield** Christos Ioannidis*** and
New Evidence on Muual Fund Performance: A Comparion of Alernaive Boorap Mehod David Blake* Trian Caulfield** Chrio Ioannidi*** and Ian Tonk**** June 2014 Abrac Thi paper compare he wo boorap mehod of Koowki
More informationThe Greek financial crisis: growing imbalances and sovereign spreads. Heather D. Gibson, Stephan G. Hall and George S. Tavlas
The Greek financial crisis: growing imbalances and sovereign spreads Heaher D. Gibson, Sephan G. Hall and George S. Tavlas The enry The enry of Greece ino he Eurozone in 2001 produced a dividend in he
More informationThe Twin Agency Problems in Corporate Finance  On the basis of Stulz s theory 
The Twin Agency Problem in Corporae Finance  On he bai of Sulz heory  Von der Fakulä für Machinenbau, Elekroechnik und Wirchafingenieurween der Brandenburgichen Technichen Univeriä Cobu zur Erlangung
More informationHow Much Can Taxes Help Selfish Routing?
How Much Can Taxe Help Selfih Rouing? Tim Roughgarden (Cornell) Join wih Richard Cole (NYU) and Yevgeniy Dodi (NYU) Selfih Rouing a direced graph G = (V,E) a ource and a deinaion one uni of raffic from
More informationA Brief Introduction to the Consumption Based Asset Pricing Model (CCAPM)
A Brief Inroducion o he Consumpion Based Asse Pricing Model (CCAPM We have seen ha CAPM idenifies he risk of any securiy as he covariance beween he securiy's rae of reurn and he rae of reurn on he marke
More informationTwo Compartment Body Model and V d Terms by Jeff Stark
Two Comparmen Body Model and V d Terms by Jeff Sark In a onecomparmen model, we make wo imporan assumpions: (1) Linear pharmacokineics  By his, we mean ha eliminaion is firs order and ha pharmacokineic
More informationSPECIAL REPORT May 4, Shifting Drivers of Inflation Canada versus the U.S.
Paul Ferley Assisan Chief Economis 4169747231 paul.ferley@rbc.com Nahan Janzen Economis 4169740579 nahan.janzen@rbc.com SPECIAL REPORT May 4, 2010 Shifing Drivers of Inflaion Canada versus he U.S.
More informationChapter 6: Business Valuation (Income Approach)
Chaper 6: Business Valuaion (Income Approach) Cash flow deerminaion is one of he mos criical elemens o a business valuaion. Everyhing may be secondary. If cash flow is high, hen he value is high; if he
More informationEquity Valuation Using Multiples. Jing Liu. Anderson Graduate School of Management. University of California at Los Angeles (310) 2065861
Equiy Valuaion Uing Muliple Jing Liu Anderon Graduae School of Managemen Univeriy of California a Lo Angele (310) 2065861 jing.liu@anderon.ucla.edu Doron Niim Columbia Univeriy Graduae School of Buine
More informationBALANCE OF PAYMENTS. First quarter 2008. Balance of payments
BALANCE OF PAYMENTS DATE: 20080530 PUBLISHER: Balance of Paymens and Financial Markes (BFM) Lena Finn + 46 8 506 944 09, lena.finn@scb.se Camilla Bergeling +46 8 506 942 06, camilla.bergeling@scb.se
More informationIndividual Health Insurance April 30, 2008 Pages 167170
Individual Healh Insurance April 30, 2008 Pages 167170 We have received feedback ha his secion of he e is confusing because some of he defined noaion is inconsisen wih comparable life insurance reserve
More informationSignal Rectification
9/3/25 Signal Recificaion.doc / Signal Recificaion n imporan applicaion of juncion diodes is signal recificaion. here are wo ypes of signal recifiers, halfwae and fullwae. Le s firs consider he ideal
More informationWorking Paper Modeling technological progress and investment in China: Some caveats
econor www.econor.eu Der OpenAccePublikaionerver der ZBW eibnizinformaionzenrum Wirchaf The Open Acce Publicaion Server of he ZBW eibniz Informaion Cenre for Economic Felipe, Jeu; McCombie, John Working
More informationUsefulness of the Forward Curve in Forecasting Oil Prices
Usefulness of he Forward Curve in Forecasing Oil Prices Akira Yanagisawa Leader Energy Demand, Supply and Forecas Analysis Group The Energy Daa and Modelling Cener Summary When people analyse oil prices,
More informationImagine a Source (S) of sound waves that emits waves having frequency f and therefore
heoreical Noes: he oppler Eec wih ound Imagine a ource () o sound waes ha emis waes haing requency and hereore period as measured in he res rame o he ource (). his means ha any eecor () ha is no moing
More informationTopic: Applications of Network Flow Date: 9/14/2007
CS787: Advanced Algorihm Scribe: Daniel Wong and Priyananda Shenoy Lecurer: Shuchi Chawla Topic: Applicaion of Nework Flow Dae: 9/4/2007 5. Inroducion and Recap In he la lecure, we analyzed he problem
More informationChapter 13. Network Flow III Applications. 13.1 Edge disjoint paths. 13.1.1 Edgedisjoint paths in a directed graphs
Chaper 13 Nework Flow III Applicaion CS 573: Algorihm, Fall 014 Ocober 9, 014 13.1 Edge dijoin pah 13.1.1 Edgedijoin pah in a direced graph 13.1.1.1 Edge dijoin pah queiong: graph (dir/undir)., : verice.
More informationDYNAMIC MODELS FOR VALUATION OF WRONGFUL DEATH PAYMENTS
DYNAMIC MODELS FOR VALUATION OF WRONGFUL DEATH PAYMENTS Hong Mao, Shanghai Second Polyechnic Universiy Krzyszof M. Osaszewski, Illinois Sae Universiy Youyu Zhang, Fudan Universiy ABSTRACT Liigaion, exper
More informationMOTION ALONG A STRAIGHT LINE
Chaper 2: MOTION ALONG A STRAIGHT LINE 1 A paricle moes along he ais from i o f Of he following alues of he iniial and final coordinaes, which resuls in he displacemen wih he larges magniude? A i =4m,
More informationImpact of Debt on Primary Deficit and GSDP Gap in Odisha: Empirical Evidences
S.R. No. 002 10/2015/CEFT Impac of Deb on Primary Defici and GSDP Gap in Odisha: Empirical Evidences 1. Inroducion The excessive pressure of public expendiure over is revenue receip is financed hrough
More informationAppendix D Flexibility Factor/Margin of Choice Desktop Research
Appendix D Flexibiliy Facor/Margin of Choice Deskop Research Cheshire Eas Council Cheshire Eas Employmen Land Review Conens D1 Flexibiliy Facor/Margin of Choice Deskop Research 2 Final Ocober 2012 \\GLOBAL.ARUP.COM\EUROPE\MANCHESTER\JOBS\200000\22348900\4
More informationPROFIT TEST MODELLING IN LIFE ASSURANCE USING SPREADSHEETS PART ONE
Profi Tes Modelling in Life Assurance Using Spreadshees PROFIT TEST MODELLING IN LIFE ASSURANCE USING SPREADSHEETS PART ONE Erik Alm Peer Millingon 2004 Profi Tes Modelling in Life Assurance Using Spreadshees
More informationMathematics in Pharmacokinetics What and Why (A second attempt to make it clearer)
Mahemaics in Pharmacokineics Wha and Why (A second aemp o make i clearer) We have used equaions for concenraion () as a funcion of ime (). We will coninue o use hese equaions since he plasma concenraions
More informationVector Autoregressions (VARs): Operational Perspectives
Vecor Auoregressions (VARs): Operaional Perspecives Primary Source: Sock, James H., and Mark W. Wason, Vecor Auoregressions, Journal of Economic Perspecives, Vol. 15 No. 4 (Fall 2001), 101115. Macroeconomericians
More informationDuration and Convexity ( ) 20 = Bond B has a maturity of 5 years and also has a required rate of return of 10%. Its price is $613.
Graduae School of Business Adminisraion Universiy of Virginia UVAF38 Duraion and Convexiy he price of a bond is a funcion of he promised paymens and he marke required rae of reurn. Since he promised
More informationExplore the Application of Financial Engineering in the Management of Exchange Rate Risk
SHS Web o Conerence 17, 01006 (015) DOI: 10.1051/ hcon/01517 01006 C Owned by he auhor, publihed by EDP Science, 015 Explore he Applicaion o Financial Engineering in he Managemen o Exchange Rae Rik Liu
More informationcooking trajectory boiling water B (t) microwave 0 2 4 6 8 101214161820 time t (mins)
Alligaor egg wih calculus We have a large alligaor egg jus ou of he fridge (1 ) which we need o hea o 9. Now here are wo accepable mehods for heaing alligaor eggs, one is o immerse hem in boiling waer
More informationWHAT ARE OPTION CONTRACTS?
WHAT ARE OTION CONTRACTS? By rof. Ashok anekar An oion conrac is a derivaive which gives he righ o he holder of he conrac o do 'Somehing' bu wihou he obligaion o do ha 'Somehing'. The 'Somehing' can be
More informationRC, RL and RLC circuits
Name Dae Time o Complee h m Parner Course/ Secion / Grade RC, RL and RLC circuis Inroducion In his experimen we will invesigae he behavior of circuis conaining combinaions of resisors, capaciors, and inducors.
More informationNewton's second law in action
Newon's second law in acion In many cases, he naure of he force acing on a body is known I migh depend on ime, posiion, velociy, or some combinaion of hese, bu is dependence is known from experimen In
More informationChapter 1.6 Financial Management
Chaper 1.6 Financial Managemen Par I: Objecive ype quesions and answers 1. Simple pay back period is equal o: a) Raio of Firs cos/ne yearly savings b) Raio of Annual gross cash flow/capial cos n c) = (1
More informationDOES TRADING VOLUME INFLUENCE GARCH EFFECTS? SOME EVIDENCE FROM THE GREEK MARKET WITH SPECIAL REFERENCE TO BANKING SECTOR
Invesmen Managemen and Financial Innovaions, Volume 4, Issue 3, 7 33 DOES TRADING VOLUME INFLUENCE GARCH EFFECTS? SOME EVIDENCE FROM THE GREEK MARKET WITH SPECIAL REFERENCE TO BANKING SECTOR Ahanasios
More informationCSE202 Greedy algorithms
CSE0 Greedy algorihm . Shore Pah in a Graph hore pah from Princeon CS deparmen o Einein' houe . Shore Pah in a Graph hore pah from Princeon CS deparmen o Einein' houe Tree wih a mo edge G i a ree on n
More informationsdomain Circuit Analysis
Domain ircui Analyi Operae direcly in he domain wih capacior, inducor and reior Key feaure lineariy i preered c decribed by ODE and heir Order equal number of plu number of Elemenbyelemen and ource ranformaion
More informationJava Semantics. The Stack and Heap. Primitive Types. Semantics and Specifying Procedures. David Evans
univeriy of virginia fall 2006 Semanic and Specifying Procedure Java Semanic David Evan www.c.virginia.edu/c205 2 The Sack and Heap Sring = new Sring (); Sring i a ype in he Java API for repreening equence
More informationCRISES AND THE FLEXIBLE PRICE MONETARY MODEL. Sarantis Kalyvitis
CRISES AND THE FLEXIBLE PRICE MONETARY MODEL Saranis Kalyviis Currency Crises In fixed exchange rae regimes, counries rarely abandon he regime volunarily. In mos cases, raders (or speculaors) exchange
More informationHedging with Forwards and Futures
Hedging wih orwards and uures Hedging in mos cases is sraighforward. You plan o buy 10,000 barrels of oil in six monhs and you wish o eliminae he price risk. If you ake he buyside of a forward/fuures
More informationStability. Coefficients may change over time. Evolution of the economy Policy changes
Sabiliy Coefficiens may change over ime Evoluion of he economy Policy changes Time Varying Parameers y = α + x β + Coefficiens depend on he ime period If he coefficiens vary randomly and are unpredicable,
More information2.6 Limits at Infinity, Horizontal Asymptotes Math 1271, TA: Amy DeCelles. 1. Overview. 2. Examples. Outline: 1. Definition of limits at infinity
.6 Limis a Infiniy, Horizonal Asympoes Mah 7, TA: Amy DeCelles. Overview Ouline:. Definiion of is a infiniy. Definiion of horizonal asympoe 3. Theorem abou raional powers of. Infinie is a infiniy This
More informationDIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS with TI89 ABDUL HASSEN and JAY SCHIFFMAN. A. Direction Fields and Graphs of Differential Equations
DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS wih TI89 ABDUL HASSEN and JAY SCHIFFMAN We will assume ha he reader is familiar wih he calculaor s keyboard and he basic operaions. In paricular we have assumed ha he reader knows
More informationMath 201 Lecture 12: CauchyEuler Equations
Mah 20 Lecure 2: CauchyEuler Equaions Feb., 202 Many examples here are aken from he exbook. The firs number in () refers o he problem number in he UA Cusom ediion, he second number in () refers o he problem
More informationChapter 9 Bond Prices and Yield
Chaper 9 Bond Prices and Yield Deb Classes: Paymen ype A securiy obligaing issuer o pay ineress and principal o he holder on specified daes, Coupon rae or ineres rae, e.g. 4%, 5 3/4%, ec. Face, par value
More information4.8 Exponential Growth and Decay; Newton s Law; Logistic Growth and Decay
324 CHAPTER 4 Exponenial and Logarihmic Funcions 4.8 Exponenial Growh and Decay; Newon s Law; Logisic Growh and Decay OBJECTIVES 1 Find Equaions of Populaions Tha Obey he Law of Uninhibied Growh 2 Find
More informationMeasuring the Effects of Exchange Rate Changes on Investment. in Australian Manufacturing Industry
Measuring he Effecs of Exchange Rae Changes on Invesmen in Ausralian Manufacuring Indusry Robyn Swif Economics and Business Saisics Deparmen of Accouning, Finance and Economics Griffih Universiy Nahan
More informationOPTIMAL BATCH QUANTITY MODELS FOR A LEAN PRODUCTION SYSTEM WITH REWORK AND SCRAP. A Thesis
OTIMAL BATH UANTITY MOELS FOR A LEAN ROUTION SYSTEM WITH REWORK AN SRA A Thei Submied o he Graduae Faculy of he Louiiana Sae Univeriy and Agriculural and Mechanical ollege in parial fulfillmen of he requiremen
More informationCHARGE AND DISCHARGE OF A CAPACITOR
REFERENCES RC Circuis: Elecrical Insrumens: Mos Inroducory Physics exs (e.g. A. Halliday and Resnick, Physics ; M. Sernheim and J. Kane, General Physics.) This Laboraory Manual: Commonly Used Insrumens:
More informationA Reexamination of the Joint Mortality Functions
Norh merican cuarial Journal Volume 6, Number 1, p.166170 (2002) Reeaminaion of he Join Morali Funcions bsrac. Heekung Youn, rkad Shemakin, Edwin Herman Universi of S. Thomas, Sain Paul, MN, US Morali
More informationARCH 2013.1 Proceedings
Aricle from: ARCH 213.1 Proceedings Augus 14, 212 Ghislain Leveille, Emmanuel Hamel A renewal model for medical malpracice Ghislain Léveillé École d acuaria Universié Laval, Québec, Canada 47h ARC Conference
More informationCointegration: The Engle and Granger approach
Coinegraion: The Engle and Granger approach Inroducion Generally one would find mos of he economic variables o be nonsaionary I(1) variables. Hence, any equilibrium heories ha involve hese variables require
More informationJ. S. BACH GENERAL BASS RULES. Adapted from Niedt's Music Handbook Leipzig Edited by N. Schmidt Lausanne 2003
J. S. BACH GENERAL BASS RULES Adaped rom Nied' Muic Handbook Leipzig 1 Edied by N. Schmid Lauanne 200 1 Table o Conen Inroducion Baic Rule Harmonic Triad Wha o play when nohing i wrien over he Ba Rule
More informationChapter 8 Student Lecture Notes 81
Chaper Suden Lecure Noes  Chaper Goals QM: Business Saisics Chaper Analyzing and Forecasing Series Daa Afer compleing his chaper, you should be able o: Idenify he componens presen in a ime series Develop
More informationEconomics Honors Exam 2008 Solutions Question 5
Economics Honors Exam 2008 Soluions Quesion 5 (a) (2 poins) Oupu can be decomposed as Y = C + I + G. And we can solve for i by subsiuing in equaions given in he quesion, Y = C + I + G = c 0 + c Y D + I
More informationEconomics 140A Hypothesis Testing in Regression Models
Economics 140A Hypohesis Tesing in Regression Models While i is algebraically simple o work wih a populaion model wih a single varying regressor, mos populaion models have muliple varying regressors 1
More information11. Tire pressure. Here we always work with relative pressure. That s what everybody always does.
11. Tire pressure. The graph You have a hole in your ire. You pump i up o P=400 kilopascals (kpa) and over he nex few hours i goes down ill he ire is quie fla. Draw wha you hink he graph of ire pressure
More informationCalculation of variable annuity market sensitivities using a pathwise methodology
cuing edge Variable annuiie Calculaion of variable annuiy marke eniiviie uing a pahwie mehodology Under radiional finie difference mehod, he calculaion of variable annuiy eniiviie can involve muliple Mone
More informationThe Transport Equation
The Transpor Equaion Consider a fluid, flowing wih velociy, V, in a hin sraigh ube whose cross secion will be denoed by A. Suppose he fluid conains a conaminan whose concenraion a posiion a ime will be
More informationOne dictionary: Native language  English/English  native language or English  English
Faculy of Social Sciences School of Business Corporae Finance Examinaion December 03 English Dae: Monday 09 December, 03 Time: 4 hours/ 9:003:00 Toal number of pages including he cover page: 5 Toal number
More informationCrosssectional and longitudinal weighting in a rotational household panel: applications to EUSILC. Vijay Verma, Gianni Betti, Giulio Ghellini
Croecional and longiudinal eighing in a roaional houehold panel: applicaion o EUSILC Viay Verma, Gianni Bei, Giulio Ghellini Working Paper n. 67, December 006 CROSSSECTIONAL AND LONGITUDINAL WEIGHTING
More informationI. Basic Concepts (Ch. 14)
(Ch. 14) A. Real vs. Financial Asses (Ch 1.2) Real asses (buildings, machinery, ec.) appear on he asse side of he balance shee. Financial asses (bonds, socks) appear on boh sides of he balance shee. Creaing
More informationDifferential Equations and Linear Superposition
Differenial Equaions and Linear Superposiion Basic Idea: Provide soluion in closed form Like Inegraion, no general soluions in closed form Order of equaion: highes derivaive in equaion e.g. dy d dy 2 y
More informationUnderstanding Sequential Circuit Timing
ENGIN112: Inroducion o Elecrical and Compuer Engineering Fall 2003 Prof. Russell Tessier Undersanding Sequenial Circui Timing Perhaps he wo mos disinguishing characerisics of a compuer are is processor
More informationInterest Rate Spreads and Mandatory Credit Allocations: Implications on Banks Loans to Small Businesses in Indonesia
Dicuion Paper No. 0402 Inere Rae Spread and Mandaory Credi Allocaion: Implicaion on Bank oan o Small Buinee in Indoneia Reza Y. Siregar January 2004 Indoneia Program Univeriy of Adelaide Adelaide 5005
More informationDigital Data Acquisition
ME231 Measuremens Laboraory Spring 1999 Digial Daa Acquisiion Edmundo Corona c The laer par of he 20h cenury winessed he birh of he compuer revoluion. The developmen of digial compuer echnology has had
More informationDividend taxation, share repurchases and the equity trap
Working Paper 2009:7 Deparmen of Economic Dividend axaion, hare repurchae and he equiy rap Tobia Lindhe and Jan Söderen Deparmen of Economic Working paper 2009:7 Uppala Univeriy May 2009 P.O. Box 53 ISSN
More informationInfrastructure and Evolution in Division of Labour
Infrarucure and Evoluion in Diviion of Labour Mei Wen Monah Univery (Thi paper ha been publihed in RDE. (), 906) April 997 Abrac Thi paper udie he relaionhip beween infrarucure ependure and endogenou
More informationReturn Calculation of U.S. Treasury Constant Maturity Indices
Reurn Calculaion of US Treasur Consan Mauri Indices Morningsar Mehodolog Paper Sepeber 30 008 008 Morningsar Inc All righs reserved The inforaion in his docuen is he proper of Morningsar Inc Reproducion
More informationChapter 7: Estimating the Variance of an Estimate s Probability Distribution
Chaper 7: Esimaing he Variance of an Esimae s Probabiliy Disribuion Chaper 7 Ouline Review o Clin s Assignmen o General Properies of he Ordinary Leas Squares (OLS) Esimaion Procedure o Imporance of he
More informationMeasuring macroeconomic volatility Applications to export revenue data, 19702005
FONDATION POUR LES ETUDES ET RERS LE DEVELOPPEMENT INTERNATIONAL Measuring macroeconomic volailiy Applicaions o expor revenue daa, 1970005 by Joël Cariolle Policy brief no. 47 March 01 The FERDI is a
More information