1 0001 VERSACOMP (4.2 ) COMPOSE2 (4.05) 04/21/99 (16:36) J:\VRS\DAT\0030\3.GML --- R030MASTER.STY V POST 1 1/1 CHAPTER 3 Closing Argument Wrongful Death Young Child Summation by Howard L. Nations * SYNOPSIS 3.00 Summary of the Facts of the Case 3.01 Opening Line There is No Magic Only Despair 3.02 Measuring the Loss of a Child What is a Boy 3.03 Justice System Cannot Do Magic Money Damages Are the Only Viable Compensation 3.04 Sympathy Versus Justice Discussed 3.05 Evaluation of Specific Damages Life That Will Never Be Parent s Loss of Companionship and Mental Anguish 3.06 Defendant Took a Gamble With a Human Life Do Not Let Defendant Win Their Bet 3.07 Society Places High Value on the Lives of Children and Seeks to Protect Them from Danger 3.08 Jury Must Send Message to Defendant Safety Must Come Before Profit * Howard L. Nations received his legal education at Vanderbilt University School of Law (J.D., 1966). He is a member of The Texas Trial Lawyers Association (President); Association of Trial Lawyers of America (Executive Committee); Texas Association of Certified Civil Trial Lawyers (Past President); Southern Trial Lawyers Association (Vice President); National College of Advocacy Foundations (Chairman Board of Trustees); Roscoe Pound Foundation (Board of Trustees). He is a Fellow of the Texas Bar Foundation and the Houston Bar Foundation. In addition, Mr. Nations is an adjunct faculty member of the South Texas College of Law, is on the Executive Board of the Texas College of Trial Advocacy, and is Chairman of the Board of the National College of Trial Advocacy. Mr. Nations has authored, co-authored and edited numerous books, articles and CLE papers and is a frequent speaker for various lawyer associations throughout the United States. Mr. Nations practices law in Houston, Texas. The names of the parties, witnesses and opposing counsel have been changed. 3 1
2 0002 VERSACOMP (4.2 ) COMPOSE2 (4.05) 04/21/99 (16:36) J:\VRS\DAT\0030\3.GML --- R030MASTER.STY V POST Summation Placing a Dollar Value on Life Analogy to Masterpiece Painting 3.10 Dehumanizing the Defendant Money is The Only Thing a Corporation Understands 3.11 Argument for Exemplary Damages Full Justice 3.12 What is a Child s Life Worth? Discussion Regarding the Value of the Life of a Child Analogy to Prize Fighters and Race Horses 3.13 Closing Line Full and Complete Justice 3.14 General Comments About the Structure of The Argument 3.00 Summary of the Facts of the Case In this case, a seven year old boy, the only child of a physician and his wife, died as a result of his exposure to a product whose dangerous propensities were known to the defendant manufacturer due to the filing of other claims which asserted the existence of a latent defect. While the evidence was disputed by the defendant, proof was offered by the plaintiff that the corporate defendant had notice of the defect and had rejected the option to recall the offensive product. The plaintiff offered proof that a recall would have cost the defendant approximately four million dollars. Plaintiff argued to the Court that there was sufficient evidence of a corporate decision not to recall the product to support such an argument during summation. The evidence on this point was disputed by the defendant, and plaintiff s counsel anticipated that defense counsel would object to a recall argument during summation. Since such an objection would interrupt the flow of plaintiff s summation, plaintiff s counsel raised the issue on the record during the Court s charge conference and obtained the ruling that the argument that the corporation considered and rejected a recall of the product was a reasonable inference to be drawn from the evidence. The Court further ruled that defense counsel s objection was duly noted and overruled, and that defense counsel was not to interrupt plaintiff s summation for an objection on this point. After a substantial verdict was awarded to the plaintiff the case was settled under a non-disclosure agreement. Hence, the identification of the parties and the product are protected and cannot be disclosed. However, this superb closing argument may be adapted for use in almost any case involving wrongful death of a child. While reviewing this summation, it is important to note counsel s unique methods of employing standard themes and arguments, particularly the magic versus realty argument, conscience of the community argument and full justice versus partial justice argument. Also, note counsel s superb response to defense counsel s argument regarding sympathy for the plaintiffs and the propriety of returning a compensatory award of four million dollars and an
3 0003 VERSACOMP (4.2 ) COMPOSE2 (4.05) 04/21/99 (16:36) J:\VRS\DAT\0030\3.GML --- R030MASTER.STY V POST Wrongful Death Young Child 3.02 exemplary award of treble damages, or twelve million dollars. Most importantly, pay close attention to counsel s incorporation of the numerous rhetorical devices, such as, the Rule of Three, Metaphor, Analogy, Rhetorical Question, Simile, Antithesis and the Echo Effect of Repetition Opening Line There is No Magic Only Despair May it please the Court, Mr. Smith, ladies and gentlemen of the jury. Now we talk of money. We talk of money because there is no magic. Is anyone so callous as to believe that if the jury had the power to wave a magic wand and return this child to his parents, there would be talk of money. No. There would be only exultant joy. You would witness this young couple emerge immediately from the depths of despair into the heights of happiness and leave this courtroom bound together as a happy family again. But, there is no magic there is only despair. There is no magic there is only reality. Magic exists only in the world of children such as David Taylor. The magic of each new day in David s life, his new challenges, his dreams, his fantasies; the magic of new friends; the testing of David s God given talents against his friends and young cousins; hitting the ball as far, running as fast; the magic of his days, his toys, birthdays and Christmas although there were only seven and there will be no more. COMMENT: This is a theme that can be used effectively over and over again in any case involving the death of a child. Counsel has the jury envision what it would be like if the courtroom doors could swing open and the child could run back to his mother and father. This is a great concept that has a lot of emotional impact. Counsel also notes that nothing short of a miracle can restore this child s life and the plaintiff parents must live with this haunting reality. This provides an ideal segue to a discussion of monetary compensation, the real issue in the case. Note that counsel introduces the popular but immensely effective theme of magic versus realty. This argument can be adapted to almost any personal injury situation. For example, there is no magic to make a quadriplegic walk, or a blind person see. The jury must then be reminded that despite these impossibilities, they have the power to render justice in the form of awarding monetary compensation. Counsel expertly weaves this theme throughout the summation and forcefully drives home the point that the parents are entitled to a substantial monetary award to compensate them for the irreplaceable loss of their son Measuring the Loss of a Child What is a Boy But what is this loss which you are called upon to measure. I am reminded of the prose on What is a Boy. Between the innocence of babyhood and the
4 0004 VERSACOMP (4.2 ) COMPOSE2 (4.05) 04/21/99 (16:36) J:\VRS\DAT\0030\3.GML --- R030MASTER.STY V POST Summation 3 4 dignity of manhood, we find the delightful creature called a boy. Boys come in assorted sizes, but all boys have the same creed: to enjoy every second of every minute, of every hour, of every day and to protest with noise, their only weapon, when the last minute is finished and Mom or Dad pack them off to bed at night. Boys are found everywhere; on top of underneath, inside of, climbing on, emerging from, running around, or jumping to. Mothers love them, little girls hate them, older sisters and brothers tolerate them, and heaven protects them. A boy is a magical creature, you can lock him out of your workshop, but you can t look him out of your heart. You can get him out of your study, but you can t get him out of your mind. You might as well give up, he s your captor, your jailer, your boss, a freckled-face, pint-size, cat-chasing bundle of noise. But when you come home at night with only the shattered pieces of your hopes and dreams, he can mend them all like new with just two magic words. Hi Dad! But David, Sr. will never again hear those magic words because the magic of young David s life ended on November 3, 19 and was replaced by stark reality when an inevitable time bomb which the defendant created and refused to recall, exploded and took with it the life of this young child, and the hopes and dreams and aspirations of this young family. COMMENT: Without going overboard, counsel tugs at the jury s heartstrings. Every juror, no matter how callous or seemingly uncaring, can relate to the infinite delight and wonderment brought about by the presence of a vivacious, inquisitive and active little boy, if not through their own experience as parents, then through the memories of their own childhood. Counsel builds on these happy thoughts and memories by quoting snippets of an endearing prose regarding the marvel of a young boy. He abruptly snatches away those good feelings by suddenly recalling the death of the youth and the heartbreak felt by the plaintiff father who will never again share those special moments with his son. Counsel s presentation is extremely effective, his choice of words superb and his ability to relate the parents loss highly impressive Justice System Cannot Do Magic Money Damages Are the Only Viable Compensation Since there is no magic in our justice system we speak of money. But we speak of money now because the defendant spoke of money in their conference room five years ago when they refused to recall this product. Why, because a recall would have cost this corporation four million dollars. So, they refused to recall and the inevitable tragedy occurred. Ladies and gentlemen, is that the standard of safety which we will tolerate in Texas? Or, is this reprehensible corporate conduct which must not be allowed
5 0005 VERSACOMP (4.2 ) COMPOSE2 (4.05) 04/21/99 (16:36) J:\VRS\DAT\0030\3.GML --- R030MASTER.STY V POST Wrongful Death Young Child 3.05 to occur again? That is your decision. That and the amount of money to be awarded for the value of this young child s life. COMMENT: As every trial attorney knows, it is often difficult to discuss monetary awards without appearing greedy or callous. Above, counsel employs a very effective method to explain why money damages should be awarded in this case. He opines that money compensation is just and proper because profit was foremost on the defendant s mind when it decided not to recall the product which ultimately cost the innocent life of this young boy. The jurors will no doubt find it easier to award substantial money damages once they realize that profit was the primary concern of the defendant corporation. Counsel will amplify this passionate theme throughout the summation. Note that throughout this summation counsel employs the use of rhetorical questions. Proper use of this technique can be very effective. The jurors answer the questions in their own minds as if they came to the conclusion independently and thus, value the conclusions more than if the information was simply given to them in lecture form Sympathy Versus Justice Discussed The defendant warned you against sympathy for this family. We agree. Don t look at this family with sympathy, sympathy is like charity, it is demeaning. Believe me, they received sympathy at the funeral every time they looked into the faces of their friends; they received sympathy when they returned to their jobs and saw sympathy in the eyes of their co-worker: they received sympathy when they returned to their church and saw their pastor and the church members and looked into their eyes filled with sympathy. They have received enough sympathy to last ten lifetimes. We are not here about sympathy; we are here about justice. COMMENT: Counsel does an excellent job of balancing emotion and logic. It is always dangerous to rely too heavily on the emotional or passionate appeal because it may be deemed prejudicial or irrelevant by the court. Above, counsel downplays the inevitable sympathy for the plaintiffs and reminds the jury to concentrate on delivering justice Evaluation of Specific Damages Life That Will Never Be Parent s Loss of Companionship and Mental Anguish In evaluating the damages in this case, don t look at the death of this young man, look at the life which will never be. Since there is no magic, examine closely, reality. The reality of the loss of David s society, participating with his parents in every phase of their lives; the reality of the loss of his companionship; and the reality of experiencing mental anguish every day of their lives. The
6 0006 VERSACOMP (4.2 ) COMPOSE2 (4.05) 04/21/99 (16:36) J:\VRS\DAT\0030\3.GML --- R030MASTER.STY V POST Summation 3 6 reality, by which you must measure the amount of money to be awarded in this case, is that these young parents will never again share the daily joys, fears, hopes and tears of David, this gift of God to this fine couple. Reality is that young David lived only seven years, ten percent of his life expectancy. His life was like a broken film, a mere preview of coming attractions. Reality is that these parents awaken every day of their lives to the realization that David is gone forever. Reality is that watching their friends children, young David s friends, is a constant source of devastating mental anguish to this couple as they lay awake at night and think of that young life that never will be. Reality is that they will never know if David would have followed in his father s footsteps, if he would have been the high school quarterback, the college athlete, the academic scholar to med school. Reality is they ll never know if he would have followed in his grandfather s footstep as a salesman, in his uncle s footsteps as a professional military man. But even more, the reality of their loss is they ll never know those special moments that reward parents so beautifully. Karen will never again know the reality of hearing the four most beautiful words in the world I love you, Mommy. They ll never experience that magic moment when young David walks in and says Hi Mom, Hi Dad, this is the girl I m going to marry. David, Sr. will never know the thrill of the moment when he picks up the phone and hears those words: Congratulations, Grandpa, it s a boy. The days of joy for families: Birthdays, Mother s Day, Father s Day, Thanksgiving and Christmas are now days of mourning in the Taylor household. These are only a few of the endless litany of losses thrust upon these parents by the gamble of the corporate defendant. COMMENT:Counsel does a superb job of personalizing the losses faced by this young couple in a manner which will touch the hearts of each juror. Again, his zealousness does not cross the line so as to become inflammatory or prejudicial Defendant Took a Gamble With a Human Life Do Not Let Defendant Win Their Bet What is this child s life worth in our community? That determination is your role in the justice system, to write the final chapter before we close the books on young David s life. But, let s look at another set of books. As we speak here today, the life of young David Taylor is carried as a four million dollar profit item on the books of this corporation. This corporation, which made the willful decision to gamble, they gambled their four million dollar profit against the safety of the public; they gambled their four million dollar profit on the judicial system of this great state; and they gambled their four million dollar profit against the life of young David Taylor. We know that young David lost that gamble. The
7 0007 VERSACOMP (4.2 ) COMPOSE2 (4.05) 04/21/99 (16:36) J:\VRS\DAT\0030\3.GML --- R030MASTER.STY V POST Wrongful Death Young Child 3.07 question is: Did the corporation that made that gamble win? That s your decision. We say that if public safety is to be served and justice rendered they must not win this horrendous gamble. That s why you are here, serving as the conscience of this community. With your verdict you have the opportunity and the responsibility to serve as the conscience of this community and one; tell the Taylors what their family and their son means to this community and the value which this community places on young David s life and the lives of all of our children. And two; tell the corporation if their gamble with the safety of our children paid off. COMMENT:In almost every summation, skilled trial attorneys take time to stress the importance and magnitude of the jury s role and function in society, in general, and in the case before them, in particular. Above, counsel relies on the popular but highly effective conscience of the community argument. Counsel embellishes the argument by analogizing the defendant s actions, or more specifically, its failure to act, to gambling. The notion of gambling is inherently associated with carelessness and indifference. This will certainly strike a chord with jurors as they weigh the damages, particularly, the exemplary damages. Note that counsel again weaves the idea that the defendant valued profit over safety into the argument. As previously mentioned, this theme is repeatedly stressed throughout counsel s summation and will no doubt be remembered when the jurors retire to deliberate Society Places High Value on the Lives of Children and Seeks to Protect Them from Danger If there anything more precious in our society than the lives of our children? The entire country was captured for fifty-six hours by the incredible efforts to save Jessica McClure from the well and the country sighed a collective sigh of relief when she was saved. Look around us and we see our regard for the safety of our children: School Zone-Reduce Speed; crossing guards and child-proof prescription bottles. But who is to assume the responsibility for the safety of our children; parents obviously; the schools and governments? definitely. But there is another group which must assume their share of this responsibility: the manufacturers of children s products.
8 0008 VERSACOMP (4.2 ) COMPOSE2 (4.05) 04/21/99 (16:36) J:\VRS\DAT\0030\3.GML --- R030MASTER.STY V POST Summation 3 8 COMMENT: Counsel expertly highlights the importance of children s safety to society. He recalls an incident that captured the interest and concern of the entire country. This will remind the jury that our society highly values the lives of its children and will go to great lengths to ensure their safety and well-being. To further stress this point, he lists several examples of how society seeks to protect its children. He ties these generalizations to this specific case by discussing those individuals who are responsible for protecting innocent children, which, of course, includes the defendant Jury Must Send Message to Defendant Safety Must Come Before Profit Therefore, you have another role as the conscience of this community, to send a message to manufacturers. This talk about money began when the defendant talked of money in their board room, when they made that disastrous, profitmotivated decision not to recall this product because it would cost them four million dollars. When you walk through that jury room door, you will have the opportunity, on behalf of all parents, citizens and consumers in this great country, to talk directly to the Board of Directors of these corporations, because believe me, they are watching this trial. It s very likely that in serving in your role as a juror in this case, you will never again have the opportunity to do so much good, for so many of your fellow citizens, by demanding safe products for our children, by demanding protection of the public from defective products, and sending a clear message to corporations which ignore safety that such actions will be punished in the courts of this state. If your verdict is large enough, your voices will be heard by the entire industry with the message that we, the citizens of Texas, value human life infinitely more than we value the profits of corporation.
9 0009 VERSACOMP (4.2 ) COMPOSE2 (4.05) 04/21/99 (16:36) J:\VRS\DAT\0030\3.GML --- R030MASTER.STY V POST Wrongful Death Young Child 3.09 COMMENT: Counsel here scores several important points. Note that he emphasizes the impact that this jury s decision will have, not only upon the defendant, but upon the corporate world, in general. Again, discussing the value of life in terms of money can be very difficult and uncomfortable. Thus, counsel turns the tables and points to the defendant as the one who initiated the discussion of money as it was the defendant who decided to place profit before safety. Counsel specifically points out that a product recall would have cost the defendant four million dollars. Note that this is the exact amount requested by the plaintiffs as compensation for the loss of their son. Placing a value on life can seem arbitrary and capricious. Therefore, counsel attaches some logic to the task by asking for the exact amount of profit gained by the defendant for failing to recall the hazardous product. He also points out that a substantial verdict will go beyond the reaches of the defendant s pockets and be heard by manufacturers all over the country Placing a Dollar Value on Life Analogy to Masterpiece Painting What is this child s life worth in our community. Is four million dollars enough? Counsel says four million dollars is too much money. How much is four million dollars? Ladies and Gentlemen, we live in a society in which paint on canvas recently sold for fifty-three million dollars. Why? Because it was the work of a master, Irises by Van Gogh. If this were a lawsuit for negligent destruction of that fifty-three million dollar Van Gogh painting, that would be the amount which justice would demand. If a jury decided that fifty-three million dollars is too much money and awarded only twenty-six and one-half million dollars, that would not be justice, that would be half justice and half justice is injustice. Is the creation of the greatest Master of them all, the human life of a child, worth at least the four million dollars we are seeking? The answer is, it s priceless, because we can t replace it, so we have to talk of money. But, remember who talked of money first. Money was inserted into this scenario because the corporate board placed profits ahead of safety.
10 0010 VERSACOMP (4.2 ) COMPOSE2 (4.05) 04/21/99 (16:36) J:\VRS\DAT\0030\3.GML --- R030MASTER.STY V POST Summation 3 10 COMMENT: Counsel employs a very effective and often used technique to underscore how the jury can assign a monetary value to human life. He analogizes life to a piece of artwork but not just any artwork, he refers to the painting of a master. At first glance, the jurors may be hesitant to award millions of dollars to the plaintiffs. After all, few people have ever had to deal with one million dollars, let alone four million. He eases the jurors minds by reminding them that people pay numerous times that amount for a mere painting, thus, they should not worry about awarding a substantial sum to the plaintiffs. His comments regarding awarding less than the value of the painting are very effective and encourages the jury not to underestimate the decedent s life Dehumanizing the Defendant Money is The Only Thing a Corporation Understands Serve as the conscience of this community and assure that this never happens again. How do you accomplish this? Remember what we re dealing with here. The defendant is a corporation. A corporation has no heart, it has no soul, it has no nerve center, it has only bank accounts. It exists solely to produce profits and converses only in the language of money and is motivated only by effects of profits. How can this profit-motivated corporation receive the message that the citizens of Texas will not tolerate corporate greed over product safety? Only by an award by this jury that substantially effects profits. Now, ladies and gentlemen, I told you that they gambled. They gambled with the public safety, they gambled with David s life and they gambled with the jury system. They gambled that their lawyers could come into this Court and could keep your verdict under four million dollars, because Ladies and Gentlemen, it would have cost them four million dollars to recall this product. So, if you return a verdict of two million dollars, they ve won. There will be celebrations in that Board of Directors room because, by their treacherous decision they would have saved two million dollars. If you return a verdict of three million dollars, it s the same thing. If you return a verdict of four million dollars, they broke even but they have no motivation not to make the same decision in the future.
11 0011 VERSACOMP (4.2 ) COMPOSE2 (4.05) 04/21/99 (16:36) J:\VRS\DAT\0030\3.GML --- R030MASTER.STY V POST Wrongful Death Young Child 3.11 COMMENT: Whenever the defendant is a corporation, it is wise to remind the jury that while a corporation may be deemed a person under the law, a corporation does not have the characteristics of a person. It is a thing; a mechanism for making money and nothing more. The effect is to impersonalize the defendant so that the jury will not feel bad about depriving it of assets. Note that counsel wisely emphasizes that returning anything less than a verdict for four million dollars will be considered a victory for the defendant. This provides an excellent segue into a discussion of exemplary damages Argument for Exemplary Damages Full Justice How can you best serve your fellow citizens, get the attention of the Board of Directors and render a full measure of justice to this fine family? First, by returning a verdict in the amount of four million dollars in compensatory damages: and secondly, by an award of exemplary damages. We have a simple method in Texas for what constitutes a fair, reasonable exemplary damages award in a case like this. It s called treble damages. In this case, in addition to the four million dollars in compensatory damages, the message that must go out from this jury, which will be heard resoundingly in the board room, is conveyed by an exemplary damage award in the amount of twelve million dollars. Corporations are motivated by profit. They operate on numbers and if, on a four million dollar gamble, they lose twelve million additional dollars, then you are conversing fluently in the language of corporations, and that turns their profit-motivated minds to the production of safer products. On voir dire we told you that the evidence would support twelve million dollars. You know now what we knew then that full justice demands both punishment and that an example be made of this defendant for the entire industry. You know now what we knew then, that the devastation visited upon this young couple cannot be compensated and justice fully served by less than four million dollars in compensatory and twelve million dollars in punitive damages.
12 0012 VERSACOMP (4.2 ) COMPOSE2 (4.05) 04/21/99 (16:36) J:\VRS\DAT\0030\3.GML --- R030MASTER.STY V POST Summation 3 12 COMMENT: It is important to remember that the law of damages differs in each jurisdiction, particularly with respect to exemplary or punitive damages. For example, in Louisiana, punitive damages are not permitted in a wrongful death action, thus, arguing for such an award would constitute grounds for reversal. Texas permits both compensatory and exemplary damages in wrongful death actions and as such, counsel sets forth a forceful argument for the recovery of both types of awards in this case. Note that counsel returns to one of his main themes; profit over safety. Without sounding vengeful, counsel explains that the jury must speak the language of the defendant corporation, and that is money. He stresses that the only way to reach the defendant is to reach into their corporate pockets, take away their profit and then some. In other words, show them that there must be an equitable balance between profit and consumer safety or they will pay dearly for the inequity. Counsel also makes the important point that full justice requires both compensatory and punitive damages What is a Child s Life Worth? Discussion Regarding the Value of the Life of a Child Analogy to Prize Fighters and Race Horses What is this child s life worth? Counsel says four million dollars is too much money to replace the life of a priceless child. In a society in which two men, Spinks and Tyson, recently split twenty-three million dollars for ninety seconds in a boxing ring, can four million dollars possibly be adequate compensation for the loss of the priceless life of a child. What is the child s life worth? If this lawsuit were not over the death of a child, but over the death of the magnificent race horse, Seattle Slew, the owners of that horse would prove ten million dollars in damages and be entitled to receive it. Why? Because checks were written for ten million dollars to buy that horse. Thus, a jury which awarded five million dollars would not be rendering justice, but would be rendering half justice, and anything less than full justice is injustice. But we are not here about paintings and race horses and boxers; we are here about the world s most precious commodity, the life of a child. What is this child s life worth? In this case, of these facts, full justice demands a verdict in the amount of four million dollars compensatory and twelve million dollars exemplary damages.
13 0013 VERSACOMP (4.2 ) COMPOSE2 (4.05) 04/21/99 (16:36) J:\VRS\DAT\0030\3.GML --- R030MASTER.STY V POST Wrongful Death Young Child 3.14 COMMENT: In case any juror missed the point of counsel s analogy regarding the value of the life of a child compared to a masterpiece painting, counsel returns to the subject to analogize the value of a child s life to the life of a race horse. He also mentions that boxers can earn upwards of twenty-three million dollars for a single fight. These types of analogies are concrete subjects that the jurors can relate to and they tend to ease any apprehensions regarding the decision to return a large verdict Closing Line Full and Complete Justice Ladies and Gentlemen, I have carried the mantle of responsibility for this lawsuit and for the value of this young man s life on my shoulders for four years, and I m now going to lift that mantle of responsibility from my shoulders and place it trustingly in your hands. And all we ask is that when you go home to your family and they say, What did you do in court?, you can look them straight in the eye and say, We helped to make this country a safer place to live, we showed a family that their son was a valued member of this community, and we rendered full and complete justice. COMMENT: Counsel concludes this outstanding summation by reminding the jurors that he trusts them to render full and complete justice. It is always good to express confidence in the jury. Paying deference to the jury has a reciprocal effect in that when counsel shows respect and belief in the jury, the jury will return the tribute in kind. He imparts a sense of patriotism and reverence which can only be attained by returning a verdict for the requested amount General Comments About the Structure of The Argument This summation obviously had a great impact on the jury as they awarded a very substantial verdict for the death of this child. This is especially important to note because wrongful death actions involving young children generally do not result in substantial compensatory or exemplary awards. In this case, counsel skillfully and successfully challenged this injustice. Howard Nations in this wonderful summation provides an excellent example of how to argue the death of a child and how to use the technique of verbal images weaved with rhetorical questions. This summation is a prime example that closing arguments do not have to be lengthy and cover every issue in the case in order to be effective. It is short, sweet and to the point but has enormous impact. It is an absolutely magnificent exercise in the art of summation.
Trying a Wrongful Death Case: Voir Dire as a Bridge to Summation By: Ben Rubinowitz and Evan Torgan Damages in a wrongful death case are fraught with complex issues and legal challenges. While it is easy
Medical Malpractice VOIR DIRE QUESTIONS INTRODUCTION: Tell the jurors that this is a very big and a very important case. Do a SHORT summary of the case and the damages we are seeking. This summary should
Oratory Techniques for Effective Opening Statements and Summations Ben Rubinowitz And Evan Torgan Without question, the ultimate goal of every trial lawyer is to win. To accomplish this goal, the lawyer
JUROR S MANUAL (Prepared by the State Bar of Michigan) Your Role as a Juror You ve heard the term jury of one s peers. In our country the job of determining the facts and reaching a just decision rests,
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE 16TH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR MONROE COUNTY, FLORIDA JENNIFER WINDISCH, Plaintiff, v. CIVIL DIVISION CASE NO: 2007-CA-1174-K JOHN SUNDIN, M.D., RHODA SMITH, M.D., LAURRAURI
T h e G i f t o f t h e M a g i p T h e G i f t o f t h e M a g i ONE DOLLAR AND EIGHTY-SEVEN CENTS. That was all. She had put it aside, one cent and then another and then another, in her careful buying
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS HOUSTON DIVISION UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. CRIMINAL ACTION H-00-0000 DEFENDANT(S) JURY INSTRUCTIONS I. General A. Introduction Members of the Jury:
OPENING STATEMENT FROM THE DEFENSE PERSPECTIVE BY JAMES C. MORROW MORROW, WILLNAUER & KLOSTERMAN, L.L.C. 53--1 Where Voir Dire is an opportunity to give the jurors an outline of your themes, opening statement
PEOPLE V. HARRY POTTER THE COURT: Members of the jury, the defendant, Harry Potter, is charged in a one-count information which reads as follows: On or about November 23, 2008, HARRY POTTER, did unlawfully
Trying Damages in the Wrongful Death Case of an Adult Child By Ben Rubinowitz and Evan Torgan When a young worker, who is married, with three children and who is earning $100,000 per year, dies after falling
What the Jury Hears in Products Liability Litigation The View From Both Sides and the Middle Theresa Zagnoli, Communications Expert and Jury Consultant Susan T. Dwyer, Defense Lawyer Jeffrey A. Lichtman,
Common Myths About Personal Injury and Wrongful Death Cases 1 By B. Keith Williams There are several myths about accident cases and the attorneys that handle them. It is important to keep these myths in
1 THE COURT: You have been selected and sworn to determine the facts and render a verdict in the case of the Commonwealth / 1 of Pennsylvania versus Robert Greene, who is charged with one count of robbery,
Page 1 Table of Content The Psychic Lotto Formula Jackpot to Success System... 4 Part 1 Channeling the Power of Your Mind to Success... 6 Part 2 Visualization... 12 Part 3 Integrating Luck and Making it
Injured on the Job Your Rights under FELA Quick Facts: What To Do If Injured 1. Consult your own doctor for treatment. Give your doctor a complete history of how your injury happened. Make sure that the
Cooper Hurley Injury Lawyers 2014 Granby Street, Suite 200 Norfolk, VA, 23517 (757) 455-0077 (866) 455-6657 (Toll Free) YOUR RIGHTS WHEN YOU ARE INJURED ON THE RAILROAD Cooper Hurley Injury Lawyers 2014
LINA AND HER NURSE. SUNDAY-SCHOOL UNI0 N, 200 MULBERRY-STREET, N. Y. LINA AND HER NURSE. SUNDAY-SCHOOL UNION, 200 MULBERRY-STREET, NEW YORK. LINA AND HER NURSE. L INA lived away in that land of the East
XARELTO: WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW ABOUT IT 1 Surgeries to replace knees and hips are commonplace in today s hospitals. Xarelto is a drug prescribed by doctors to prevent blood clots after those surgeries.
Devotion NT298 CHILDREN S DEVOTIONS FOR THE WEEK OF: LESSON TITLE: Paul s First Missionary Journey THEME: God has a calling on the lives of every one of His children! SCRIPTURE: Acts 12:25 13:52 Dear Parents
CAUSE NO. 2009V-224 COLLEEN MIDDLETON AND BOBBY R}\Y MIDDLETON, INDIVID UALLY AND AS REPRESENTATIVES OF THE ESTATE OF ROBERT MIDDLETON FOR AND ON BEHALF OF ALL THOSE ENTITLED TO RECOVER FOR HIS DEATH UNDER
DEPUY HIP REPLACEMENTS: WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW ABOUT THEM 1 As people get older, some of their bones actually do get weary and tired. Sometimes, bones and joints need to be replaced by doctors to improve
Consumer Awareness How to Keep From Getting Ripped Off by Big Insurance Provided as an educational service by: Anthony D. Castelli, Esq. Concentration in Auto and Work Related Injuries (513) 621-2345 ATTENTION!!!
ROLES TO ASSIGN 1. Judge 2. Courtroom Deputy 3. Prosecutor 1 opening statement 4. Prosecutor 2 direct of Dana Capro 5. Prosecutor 3 direct of Jamie Medina 6. Prosecutor 4 cross of Pat Morton 7. Prosecutor
OPENING STATEMENTS Introduction The opening statement is a most important part of trying a lawsuit. Many lawyers do not treat the opening statement with the importance it deserves. Many opening statements
Pastor Spotlight Martha Fisher, CBC Women s Pastor Inspiration Martha Fisher, Women s Pastor at Community Bible Church, leads with a passion to reach, teach and help the women of our community for Jesus.
Third-Party Funding of Individual Lawsuits: A Rational Dialogue Kirby Griffis Hollingsworth LLP THE SCENE: Boardroom of Rational Actor Widgets Co. RAWCO makes widgets, which have many useful applications
Attachment No. 2 Proposed Plain Language Revisions to Colorado Criminal Jury Instruction Chapter 1:04 and Chapter 3 The work of the Plain Language Subcommittee is set forth below. For comparison, the redrafted
Mandatory Arbitration The Alternative To Trial By Christopher M. Davis, Attorney at Law 206-727-4000 Phone: 206-727-4000 Fax: 206-727-4001 email@example.com Copyright 2007 by Christopher Michael
ZOFRAN: WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW ABOUT IT 1 When people seek relief from nausea, they might eat a few crackers, drink ginger ale, or take an over-the-counter medication like Pepto-Bismol. But, when the nausea
ISI Debtor Testimonials April 2015 ISI Tackling problem debt together The following are the words of debtors who have availed of the ISI s debt solutions and are real cases. They have reviewed and agreed
Table of Contents 1. What is a wrongful death claim?... 2 2. Who may recover compensation for a wrongful death?... 3 3. How is a wrongful death claim commenced?... 4 4. What types of losses are compensated
Whereas I was Blind, Now I See John 9: 1-11; 25 We all know that great hymn well: Amazing grace, how sweet the sound, that saved a wretch like me; I once was lost, but now I m found; was blind, but now
SETTLEGOODE v. PORTLAND PUBLIC SCHOOLS, et al CV-00-313-ST JURY INSTRUCTIONS FOLLOWING CLOSE OF EVIDENCE These instructions will be in three parts: first, general rules that define and control your duties
THE BASICS Getting a Divorce in New York State Either the wife or the husband can ask a Court for a divorce. In this booklet, we say that the wife is the person who will go to Court to request a divorce
New York Law Journal Wednesday, July 31, 2002 HEADLINE: BYLINE: Trial Advocacy, Cross-Examination: The Basics Ben B. Rubinowitz and Evan Torgan BODY: Cross-examination involves relatively straightforward
KYLE AND WES ARE AMONG THE NEXT GENERATION OF GREAT TRIAL LAWYERS. Bruce Kaster, Kaster & Lynch, P.A. Ocala, Florida Superior knowledge. Relentless advocacy. Those words perfectly describe Farrar & Ball
Open Your Eyes Wrongful Death and Survival Actions In Maryland & the District of Columbia A Wrongful Death Action What is a wrongful death lawsuit? In the context of a medical malpractice lawsuit, wrongful
Jury Duty Information HANDBOOK FOR JURORS IN CRIMINAL AND CIVIL CASES IN THE 29 th Judicial Court For the Parish of St. Charles Courthouse Hahnville, Louisiana JUDGES EMILE R. ST.PIERRE Division C M. LAUREN
EARLY CARE & EDUCATION LAW UNIT Publication Date: November 2013 WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW ABOUT SMALL CLAIMS COURT In the operation of your child care business you may encounter problems which force you to
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF JACKSON COUNTY, MISSOURI AT INDEPENDENCE MICHELLE TALIAFERRO, ) MARIETTA TALIAFERRO and ) KEITH TALIAFERRO, ) ) Plaintiffs, ) ) v. ) Case No. 02CV233442 ) Division 16 GREEN VALLEY
T h e C o p a n d t h e A n t h e m p The Cop and the Anthem S OAPY MOVED RESTLESSLY ON HIS SEAT in Madison Square. There are certain signs to show that winter is coming. Birds begin to fly south. Women
ASBESTOS LITIGATION YOUR GUIDE TO THE LEGAL PROCESS INSIDE > About Simmons Hanly Conroy > Filing an Asbestos Lawsuit > Resources Hard at Work for You > Results That Matter > Legal FAQ > Taking the First
From Opening to Summation, Making First Impressions Count By Ben Rubinowitz and Evan Torgan There is an old adage that every trial lawyer should accept as gospel: "You don't get a second chance to make
MINNESOTA JUDICIAL TRAINING UPDATE CRIMINAL VOIR DIRE QUESTIONS ASKED BY THE COURT THE MN SUPREME COURT TASK FORCE ON JURY SELECTION HAS RECOMMENDED THAT JUDGES BE MORE PROACTIVE IN ASKING INITIAL QUESTIONS
Background Having a motorcycle accident is traumatic and can often entail substantial damage to your beloved motorcycle and serious injuries. If the accident was caused or contributed to by the bad driving
TOP 10 MOST COMMON MISTAKES MADE IN HANDLING YOUR OWN INJURY CLAIM More times than not, your personal injury claim will be a battle with an insurance company. A highly trained adjuster will be assigned
The HIDDEN COST Of Proving Your Innocence Law-abiding citizens use guns to defend themselves against criminals as many as 2.5 million times every year, or about 6,850 times per day. This means that each
p T h e L a s t L e a f IN A SMALL PART OF THE CITY WEST OF Washington Square, the streets have gone wild. They turn in different directions. They are broken into small pieces called places. One street
VOIR DIRE FROM THE DEFENSE PERSPECTIVE BY JAMES C. MORROW MORROW, WILLNAUER & KLOSTERMAN, L.L.C. 44--1 You have been sitting in your chair at counsel table for a good part of the day, perhaps making an
Do You Have a Case? Truck Accident ebooklet Andrew Miller 201 South 3rd Street Logansport, IN 46947 P: (574) 722-6676 www.starrausten.com Disclaimer No attempt is made to establish an attorney-client relationship
Devotion NT320 CHILDREN S DEVOTIONS FOR THE WEEK OF: LESSON TITLE: The Gift of Love THEME: God desires for us to demonstrate His love! SCRIPTURE: 1 Corinthians 13:1-13 Dear Parents Welcome to Bible Time
You are probably reading this guide because you were recently in an automobile accident. Now you are faced with some difficulties. The tasks of managing your care and your insurance claim can be confusing
STEPS IN A TRIAL Note to Students: For a civil case, substitute the word plaintiff for the word prosecution. A number of events occur during a trial, and most must happen according to a particular sequence.
FURR & HENSHAW 1900 Oak Street, P.O. Box 2909 Myrtle Beach, SC 29578 Phone: (843) 626-7621 and 1534 Blanding Street Columbia, SC 29201 Phone: (803) 252-4050 YOUR AUTOMOBILE ACCIDENT CASE The purpose of
IMPROVING SETTLEMENT SAVVY Kathy Perkins Kathy Perkins LLC, Workplace Law & Mediation www.kathy-perkins.com In these difficult economic times, parties may be looking to reduce litigation costs and risk
Form: Plaintiff's original petition-wrongful Death [Name], PLAINTIFF vs. [Name], DEFENDANT [ IN THE [Type of Court] COURT [Court number] PLAINTIFF'S ORIGINAL PETITION 1. DISCOVERY CONTROL PLAN 1.1 Plaintiff
Settling Your Injury Case... Without a Lawyer How to maximize the value of your claim under $10,000 The information provided in this report is for informational purposes only. Shulman DuBois LLC does not
DUI Voir Dire Questions INTRODUCTION 1. Can you give me an example of a law that you disagree with (i.e., the speed limit)? 2. Someone tell me what the First Amendment protects? You see Ladies and Gentlemen,
A story of Nick Vujicic -- no arms, no legs 沒手沒腳的 Nick Vujicic 之故事 My name is Nick Vujicic and I give God the Glory for how He has used my testimony to touch thousands of hearts around the world! I was
SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA, COUNTY OF CONTRA COSTA Mock Trial Script The Case of a Stolen Car This mock trial is appropriate for middle and high school students. The script includes a role for a narrator,
Maximizing Strikes for Cause MAXIMIZING STRIKES FOR CAUSE IN CRIMINAL CASES BY ROBERT R. SWAFFORD I. INTRODUCTION This paper will introduce an approach to jury selection that is radically different from
TOP TEN TIPS FOR WINNING YOUR CASE IN JURY SELECTION PRESENTED BY JEFF KEARNEY KEARNEY & WESTFALL 2501 PARKVIEW STREET, SUITE 300 FORT WORTH, TEXAS 76102 (817) 336-5600 LUBBOCK CRIMINAL DEFENSE LAWYERS
p T w o T h a n k s g i v i n g D a y G e n t l e m e n THERE IS ONE DAY THAT IS OURS. THERE IS ONE day when all Americans go back to the old home and eat a big dinner. Bless the day. The President gives
A REASONABLE PERSPECTIVE ON RECREATIONAL INJURY LIABILITY James C. Kozlowski, J.D., Ph.D. 1988 James C. Kozlowski Driving an automobile is probably the most dangerous activity in our daily lives. Certainly,
SMALL CLAIMS COURT What Is Small Claims Court? Nebraska law requires that every county court in the state have a division known as Small Claims Court (Nebraska Revised Statute 25-2801). Small Claims Court
INTRODUCTORY REMARKS and INITIAL VOIR DIRE (CRIMINAL) (JUDGE O. H. EATON, JR. ) Good morning ladies and gentlemen. Welcome to the criminal division of the Circuit Court. The Circuit Court considers criminal
Table of Contents Introduction 3 Why Not Settle With the Insurance Companies 4 What to do First 7 Hiring a Personal Injury Lawyer 11 How Much is My Claim Worth? 14 What if I have a Pre-Existing Condition?
JURY INSTRUCTIONS PRELIMINARY INSTRUCTIONS 1. ANTITRUST CLAIMS 2. Elements of Monopoly Claim 2.1 Definition of Monopoly Power 2.2 Relevant Market 2.3 Existence of Monopoly Power 2.4 Willful Maintenance
Dear Expectant Mother, We are Lisa and DJ and we ve been married for a very happy twelve years. Having a child is something that we have always dreamed of. Like most people, we assumed it would come naturally
 JMCA Civ 37 JAMAICA IN THE COURT OF APPEAL SUPREME COURT CIVIL APPEAL NO 41/2007 BEFORE: THE HON MR JUSTICE MORRISON JA THE HON MR JUSTICE BROOKS JA THE HON MS JUSTICE LAWRENCE-BESWICK JA (AG) BETWEEN
To All BIS Digital, Inc. Associates: It is with deep sorrow that I have to announce the passing of Bob Wolfe. After fighting cancer for the last several months he had called me last Friday from the hospital
Dealing With Weaknesses and Maintaining Credibility By Ben Rubinowitz and Evan Torgan While many trial lawyers focus on the credibility of their witnesses, a truism remains: No one s credibility is more
Immigration and the Next America Most Reverend José H. Gomez Archbishop of Los Angeles Rotary Club of Los Angeles Los Angeles, California January 10, 2013 My friends, I am honored to be here with you this
WORKERS COMPENSATION & YOUR RIGHTS 655 Florida Grove Road Mailing Address P.O. Box 760 Woodbridge, NJ 07095 (732) 324-7600 GILL & CHAMAS Raymond A. Gill, Jr.* Peter Chamas* James Pagliuca Michael J. Hanus
MARRIAGE TESTIMONY Dear Friends I am very glad to share with you my testimony. By the grace of God I am married to Victoria and all my prayers have been answered. The wonderful thing is our Marriage has
Gift of the Magi By O Henry One dollar and eighty-seven cents. That was all. And sixty cents of it in the smallest pieces of money - pennies. Pennies saved one and two at a time by negotiating with the
Copyright (c) 2015 Christopher Small and The Art of Lawyering. All rights reserved. 1 In this special report, I ll be sharing with you the ten biggest mistakes that lawyers make when marketing their law
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF MISSOURI WESTERN DIVISION UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, ) ) Plaintiff, ) ) vs. ) Case No. 09-00296-03-CR-W-FJG ) ROBERT E. STEWART, ) ) Defendant.
Chapter 35 Kevin Reichard Senior Financial Network SENIOR SUPER HERO (Story told by the Reverse Mortgage Professional) I was sitting at my desk in my home office comparing two great job offers after me,
ALTERNATIVE DISPUTE RESOLUTION CENTER 840 Newport Center Drive Suite 450 Newport Beach, CA 92660-6324 Telephone: (949) 760-5288 Fax: (949) 760-5289 NFL, RETIRED PLAYERS RESOLVE CONCUSSION LITIGATION; COURT-APPOINTED
THE FLORIDA JURY: SEEKING JUSTICE FOR ALL An article produced and distributed by The Law Office of Keith R. Taylor to provide Florida residents with insight into the jury trial system. This article explains
In this chapter, we present the theory of consumer preferences on risky outcomes. The theory is then applied to study the demand for insurance. Consider the following story. John wants to mail a package