Don t Drink the Water: Clean Coal s Downside

Size: px
Start display at page:

Download "Don t Drink the Water: Clean Coal s Downside"

Transcription

1 Don t Drink the Water: Clean Coal s Downside By Suemedha Sood Thursday, January 31, 2008 at 10:35 am Photo Credit: istockphoto Merle Wertman, now 62, was diagnosed with Polycythemia Vera five years ago. He had no idea what Polycythemia Vera was. That isn t surprising, considering less than one in 100,000 Americans a year are diagnosed with the extremely rare form of bone marrow cancer, that causes an abnormal increase in blood cells. What is surprising is that Wertman is one of 131 people near his hometown of Tamaqua, Penn., now battling this rare cancer.

2 Illustration by:matt Mahurin In eastern Pennsylvania s Carbon, Luzerne, and Schuylkill counties, that surround the Tamaqua borough, the rate of the rare blood cancer is 4.5 times the national rate, according to data from the Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry (ATSDR), a federal public health agency of the Dept. of Health and Human Services. The cancer cluster (shown on the map below) follows along Ben Titus Road, next to the Big Gorilla coal combustion waste dump of the Northeastern Power Co. The area is also home to the Superfund sites McAdoo Associates, Air Product & Chemicals Inc., Expert Management Inc. and ICI Americas Inc. They have no idea what it comes from. Nobody knows, said Wertman. Is it the environment, is it the water? No one knows. A retired prison guard, Wertman has lived in and around Tamaqua his entire life. He gets angry when he thinks about the blood cancer rate in his hometown and the lack of accountability for its causes. The Department of Health in Pennsylvania sucks, he said. [They] say there s nothing wrong with the environment around here It s bullshit, back and forth. While multiple environmental factors could well be at play, much evidence points to the waste produced by coal-fired energy plants. Although the ATSDR did not report a specific link between polycythemia vera and fly ash [a type of coal ash], said Dante Picciano, a local scientist and environmentalist active on the issue of coal ash dumping, we believe that the relationship between the two should be at the top of the list for any investigations into the specific cause of the rare cancer.

3 This is also of concern to Dr. Paul Roda, an oncologist and hematologist who is now treating roughly one-third of the PV patients in the area. In my mind, he said, it s certainly a cluster. You don t see that many cases in a very small area particularly a very low population area. Roda did point out that another cause could be the materials dumped at the nearby McAdoo superfund site. In the 1970s, toxic chemicals were dumped down a mine ventilation shaft, which led to the Environmental Protection Agency classifying it as a superfund site. We haven t done enough studies to know if this is due to coal ash or the material that was dumped down the site. Roda said. Coal combustion waste, or coal ash, is the solid waste byproduct created when coal is burned. One million railroad cars could be filled with the amount of coal ash produced from coal combustion in the United States each year. When coal combustion waste is disposed in a dump site usually a mine, landfill, waste pond or out in the open in a sand-and-gravel pit the toxins from the ash can leach into the groundwater and surface water, often migrating to the drinking water. In many areas, where residents get their water from wells, those toxins dissolve directly into the drinking water. According to the Environmental Protection Agency s own research, coal ash dumping can lead to higher rates of cancer, developmental problems in children and adverse effects in women of child-bearing age. Despite the fact that coal ash contains mercury, lead, arsenic, chromium, cadmium, selenium, beryllium, and other toxic metals, the EPA has yet to categorize coal ash as hazardous waste. In addition, coal ashhas been found to be up to 100 times more radioactive than nuclear waste, due to the concentrations of uranium and thorium that increase 10-fold after coal is burned. But Northeastern Power Co. Plant Manager Edward Missal says he isn t aware of any links between coal ash dumping and cancer. The EPA has taken a look at that and pretty much ruled that out as far as what I m under the understanding of, he said. The solid waste side of coal is being overlooked as environmentalists focus their attention on air pollution and as government agencies and coal companies push clean coal technologies. Cleaner coal technologies actually produce more toxic coal ash in the resulting solid wase than dirty coal technologies, says Jeff Stant of the Clean Air Task Force. These technologies pulverize low-grade fuels in a way that releases fewer pollutants into the air. But those pollutants have to go somewhere, and they end up as ash. Stant was a contributing author for a recently released report investigating 15 mine disposal sites in Pennsylvania, most of which are dumping sites for ash from Fluidized Bed Combustion (FBC), a clean coal technology. The study, entitled Impacts on Water Quality from Placement of Coal Combustion Waste in Pennsylvania Coal Mines, found coal ash to be contaminating the groundwater and surface water at levels exceeding federal drinking water standards by 30 to 40 times. Clean FBC plants produce at least five times more coal ash by volume than standard plants do. These plants inject limestone into the burn chamber to capture more emissions and therefore release fewer emissions-thus the misnomer, clean. But, the limestone leaves behind a burned

4 residual, which ends up in the ash. The bigger problem is that clean plants burn more wastecoal than actual coal. Waste-coal consists of the impurities removed from coal in addition to some coal itself, and it contains an ash content that s three times higher than regular coal. Most of the new clean coal plants proposed in Pennsylvania, West Virginia, and other states will be located next to mines expected to serve as dump sites for coal ash. The Department of Energy and the coal companies actually promote coal ash disposal as a clean coal technology. The following methods for disposal are being promoted as beneficial uses for the environment: mine-filling, agricultural use, use in cement, incorporation into concrete, and use in wallboards. The DOE and the coal industry say these uses are eco-friendly. They say that dumping in mines or mine reclamation as they call it will clean up the water draining from mines by lowering its acidity. The opposite is actually true, according to the Pennsylvania study, which found that in two-thirds of the sites, more toxic concentrations known to leach from ash were measured in the water after the ash was dumped in the mines. When used for soil amendment in agricultural use, the toxic metals from the ash can be taken up by plants and, again, leech out of the soil into the groundwater. The toxins in the ash can potentially pose problems in cement and concrete, especially in unmonitored facilities. I have never seen levels of lead in a mine pool of that magnitude, says Robert Gadinski, another contributing author of the report. And that includes lead sites where lead waste is supposed to be dumped. One example at Marjol Battery in Scranton, Penn., where they dump battery casings and battery waste even at that site, we never found lead at such high levels. Gadinski, a geologist retired from Pennsylvania s Department of Environmental Protection, knows about the dangers of coal ash. That s why he was none too pleased when he first read in the newspaper about a plan by PPL Utilities to start dumping coal ash in the mine by his house in Mowry, Pennsylvania. I know that there are mine tunnels from the valley where I live into these mine workings, Gadinski said. Any water that comes out of it is going to drain into the valley and go right to the groundwater. Hundreds of wells are at risk here. A month later, PPL was ordered by the state Dept. of Environmental Protection to clean up a spill of 100 million gallons of coal ash in the Delaware River due to the toxic and carcinogenic nature of the discharge. And that s the same stuff they want to dump here, saying it s beneficial, said Gadinski referring to the Dept. of Environmental Protection. Gadinksi has been fighting the initiative for three years, filing complaints with the state government and appealing the matter to the federal government s Office of Surface Mining. All to no avail. Though the project was on hold while a new co-generation plant (Schuylkill Energy) took over, the Dept. of Environmental Protection still supports plans to go forward. The EPA acknowledges that coal ash dumping has contaminated the water at levels exceeding federal drinking water standards in Indiana, Maryland, New York, North Carolina, South Carolina, Texas, Virginia, and Wisconsin. The only reason more cases have not been documented is that most dump sites lack monitoring systems to detect contamination, says Lisa Evans, an attorney with the Earth Justice environmental group. Where we re finding cases of damage is where there is monitoring data, said Evans. But it s not where the worst disposal practices are. [For example,] data from around 2000 showed that

5 Wisconsin had more sites with contaminated water than other states, but that s because Wisconsin actually had a better state program, so they were able to detect the contamination. Evans insists that even though hard data has only been documented in certain states, this is really an issue everywhere you have coal and don t have strict regulations for its disposal. The EPA released a report publicizing the health risks of coal ash dumping in Eight years later, the agency has still taken no action to regulate disposal practices. In August 2007, the agency released a Notice of Data Availability on the Disposal of Coal Combustion Wastes requesting public comments on the data. Now, in the coming weeks, environmental groups will submit their comments and proposals to the EPA, calling for stricter regulations, better monitoring, and investigations to obtain data on coal ash dump sites all over the country. Whether anything will actually come of this is debatable. Wertman, the former prison guard from Tamaqua, says that in his hometown, politics gets in the way of tackling any of the environmental factors that could have caused his illness. He talks about a specific case in which the ATSDR admitted that Polycythemia Vera can be tied to environmental factors. Soon after the the public health agency published an abstract (available here) reporting this information in Blood, the science journal for the American Society of Hematology, agency officials started backpedaling. Now, anyone who tries searching for this information on the agency s website will find a statement contradicting the agency s own findings by claiming, No link has been found between environmental factors and PV cases in the Pennsylvania counties Schuylkill, Luzerne and Carbon. Dr. Zev Wainberg, an oncologist/hematologist at the Santa Monica-UCLA Medical Center and Orthopaedic Hospital, said that the high rates of such a rare disease in this area are surprising. Certainly it suggests, Wainberg said in an interview, that there s something environmental in that area that would promote an increased instance of that disease. Because this is an uncommon disease it s not a disease that affects that many people, typically, in a small population. But that being said, it s a lot easier to say that than it is to prove it. Comments 12 Comments stuartm Comment posted February 3, 6:54 pm Great article. Think about doing a piece on the biofuels industry and environmental problems in the production process. The EU is considering trade barriers for import of "carbon border taxes." Really interesting newer issue. ricky Comment posted February 2, 7:54 am I know Merle very well!

6 For 17 years my family and I lived on the same side of the block four houses away. About 13 years ago I built a house and moved to Ben Titus Rd Still Creek. This is the Road where we had 4 cases of Polycythemia Vera two in one house sadly to say one just passed away! Three years ago I was diagnosed with advanced Prostate Cancer. I agree that it is a big CLUSTER! The 500 block of Washington St. where Merle lives and I lived is also a BIG CLUSTER at last count there were 14 people with cancer sadly to say one just passed away! That is one block not the whole street. Our blocks are not very big! Do the math its not how we live its what we breathe and the water we drink. These local companies and superfund sites that pollute the environment should be responsible for what they are doing to our lives. WHEN IS IT ALL GOING TO END? ricky Comment posted February 2, 1:54 am I know Merle very well! For 17 years my family and I lived on the same side of the block four houses away. About 13 years ago I built a house and moved to Ben Titus Rd Still Creek. This is the Road where we had 4 cases of Polycythemia Vera two in one house sadly to say one just passed away! Three years ago I was diagnosed with advanced Prostate Cancer. I agree that it is a big CLUSTER! The 500 block of Washington St. where Merle lives and I lived is also a BIG CLUSTER at last count there were 14 people with cancer sadly to say one just passed away! That is one block not the whole street. Our blocks are not very big! Do the math its not how we live its what we breathe and the water we drink. These local companies and superfund sites that pollute the environment should be responsible for what they are doing to our lives. WHEN IS IT ALL GOING TO END? stuartm Comment posted February 3, 12:54 pm Great article. Think about doing a piece on the biofuels industry and environmental problems in the production process. The EU is considering trade barriers for import of "carbon border taxes." Really interesting newer issue. COLLEEN Comment posted January 10, 3:58 pm i I WOULD LIKE TO KNOW THE LOCATION OF THE 9 COAL ASH DUMPS THAT EXIST IN WISCONSIN. THANKS

7 COLLEEN Comment posted January 10, 11:58 pm i I WOULD LIKE TO KNOW THE LOCATION OF THE 9 COAL ASH DUMPS THAT EXIST IN WISCONSIN. THANKS lmkahl Comment posted August 17, 2:41 pm A little known company in Baltimore may have the answer to the fly ash dillema. They have pioneered a cement technology that utilizes 100% fly ash and no Portland cement check them out at adidas online Comment posted June 3, 1:02 am Thanks for this interesting post,i like it. Gregvl Comment posted June 25, 3:36 am Cerenetchinc and other companies are great, the only downfall is if a plant needs to offset the waste issue with the cost associated to utilize another solution, overall profits drop, and the bottom line does not look as promising as originally proposed to investors. At the cost of human lives, companies will gamble with what the overall outcome will be when they are charged with dumping fly ash waste into abandoned mines and the tie to lost lives. By the time this comes to fruition, the company will be well in advance and able to afford a nice settlement for everyone, and I am sure the paper trail of any identification to the negative affects of dumping fly ash in these mines will be well destroyed and ash in and of themselves. confidential shredding Comment posted August 9, 1:42 pm i liked the article just hate the story within. Water Damage Jacksonville Comment posted August 23, 8:08 am Think about doing a piece on the biofuels industry and environmental problems in the production process. The EU is considering trade barriers for import of carbon border taxes. Really interesting newer issue. cycjyf Comment posted October 20, 5:59 am

8 I can't believe how much of this I just wasn't aware of. Thank you for bringing more information to this topic for me. I'm truly grateful and really impressed.

350.270 Disposal of coal combustion by-products at surface coal mining operations -- Permitting process -- Requirements for disposal -- Authority for

350.270 Disposal of coal combustion by-products at surface coal mining operations -- Permitting process -- Requirements for disposal -- Authority for 350.270 Disposal of coal combustion by-products at surface coal mining operations -- Permitting process -- Requirements for disposal -- Authority for administrative regulations. (1) The cabinet may issue

More information

AP ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE 2012 SCORING GUIDELINES

AP ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE 2012 SCORING GUIDELINES AP ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE 2012 SCORING GUIDELINES Question1 Read the following article from the Fremont Gazette and answer the questions that follow. (a) Identify and describe TWO water-related environmental

More information

A pound of coal supplies enough electricity to power ten 100-watt light bulbs for about an hour.

A pound of coal supplies enough electricity to power ten 100-watt light bulbs for about an hour. Did You Know? A pound of coal supplies enough electricity to power ten 100-watt light bulbs for about an hour. Nonrenewable Coal Coal Basics Coal Takes Millions of Years To Create Coal is a combustible

More information

About Pure Earth and the Toxic Site Identification Program

About Pure Earth and the Toxic Site Identification Program About and the Toxic Site Identification Program is a New York based not-for-profit organization that partners with governments, NGOs and community groups to solve life-threatening pollution problems in

More information

Report on the Need for New York to Refinance the Superfund

Report on the Need for New York to Refinance the Superfund Page 1 of 5 Reports Policy Guide Reports Speeches Legislative Initiatives Report on the Need for New York to Refinance the Superfund June 11, 2003 Toxic Waste Many people around the country live in areas

More information

Compliance Guidance for Motor Vehicle Waste Disposal Wells in Oregon September 2015

Compliance Guidance for Motor Vehicle Waste Disposal Wells in Oregon September 2015 Compliance Guidance for Motor Vehicle Waste Disposal Wells in Oregon September 2015 Underground Injection Control Program 700 NE Multnomah Street Suite 600 Portland, OR 97232 Phone: 503-229-6371 800-452-4011

More information

Site Description and History

Site Description and History 1300 Northwest 31 st Avenue Fort Lauderdale, Florida County: Broward District: Southeast Site Lead: EPA Placed on National Priorities List: October 4, 1989 HWC # 085 Site Description and History The Wingate

More information

Maximising recycling rates tackling residuals

Maximising recycling rates tackling residuals September 2002 Briefing Maximising recycling rates tackling residuals Background Friends of the Earth is an international organisation with over 70 member groups across the World. The majority of these

More information

Florida s Source Water Assessment and Protection Program: Source Water Assessments

Florida s Source Water Assessment and Protection Program: Source Water Assessments Florida s Source Water Assessment and Protection Program: Source Water Assessments Florida Department of Environmental Protection Tallahassee, Florida October 12, 2004 Introduction Florida s lakes, rivers,

More information

Ground Water Contamination by Leachate

Ground Water Contamination by Leachate Ground Water Contamination by Leachate Manoj P. Wagh, Piyush K. Bhandari, Swapnil Kurhade Assistant Professor, Department of Civil Engineering, P. D. V. V. P. College of Engineering, Ahmednagar, India.

More information

Country Club Ichthycide. LESSON 3 Parts per Million Adapted from, Investigating Groundwater: The Fruitvale Story

Country Club Ichthycide. LESSON 3 Parts per Million Adapted from, Investigating Groundwater: The Fruitvale Story Country Club Ichthycide LESSON 3 Parts per Million Adapted from, Investigating Groundwater: The Fruitvale Story TEACHER NOTE: Omit this lesson if students have a working knowledge of ppm. Overview Students

More information

BEST AVAILABLE TECHNIQUES (BAT) AND BEST ENVIRONMENTAL PRACTICES (BEP): THE CASE OF ARTICLE 8 OF THE MINAMATA CONVENTION ON MERCURY

BEST AVAILABLE TECHNIQUES (BAT) AND BEST ENVIRONMENTAL PRACTICES (BEP): THE CASE OF ARTICLE 8 OF THE MINAMATA CONVENTION ON MERCURY BEST AVAILABLE TECHNIQUES (BAT) AND BEST ENVIRONMENTAL PRACTICES (BEP): THE CASE OF ARTICLE 8 OF THE MINAMATA CONVENTION ON MERCURY Okonkwo OJ Department of Environmental, Water & Earth Sciences, Faculty

More information

HAZARDOUS WASTE. liquid material that is toxic, ignitable, corrosive, or reactive enough to explode or release toxic fumes.

HAZARDOUS WASTE. liquid material that is toxic, ignitable, corrosive, or reactive enough to explode or release toxic fumes. HAZARDOUS WASTE Ø Hazardous waste: is any discarded solid or liquid material that is toxic, ignitable, corrosive, or reactive enough to explode or release toxic fumes. l The two largest classes of hazardous

More information

Health Consultation. COLLEGE GROVE RESIDENTIAL LEAD CONTAMINATION (a/k/a COLLEGE GROVE BATTERY CHIP SITE) COLLEGE GROVE, WILLIAMSON COUNTY, TENNESSEE

Health Consultation. COLLEGE GROVE RESIDENTIAL LEAD CONTAMINATION (a/k/a COLLEGE GROVE BATTERY CHIP SITE) COLLEGE GROVE, WILLIAMSON COUNTY, TENNESSEE Health Consultation COLLEGE GROVE RESIDENTIAL LEAD CONTAMINATION (a/k/a COLLEGE GROVE BATTERY CHIP SITE) COLLEGE GROVE, WILLIAMSON COUNTY, TENNESSEE EPA FACILITY ID: TNSFN0406979 JANUARY 8, 2004 U.S. DEPARTMENT

More information

What is Wrong with Fracking?

What is Wrong with Fracking? What is Wrong with Fracking? Hydraulic Fracturing is a how natural gas is extracted from shale rock hundreds of feet below ground. Because dangerous chemicals and explosions are used in the process, environmentalists

More information

Well Positioned for the Future

Well Positioned for the Future Dominion Generation Virginia City Hybrid Energy Center Well Positioned for the Future The Coal Institute July 13, 2015 Rick Boyd Manager of Fuel Origination & Operations 1 Dominion Profile Operating Segments

More information

Q 4/17/13: Thank you for your quick response to our email dated April 10, 2013. In looking over your comments, we have a few clarifying remarks.

Q 4/17/13: Thank you for your quick response to our email dated April 10, 2013. In looking over your comments, we have a few clarifying remarks. Q & A Q 4/10/13: In anticipation of the DEM action plan implementation in the next few days, Citizens Advocating for a Safe Environment (CASE) would like to bring a few concerns to your attention. Some

More information

This is Superfund. A Community Guide to EPA s Superfund Program

This is Superfund. A Community Guide to EPA s Superfund Program This is Superfund A Community Guide to EPA s Superfund Program IF THERE IS A SUPERFUND SITE in your neighborhood, you are probably wondering, what will happen? and, what can I do? This brochure will give

More information

Charter Township of Lansing v. Lansing Board of Water & Light Media Kit. Press Release Timeline Additional Questions Glossary Map Acronym Guide

Charter Township of Lansing v. Lansing Board of Water & Light Media Kit. Press Release Timeline Additional Questions Glossary Map Acronym Guide Charter Township of Lansing v. Lansing Board of Water & Light Media Kit Press Release Timeline Additional Questions Glossary Map Acronym Guide Media Contact: Kathleen Rodgers rodgerskm@lansingtownship.org

More information

January 2014: Jeanne Briskin of the U.S Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)

January 2014: Jeanne Briskin of the U.S Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 The Upstate New York Society for Risk Analysis Webinar Series, Scientific Studies on Impact of Natural Gas Extraction from

More information

FACT SHEET PROPOSED MERCURY AND AIR TOXICS STANDARDS

FACT SHEET PROPOSED MERCURY AND AIR TOXICS STANDARDS FACT SHEET PROPOSED MERCURY AND AIR TOXICS STANDARDS ACTION On March 16, 2011, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) issued a proposed rule that would reduce emissions of toxic air pollutants from

More information

Outlook on Integrated Gasification Combined Cycle (IGCC) Technology

Outlook on Integrated Gasification Combined Cycle (IGCC) Technology The IGCC Process: From Coal To Clean Electric Power Outlook on Integrated Gasification Combined Cycle (IGCC) Technology Testimony of Edward Lowe Gas Turbine-Combined Cycle Product Line Manager General

More information

Learning Objectives. Solid and Hazardous Wastes. Definitions. Statement of Problem. Gene D. Schroder PhD

Learning Objectives. Solid and Hazardous Wastes. Definitions. Statement of Problem. Gene D. Schroder PhD Learning Objectives Solid and Hazardous Wastes Gene D. Schroder PhD To understand the sources of solid and hazardous wastes. To understand methods of solid waste disposal. To evaluate the health risks

More information

Fossil Fuels are SO last century! THE CASE FOR GREEN ENERGY!

Fossil Fuels are SO last century! THE CASE FOR GREEN ENERGY! Fossil Fuels are SO last century! THE CASE FOR GREEN ENERGY! Green Technologies have never been so accessible and so inexpensive! And with Global Climate Change running rampant, we have no time to spare!

More information

Description Purpose Health Education. Health Assessment. Outcomes of the program Partners Contact Information

Description Purpose Health Education. Health Assessment. Outcomes of the program Partners Contact Information 1 Description Purpose Health Education Message Mapping Developing Community Interaction Health Assessment Identifying Contaminants of Concern Elements of Exposure Pathways Outcomes of the program Partners

More information

PHARMACEUTICAL AND CHEMICAL WASTE MANAGEMENT

PHARMACEUTICAL AND CHEMICAL WASTE MANAGEMENT Medicines and Medical Devices Agency of Serbia PHARMACEUTICAL AND CHEMICAL WASTE MANAGEMENT Ivana Bozic, MSc Health, Safety and Environment ISWA Beacon Conference, Novi Sad, 08 10 December 2010 458, Vojvode

More information

Guidelines for Cleaning up Former Methamphetamine Labs

Guidelines for Cleaning up Former Methamphetamine Labs Guidelines for Cleaning up Former Methamphetamine Labs Methamphetamine (meth) drug labs are not a new hazard to Iowa. In 2003, federal, state and local authorities seized more than 1,100 Iowa labs, and

More information

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL EMVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT ACT AMENDMENT BILL: WASTE. Parliament 28 th January 2014. Dr Dhiraj Rama

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL EMVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT ACT AMENDMENT BILL: WASTE. Parliament 28 th January 2014. Dr Dhiraj Rama NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL EMVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT ACT AMENDMENT BILL: WASTE Parliament 28 th January 2014 Dr Dhiraj Rama NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL MANGEMENT ACT AMENDMENT BILL: MINING CONTENTS 1. Introduction

More information

DRAFT Guidelines for Manually Diverting Outdoor Wastewater to the Sanitary Sewer

DRAFT Guidelines for Manually Diverting Outdoor Wastewater to the Sanitary Sewer Only RAIN down the Storm Drain... DRAFT Guidelines for Manually Diverting Outdoor Wastewater to the Sanitary Sewer This publication applies to you if: You generate wastewater outdoors, and The wastewater

More information

PROPOSAL FOR HOUSTON COUNTY BAN ON SILICA SAND MINING / PROCESSING ACTIVITY. Introduction and Assumptions

PROPOSAL FOR HOUSTON COUNTY BAN ON SILICA SAND MINING / PROCESSING ACTIVITY. Introduction and Assumptions PROPOSAL FOR HOUSTON COUNTY BAN ON SILICA SAND MINING / PROCESSING ACTIVITY Introduction and Assumptions 1. The existing section 27 Mineral Extraction of the Zoning Ordinance would remain and continue

More information

Reducing Carbon Pollution in D.C s Renewable Portfolio Standard Will Clean the Air without Impacting Ratepayers. Frequently Asked Questions

Reducing Carbon Pollution in D.C s Renewable Portfolio Standard Will Clean the Air without Impacting Ratepayers. Frequently Asked Questions Reducing Carbon Pollution in D.C s Renewable Portfolio Standard Will Clean the Air without Impacting Ratepayers Summary: Frequently Asked Questions While Mid-Atlantic States like Delaware and New Jersey

More information

Managing Floor Drains and Flammable Traps

Managing Floor Drains and Flammable Traps Managing Floor Drains and Flammable Traps Contents: Problem... 1 Solution... 2 Maintenance... 2 Waste Management Options... 2 For More Information... 4 BMP Chart... 5 This fact sheet discusses recommended

More information

CITY OF POMPANO BEACH Broward County, Florida

CITY OF POMPANO BEACH Broward County, Florida RESOLUTION NO. 2015-399 CITY OF POMPANO BEACH Broward County, Florida A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF POMPANO BEACH, FLORIDA, OPPOSING THE OIL DRILLING PERMIT APPLICATION SUBMITTED BY

More information

Coal Ash Production and Use Survey 2014

Coal Ash Production and Use Survey 2014 Coal Ash Production and Use Survey 2014 News Conference Washington DC Thomas H. Adams, ACAA Executive Director December 15, 2015 Founded in 1968 Headquartered in Farmington Hills, MI 160 members utilities,

More information

Removing Thallium from Industrial FGD Scrubber Water with Sorbster Adsorbent Media

Removing Thallium from Industrial FGD Scrubber Water with Sorbster Adsorbent Media Case History MAR Systems Inc. Removing Thallium from Industrial FGD Scrubber Water with Sorbster Adsorbent Media Trace thallium levels in process and wastewater streams pose a human toxicity threat. Tidwell

More information

Spills and leaks Associated with Shale Gas Development (Updated April 27 th, 2012)

Spills and leaks Associated with Shale Gas Development (Updated April 27 th, 2012) NEW YORK STATE WATER RESOURCES INSTITUTE Department of Earth and Atmospheric Sciences 1123 Bradfield Hall, Cornell University Tel: (607) 255-3034 Ithaca, NY 14853-1901 Fax: (607) 255-2016 http://wri.eas.cornell.edu

More information

Inorganic mercury/ elemental mercury General information

Inorganic mercury/ elemental mercury General information Inorganic mercury/ elemental mercury General information Key Points Fire Does not easily burn under normal conditions Reacts with nitric acid and hot concentrated sulphuric acid. May react explosively

More information

The EPA's Superfund Remediation of Oil Spill Sites

The EPA's Superfund Remediation of Oil Spill Sites The EPA's Superfund Remediation of Oil Spill Sites Brett Bryngelson Background The United States, being the most consumptive industrial nation in the world, demands large volumes of raw materials. This

More information

Clean Water Fund requests that you provide appropriate credit on all reprinted materials.

Clean Water Fund requests that you provide appropriate credit on all reprinted materials. a Florida s Toxic Trash Exposed September 12, 2012 About Clean Water Fund www.cleanwaterfund.org Clean Water Fund (CWF) is a national 501 (c) 3 research and education organization that has been promoting

More information

Coal Ash. The toxic threat to our health and environment. By Barbara Gottlieb with Steven G. Gilbert, PhD, DABT and Lisa Gollin Evans

Coal Ash. The toxic threat to our health and environment. By Barbara Gottlieb with Steven G. Gilbert, PhD, DABT and Lisa Gollin Evans Coal Ash The toxic threat to our health and environment A Report From Physicians For Social Responsibility and earthjustice By Barbara Gottlieb with Steven G. Gilbert, PhD, DABT and Lisa Gollin Evans Coal

More information

WCD LITIGATION SUPPORT AND CLAIMS EXPERIENCE

WCD LITIGATION SUPPORT AND CLAIMS EXPERIENCE WCD LITIGATION SUPPORT AND CLAIMS EXPERIENCE WCD Group, LLC, its Principals and key consultants have been providing consulting, engineering, strategic and technical litigation support, claims consulting,

More information

Birmingham City University / Students Union Aspects and Impacts Register. Waste. Impacts description

Birmingham City University / Students Union Aspects and Impacts Register. Waste. Impacts description Birmingham City University / Students Union and Impacts Register Waste Production of non - hazardous waste Production of hazardous waste Storage of non - hazardous waste Potential for waste to be disposed

More information

ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT: CLEAN WATER RESEARCH AS RELATED TO ACID MINE DRAINAGE

ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT: CLEAN WATER RESEARCH AS RELATED TO ACID MINE DRAINAGE ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT: CLEAN WATER RESEARCH AS RELATED TO ACID MINE DRAINAGE LESSON PLAN CREATED BY: Todd Mills (Grades 9 12) Lois Morris (Grades 6-8) Terry Rostcheck (Grades 6 8) Susan Tegi (Grades

More information

HAZARDOUS WASTE / MATERIALS GIS DATASETS and OTHER DATABASES

HAZARDOUS WASTE / MATERIALS GIS DATASETS and OTHER DATABASES HAZARDOUS WASTE / MATERIALS GIS DATASETS and OTHER DATABASES GIS DATASETS 1.1 CONTAMINATED SITES General Description: This folder is perhaps the most important because it pertains to sites where the surface

More information

The Clean Air Act and Public Health

The Clean Air Act and Public Health Written Statement of Sarah Bucic, MSN, RN On behalf of the American Nurses Association and the Delaware Nurses Association The Clean Air Act and Public Health Before the Committee on Environment and Public

More information

Case Study 3 Conservation Chemical Company, Kansas City, Missouri, EPA Region 7

Case Study 3 Conservation Chemical Company, Kansas City, Missouri, EPA Region 7 29 technologies. The large amount of waste at the site poses a difficult problem for which some innovative cleanup technologies, including in situ techniques to avoid excavation, could have been considered

More information

CASE STUDY UNIT 3. The Case of the New Power Plant

CASE STUDY UNIT 3. The Case of the New Power Plant CASE STUDY UNIT 3 The Case of the New Power Plant Teaching Instructions Overview In this case study, students analyze the trade-offs involved in developing new sources of electricity, discovering in the

More information

Cancer Cluster Investigation French Limited Superfund Site, Harris County, Texas

Cancer Cluster Investigation French Limited Superfund Site, Harris County, Texas Cancer Cluster Investigation French Limited Superfund Site, Harris County, Texas Time Period: 1995-2011 Prepared by the Texas Department of State Health Services Summary Some residents living in the vicinity

More information

Background A. What is HHW? Why do I need to know? B. Types of Hazardous Waste Corrosive: Toxic: Ignitable: Reactive:

Background A. What is HHW? Why do I need to know? B. Types of Hazardous Waste Corrosive: Toxic: Ignitable: Reactive: Sponsoredby: Background A. What is HHW? Why do I need to know? Common household chemicals and substances that are no longer being used by their owners are called Household Hazardous Waste, or HHW for short.

More information

TEXAS: SAN ANTONIO San Antonio Protects Edwards Aquifer

TEXAS: SAN ANTONIO San Antonio Protects Edwards Aquifer TEXAS: SAN ANTONIO San Antonio Protects Edwards Aquifer Background San Antonio, the seventh largest city in the United States, covers approximately 515 square miles of Bexar County in south central Texas.

More information

Solid waste management and chemical safety

Solid waste management and chemical safety 52 CHAPTER 6 Solid waste management and chemical safety To keep the household and village environment clean and to reduce health risks, solid waste (refuse) should be disposed of properly. Untreated refuse

More information

Revealing the costs of air pollution from industrial facilities in Europe a summary for policymakers

Revealing the costs of air pollution from industrial facilities in Europe a summary for policymakers Revealing the costs of air pollution from industrial facilities in Europe a summary for policymakers A new European Environment Agency (EEA report, Revealing the costs of air pollution from industrial

More information

5 th -6 th : Electronic Jeopardy

5 th -6 th : Electronic Jeopardy Objectives: The students will learn the lifecycle of electronic devices, the environmental impacts of new age electronic waste (e-waste), and the disposal options at the end of an electronics' useful life.

More information

10 Nuclear Power Reactors Figure 10.1

10 Nuclear Power Reactors Figure 10.1 10 Nuclear Power Reactors Figure 10.1 89 10.1 What is a Nuclear Power Station? The purpose of a power station is to generate electricity safely reliably and economically. Figure 10.1 is the schematic of

More information

FIELD TRIP TO A POWER PLANT - A Reading Guide

FIELD TRIP TO A POWER PLANT - A Reading Guide TITLE: TOPIC: FIELD TRIP TO A POWER PLANT - A Reading Guide Energy and the sources of energy used in power plants GRADE LEVEL: Secondary CONTENT STANDARD: Earth and Space Science CONTENT OBJECTIVE: For

More information

ANALYZING ENERGY. Time and Student Grouping Energy Source Analysis and Consequence Wheel: One class period. Grade Levels: 6-12

ANALYZING ENERGY. Time and Student Grouping Energy Source Analysis and Consequence Wheel: One class period. Grade Levels: 6-12 ANALYZING ENERGY Lesson Concepts: Students will analyze the advantages and disadvantages of nine different energy sources. They will use their knowledge to predict what would happen if the world did not

More information

Chapter 3: Separating Mixtures (pg. 54 81)

Chapter 3: Separating Mixtures (pg. 54 81) Chapter 3: Separating Mixtures (pg. 54 81) 3.2: Separating Mechanical Mixtures (PB Pg. 40 5 & TB Pg. 58 61): Name: Date: Check Your Understanding & Learning (PB pg. 40 & TB pg. 61): 1. What are four methods

More information

The Regulatory Impact Analysis (RIA) for the Mercury Air Toxics Standard (MATS)

The Regulatory Impact Analysis (RIA) for the Mercury Air Toxics Standard (MATS) The Regulatory Impact Analysis (RIA) for the Mercury Air Toxics Standard (MATS) Kevin Culligan U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) Associate Division Director, Sector Policies and Programs Division

More information

IDENTIFYING YOUR WASTE

IDENTIFYING YOUR WASTE United States Environmental Protection Agency EPA530-F-97-029 September 1997 http://www.epa.gov Solid Waste and Emergency Response IDENTIFYING YOUR WASTE THE STARTING POINT This brochure explains the methodology

More information

Environmental Justice

Environmental Justice Environmental Justice Environmental Justice Environmental Justice is the fair treatment and meaningful involvement of all people regardless of race, color, national origin, or income with respect to the

More information

Electricity Sources. Coal Fleet

Electricity Sources. Coal Fleet This paper is called Coal Facts because it provides factual information and data related to coal-based electricity. Most of the data are taken from independent third party sources, such as the Energy Information

More information

Questions from Water Celebration Day

Questions from Water Celebration Day Questions from Water Celebration Day Julie Archer, WV Surface Owners Rights Organization What barriers inhibit surface owners or counties from simply repurchasing several leases, or offering to purchase

More information

Coal Products: Status and Future for the USA

Coal Products: Status and Future for the USA 2001 International Ash Utilization Symposium, Center for Applied Energy Research, University of Kentucky, Paper #109. Copyright is held by the Authors. http://www.flyash.info Coal Products: Status and

More information

Recycling Old Mobile Phones

Recycling Old Mobile Phones Schools Mobile Phone Recycling Program Lesson Background This lesson plan has been designed using the Australia Curriculum to engage students from Middle and Upper Primary (Years 3 to 6), with extension

More information

Environmental Forensics

Environmental Forensics Environmental Forensics N O T E S Volume 10 2011 CERCLA s Petroleum Exclusion and the Use of Chemical Forensic Methods Tarek Saba and Paul Boehm For more information on Exponent s environmental services,

More information

Biomass Renewable Energy from Plants and Animals

Biomass Renewable Energy from Plants and Animals Renewable Biomass Biomass Basics Biomass Renewable Energy from Plants and Animals Biomass is organic material made from plants and animals. Biomass contains stored energy from the sun. Plants absorb the

More information

Our Environmental Protection Plan RECYCLING CAPABILITIES AND ENVIRONMENTAL ACCOMPLISHMENTS

Our Environmental Protection Plan RECYCLING CAPABILITIES AND ENVIRONMENTAL ACCOMPLISHMENTS Our Environmental Protection Plan RECYCLING CAPABILITIES AND ENVIRONMENTAL ACCOMPLISHMENTS WHO WE ARE Since day one, East Penn has made safe recycling an everyday practice. East Penn opened its doors as

More information

Assessing and Reducing the Risk of Groundwater Contamination from HOUSEHOLD WASTE MANAGEMENT

Assessing and Reducing the Risk of Groundwater Contamination from HOUSEHOLD WASTE MANAGEMENT IP-43 Assessing and Reducing the Risk of Groundwater Contamination from HOUSEHOLD WASTE MANAGEMENT Why should I be concerned? Kentucky's groundwater is one of its most vital resources. It supplies drinking

More information

RAILROAD COMMISSION OF TEXAS APPENDIX C LIST OF E&P WASTES: EXEMPT AND NONEXEMPT

RAILROAD COMMISSION OF TEXAS APPENDIX C LIST OF E&P WASTES: EXEMPT AND NONEXEMPT RAILROAD COMMISSION OF TEXAS APPENDIX C LIST OF E&P WASTES: EXEMPT AND NONEXEMPT WASTE MINIMIZATION IN THE OIL FIELD - APPENDIX C NOTES RAILROAD COMMISSION OF TEXAS LIST OF E&P WASTES: EXEMPT AND NON EXEMPT

More information

INFORMATION SHEET ORDER NO. R5-2011-XXXX TRIANGLE ROCK PRODUCTS, INC. FLORIN ROAD AGGREGATE PLANT SACRAMENTO COUNTY

INFORMATION SHEET ORDER NO. R5-2011-XXXX TRIANGLE ROCK PRODUCTS, INC. FLORIN ROAD AGGREGATE PLANT SACRAMENTO COUNTY ORDER NO. R5-2011-XXXX INFORMATION SHEET Background Triangle Rock, Inc. (Discharger) submitted a Report of Waste Discharge (RWD) on 23 August 2010. The Discharger is expanding the mining operations at

More information

Bioremediation. Introduction

Bioremediation. Introduction Bioremediation Introduction In the twentieth century, the ever increase in the global human population and industrialization led to the exploitation of natural resources. The increased usage of heavy metals

More information

EPA Superfund Actions and ATSDR Public Health Data. July 1995 OTA-BP-ENV-156

EPA Superfund Actions and ATSDR Public Health Data. July 1995 OTA-BP-ENV-156 EPA Superfund Actions and ATSDR Public Health Data July 1995 OTA-BP-ENV-156 Foreword T he Superfund program, authorized by Congress 15 years ago, was intended to address the clean up of U.S. hazardous

More information

Energise your waste! EU legislation pushes for a reliable alternative to landfilling for residual waste. 13 th September 2011, Birmingham

Energise your waste! EU legislation pushes for a reliable alternative to landfilling for residual waste. 13 th September 2011, Birmingham Energise your waste! EU legislation pushes for a reliable alternative to landfilling for residual waste 13 th September 2011, Birmingham Recycling & Waste Management (RWM) Exhibition Dr.ir. Johan De Greef

More information

Soil and Materials Engineers, Inc. Mark J. Quimby Project Consultant

Soil and Materials Engineers, Inc. Mark J. Quimby Project Consultant Soil and Materials Engineers, Inc. Mark J. Quimby Project Consultant Michigan Indiana Ohio www.sme-usa.com consultants in the environment, geosciences and materials OVERVIEW Site Description and History

More information

HAZARD COMMUNICATION & THE GLOBAL HARMONIZING SYSTEM EMPLOYEE TRAINING

HAZARD COMMUNICATION & THE GLOBAL HARMONIZING SYSTEM EMPLOYEE TRAINING HAZARD COMMUNICATION & THE GLOBAL HARMONIZING SYSTEM EMPLOYEE TRAINING This easy-to-use Leader s Guide is provided to assist in conducting a successful presentation. Featured are: INTRODUCTION: A brief

More information

Generating Current Electricity: Complete the following summary table for each way that electrical energy is generated. Pros:

Generating Current Electricity: Complete the following summary table for each way that electrical energy is generated. Pros: P a g e 1 Generating Current Electricity: Complete the following summary table for each way that electrical energy is generated. Generating Electrical Energy Using Moving Water: Hydro-Electric Generation

More information

This fact sheet provides an overview of options for managing solid

This fact sheet provides an overview of options for managing solid What Is Integrated Solid Waste Management? This fact sheet provides an overview of options for managing solid waste, identifies the important issues you should consider when planning for solid waste management,

More information

Opinion Poll. Small Business Owners Support Government Investments in Renewable Energy and EPA Clean Air Standards. April 24, 2012

Opinion Poll. Small Business Owners Support Government Investments in Renewable Energy and EPA Clean Air Standards. April 24, 2012 Opinion Poll Small Business Owners Support Government Investments in Renewable Energy and EPA Clean Air Standards April 24, 2012 Small Business Majority 4000 Bridgeway, Suite 101 Sausalito, CA 94965 (866)

More information

Evaluation of Uranium and Radium in a Private Well

Evaluation of Uranium and Radium in a Private Well Evaluation of Uranium and Radium in a Private Well PITTSYLVANIA, VIRGINIA Letter Health Consultation April 16, 2014 Division of Environmental Epidemiology Richmond, Virginia 23219 COMMONWEALTH of VIRGINIA

More information

Chemical Engineer Office of Resource Conservation and Recovery

Chemical Engineer Office of Resource Conservation and Recovery Waste-to to-energy in the U.S. and Trends for the Future Jesse Miller Chemical Engineer Office of Resource Conservation and Recovery Tuesday, August 9, 2011 1 Presentation Outline ORCR Atiiti Activities

More information

Town of New Castle Utility Department Introduction

Town of New Castle Utility Department Introduction Town of New Castle Utility Department Introduction Town of New Castle Utility Department Mission Statement Our commitment is to ensure that our customers receive high quality water and wastewater treatment

More information

Slide 1. Enviros Consulting Ltd

Slide 1. Enviros Consulting Ltd Slide 1 Regulation of Waste Management Activities Past, Present and Future! Steve Bell Technical Manager Waste Management Thursday, 26 July 2007 Presentation Aims An insight of where we have come from

More information

SAMPLE ACTIVITY. from

SAMPLE ACTIVITY. from SAMPLE ACTIVITY from The Water SourceBook Distributed By Legacy, Inc., Partners in Environmental Education Funding for this project is made possible by proceeds from the sale of Alabama's Protect Our Environment

More information

Basic Mercury Data & Coal Fired Power Plants

Basic Mercury Data & Coal Fired Power Plants Basic Mercury Data & Coal Fired Power Plants CCTR Basic Facts File #2 Brian H. Bowen, Marty W. Irwin The Energy Center at Discovery Park Purdue University CCTR, Potter Center, 500 Central Drive West Lafayette,

More information

Chapter 10. Overview of Federal Laws and Regulations Governing Incineration

Chapter 10. Overview of Federal Laws and Regulations Governing Incineration Chapter 10 Overview of Federal Laws and Regulations Governing Incineration Contents Land-Based Incineration.......................... Ocean Incineration.............................. Statutes Governing

More information

1. PUBLIC HEALTH STATEMENT

1. PUBLIC HEALTH STATEMENT 1 This Statement was prepared to give you information about fuel oils and to emphasize the human health effects that may result from exposure to them. The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has identified

More information

N O T E S. Environmental Forensics. Identification of Natural Gas Sources using Geochemical Forensic Tools. Dispute Scenarios

N O T E S. Environmental Forensics. Identification of Natural Gas Sources using Geochemical Forensic Tools. Dispute Scenarios Environmental Forensics N O T E S V o l u m e 2 9 Identification of Natural Gas Sources using Geochemical Forensic Tools By Paul Boehm, Ph.D. and Tarek Saba, Ph.D. F o r m o r e i n f o r m a t i o n o

More information

Parts per million (ppm) or Milligrams per liter (mg/l): one part by weight of analyte to 1 million parts by weight of the water sample.

Parts per million (ppm) or Milligrams per liter (mg/l): one part by weight of analyte to 1 million parts by weight of the water sample. 2015 Annual Drinking Water Quality Report St. Johns County Utility CR 214 Mainland We're pleased to present to you this year's Annual Water Quality Report. This report is designed to inform you about the

More information

Don t spit in the well - you may need to drink from it! -- Unknown, Russia.

Don t spit in the well - you may need to drink from it! -- Unknown, Russia. Don t spit in the well - you may need to drink from it! -- Unknown, Russia. WATER POLLUTION Water is a unique substance, because it can naturally renew and cleanse itself, by allowing pollutants to settle

More information

Transcript for Asbestos Information for the Community

Transcript for Asbestos Information for the Community Welcome to the lecture on asbestos and its health effects for the community. My name is Dr. Vik Kapil and I come to you from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Agency for Toxic Substances

More information

Environmental laws have been enacted to protect natural resources and the public health. A number

Environmental laws have been enacted to protect natural resources and the public health. A number Workers Whistleblower Protection Under Seven Federal Environmental Laws Protecting Workers Who Exercise Rights PWWER A PROJECT OF THE NATIONAL Committees for Occupational Safety and Health NETWORK FACTSHEET

More information

Dukes of Hazard Activity Time:

Dukes of Hazard Activity Time: Dukes of Hazard Activity Time: TEACHERS: Read Populution and Water Source Protection on page 80 of Peel Water Story book. Objectives: Students will: Identify household hazardous waste (HHW) materials around

More information

Environment Impact Assessment of Thermal Power Plant for Sustainable Development

Environment Impact Assessment of Thermal Power Plant for Sustainable Development International Journal of Environmental Engineering and Management. ISSN 2231-1319, Volume 4, Number 6 (2013), pp. 567-572 Research India Publications http://www.ripublication.com/ ijeem.htm Environment

More information

Appendix B: Water Treatment Scenarios from AMD Treat

Appendix B: Water Treatment Scenarios from AMD Treat Appendix B: Water Treatment Scenarios from AMD Treat 103 of 104 Jeddo Tunnel Abandoned Mine Drainage Passive vs. Active Treatment Cost Estimates Provided by Office of Surface Mining AMD Treat Software

More information

Teacher s notes. Overview. The arguments. Lead-in. Key words. Describing a process and checking for understanding

Teacher s notes. Overview. The arguments. Lead-in. Key words. Describing a process and checking for understanding Level: Intermediate upwards Timing: 90 minutes plus Material needed: One copy of the student worksheet, Part A or B of the article and Vocabulary record per student Group size: Any Overview This lesson

More information

Wolverine Clean Energy Venture

Wolverine Clean Energy Venture Prepared for: Wolverine Power Supply Cooperative Cadillac, Michigan Supplement to CAA Section 112(g) MACT Auxiliary Boiler Amended Application No. 317-07 Wolverine Clean Energy Venture Rogers City, MI

More information

Waste a source of energy. Regional Solid Waste Management Plan Review: Engaging solutions for tomorrow. Incineration. Incineration

Waste a source of energy. Regional Solid Waste Management Plan Review: Engaging solutions for tomorrow. Incineration. Incineration Waste a source of energy Regional Solid Waste Management Plan Review: Engaging solutions for tomorrow Garbage School 301: Waste to Energy All organic materials contains energy Plant or animal based Plastics

More information

MBA PROGRAM BRAC BUSINESS SCHOOL,BRAC UNIVERSITY SAMPLE QUESTIONS SECTION I: QUANTITATIVE

MBA PROGRAM BRAC BUSINESS SCHOOL,BRAC UNIVERSITY SAMPLE QUESTIONS SECTION I: QUANTITATIVE MBA PROGRAM BRAC BUSINESS SCHOOL,BRAC UNIVERSITY SAMPLE QUESTIONS SECTION I: QUANTITATIVE 1) A sporting goods store sold 64 cricket bats in one week, some for Tk. 3 and the rest for Tk. 4 each. If receipts

More information

AP ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE 2010 SCORING GUIDELINES

AP ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE 2010 SCORING GUIDELINES AP ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE 2010 SCORING GUIDELINES Question 1 (a) Choose any ONE of the three pollutants mentioned above and respond to each of the following. (i) Describe one specific source, other than

More information