1 Information Seeking Behaviour and Usage on a Multi-media Platform: Case Study Europeana David Nicholas and David Clark Abstract The article examines the usage of the Europeana.eu website, a multilingual online collection of millions of digitized items from European museums, libraries, archives and multi-media collections. It concentrates on three aspects of use: (1) stickiness and site loyalty; (2) social media referrals; (3) that associated with virtual exhibitions. Three methods for obtaining the data are examined: Google analytics, ClickStream logs and http server logs. The analyses produced by Google Analytics are highlighted in the article. Keywords Information seeking Google analytics Log analysis Multimedia website Europeana David Nicholas is a Director and founder of the CIBER research group (http://ciber-research. eu). The group is perhaps best known for monitoring behaviours in the virtual space, especially in regard to the virtual scholar and the Google Generation, which has been featured widely in the media, including on BBC TV and Australian TV (ABC). David is also a professor at the College of Communication and Information Studies, University of Tennessee and at the ischool at Northumbria University. Previously David was Head of the Department of Information Studies at University College London for seven years ( ) and previous to that was Head of the Department of Information Science at City University for a similar period of time. Dave. David Clark has forty years experience of data processing and information management in publishing and related industries. He returned to full-time education in 1995 to take a masters degree in knowledge engineering. He has a PhD in Computer Science, from the University of Warwick, where he taught and researched from He then moved to University College London, leaving in 2011 to form CIBER Research Ltd. He is a Director of the CIBER Research Ltd. D. Nicholas ( ) College of Communication and Information Studies, University of Tennessee, Knoxville, USA D. Clark D. Nicholas CIBER Research Ltd., Newbury, UK C. Chen, R. Larsen (eds.), Library and Information Sciences, DOI / _6, The Author(s)
2 58 D. Nicholas and D. Clark Background Transactional log studies are becoming more and more popular ways of evaluating websites (Davis 2004; Davis and Solla 2003). In particular, Http server logs and clickstream logs have proven to be very effective ways of analysing behavior on textual websites (Nicholas et al. 2006).The primary goal of many log or usage data studies is to find out about use rather than users. In terms of usage studies, previous log studies have led to different conclusions about the success or otherwise of the Big Deal and consortium subscriptions to journals. Davis (Davis 2002) challenged the composition of geographic based consortia. He recommended libraries create consortia based on homogeneous membership. On the other hand, Gargiulo (2003) analysed logs of an Italian consortium and strongly recommended Big Deal subscriptions. Essentially one of the limitations of basic log analysis is the fact that there is little possibility to link use data with user data, hence a vague and general picture of users information seeking behaviour is obtained. This technical restriction makes it difficult to use the demographic data of users for finding out about differences in information seeking activities of users in regard to different tasks, statuses, genders and so on. In this paper, Google analytics data will be investigated to explore new ways of evaluating behavior on the web. Europeana, launched in 2008 as a prototype and operating as a full service since 2010, is a gateway, portal or search engine to the digital resources of Europe s museums, art galleries, libraries, archives and audio-visual collections (Fig. 1). Europeana is regarded as trusted (curated) source connecting users directly to authentic and curated material. It provides multilingual access to 26 million European cultural objects in 2200 institutions from 34 countries. Books and manuscripts, photos and paintings, television and film, sculpture and crafts, diaries and maps, sheet music and recordings, they re all there. Europeana claim that there is no longer the need to travel the continent, either physically or virtually. If you find what you like you can download it, print it, use it, save it, or share it 1. While Europeana is essentially a portal it also has aspirations well beyond that; it believes it can help stimulate the European digital economy; it also mounts online exhibitions and takes part in crowd sourcing experiments (World War 1 is currently the subject of such an experiment). Europeana is also working with other digital channels to distribute their content, most notably Google, Wikipedia and Facebook. It is a site that currently attracts around five million visitors and is used heavily by humanities scholars, heritage professionals and even tourists. CIBER have been analysing usage of Europeana since 2009 and have now amassed a three-year long-series of data to evaluate Europeana s growth, changes and innovations. As a consequence we have assembled a large evidence base showing how a whole range of people use cultural collections and artefacts, in a virtual environment. Thus we use logging as the basis of insight and prediction about the purpose and motive of the millions who use Europeana. 1
3 Information Seeking Behaviour and Usage on a Multi-media Platform 59 Fig. 1 Europeana home page Aims and Objectives The study reported here features our latest research which focuses on three types of digital behavior prevailing in Europeana which we regard to be particularly significant and strategic forms of digital behaviour not only for Europeana, but for all information providers on the Web. These are: 1. Stickiness and user loyalty. Stickiness is anything about a Web site that encourages a visitor to stay longer (engagement) and visit more often (returnees). All information providers are interested in what constitutes stickiness and how they can make their sites stickier. 2. Social media referral.volume and characteristics of the traffic coming from Facebook, twitter and the like, which could potentially drive a lot of traffic to Europeana and encourage much re-use of Europeana content.
4 60 D. Nicholas and D. Clark 3. Virtual exhibition usage. Virtual exhibitions are a recent innovation in which Europeana sets much store. Clearly these exhibitions provide a lot of added value for a site which essentially functions as a search engine. Exhibitions could capture the interest of the digital information consumer and armchair tourist. They could speak to a lot of people. A prime objective of the study is to see what Google Analytics could provide in regard to robust and precise usage data and how it compared with our traditional usage sources http server logs and ClickStream logs. While textual websites, like those of scholarly publishers and libraries, have been well researched from a digital usage point of view (Julien and Williamson 2010), very few studies of multi-media platforms have been undertaken, and so in the way the paper is quite unique. Methodology For CIBER s earlier Europeana work we relied upon server http request logs using CIBER s own deep log methods (Nicholas et al. 2013). However, for the study reported here we wanted also to see what extent, the now ubiquitous, Google Analytics (GA) data could undertake key information seeking analyses more cheaply and effectively. This is important given the fact that Europeana, like many organisations, are relying increasingly heavily on GA for all their usage and marketing needs. While we have utilised GA heavily in this paper as we will learn GA cannot always supply the data required in a convenient form and have thus supplemented it with our own tried and trusted deep log methods. There is great potential to make better use of GA but it requires considerable investment and effort, not only to interpret the output but in experimental design, preparation and configuration of event tracking code, and this is generally not undertaken by institutions and analysts. In addition, to the http logs and GA data, we also had access to a series of Click- Streamer logs which had become recently available. However, we only had access to the ClickStreamer series of Portal logs from June to December 2012 (the minimal time-scale necessary for a robust analysis given the seasonal/diverse nature of usage data). As a result we have sometimes used the old series of raw http-request logs for a broader overview and perspective. Thus, to provide the best and most comprehensive analysis of Europeana usage we have used a variety of data sources. And it is worth pointing out their various strengths and weaknesses. There are, in essence, three points at which we can take the pulse of a website. On receipt of a request by the server; by tapping into the internal process of the site s content management system (CMS); by causing the browser to send an acknowledgement when content is received. The first of these, monitoring incoming traffic, has been used since the web s inception. It relies on http server request log files originally intended for server management and software maintenance. Not being intended for market research purposes, means the record is not always in the most convenient form. On the other hand it may hold informa-
5 Information Seeking Behaviour and Usage on a Multi-media Platform 61 Fig. 2 Taking the pulse of a website using logs tion that would not otherwise be collected because it did not seem relevant at the relevant at the time. Figure 2 outlines the web-server process and the points at which usage can be measured. For a very simple website with no CMS the URL requested (e.g. a link in the clickstream) maps more or less directly to a web-page file, which is despatched by the server back to the client (browser). In this case the traditional server log is in effect also the CMS log. But today, CMS is the norm and the request no longer maps direct to a file but is interpreted by the CMS. As a result records are retrieved from a database and a web page constructed on demand. The cost of this flexibility and complexity is that the incoming request is no longer a straightforward and reliable indication of what was served in response. Interpretation of request logs becomes a matter of reverse engineering the programming of the CMS. In such cases logging from within the CMS becomes attractive. For some purposes this is obvious and inherent to the application area: an online shop for example will almost certainly be linked to stock control, and accounting records. These can be considered specialised varieties of log file ; they can be used for analysis in similar ways to the server log. Or, a specific form of log may be kept for market research and data mining. For any special logging the problem is to specify in advance what needs recording. The difficulty of web-server based logging, wherever the monitoring point, is that it does not record what happens at the user end. A web-page is served but there is no record of its receipt. The solution is to insert scripting into the web-page so that on receipt a secondary request is despatched to report back to a logging system. This is the method employed by Google Analytics and others similar solutions such as the open source Piwik. This can, like CMS logging, resolve the reverse engineering problem, but the task of deciding what to track and of deploying the necessary web tracker events to best effect remains. It also needs to be noted that
8 64 D. Nicholas and D. Clark Fig. 4 Europeana daily visits Returning Visitors Stickiness has most often been associated with site loyalty and the propensity of people to revisit. Returnees, unlike dwell time, are definitely a quality metric. We have not been able to undertake this analysis before on Europeana because of an absence of cookies in the raw logs (the surest method for identifying revisits). These cookies are available in the ClickStream series, but only from June 2012, so we are really limited to GA data. As mentioned earlier cookie-based visitor identification is not 100 % reliable: cookies may be deleted; the same person may access the site from more than one browser. It is therefore probable that there is a systemic overstatement of New and Unique Visitors and a corresponding under recording of returning visits. But we do not know the extent of this and given the relative importance of this metric, far more meaningful than a Facebook like, for instance, Europeana hopes to do more research to establish its real significance, by triangulating the data with demographic, survey or qualitative data. Only one in four visitors return to Europeana, as compared to two out of five for a typical publisher website. This says something about dependency. Within that 25 %, 10 % return only once, 4 % make three visits, 2 % four. Nine per cent of visi-
9 Information Seeking Behaviour and Usage on a Multi-media Platform 65 Fig. 5 Europeana: return visits. (Source: GA) tors returned five times or more. GA may understate the return rate a little but the distribution follows is a typical power law (Fig. 5). This suggests that Europeana s core audience, defined as those people visiting five times of more, is about onetenth the size of its visitor numbers about 500,000. When looking at returning visitors it is well to remember that most visits are very fleeting; even when bouncers (one visit, on view) are ignored many returning visits are measured in seconds rather than days. So strong is this phenomenon that it is difficult to convey on a single chart. The following three charts (Figs. 6 8) are derived from a single dataset, a sample of 600,000 visits made between June and December These are visits selected because the Google cookies were present and contained timing data for a previous visit. The Google cookie expires 2 years after the last visit so first we look at a timescale of 24 months. In many cases the cookie will have been deleted earlier so the evidence of long-term use of Europeana will be understated. Nonetheless we do see evidence of users who first used Europeana over two years ago, and even a few who have recorded no other visit in the intervening period. But these are counted in single figures compared to the thousands who return within a month (Fig. 6). When we look even closer (Fig. 8), at those visitors who return within three days rather than months an interesting pattern can be seen. Regular users appear to have a daily routine; there is a distinct series of peaks in the graph at 24, 48, and 72 h. In fact, equipped with this insight, we can turn to a daily plot (Fig. 8) and see the same
10 66 D. Nicholas and D. Clark Fig. 6 Europeana: months between visits. (Source: GA) daily routine persists through a whole month. It is also possible to see traces of a weekly cycle: the daily peak is a little higher at 7, 14, 21 and 28 days. One explanation for this phenomenon is that a significant part of Europeana use takes place within institutions using browsers set up in kiosk mode. However, even when the data is reprocessed with a filter to remove the most obvious heavy institutions referrals the daily pattern persists. Engagement We can calculate levels of engagement by considering both: (a) duration of a visit; (b) numbers pages viewed during a visit. The most recent data shows that 60 % of visits are very short (<10 s); and less than 2 % are recorded by GA as exceeding 30 min (the normal cookie timeout for a visit). Most visits are over in the blink of an eye. This is probably what we would expect of a discovery site rather than a destination site, where the times are much higher. In terms of page views 58 % looked at just one page, less than 5 % view more than 16 pages. Of course this comes with short visits. The site s character is of course changing with the introduction of virtual exhibitions and when we come to the virtual exhibition section we can see people dwelling longer and examining more pages.
11 Information Seeking Behaviour and Usage on a Multi-media Platform 67 Fig. 7 Hours between visits. (Source: GA) When looking at figures for duration of visit it is important to note the highly skewed distribution: most visits are very short, a table with ranges of values can be misleading, as is any average figure. Table 1 and Fig. 9 and show visit times for December The average visit duration is 2 min and 19 s, it varies little depending on what time span is analysed, whereas the chart reveals the full picture: there is much larger range, a few visits are very much longer, but most are extremely short. In December % of visits were timed at less than 10 s; only 10 % of visits fall broadly (1 3 min) into the average category band. The story on engagement is an interesting one: usage (page views) has not kept pace with overall growth rates, having grown just over 60 % from Autumn to Autumn and with a huge fall (nearly 30 %) being recorded in the number of pages viewed per visit (was previously 5.4 and now 3.8) and a smaller, but still large fall (nearly 17 %) in the duration of visits. Average is a very poor measure of visit duration so not much can be read into a decline in this figure from 2:46 s, to 2:18 s. Especially as the Bounce Rate has fallen (from 54 to 50 %), and we might have expected this to go up in the circumstances. So, it is probable that stickiness has increased (fewer bouncers), but is partly masked by a corresponding reduction in the number of unreal users consuming many pages in long sessions. These unreal users are not search-engine spiders which are already excluded from the analysis. Nor do we mean outliers which are cases where we have come
12 68 D. Nicholas and D. Clark Fig. 8 Days between visits. (Source: GA) Table 1 Duration of visits, December (Source: GA) Visit duration (s) Visits , , , , , , ,707 to a firm conclusion that the activity is that of a cloaked bot. Once we have discounted these we are still left with patterns of activity that are implausible, such as sessions that never time out or appear to view an unreasonable pages etc. In some cases that can be explained by kiosk applications in libraries, API usage, or by developer testing. Essentially unreal users are that portion of the recorded usage which we find not proven. There is insufficient evidence to classify as robot or outlier, but the suspicion remains that it would be unwise to fully trust any inference from this data.
13 Information Seeking Behaviour and Usage on a Multi-media Platform 69 Fig. 9 Europeana: duration of visit. (Source: GA) Social Media With so much Europeana (and scholarly publisher) planning (and hopes) resting on social media use for growth and re-use it is worth first pointing out that there are substantial problems in defining Social Media, which need to be clarified in order to make a fair and accurate evaluations and comparison of growth rates and contribution to overall traffic. The Google Analytics advanced segment for social media, as personally defined and used by Europeana, contains 20 sources (referrer domains), some of which have registered insignificant or even no traffic at all during the last six months (October 2012 March 2013) See Table 2. The major sources of social traffic are Facebook, and Wikipedia; there is also significant traffic from WordPress, Blogspot, twitter and, a considerable way behind, Pinterest, the latter being publicised on the Europeana homepage for many weeks during We shall return to individual performance later in this section, here we shall confine ourselves to the problems of definition. An interesting definitional case is Twitter. The Twitter traffic is identified by include Source containing t.co. Patently, this is too loose a definition as it will not only pick up t.co, but any domain containing that sequence of characters e.g. search.bt.com. The result is that that the number of visits captured by this method is at 9,993 (for the most recent six months) four times greater than the actual number of visits from t.co (Twitter). The true total of social sources (40,791) is inflated
14 70 D. Nicholas and D. Clark Table 2 Social segment definition (GA) Social Page views facebook.com tweet 0 LinkedIn 361 YouTube 42 reddit 167 digg 14 delicious 83 stumbleupon 0 Flickr 222 MySpace 0 hootsuite 28 retronaut 167 Wikipedia bit.ly 0 tinyurl 0 t.co 9993 wp.me 0 blogspot 4044 wordpress 4253 Pinterest 1265 sum intersect Oct-Mar by 19 % (48,449).The overall effect on the visit count for the social segment is to some extent mitigated by the fortunate chance that the loose t.co rule will pick up blogspot.com which is already included by its own rule. The problem can be fixed by replacing the rule include Source containing t.co with include Source Exactly matching t.co or with include Source Matching RegEx ^t\.co. Blogs pose definitional problems too (Table 3). The social segment includes blogs but only those from WordPress and Blogger. There are many other blogs hosted elsewhere that are not included. On the other hand treating all referrals originating from a WordPress or Blogger domain may be too broad a definition of a blog. WordPress in particular is a popular hosting platform for photographers and artists galleries. No method of classification will be entirely satisfactory but on balance we think the social classification should be broadened to include any domain containing the subdomain blog. or blogs., but excluding blog.europeana.eu. The result is that another 1,085 visits can be added to the social segment. Google Analytics provides under Traffic Sources a Social analysis. Looking at the Network Referrals section of this report it is clear that the GA definition of social is again far broader than either Europeana s own Advanced Segment definition or the corrected and extended version used by CIBER. How many networks are included depends on the period of the report: for March-April 2013 it includes 48, Jan May 2012/2013 includes 78 etc. The definition is as long as a piece of string and makes social network behaviour very difficult to delineate.
15 Information Seeking Behaviour and Usage on a Multi-media Platform 71 Table 3 Social segment blogs (selection only). (Source: GA) Oct 1, 2011 Mar 31, 2012 Oct 1, 2012 Mar 31, 2013 agioritikesmnimes.pblogs.gr 64 0 bazoga.over-blog.com 43 0 bgpw.blog.pl blog.bnf.fr blog.crdp-versailles.fr 43 0 blog.daum.net blog.euscreen.eu 0 64 blogs.ec.europa.eu blogs.helsinki.fi 21 0 blog.sina.com.cn 0 64 blogs.law.harvard.edu 64 0 blog.slub-dresden.de 21 0 blogs.sch.gr boqo.over-blog.com 21 0 cblog.culture.fr 43 0 christypato.blog.br 21 0 deal.blog.kazeo.com deal.blog.mongenie.com digiblog.hu 21 0 enfinlivre.blog.lemonde.fr 43 0 estudamais8.blogs.sapo.pt 21 0 eueublog.wordpress.com 0 64 fablog.iransalamat.com 43 0 formacion.universiablogs.net 43 0 googleblog.blogspot.com 21 0 kluwercopyrightblog.com 21 0 konzervativci.blog.com.mk 21 0 leblog-ffg.over-blog.org libblog.ucy.ac.cy 21 0 pisani.blog.lemonde.fr sog.blog.so-net.ne.jp 0 21 somewhereinblog.net To conclude there are three social definitions at work here: Google s, Europeana s social segment and CIBER s own expanded version based on a corrected version of the Europeana social segment and used for the following analyses. Size and Growth in Traffic To place social media referrals in context it is worth first looking at all referrals. Seventy per cent of the 4.5 M visits to Europeana in the past year (2012) were search referrals, nearly all (97 %) from Google. By contrast, runner-up Bing accounts for just 0.5 %. Eighteen per cent of visits originate as links from other sites,
16 72 D. Nicholas and D. Clark 11 % are direct typed-in or bookmarked and campaigns (newsletters etc.) contribute a little over 1 %. Google Analytics was not reporting social referral before Oct 2011, so there is a limited time series, which we can to some extent enhance with log data. The limited data we have show that there was a slight peak in social referrals around the time of a new portal launch in October 2011 (thanks to associated publicity one presumes), but after that it settles down to around 1,000 per week; since August 2012 there has been some irregular growth and the base-rate is now nearing 1500 per week. Between Oct March 2011/2012 and 2012/2013 the overall year-on-year general visitor growth is 90 %. However if we look at the social segment the visitor growth is 34 %. Exclude blogs and visitor growth falls to 25 %. Looking at blogs alone [the visitor growth rate is 58 %. The social element is a little more significant on the exhibitions site and predictably significant for blog.europeana. In April 2013 Social Referrals only accounted for one per cent of all visits to the site, a bare 0.02 % higher than a year previous. It could be that Europeana s social media activity takes place solely within the context of these sites and entirely bypasses Europeana.eu. In such a context we cannot refute claims for the efficacy of social media, nor can we support them. In the context of the Europeana.eu website however social referral is not at present significant and is not growing above the trend for the site as a whole. So the action has to be happening elsewhere, on the social media sites themselves. Individual Social Media The dominant social media network is Facebook with nearly 30,000 referrals in the year since the new portal launch (Oct 2011). The average visit duration of these Facebook sourced visitors is, according to Google Analytics just over 3 min. Although average is a poor single metric to use in this context the distribution being log-normal the duration is slightly higher than the 2.5 min average for all visitors. So more dwell time for social media users, but not really sufficient to build a strong case for more committed users, and anyway see our earlier comments about the problems of using dwell time in isolation as a metric. Facebook was followed by WordPress in popularity, nearly 9000 referrals, Blogger (over 4200), Twitter (nearly 3300) and Netvibes (just over 2000). When we consider and compare only the relatively stable Autumn months (Sept Dec, 2011 and 2012) the overall doubling of traffic on the site is not matched by a corresponding growth in social referrals year on year: Facebook (nearly referrals, 2012) and Twitter (1650 referrals) traffic in particular shows only a 12 % increase in visits. Only WordPress, with only a third of the Facebook traffic (3037 referrals in 2012; 162 % year-on-year growth) has kept pace with the overall pace of the site. However, Twitter is an interesting case because while there is little growth in referrals, dwell time has in fact doubled. The average for Twitter was 2.5 min in autumn 2011, 5 min in Pinterest, Europeana s latest social media venture, a content sharing service that allows members to pin images videos and other
17 Information Seeking Behaviour and Usage on a Multi-media Platform 73 objects to their pin board, currently featured on the Europeana homepage (and so attracting considerable publicity), surprisingly perhaps comes in at 6th in the social media ranking, with a light traffic flow (681 visits Sep Dec 2012). The high number of page views per visit from Pinterest (average 12) and very long dwell time (12 min) suggest unreal user activity, something odd is happening here. We suspect, as this feature on the home page is quite recent, that this may be internal development or testing activity. This should be checked, otherwise a false impression might be provided. We can contrast the traffic flow for the site as a whole with the flow of social media visits using Google Analytics. For the site as a whole most inbound traffic goes direct to a record (about half of all non-search engine referrals) and twelve per cent to search. Interestingly, for social referrals half the inbound traffic goes to the homepage and around seventeen per cent to search. An informal analysis of trackbacks provided by Google Analytics suggests that much of the social traffic may be by people involved in development or research in digital humanities and related fields, not a very representative group: insiders. During the period, 30 Dec Jan 2013, when there were 6,628 social referrals, blog.europeana.eu had 8,000 visitors. It is probable the blog users are already familiar with Europeana in which case it is probably not bringing in many new users. My Europeana, a personal/customised facility, may also be considered to belong in the social category. Between June and December 2012 a total of 1400 users were recorded as having logged in with a userid, less than 300 even in the busiest month of November. Though a few users appear to login and view many hundreds of pages in a month there is little evidence of regular and sustained use of My Europeana, less than 50, a tiny amount, have used the feature for three or more months in seven. The majority appear in the record one month only during which they view less than forty pages. Overall logged-in users account for one-half per cent of all page views. Social media, then, is not driving Europeana growth, and unlikely to do from the evidence we have to hand. The example of Pinterest is illustrative. Consider the featuring of a link to Pinterest on the Europeana homepage: this would appear to be of net benefit to Pinterest. Europeana has over 2,000 followers on Pinterest and over 600 pins, but referrals back to Europeana during the last four months of 2012 amount to 680. The big question is what, in the context of Europeana, is social media for? Should we expect it to drive traffic to Europeana, or is Europeana the glue layer that enables Pinterest to be a showcase for Europeana s provider institutions? There is scope for a more comprehensive research programme in this area, linking together the traffic analysis of the Europeana web-presence (including blog, exhibitions, API) with similar data drawn from Europeana s providers. Of course, all these social media initiatives are insignificant compared to the bread and butter search engine referral; and not just via Google: pionier.net.pl the Polish aggregator site brought in 37,000 (5 %) referrals, compared to facebook.com 29,000 (< 4 %), with all its millions of members. A study by Europeana (http://pro. europeana.eu/pro-blog/-/blogs/ ) shows that API use by the Polish partners is proving very successful in sending traffic to Europeana.
18 74 D. Nicholas and D. Clark Most of the social media (narrowly defined) traffic appears to flow into the home page rather than to specific items. This is in marked contrast to referrals from blogs which are more often to a specific page. Country Analysis First a note of caution: determining the user s location is only approximate and, particularly when looking at the standard Google Analytics report, language choice and country are not the same: Language: en-us is not the same as Country/Territory: United States. The language indication is merely the default setting of the browser and cannot be relied upon. Location, which is based on IP address allocation, can also cross borders. Taking this into account it is still somewhat surprising to find that the most active country for social media traffic to Europeana.eu is Spain. In the most recent sixmonths Spain accounts for 8.8 % of social media traffic as defined by Europeana s own Social Media advanced segment, the USA is second (7.1 %). Taking into account the much larger population of the USA and the mature state of social media uptake there this is unexpected. However, as we have already observed Social Media accounts only for 1 per cent of visits and visitors, so the statistics are likely to be unstable and be perturbed by factors which can be difficult to identify. Social Actions and Social Media In order to find out whether users coming from social media are more likely to share (thought to be a positive by information providers) you first have to define likely to share. The clickstream logs show negligible use of the SAVE_SOCIAL_TAG action. For the period June December 2012 (the only period for which we have clickstream logs) the action occurred 189 times. Set against 9.6 million accesses to object pages (FULL_RESULT_HTML) and 4.8 million presentations of search results (BRIEF_RESULT:search), and 1.6 views of the homepage (INDEXPAGE) it is clear that not much sharing goes on; so insignificant that we need to look for another definition of social media sharing. If we turn to the Google Analytics equivalent, Social Plugins, the numbers are still low, but better: September 2012 March 2013, 3,945 Unique Social Actions. Set against the 3.4 million visits in that period a social sharing action occurs at a rate of one per 866 visits (0.12 %). When that report is restricted using Europeana s own Social Media advanced segment the number is reduced to 291 Unique Social Actions. There is indeed a greater propensity to share by visitors coming from social media: a rate of one per 146 visits (0.68 %). But the actual numbers are very small, in fact of the 142 Social sharing sources used by all visitors only three Facebook, Google+, and Twitter appear when the report is restricted to social segment referrals. One reason for this may be that the advanced segment has been defined too narrowly inputs should match outputs; all the social sites recorded by Google
19 Information Seeking Behaviour and Usage on a Multi-media Platform 75 Fig. 10 Exhibitions: visits. (Source: GA) Analytics as social sources should be included in the segment. The alternative is to restrict the Social Plugins report to match the advanced segment. In that case the all users figure declines to one in 1,104 (0.09 %) [the Social segment is, of course, unchanged at 0.68 %]. So, users coming from social media are more likely to share. However there might be a strong element of auto-correlation here, a tautology: social media users share because that is what social media is about. Virtual Exhibitions Exhibitions were only just featuring towards the end of or Europeana Connect work in 2011 so CIBER came to this topic fresh and very interested in looking at the impact it has had. It looked like a break-through in Europeana thinking and here surely is something that could capture the interest of the digital information consumer and armchair tourist, strategic markets for Europeana. It could speak to a lot of people. Certainly so as the homepage seems to have become increasingly a promotional tool and virtual exhibitions are clearly thought to have a major role here, in promoting, highlighting and sampling Europeana; there is a prominent carousel from which you can choose an exhibition to visit. The amount of space allocated to comment and feedback on exhibits suggests a degree of interactivity is expected; furthermore exhibitions are by their nature places to view and browse and therefore we should expect that people spend greater amounts of time here than elsewhere on the Europeana site. Dwell time is a more meaningful a metric here. We have to rely solely on GA for this evaluation (Fig. 10) as we do not have raw log files for the exhibitions site. Sept Dec, 2011 and 2012 data shows that there has been a 50 % increase in visitors, and pages per visit has increased from 7 to 12 pages, the bounce rate is very low (0 %) compared to the main site, so people appear to be dwelling; and we might have, at long last, that much sort after stickiness. About 10 % of exhibition visitors appear to be using a mobile (tablet) platform, which is also relatively high. The most recent figures (Tables 4 and 5) show that the overall number of exhibition visits (less than 50,000 Sept Dec 2012) is still relatively low relative compared to the visits to the main site (1.6 million). That is, just over 3 % of all visitors find their way to an exhibition. But that is perhaps an unreasonable comparison; they
20 76 D. Nicholas and D. Clark Table 4 Exhibitions, Europeana.eu. (Source: GA) Sep Dec 2012 Sep Dec 2011 (%) Visits 47,078 30, Visitors 38,573 26, Pageviews 550, , Pages per visit Duration of visit 00:02:44 00:02:58 8 Bounce rate 0 % 32 % 99 New Visits 80 % 83 % 3 Table 5 Exhibitions, visitors 30 Dec Jan (Source: GA) Visits Pages/visit Bounce rate (%) Royal book collections 2, , European sports Total visits 14,078 are, after all, a relatively novel feature and fifty-thousand visits are significant when placed in contrast to the traffic flows associated with social media. Thirty-per-cent of visits to exhibitions come from the carousel on the main site homepage (11,881 visits), so homepage promotion appears to be successful. In fact nothing else is really very successful (e.g. newsletters). In contrast to the main site Search traffic is far less significant (less than a quarter) as a source of visitors. Whilst referral traffic tends to be directed to the main page, direct traffic lands on specific exhibitions, notably with 6,540 visits (13 % of total) September December There is a strong flow from one exhibit (record) to another which suggests visitors are following the exhibition sequence. In conclusion: exhibitions are sticky and successful but interest (as is the nature of the exhibition trade) is volatile. Conclusions For the very first time CIBER has been able to evaluate Europeana usage by all the available quantitative methodologies: deep log analysis, ClickStreamer logs and Google Analytics. In fact we believe this is the first time the three methodologies have been employed in regard to usage of a single website. We were especially interested to find out whether Google Analytics popularity is matched by its capabilities and this article produces many useful GA derived analyses. GA proved to be a very useful usage tool, albeit one which sometimes underestimates usage, and also one which needs careful calibration and interpretation to obtain full benefits. Of course, using multiple sources of data has a downside as it highlights differences and divergences which need to be resolved. Considerable effort has gone into ironing out the resulting confusion caused. If you only have one clock you either trust the time it tells, compensating for known errors, or do without. If you have two clocks that tell different times, you cannot trust either: you know less not more.
Continuing and evolving evaluation the big data way text Professor David Nicholas and Dr David Clark text CIBER and University of Tennessee Europeana is an innovative web portal that opens a doorway to
5 Point Social Media Action Plan. Workshop delivered by Ian Gibbins, IG Media Marketing Ltd (firstname.lastname@example.org, tel: 01733 241537) On behalf of the Chambers Communications Sector Introduction: There
1 Which of the following questions can be answered using the goal flow report? [A] Are there a lot of unexpected exits from a step in the middle of my conversion funnel? [B] Do visitors usually start my
GOOGLE ANALYTICS 101 Presented By Adrienne C. Dupree Please feel free to share this report with anyone who is interested in the topic of building a profitable online business. Simply forward it to them
How to Measure Marketing Results: The Newest Rules www.fusionb2b.com How to Measure Marketing Results: The Newest Rules In a recent survey sponsored by FUSION b2b s client the Construction Marketing Association,
Session 2 Exploration main reports in more detail Real-Time reports Real-Time reports Use Real-Time to monitor user activity as it happens see each pageview being reported seconds after it occurs how many
8 illegitimate reasons for discrepancies between AdWords and Google Analytics conversions If you are an experienced AdWords advertiser, you probably have familiarity with AdWords conversion tracking code.
GUIDE Social Media Strategy Guide How to build your strategy from start to finish Social Media Strategy Guide How to build your strategy from start to finish Whether you re a social media coordinator for
Lead Generation in Emerging Markets White paper Summary I II III IV V VI VII Which are the emerging markets? Why emerging markets? How does the online help? Seasonality Do we know when to profit on what
1 Google Analytics for Robust Website Analytics Deepika Verma, Depanwita Seal, Atul Pandey 2 Table of Contents I. INTRODUCTION...3 II. Method for obtaining data for web analysis...3 III. Types of metrics
PEGASUS CREATIVE Google Analytics and the Modernization of Marketing Web Content Development Internship Chandler Anderson 5/12/2013 One of the most important functions of any kind of business is gathering
Measuring your Social Media Efforts Measuring your Social Media Efforts Author PR & Social Media Consultant, Sarah Michelle Willis (MCIPR), is a passionate senior strategic PR & Communications professional
understanding media metrics WEB METRICS Basics for Journalists FIRST IN A SERIES Contents p 1 p 3 p 3 Introduction Basic Questions about Your Website Getting Started: Overall, how is our website doing?
SEO 360: The Essentials of Search Engine Optimization By Chris Adams, Director of Online Marketing & Research INTRODUCTION Effective Search Engine Optimization is not a highly technical or complex task,
BeeSocial M A R K E T I N G Create A Buzz About Your Business Social Media Marketing Bee Social Marketing is part of Genacom, Inc. www.genacom.com What is Social Media Marketing? Social Media Marketing
WEB ANALYTICS Presented by Massimo Paolini MPThree Consulting Inc. www.mpaolini.com 408-256-0673 WEB ANALYTICS IS ABOUT INCREASING REVENUE WHAT WE LL COVER Why should you use Asynchronous code What are
Infinity Call Tracking An introduction from our founder Infinity Tracking is the most advanced call tracking solution in the UK and can track an unlimited number of search keywords. For any company where
Impressive Analytics and Insight on a Shoestring Lisa Ikariyama & Tracy Anderson Cabbage Tree Creative www.cabbagetree.co.nz Getting Started Before you design a page on your website or get started with
White Paper Best Practices and Emerging Marketing Trends Measuring ROI: The Marketing Metrics You Can t Ignore What gets measured, gets managed. Peter Drucker Why Measure? From beginning to end and sometimes
More Enquiries, Same Budget: Solving the B2B Marketer s Challenge You need to increase inbound enquiries, both in volume and quality, but your budget is restricted. Sound familiar? Prospect Analytics offers
White paper: Google Analytics 12 steps to advanced setup for developers We at Core work with a range of companies who come to us to advises them and manage their search and social requirements. Dr Jess
INSIGHTS WHITEPAPER What Motivates People to Apply for an MBA? netnatives.com twitter.com/netnatives NET NATIVES HISTORY & SERVICES Welcome to our report on using data to analyse the behaviour of people
How using Google Analytics can improve your website performance and social campaigns How using Google Analytics can improve your website performance and social campaigns Google Analytics is undoubtedly
Introduction to Web Analytics Terms N10014 Introduction N40002 This glossary provides definitions for common web analytics terms and discusses their use in Unica Web Analytics. The definitions are arranged
A Beginner s Guide to Google Analytics by Ben Barden Third Edition Updated 19/10/2014 Contents Getting Started... 3 Introduction... 3 Get the code... 3 Orientation... 4 Jargon Buster... 4 Understanding
ARTICLE 29 DATA PROTECTION WORKING PARTY 00879/12/EN WP 194 Opinion 04/2012 on Cookie Consent Exemption Adopted on 7 June 2012 This Working Party was set up under Article 29 of Directive 95/46/EC. It is
Page 1 of 5 An Introduction to Social Media for Business Social media is the general term used to describe the growing number of websites and networks whose users can submit and share content, communicate,
Introduction To Integrated Marketing: BUILDING A HOLISTIC MARKETING STRATEGY Email Social Media Online Events Blogs Web S ite Intelligence Landing Pages Integrated Analytics Many B2B marketers invest fortunes
Page 1 Page 2 INTRODUCTION... 3 WHAT S NEW THIS YEAR?... 4 SOCIAL MEDIA RESULTS... 5 FEW COMPANIES TRACK ROI... 5 ROI METRICS... 6 WHAT PEOPLE SAY:... 6 REE... 7 SOCIAL MEDIA BUDGETS... 7 INVESTMENT CREATES
Interpreting Web Analytics Data Whitepaper 8650 Commerce Park Place, Suite G Indianapolis, Indiana 46268 (317) 875-0910 email@example.com www.pentera.com Interpreting Web Analytics Data At some point in
SOCIAL MEDIA ADVERTISING STRATEGIES THAT WORK ABSTRACT» Social media advertising is a new and fast growing part of digital advertising. In this White Paper I'll present social media advertising trends,
Google Analytics Basics Contents Google Analytics: An Introduction...3 Google Analytics Features... 3 Google Analytics Interface... Changing the Date Range... 8 Graphs... 9 Put Stats into Context... 10
Marketing Online SEO Facebook Google Twitter YouTube What is Internet Marketing? Internet marketing is considered to be broad in scope because it not only refers to marketing on the Internet, but also
AUDIENCE ENGAGEMENT DISCOVERY VS. SEARCH VS. SOCIAL FEBRUARY 2014 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Critical to developing relationships with consumers and audiences on the web is the ability to engage them beyond a mere
Online Marketing Training Level: 1 Duration: 3 Days Time: 9:30 AM - 4:30 PM Cost: 697 Overview Online Marketing is all about ensuring your business, product or service is maximising the potential of the
OVERVIEW OF INTERNET MARKETING Introduction to the various ways in which you can market your business online 2 April 2012 Version 1.0 Contents Contents 2 Introduction 4 Skill Level 4 Terminology 4 What
What is Prospect Analytics? Everything you need to know about this new sphere of sales and marketing technology and how it can improve your business Table of Contents Executive Summary... 2 The Power of
A 7-Step Analytics Reporting Framework By Feras Alhlou, Principal Marketing Consultant 2 Marketing Optimization Imagine that you just attended a conference on digital marketing and analytics. You re pumped
Web design At the start of a new or redesign web project, an important first step is to define the objectives for the web site. What actions do you want visitors to take when they land on the web site?
smart. uncommon. ideas. Executive Overview Your brand needs friends with benefits. Content plus keywords equals more traffic. It s a widely recognized onsite formula to effectively boost your website s
Do I Really Need A New Website & Interactive Strategy? Steps to Building an Effective On-Line Strategy Table of Contents: Introduction - Page 2-3 Interactive Web Design - Page 3-5 Basic Interactive Website
1 Understand how PPC can help you achieve your marketing objectives at every stage of the sales funnel. 2 WHO IS THIS GUIDE FOR? This guide is written for marketers who want to get more from their digital
web analytics 201 Not just for beginners, This primer is designed to help clarify some of the major challenges faced by marketers today, such as:...and beyond -defining KPIs in a complex environment -organizing
The six key marketing challenges facing recruitment firms today September job opportunities across the UK were up by 16% year-on-year according to research statistics from Reed, and while the British economy
The Guide to: Email Marketing Analytics" This guide has been lovingly created by Sign-Up.to we provide email marketing, mobile marketing and social media tools and services to organisations of all shapes
Google Analytics workbook Sub-title here Google Analytics workbook Overview Google Analytics is just one of many tools available for tracking activity on a website or mobile application. It provides users
Central Ohio s Small Business Resource Who is @Tonya Wilson? Program Coordinator for the Ohio SBDC at Columbus State Manage SBDC marketing, branding, outreach, digital media & events AAS Multimedia Production
MONITORING YOUR WEBSITE WITH GOOGLE ANALYTICS How to use Google Analytics to track activity on your website and help get the most out of your website 2 April 2012 Version 1.0 Contents Contents 2 Introduction
Fully Qualified Marketing Company Helping our clients succeed online Visit www.finnmedia.ie for free advice & details Digital Marketing Strategy What is it? Digital strategy is about adapting your organisation
Introduction to Social Media Marketing Using social media to promote your events. What is Social Media Marketing? Social media marketing is the process of gaining awareness, driving traffic and engaging
The Power of Social Media - TrekTraka LLC Level 1, 80 Jephson St Toowong, Qld, Australia e firstname.lastname@example.org p +61 (0)7 3103 2660 w www.trektraka.com 2 Purpose of this paper This paper provides a high
The Perfect Digital Marketing Recipe For Your Business Success Executive Summary With a wide variety of options available to us, it can often be difficult to find the optimum combination of tools and techniques
Social media importance in Businesses Social media networks were a novelty 5 years ago, but today their importance is no longer debated. Yes, businesses have definitely realized the power of social media
Google Analytics Health Check Laying the foundations for successful analytics and optimisation Google Analytics Property [UA-1234567-1] Domain [Client URL] Date of Review MMM YYYY Consultant [Consultant
AN INTRODUCTION TO PINTEREST FOR BUSINESS. A setup and strategy guide for marketers. A publication of 2 CONTENTS. 04 10 Why Use Pinterest? How to Create a Pinterest Business Account 15 15 Pinterest for
Web Analytics Big Three Definitions Version 1.0 Unique Visitors Visits/Sessions Page Views Web Analytics Association 2300 M Street, Suite 800 Washington DC 20037 email@example.com 1-800-349-1070
Online Certificate March 2012 Setting the standard Changeboard Key information Certificate type Digital Metric type Web traffic ABC headline 5,445 Daily average Unique Browsers Period 1 March 2012 to 31
Guide: Social Media Metrics in Government Guide: Social Media Metrics in Government Why Social Media Metrics Matter to Your Agency In a digital strategy, nearly anything can be measured, compiled and analyzed.
Lead Generation in Emerging Markets White paper Summary I II III IV V VI VII Which are the emerging markets? Why emerging markets? How does online help? Seasonality Do we know when to profit on what we
Adults media use and attitudes report Research Document Publication date: April 013 Contents Section Page 1 Executive summary... 4 Introduction... 1.1 Background... 1. Research methodology and analysis...
Why Google Analytics Doesn t Work for E-Commerce Why Google Analytics Doesn t Work for E-Commerce Customers they are the core of e-commerce. Because their buying behaviour has become so complex, businesses
Higher Education in Further Education Webinar Contents 1. Introduction 2. Make an HE Recruitment Calendar 3. Advertise across multiple platforms 4. Understand your digital audience 5. Engage students with
Internet Marketing Services From Transform Your Marketing to the Way the World Wants to be Marketed To! It's no secret that the marketing landscape has changed dramatically over the past few years as Internet
CREATING YOUR ONLINE PRESENCE Congratulations on signing up for your webhosting package, you ve just completed the first and most important step in establishing your online presence. There are just a few
Social media Content Coordinator (online marketing manager) We serve private, non profits and governmental agencies. We are seeking to grow our digital media department as well as the company s digital
About the Tutorial is a technique that you can employ to collect, measure, report, and analyze your website data. It is normally carried out to analyze the performance of a website and optimize its web
What You Need to Know Before Distributing Your Infographic Improve your audience outreach efforts by learning why and how to use the best social, owned and earned platforms available. Targeting specific
Cookies Compliance Advisory Note: this is an advisory notice that summarises the current position of the Article 29 Working Group and makes suggestions as to how organisations might practically achieve
Today s Presentation Lesson 1. What's the big deal?- Understand how your prospective student customer communicates- The digital native Lesson 2. Internet marketing- Improve your organisations website Lesson
The Evolution of Social Media Marketing: 9 trends to know now. It s hard to think of a time when social media didn t exist when people of all ages weren t snapping photos of their food, sharing selfies
Digital TV switchover: Social media By Matt Heselden, Social media lead Summary With the growth in popularity of social media, we recognised that increasing numbers of consumers and opinion formers would
Changes In Google And Bing Local Results Penguin Update Continues To Affect Local Rankings TOP 7 UPDATES IN LOCAL SEARCH FOR JANUARY 2015 1 How To Add A sticky Post on Google+ page Facebook Allows Calls-To-Action
Social Media and Content Marketing. A Guide for B2B Marketing Managers Social media and content marketing. A guide for B2B marketing managers On the Internet, marketing trends come and go faster than ever.