2009 Residential Bill Survey Jurisdictional Electric Utilities July 1, 2009 Billing

Transcription

1 2009 Residential Bill Survey Jurisdictional Electric Utilities July 1, 2009 Billing Commission Staff presents a survey of electric utility billings for residential customers served under Indiana state rate-setting jurisdiction. The surveyed providers to these customers include 5 investor-owned, 4 co-operative and 15 municipal Utilities. We note that 61 municipal and 38 co-operative electricity providers within the state are excluded as non-jurisdictional. We present the results in a variety of ways to improve the transparency of data collected. All rates included in this survey are those applicable on customer bills issued July 1. The initial tables show the July 1, 2009 bill applicable to simple tariff residential customers at 500, 1000, 1500, and 2000 kwh monthly consumption levels first alphabetically and then ranked by 1000 kwh cost, highest being 1 st. Next we present the year over year change to the customer bills at 1000 kwh. The survey includes all rate trackers but excludes taxes. Expense and capital trackers provide a means to include cost changes in customer rates outside of a traditional rate case. The fuel and power cost tracker for each municipal in 2009 is compared to 2008 in Table 4. The investor-owned group employs a variety of tracking mechanisms for which the 2009 and 2008 charges are listed for comparison. Table 6 has been added to disaggregate the base and variable cost components of 1000 kwh consumption. Figure Nos. 1 and 2 show the investor-owned electric utilities 1000 kwh residential customer bills for the current and historical periods, respectively. Table/Figure List Table 1 Jurisdictional Electric Utility Residential Customer Bill Survey: By Type and Utility Name Alphabetically Table 2 Jurisdictional Electric Utility Residential Customer Bills: 1000 kwh Table 3 Jurisdictional Electric Utility Residential Customer Bill: 2009 vs Comparison Table 4 Jurisdictional Municipal Electric Utility Residential Customer Bills: Fuel/Power Cost Tracker 2009 vs Comparison Table 5 Investor-owned Electric Utility Residential Customer Bills: Rate Tracker 2009 vs Comparison Table 6 Investor-owned Electric Utility Residential Customer Bills: Base and Variable Cost Components Figure 1 Figure 2 Investor-owned Electric Utility Residential Customer Bills: 1000 kwh Consumption, July 1, 2009 Billing Investor-owned Electric Utility Residential Customer Bills: 1000 kwh Consumption, Historically

2 Table 1 JURISDICTIONAL ELECTRIC UTILITY RESIDENTIAL CUSTOMER BILL SURVEY [July 1, 2009 Billing] By Utility Name and Type MUNICIPAL UTILITIES Anderson Municipal Auburn Municipal Columbia City Municipal Crawfordsville Municipal Frankfort Municipal Kingsford Heights Municipal Knightstown Municipal Lebanon Municipal Logansport Municipal Mishawaka Municipal Peru Municipal Richmond Municipal Straughn Municipal Tipton Municipal Troy Municipal COOPERATIVE UTILITIES Harrison County REMC Jackson County REMC Marshall County REMC Northeastern REMC INVESTOR OWNED UTILITIES Duke Energy Indiana Indiana Michigan Power D/B/A AEP Indianapolis Power & Light Co. Northern Indiana Public Service Co. So. Indiana Gas & Electric Co. D/B/A Vectren kwh Consumption Overall Ranking* $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ *Overall Ranking based on Total Rate at 1000 kwh consumption.

3 Table 2 JURISDICTIONAL ELECTRIC UTILITY RESIDENTIAL CUSTOMER BILLS [July 1, 2009 Billing] Overall Ranking for 1,000 kwh of Consumption < kwh Consumption > NAME kwh kwh kwh kwh 1 So. Indiana Gas & Electric Co. D/B/A Vectren $ $ $ $ Marshall County REMC $ $ $ $ Troy Municipal $ $ $ $ Northeastern REMC $ $ $ $ Northern Indiana Public Service Co. $ $ $ $ Harrison County REMC $ $ $ $ Jackson County REMC $ $ $ $ Duke Energy Indiana $ $ $ $ Logansport Municipal $ $ $ $ Anderson Municipal $ $ $ $ Kingsford Heights Municipal $ $ $ $ Peru Municipal $ $ $ $ Richmond Municipal $ $ $ $ Knightstown Municipal $ $ $ $ Crawfordsville Municipal $ $ $ $ Columbia City Municipal $ $ $ $ Lebanon Municipal $ $ $ $ Indiana Michigan Power D/B/A AEP $ $ $ $ Indianapolis Power & Light Co. $ $ $ $ Tipton Municipal $ $ $ $ Frankfort Municipal $ $ $ $ Mishawaka Municipal $ $ $ $ Straughn Municipal $ $ $ $ Auburn Municipal $ $ $ $ Average $ $95.13 $ $ Survey $ $86.28 $ $ % Change 8.99% 10.26% 10.88% 11.27%

4 Table 3 Jurisdictional Electric Utility Residential Customer Bill 1000 kwh Usage, July 1 Billing (By Name) Year to Year Comparison MUNICIPAL UTILITIES % Change Anderson Municipal $ $ % Auburn Municipal $ $ % Columbia City Municipal $ $ % Crawfordsville Municipal $ $ % Frankfort Municipal $ $ % Kingsford Heights Municipal $ $ % Knightstown Municipal $ $ % Lebanon Municipal $ $ % Logansport Municipal $ $ % Mishawaka Municipal $ $ % Peru Municipal $ $ % Richmond Municipal $ $ % Straughn Municipal $ $ % Tipton Municipal $ $ % Troy Municipal $ $ % Muni Averages % COOPERATIVE UTILITIES Harrison County REMC $ $ % Jackson County REMC $ $ % Marshall County REMC $ $ % Northeastern REMC $ $ % Co-op Averages % INVESTOR OWNED UTILITIES Duke Energy Indiana $ $ % Indiana Michigan Power D/B/A AEP $ $ % Indianapolis Power & Light Co. $ $ % Northern Indiana Public Service Co. $ $ % So. Indiana Gas & Electric Co. D/B/A Vectren $ $ % IOU Averages %

5 Table 4 Jurisdictional Municipal Electric Utility Residential Customer Bill 1000 kwh Usage, July 1 Billing (By Name) Year to Year Comparison Fuel/Power Factor Adjustment Mechanism Fuel/Power Factor 1000 kwh Change Anderson Municipal $29.42 $21.66 $7.76 Auburn Municipal Columbia City Municipal Crawfordsville Municipal Frankfort Municipal Kingsford Heights Municipal Knightstown Municipal Lebanon Municipal Logansport Municipal Mishawaka Municipal Peru Municipal Richmond Municipal Straughn Municipal (1.13) Tipton Municipal Troy Municipal

6 Table 5 Indiana Investor-Owned Electric Utilities Year to Year Comparison Adjustable Rate Mechanisms on Residential Bills 1000 kwh Usage, July 1 Billing Change $ $ $ Indiana Michigan Power D/B/A AEP FAC DSM Off-System Sales Sharing (1.77) (1.77) RTO QPCP & QPCP O&M EA Merger Savings (Settlement) (0.93) 0.93 Total Indianapolis Power & Light Co. FAC Voluntary Credit applied via FAC (7.30) 7.30 QPCP & QPCP O&M DSM ACLM Total Northern Indiana Public Service Co. FAC QPCP QPCP O&M Customer Credit (Settlement) (6.36) (6.04) (0.32) Total Duke Energy Indiana FAC (0.62) QPCP QPCP O&M EA (0.17) 0.39 (0.56) DSM (0.32) MISO (0.68) IGCC Summer Relability Amortization Phase Out (0.59) (0.56) (0.03) Total So. Indiana Gas & Electric Co. D/B/A Vectren FAC 9.93 (1.37) QPCP QPCP O&M MISO (3.35) 1.58 (4.93) Reliability (RCRA) (3.27) (1.41) (1.85) DSM Total FAC = Fuel Adjustment Charge QPCP = Qualified Pollution Control Property DSM = Demand Side Management ACLM = Air Conditioning Load Management QPCP O&M = Qualified Polltion Control Property Operation & Maintenance EA = Emission Allowance IGCC = Clean Coal Tracker for Gasification Plant RTO = Midwest ISO or PJM ISO Non-fuel

7 Table 6 Indiana Investor-Owned Electric Utilities Base and Variable (Tracker) Bill Components 1000 kwh Usage, July 1, 2009 Billing Base Variable Total $ $ $ Indiana Michigan Power D/B/A AEP Indianapolis Power & Light Co Northern Indiana Public Service Co Duke Energy Indiana So. Indiana Gas & Electric Co. D/B/A Vectren Notes: Northern Indiana Public Service Co. Base amount includes a $6.36 credit applied through the FAC Duke Energy Indiana Base amount includes a $0.59 amortization removal credit

8 Figure 1 Comparison of Investor Owned Utilities Residential Electric Bills at 1,000 kwh July 1, 2009 $140 $120 $100 $80 $60 $40 $20 $0 AEP (I&M) IP&L NIPSCO Duke SIGECO Overall 1,000 kwh Ranking* Indiana Michigan Power D/B/A AEP $ Indianapolis Power & Light Co. $ Northern Indiana Public Service Co. $ Duke Energy Indiana $ So. Indiana Gas & Electric Co. D/B/A Vectren $ *Overall Ranking based on evaluation of 24 utilities.

9 Figure 2 10 Year Comparison of Investor Owned Utility Residential Electric Bills at 1,000 kwh AEP (I&M) $ $ AEP (I&M) $ IP&L$ NIPSCO$68.43 Duke $68.34 SIGECO $ $ $ $ $ IP&L $65.95 $68.92 $ $ $ $ $ NIPSCO $91.28 $91.55 $ $ $ $ SIGECO $ Duke $72.08 $79.20 $ $ $ $ $ SIGECO $77.91 $87.54 $ $ $ $ $ NIPSCO Duke I&M IP&L Utility Change 5 Years 10 Years American Electric Power Co. (I&M) AEP (I&M) $ % $ % Indianapolis Power & Light IP&L $ % $ % Northern Indiana Public Service Co. NIPSCO $ % $ % Duke Energy Indiana Duke $ % $ % Southern Indiana Gas & Electric Co. SIGECO $ % $ %