FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/11/ :42 PM INDEX NO /2011 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 149 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/11/2015

Save this PDF as:
 WORD  PNG  TXT  JPG

Size: px
Start display at page:

Download "FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/11/ :42 PM INDEX NO /2011 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 149 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/11/2015"

Transcription

1 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/11/215 5:42 PM INDEX NO. 6524/211 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 149 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/11/215 SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY OF NEW YORK Third-Party Hon. Charles E. Ramos Index No. 6524/211 Defendant. Motion Sequence MENLO CAPITAL GROUP,LLC, an unincorporated division of CITIBANK, N.A., NOTICE OF ENTRY OF JUDGMENT Third-Party Defendant. PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that annexed hereto is a true and correct copy of a Judgment of the Supreme Court of the State of New York, County of New York (Honorable Charles E. Ramos, J.S.C.) dated October 9, 215 and entered in the New York County Clerk's Office on December 11, 215. Dated: New York, New York December 11, 2 15 Respectfully submitted, By: H---+-'-+-F Norris D. Joshua K. Bromberg 551 Fifth Avenue, 18th Floor New York, New York 1176 Telephone: (212) Attorneys for Plaintiff L.E.K. CONSULTING LLC NWOLFF\ /11115

2 TO: Andrew W. Hayes 26 Tresser Boulevard, 9th Floor Stamford, Connecticut 691 Telephone: (917) and- Andrew W. Hayes 27 East 94th Street, Suite New York, New York 1128 Attorneys for Defendant/Third-Party Plaintiff MENLO CAPITAL GROUP, LLC Alan Guy Samuel Rubin Freshfields Bruckhaus Deringer US LLP 61 Lexington A venue, 1st Floor New York, New York 122 Telephone: (212) Attorneys for Third-Party Plaintiff Defendant an unincorporated division of CITIBANK, N.A. NWOLFF\ /

3 (FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/11/215 12:2 PM) NYSCEF DOC. NO. 148 INDEX NO. 6524/211 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/11/215 SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY OF NEW YORK Index No. 6524/211 Defendant. Third-Party PROPOSED JUDGMENT an unincorporated division ofcitibank, N.A., Third-Party Defendant X Upon reading and filing the Notice of Motion dated May 26, 215 by plaintiff for Summary Judgment (i) in plaintifs favor and against defendant in the principal amount of $69,98, plus interest, and (ii) dismissing with prejudice defendant's affirmative defenses, the Plaintiffs Memorandum of Law dated May 26, 215, the Affidavit of Susan St. Sure sworn to on December 8, 211, the Affidavit of Norris D. Wolff sworn to on May 26, 215 and all of the exhibits and pleadings attached thereto in support of the motion, and the defendant's Memorandum of Points and Authorities in Opposition thereto and in support of Defendant's Cross-Motion dated June 22, 215, the Affidavit of Akhil Suri in Opposition to the Motion for Summary Judgment dated January 18, 212, the Affirmation of Andrew w. Hayes in Opposition to Summary Judgment and in Support of Defendant's Cross-Motion dated June 22, 215 and filed June 2, 215, the Reply Memorandum of NWOLFF\ /18115

4 Law of Plaintiff in Support of its Motion for Summary Judgment dated July 8, 215, and the Court having rendered a Decision and Order dated August 6, 215 and filed August 7, 215, granting in its entirety plaintiffs motion, NOW, on motion of plaintiff, by its attorneys, Kleinberg, Kaplan, Wolff & Cohen, P.C., it is ADJUDGED, that Plaintiff L.E.K. Consulting LLC, residing at 11 Glendon Avenue, Los Angeles, California 924, have Judgment and recover of Defendant Menlo Capital Group, LLC, residing at 11 California Street, San Francisco, California 95111, the sum of $69,98 and interest at 18% as follows: Interest of $156, (representing interest at 18% on $174,4 thereof from 7/4/2 I to 8/ I /2 15); Interest of $15,86.8 (representing interest at 18% on $174,4 thereof from 8/7/2 l to 8/1/2 15); and Interest of $18,24 7. (representing interest at 18% on $21, 18 thereof from 9/1/21 tq 8/1/215). amounting to tota! interest of $28,899.9 as of 8/1/215, together with statutory costs of $6, X amounting in total to $699,479.9, and that Plaintiff have execution therefor. Fl LED DEC ' ()face MEW... NWOLFF\ /18/15 2

5 INDEX NO. 6524/211 RE I&R.aJ &«w15 PUBl,HER. NYC 11 SlJl>RJMfC COURT OF TRE STATE OF NE.W YORK cq_unty OF: NEW YORK MENLO CAPITAL GROlJP, LLC, D_E fe-ant. Third-Party Plninti If - against- CITJ VENTUH.I : Ct\PTTAL INTERNATIONAL, an unincorporated llivisiou of CITIBANK, N.A., Third-Patty Defendant. Index No. 6524/211 <ll:oilt.s of laintiff Costs before note of i'ssue CPLR 821 subd. l Costs after note of issue CPLR 821 subd. 2 Trial of issue CPLR 821 subd. r:r.j Allowance by stillutc CPLR RtJ2(n), (b) Additional allowance.... U CPLR 82 (d) Moti\ln costs.., CPLR 822 Appeal to Appellate Term.. CPLR 82 (b) Appeal to Appellate Division.... CPLR 82 (a) Appeal to Court of Appeals CPLR 824 Costs upon frivolous claims and counterclaims CPLR 8-a I 'jm' co fee for index number CPLR 818(a) Referee's fees CPLR 8 I (a)( 1), 8(a)....'..... Commissioner's compensation CPLR 8l(a)(2) Clerk's fee, tiling notice of pend. or attach, CPLR 82l(a)(l) Enteringanddocketingjudgment CPLR 81(a)(7), 8L6(a)(2) z Paid for searches CPLR 81(a)(IO)..... Affidavits & acknowledgments CPLR Gj Serving copy_ suos & com.plaint CPLR 81l(h)(l), 8l(d) U"J Request for JUdiCial mtervenuon Note of issue CPLR B2(a) _... CQ Paid referee's report CPLR 8l(a)(l2) Certified copies of papers CPLR 8 I (a)(4) Satisfaction piece CPLR 52(a), Transcripts and tiling CPLR Certified copy of judgment CPLR Postage CPLR 8 I (a)( 12) Jury fee CPLR 82(c) Stenographers' fees CPLR 82, Sheriff's fees on execution CPLR 8!1, Sheriff's fees, attachment, arrest, etc. CPLR Paid printing cases CPLR 8l(a)(6)..... Clerk's fees Court of Appeals CPLR 8l(a)(l2) Paid copies of papers CPLR 816(a)(4).... Motion expenses CPLR 8l(b)..... Fees for publication CPLR 8l(a)() Serving subpoena CPLR 8tl(h)l, 8l(d) Paid for Search CPLR 81(a)(IO) Referee's report Attendance of witnesses CPLR 81 (a)(b)(c), 8 I (a)( I)... COSTS ::, 2 DISBURSEMENTS "- TOTAL $ 4

6 State of New York, County of being duly sworn, deposes and says; that deponent is not a party to the action, is over 18 years of age and resides at That on deponent served the within bill of costs and notice of taxation on attorney(s) for herein, at his/her office at during his/her absence from said office strike out eitber (a) or (bj (a) by!hen and there leaving a!rue copy of the same with hislber clerk; partner; person having charge of said office. {b) and said office being closed, by deposiling a true copy of same, enclosed in a sealed wrapper directed to said attomey(s), in the office letter drop or box. Sworn to before me on State uf New Y Oik, County of being duly sworn, deposes and says; that deponent is not a party to the action, is over 18 years of age and resides at That on deponent served the within bill of costs a..'ld notice of taxation on attomey(s) for a! the address designated by said attorney(s) for that purpose by depositing a true copy of same enclosed in a postpaid properly addressed wrapper, in-a post office--{)fficial depository under the exclosive care and custody of the United SC!b:s PosW Service within New Y od: State. Sworn to before me on ss.: ss.: Index No. 6524ll11 SLJPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF 1\'EW YORK CO I!_NrY OF NEW YORK. -,. against Defendant Third-Party PJaintiff. - a,<>ainst - au IIRincorporatd division orcrrmank, N.A., Third-Party Defendant. Please Take Notice that the within is a true copy of the items of costs and disbursements in the within action tiued* and that tlle same wiu be taxed* by the Clerk of Court, at his/her office in the courthouse thereof on at M. of that day---and the amount inserted in the judgment Yours, etc. Kleinberg, Kaplan, Wolff & Cohen, P.C. Attorney( s) for Plaintiff To Attorney(s) for Service of the withln bill of costs and notice of taxation is hereby admitted on _ Attorney( s) for... 11,.. l Q!!! c. ' c: ij 2. g g. :::: <- ntt= s- - "' rn " ::T en ::: o.g:::;! o... =:J -i (1 5- ;;.; -' ::r = a o "'d :- '< <::; o 6. -g ::re2-5 '<" - g ::::! -- n c. 1-.J.. erg. =!! s ;;1 1'-.) "'...., :::r <7Q (1 "' (").;;; :;. g, - S< V\ "' "' "' (1 P"t)- - g: X -- ::S c. ::: nna2.? "' - g. '" "' - Cl.Cll ns n o - - cnuga.o g.ocg.ct2:$ii" _,:g (n 5" -.."'...!!?. ;c. nno-ol-t) c: - ;:!. ;:::J ; 1i s, e. O'Q g 5 c.. g u;.c: 2. :I...,.., ::;-g g-o s ;,. u;ge e:n"'::z. E: c:(icto ;:; =-= s t=;: g. g ::; :s;::::r-cii:'<c:eig. ::1 r.r.. ;:!.... O"Q c.. v,j.q) :;TCD-::1" (.. if g'.g "":! ::r" tn ""Cf ::r C) \ -[- - - ::J. ('I - ' c;; s:- ::r g_ :;t, b) ::r. Q) "'-' '(:. 5o..,:rU 1: ;: (b o.::l. : '\:::!:- -g.?. Cl....., _. "'C... tl? "' =r ;rge c;n (n g. "-: = g ; g. 7';!"' a'::rg_ ::t.?g. f:... g..: - 1'r c.: ::;. - "' c;; z;! S'<>uocr = c: ::;tngi '<t:= <> "' g (1 C" a cr - a. 2. p;-g,ac.g_"' ;; - ; g_ C) s "' - 6: g. "' < c....-;,nn O'[gg.g... :::1. :::> c{l)g-:::. OQ -,., "'. Qe, := '< g!?. r; ::> g. (1 <> c ::l "' s, 5- ;;; r;; "' J "' s!'! 5-..,... I» ( c:r ( , ::r p; :::!1 ;><:: s... c:r tl) i;l!;; z.-<?" "' fjl c: z ::l.., z m "' f z Slrikt out Olle ( )

7 -.. -._., SUPREME COURT O:F THE STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY OF NEW YORK w )( L.ItK. CONSUI,TING LJ,C, against - MENLO CAPITAL GROUP, tlc, Plaintiff, Defendant " 1-/ FILED AND DOCKETED DEC ;:> AT /2 : 2..(o 1 M N.Y., CO. CLK'S OFACE Norris D. Wolff, Esq. KLinNBER(}, KAPLAN, WOLFF & COHEN, P.C Fifth Avenue, 18th Floor New York, New York 1176 Telephone: (2.12) Facsimile: (212) Attorneys for Plaintiff L.E.K. CONSULTING LLC

8 SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY OF NEW YORK Hon. Charles E. Ramos Defendant. Index No. 6524/211 Motion Sequence Third-Party AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE an unincorporated division of CITIBANK, N.A., Third-Party Defendant. STATE OF NEW YORK ) ) ss.: COUNTY OF NEW YORK). JANET LEE FALK, being duly sworn, deposes and says: New York. 1. I am not a party to the action, am over 18 years of age and reside in Kings County, 2. On December 11, 215, I caused true copies of the annexed Notice of Entry of Judgment to be served by and by mailing the same in a sealed envelope, with postage prepaid NWOLFF\ /11/15

9 thereon, in a post office or official depository of the United States Postal Service within the State of New York, addresed to the last known addresses ofthe addressees as indicated below: Andrew W. Hayes 26 Tresser Boulevard, 9th Floor Stamford, Connecticut and- Andrew W. Hayes 27 East 94th Street, Suite New York, New York 1128 Attorneys for Defendant/Third-Party Plaintiff MENLO CAPITAL GROUP, LLC Alan Guy Samuel Rubin Freshfields Bruckhaus Deringer US LLP 61 Lexington A venue, 1st Floor New York, New York Attorneys for Third-Party Plaintiff Defendant an unincorporated division of CITIBANK, N.A. NWOLFF\ /