1 ASSESSMENT OF STUDENT LEARNING: AN OVERVIEW OF THE LANDSCAPE Natasha A. Jankowski Assistant Director, NILOA Research Assistant Professor, UIUC
2 Overview NILOA who we are and what we do Overview of assessment What it is and why we do it National picture of assessment activities Operationalize assessment through the DQP What it is and what institutions are doing with it Implications for assessment Structure and alignment of learning Resources and institutional examples
3 Established in 2008, the mission of the National Institute for Learning Outcomes Assessment (NILOA) is to discover and disseminate ways that academic programs and institutions can productively use assessment data internally to inform and strengthen undergraduate education, and externally to communicate with policy makers, families and other stakeholders. Jointly located at the University of Illinois and Indiana University.
5 What is assessment? Assessment is the systematic collection, review, and use of information about educational programs undertaken for the purpose of improving student learning and development. (Palomba and Banta 1999) SLOs Use to improve Select Measures Analyze the data Gather data
6 Where does it happen? Assessment occurs at a variety of levels Within a single course Within a program Within a degree In general education Across an institution Assessment is complex and that s ok because learning is too!!
7 Why do we do it? Institutions of higher education are increasingly asked to show the value of attending, i.e. impact Students are increasingly mobile and diverse Public and policy makers want assurance of the quality of higher education Regional accreditors are asking institutions to show evidence of student learning and instances of use But these are mostly external what are some internal reasons we would engage with assessment? (and not just because someone said you have to do it)
8 What is happening nationally? 2013 National Provost Survey Sample: All regionally accredited, undergraduate degree-granting institutions (n=2,732) Announced via institutional membership organizations, website, newsletter, mailing Online and paper 44% response rate (n=1,202) 725 schools participated in both 2009 and 2013
9 Findings Look for our survey report which will be released mid-january in our newsletter but for now enjoy a sneak peak of the results
10 National Student Surveys Rubrics Classroom-based Alumni surveys Placement exams Locally developed surveys Capstones Locally developed tests General knowledge and skill Employer surveys Portfolios External Other Assessment Tools
11 Assessment Approaches by Institutional Type 100% 90% 80% 70% 60% 50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 0% Doctoral Masters Baccalaureate Associates Other
12 Percent of Institutions Change Over Time
13 Most Valuable Assessment Approaches The top three 1. Classroom-based assessment 2. National Student Surveys 3. Rubrics
14 Drivers of assessment Regional accreditation Program accreditation Institutional commitment to improve Faculty or staff interest in improving student learning Concerns about the effectiveness and value of postsecondary education President and/or governing board direction or mandate National calls for accountability and/or transparency Statewide governing or coordinating board mandate External funding (federal, state, or foundation grants) Institutional membership initiatives (e.g., VSA, U-CAN, Transparency by Design, AAUDE, VFA) State mandate Participation in a consortium or multi-institution collaboration Other Other Associates Baccalaureate Masters Doctoral
15 Then and Now Institutions are doing more assessments (3 in 2009 now 5 in 2013) More institutions have student learning outcomes statements National initiatives with implications for assessment continue to build steam Degree qualifications profile (DQP) Piloted in over 400 institutions Competency-based education University of Wisconsin system Southern New Hampshire University Western Governor s University Alverno College MOOCs Prior-learning assessment (PLA)
16 NILOA s role with the DQP NILOA is harvesting (collecting, analyzing, summarizing, synthesizing) what can be learned from all of the funded and unfunded work currently going on with the DQP. Providing resources and information to institutions engaged in working with the DQP Document what is being done, by whom, and any lessons learned Gather information to help guide the upcoming revision of the DQP Identify synergies and cross-cutting issues Provide support to campuses
17 DQP Corner Resource New to the DQP Resource Kit Occasional papers Webinar Series DQP In Practice Assignment Library coming soon!
18 What is the DQP? Three degree levels: Associate Bachelor Master Five competency areas: Specialized Knowledge Broad, Integrative Knowledge Intellectual Skills Applied Learning Civic Learning Regional Accreditors ACCJC HLC SACS WASC States Oregon Organizations AASCU AAC&U CIC Unfunded
19 Who is working with it? What are they doing?
20 Community Colleges 100 institutions are focusing on the associate degree level Most focus on specific programs and pathways to transfer Working in partnership with four-year institutions Sharing assignments and data Kansas City Kansas Community College New Mexico Junior College IUPUI and Ivy Tech North Dakota State College of Science
21 Assessment and the DQP Ongoing, embedded in courses and curriculum Driven by and owned by faculty Not about standardization For every student To raise student awareness of the purpose of courses and their progress towards competencies Not an exo-skeletal approach
22 Implications of the DQP Alignment and Structure Curriculum mapping (moving from my course to our curriculum ) Data audit and Course taking patterns How are we going to know what every student who attends is leaving with the desired knowledge and skills? But how do we keep it meaningful, manageable, and not a reporting burden? Ariovich, L. & Richman, W.A. (2013, October). All-in-one: Combining Grading, Course, Program, and General Education Outcomes Assessment.(Occasional Paper No.19). Urbana, IL: University of Illinois and Indiana University, National Institute for Learning Outcomes Assessment.
23 What is the value of alignment and mapping? Causal Statements The ability to make causal claims about our impact on students and their learning Institutional structures and support + student = enhanced learning
24 Difficulty of Causal Statements Mobility of students Untracked changes Changes in courses add up to program level change Levels at which use occurs Longer than a year cycle Loosely coupled relationships Life
25 Theories of Change Why do we think the changes we make will lead to better outcomes? What is assumed in the changes we select as it relates to how students understand and navigate higher education?
26 Theory of Change (TOC) A process of outlining causal pathways by specifying what is needed for goals to be achieved (Carman, 2012) It requires articulating underlying assumptions which can be tested and measured (Jones, 2010) A Theory of Change provides a roadmap outlining how one thinks or conceptualizes getting from point A to point B over time (Ployhart & Vandenburg, 2010)
27 For instance Coverage and content Opportunities and support Intentional, coherent, aligned pathways Within each of these is the belief about a root cause why students were not learning or not meeting the outcome and the mechanism by which the institution can help them succeed
28 Root Cause A process of exploring not only that something happened, but why it happened the way that it did (Rooney & Heuvel, 2004) Moves beyond surface-level problem identification and examines assumptions in order to prevent reoccurrences (Taitz, Genn, Brooks, Ross, Ryan, Shumack, Burrell, & Kennedy, 2010)
29 But Toulmin (2003) Evidence Claim Warrant Warrants Arguments
30 What does it look like in practice? Case Studies and Cross-case report
31 The Brian Barton Story A faculty chair in business examined the results of program outcomes for learners who completed the program capstone course and found that on one of the outcomes, learners were performing below what he regarded as the minimum threshold. Through the curriculum maps and alignments linking learning activities in individual courses to program outcomes in the capstone, he was able to identify across the entire program which courses had the strongest alignment to the outcome in question. From there, he was able to delve deeper into individual learning activities, to combine that information with additional data including course evaluations, and from the combined data to make detailed changes in specific courses and specific learning activities or assignments within courses. By the time participants in the revised courses and learning activities completed the capstone course, there was a measurable improvement in the particular outcome in question. The faculty chair involved in the process stated, The concept of having an outcomes-based approach and having a strong theory of alignment all the way down to individual learning activities helps facilitate the use of assessment data.
32 Veterinary Technology Veterinary technology students did not score as well as needed in quantitative reasoning, for example, so veterinary technology faculty redesigned several key assignments to build and document that competency in students. Whereas previously students only read an article to learn about monitoring glucose levels in felines, the new assignment asked them to read the article, to take a reading of a cat s glucose level, and then to use both sources to write an analytical report. This curriculum redesign created a more robust and discipline-specific quantitative reasoning experience for students and a richer set of documents to be collected and examined through eportfolio. Addressing general education requirements throughout the program, according to the veterinary technology program director, means that programs need to decide where they are addressing general education within the curriculum, and using student artifacts collected through the eportfolio brings assessment to the forefront of the classroom.
33 Writing Across the Curriculum The religion department wanted to know if their students were writing at a desired level, and so the faculty developed a writing rubric, gathered a random collection of student essays, and had a faculty panel rate them. A report was generated from the rating that outlined where students demonstrated or fell short on the outcomes in question. Areas where students fell short were used to refocus teaching and also to rethink the sequence of courses and assignments within courses so as to better reinforce the desired outcomes and help students improve. A faculty member involved in this effort remarked, It seems so modest to state it now we identified an intended learning outcome, made rubrics, looked at essays, and altered teaching but that fairly modest process generated a holistic view of what students were doing well and what they were not doing so well, which allowed for minor adjustments. In a year or two these adjustments showed that students are doing better on a given outcome.
34 Evidence-based Storytelling Evidence of student learning is used in support of claims or arguments about improvement and accountability told through stories to persuade a specific audience (Jankowski, 2012)
35 Discussion and Reflection Making sense of results Meaning Making Multiple individuals across the institution critically engaging with assessment data Make sense of data to determine what, if anything, to do 70% Examine multiple data points Group data by theme not method
36 Resources NILOA occasional papers and reports NILOA case studies Measuring Quality Inventory ACCJC project website: (resources including worksheets and templates)
37 Thank You National Institute for Learning Outcomes Assessment (NILOA): Questions and comments:
THE DEGREE QUALIFICATIONS PROFILE: A FRAMEWORK FOR ASSESSING GENERAL EDUCATION Natasha Jankowski and Pat Hutchings, NILOA Stefani Dawn, Oregon State University Laurie Dodge, Brandman University AAC&U General
Using the Degree Qualifications Profile: Institutional Examples of Promising Practices Jillian Kinzie, Indiana University & NILOA Pat Hutchings, Gonzaga University & NILOA Margaret Bailey, Point Loma Nazarene
National Institute for Learning Outcomes Assessment January 2014 Knowing What Students Know and Can Do The Current State of Student Learning Outcomes Assessment in U.S. Colleges and Universities George
1 Student Learning Outcomes Assessment in the United States: Trends and Good Practices S T A C I P R O V E Z I S, P H. D. N I A D - U E U N I V E R S I T Y E V A L U A T I O N F O R U M 2 0 1 2 J U L Y
Taking Action on Evidence to Enhance Teaching and Learning Jillian Kinzie Associate Director Center for Postsecondary Research, Indiana University School of Education, and Senior Scholar National Institute
POST-SECONDARY REGIONAL ACCREDITATION ASSESSMENT STANDARDS IN THE UNITED STATES Tammie Cumming, PhD Yongchao Zhao, M.S. City University of New York New York City College of Technology, United States of
Supporting Community College Faculty and Administrator Engagement in Learning Outcomes Assessment: Updates from the Field Laura Giffin Research Analyst, National Institute for Learning Outcomes Assessment
National Institute for Learning Outcomes Assessment March 2014 Institutional Assessment Practices Across Accreditation Regions Nora Gannon-Slater, Stanley Ikenberry, Natasha Jankowski, & George Kuh nowledge
California State University, Stanislaus Doctor of Education (Ed.D.), Educational Leadership Assessment Plan (excerpt of the WASC Substantive Change Proposal submitted to WASC August 25, 2007) A. Annual
National Institute for Learning Outcomes Assessment January 2014 Knowing What Students Know and Can Do The Current State of Student Learning Outcomes Assessment in U.S. Colleges and Universities George
MSU Departmental Assessment Plan 2009 2010 Department: Education Department Head: Dr. Joanne Erickson Assessment Coordinator: Bill Freese 214 Reid Hall 994 3072 Degrees/Majors/Options Offered by Department
Name of the Undergraduate Degree Program Bachelor of Business Administration - Marketing Mission Statement The Unit s mission is to create enduring educational value for our students, our alumni, and the
A Guide to Learning Outcomes, Degree Level Expectations and the Quality Assurance Process in Ontario A Guide to Learning Outcomes, Degree Level Expectations and the Quality Assurance Process in Ontario
Diane L. Maldonado, Ph. D. Point Park University 1. Describe the current state of student learning outcomes assessment 2. Discuss regional accreditation standards and actions 3. Identify assessment trends
Proposal to Change an Academic Program Adding an Online Version of an Existing Program at The University of Minnesota, Crookston Bachelor of Manufacturing Management for Online Delivery Prepared and Submitted
National Institute for Learning Outcomes Assessment June 2010 Exploring the Landscape: What Institutional Websites Reveal About Student Learning Outcomes Assessment Activities Natasha Jankowski and Julia
A Research Brief on the A Survey Research of the Brief Shared Design Elements & Survey Emerging of the Practices Shared of Design Competency-Based Elements & Emerging Education Practices Programs of Competency-Based
Plan 7-30-12 1 Professional Education Unit Assessment System School of Education and Child Development Drury University Overview and Goals The PEU assessment system is designed to facilitate collection
GEORGIA STANDARDS FOR THE APPROVAL OF PROFESSIONAL EDUCATION UNITS AND EDUCATOR PREPARATION PROGRAMS (Effective 9/01/08) Kelly Henson Executive Secretary Table of Contents Standard 1: Candidate Knowledge,
Proposal to Change an Academic Program Adding an Online Version of an Existing Program at The University of Minnesota, Crookston Bachelor of Science in Business for Online Delivery Prepared and Submitted
Name of the Undergraduate Degree Program Bachelor of Business Administration - Management Information Systems Mission Statement The Unit s mission is to create enduring educational value for our students,
Summary of the Case American Intercontinental University 1 Master of Education Program The Summary of the Case is written by the auditors and approved by program faculty. The Summary reflects the auditors
21 st Century Educator Preparation: How University System of Georgia s Colleges of Education Prepare Teachers to use Technology Dr. Angela Coleman Assistant Vice Chancellor, Educator Preparation University
Demonstrating Institutional Quality through Academic Accreditation A Case Study of a Public University in the U.S December 3, 2014. Ritu Subramony, Ph.D., M.S. Director of Academic Accreditation Content
2013-2014 ANNUAL ASSESSMENT REPORT TEMPLATE Part 1: Background Information B1. Program name: [ Computer Science ] B2. Report author(s): [ Nikrouz Faroughi ] B3. Fall 2012 enrollment: [_71 ] Use the Department
Name of the Undergraduate Degree Program Bachelor of Accounting Mission Statement This program provides students with the knowledge and skills necessary to enter the fields of public, private sector, corporate
Indiana University Kokomo School of Business M.B.A. Program Assessment Report Academic Year 2014/15 I. BRIEF SUMMARY OF ASSESSMENT PLAN Highlights of the Assessment Plan Assurance of student learning remains
Curriculum Proposal Training Assessment Forms Center for Teaching and Learning Monica Varner, Ph.D. Director of Assessment and Institutional Effectiveness and Center for Teaching and Learning Associate
Tools for Articulation: Common Course Curricula February 19, 2014 Listening In Attendees are in listening only mode. Sound: Speakers or Phone? Questions? Technical Support: firstname.lastname@example.org
Draft Policy on Graduate Education Preface/Introduction Over the past two decades, the number and types of graduate programs have increased dramatically. In particular, the development of clinical master
Assessing Quantitative Reasoning in GE (Owens, Ladwig, and Mills) Introduction Many students at CSU, Chico, receive much of their college-level mathematics education from the one MATH course they complete
Improving Board Engagement with Educational Quality Institutional Case Report Templates As part of this AGB project, we will be compiling a set of case reports based on the experiences of the participants.
Niagara College of Applied Arts and Technology Program Quality Assurance Process Audit 18 Month Follow-up Report Submitted by: Niagara College Report Submitted September 2013 INTRODUCTION Niagara College
Mission, Goals and Accomplishments Effective Design and Implementation of Program Assessment Jeff Moore, Director UCF School of Performing Arts It All Goes Together Teaching Celebrating Learning Reporting
Unit Plan for Assessing and Improving Student Learning in Degree Programs Masters Programs in Special Education Unit: Special Education Unit Head approval: Date: April 9, 2008 SECTION 1: PAST ASSESSMENT
BS Environmental Science (2013-2014) Program Information Point of Contact Brian M. Morgan (email@example.com) Support for University and College Missions Marshall University is a multi-campus public
Page 1 of 12 UW-Madison Plan for the Assessment of Student Learning JANUARY 2015 Page 2 of 12 This document describes a strategic and systematic process of improving the quality of degree and co-curricular
Program: Civil Engineering Master s and Graduate Certificate Program Department: Civil Engineering Number of students enrolled in the program in Fall, 2011: 84 Faculty member completing template: Ramzi
EARLY CHILDHOOD UNDERGRADUATE COLLEGE PROGRAMS FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS Are you thinking about improving your knowledge and competencies in order to better enhance children s outcomes in your program?
Institutional Effectiveness Improve Intentionally Focus + Execution Without clear focus and precise execution, the best strategic thinking is meaningless. Every worthwhile endeavor requires a thoughtful
Page 1 IPP Learning Outcomes Report Program: Department: Applied Behavior Analysis Certificate Program Psychology Number of students enrolled in the program in fall, 2011: Data unavailable Students become
Name of the Undergraduate Degree Program Bachelor of Business Administration - Human Resource Management Mission Statement The Unit s mission is to create enduring educational value for our students, our
Degree Program Student Learning Report (rev. 7/14) Fall 2013 Spring 2014 The Department of Applied Technology in the School of Business & Technology Business Information Technology, B.S. Effectively assessing
CASE STUDY JUNIATA COLLEGE Assessing Global Learning: Lessons from the Field BY JENIFER CUSHMAN, JUNIATA COLLEGE Reproduction is strictly prohibited without written permission of the author. 2013 Jenifer
ETL Master s Program Eportfolio Process to Transference in PK-12 1 Participation in an ETL Master s Program Eportfolio Process to Transference in PK-12 Sheryl R. Abshire, Cindy Cummings, Diane R. Mason,
Competency Based Education: Top Tactics and Most Overlooked Strategies Prepared for the 2015 AASCU Annual Meeting www.pearsoned.com/cbe October 2015 Objectives for our session Overview Discover lessons
AGENDA Task Force on Strategic Planning for Online Education Via Conference Call Dial-in number 1-800-308-9936, and passcode 816044 April 29, 2015 1. Call to Order and Opening Remarks Chair John Hitt 2.
THE GENERAL EDUCATION TRANSFER POLICY AND IMPLEMENTATION GUIDELINES Eastern Kentucky University Kentucky Community and Technical College System Kentucky State University Morehead State University Murray
Student or participant learning or satisfaction Outcomes of the processes Reporting and feedback from the assessment measures Show US The Learning Delivery processes Planning processes An Institution-Wide
Western Carolina University Marketing B.S B.A Business Assessment Plan for 2006-2007 Primary Contact Name/Info : Professor Debra Burke, Department Head Forsyth 107 828-227-3720 Department Mission Statement
ABSTRACT Assessment Practices in Undergraduate Accounting Programs Anna L. Lusher Slippery Rock University This study examined accounting program assessment plans at 102 colleges and universities in the
2014 2015 Annual Assessment Report for Psychology FOR GRADUATE AND CREDENTIAL PROGRAMS: THIS TEMPLATE REFERS TO SAC STATE BACCALAUREATE LEARNING GOALS. PLEASE IGNORE THESE REFERENCES IN YOUR REPORT. Q1.1.
MASTER OF SCIENCE IN EDUCATION Educational Leadership Technology Online www.hsu.edu The HSU Master of Science in Education (M.S.E.) in educational leadership and technology as well as building level leader
RYERSON UNIVERSITY POLICY OF SENATE PERIODIC PROGRAM REVIEW OF GRADUATE AND UNDERGRADUATE PROGRAMS Policy Number 126 Previous Approvals: April 5, 2005; May 6, 2008; November 2, 2010; May 3, 2011, May 3,
Advanced Assessment Summary Introduction The Division of Education at Indiana University Kokomo serves an eleven-county area in north central Indiana, which includes Carroll, Cass, Clinton, Fulton, Grant,
Indiana University Kokomo School of Business Undergraduate Program Assessment Report Academic Year 2014-2015 I. BRIEF SUMMARY OF ASSESSMENT PLAN Highlights of the Assessment Plan Assurance of student learning
Illinois State Board of Education February 2013 Guidance Document 13-06 Model Teacher Evaluation System Measuring Student Growth Using Type III Assessments This document is intended to provide non-regulatory
Complete College Ohio Task Force: Working Group Final Recommendations Ready for College No Time to Waste Help Me Cross the Finish Line Recommendation 1: Require institution-specific Campus Completion Plans.
Redesigning a Master s for Teachers Program Cathy Stockton Louisiana Tech University Abstract This paper describes the process that one college of education used to redesign the master s for teachers program.
GUIDE TO EVALUATING INSTITUTIONS A Publication of the Accrediting Commission for Community and Junior Colleges Western Association of Schools and Colleges JULY 2013 Edition ACCJC/WASC 10 Commercial Blvd.
NATIONAL BENCHMARKING AND ACCREDITATION Using Benchmarking Data for Regional Accrediting www.nccbp.org 1 Using Benchmarking Data for Regional Accrediting The goal of accreditation is to ensure that education
2010-2015 Strategic Plan Template Department of Special Education and Child Development 2010-2015 Strategic Plan I. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 1-2 pages A. Mission and goals: The mission of the Department Special
Initial Program Assessment Summary The Division of Education at Indiana University Kokomo serves an eleven-county area in north central Indiana, which includes Carroll, Cass, Clinton, Fulton, Grant, Hamilton,
National Institute for Learning Outcomes Assessment October 2013 All-in-One: Combining Grading, Course, Program, and General Education Outcomes Assessment W. Allen Richman Laura Ariovich nowledge accountability
National Institute for Learning Outcomes Assessment August 2011 Making Assessment Meaningful: What New Student Affairs Professionals and Those New to Assessment Need to Know Marilee J. Bresciani For some
An introductory guide to AACSB AoL (Assurance of Learning) at SDA Bocconi M.Brusoni P.Egi March 2012 Index SDA Bocconi AACSB Accreditation Process Assurance of Learning - AoL Process SDA Bocconi Learning
Template Program BA, Social Science Department Social Science Number of students enrolled in the program in Fall, 2011 148 Faculty member completing template David M. Lang, Director (Date 1/19/12) Period
Assessment of Graduate Programs: Clear, Simple, and USEFUL Barbara E. Walvoord, Ph.D. Professor Emerita University of Notre Dame Notre Dame IN 46556 Walvoord@nd.edu Mobile: 574-361-3857 1 SACS Standards
ASU College of Education Course Syllabus ED 4972, ED 4973, ED 4974, ED 4975 or EDG 5660 Clinical Teaching Course: ED 4972, ED 4973, ED 4974, ED 4975 or EDG 5660 Credit: 9 Semester Credit Hours (Undergraduate),
REGISTRATION CRITERIA FOR CFP BOARD REGISTERED PROGRAMS Registration Criteria for CFP Board Registered Programs (Updated March, 2013) The following section contains the financial planning program registration
Exploring Degree Qualifications A Descriptive Analysis of the Quality Initiative Demonstration Project to Test the Lumina Foundation s Degree Qualifications Profile Gloria Rogers, Amber Holloway, & Lynn
Credit for Prior Learning: Moving from Piecemeal Approach to a Systems Model Mary Beth Lakin, ACE Mary Ellen Dallman, USG ALC Wilson Finch, THEC Tim McGowan, UW System WHAT S IN A NAME? LOST IN TRANSLATION
Donna Woolcott, PhD Executive Director, Quality on Quality MAY 7, 2012 UNIVERSITY OF WINDSOR Overview of quality assurance R International context R Ontario context Quality Council mandate Key elements
6 This chapter is designed to acquaint the reader with the context for accreditors increased emphasis on student learning outcomes as a key indicator of institutional quality and on the use of learning
The Value of National Accreditation 2015 Table of Contents What is Accreditation... 3 Functions of Accreditation... 4 Types of Accrediting Agencies... 5 What Does it Mean to be a Recognized Accrediting
Department of Economics Cal State Univ., Hayward Phone 510 885 3275 OR 25800 Carlos Bee 510 885 3265 Hayward, CA 94542-3068 Fax 510 885 4796 DEPARTMENT AND PROGRAM MISSION, GOALS, AND ASSESSMENT A FOCUS
Building Pathways to Postsecondary 2.0 Summits 2014-2015 Paula Palmer, JoAnn Simser, and Pakou Yang Minnesota Department of Education Minnesota State Colleges and Universities Leading for educational excellence
Degree Completion through Prior Learning Assessment and Competency Based Education December 4, 2014 Presenter: Pamela Tate, President & CEO Council for Adult and Experiential Learning CAEL s Overarching
1 Quality Collaboratives (QC) Case Study September 2015 QC Dyad: Elizabethtown Community and Technical College (ECTC) & University of Louisville (U of L) Contact: Martha Wolfe, professor of biology (ECTC)
COMMISSION FOR HIGHER EDUCATION Friday, October 14, 2011 DISCUSSION ITEM D: New Program Proposal Guidelines Staff Recommendation Background For discussion only. Drafts of the New Program Proposal Guidelines