1 THE INTEGRATION OF SPIRITUALITY ISSUES IN CACREP COUNSELOR PREPARATION PROGRAMS AND ACCREDITED THEOLOGICAL SCHOOLS A Dissertation by JOHN-NELSON B. POPE Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY in COUNSELOR EDUCATION Texas A&M University-Corpus Christi Corpus Christi, Texas December 2011
2 THE INTEGRATION OF SPIRITUALITY ISSUES IN CACREP COUNSELOR PREPARATION PROGRAMS AND ACCREDITED THEOLOGICAL SCHOOLS A Dissertation By JOHN-NELSON B. POPE This dissertation meets the standards for scope and quality of Texas A&M University-Corpus Christi and is hereby approved. Robert L. Smith, PhD, Chair Richard S. Balkin, Ph.D.,Committee Member Mary Fernandez, Ph.D., Committee Member Kaye Nelson, Ed.D., Committee Member Sherrye Garrett, Ed.D., Graduate Faculty Representative Luis Cifuentes, Ph.D. Dean of Graduate Studies December, 2011
4 John-Nelson B. Pope All Rights Reserved December, 2011 iii
5 Dedication Soli Deo Gloria. Ego hunc librum dedicant ut te, uxor mea - mea vita, amor et gaudium. iv
6 Nel mezzo del cammin di nostra vita Mi ritrovai per una selva oscura, Ché la diritta via era smarrita. -Dante Alighieri, The Divine Comedy Acknowledgements Midway through life s journey, I found myself in a darkening wood. Something had changed. My vocation, my calling as a Minister of the Word and Sacrament, had become tortuous. No, my ardent love for God had not waned. I had imagined my task similar to a spiritual warrior, armed with Scripture, who willingly, if not always joyfully, fought the good fight. But something had changed. I grew weary preaching Good News that only a handful chose to hear. I dreamt of proclaiming God s love, justice, and mercy that would fork like lightning around the sanctuary. More and more parishioners told me that they would rather I preach about a god rewarding them with health, wealth and prosperity if only they believed hard and long enough. Why couldn t I be more like that young preacher in Houston who had transformed a basketball arena into a megachurch? That s just make-believe, I thought. God in Christ never promised material success or health in life. Rather, He offered an authentic, meaningful existence that burned like the stars and for all eternity. He offered His shalom ( ). Simple, right? No. Jesus never said it was going to be easy. He said that his disciples needed to deny themselves, even take up their cross daily and follow Him (Luke 9:23, version). He then presented the deciding factor: What good is it for someone to gain the whole world, and yet lose or forfeit their very self (Luke 9:25, version)? Peace is not the absence of conflict. Rather, it is choosing to follow God s agenda instead of one s own. v
7 Not enough folk accepted what I preached. They said I expected too much of them. I retorted I was not preaching jeremiads, but grace pure and simple. They said it was time to leave. Thus, I entered a darkening wood, feeling sorry for myself. I had lost my way... One day Lyle Holin, my friend and a counselor at the Vocational Rehabilitation office in Bay City, Texas, told me that he thought I should consider returning to school and earn a doctorate. He said he was completing his first year in the Counselor Education and Supervision Program at Texas A&M University-Corpus Christi and was thriving there. He urged me to apply to the program for fall 2008, even though the deadline had recently passed. That night, my wife and I prayed about it. The next day, I quickly gathered my transcripts and requisite papers and applied. I was granted an interview, and shortly afterward was accepted. Light returned to the wood and so I began the journey anew, taking a different route. I would never have been able to complete my dissertation without the gentle guidance of my committee members, help from staff, fellow cohort 8 members, friends, and prayers and support from my family and wife. I would like to express my deepest gratitude to my advisor and committee chair, Dr. Robert Smith, for his excellent guidance, caring, patience, and providing me with an excellent atmosphere for doing research. Without his steady hand, I would not have been able to devise the survey instrument. His lovely wife, Susan Smith, lifted my spirits with her joyfulness. I would also like to thank Dr. Kaye Nelson, who not only taught me to appreciate qualitative research, but served as a mentor, blessing, and sounding board. Besides providing my doctoral supervision, Dr. Nelson spent hours working with me to vi
8 develop the semi-structured interview rubric. Both Dr. Smith and Dr. Nelson have imbued me with a passion for Counselor Education and they cheerfully husbanded me through this process. I am thankful for Dr. Richard Balkin who clearly and joyfully explicated the why and wherefore of statistics and quantitative research. I am grateful to Dr. Sherrye Dee Garrett who cheerfully corrected my writing and served as my advocate, throughout the dissertation process. My special thanks go to Dr. Mary Alice Fernandez for her prayers and who graciously agreed to join the committee at the last moment. Dr. Richard Ricard brought sparking light and humor in the area of statistics. Mrs. Rachel Perez is an extraordinary asset to the Counseling and Educational Psychology Department and assisted me greatly in my work as clinic co-director. Finally, of those who assisted me with my dissertation, I am grateful to Veronica Miles, my amanuensis, who spent hours listening to eleven interviews and transcribing them. I also deeply appreciate Dr. Marvarene Oliver, who served as the Coordinator of the Training and Counseling Clinic. She taught me how to run the clinic and to expect the very best of my students. I cannot adequately describe the positive influence fellow cohort members had on me during my doctoral studies. Dr. Stephen Lenz, with whom, I worked spurred me to excellence, amazed me with his brilliance, and allowed me the privilege of officiating his marriage to his beloved Rachel. Annelise Vela was an effusive fountain of new ideas for the cohort and hosted cohort members at her home. Dr. Denise Dominguez, with her laughing eyes, contributed her organizational skills and humor during long study hours. Sandra Lopez brought her faith in God and quiet passion to improve the professionalism vii
9 of school counseling. Mary Rangel-Gomez, who had for several years served as the department s administrative assistant added her experience and knowledge, thus assisting cohort members through the Scylla and Charybdis of doctoral studies. Finally, I am thankful for Joy Snook who was my right hand at the Counseling and Training Clinic and who encouraged me greatly throughout the writing of this dissertation. I was privileged to know, befriend and learn from the following people who brought light and joy to my journey these past 3 years: Mr. Tom Callicot, Dr. Manuel Zamarripa. Dr. Joseph Biberstein, Dr. Sherrill Luther, Dr. Fred Capps, Dr. Yvonne Castillo, Dr. Mary Lou Holt-Adams, Shannon Dobesh, R.J. Davis, and my supervisees during my 2 years as clinic director. There have been people whose lives and examples served as lodestones during crisis and opportunity: My grandparents, Mrs. Dakos, Peggy Holman, Dr. Gerald Critoph, Mr. and Mrs. Robert Anderson, Jerry Walter and his wife Karen, Neil Pfefer and his wife Paula, John Merck, Dr. Rives Chalmers, Dr. Don LaGrone, and friends, Dr. Lori Colwell, Dr. Kimberly Buck, and Dr. Nicole Bereolos. I extend my love and gratitude to my parents, Daniel and Ruth Pope, and my daughter Bethany, who also did a gentle edit on the manuscript and her husband Matthew. I am thankful for my middle child Day and youngest daughter Katie and their loved ones, Robert, and Ruth Ann; my brother Dan and his family, my sister Elaine and her family; and especially my cousins Clinton and Molly White. All have been unflagging in their encouragement, love and prayed daily for the wellbeing of my family. Finally, I would like to thank my wife, Joy-Marie Walsh Pope. When I proposed to her nearly thirty years ago, I told her that we would likely never be rich, but our lives viii
10 together would never be boring. I thank God that she accepted my offer of marriage. She will always be my life, love, and joy. Nearly 2 years ago, my friend Lyle Holin grappled with the unexpected death of his beloved Jill Cook. For a season, he too, had entered the darkened wood and his grief overtook him. So, I rejoiced when I learned he had accepted an offer to teach in the graduate counseling program at the University of Great Falls in Montana. This program would provide Lyle with the intellectual challenge and opportunity to teach students counseling. There, he would find his bliss running, cycling, swimming, and snow skiing. As he was preparing to move to Montana, Lyle told me that he had considered applying as faculty at the University of Louisiana at Monroe, but chose to go to Montana instead. He thought the program at ULM would be a good match for me. I quickly gathered my papers and transcripts and applied. I was interviewed, and was offered a faculty position. Three weeks later, I had found my way, left the woods completely and was teaching. ix
11 Table of Contents Page Abstract...xv List of Tables... Error! Bookmark not defined. List of Figures... Error! Bookmark not defined. CHAPTER 1: SPIRITUALITY AND RELIGION...1 Origins...1 Importance of Religion and Spirituality...2 Spirituality in Counselor Preparation...3 Theological Education...4 Statement of the Problem...5 Purpose of the Study...5 Limitations...6 Significance of the Study...7 Quantitative Research Questions...8 Qualitative Research Questions...9 Methodology...9 Procedures...13 Data Analysis...14 Definition of Terms...16 Summary...21 CHAPTER 2: LITERATURE REVIEW...22 Origins of Spirituality and Religion...22 x
12 Page Spirituality and Religion in Psychology and Counseling...26 Call for Spiritual Sensitivity within Counseling...28 Course Designs...33 Spirituality and Spiritual Formation in Theological Schools...37 Professional and Spiritual Identity of Pastoral Counselors...40 Infusing Spirituality into the Pastoral Counselor Training...44 CHAPTER 3: METHODOLOGY...45 Research Questions...48 Design...48 Participants...50 Procedures...52 Data Analysis...53 Assumptions and Limitations...54 Research Permission, Informed Consent and Ethical Considerations...55 The Role of the Researcher...57 CHAPTER 4: RESULTS...59 Characteristics of Participants...59 Results for Research Questions...62 Ancillary Analyses...72 Results of Qualitative Interviews...77 Summary...91 xi
13 Page CHAPTER 5: DISCUSSION...93 Implications for Future Studies...95 Conclusions References Appendix A Appendix B Appendix C Appendix D Appendix E Appendix F Appendix G Appendix H Appendix I Appendix J Appendix K Appendix L Appendix M xii
14 List of Tables Page Table 1. Sample Demographic Characteristics...60 Table 2. Institution Characteristics...62 Table 3. Interest in Infusing Spirituality Concepts into the Curriculum...64 Table 4. Degree of Infusing Spirituality Concepts into the Curriculum...65 Table 5. Method of Infusing Spirituality Concepts into the Curriculum...66 Table 6. Significant Differences Between ATS Programs (n = 46) and CACREP Programs (n = 45)...68 Table 7. Opinions Regarding Infusion of Spirituality Concepts...70 Table 8. Infusion of Spirituality Concepts as a Function of Accreditation Type...76 Table 9. Participants Understanding of Spirituality Concepts...80 Table 10. Personal Experience of Integrating Spirituality Concepts into Curriculum...84 Table 11. Challenges and Successes Integrating Spirituality Concepts into Curriculum. 89 xiii
15 List of Figures Page Figure 1. Visual Model for Mixed Methods Procedures...48 xiv
16 Abstract The study utilized a sequential, mixed methods design comparing how the Council for Accreditation of Counseling and Related Educational Programs (CACREP) accredited counselor preparation programs and the Association of Theological Schools (ATS) accredited institutions understand, interpret, and implement spirituality concepts within their programs. There were 511 invitations sent to faculty/department heads to participate in the online survey in both CACREP (n = 250) and ATS (n = 261) graduate programs. Ninety-nine completed the survey. Eleven participants, selected from the survey, agreed to be interviewed during the qualitative phase of the study. Chi square test for independence was conducted to determine if there was a relationship between institution accreditation (ATS vs. CACREP) and incorporating training in spirituality into the curriculum. Results of this analysis revealed a significant relationship between the two. Cross tabulation analysis revealed that more ATS accredited programs (93.2%) were prepared to teach/train students in spirituality than CACREP (68.2%) accredited programs. There was strong agreement among respondents from both CACREP and ATS accredited institutions that spirituality concepts should be infused throughout the course of study, M = 4.15, SD =1.14. To a lesser degree, there was agreement among the respondents that spirituality concepts should be taught through infusion and specific courses in the counselor training process, (M = 3.97, SD = 1.16). Interviewed participants described the infusion of spirituality competencies into their teaching, either in terms of their own theoretical orientation, practice, and personhood or as a curriculum requirement, that is, in accreditation standards. Respondents from theological schools reported that they prepared themselves to teach xv
17 spirituality through theological reflection and experiences within ecclesiastical settings and were supported by their departments. Respondents from secular programs reported they did not experience that same level of support, although they did not encounter hindrances. When asked about what most hindered their successful teaching of spirituality concepts, respondents stated their students were reluctant to examine their beliefs. Conversely, respondents stated that their greatest success of teaching spirituality concepts occurred when their students became more open and accepting of others belief systems and who deepened their ability to reflect about spiritual issues. The majority of accredited programs incorporate training in spirituality into the curriculum. Faculty are trained properly regarding spirituality concepts and the common methods they use in the classroom, and had no plans to increase their coverage of such concepts in the near future. The religious and spiritual beliefs and religious affiliation of respondents who participated in the survey and interviews corresponded with the general population of the United States. xvi
18 1 CHAPTER 1: SPIRITUALITY AND RELIGION Origins Early humans, living during the Upper Paleolithic (40,000 to 10,000 BCE), expressed their spiritual inclinations through making tools and weapons, burial of the dead, and later through rock and cave art (Eliade, 1978). It was during the latter period, that shamans began organizing the realm of the spiritual into religion (Whitley, 2009). Sophisticated religions developed alongside the rise of civilizations and have sometimes survived the decline of those same civilizations because, at the core, they express something powerful beyond words or description that visits meaning, purpose, and mystery upon their adherents. They offer, what Rudolf Otto (1957), called a sensus numinis a sense of awe. Otto (1957) also described humans universal ability to experience and join in mysterium tremendum, literally terrifying mystery whereupon the worshiper is filled with dread of the Holy. Despite humans sophisticated mastery of technology and ever improving living conditions, they still seek to encounter and be transformed by something far greater than themselves. They still seek it within themselves, in others, in churches, synagogues, temples, and mosques. As Western civilization has become increasingly secularized, traditionally religious people have begun to seek assistance from counselors and other mental health providers to assist them in their quest to encounter the thing holy in the heart (Otto, p. 14). It is the aim of this study to examine and to compare how counselor preparation graduate programs and pastoral care programs at theological institutions are preparing counselors to be cognizant of their clients spiritual and religious ideas.
19 2 Importance of Religion and Spirituality According to the Gallup (2008) poll, a majority of Americans identify themselves as being religious or spiritual: 78% believe in God, 15% believe in a universal spirit, 6% do not believing in either, and 1% have no opinion. Gerontologist Harold Koenig (2008), director of the Center for Spirituality, Theology, and Health at Duke University, defined and described religion as possessing: 1. A system of beliefs and practices of those within a community, with rituals designed to acknowledge, worship, communicate with, and come closer to the Sacred, Divine or ultimate Truth or Reality (i.e., God) 2. A set of scriptures or teachings that describe the meaning and purpose of the world, the individual s place in it, the responsibilities of individuals to one another, and the life after death 3. A moral code of conduct that is agreed upon by members of the community, who attempted to adhere to that code. (p. 6) Koenig (2008) stated, Religion is a unique construct or domain separate from positive psychology and distinct from secular humanism that can be measured, quantified, and examined in relationship to health outcomes (p. 6). Defining, describing, or quantifying spirituality presents challenges. Unlike religion, which is a social institution, spirituality as a construct is less tangible. It can exist within or apart from religions and religious experiences (Teasdale, 2001, p ). Cashwell, Bentley, and Bigbee (2007, p. 66) understood spirituality through the lens of counseling psychology:
20 3 We define spirituality as a developmental process that is both active and passive wherein beliefs, disciplined practice, and experiences are grounded and integrated to result in increased mindfulness (nonjudgmental awareness of present experiences), heartfulness (experience of compassion and love), and soulfulness (connections beyond ourselves). (p. 67) It is this latter understanding of spirituality, which will be employed throughout this study. In 2009, the Council for Accreditation of Counseling and Related Educational Programs (CACREP) adopted standards stressing the importance of spirituality in counselor preparation programs. Yet, should this spirituality be infused within the delivered curriculum through specific courses, integration throughout the educational process, or a combination of both? Perhaps, counselor educators and theological educators can find fundamental methods to infuse spirituality in the curriculum. Spirituality in Counselor Preparation Perhaps with the decline of American denominations, people are seeking counseling regarding spiritual issues, once regarded the purview of clergy. Many counselors have been ill prepared to provide appropriate spirituality-sensitive counseling (Briggs & Rayle, 2005; Kelly, 1995). Burke et al. (1999, p. 77) asserted that the topics of spirituality and religion in counselor preparation have received modest to mixed attention despite the standards set forth by CACREP. The authors recommended that a balanced view of religious and spiritual issues be included or infused throughout appropriate aspects in counselor preparation, according to CACREP standards (1999).
21 4 Using eight CACREP core curricula standards the authors offered recommendations how they might be applied to counselor preparation pedagogy. Even though the ACA s Code of Ethics contains a spirituality/religious component and that CACREP addresses the same issues in their foundations sections, few graduate programs (25%) in counselor preparation have implemented specific academic courses in spirituality in their curricula (Briggs & Rayle, 2005, p. 252). Briggs and Rayle asserted that CACREP has offered few suggestions on how spirituality and religious concerns may be included in core curricula, resulting in counselor competency. Because there is a paucity of literature concerning spirituality in counselor education and supervision, further research is warranted. Da Silva (2007) determined that a minority of authors advocated that spirituality competencies be infused throughout all content areas of the CACREP standards. In his study graduating counselors who were exposed to content regarding spirituality and religion, throughout their educational process would, therefore, be more thoroughly prepared to apply issues regarding spirituality and religion as constructs in their counseling practices. Theological Education Since the Enlightenment and continuing to the present, there has been tension between theology and spirituality in seminaries and schools of divinity. From about 1830 to 1880, theological educators, under the influence of their Germanic counterparts, embraced science, perceiving theology in objective terms: critiqued, measured, quantified, and analyzed (O Conner & Meakes, 2008, p. 499). It was assumed that students were already spiritually formed (Choung, 2006, p. 2). Also schooled in historical
22 5 criticism, theological educators found it difficult to understand the concept of spirituality (Mudge & Poling, 1987, p. xvii). The accrediting body for postgraduate theological institutions is the Association of Theological Schools (ATS). According to ATS, theological institutions experienced a crisis of faith because of the continued decline in the promotion of spirituality (Calian, 2002, p. 92). Many students were historically and theologically illiterate about their faith and faith traditions. They struggled with the ethical, moral, and spiritual standards expected of those preparing for the ministry and for ordination (2002). As a result in 1996, ATS began adding spirituality components to its accreditation requirements (Calian, 2002, p. 92; Aleshire, 1999; Appendices G & H). Statement of the Problem Only a handful of surveys, (Young, Wiggins-Frame, & Cashwell, 2007, p. 47) have been conducted regarding how counselor preparation and programs are meeting the spirituality standards of CACREP. Survey research on the spirituality competencies related to 2009 CACREP standards and the methods of implementing them have been lacking. Concomitantly, similar research on spirituality competences related to accredited theological schools and the methods of implementing them have been lacking. Purpose of the Study This sequential mixed-methods study will seek to compare how CACREP accredited counselor preparation programs and ATS accredited institutions understood, interpreted, and implemented spirituality concepts. This study, in its quantitative phase, obtained data from CACREP and ATS accredited institutions in (a) the level of interest in infusing spirituality concepts, (b) the degree to which programs infuse spirituality
23 6 concepts, and (c) the methods used to infuse spirituality concepts within their curricula. Finally, this study, in its qualitative phase, attempted to gain insight on (a) faculty members views of infusing spiritual competencies into their teaching and (b) their suggestions regarding increasing their knowledge in this area. Statistical quantitative data were obtained from respondents, who were department heads or designated agents of CACREP accredited programs and their counterparts of ATS accredited institutions, using an online survey. Additionally, 11 tenure-track faculty interested in integrating spirituality concepts into their curriculum were purposefully sampled from CACREP and ATS accredited institutions throughout the United States and Canada, They were interviewed to gain more in-depth information. Semi-structured interviews were used. This data was obtained from tenure track faculty in counselor preparation programs and theological education programs during their respective national conferences and by interviewing them by phone at their schools. Limitations To conduct the quantitative phase of this study, a survey was sent to department heads or their agents of CACREP accredited counselor preparation programs and their counterparts in ATS accredited pastoral counseling/care programs. They were asked to relay this survey to faculty whose interests and task related to integrating spirituality concepts within their counselor preparation program. This study excluded department heads and agents whose programs were not accredited by CACREP or by ATS. Participants were identified and recruited using CACREP and directories. Although every reasonable effort was made to ensure that the department heads or their agents were contacted by , it is likely that some did not receive an invitation to participate.
24 7 As with all self-report data, it is possible that the respondents were influenced to give socially desired responses. In a pilot survey, this investigator learned that many department chairs or program directors did not respond, resulting in a small sample (Pope, 2009). Missing data items was also a limitation. Due to the voluntary nature of survey research, not all survey questions were answered and a few potential respondents were unable or reluctant to go online. Finally, it was difficult to reduce spirituality to measurable units (Koenig, 2008; Hamilton & Jackson, 1998, p. 242). This necessitated incorporating qualitative procedures in the study. Tenure-track faculty were recruited from (a) counselor preparation programs and (b) pastoral counseling/care programs. A select few were interviewed. After coding and identifying themes, faculty responses added richness to the study. Significance of the Study Saunders, Miller, and Bright (2010) reported burgeoning of research positively associating measures of spiritual and religious beliefs and practices (SRBP) and measures of medical and psychological health. Findings indicated that individuals with positive SRBP demonstrated decreased levels of anxiety, depression, suicide, substance abuse, and psychological distress and, significantly, increased hope, well-being, optimism, and resiliency (Saunders et al., 2010). These studies have suggested that spirituality is relevant to psychological care and that clients often desire to discuss spirituality-related issues with their therapists. It is therefore incumbent for therapists to recognize that spirituality and religion are linchpins of individual and cultural diversity (Saunders et al., 2010). However, some prospective clients are reluctant to seek therapy out of fear that their SRBP will not be respected. Most clients prefer to be treated by therapists who hold
25 8 spiritual values and beliefs, and they are even more likely to engage therapists who are able to integrate their personal values and beliefs into counseling (Hage, 2006). A nationwide appended poll of 1000 likely voters, conducted on behalf of the American Association of Pastoral Counselors (AAPC, 2000) and the Samaritan Institute, found that: 1. Eighty-three percent believed that their spirituality and religious practices were inextricably bound to their emotional health. 2. Seventy-five percent said that it was important to see professional counselors who are able to incorporate their values and beliefs into the counseling process. 3. Sixty-nine percent preferred to see a professional counselor who represented spiritual values and beliefs if they had a serious problem requiring counseling. Despite these statistics, many professional counselors do not address their clients SRBD because they did not receive adequate preparation and training in this area (Young, Cashwell, Wiggins-Frame, & Belaire, 2002). Quantitative Research Questions 1. What is the level of interest of counselor educators and instructors of pastoral care training programs in infusing spirituality competencies within their curriculum? 2. To what degree are counselor educators and instructors of pastoral care training programs infusing spirituality in their curriculum? 3. What methods are used to infuse spirituality concepts within the curriculum?
26 9 4. What is the relationship between the infusion of spirituality concepts in CACREP accredited counselor preparation programs and ATS accredited programs on their understanding, interpreting, and implementation of spirituality concepts within their curriculum? Qualitative Research Questions 1. What are faculty experiences of CACREP and ATS schools that have integrated spirituality in their curriculum? 2. What suggestions do faculty have regarding increasing their knowledge of spirituality and infusing this construct in their curriculum? Methodology It is arguable whether qualitative research is the antipode to quantitative. Social scientist Donald Campbell once said, All research ultimately has a qualitative grounding (as cited in Sokolowski & Banks, 2009, p. 29). Behavioral scientist Fred Kerlinger, on the other hand, famously observed, There is no such thing as qualitative data; everything is either 1 or 0 (as cited in Sokolowski & Banks, 2009, p. 29). Qualitative research is grounded in a process in which an investigator gains understanding of a complex, holistic picture, analyzes words, reports detailed views of informants, and conducts the study in a natural setting (Creswell, 2009, p. 15). Data is gathered from those immersed in everyday life of the setting in which the study is framed (Ivankova, p. 44). Data is analyzed based on the values the participants perceive to be true for their world. As a result, the researcher understands the problem within multiple layers of context.
27 10 Quantitative research is deductive in that a given topic of interest is identified and narrowed down so more specific questions may be answered or hypotheses may be tested using numerical data (Mertler & Charles, 2008). The aim of research is to pursue and explore reality even though it is something that can never be reached or fully understood (Trochim, 2006). The post-positivist researcher separates variables and causally relates them to determine the magnitude and frequency of relationships (Ivankova, 2004). By choosing which variables to investigate and instruments to employ, the researcher could garner reliable and valid scores from the data (Ivankova, 2002). If it is true that quantitative research and qualitative research are antipodal, then mixed methods research is equatorial, sharing characteristics of both. Mixed methods research is pragmatic a technique for collecting, analyzing, and mixing qualitative and quantitative data (Creswell, 2007; Tashakkori & Teddlie, 2003). Creswell, Plano-Clark, Gutmann, & Hanson (2003) defined this mixed methods approach as involving: the collection or analysis of both quantitative and/or qualitative data in a single study in which the data are collected concurrently or sequentially, are given a priority, and involve the integration of the data at one or more stages in the process of research. (p. 212) Tashakkori and Teddlie (1998) held that the term mixed model is more appropriate than mixed method, because mixing entails more than an eclectic mixing of methodologies applied at various stages throughout the research within the broader quantitative or qualitative approach (Bazeley, 2004). This integration of qualitative and quantitative methods and paradigmatic influences occurred throughout the research
GRADUATE SCHOOL OF THEOLOGY & MINISTRY PROGRAM OVERVIEW ORU SEMINARY A GLOBAL PLACE FOR WORLD-CLASS TRAINING IN MINISTRY, COUNSELING, AND LEADERSHIP The Oral Roberts University Graduate School of Theology
Doctor of Ministry Pastoral Care and Counseling Emphasis Overview San Francisco Theological Seminary offers a Doctor of Ministry with special emphasis on Pastoral Care and Counseling. This is one of several
D.Min. in Pastoral Care and Counseling Guidelines and Strategies for Completing the Program Revised 1/11 Index Section I Curriculum 3 Constructing a Course of Study 3 Areas of Study 3 Core D.Min. Seminars
Program Coordinator, Clinical Mental Health Counseling Montreat College, Montreat, NC Position Activities Montreat College is currently seeking to fill a part-time (20 hours per week) Program Coordinator
Dear friends, A message from the Perth Bishops Young people are an important part of the Church community. The document Anointed and Sent from the Australian Catholic Bishops Conference and now our local
` GUIDELINES FOR CATHOLIC HIGH SCHOOL RELIGION TEACHER CERTIFICATION Archdiocese of Cincinnati Office of Evangelization & Catechesis 2016 TABLE OF CONTENTS I. THE RELIGION TEACHER PAGE A. Personal Qualifications...
MASTER OF SCIENCE IN PASTORAL CARE AND COUNSELING Recognizing that the field of pastoral care and counseling requires both general common course work, as well as a concentration in one s particular area
The mission of the arises out of faith in God who calls the worlds into being, creates humankind in the divine image, and intends for us the blessing of wholeness and harmony with God, with creation, with
Basic Programs Oriented Toward Ministerial Leadership A MASTER OF DIVINITY (MDiv) A.I Purpose of the Degree A.1.0 The Master of Divinity degree is the normative degree to prepare persons for ordained ministry
Religious Education in Catholic Schools a statement from the Catholic Bishops Conference of England & Wales May 2000 Catholic Media Office Published in 2000 by the Catholic Media Office 39 Eccleston Square,
1 LECTURE NOTES ON PROFESSIONAL CHAPLAINCY George Grant April, 2003 Introduction The Three Tracks of Ministry Academics: Basic degree for any form of ministry is the Master of Divinity (M.Div.). The M.Div.
Master of Arts in Theology Overview The Whitworth Master of Arts in Theology Program seeks to produce Christ-centered, well-educated, spiritually disciplined, visionary leaders for the church and society.
COMMUNICATIONS ADDRESS: 2675 W. State Route 89A, No. 465, Sedona, AZ 86336 ADMINISTRATION TOLL FREE WITHIN THE CONTINENTAL US: (888) 866-4685 OUTSIDE US: (928) 203-0730 FAX (928) 204-0543 UNIVERSITY OF
DOCTOR OF MINISTRY Focus Group Cohort Transformational Church Leadership for a Digital Society A Doctor of Ministry Focus Group led by Dr. JT Roberson, Jr., Mentor Dr. Constance L. Chamblee, Mentor Fall.
APPLICATION FOR ADMISSION OFFICE of ADMISSIONS, McAFEE SCHOOL of THEOLOGY MERCER UNIVERSITY 3001 MERCER UNIVERSITY DRIVE ATLANTA, GEORGIA 30341-4115 OFFICE: (678) 547-6474 TOLL FREE: (888) 471-9922 THEOLOGYADMISSIONS@MERCER.EDU
MINISTRY INTERNATIONAL INSTITUTE COUNSELING TRAINING In addition to providing Theological Training, Ministry International Institute (MII) founded by J. Tony Slay is also committed to providing quality
loyola university chicago institute of pastoral studies faith in action The many faces of ministry each generation of christians, since the first, has preserved the memory of jesus and, as best they could,
1 BHU Graduate School The graduate school of Beulah Heights University offers a Master of Arts program (42 hours) with concentrations in Religious Studies or Leadership Studies. The graduate school also
Pastoral Care vs. Professional Counseling: Discerning the Differences 1999 L. Ronald Brushwyler, D.Min. with Sheryl Carle Fancher, M.A. James C. Geoly, J.D. John R. Matthews, S.T.M. Margo M.R. Stone, Psy.D.
How do I become a counsellor? Students taking psychology are often interested in becoming counsellors or therapists. This guide is intended to assist with students who wish to go down this path. Please
i The University of Louisiana at Monroe Online Doctoral Program in Marriage and Family Therapy: Concentration in Creative Systemic Studies Doctor of Philosophy Degree Program Handbook Policies and Procedures
Page 1 of 5 Dear Ministry Site Supervisor, Thank you for your willingness to invest in the growth of our student! By meeting with our student regularly during the course of this semester you are serving
Ph.D. Counselor Education and Supervision 2014 2015 Program Guidebook NOTE: 1) This guidebook is subject to change. If it does, students will be notified via email and will be provided with the revised
5. Curriculum 5.1 Master of Divinity Program Goals & Objectives The Master of Divinity is the normative degree prerequisite for ordained pastoral ministry in the church. It is also the degree that serves
Table of Contents (Click on any title below to jump to that page) 1. An Introduction to Angelic Prayers 2. Angelic Prayers i. An Everyday Prayer ii. Honouring My Inner Beauty iii. Manifesting iv. Balancing
Student Handbook Welcome to the VA New York Harbor Healthcare System Clinical Pastoral Education (CPE) Center. This Student Handbook will serve as your guide during your experience in our CPE Center. The
1. Standard Curriculum MFT Educational Guidelines 1.01 The program will document that all students have completed, or will complete while in the program, all coursework and clinical requirements of the
PREPARATION FOR TEACHING IN CATHOLIC SCHOOLS Preparation for Teaching in Catholic Schools (Initial Teacher Education Course) 2012 1. Introduction 1 The Institute for Catholic Education periodically updates
Oasis Family Life Enrichment Centre 422-A TELOK BLANGAH ROAD, SINGAPORE 098848 Website: www.oasisflec.org.sg, Email: firstname.lastname@example.org Tel: 62747480 Fax: 62760024 PROSPECTUS FOR CHRISTIAN COUNSELLING
Things To Consider When Choosing A Counselor The following information is meant to be a guide to help you make an informed decision on a counseling resource for either yourself or someone you know. Making
DENOMINATIONAL CONNECTIONS I. Vocation and Ministerial Authorization II. Ordained Elder in The United Methodist Church III. Ordained Deacon in The United Methodist Church IV. United Methodist Student Support
Master of Arts, Counseling Psychology Course Descriptions Advanced Theories of Counseling & Intervention (3 credits) This course addresses the theoretical approaches used in counseling, therapy and intervention.
Doctor of Ministry Program A. Purpose and Objectives of the Program The Doctor of Ministry (D. Min.) degree is a terminal degree in the practice of ministry. It is offered to persons who are engaged in
Dean of the School of Adult Learning North Park University Chicago, IL Click Here To Apply Dean of the School of Adult Learning North Park University POSITION PROFILE and ANNOUNCEMENT North Park University
Counselor Education CAREER COUNSELING, CLINICAL MENTAL HEALTH COUNSELING, AND SCHOOL COUNSELING Dr. Peggy Whiting, Coordinator Counselor Education Program Program Telephone: (919) 530-6182 Fax: (919) 530-5328
Our Core Beliefs 1 We are rooted in the Gospel above all else. From this experience of God in the person of Jesus and the Word of Scripture, all our core beliefs flow. We are formed by Ignatian Spirituality
WMBC Counseling Ministry Personal Data Inventory Please complete this inventory carefully (Question marks have been eliminated.) Personal Identification Name: Birth Date: Physical Address: Mailing Address
Standards & Guidelines for professionals March 2011 ELCA Youth Ministry Network 866.ELCANET www.elcaymnet.org INTRODUCTION Recent years have seen an increase in the level of professionalism of those who
!1 HMS Richards Divinity School ls s and matrix) nd matrix) s) rses (we need to generate these) onsecration Service Events dar eetings lty Annual Reports DUE t Weekend uate Consecration HMS Richards Divinity
HEALTHY CONGREGATIONS Biblical Reflections for Church Leaders Healthy congregations and effective leaders in every place making disciples of Jesus Christ for the transformation of the world. Mission of
M.A. Counseling Psychology 2015 2016 Program Guidebook NOTE: 1) This guidebook is subject to change. If it does, students will be notified via email and will be provided with the revised version. 2) Policies
Ministries in Chaplaincy, Pastoral Counseling and Clinical Education Endorsement Standards and Procedures Call Criteria Program Guidelines Revised and Adopted Congregational & Synodical Mission May 2012
Living Water Church Ministry Training Center He that believeth on me, as the scripture hath said, out of his belly shall flow rivers of living water. John 7:38 1000 Hall Valley Drive Bridgeport, WV 26301
Standards of Accreditation Theological schools accredited by the Commission on Accrediting of the Association of Theological Schools (the Commission ) are special-purpose institutions of postbaccalaureate,
Comparison Chart: Competencies vs. Outcomes APC ACPE Crosswalk APC Competency/ Common Standards for ACPE outcomes Certification (Level I = 311.x Level II = 312.x) TPC1: Articulate a theology of spiritual
Dissertation Research (DR) DR 9108 - Dissertation Research This course will enable the student to conduct preliminary research for a dissertation proposal, to draw from bibliographical resources relevant
Online CMHC Program Course Descriptions Students must meet with their advisor prior to registering for courses. If a student wishes to take a course outside the suggested schedule of study, they must first
School of Counseling Handbook (2014) OVERVIEW The Master of Arts in Counseling and the Postgraduate Diploma in Counseling programs prepares Christian counselors with the knowledge, skill, and insight to
Welcome to United! Spirit Led, Renewing the Church! United Theological Seminary 4501 Denlinger Road Dayton, Ohio 45426 Our purpose is to recruit and educate faithful leaders for the mission of Jesus Christ
The Doctor of Ministry Program: Pastoral Leadership in Care and Counseling June 2007 2 Pastoral Leadership in Care and Counseling PTS offers this program in conjunction with the Counseling and Mediation
Guidelines for Integrative Core Curriculum Themes and Perspectives Designations The purpose of this document is to provide guidelines for faculty wishing to have new or existing courses carry Themes and
Couple, Marriage, and Family Therapy at Texas Tech University Mission Statement and Learning Outcomes 2016 T he Couple, Marriage, and Family Therapy graduate programs at TTU provide systemic research and
Taking God s love to others through service 37 Then the righteous will answer him, Lord, when was it that we saw you hungry and gave you food, or thirsty and gave you something to drink? 38 And when was
NATIONAL CATHOLIC SCHOOL OF SOCIAL SERVICE Baccalaureate Study in Social Work Goals and Assessment of Student Learning Outcomes In keeping with the social teachings and values of the Roman Catholic Church,
A. MEANING OF THE SACRAMENT DIOCESE OF GALLUP SACRAMENTAL GUIDELINES ANOINTING OF THE SICK "The Lord himself showed great concern for the bodily and spiritual we/fare of the sick and commanded his followers
Real-life experience for real-world ministry. Hazelip School of Theology Ministry is changing. Join the conversation. Ministry happens in many different ways. And the needs of those who lead and work within
Louisville Presbyterian Theological Seminary Doctor of Ministry Handbook Office of the Doctor of Ministry and Continuing Education January, 2013 TABLE OF CONTENTS PURPOSE AND MISSION... 3 PLAN OF STUDY...
Counselor Education Program Mission and Objectives Our Mission The LSU Counselor Education program prepares students to function as professional counselors in a variety of human service settings such as
GREETINGS CEREMONY OF MARRIAGE By Marianne Williamson Edited by Rev. Gregg R. Anderson Aspen Chapel and, I extend to you greetings and affirmation on this momentous day of love and confirmation. To our
Master of Divinity The Master of Divinity is a professional degree open to anyone, regardless of whether you wish to become a Unity minister. People who are interested in Unity licensing and ordination
DOCTOR of MINISTRY Emphasis in Church Revitalization Charlotte I am so grateful for the marvelous blessing of this unique D.Min. emphasis and how it came together. I am praying that our Lord will use this
Diaconal Ministry at Luther Seminary Diaconal ministers are consecrated to ministry of Word and Service, at the intersection of church and world. Diaconal ministers work to seek wholeness in the world,
MASTERS DEGREES in COUNSELING AND THERAPY Explore your Mind, Start your Career, Benefit Others Clinical Mental Health Counseling Marriage and Family Therapy Creative Arts Therapy Concentrations Explore
UTAH STATE UNIVERSITY Professional School Guidance Counselor Education Program Mapping Course Key: PSY 6130 Evidence-Based Practice: School Intervention PSY 6240 Comprehensive School Counseling Programs
Commission on Accrediting DEGREE PROGRAM STANDARDS TABLE OF CONTENTS Standard A Master of Divinity (MDiv) 1 Standard B Master of Arts in [specialized ministry] (MA in [specialized ministry]), or Master
BYLAWS OF COUNSELING AND CONSULTATION SERVICES (CCS) 1.0 COUNSELING AND CONSULTATION SERVICES MEMBERSHIP 1.1 Voting membership shall consist of all AAUP bargaining unit members with appointments in CCS.
OBSERVE ANALYZE TRANSFORM PSYCHOLOGY, SOCIAL WORK AND RELIGIOUS STUDIES PSYCHOLOGY The mind works in mysterious ways. With a psychology degree from Clarke, you ll be prepared to enter the exciting field
Student Handbook 5210 Centennial Blvd. Colorado Springs, CO 80919 email@example.com www.crosstocrown.org Student Handbook Welcome to New Covenant School of Theology (NCST). We count it a joy to help
Foundations S H A P I N G T H E M I N I S T RY O F C H R I S T I A N E D U C AT I O N I N Y O U R C O N G R E G AT I O N T he church of Jesus Christ cannot survive without the fundamental ministry of teaching.
Intro. Chapter pg 1a Seasonal Getting to know you Call To Faith 6th Grade Activities will be in your boxes with supply needed to develop the activities. Title Overview Scripture Chapter Words Activities
Thursday, September 13, 2012 Theological Schools and the Church Friday, September 14, 2012 A Perspective from the Lilly Endowment What have we learned from the Flourishing in Ministry Project? Theological
FITNESS FOR THE PROFESSION OF COUNSELING A Policy Statement from the Faculty and Staff of the Department of Counseling and Human Services, College of Professional Studies, University of Scranton. PROFESSIONAL
admission materials Hardin-Simmons University w w w. l o g s d o n s e m i n a r y. o r g An Invitation to the Ministry in a changing and complex world presents both exciting opportunities and significant
Introducing King s Online Bible School Our Goals for our Students We desire and pray that you will: abide in Christ abide in His Word abide in His church abide in His love For all things belong to you,
Proposal to Modify the MA in School Counseling Department of Counseling Prepared and Submitted by Department of Counseling DATE: November, 2013 SEHS COI Approved: December 3, 2013 1. List proposed program
FORMATION CRITERIA for ORDAINED MINISTRY: IME Phase 2 Structure of the formation criteria The Formation Criteria are organised under seven headings: A. Christian faith, tradition and life B. Mission, evangelism
Introduction to North Central University North Central University is a private, coeducational, undergraduate, primarily residential university owned and operated by eleven Assemblies of God Districts of
SIUE Mass Communications Graduate Program Guide & Handbook Designed To Educate & Assist Our Prospective & Current Masters Candidates Copyright SIUE Mass Communications Department 2010 Table of Contents
Table of Contents Introduction...4 Meeting and Setting Goals...6 Week 1: The Great Human Questions...9 Week 2: Examining the Ways We Know...15 Week 3: The Christian Worldview...24 Appendix A: The Divine
Page 1 of 9 THEOLOGICAL EDUCATION FOR THE ANGLICAN COMMUNION PRIESTS AND TRANSITIONAL DEACONS TARGET GROUP At selection evidence should be shown that At ordination evidence should be shown that After ordination
We believe in all the teachings of the Apostles and that the Church is built on the foundation of the Apostles, Prophets with Jesus Christ the Chief Corner Stone. EDUCATING TODAY S CHRISTIAN LEADERS MESSAGE
Philosophy of Counseling 1 Philosophy of Counseling CSD 5530 October 17, 2005 Philosophy of Counseling 2 There are several aspects of an effective counselor. Three of those aspects are thorough knowledge
PROVIDE AN INTEGRAL, QUALITY EDUCATION A. Promote quality education of the whole person The Marianist school educates the whole person, developing the individual s physical, psychological, intellectual,
PASTORAL ASSOCIATE Position Description and Competencies Archdiocese of Milwaukee Human Resources Department 3501 S. Lake Dr. - PO Box 070912 Milwaukee, WI 53207-0912 414-769-3329 or 1-800-769-9373, ext.
PRINCIPLES OF GOOD PRACTICE FOR STUDENT AFFAIRS AT CATHOLIC COLLEGES AND UNIVERSITIES Introduction The purpose of these Principles is to provide a framework for student affairs professionals who work at
SELF-EVALUATION ECCLESIAL LAY MINISTRY PROGRAM Diocese of Lafayette-in-Indiana Applicant: Directions: Please read each statement and evaluate this statement based on the following levels of satisfaction:
1 BENEDICTION AND FINAL GREETINGS Hebrews 13:20-25 As the writer comes to the end of the letter, he prays for his readers. He prays to the God who knows everything and who knows our hearts. Although we
Annual Performance Evaluation Rector Employee Name: Seth Dietrich Position Title: Rector Supervisor Name: Supervisor Title: Bishop of Milwaukee; Wardens of Christ Church Date of Review: Period of Review:
Your consent to our cookies if you continue to use this website.