1 SOURCE: TITLE: AGENDA ITEM: CONTACT: ITU-T ITU-T Security Standardization GTSC, agenda item 5.5 Herb Bertine, GSC11(06)_GTSC_07 Telecommunication Security Herbert Bertine Chairman, ITU-T SG 17
2 High Level Security Drivers ITU Plenipotentiary Conference (PP-02) Intensify efforts on security World Telecommunications Standardization Assembly (WTSA-04) Security robustness of protocols Combating/Countering spam World Summit on the Information Society (WSIS-05) Cyber security
3 ITU-T Study Groups ITU-T work is divided up between Study Groups (SGs). SG 2: Operational aspects of service provision, networks and performance SG 4: Telecommunication management SG 5: Protection against electromagnetic environment effects SG 6 Outside Plant and related indoor installations SG 9 Integrated broadband cable networks and television and sound transmission SG 11 Signaling requirements and protocols SG 12 Performance and quality of service SG 13 Next Generation Networks SG 15: Optical and other transport networks SG 16: Multimedia services, systems and terminals SG 17: Security, languages and telecommunication software* SG 19: Mobile Telecommunications Networks *SG17 is the Lead Study Group on telecommunication security.
4 Overview of ITU-T Security Standardization Collaboration is key factor
5 WP 2/17 Security Questions ( ) Q7/17 Telecom Systems Security Management *ISM Guideline for Telecom *Incident Management *Risk Assessment Methodology *etc *X.1051 Telecom Systems Users Telebiometrics *Multimodal Model Fwk *System Mechanism *Protection Procedure *X.1081 Secure Communication Services *Mobile Secure Communications *Home Network Security *Security Web Services Q9/17 *X.1121, X.1122 Cyber Security Q6/17 *Overview of Cyber-security *Vulnerability Information Sharing * Incident Handling Operations Countering spam *Technical anti-spam measures Q17/17 New Q8/17 Q5/17 Security Architecture & Framework *Architecture, Model, Concepts, Frameworks, *etc *X.800 series *X.805 Q4/17 Communications System Security *Vision, Coordination, Roadmap, Compendia
6 Highlights of what s new since GSC-10 Two new ITU-T Questions: Q.15/13, NGN security (May 2005) Q.17/17, Countering spam by technical means 38 security Recommendations are under development in Study Group 17 Other SGs are developing security Recommendations for specific technologies for example 5 on NGN security Focus Group on Security Baseline For Network Operators New Horizons for Security Standardization Workshop Security standards roadmap Cybersecurity web portal
7 Q.15/13 NGN Security Recognizing that security is one of the defining features of NGN, it is essential to put in place a set of standards that will guarantee, to the maximum degree possible, the security of the telecommunications infrastructure as PSTNs evolve to NGNs. The NGN Security studies must address and develop network architectures that: - Provide for maximal network and end-user resource protection - Allow for highly-distributed intelligence end-to-end - Allow for co-existence of multiple networking technologies - Provide for end-to-end security mechanisms - Provide for security solutions that apply over multiple administrative domains
8 Q.17/17 Combating spam by technical means Spam has become a widespread problem causing a complex range of problems to users, service providers, and network operators around the globe. While spam was originally used to send unsolicited commercial messages, increasingly spam messages are being used to spread viruses, worms, and other malicious code that negatively impact the security and stability of the global telecommunication network. Spam may include the delivery of phishing and spyware. It is a global problem that requires a multifaceted, comprehensive approach. Study items to be considered include, but are not limited to: - What risks does spam pose to the telecommunication network? - What technical factors associated with the telecommunication network contribute to the difficulty of identifying the sources of spam? - How can new technologies lead to opportunities to counter spam and enhance the security of the telecommunication network? - Do advanced telecommunication network technologies (for example, SMS, instant messaging, VoIP) offer unique opportunities for spam that require unique solutions? - What technical work is already being undertaken within the IETF, in other fora, and by private sector entities to address the problem of spam? - What telecommunication network standardization work, if any, is needed to effectively counter spam as it relates to the stability and robustness of the telecommunication network?
9 SG 17 Security Recommendations under development (1/3) Summaries of all Study Group 17 Recommendations under development are available on the Study Group 17 web page at: Communications Systems Security Project X.sbno, Security baseline for network operators Security Architecture and Framework X.805+, Division of the security features between the network and the users X.805nsa, Network security certification based on ITU-T Recommendation X.805 X.ngn-akm, Framework for authentication and key management for link layer security of NGN X.pak, Password-authenticated key exchange (PAK) X.spn, Framework for creation, storage, distribution and enforcement of security policies for networks
10 SG 17 Security Recommendations under development (2/3) Cyber Security X.cso, Overview of cybersecurity X.sds, Guidelines for Internet Service Providers and End-users for Addressing the Risk of Spyware and Deceptive Software X.cvlm, Guidelines on Cybersecurity Vulnerability Life-cycle Management X.vds, A vendor-neutral framework for automatic checking of the presence of vulnerabilities information update Security Management X.1051 (R), Information security management guidelines for telecommunications based on ISO/IEC X.rmg, Risk management guidelines for telecommunications X.sim, Security incident management guidelines for telecommunications Telebiometrics X.bip, BioAPI interworking protocol X.physiol, Telebiometrics related to human physiology X.tai, Telebiometrics authentication infrastructure X.tpp-1, A guideline of technical and managerial countermeasures for biometric data security X.tpp-2, A guideline for secure and efficient transmission of multi-modal biometric data X.tsm-1, General biometric authentication protocol and profile on telecommunication systems X.tsm-2, Profile of telecomunication device for Telebiometrics System Mechanism (TSM)
11 SG 17 Security Recommendations under development (2/3) Secure Communication Services X.crs, Correlative reacting system in mobile network X.homesec-1, Framework of security technologies for home network X.homesec-2, Certificate profile for the device in the home network X.homesec-3, User authentication mechanisms for home network service X.msec-3, General security value added service (policy) for mobile data communication X.msec-4, Authentication architecture in mobile end-to-end data communication X.p2p-1, Requirements of security for peer-to-peer and peer-to-multi peer communications X.p2p-2, Security architecture and protocols for peer to peer network X.sap-1, Guideline on secure password-based authentication protocol with key exchange X.sap-2, Secure communication using TTP service X.websec-1, Security Assertion Markup Language (SAML) X.1141 now in AAP Last Call X.websec-2, extensible Access Control Markup Language (XACML) X.1142 now in AAP Last Call X.websec-3, Security architecture for message security in mobile web services Countering spam by technical means X.csreq, Requirement on countering spam X.fcs, Technical framework for countering spam X.gcs, Guideline on countering spam X.ocsip, Overview of countering spam for IP multimedia application X.tcs, Technical means for countering spam
12 SG 13 Security Recommendations under development NGN Security Security Requirements for NGN Release 1* Guidelines for NGN Security Release 1* Authentication requirements for NGN Release 1 AAA Service for Network Access to NGN Security considerations for Pseudowire (PWE) technology * Continuation of the work originated in the ITU-T Focus Group on NGN
13 Focus Group: Security Baseline for Network Operators Established October 2005 by SG 17 Objectives: Define a security baseline against which network operators can assess their network and information security posture in terms of what security standards are available, which of these standards should be used to meet particular requirements, when they should be used, and how they should be applied Describe a network operator s readiness and ability to collaborate with other entities (operators, users and law enforcement authorities) to counteract information security threats Provide meaningful criteria that can be used by network operators against which other network operators can be assessed, if required. Next Step Survey network operators by means of a questionnaire
14 New Horizons for Security Standardization Workshop Workshop held in Geneva 3-4 October 2005 Objectives Provide an overview of key international security standardization activities; Seek to identify primary security concerns and issues; Determine which issues are amenable to a standards-based solution; Identify which SDOs are are best equipped to do so; and Consider how SDOs can collaborate to improve the timeliness and effectiveness of security standards and avoid duplication of effort. Results reported under following topics: What are the crucial problems in ICT security standardization? Meta issues and need for a global framework; Standards Requirements and Priorities; Liaison and information sharing; User issues; Technology and threat issues; Focus for future standardization work; Process issues; Follow-on issues Report available at
15 ICT Security Standards Roadmap Four Part Roadmap Part 1 contains information about organizations working on ICT security standards Part 2 is a database of existing security standards Presently includes ITU-T, ISO/IEC JTC1 and IETF standards Will be expanded to include other standards Part 3 will be a list of standards in development Part 4 will identify future needs and proposed new standards Publicly available under Special Projects and Issues at: We invite you to use the Roadmap, provide feedback and help us develop it to meet your needs
16 The ITU Global Cybersecurity Gateway LIVE at: Provides an easy-to-use information resource on national, regional and international cybersecurity-related activities and initiatives worldwide.
17 Structure of the Cybersecurity Gateway The portal is geared towards four specific audiences: Citizens ; Businesses ; Governments, International Organizations Database information collected within five main themes: 1. Information sharing of national approaches, good practices and guidelines; 2. Developing watch, warning and incident response capabilities; 3. Technical standards and industry solutions; 4. Harmonizing national legal approaches and international legal coordination and enforcement; 5. Privacy, data and consumer protection. Additional information resources on the following topics: spam, spyware, phishing, scams and frauds, worms and viruses, denial of service attacks, etc.
19 Some useful web resources ITU-T Home page Study Group 17 LSG on Security Recommendations ITU-T Lighthouse ITU-T Workshops Security Roadmap Cybersecurity Portal
20 Closing Observations Security is everybody's business Collaboration with other SDOs is necessary Security needs to be designed in upfront Security must be an ongoing effort Systematically addressing vulnerabilities (intrinsic properties of networks/systems) is key so that protection can be provided independent of what the threats (which are constantly changing and may be unknown) may be X.805 is helpful here
21 Additional details on security work in ITU-T Study Groups: - Study Group 17 - Study Group 4 - Study Group 9 - Study Group 13 - Study Group 16 - Study Group 19
22 ITU-T SG 17 Work on Security
23 Study Group 17: Security, languages and telecommunication software SG 17 is the Lead Study Group on telecommunication security - It is responsible for coordination of security across all Study Groups. Subdivided into three Working Parties (WPs) WP1 - Open systems technologies; WP2 - Telecommunications security; and WP3 - Languages and telecommunications software Most (but not all) security Questions are in WP2 Summaries of all draft Recommendations under development in SG 17 are available on the SG 17 web page at
24 Current SG 17 security-related Questions Working Party 1: 1/17 End-to-end Multicast Communications with QoS Managing Facility 2/17 Directory services, Directory systems, and publickey/attribute certificates 3/17 Open Systems Interconnection (OSI) 16/17 Internationalized Domain Names (IDN) Working Party 2: 4/17 Communications Systems Security Project 5/17 Security Architecture and Framework 6/17 Cyber Security 7/17 Security Management 8/17 Telebiometrics 9/17 Secure Communication Services 17/17 Countering spam by technical means
25 ITU-T SG 17 Question 4 Communications Systems Security Project Security Workshop ICT Security Roadmap Focus Group on Security Baseline For Network Operators
26 New Horizons for Security Standardization Workshop Workshop held in Geneva 3-4 October 2005 Hosted by ITU-T SG17 as part of security coordination responsibility ISO/IEC JTC1 played an important role in planning the program and in providing speakers/panelists. Speakers, panelists, chairs from: ITU-T ISO/IEC IETF Consortia OASIS, 3GPP Regional SDOs ATIS, ETSI, RAIS
27 Workshop Objectives Provide an overview of key international security standardization activities; Seek to find out from stakeholders (e.g., network operators, system developers, manufacturers and end-users) their primary security concerns and issues (including possible issues of adoption or implementation of standards); Try to determine which issues are amenable to a standards-based solution and how the SDOs can most effectively play a role in helping address these issues; Identify which SDOs are already working on these issues or are best equipped to do so; and Consider how SDOs can collaborate to improve the timeliness and effectiveness of security standards and avoid duplication of effort.
28 Workshop Results Excellent discussions, feedback and suggestions Documented in detail in the Workshop report Results are reported under following topics: What are the crucial problems in ICT security standardization? Meta issues and need for a global framework; Standards Requirements and Priorities; Liaison and information sharing; User issues; Technology and threat issues; Focus for future standardization work; Process issues; Follow-on issues The report is available on-line at:
29 ICT Security Standards Roadmap (An SG 17 Work-in-progress) Part 1 contains information about organizations working on ICT security standards Part 2 is database of existing security standards Part 3 will be a list of standards in development Part 4 will identify future needs and proposed new standards
30 Roadmap access Part 2 includes ITU-T, ISO/IEC JTC1 and IETF standards. It will be expanded to include other standards (e.g. regional and consortia specifications). It will also be converted to a Database format to allow searching and to allow organizations to manage their own data Publicly available under Special Projects and Issues at: We invite you to use the Roadmap, provide feedback and help us develop it to meet your needs
31 Other Q.4/17 projects Security in Telecommunications and Information Technology an overview of existing ITU-T Recommendations for secure telecommunications. Security compendium: catalogue of approved ITU-T Recommendations related to telecommunication security extract of ITU-T approved security definitions listing of ITU-T security related Questions We are in the process of establishing a Security Experts Network (SEN) to maintain on-going dialogue on key issues of security standardization.
32 Focus Group: Security Baseline for Network Operators Established October 2005 by SG 17 Objectives: Define a security baseline against which network operators can assess their network and information security posture in terms of what security standards are available, which of these standards should be used to meet particular requirements, when they should be used, and how they should be applied Describe a network operator s readiness and ability to collaborate with other entities (operators, users and law enforcement authorities) to counteract information security threats Provide meaningful criteria that can be used by network operators against which other network operators can be assessed, if required. Next Step Survey network operators by means of a questionnaire
33 ITU-T SG 17 Question 5 Security Architecture and Framework Brief description of Q.5 Milestones Draft Recommendations under development
34 Brief description of Q.5/17 Motivation The telecommunications and information technology industries are seeking cost-effective comprehensive security solutions that could be applied to various types of networks, services and applications. To achieve such solutions in multi-vendor environment, network security should be designed around the standard security architectures and standard security technologies. Major tasks Development of a comprehensive set of Recommendations for providing standard security solutions for telecommunications in collaboration with other Standards Development Organizations and ITU-T Study Groups. Maintenance and enhancements of Recommendations in the X.800 series: X.800, X.802, X.803, X.805, X.810, X.811, X.812, X.813, X.814, X.815, X.816, X.830, X.831, X.832, X.833, X.834, X.835, X.841, X.842 and X.843
35 Q.5/17 Milestones ITU-T Recommendation X.805, Security Architecture for Systems Providing End-to-end Communications, was published in ISO Standard , Network security architecture, was developed in collaboration between ITU-T Q.5/17 and ISO/IEC JTC 1 SC 27 WG 1. The Standard is technically aligned with X.805. It was published in 2006.
36 ITU-T Recommendation X.805 VULNERABILITIES Security layers Applications security Services security Infrastructure security Access control Authentication Non-repudiation Data confidentiality Communication security Data integrity Availability Privacy THREATS Destruction Corruption Removal Disclosure Interruption ATTACKS End-user plane Control plane Management plane 8 Security dimensions X.805_F3 X.805 defines a network security architecture for providing end-to-end network security. The architecture can be applied to various kinds of networks where the end-to-end security is a concern and independently of the network s underlying technology.
37 Q.5/17 Draft Recommendations 1/2 Applications and further development of major concepts of ITU-T Recommendation X.805 X.805+, Division of the security features between the network and the users. This Recommendation specifies division of security features between the networks and users. It provides guidance on applying concepts of the X.805 architecture to securing service provider s, application provider s networks and the end user s equipment. X.805nsa, Network security certification based on ITU-T Recommendation X.805. This Recommendation describes the methodology, processes and controls required for network security certification based on ITU-T Recommendation X.805, Security Architecture for Systems Providing End-to-End Communications.
38 Q.5/17 Draft Recommendations 2/2 Standardization in support of Authentication Security Dimension (defined in X.805) X.pak, Password-authenticated Key Exchange Protocol (PAK). This Recommendation specifies a password-based protocol for authentication and key exchange, which ensures mutual authentication of both parties in the act of establishing a symmetric cryptographic key via Diffie-Hellman exchange. X.ngn-akm, Framework for authentication and key management for link layer security of NGN. This Recommendation establishes a framework for authentication and key management for securing the link layer of NGN. It also provides guidance on selection of the EAP methods for NGN. Standardization of network security policies X.spn, Framework for creation, storage, distribution, and enforcement of security policies for networks. This Recommendation establishes security policies that are to drive security controls of a system or service. It also specifies a framework for creation, storage, distribution, and enforcement of policies for network security that can be applied to various environmental conditions and network devices.
39 ITU-T SG 17 Question 6 Cyber Security Motivation Objectives Scope Current area of focus Draft Recommendations under development
40 Q.6/17 Motivation Network connectivity and ubiquitous access is central to today s IT systems Wide spread access and loose coupling of interconnected IT systems is a primary source of widespread vulnerability Threats such as: denial of service, theft of financial and personal data, network failures and disruption of voice and data telecommunications are on the rise Network protocols in use today were developed in an environment of trust. Most new investments and development is dedicated to building new functionality and not on securing that functionality An understanding of cybersecurity is needed in order to build a foundation of knowledge that can aid in securing the networks of tomorrow
41 Q.6/17 Objectives Perform actions in accordance with Lead Study Group (LSG) responsibility with the focus on cybersecurity Work with Q.1 of SG 2 on a definition of Cybersecurity Identify and develop standards required for addressing the challenges in cybersecurity, within the scope of Q.6/17 Provide assistance to other ITU-T Study Groups in applying relevant cybersecurity Recommendations for specific security solutions. Review project-oriented security solutions for consistency. Maintain and update existing Recommendations within the scope of Q.6/17. Coordinate security activities with other ITU-T SGs, ISO/IEC JTC 1 eg. SC6, SC27 and SC37), and consortia as appropriate. Provide awareness on new security technologies related to cybersecurity
42 Q.6/17 Scope Definition of Cybersecurity Security of Telecommunications Network Infrastructure Security Knowledge and Awareness of Telecom Personnel and Users Security Requirements for Design of New Communications Protocol and Systems Communications relating to Cybersecurity Security Processes Life-cycle Processes relating to Incident and Vulnerability Security of Identity in Telecommunication Network Legal/Policy Considerations
43 Q.6/17 Current Area of Focus Work with SG 2 on the definition and requirements of cybersecurity. Collaborate with Q5,7,9,17/17 and SG 2 in order to achieve better understanding of various aspects of network security. Collaborate with IETF, OASIS, ISO/IEC JTC1, W3C, APEC-TEL and other standardization bodies on cybersecurity. Work on framework for secure network operations to address how telecommunications network providers secure their infrastructure and maintain secure operations. Work on Recommendation for standardization of vulnerability data definition. Study new cybersecurity issues How should ISPs deal with botnets, evaluating the output of appropriate bodies when available. Call for contributions for the outstanding questions identified in the revised scope.
44 Q.6/17 Draft Recommendations 1/2 1. Overview of Cybersecurity (X.cso) This Recommendation provides a definition for Cybersecurity. The Recommendation provides a taxonomy of security threats from an operator point of view. Cybersecurity vulnerabilities and threats are presented and discussed at various network layers. Various Cybersecurity technologies that are available to remedy the threats include: Routers, Firewalls, Antivirus protection, Intrusion detection systems, Intrusion protection systems, Secure computing, Audit and Monitoring. Network protection principles such as defence in depth, access and identity management with application to Cybersecurity are discussed. Risk Management strategies and techniques are discussed including the value of training and education in protecting the network. A discussion of Cybersecurity Standards, Cybersecurity implementation issues and certification are presented. 2. A vendor-neutral framework for automatic checking of the presence of vulnerabilities information update (X.vds) This Recommendation provides a framework of automatic notification on vulnerability information. The key point of the framework is that it is a vendor-neutral framework. Once users register their software, updates on the vulnerabilities and patches of the registered software will automatically be made available to the users. Upon notification, users can then apply
45 Q.6/17 Draft Recommendations 2/2 3. Guidelines for Internet Service Providers and End-users for Addressing the Risk of Spyware and Deceptive Software (X.sds) This Recommendation provides guidelines for Internet Service Providers (ISP) and end-users for addressing the risks of spyware and deceptive software. The Recommendation promotes best practices around principles of clear notices, and users consents and controls for ISP web hosting services. The Recommendation also promotes best practices to end-users on the Internet to secure their computing devices and information against the risks of spyware and deceptive software 4. Guidelines on Cybersecurity Vulnerability Life-cycle Management(X.cvlm) The Recommendation provides a framework for the provision of monitoring, discovering, responding and post-analysis of vulnerabilities. Service providers can use this Recommendation to complement their existing Information Security Management System process in the aspect of regular vulnerability assessment, vulnerability management, incident handling and incident management.
46 ITU-T SG 17 Question 7 Security Management Systems Tasks Recommendations planned Revised X.1051 Approach for revised X.1051
47 Q.7/17 Tasks Information Security Management Guidelines for telecommunications (Existing X.1051, Information security management system Requirements for telecommunications (ISMS-T) ) Maintain and revise Recommendation X.1051, Information Security Management Guidelines for telecommunications based on ISO/IEC Jointly develop a guideline of information security management with ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 27. Risk Management Methodology Study and develop a methodology of risk management for telecommunications in line with Recommendation X Produce and consent a new ITU-T Recommendation for risk management methodology. Incident Management Study and develop a handling and response procedure on security incidents for the telecommunications in line with Recommendation X Produce and consent a new ITU-T Recommendation for incident management methodology and procedures.
48 Recommendations planned in Q.7/17 (Security Management) X.1050: To be proposed X.1051: In revision process Information Security Management Guidelines for Telecommunications based on ISO/IEC X.1052: To be proposed X.1053: To be proposed (Implementation Guide for Telecoms) X.1054: To be proposed (Measurements and metrics for Telecommunications) X.1055 :In the first stage of development Risk Management Guidelines for Telecommunications X.1056: In the first stage of development Security Incident Management Guidelines for Telecommunications X.1057: To be proposed (Identity Management for Telecoms)
49 Information security management guidelines for Telecommunications (Revised X.1051) Revised X.1051 Security policy Organising information security Asset management Human resources security Physical & environmental security Information Assets for Telecom Communications & operations management Access control Information systems acquisition, development and maintenance Information security incident management Business continuity management Compliance
50 Q.7/17 Approach to develop revised Recommendation X.1051 ISMS Process CONTROL Implementation guidance Other information CONTROL Implementation guidance for Telecom Other information CONTROL Implementation requirements for Telecom ISO/IEC (2005) Revised X.1051 Existing X.1051
51 ITU-T SG 17 Question 8 Telebiometrics Objectives Study areas on Biometric Processes X.1081 and draft Recommendations under development
52 Q.8/17 Objectives 1)To define telebiometric multimodal model framework 2)To specify biometric authentication mechanism in open network 3)To provide protection procedures and countermeasures for telebiometric systems
53 Q.8/17 Study areas on Biometric Processes X.tai: Telebiometrics Authentication Infrastructure X.bip: BioAPI Interworking Protocol X.1081 X.physiol Safety conformity X.tsm: Telebiometrics System Mechanism X.tpp: Telebiometrics Protection Procedures Biometric Sensors Storage NW Acquisition (Capturing) NW Extraction NW Matching Score NW NW:Network Decision NW Application Yes/No
54 Q.8/17 Recommendations 1/4 - X.1081 The telebiometric multimodal model framework A framework for the specification of security and safety aspects of telebiometrics This Recommendation defines a telebiometric multimodal model that can be used as a framework for identifying and specifying aspects of telebiometrics, and for classifying biometric technologies used for identification (security aspects). - X.physiol Telebiometrics related to human physiology This Recommendation gives names and symbols for quantities and units concerned with emissions from the human body that can be detected by a sensor, and with effects on the human body produced by the telebiometric devices in his environments.