1 Software Service Composition in Next Generation Networking Environments vorgelegt von Diplom-Wirtschaftsingenieur Carsten Bether aus Elsterheide Von der Fakultät IV Elektrotechnik und Informatik der Technischen Universität Berlin zur Erlangung des akademischen Grades Doktor der Ingenieurwissenschaften Dr.-Ing. genehmigte Dissertation Promotionsausschuss: Vorsitzender: Prof. Dr.-Ing. Uwe Nestmann (TU-Berlin) Berichter: Prof. Dr.-Ing. habil. Sahin Albayrak (TU-Berlin) Berichter: Prof. Dr. Nicholas Bambos (Stanford University) Berichter: Prof. Dr. rer. nat. habil. Dr. h. c Alexander Schill (TU-Dresden) Tag der wissenschaftlichen Aussprache: Berlin 2008 D 83
3 Acknowledgments I would like to thank the initiators and shepherds of this project, Prof. Sahin Albayrak, Prof. Nicholas Bambos, Dr. Klaus Radermacher and Falk Henkel. Their encouragement and constant feedback made it possible to write this dissertation from multiple locations (Dresden, Berlin, and San Francisco) with the participation of professors at multiple universities (TU-Berlin, TU- Dresden, Stanford University, and Virginia Tech) and of major market players (Deutsche Telekom AG and Bea Systems Inc.). I further deeply appreciate the contributions of Prof. Alexander Schill and Prof. Athman Bouguettaya, who not only shaped my understanding of service-oriented software systems, but also helped me create a systematic way to approach, structure and formulate scientific work. I would also like to express my appreciation to Ursula Wahls, who helped me obtain a research fellowship at Deutsche Telekom AG. Franziska Vogel and Katrin Zobel-Lu supported me with long hours of corrections to improve my English grammar and writing. Sylvia Allen gave the thesis its final polishing and structure in endless discussions about specific aspects of the German and English languages. Last, but definitely not least, I would like to thank my family, my mother who persuaded me to attend a university, my father who taught me to appreciate the simple things in life and my brother, one of the strongest pillars I have.
5 Preface After a decade of rapid changes caused by digitalization, privatization and globalization, the telecommunications market is steadily continuing to diversify. Situated between customer demands and the technological revolution, today s service providers must meet many challenges. Four trends speed up the evolution of telecommunication: Customer Expectations: Increasing customer demand and changing customer expectations of telecommunication services Convergence: The independent use of telecommunication services, without regard to devices, networks and location [Mil02] IP centricity: The tendency to handle network transport via the wellknown packet-based Internet Protocol (IP) Software focus: The shift from hardware solutions to a focus on the use of software components Present providers maintain infrastructures which have grown through technological evolution into huge, heterogeneous and complex systems. Following the design strategy of one network per service, silo architectures have emerged as redundant backbones of information transmission capabilities. At the same time, the community of users expects converged services for less cost. The answer to this challenge facing telecommunication providers may exist in the formation of a mediating abstract software layer, a layer that organizes telecommunication services to be agile, flexible and quickly responsive to customer needs while still integrating legacy transport facilities. To design and implement such an approach, the software service paradigm can deliver
6 a constellation of concepts, values, perceptions, and practices shared by the software engineering community. Based on this observable complementarity between telecommunication and software services, this thesis demonstrates that software can harness agility and flexibility for the telecommunication domain by using the composition of service contracts and implementations, while remaining semantically rich and loosely coupled. Keywords: Next Generation Network, Service Oriented Architecture, Service Composition, Telecommunication Service Framework
7 Zusammenfassung Gegenwaertige Veraenderungen in der Telekommunikationsindustrie werden durch verringerte Markteintrittsbarrieren, generell verfuegbare Flatrate Zugaenge sowie frei verfuegbare, ausgereifte Softwaretechnologien vorangetrieben. Diese Veraenderungen inspirieren derzeit sowohl Markteilnehmer als auch Forscher dazu, nach neuen Moeglichkeiten zur flexibleren Bereitstellung von Telekommunikationsdiensten zu suchen. Eine im Rahmen dieser Arbeit durchgefuehrte Umfrage zeigt, dass Inadequitaet, Inflexibilitaet und zu hohe Kosten die am haeufigsten genannten Gruende fuer die Unzufriedenheit mit vorhandenen Infrastrukturen sind. Gegenwaertige Trends zeigen, dass sich Telekommunikationsinfrastrukturen mehr und mehr zu einer IP-basierten Zukunftsarchitektur entwickeln, dem Next Generation Network (NGN). Gleichzeitig zeichnen sich im Software Engineering Tendenzen ab, flexible Softwareschichten mittels einer Service-Orientierten Architektur (SOA) zu realisieren. Die vorliegende Dissertation eroertert die Komplementaritaet beider Konzepte, um die genannten Herausforderungen derzeitiger Infrastrukturen aufzuweichen und moegliche Loesungen speziell fuer die benoetigte Agilitaet und Flexibilitaet bei der Bereitstellung von Telekommunikationsdiensten aufzuzeigen.
9 Abstract Recent and continuing changes in the telecommunication market, which have been driven by lowered barriers to market, affordable flatrate broadband access, and freely available, mature software environments, have inspired researchers and industry to search for new capabilities to provide telecom services in a more flexible manner. A survey conducted in the context of this thesis found that inadequacy, inflexibility and immense costs are the the issues most mentioned in association with existing infrastructures. Current tendencies show that telecommunication is moving toward a generic IP-based architecture, the Next Generation Network (NGN). At the same time, software engineering tends to implement flexible software solutions using Service-Oriented Architectures (SOA). Bringing telecommunication and software engineering together, this dissertation uses the complementarity of these two concepts to resolve known problems and propose solutions that emphasize the flexibility and agility needed in the provision of telecommunication services.
10 Contents I Introduction 1 1 Basics Synopsis Domain Definition Problem Statements Research Questions Objectives and Contributions Objectives Contributions Solution Approach Examining Underlying Concepts Evaluating Related Work Postulates The SOTF Framework Prototype Scenario Structure of the Thesis Telecommunication Networks Synopsis
11 2.2 Definition of Telecommunication Network Evolution of Networks Network Convergence Service-Specific Networks Service-Integrated Networks Intelligent Networks Distributed, Overlay Networks Next Generation Networks Definition of NGN NGN Requirements Development of NGN Reference Model Quality of Service QoS Parameters Drivers and Requirements of the NGN Concept Summary Services Synopsis Evolution of Services Business Services Telecommunication Services Software Services Service Paradigm Entities and Principles Service-Oriented Architecture Definition of SOA SOA s Entities and Activities Implications of the SOA Architectural Style
12 3.5 Lifecycle and Scope Lifecycle Distribution Scope Summary II Composition Model and Related Work 57 4 Service Composition Synopsis Definition of Composition An Overview of Service Composition A Composition Machine Elements Behavior Conditions Behavior Model Patterns Sequence Parallelism Exclusive Decision Multiple Decision Looping Non-Functional Properties State Management Transaction Handling Security and Trust Quality Measurement Errors
13 4.7.6 Invocation Communication Summary of Composition Requirements and Implications Syntax Formalization of Service Composition Summary Research Scope and Related Work Synopsis Research Scope Domain Boundaries Composition Focus Composition Essentials Formalism-Based Approaches Software Engineering Entities Research Relevance of Formalism Approaches Research Relevance of Software Engineering Approaches Telecommunication Network Frameworks IP Multimedia Subsystem (IMS) Research Relevance Telecommunication Software Frameworks Open Mobile Alliance Open System Architecture (OSA) Research Relevance Software Frameworks Web Services Ontologies Agents Comparative Analysis Summary
14 III Service Frameworking in the NGN Services in Next Generation Networks Synopsis Terminology A Telecommunication Service Ontology Semantic Perspectives Service Cluster Semantics Community Services Content Services Communication Services Control Services Summary SOTF: A Service-Oriented Telecommunication Framework Synopsis The TOGAF Approach A Service-Oriented Telecommunication Framework (SOTF) Framework and Principles Architectural Vision General Vision Composition Vision General Principles and Requirements Business Architecture Input and Requirements Approach Result Data Architecture Input and Requirements
15 7.6.2 Approach Result Application Architecture Input and Requirements Approach Result Composition, Composeability and Matchability Degree of Composeability SOTF Service Composition Summary IV Applied Service Composition in the NGN Prototype Implementation Synopsis Prototype Specification Project Background MMCCS Software Components Prototype Scenario Scenario Introduction Scenario Assumptions Scenario Use Cases ConnectME, Service Division Overview Use Cases ConnectME, Application Division Overview Use Cases Summary
16 9 Prototype Validation and Discussion Synopsis Non-functional Service Heterogeneity State Management Transaction Handling Communication Inter-service, Circular, and Automatic Invocation Inter-service Invocation and Circularity Automatic Invocation Quality Awareness Prototype Enhancements Summary V Conclusion Contributions, Future Research and Outlook Synopsis Answers to Research Questions Thesis Contributions Suggestions for Future Research Outlook VI Appendices 263 A A. Appendix of Theoretical Background 265 A.1 BNF Notation B B. Appendix of SOTF Framework Conceptualization 267 B.1 Specification of Application Architecture Components
17 C C. Appendix of Prototype Implementation 271 C.1 Definition of NGN Service Types Glossary 275 Bibliography 300
18 List of Figures 1.1 User Expectations of Telecommunication Services [ussg06] Research Approach of the Thesis Structure of the Thesis Network Evolution Milestones IN Conceptual model Reference Model of NGN Business Service Entities and Activities Telecommunication Service Entities and Activities Software Service Entities and Activities SOA Service Lifecycle SOA Distribution Scopes Orchestration and Composition A Composition Machine Composition Behavior Structure of Sequence Composition Pattern Structure of Parallel Composition Pattern Structure of Exclusive Decision Composition Pattern Structure of Parallel Composition Pattern
19 4.8 Structure of Loop Composition Pattern Syntax Formalization of Service Composition Syntax Formalization of a Composition Member Service Summary of Notation for Composition Behavior Research Scope Basic Internet Protocol (IP) Stack IP Multimedia Subsystem (IMS) Open Mobile Alliance Service Environment A Telecommunication Service Ontology Semantic Specification of a Service Cluster Semantic Specification of the Community Service Cluster Semantic Specification of the Content Service Cluster Semantic Specification of the Communication Service Cluster Semantic Specification of the Control Service Cluster NGN Service Cluster: Cohesion and Clauses TOGAF Architecture Development Cycle (ADM) SOTF: Architectural Vision SOTF: Principles and Requirements SOTF Business Architecture, Services, Clusters and Operations SOTF Data Architecture, Basic Service Data Entities SOTF Data Architecture, Service Data Entities SOTF Technology Architecture, Software Components Components of the MMCCS architecture Scenario Use Cases Sequence Diagram of Lookup Service Use Case Sequence Diagram of Invoke Service Use Case
20 9.1 Quality of Service Lookup by Service Specification Type Quality of Service Invocation by Service Specification Type Quality of Service Processing by Service Specification Type.. 248
22 List of Tables 2.1 Evolution of Networks Drivers and Requirements of the NGN Concept Evolution of the Software Engineering Paradigm Design Principles and Implications of the SOA Architectural Style Composition Environment Requirements and Issues Efficient Use of Service Composition in Telecom Infrastructures Comparative Analysis of Related Work Quality Model of Software Services Community Cluster Business Operations Content Cluster Business Operations Communication Cluster Business Operations Control Cluster Business Operations Composition Cluster Business Operations System Cluster Business Operations SOTF Component Specification: Design and Execution SOTF Component Specification: Control and Persistence
24 Part I Introduction
26 Chapter 1 Basics Mozart, you are not the only composer... Count von Strack, Amadeus  1.1 Synopsis This chapter describes the structure of the thesis in detail. It broadly defines the telecommunication domain, exposes questions to be researched, and proposes a potential solution to the crippling rigidity of current telecommunication infrastructures. The chapter closes with a structural overview of the thesis. 1.2 Domain Definition We can observe three primary interrelated perspectives of telecommunication: the economic, the operational, and the technical.
27 4 Chapter 1, Basics Economic Perspective The telecommunication domain has undergone rapid changes over the last few years. Economically, telecommunication now earns three percent of the world s revenue, and the market volume is increasing. The market fluctuates constantly. Players in the market face stiff competition. Identifiable roles of those players, in reference to their service offerings in the new, evolving telecommunication market, are listed below. The Sales Provider connects services to the user but does not have an infrastructure. 1 The Service Provider connects services to the user using its own infrastructure. The Network Provider offers pure network transport capacities. Depending on their strategy, providers can take on one or more roles. For example, Deutsche Telekom AG functions as a network, service and sales provider, while Ebay/Skype Inc. acts as both service provider and sales provider. The current market situation requires providers to engage in a continuous search for new business models and services while maintaining existing services. Users of telecom services have various expectations which must be satisfied by telecom providers: [ussg06] Individuality: desire to stand apart, status Convenience: simplicity, ease of use, accessibility Information: desire to stay informed, desire to inform Control: security, privacy, safety Belonging: desire to belong to a group, peer groups, communities Productivity: speed, time efficiency, general efficiency experienced while communicating 1 The infrastructure is the equipment a provider maintains to operate its network. A network is the combination of links and nodes that enable the transmission of information from one part of the network to another.
28 1.2 Domain Definition 5 Pleasure: escapism, leisure, infotainment, fun Independence: self-determination Figure 1.1 demonstrates how user expectations changed over time. Information Increasing information density Control Complexity of threats Convenience Goals of technology development Productivity Service complexity Individuality Complexity of product world Belonging Topic sharing Pleasure Everyday life complexity Independence Complexity of mobility Complexity Pure Information Providing Modern Risk Society Substitution Communication Infrastructure Mass Consumption Forming Social Relations Increasing Role of Pleasure Mobility Screening And Personalization Deepening Loss Of Security Multi Optionality Communication Efficiency Mass Customization Communication Management Differentiation Through Entertainment Flexibility Contextualisation Of Information Security Providing Context Adaptivity Life Assistance Identity Management Social Enabling Pleasure On Demand Convergence Time < 1990 < 2005 > 2005 Figure 1.1: User Expectations of Telecommunication Services [ussg06] Everybody, anytime and everywhere [Tec99] is the motto of today s telecom services. The proliferation of provider roles and user expectations raises interesting operational and technological challenges for telecom service providers.
29 6 Chapter 1, Basics Operational Perspective Apart from the economic aspects of the telecom domain, a telecommunication network must be operated. Typical operational challenges are customer provisioning and service activation, Quality of Service (QoS) through Service Level Agreements (SLA) and security. [Bag04] In general, these operations have been executed through hardware and software architectures that are home-grown, proprietary and rigid. Providers have both maintained and upgraded huge infrastructures at the same time. In addition, telecommunication companies are burdened with heterogeneous environments which stand in the way of efficient operation. To succeed in the current economic environment, telecom providers need to establish agility: their systems must be able to adapt new services quickly, and most importantly, without sacrificing reliability. In place of the current pattern of large, rigid infrastructures, telecom systems should operate as a collection of interconnected functions. There is a need for infrastructure transparency, which would give providers the freedom to decide whether to build new functions or update existing ones, and to decide which of these functions are part of their business core competencies, providing opportunities for them to distinguish themselves from competitors, and which can be effectively outsourced. [NB05] Technical Perspective A third aspect of telecommunications is technology management the management of a network s technical components and their realization and interconnection. With the rapid changes in technology and in the marketplace, providers must constantly consider the possibilities of new tools and new uses for tools. User devices (PCs, mobile phones, PDAs, TVs), networks (GPRS, UMTS, CDMA), and software frameworks (Java EE,.NET) are only a few current examples of technologies that can be evaluated and possibly integrated. However, a decision to use a technology requires a huge investment and cannot be rolled back without additional costs. Telecommunication services must be designed, implemented, controlled and delivered while remaining reliable, robust and secure. [Bag04] Providers must respond quickly to developing business situations and minimize costs through reduction of time to market. The technological infrastructure should reflect and implement that requirement as well.
30 1.2 Domain Definition 7 In responding to the issues outlined above, it is crucial to leverage agility throughout the telecom organization. Agility appears as a critical challenge in the current state of telecom technology, where huge legacy landscapes dominate. The ideal scenario would be a service architecture that can support multiple types of services and management applications over multiple types of transport. There is currently no standardized process to design and implement the agile, flexible architectures that the emerging telecommunication industry requires. In general, two approaches are being used: the current telecommunication approach, driven by telecom standardization organizations, and the software engineering approach, driven by software framework distributors and software vendors. Unfortunately, the approaches are not in sync, and as a consequence, a broad and heterogeneous field of architectures, standards, and implementation methods exist. This technological heterogeneity presents major obstacles not only to efficient operation but also to the development of larger, yet still efficient, telecom networks. Definition of Telecommunication Telecommunication 2 is the electronic transmission of information over significant distances. [Uni] The word Telecommunication is a synthesis of the two elements tele and communication. Communication is an exchange of information. The prefix tele, adding the aspect of long distance transmission, raises a technological challenge. Telecommunication serves as a business market, encompasses some general roles and interactions, and has a considerable impact on the development of technology. Definition of Telecom Services The manifestation of telecommunication in the marketplace is a telecommunication (telecom) service. A telecom service is a packaged set of capabilities that is perceived by a human user when interacting with a telecommunications network or a service provider and for which separate billing can be arranged. [Con97] In this thesis the term service will cover both business and technical aspects, further illustrated in Chapter 3. Chapter 6 gives an elaborated overview of services in telecommunication networks. 2 The abbreviation telecom is used interchangeably with telecommunication.
31 8 Chapter 1, Basics 1.3 Problem Statements In general, this thesis is a response to the existing mismatch, indicated by the challenges discussed in the previous section, of the approaches of IP-based telecommunication networks and software engineering. Problem Statement for the Telecommunication Domain The telecommunication domain is huge, complex and (so far) semantically undefined. There is no common understanding of how to structure, organize and share the large amount of knowledge about services that exists in the domain. There is, further, no clarity as to which services must be provided in a telecommunication infrastructure and which are optional. Considering the current tendency to implement such services using software, new ways must be found to model and define services in a flexible manner, so that the business, data and technology perspectives can transform one another, and so that participating stakeholders have no need to be aware of which services are provided using which software components. There is an unfilled need for a rigorous analysis of existing scientific and industry work with the aim of building an integrated, implementable model of interworking services. There is, in addition, a need for a unified methodology to transform such a model into computable software artifacts that are extensible and flexible to use. Problem Statement for the Software Service Paradigm Relatively few researchers have studied the potential of an SOA approach within an NGN infrastructure. Existing discussions are held in a limited context, driven either by technology (such as Web Services or Java EE) or by software components (such as runtime environment, service contract, or message bus). Framework approaches, which would include domain specifics as a bridge between building blocks and encompassing environments, are missing. In particular, the identification and semantic clustering of telecom services have yet to be elaborated. Semantic descriptions that would provide standardized sets of services have not been established. The industry approach has been the introduction of Service Delivery Platforms (SDP), which unfortunately do not provide either an architecture or a service design methodology with standardized interfaces.
32 1.4 Research Questions 9 Problem Statement for Service Composition Composition solutions, following the service paradigm principles, are either algebraically formulated (as in Finite State Approach and π-calculus) or graphically modeled (as in Colored Petri Nets and Hierarchical Task Network (HTN) Planning) as standalone domain-independent systems. However, service composition, especially in the field of telecommunication, is particularly challenging because telecom services are coarse-grained, real-time, and subject to frequent changes while requiring the maintenance of high reliability. [CKMRM03] The seamless integration of synchronous and asynchronous services in a composition scenario is in a very early stage. [Sch05] Emerging technologies such as the Web Service framework seem to fit the basic telecom business interface, but they are not designed for composition in a high-performance real-time telecommunication scenario. There is an unrealized potential for the discussion and design of composition solutions within the requirements of the telecom domain. 1.4 Research Questions The main goal of this thesis is to deliver a satisfactory answer to the question, How can the software service paradigm supplement the emerging IP-based telecommunication infrastructures to improve agility through reuse? In that context, the following research questions will be addressed: Conceptual Complementarity of Telecommunication Networks and the Software Service Paradigm In a discussion of software services in a telecommunication network, which definition context, entities and activities should be reflected? What should a software service lifecycle in a telecom network look like? What are the specifics of services in the telecom domain? What role does composition play in the service lifecycle?
Future Internet Roadmap Deliverable 1.1 Service Web 3.0 Public Roadmap Authors: Elena Simperl (UIBK) Ioan Toma (UIBK) John Domingue (OU) Graham Hench (STI) Dave Lambert (OU) Lyndon J B Nixon (STI) Emilia
INTERNATIONAL TELECOMMUNICATION UNION ITU-T Y.2001 TELECOMMUNICATION STANDARDIZATION SECTOR OF ITU (12/2004) SERIES Y: GLOBAL INFORMATION INFRASTRUCTURE, INTERNET PROTOCOL ASPECTS AND NEXT-GENERATION NETWORKS
SOFTWARE ENGINEERING Key Enabler for Innovation NESSI White Paper Networked European Software and Services Initiative July 2014 Executive Summary Economy and industry is experiencing a transformation towards
Chapter 1 Introduction to SOA with Web Services Complexity is a fact of life in information technology (IT). Dealing with the complexity while building new applications, replacing existing applications,
PROJECT FINAL REPORT Grant Agreement number: 212117 Project acronym: FUTUREFARM Project title: FUTUREFARM-Integration of Farm Management Information Systems to support real-time management decisions and
econstor www.econstor.eu Der Open-Access-Publikationsserver der ZBW Leibniz-Informationszentrum Wirtschaft The Open Access Publication Server of the ZBW Leibniz Information Centre for Economics Van Ooteghem,
Institut fur Architektur von Anwendungssystemen Universität Stuttgart Universitätsstraße 38 70569 Stuttgart Diplomarbeit Nr. 2810 Extension of a SCA Editor and Deployment-Strategies for Software as a Service
Business Models for Mobile Broadband Media Services Case Study Indonesia Telecom Market LAILI AIDI TRITA-ICT-EX-2012:305 Degree project in Communication Systems Second level, 30.0 HEC Stockholm, Sweden
Industrialized and Ready for Digital Transformation? Why Banks Lack the Agility to Compete synpulse 3 4 synpulse Foreword synpulse 5 Digital transformation of banking is powered by the remarkable development
The VLDB Journal DOI 10.1007/s00778-006-0020-3 REGULAR PAPER Deploying and managing Web services: issues, solutions, and directions Qi Yu Xumin Liu Athman Bouguettaya Brahim Medjahed Received: 12 August
Cooperative Device Cloud - Provisioning Embedded Devices in Ubiquitous Environments vorgelegt von Dipl.-Inf. Andreas Kliem geb. in Berlin Von der Fakultät IV - Elektrotechnik und Informatik der Technischen
FRAUNHOFER RESEARCH INSTITUTION AISEC CLOUD COMPUTING SECURITY PROTECTION GOALS.TAXONOMY.MARKET REVIEW. DR. WERNER STREITBERGER, ANGELIKA RUPPEL 02/2010 Parkring 4 D-85748 Garching b. München Tel.: +49
1 Integrating Conventional ERP System with Cloud Services From the Perspective of Cloud Service Type Shi Jia Department of Computer and Systems Sciences Degree subject (EMIS) Degree project at the master
Masaryk University Faculty of Informatics Master Thesis Database management as a cloud based service for small and medium organizations Dime Dimovski Brno, 2013 2 Statement I declare that I have worked
IDENTITY MANAGEMENT DEFINED How to position enterprises into the Identity Management framework Informatics & Economics Faculty of Economics Erasmus University Rotterdam Monday, 19 December 2005 Drs. (Master)
JAVA-BASED INTELLIGENT NETWORK MONITORING by Haifeng Xi Thesis submitted to the Faculty of the Graduate School of the University of Maryland at College Park in partial fulfillment of the requirements for
R din rou Cloud Service Analysis Choosing between an on-premise resource and a cloud computing service Master of Science Thesis in the Master Degree Programme, Software Engineering and Technology JONAS
Semantic Mediation between Loosely Coupled Information Models in Service-Oriented Architectures vorgelegt von Diplom-Informatiker Nils Barnickel aus Berlin Von der Fakultät IV Elektrotechnik und Informatik
Digital Identity Management A Critical Link to Service Success A Public Network Perspective A Telecompetition Group Market Study Report January, 2007 Table of Contents 1 Executive Summary...1 2 Introduction...3
Convergence of Social, Mobile and Cloud: 7 Steps to Ensure Success June, 2013 Contents Executive Overview...4 Business Innovation & Transformation...5 Roadmap for Social, Mobile and Cloud Solutions...7
Cloud Based Collaboration Platform for Transport & Logistics Business Networks Prof. Dr. Rod Franklin, Managing Director, Executive Education and Adjunct Professor of Logistics, The Kuehne Logistics University,
NESSI White Paper, December 2012 Big Data A New World of Opportunities Contents 1. Executive Summary... 3 2. Introduction... 4 2.1. Political context... 4 2.2. Research and Big Data... 5 2.3. Purpose of
Cloud Computing Uncovered: A Research Landscape MOHAMMAD HAMDAQA AND LADAN TAHVILDARI Software Technologies Applied Research (STAR) Group, University of Waterloo, Waterloo, Ontario, Canada Abstract The
Chapter 2 A Context for the Study: Using the Literature to Develop a Preliminary Conceptual Model 2.1. Introduction Chapter 1 introduced the research study. This chapter locates Z39.50 development in the
Mobile Identity Management: An Enacted View George Roussos, Don Peterson, and Uma Patel Abstract. Growth of mobile business requires the ability to provide context aware services when and where needed,
Arbeitsberichte der Hochschule für Wirtschaft FHNW Nr. 28 Enterprise Architectures for Cloud Computing Laura Aureli, Arianna Pierfranceschi, Holger Wache ISSN Nr. 1662-3266 (Print) Nr. 1662-3274 (Online)