1 THE RESOURCE FOR BANkRUPTCY, COLLECTION AND DEBT RECOVERY Vol. 26 Issue No. 2 March/April 2011 Disentitlement of the Debtor from Judicial Proceedings DEFIANT TO THE END IN THIS ISSUE Partnering Effectively With Third-Party Collection Agencies Help decrease collection costs and increase your success rate by working together What You Need To know About Collecting Accounts In Canada
2 You can expect results when you talk to leaders debt 33 82% 74% 89% readers are are their company s key key decision makers: are are involved in the the purchasing process and and make make the the final final purchasing decisions. are are partner/owner/president/chair/ceos of of Debt Debt 3 3 readers have have recommended, specified or or approved the the purchase of of products and and services, including: Computer/office software, e.g. e.g. collection, bankruptcy, organizational Law Law office office automation services Legal Legal support services, e.g. e.g. skip skip tracers, auctioneers, process server services Office Office supplies and and equipment Online information services Source: Source: Debt Debt 3 3 Independent Reader Reader Survey Survey For For more more information on on how how your your company can can target target this this exclusive audience, contact: Buz Buz Buzogany Buzogany Associates Phone: (828) (828) Cell: Cell: (828) (828)
4 contents Vol. 26 Issue No. 2 March/April 2011 Debt3 (ISSN ) is published bi-monthly by the Commercial Law League of America, 205 N. Michigan Ave., Suite 2212; Chicago, IL 60601; (312) POSTMASTER: Send address changes to Debt3, 205 N. Michigan Ave., Suite 2212, Chicago, IL Periodicals postage paid at Chicago, Illinois and additional mailing office. Copyright 2011 by the Commercial Law League of America. Permission to reprint materials in Debt3 may be granted on written request to the editor at the Commercial Law League offices. The views and conclusions expressed in articles are those of the authors and are not necessarily those of the Editorial Board or of the Commercial Law League of America, nor should any advertisement be considered an endorsement of the product or service involved. The price of an annual subscription to members of the Commercial Law League of America ($18.00) is included in their dues. Annual subscription to others is $65.00 per year in the U.S. and Canada, $70.00 elsewhere. Single copy price is $ Write the Commercial Law League of America, 205 N. Michigan Ave., Suite 2212; Chicago, IL 60601; (312) Features: 8 Disentitlement Of The Debtor From Judicial Proceedings: Defiant To The End Encouraging payment through disentitlement. By David Cook, Cook Collections Attorneys, PLC 1 5 Is Your Collection Agency Collecting Accounts In Canada? Find out if registering in Canada makes sense for your organization. By Richard Payne of Morrison and Payne Barristers and Solicitors 1 8 Do Your Clients Partner Effectively With Third- Party Collection Agencies? Help decrease collection costs by working together. By Robert S. Shultz, partner, Quote to Cash Solutions (Q2C) LLC ABC Specialist 21Appointed Bankruptcy Judge Creditors Rights Specialist Ronald H. Sargis was appointed bankruptcy judge to the United States Bankruptcy Court for the Eastern District of California in Sacramento. By Robert L. Pollak, Esq. of Glassberg, Pollak and Associates Industry information: 6 Legal News Round-Up Find out the latest legislative news from Washington! Tales From 25 The Front This issue, Timothy Wan shares a tale of tuition, repeated requests for adjournment and a case that extended for more than 17 months. LEAGUE NEWS: 5 The President s Page Read CLLA President Gary Weiner s farewell column! 27 Viewpoint Social networking can help you connect with acquaintances you already know but when it comes to making new contacts, there s no replacement for meeting face-to-face. 28 CLLA Flashback Find out the background on the famed CLLA gavel. Member news: 23 Newly Admitted Members Find out who joined the CLLA in January and February! 24 Member News The latest news from CLLA members around the globe
5 Membership Application Applicants Must Complete Areas A-D. Please Type or Print Clearly. Preferred mailing address Office Home A Date of Birth / / Name (This membership is individually based. No firm/corporate memberships.) M D YR Home Address (CLLA will not publish unless indicated) City/State/Zip Code (5 + 4) Firm/Company/School Name Firm/Company/School Address City/State/Zip Code (5 + 4) Work Phone Fax Home/ Mobile Phone Website (URL) Referred By: (CLLA Member) City/State/Zip Code Bar Jurisdiction(s) Bar Number(s) Date(s) Law School Name City/State Graduation Date Please indicate your main practice area (s) here Indicate the size of your firm/company (please check number of employees ): Does majority of your practice focus on commercial litigation? Yes No American Board of Certification Yes I am ABC certified. B Membership (please choose type) C Dues Please indicate your profession: Lawyer $480 Commercial Collection Agency Representative $480 Debt Buyer $480 Law List Publisher $480 Paralegal, Collector, Office Administrator in a firm $480 Turnaround Manager $480 Vendor $480 OTHER $480 If you do not see a category that fits your desired membership profile, please select OTHER and enter category. Subject to approval by CLLA Officers. I. Practice Section Membership (Please indicate) (1 section complimentary, each additional for $50) Bankruptcy Section Creditors Rights Section ***Please include additional section payment into total amount, if selected. SPECIAL STATUS Eligibility & Rate Dues Special Emerging Professional Rate $130 ONLY APPLIES TO U.S., Canadian and International Applicants under 31 years of age or admitted to bar under 6 years (4 year limit) Law Professor/Teacher $50 Editor, Legal Periodical $50 Law Clerk $50 Law Student $25 Judge U.S.Trustee (not private trustee) Waived Waived Additional Contributions (OPTIONAL) Fund for Public Education 501c(3) $30 Items included in membership fee: *National Membership *Regional Membership * One Section Membership *Subscriptions to Debt3 Magazine & *The DePaul Business & Commercial Law Journal *Young Members Section Membership (if eligible) D Enclosed check for $ (Please make all checks/ money orders payable in U.S. dollars and drawn on a U.S. bank to: Commercial Law League of America ) I authorize you to charge $ to my: VISA MasterCard AMEX Signature of Applicant Date Account Number Expiration All applicants must remit one full year s dues with application based on eligibility status. Dues are applied as of and prorated to the date application is received. Your name will be published as an applicant for membership the date it is received and the period for objections to be filed, extends to the end of the calendar month following the date of publication. If no objection is received by that time, you will become a full member of the League and will be sent your New Member Information Packet and online access information. Send first year s dues and completed application to: Commercial Law League of America, 205 N. Michigan Avenue, Suite 2212, Chicago, IL Phone: (312) Fax: (312) Website:
6 about clla Vol. 26 Issue No. 2 March/April 2011 meeting notices Strategic Planning & Leadership Conference Washington D.C. Aug. 5-7, 2011 Western Region Meeting Universal City, Calif. Sept. 16, 2011 CLLA Annual Breakfast & Education Program at the National Conference of Bankruptcy Tampa, Fla. Oct. 13, st Annual New York Meeting New York Nov , nd Annual New York Meeting New York Nov. 8-11, 2012 officers and board of governors President Gary Weiner, Springfield, Mass. President-Elect James Beau Hays, Atlanta, Ga. Treasurer Murray S. Lubitz, White Plains, N.Y. Recording Secretary Mark J. Bressler, Edison, N.J. Immediate Past President Ernest Rick Thomas III, Cincinnati, Ohio Board Members Robert A. Bernstein, Charleston, S.C. Alan I. Nahmias, Woodland Hills, Calif. Ivan Jac Reich, Fort Lauderdale, Fla. Jeffrey Schatzman, Miami, Fla. Joseph Terkell, New City, N.Y. Frederic I. Weinberg, Conshohocken, Penn. Warren Pinchuck, Boca Raton, Fla. Marc Hirschel, Lakeville, Conn. Deborah Kanner Ebner, Chicago, Ill. Mark J. Sheriff, Columbus, Ohio Bruce Godwin, Boca Raton, Fla. David Mendelson, Memphis, Tenn. Executive Vice President Oliver P. Yandle editorial staff Board of Associate Editors David A. Rubin, chair, Toronto, Ontario Nancy B. Hamilton, vice chair, Cleveland, Ohio Lawrence C. Brown, vice chair, Buffalo, N.Y. Neil S. Abbott, Toronto, Ontario Richard G. Baumann, Los Angeles, Calif. John M. Birk, law list publisher representative, Gainesville, Fla. David Cook. San Francisco, Calif. Nicholas Krawec, Pittsburgh, Penn. Brenda A. Majewski, Creditors' Rights Section representative, Milwaukee, Wis. Lee M. Mendelson, Van Nuys, Calif. Louis S. Robin, Longmeadow, Mass. Robert Schatzman, Miami, Fla. Editor Oliver P. Yandle Design/Publication Consultants Newcomb Solutions Publishing/Marketing Coordinator Erin Brereton Editing Director Joshua Greene Contributing Editors David Franklin, Montreal, PQ Steven A. Frieze, London, England Harry Greenfield, Cleveland, Ohio Nicholas Krawec, Pittsburgh, Penn. Joseph A. Marino, Clifton, N.J. Timothy Wan, Commack, N.Y. Young Members Representative CLLA Core Purpose: To be the leader in providing legal, educational and professional services to the business and credit communities. CLLA Core Values: We provide service and value through competence, ethics and professionalism. We foster relationships. We create business and leadership opportunities. We provide high quality education. We are the leader in our industry. League members and other readers are invited to submit previously unpublished articles on commercial practice or topics relating to the general practice of law. Articles should be submitted electronically via . The preferred format is Microsoft Word or plain text. WordPerfect is accepted but not preferred. All articles will be reviewed. Send articles to Manuscripts can be sent to Attn: Editor, Debt3 Magazine c/o Commercial Law League of America; 205 N. Michigan Ave., Suite 2212; Chicago, IL CLLA can be reached at or toll free at
7 president s page President, Commercial Law League of America moving forward with our vision This is my last president s column, and while I can say I find it hard to believe a year has gone by so quickly, in reality, I can say I wish I had accomplished more in my short term. When I started, the League had gone through a consolidation of finances, which was aimed at providing more clarity in how we as an organization operate. We have been able to accomplish that feat and clearly now see how our expenses effect the bottom line throughout our regions and not limit those opportunities to only our organization. We have made progress with our own internal disputes, and while we clearly did not solve all of the issues within our family, I would like to think we are moving in the same direction now. The future for the CLLA, in my opinion, is bright, and as I have said in previous columns, I am much more of a half-full than half-empty type of person. I believe the path that we have begun through the strategic plan in expanding our market place to include practice groups made up of attorneys whose areas of expertise are outside commercial collections and bankruptcy has opened up area of growth which will benefit all of our existing members and our new members, as well. Organizations that fail to grow and adapt to the changes in the marketplace will be left behind. As many of you know, senior to me in terms of length in this organization, we have not adapted well in the past, and as a result, we were left behind on some major changes in our industry as other sister organizations have thrived in membership growth. We are truly unique, which I have seen as I have worked my way through other conferences and organizations, and the strength that we have based on friendship, business and education is something that others may try to follow, but they do not have our foundation. We must make sure that our foundation stays strong as we expand our membership. I am truly excited about the growth in the practice group area, and the efforts of our membership and staff have succeeded in creating new opportunities in the League for complex litigators and construction attorneys. We hope to expand programs for transactional attorneys and landlord/tenant practitioners, as well. Now as we go down this path, we expect this to provide opportunities for our regions to put on half-day or one-day educational programs aimed at a specific practice group. The goal here will be to allow us to bring the CLLA to your neighborhood, and the program will be deemed a success by introducing the CLLA to new members and providing both educational and networking opportunities close to your own home. While these oneday programs will be open to the League membership, we do not envision these to compete with our fall and spring conferences. In my year as president, we will have put on programs in all five regions for the first time in more than five years, and I hope that we will continue with these programs. CLLA means business and this is a way for us to provide education and networking opportunities throughout our regions and not limit those opportunities to only our fall and spring conferences. As part of the strategic plan (Vision for 2015), we have reviewed the fall and spring conferences and recognize that these conferences have to be revamped and analyzed from a membership and cost basis. Are we providing what our members want? Is it time to investigate other locations? Making changes can be hard sometimes, but failing to react to the need to make changes can be far worse. Additionally, it is quite clear that we need to provide a proper mechanism to implement the goals of the strategic plan. I believe that the Board of Governors has to become the driving force in insuring that the plan becomes a reality and to insure accountability for the plan. We are very fortunate in that we have a strong League office, which is supported by TSO. In this past year, I have had the pleasure to work with Oliver Yandle, the League s executive vice president, along with Meghan Flesch, our education director, and Marisa Pochter, our director of membership and administration. We have all had to go through some learning curves, but I cannot emphasize enough their dedication to see the CLLA succeed. They are professionals who know how we can succeed, and they know they need the members support and efforts to see us move forward. I have also worked very closely with Immediate Past President Rick Thomas and President-Elect Beau Hays, and their efforts and dedication to this League are immense. I greatly appreciate their guidance and support over the last year. I know one thing that the League is in great hands moving forward, as I expect great things from Beau over the next year. I thank you all for giving the me privilege of serving as president of this great organization, and I hope that my contribution over the last year continues us on the course to success as we move forward in the vision for Gary Weiner is managing shareholder at Weiner & Lange P.C. in Springfield, Mass. After receiving his B.S. from Syracuse University and his J.D. from Suffolk University Law School, Weiner was admitted to the bar in Massachusetts in He has served as CLLA recording secretary, Board of Governors attorney-atlarge, New England Region chair and Young Members Section board representative and chair. Weiner s affiliations include the American Bankruptcy Institute, American Bar Association and the National Association of Bankruptcy Trustees. He also is a past chair of the Hampden County Bar Association New Members Section and is the former president of the Longmeadow Softball Association. 5
8 legal news round-up Keep Current With Industry-Related News From Around The U.S. COURTESY Of OUR WASHINGTON HOT NEWS CORRESPONDENT DAVID GOCH 6Debt3 March/April 2011 DEBT COLLECTION RANkS 2ND ON FTC COMPLAINT LIST For the 11th consecutive year, the leading consumer complaint category in 2010 was identity theft, garnering 19 percent a total of 250,854 of the complaints received, according to a recently released FTC report. Debt collection was the second consumer complaint category, accounting for 11 percent of complaints. COURT SAYS ABA SUIT QUESTIONINg FTC RED FLAgS RULE ISN T VIABLE In early March, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit ruled (ABA v. FTC D.C. Cir., No /4/11) that the American Bar Association s challenge to the scope of the FTC s red flags rule had been rendered moot by the recent legislative fix. The ABA and FTC disagreed over whether the FTC s rule, requiring creditors to implement identity theft prevention programs, could be applied to attorneys. Based on the Red Flag Program Clarification Act (Pub. L. No ), the court said that the FTC s previous assertion that the rule s definition of creditor includes all entities including law firms and health care providers that regularly permit deferred payments for goods or services is no longer viable. The ABA complaint was remanded to the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia with instructions to have it dismissed. SENATE PASSES 1099 REPORTINg OBLIgATIONS REPEAL The Senate passed a repeal of the new IRS Form 1099 information reporting requirements as part of S. 223, legislation reauthorizing federal aviation programs, in late February. Lawmakers had adopted the repeal of the Form 1099 rules, enacted under the health care reform law, as an amendment to the FAA bill. The Senate voted 87-8 to pass the underlying Federal Aviation Administration Reauthorization measure. House Ways and Means Committee Chairman Camp (R-Mich.), following the markup of two standalone 1099 repeal bills (H.R. 4, H.R. 705), said he hopes to proceed via a conference between the two chambers. As of press time, the House planned to begin the debate about repealing the 1099 rules as early in late February/early March. BANkRUPTCY FILINgS FOR 2010 REACH 5-YEAR HIgH Bankruptcy filings for the 2010 calendar year rose 8 percent to a 5-year high, according to recently released Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts statistics. A total of 1,593,081 bankruptcy filings occurred in 2010; in 2009, 1,473,675 bankruptcies were filed. In 2010, business filings totaled 56,282 a 7 percent decrease from 2009 s 60,837 filings. Non-business bankruptcy filings totaled 1,536,799 in 2010, a 9 percent increase from 2009 s 1,412,838 filings. Chapter 7 filings totaled 1,139,601 in 2010, increasing 8 percent from 2009 s 1,050,832. Chapter 11 filings totaled 13,713 in 2010, a 10 percent decrease from 2009 s 15,189 filings, and Chapter 13 filings totaled 438,913 in 2010, an 8 percent increase from 2009 s 406,962. NEW YORk FED: BAPCPA LED TO FORECLOSURE INCREASE The Bankruptcy Abuse Prevention and Consumer Protection Act (Pub. L. No ), enacted in 2005, has contributed to an increase in subprime mortgage foreclosures, according to a recently released Federal Reserve Bank of New York report. The report found that the act helped the number of foreclosures grow because it disallows some borrowers from discharging unsecured debt, thus restricting cash flow that could be used to meet mortgage obligations. The report also concluded that BAPCPA s means test prohibits some relatively better-off households that are facing financial duress from filing for Chapter 7 protection which makes it relatively easier to discharge some unsecured debts, providing homeowners with more cash to pay their mortgage and other secured debts. Many instead file for Chapter 13 relief. REED CASE granted REHEARINg EN BANC The Fifth Circuit agreed to grant an en banc rehearing in Reed v. City of Arlington in late February. On behalf of the CLLA, the law firm of Barron Newburger & Sinsley filed an amicus curiae requesting such a rehearing. This case held that judicial estoppel could be applied against the trustee based on the debtor s failure to disclose an asset. The oral argument will be the week of May 23.
9 INTRODUCING COLLECTMAX VERSION 5 NEW Home Screen Design NEW Debtor and Client Screens NEW Data Tracking and Export Capabilities NEW Enhanced Litigation Management NEW Scanning and Reporting Options NEW Accounting Spreadsheets NEW Quick Links to Account Details CollectMax, the collections software preferred by hundreds of law firms nationwide, is now even better. To learn more, go to collectmax.com or call CLLA : Chicago, IL : April 12 17, 2011 NARCA : Chicago, IL : May 12 14,
10 Disentitlement of the Debtor from Judicial Proceedings DEFIANT TO THE END BY DAVID COOK COOK COLLECTIONS ATTORNEYS, PLC Encouraging Payment through Disentitlement 8Debt3 March/April 2011
11 Ray Charles taught us disentitlement: Hit the road, Jack, and don t you come back no more, no more, no more, no more. 1 Disentitlement offers the nuclear 2 remedy to compel payment, if possible, from the recalcitrant debtor and, like Jack in Ray Charles wonderful song, hits the road. This article is a primer on civil disentitlement. Imagine the following scenario: The plaintiff wins a diffi cult case against the defendant 3 (now the debtor), who refuses to pay the judgment. The debtor fi les an appeal but declines to post a bond. 4 The plaintiff freely enforces the judgment but lacks quality information that identifies worthwhile assets subject to enforcement. State law remedies enable the plaintiff to compel the defendant to make broad asset disclosures. 5 These remedies consist of a faceto-face examination labeled a debtor s examination under oath and transcribed by a court reporter. 6 These courtroom sessions feature the hyper-aggressive enforcement attorney extracting information from the insolent, if not arrogant, debtor. 7 ( What? You do not remember your bank account. You got three seconds before I haul you in front of a judge and cite you for contempt. Five days in the clink 8 for every question that you dodge. Maybe you might cool your heels in the county cooler until you tell me. Shall I hit the reset button and we start again? ) Tragically, amnesia afflicts most judgment debtors. Might this tactic work? Can the plaintiff expect the debtor to disclose the hidden assets or even answer written discovery? A fantasy if the plaintiff believes that the debtor will hand over the keys to the kingdom. This remedy is a dud. Maybe. Whether a face to face chest bumping or through written discovery, the debtor is the sphinx. Hoarding assets that are hidden or fraudulently conveyed, the debtor hides from the process server 11 or sheriff or refuses to answer the answer the written discovery. Expect dead silence. THE END game OF THE DISCOVERY DEFAULT Confronting the debtor s recalcitrance and the anticipated discovery default, the plaintiff moves the court for a bench warrant, an order compelling the debtor to appear in court or face incarceration in the county jail. If discovery consisted of interrogatory and a document request, the creditor moves for an order compelling the written discovery and of course monetary sanctions. As chaotic and fruitless a debtor s examination might be, the debtor appears in court and provides some information, even his or name. 9 At a minimum, the debtor is alive and well, or at least present in the flesh. If the debtor is inaccessible, the creditor has other options. For example, if the debtor is offshore or evasive rending a personal appearance unlikely, the plaintiff can serve postjudgment interrogatories and a document request. 10 Without surprise, the defendant refuses to comply with any order. The defendant dodges the sheriff serving the bench warrant or absconds from the jurisdiction, or ignores the order compelling responses to the written discovery. Discovery is DNR. 12 In the face of this obstruction, the judgment degrades into wallpaper because the plaintiff is bereft of valuable information revealing assets. Worse, the plaintiff is stuck 9
12 The most famous (and recent) case is Polanski v. Superior Court, where, after pleading guilty to sexual assault charges, Roman Polanski fled to france, fearing that he would be given a long prison sentence. Polanski claimed significant errors by the judge. battling an unbonded appeal that is costly and sometimes unpredictable. Sometimes the appellate bench focuses on errors and mishaps commissioned by counsel and even recasts the appellate process as a teachable moment. 13 Call these moments: Tough love, Exemplars of the trial court going off the tracks, Attention to details is a homily easily forgotten, Counsel high-jacking the jury or Due process in the rear view mirror. These risks, although rare, always loom large, but any plaintiff, facing a well-written appeal, should consider that no trial is perfect. Every trial has many many moving parts. 14 Some parts might have been left on the judge s editing floor, such as due process. Summarily dumping the appeal is in today s nomenclature, a good thing. FRAUDULENT CONVEYANCES METASTASIZE With a big dollar judgment in hand, and absent successful prejudgment relief, the plaintiff anticipated 15 that the defendant fraudulently conveyed everything he or she had during the case or near judgment. 16 More elaborate schemes are the transfers of the business to a series of limited liabilities companies that warehouse the inventory, receivables or fixed assets. Try encumbering the business with 20 to 100 (no exaggeration here) financing statements (UCCs) bearing offshore or non-existent entities as secured creditors (controlled by the defendant s principal) encumbering all assets of the defendant. 18 This list barely gets the plaintiff through the hors d oeuvres of pre- and post-asset protection machinations in the face of a large and inevitable judgment. With some rational information 19, the judgment creditor files a fraudulent conveyance action to recover the property or actually enforces the judgment against the property. In either setting, the fraudulent conveyee and even the debtor appear and defend the fraudulent transfer. The debtor claims that the transfer is bona fide, lacked the requisite intent to hinder, delay or defraud, or that transfer occurred many years ago and therefore outside the statute of limitations. No matter the defense but lacking post-judgment disclosures from the defendant, the plaintiff is severely handicapped in piercing these fatuous claims. Worse, the plaintiff bears the affirmative of proof to prove-up a fraudulent conveyance. 20 DISENTITLEMENT LIFTS THE VEIL OF ASSET PROTECTION Is the plaintiff at the bottom of the well? Has the investment in the case tanked because the defendant defeats enforcement by stonewalling post-judgment discovery? Worse, does the plaintiff forfeit any chances to grab secreted assets because the defendant refuses to provide key information that is paramount to proof at trial? The answer is no, and the remedy to combat risk of reversal or scourge of fraudulent conveyances is disentitlement. 10 These conveyances are the transfers of valuable real property to family members. The debtor creates offshore dummy entities to warehouse bank and securities accounts. How about the new minted LLCs that enable the debtor to open safe deposit boxes that contain (no kidding, folks) gold bullion or coins? Try the simple retitling of property from community property (or jointly held) to separate property of a spouse. 17 THE SWISS guide TO DISENTITLEMENT The starting premise is that civil disentitlement ousts the defaulting defendant from participating in an appeal from the underlying judgment 21 or ensuing post-judgment proceeding. How do we score disentitlement? What is disentitlement? Disentitlement precludes the
13 debtor from participating in judicial process, such as dismissing the appeal. However, disentitlement is more than just bouncing the appeal. The court can disentitle the defendant from participating at the trial court level or filing. The basis is that the defendant has defaulted on a post-judgment discovery order, dodged process servers and marshals, violated an order impounding property or forbidding the transfer of property, or any other conduct that constitutes an affront to the court. 22 Disentitlement is a well-known, well-understood established remedy in the criminal justice system. Typically, disentitlement arises from the criminal defendant who has been convicted but flees the jurisdiction before sentencing but still prosecutes the appeal. 23 The most famous (and recent) case is Roman Polanski vs. Superior Court, 24 in which the movie director, after pleading guilty to sexual assault charges, fled to France, predicated upon his belief that the trial court would hand down a long prison sentence. Polanski asserted significant errors by the judge, but the court upheld, in part, disentitlement predicated upon the adage that the appellate cannot seek the benefits of the judicial system on one hand but defy lawful orders and judgments on the other hand. 25 INCREMENTAL DISENTITLED Disentitlement is more than all or nothing but an incremental remedy available to the courts to protect the adverse party from prejudice arising from the defendant s absence from the jurisdiction. The key case is Degen vs. United States. 26 The defendant was facing both criminal charges (manufacture and distribution of marijuana) and civil forfeiture proceedings (monies and funds from the criminal activity. The defendant fled to a no-extradition county, and the government moved for disentitlement at the trial court level, which the court ordered. The Supreme Court reversed and held that disentitlement under those facts was too blunt an instrument and ordered the district court to consider more incremental remedies. 27 These incremental remedies would include traditional discovery sanctions for the uncooperative party under FRCP 37, trial management orders potentially as an in limine order, or other remedies available to any trial court in the management of a trial. 28 These remedies would be a measured response, or better stated as incremental (i.e., Degen incrementalism ) in minimizing the prejudice suffered by the plaintiff based on uncooperative conduct of the defendant. 29 DISENTITLEMENT IN APPEALS FROM MONEY JUDgMENTS In civil cases, disentitlement authorizes the appellate court to dismiss the appeal by the defendant. Both federal and state case law is replete with the dismissal of appeals precipitated by the defendant (appellant) default in discovery and refusal to comply with the discovery order compelling discovery. In TMS vs. Aihara 30, the California court of appeal dismissed the appeal of the defendant (appellant) who refused to respond to post-judgment interrogatories, seeking the disclosure of In civil cases, disentitlement authorizes the appellate court to dismiss the appeal by the defendant. There are numerous federal and state cases where defendant s (appellant s) discovery defaults preceipitate the dismissal of appeals based on the refusal to comply with court orders.
14 assets, and refused to comply with the ensuing discovery order. The court dismissed the appeal predicated upon the defendant s defiance of the order and held that the defiance was an affront to the court. This case is useful in setting down a clear, well-understood marker that defiance of the post-judgment discovery order disentitles the defendant to appellate relief. In Empire Blue Cross and Blue Shield vs. Finkelstein 31, the Second Circuit upheld the dismissal of the appeal by the defendants who dodged service of the postjudgment examination order, dodged service of the U.S. Marshal serving a bench warrant and absconded from the jurisdiction. 32 This case was handed down post Degen that limited federal disentitlement to the most egregious in which the court affirmed the dismissal based on what amounts to be classic avoidance tactics initiated by many debtors to avoid payment. In Goya Foods Inc. vs. Ulpiano-Unanue Casal etc., 33 the court upheld disentitlement based on defiance of post-judgment discovery, transferring property subject to restraining orders, repetitive and meritless claims and appeals, and other contemptuous conduct. INCREMENTAL DISENTITLEMENT AT THE TRIAL COURT In a fraudulent conveyance action, disentitlement is an incremental and evidentiary remedy. In nearly all fraudulent conveyance actions based hinder, delay and defraud, the judgment creditor must prove the debtor s state of mind. 34 Proof is usually circumstantial. 35 The fact that the defendant (qua debtor) defaulted in failing to respond to post-judgment discovery and defied the order compelling discovery is proof that the defendant is engaging in a campaign to avoid payment by concealing assets. Refusing to reveal property is an act of concealment 36 of the property that is one of the key badges of fraud. This is strong circumstantial proof. The fact that the defendant refuses to make asset disclosures, and refuses to comply with a discovery order, concealing the property itself, is evidence of ill will, malice and hatred and support a the intent to hinder, delay and defraud finding. The order itself and the underlying postjudgment discovery, while hearsay on it s face, is admissible as an evidence of a refusal to pay, and the order is admissible under the request for judicial notice standards. The order itself is even collateral estoppel in the ensuing proceedings The better question is whether the discovery order can disentitle the conveyor (the defendant) and the conveyee from defending the fraudulent conveyance and strike their opposition. Degen incrementalism answers that question. 38 In the fraudulent conveyance action, the defendant claims a bona fides transfer. The
15 defendant denies the intent to hinder, delay and defraud, claims solvency, or asserts pre-suit estate, trust, or tax planning as the justification for the transfer. The defendant and transferee deny knowledge of claims against the defendant. 39 How can the defendant have the intent to hinder, delay and defraud without knowledge of the claim? The discovery order and discovery itself provide information that would undermine these claims. Given that defendant is probable sole repository of these facts, the court can disentitle the defendant from defense to the fraudulent conveyance claims through a discovery sanctions, 40 limine order, or estoppel relief. The court would find that that discovery obstruction constitutes both an admissions of concealment of assets, and impediment to plaintiff s burden to show intent to hinder, delay and defraud. If the defendant will not talk, and the battle focuses on defendant s state of money, the presumption is that he possessed the requisite intent and is barred from claiming to the contrary.while an evidentiary order is not the same as disentitlement from the proceeding per se, nonetheless, the court finding that the defendant transferred the property with the intent to hinder, delay and defraud assures that the plaintiff has proven its own cases. The balance of the case is subject to the affirmative defenses of the conveyee defendants. 41 The transfer of property by a debtor without fair and equivalent consideration rendering the debtor insolvent or insolvent at the time is another form of fraudulent conveyance. 42 Confronted with the defiant conveyor defendant, the court would bar evidence of the defendant s financial condition and find that the willful refusal to respond to discovery is an admission 13
16 that the defendant was insolvent or rendered insolvent as a result of the transfer. This is another form of incremental disentitlement. SUMMARY: DISENTITLEMENT AS THE NUCLEAR OPTION The plaintiff has won, but the defendant announced his or her intention to decline payment but appeal the judgment. The defendant has probably committed multiple fraudulent conveyances. Further litigation is in the offing. The plaintiff bemoans the fact that the cause has assumed a life of its own, without any promise of payment and becomes disenchanted with the never ending process and escalating fees. Disentitlement addresses the client s concerns. Disentitlement at the appellate and trial court level could quash the appeal or expedite the fraudulent conveyance action. Short-cutting the appeal or shorting the fraudulent conveyance action brings justice to the plaintiff a little sooner than later and might rompt payment of the judgment. 1 Performed by Ray Charles, ABC label, Hit the Road, Percy Mayfield, writer. 2 The non-nuclear option is the Daisy Cutter. Non-nuclear device upon detonation clears entire landing zone, hence, cuts the daisies. 3 For purpose of clarity, the debtor is cited as the defendant. 4 The debtor is entitled to an automatic 14 days under FRCP 62(a) and discretionary stay under Rule 62(d). Most states authorize enforcement absent a perfected appeal. (bond and notice of appeal). California Code of Civil Procedure Section 917.1(a). Federal discretionary stays require assurances that the defendant will not evade payment if the appeal is lost. See generally Federal Prescription, Inc. vs. American Pharmaceutical Association etc. 636 F. 2nd. 755 (DC, CA, 1980) 5 FRCP 69(a)(2) permits the judgment creditor to use remedies available under Rules or discovery permitted by the law of the state where the district court sits. 6 C.C.P. Section (a)(a) The judgment creditor may apply to the proper court for an order requiring the judgment debtor to appear before the court, or before a referee appointed by the court, at a time and place specified in the order, to furnish information to aid in enforcement of the money judgment. 7 We call this blood on the walls moment. 8 12th Century English jail. Recently brought back in Shakespeare in Love by actor Geoffrey Rush. We will all be in the clink. 9 What is your name? Bob Jones Were you born with that name? No. What is your birth name? Robert Jones, Jr. Is that the name that appears on your driver s license? Yes. Let me see your driver s license. Do we have a problem, Houston? Yes, we do, because the writs and abstracts must reflect the real, and not the abbreviated name of the debtor. The debtor uses his birth name, as reflected on the driver s license, to open a bank account. The wrong name in the judgment shields the debtor s assets from enforcement. 10 Post-judgment interrogatories and document request, or the order should appear, should be launched as soon as possible after judgment. Service of the Order to appear creates a lien upon the debtor s personal property. C.C.P Section (d). 11 Knock, knock, Is Mr. Jones at home? Who are you? I have legal papers. What legal papers? Legal papers that says he needs to show up in court. Really? Yeah, Really. [Silence.] What case? Well, the case he lost, what do you think? He doesn t live here. Wrong address, buddy. 12 Do not resuscitate. Common for the terminally ill. 13 Seaman s Direct Buying Serv., Inc. v. Standard Oil Co., 36 Cal. 3d 752, infuses tort liability into a breach of contract and upset settled expectation in commercial contracts for years. 14 A throwback to the analog age. 15 This anticipation is rational. The purpose of a fraudulent conveyance is to increase the expense of reaching an asset and dissuading the creditor from taking further action, given the financial barrier. The more elaborate, even though absurd, fraudulent conveyance, the greater expense to unwind. 16 Fraudulent conveyance law starts with Statute of Elizabeth 13 from the reign of Queen Elizabeth the first. The Uniform Fraudulent Transfer Act, Uniform Fraudulent Conveyance Act, Bankruptcy Code Section 548, and resulting trust claims embody modern fraudulent conveyance law. 17 A colorful case is In re Marriage of Dick, 15 Cal App. 4th 144, (Cal. App. 2 Dist 1993). It is well settled that a trust created for the purpose of defrauding creditors or other persons is illegal and may be disregarded. [Citation omitted] This rule has been applied to the creation of trust where the grantor s intention was to prevent his wife,..., from reaching the property. [Citation omitted] The rule regarding fraudulent corporations is equally well-settled: When a corporation is used by an individual or individuals, or by another corporation, to perpetrate a fraud, circumvent a statute, or accomplish some other wrongful or inequitable purpose, a court may disregard the corporate entity and treat the acts as if they were done by the individuals themselves... [Citation omitted] Thus, the court below was entitled to look past the apparent form of ownership in which husband s assets were held to determine the extent of husband s true interest in them and the availability of those assets in assessing husband s ability to pay. [Citation omitted] 18 The Internet, and treatises, abound with asset protection schemes. Accountants and attorneys peddle these fee driven schemes (priced in the $10,000 to $50,000 range) 19 Fraudulent conveyance actions are a species of fraud and probably subject to the higher standard of pleading found in FRCP 9(b) In alleging fraud or mistake, a party must state with particularity the circumstances constituting fraud or mistake. Malice, intent, knowledge, and other conditions of a person s mind may be alleged generally. 20 The plaintiff bears the burden of proof of a fraudulent conveyance. See Whitehouse vs. Six Corporation 40 Cal. App. 4th 527, (Cal App 2 Dist, 1995) 21 Polanski vs. Superior Court 180 Cal. App. 4th 507, (Cal. App 2nd Dist. 2009) ( Polanski ) 22 The most illustrative case is Blue Shield vs. Finkelstein 111 F. 3rd. 278, (2nd Circuit, 1997) 23 Polansk, Id. 24 Polanski, Id. 25 Polanski, Id., p Degen v. United States (1996) 517 U.S. 820, 824 [135 L.Ed.2d 102, 116 S.Ct. 1777] (Degen) [Superseded in the civil forfeiture proceedings by 28 U.S.C. 2466] 27 Degen, Id., p Degen, Ir., p Id. 30 TMS vs. Aihara 71 Cal. App. 4th 377, 379 (Cal. App. 2 Dist, 1999). 31 Empire Blue Cross and Blue Shield vs. Finkelstein 111 F. 3rd. 278, (2nd Circuit, 1997) 32 Empire Blue Cross at p Goya Foods Inc. vs. Ulpiano-Unanue Casal 275 F.3rd. 124 (2nd Circuit, 2001) 34 Civil Code Section (a) 35 Neumeyer vs. Crown Funding etc. 56 Cal. App. 3rd. 178, 183 (Cal. App. 1 Dist, 1977) Because of the difficulty of direct proof of actual intent to defraud creditors, in most cases the evidence must of necessity consist of inferences drawn from the circumstances surrounding the transaction and the relationship and interests of the parties. 36 See Civil Code Section (b)(7) as badge of fraud: Whether the debtor removed or concealed assets. 37 Parklane Hosiery vs. Shore 439 U.S 322 (1979) 38 Degen rejected disentitlement as the blunt instrument but provides alternative means to protect the adverse party from prejudice. Degen at See e.g., safe harbor defenses found in Section (a) safe harbor available to the transfer who receive the property in good faith and pays fair and equivalent consideration. Annod vs. Hamilton & Samuels 100 Cal. App. 4th 1286, (Cal. App. 4 Dist 2002) 40 FRCP 37(b)(2)(A)(i)-(vii) 41 See note This is constructive fraud. See Civil Code Section
17 Is your collection agency collecting accounts In canada? find out if registering in Canada makes sense for your organization. By richard Payne of Morrison and Payne Barristers and Solicitors
18 as a member of the Commercial Law League of America, I have had a number of opportunities to speak to representatives of collection agencies throughout the United States. ome of these agencies are large and nationally operated, and some of them have taken the time and incurred the costs of ensuring that they are registered and licensed to carry on business in every state of the union. However, in my discussions, it appears that some of those agencies have not taken the time to register in Canada, even though they include collections in Canada as part of their business operation. I was speaking to a representative of one of those agencies at the recent CLLA meeting in New York City and indicated that I would put together a summary of the requirements and costs associated with registering in the province of Ontario where my practice is located. I then thought that this might be a matter of more general interest and as a result, I have put together this article. The requirements and costs set out in this article are essentially limited to the province of Ontario. However, each of the Canadian provinces has its own requirements, and it is recommended to get the particulars of what arrangements might be applicable once a local counsel is contacted. In regard to costs, the only real fixed cost with registering in Ontario is the incorporation of an Ontario company, which should be accomplished for under $2,000. The issue of bonding is likely something that can be set up though the bonding agency used by the main office. Other costs, such as office space and employees, will vary with the circumstances of the agency. The regulation of collection agencies in Ontario is governed by the Ministry of Consumer Services Consumer Protection Branch. Brian Pitkin, the registrar for Collection Agencies in Ontario, agreed to be interviewed for this article. I spoke with him and asked whether there had been any problems with respect to collection agencies based in the states attempting to collect accounts in Ontario. Pitkin responded that his office is essentially complaint driven they do not have the resources to initiate investigations themselves. He stated that when they receive a complaint, they will respond by sending a letter indicating that they are to either register in compliance with Ontario law or to cease and desist operating the collection business in Ontario. Pitkin stated that the primary difficulty for foreign collection agencies to be registered in Ontario is the requirement in the Collection Agencies Act that a collector be ordinarily resident in Canada. 16
19 The basic requirements for registration of a collection agency in Ontario are as follows: 1) A person must be at least 18 years old. 2) The agency must have two years experience or the equivalent in all aspects of collections. 3) The agency must write and pass the Collection Agency s examination. 4) If the agency is a corporation, it must be incorporated in a Canadian jurisdiction. 5) The agency must demonstrate the financial ability to conduct business. 6) The agency must demonstrate by past conduct that the business will be managed in accordance with the law and with integrity and honesty. 7) The agency must not be directly or indirectly involved in the lending of money. 8) The agency must not be bailiff. 9) And the agency must obtain a security bond. Essentially, Pitkin stated that this is not an issue that concerns his office. He said that they very seldom get a complaint. He stated that his office probably receives one or two complaints per year with respect to collection agencies not registered in Ontario. Pitkin said that there are already quite a number of U.S. owned agencies that are operating and are registered in Ontario. He stated that of the dozen largest collection agencies in Ontario, at least half of those are owned by U.S. corporations. The bottom line is if your collection agency is sending demand letters to Ontario, then unless a complaint is received from a consumer, then there is likely to be no consequence. However, if you are doing a substantial amount of business in Ontario, then you probably should make inquiries into being in compliance with Ontario law, as a number of larger American collection agencies have already done. Richard Payne is from Morrison and Payne Barristers and Solicitors (www. morrisonandpayne.com), 45 Sheppard Avenue East, Suite 506, Toronto, Ontario M2N 5W9. He can be reached at (416) , ext. 224 or 17
20 Do Your Clients Partner Effectively With Third-Party Collection Agencies Help Decrease Collection Costs And Collect Past-Due Balances By Successfully Working Together 18 Robert S. Shultz is a partner at Quote to Cash Solutions, and can be reached at In ultimately use third-party collection agencies, they often fail to use them effectively. my travels as a credit professional for more than 30 years and as a quote to cash consultant for the past nine-plus years, I find that although most credit managers Ineffective partnering with agencies increases a creditor s collection costs and decreases the likelihood a past due balance will ever be collected. Many companies refer delinquent customers to collection agencies only after all internal efforts to collect have failed. Oftentimes, accounts are held internally too long. This reduces the agency s chances of success. The following information is intended to offer suggestions on how your clients can improve how they manage their internal collection process. The result will be a more effective use of collection agencies and legal options with improved results. It Is Best To Have An Integrated Collection Process. It is a much better strategy for the credit department to work closely with an agency. An agency should be an integral part of the collection process. It only takes a brief analysis of internal collection costs compared to a blended approach: When an agency is utilized as part of the collection process, costs can actually be lower and yield better results. The key is to develop a strategy to determine which accounts are best handled by limited internal staff and which accounts a collection agency is more suited for. Simply put, there is a point where repetitive and costly internal efforts are not cost effective. A debtor may not be intimidated by repeated calls or correspondence. They often delay payment thinking that a future sale will be more important to the supplier than timely collection of an unpaid balance.
Date Signed: May 7, 2015 UNITED STATES BANKRUPTCY COURT DISTRICT OF HAWAII In re THE MORTGAGE STORE, INC. Case No. 10-03454 Chapter 7 Debtor. DANE S. FIELD, Bankruptcy Trustee of The Mortgage Store, vs.
Law Related to Fraud Bankruptcy (Insolvency) Fraud Bankruptcy Court Filed in a local district of the U.S. Bankruptcy Court Bankruptcy judges hear all cases involving: Debtors and creditors rights Approval
Province of Alberta LIMITATIONS ACT Revised Statutes of Alberta 2000 Current as of December 17, 2014 Office Consolidation Published by Alberta Queen s Printer Alberta Queen s Printer 5 th Floor, Park Plaza
JUSTICE COURT # 2 GRAHAM COUNTY STATE OF ARIZONA P.O. BOX 1159, 136 WEST CENTER STREET, PIMA AZ 85543 PHONE (928) 485-2771 FAX (928) 485-9961 SMALL CLAIMS INSTRUCTIONS FOR FILING ***EFFECTIVE JANUARY 1,
Case 1:09-cv-21435-MGC Document 208 Entered on FLSD Docket 06/01/2011 Page 1 of 6 E. JENNIFER NEWMAN, UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA Case No. 09-21435-Civ-COOKE/TURNOFF vs. Plaintiff
PLEASE NOTE: Legislative Information cannot perform research, provide legal advice, or interpret Maine law. For legal assistance, please contact a qualified attorney. Be it enacted by the People of the
Restitution Basics for Victims of Crimes by Adults If you are the victim of a crime, you have a right to be repaid for losses that resulted from the crime. This booklet will help you understand: How to
Law360, New York (October 08, 2014, 10:04 AM ET) -- We all know the story. A plaintiff sues in state court and wants to hometown the out-of-state defendant. In order to ensure a favorable state-court forum
Home Mortgage Foreclosures in Maine Find more easy-to-read legal information at www.ptla.org Important Note: This is very general information about home mortgage and foreclosure rules in Maine. It is not
Jurisdictional Limits The justice courts have exclusive jurisdiction or the authority to hear all civil actions when the amount involved, exclusive of interest, costs and awarded attorney fees when authorized
Order filed June 16, 2011 NOTICE: This order was filed under Supreme Court Rule 23 and may not be cited as precedent by any party except in the limited circumstances allowed under Rule 23(e)(1). IN THE
COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CLERMONT COUNTY, OHIO LEWIS GENE WAMBSGANZ : Plaintiff : CASE NO. 2011 CVH 00456 vs. : Judge McBride FREDERICK C. LAYPOOL : DECISION/ENTRY Defendant : Richard B. Uhle, attorney for
ALERT Financial Services Litigation July 2013 Florida s New Fast Track Foreclosure Law Creates Additional Requirements for Lenders and Mortgage Servicers According to the Florida House of Representatives,
AMENDED IN ASSEMBLY APRIL 14, 2015 california legislature 2015 16 regular session ASSEMBLY BILL No. 597 Introduced by Assembly Member Cooley February 24, 2015 An act to amend Sections 36 and 877 of, and
NOT ACTUAL PROTECTION: ACTUAL INNOCENCE STANDARD FOR CRIMINAL DEFENSE ATTORNEYS IN CALIFORNIA DOES NOT ELIMINATE ACTUAL LAWSUITS AND ACTUAL PAYMENTS By Celeste King, JD and Barrett Breitung, JD* In 1998
SENATE, No. STATE OF NEW JERSEY th LEGISLATURE INTRODUCED JUNE, 00 Sponsored by: Senator JEFF VAN DREW District (Cape May, Atlantic and Cumberland) SYNOPSIS "New Jersey Fair Debt Collection Practices Act."
2015 IL App (1st) 141985-U No. 1-14-1985 NOTICE: This order was filed under Supreme Court Rule 23 and may not be cited as precedent by any party except in the limited circumstances allowed under Rule 23(e)(1).
CALIFORNIA FALSE CLAIMS ACT GOVERNMENT CODE SECTION 12650-12656 12650. (a) This article shall be known and may be cited as the False Claims Act. (b) For purposes of this article: (1) "Claim" includes any
Page 1 of 9 Guide to Small Claims Court 1. Introduction 2. What is Small Claims Court? 3. Who Can Sue and What Can You Sue About? 4. Before You Sue 5. When Must a Lawyer Represent Me in Small Claims? 6.
SUPERIOR COURT OF THE COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES If you are a subscriber of Kaiser Foundation Health Plan, Inc. and you, or your dependent, have been diagnosed with an autism spectrum disorder, you could receive
CONSUMER Information for Advocates Representing Older Adults National Consumer Law Center Debt collectors have been the most complained-about industry on the Federal Trade Commission s consumer website
(DSNB180TC122315) (PL068) DEPARTMENT STORES NATIONAL BANK CREDIT CARD DISCLOSURES Interest Rates and Interest Charges Annual Percentage Rate 24.75% * (APR) for Purchases Store Accounts This APR will vary
Case 08-01176-AJC Document 1 Filed 03/01/2008 Page 1 of 12 UNITED STATES BANKRUPTCY COURT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA MIAMI DIVISION In re: JOSE SANCHEZ Case No.: 01-42230-BKC-AJC and FANNY SANCHEZ, Chapter
DENIED: September 12, 2013 CBCA 3084 SELRICO SERVICES, INC., v. Appellant, DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE, Respondent. Theodore M. Bailey and Kristin Zachman of Bailey & Bailey, P.C., San Antonio, TX, counsel for
Missouri Small Claims Court Handbook The Missouri Bar Young Lawyers' Section TABLE OF CONTENTS I. INTRODUCTION TO THE SMALL CLAIMS COURT...1 Page II. THINGS TO CONSIDER BEFORE BRINGING A CLAIM...1 A. WHO
Fair Debt Collection Practices Act Introduction The Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA), effective in 1978, was designed to eliminate abusive, deceptive, and unfair debt collection practices. The
FILED United States Court of Appeals UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS Tenth Circuit WILLIAM MOSHER; LYNN MOSHER, Plaintiffs - Appellants, FOR THE TENTH CIRCUIT November 19, 2014 Elisabeth A. Shumaker Clerk
Maryland Debt Collection Laws Submitted Thomas A. Mauro, Esq., Mauro Law Offices, P.C. www.tmaurolaw.com Published by The National List of Attorneys www.nationallist.com Thomas A. Mauro is the senior member
NOTICE Decision filed 10/15/15. The text of this decision may be changed or corrected prior to the filing of a Petition for Rehearing or the disposition of the same. 2015 IL App (5th 140227-U NO. 5-14-0227
Province of Alberta HEALTH INSURANCE PREMIUMS ACT Revised Statutes of Alberta 2000 Current as of April 1, 2014 Office Consolidation Published by Alberta Queen s Printer Alberta Queen s Printer 7 th Floor,
NOTICE OF PROPOSED CLASS ACTION SETTLEMENT Aliano et al. v. Templeton Rye Spirits, LLC, Case No. 2014-CH-15667 (Cir. Ct. Cook Cnty., Ill.) IF YOU PURCHASED TEMPLETON RYE WHISKEY FROM JANUARY 1, 2006 TO
NOTICE OF PROPOSED CLASS ACTION SETTLEMENT AND HEARING DATE FOR COURT APPROVAL Penaloza, et al., v. PPG Industries, Inc., Case No. BC471369 As a current or former non-exempt PPG employee, you may be entitled
Payment System Override Deems Transaction Not Ordinary Ames Merchandising Corp. v. Cellmark Paper Inc. (In re Ames Dept. Stores, Inc.), 2011 Bankr. LEXIS 969 (Bankr. S.D.N.Y. Mar. 28, 2011) In Ames Merchandising
california legislature 2015 16 regular session ASSEMBLY BILL No. 597 Introduced by Assembly Member Cooley February 24, 2015 An act to amend Sections 36 and 877 of, and to add Chapter 6 (commencing with
UNITED STATES BANKRUPTCY COURT MIDDLE DISTRICT OF LOUISIANA IN RE: CASE NO. JAMES MICHAEL WATSON 03-13355 DEBTOR CHAPTER 7 SECURITY RESOURCES, L.L.C. ADV. NO and INTERFACE SECURITY SYSTEMS, L.L.C. 04-1005
Chapter 57D. North Carolina Limited Liability Company Act. Article 1. General Provisions. Part 1. Short Title; Reservation of Power; Definitions. 57D-1-01. Short title. This Chapter is the "North Carolina
WorthReading by Jay Winston and Alex Powietrzynski Comfort Orders: Protect Yourself from Unnecessary and Costly Litigation Jan. 1, 2014 Most businesses will experience a bankruptcy by a customer or otherwise
Blispay Card agreement 1. Definitions 2. How Blispay Card works 3. Making payments 4. Fees and interest 5. When things go wrong 6. Arbitration Provision 7. Legal 8. Communications and information sharing
NOTICE This order was filed under Supreme Court Rule 23 and may not be cited as precedent by any party except in the limited circumstances allowed under Rule 23(e(1. 2015 IL App (4th 150225-U NO. 4-15-0225
Creditor Lawsuits Handbook In Magisterial District Court A Handbook for people dealing with creditor lawsuits, including information on such suits and common defenses. Revised July 2009 Introduction This
Advanced Bankruptcy for Bankers Candace C. Carlyon, Esq. www.sheacarlyon.com 1 Pre Bankruptcy Review loan files, confirm collateral security, obtain as much information as possible Consider timing of remedies
Chapter 153 2013 EDITION Violations and Fines VIOLATIONS (Generally) 153.005 Definitions 153.008 Violations described 153.012 Violation categories 153.015 Unclassified and specific fine violations 153.018
RULE 2084-1. SCOPE CHAPTER 13 RULES Local Rules 2084-1 through 2084-26 govern chapter 13 practice in cases filed after October 16, 2005. RULE 2084-2. FILING REQUIREMENTS (a) Application to Pay Fee in Installments.
SUPREME COURT OF WISCONSIN 2012 WI 123 CASE NO.: COMPLETE TITLE: In the Matter of Disciplinary Proceedings Against Thomas E. Bielinski, Attorney at Law: Office of Lawyer Regulation, Complainant, v. Thomas
COLORADO COURT OF APPEALS February 15, 2001 Court of Appeals No. 98CA1099 El Paso County District Court No. 96CV2233 Honorable Theresa M. Cisneros, Judge Carol Koscove, Plaintiff-Appellee, v. Richard Bolte,
Understanding Bankruptcy What is Bankruptcy? Bankruptcy is a legal process where an individual or organizational debtor is able to seek some financial relief. A fundamental goal of the federal bankruptcy
UNITED STATES BANKRUPTCY COURT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK In re: Chapter 7 DYLAN BROWN, Debtor. Case No. 05-60220 (ALG) HEARST MAGAZINES, A Division Of HEARST COMMUNICATIONS, INC., -against- Plaintiff,
Province of Alberta VICTIMS RESTITUTION AND COMPENSATION Statutes of Alberta, Current as of December 17, 2014 Office Consolidation Published by Alberta Queen s Printer Alberta Queen s Printer 7 th Floor,
Filed 8/27/14 Tesser Ruttenberg etc. v. Forever Entertainment CA2/2 NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying
BAP Appeal No. 05-36 Docket No. 29 Filed: 01/20/2006 Page: 1 of 7 UNITED STATES BANKRUPTCY APPELLATE PANEL OF THE TENTH CIRCUIT IN RE RICHARD A. FORD and TONDA L. FORD, also known as Tonda Yung, Debtors.
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, Plaintiff, v. ROBERT J. BIRCH, Defendant and Third-Party Plaintiff, v. PENNSYLVANIA HIGHER EDUCATION
IN THE UNITED STATES BANKRUPTCY COURT FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS IN RE: SCOTT E. LUSTER and Bankruptcy Case No. 00-31005 PHYLLIS LUSTER, SCOTT LUSTER ENTERPRISES, Debtors. HEPTACORE, INC., Plaintiff,
Clark County District Court SMALL CLAIMS COURT INFORMATION INTRODUCTION The Small Claims Department of District Court allows a person or business with a legal dispute to sue without hiring an attorney.
FAMILY LAW NEWS & REVIEW LOS ANGELES COUNTY BAR ASSOCIATION FIRST QUARTER 2010 assist in the making of the child custody decision, and further delay in proceedings would have resulted if a new child custody
Consensus of Judges on Multnomah County Court Foreclosure Panel The judges who serve on the Multnomah County Court s Foreclosure Panel have been presented with the following recurring issues, which over
Case 12-30885-hdh7 Doc 72 Filed 11/22/13 Entered 11/22/13 11:07:32 Page 15 of 27 EXHIBIT A NOTICE OF PROPOSED CLASS SETTLEMENT ALL PERSONS WHO PAID MONEY FOR A MEMBERSHIP IN LULLY S, INC. d/b/a THE RIGHT
Bankruptcy 101 A Guide to Personal Bankruptcy Brought to you by Jon Martin, Esq. Http://www.TheSinCityLawyer.com Bankruptcy laws help people who can no longer pay their creditors get a fresh start by liquidating
TABAS FREEDMAN Attorneys One Flagler Building 14 Northeast First Avenue, Penthouse Miami, Florida 33132 Telephone 305.375.8171 Facsimile 305.381.7708 www.tabasfreedman.com Gary M. Freedman email@example.com
UNDERSTANDING THE COLLECTION PROCESS FOR COMMUNITY ASSOCIATIONS 1. PRE-LITIGATION BY: MULCAHY LAW FIRM, P.C. Almost every community association has problems in collecting unpaid assessments. Most associations
STATE OF MICHIGAN MACOMB COUNTY CIRCUIT COURT JOHN E. BUTERBAUGH and CARRIE BUTERBAUGH, Plaintiffs, vs. Case No. 2012-4691-CH SELENE FINANCIAL, LP, JPMORGAN MORTGAGE ACQUISITION CORP., AS TRUSTEE FOR THE
Background The Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA) (15 USC 1692 et seq.), which became effective in March 1978, was designed to eliminate abusive, deceptive, and unfair debt collection practices.
Illinois Official Reports Appellate Court CitiMortgage, Inc. v. Bukowski, 2015 IL App (1st) 140780 Appellate Court Caption CITIMORTGAGE, INC., Plaintiff-Appellee, v. ANNA BUKOWSKI and KATHERINE D. BUKOWSKI,
Chapter 213. Enforcement of Texas Unemployment Compensation Act... 2 Subchapter A. General Enforcement Provisions... 2 Sec. 213.001. Representation in Court... 2 Sec. 213.002. Prosecution of Criminal Actions...
PLEASE NOTE This document, prepared by the Legislative Counsel Office, is an office consolidation of this Act, current to December 2, 2015. It is intended for information and reference purposes only. This
A GUIDE TO FILING FOR BANKRUPTCY PROTECTION UNDER CHAPTER 7 OF THE BANKRUPTCY CODE Michael R. Totaro Totaro & Shanahan P.O. Box 789 Pacific Palisades, CA 90272 310 573 0276 (v) 310 496 1260 (f) Mtotaro@aol.com
Fair Debt Collection Practices Act 1 The Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA)(15 U.S.C. 1692 et seq.), which became effective March 20, 1978, was designed to eliminate abusive, deceptive, and unfair
In the United States Court of Appeals For the Seventh Circuit No. 14-2423 IN RE: SWEPORTS, LTD., Debtor-Appellee. APPEAL OF: MUCH SHELIST, P.C., et al., Creditors-Appellants. Appeal from the United States
The Rosenthal Fair Debt Collection Practices Act California Civil Code 1788 et seq. 1788. This title may be cited as the Rosenthal Fair Debt Collection Practices Act. 1788.1 (a) The Legislature makes the
Case 1:11-cr-00326-SCJ-JFK Document 119-1 Filed 01/20/12 Page 1 of 16 GUILTY PLEA and PLEA AGREEMENT United States Attorney Northern District of Georgia UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT NORTHERN DISTRICT OF
EARLY CARE & EDUCATION LAW UNIT Publication Date: November 2013 WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW ABOUT SMALL CLAIMS COURT In the operation of your child care business you may encounter problems which force you to
AN ACT IN THE COUNCIL OF THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA To amend the District of Columbia Procurement Practices Act of 1985 to make the District s false claims act consistent with federal law and thereby qualify
FORECLOSURE GLOSSARY NOTICE: This glossary of legal words and phrases related to foreclosure is provided to you by the Clermont County Common Pleas Court to help you better understand your legal problem
Property Can Be Recovered from Subsequent Transferee Without First Avoiding Fraudulent Transfer to Initial Recipient September/October 2005 Robert E. Krebs The power of a bankruptcy trustee or a chapter
NEW JERSEY JUDICIARY SPECIAL CIVIL A GUIDE TO THE COURT Superior Court of New Jersey Law Division Special Civil Part Special Civil A Guide to the Court page 1 Special Civil is a court of limited jurisdiction
Case 4:07-cv-01471 Document 1 Filed 08/20/2007 Page 1 of 12 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF MISSOURI UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, ) ) Case No. Plaintiff, ) ) v. ) ) ) WILLIAM
CHAPTER 32-09.1 GARNISHMENT 32-09.1-01. Definitions. In this chapter, unless the context or subject matter otherwise requires: 1. "Defendant" means every judgment debtor. 2. "Disposable earnings" means
[Cite as Huntington Natl. Bank v. Winter, 2011-Ohio-1751.] IN THE COURT OF APPEALS FIRST APPELLATE DISTRICT OF OHIO HAMILTON COUNTY, OHIO HUNTINGTON NATIONAL BANK and MERCHANTS BANK & TRUST CO., vs. Plaintiffs-Appellees,
Salvatori, Wood, & Buckel ATTORNEYS AT LAW 9132 Strada Place, Fourth Floor, Naples, FL 34108-2683 John D. Humphreville Tel: 239.552.4100 Direct Dial: 239.552.4107 Fax: 239.649.1706 firstname.lastname@example.org Web:
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA REBECCA S. ZEIGENFUSE : CIVIL ACTION on behalf of herself and all : others similarly situated : : v. : : APEX ASSET MANAGEMENT,
Visa Credit Card Cardmember Agreement In this Agreement the words You, Your and Yourself mean each and all of those who apply for the card or who sign this Agreement. Card means the Visa Credit Card and
Province of Alberta MOTOR VEHICLE ACCIDENT CLAIMS ACT Revised Statutes of Alberta 2000 Chapter M-22 Current as of April 1, 2015 Office Consolidation Published by Alberta Queen s Printer Alberta Queen s
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA VERA WILLNER, ET AL. V. MANPOWER INC., CASE NO. 3:11-CV-02846-JST (MEJ) IMPORTANT: You are not being sued. Please read this Notice carefully.
QUESTIONS CONCERNING BANKRUPTCY The Law Office of Paul D. Post, P.A. is a debt relief agency. We help people file for bankruptcy relief under the Bankruptcy Code. The assistance provided to clients may
No. 1-10-1298 NOTICE: This order was filed under Supreme Court Rule 23 and may not be cited as precedent by any party except in the limited circumstances allowed under Rule 23(e)(1). FIFTH DIVISION June