1 Current Research: The Instructional Consultant Role of the School Library Media Specialist SLMQ, Volume 21, Number 2, Winter 1993 Patricia W. Pickard, Department of Educational Media, DeKalb County School System. At the time of this article she was library media specialist at Sequoyah Junior High School in Doraville, Georgia. The role of the school library media specialist has progressed from that of librarian, or keeper of books, to master teacher, instructional design consultant, or teacher-librarian, which is the term used in Canada. In 1988, Information Power: Guidelines for School Library Media Programs defined the role of the school library media specialist as information specialist, teacher, and instructional consultant. Previous standards published by AASL in 1960 and 1969 had contributed to the growth of the instructional role. The 1975 standards, Media Programs: District and School, elevated the instructional role and described the requirements for that role as design and consultation. Design meant that the library media specialist was to initiate and participate in curriculum development, while consultation meant that the library media specialist was to recommend media applications for instructional settings. By the late 1970s, many articles and books focused on the concept of instructional design and the librarian s role in it. In the early 1980s, several models for instructional development or design and curriculum involvement by the library media specialist appeared in the literature. Nickel listed twelve steps for the library media specialist to follow in order to play a key role in curriculum planning and development, including being aware of the total instructional program of the school; visiting classes as often as possible; knowing the current methods of teaching; becoming involved in the actual planning of the curriculum; conducting in-service for teachers; knowing bibliographies in the textbooks and adding books cited in them to the media center collection; and participating as a member of the instructional team.(1) Baker went even further to describe teachers perception of the role of the library media specialist. Teachers expect that the library media specialist will be capable of serving as a member of the teaching team, willing and able to participate as a professional equal. He continued: Administrators expect that library media specialists will be master teachers who display through technique, methodology, and discipline that they are excellent teachers of students with regular and special learning needs, and of their fellow teachers as well. The administrators expect the specialist to assume a leadership role, to influence the quality of instruction and the course of teaching and learning, not just in the library media center, but throughout the building.(2)
2 Wehmeyer defined the instructional role of the library media specialist as consigliere-someone who is identified by and works closely with the principal and is an instructional leader on the basis of expertise. The consigliere is an indirect instructional leader who interacts as a colleague with classroom teachers. Such change facilitators do not issue directives; rather, they ask, inform, model, suggest, and support. (3) In an Arizona study of perceptions of the role of the library media specialist,(4) however, only 6.5 percent of the principals surveyed and 3.4 percent of the media specialists indicated a belief that the library media specialist should exercise a leadership role in the educational and local communities. The competency stated encourage and practice a professional school library media philosophy that supports the principles and practices of the education was ranked first in importance by 55.6 percent of the principals and 44.4 percent of the library media specialists. The study did not specifically address the instructional role. The competency stated assist faculty in selection of appropriate library materials ranked 5.0 in importance with principals and 4.5 with library media specialists (on a scale of 0B5). Even though the instructional role of the library media specialist has evolved to one of prominence in the literature, research studies indicate discrepancies between theory and practice. Studies have shown a ten-year lag between the introduction of the concept and its actualization in the profession. Craver states: Instructional design, while introduced as an officially sanctioned activity by the 1975 standards, was far from a practiced reality as late as (5) Stripling points out that most of the instructional development research, theories, and models published through 1984 were written by those in higher education, not by practicing library media specialists.(6) In a Texas study, school library media specialists ranked competencies associated with consultation, instruction, and utilization (instructional development) very low in importance to effective job performance and skill development as compared with the more traditional roles of organization, management, acquisition, and dissemination.(7) Williams studied the teacher/media specialist cooperation and services within middle schools in Cobb County, Georgia.(8) She found that 83 percent of the responding library media specialists had worked in a team-teaching situation in which ideas and responsibilities were shared to plan, develop, and implement student instruction, while only 11 percent of responding teachers had participated in such a unit. Descriptions of the units revealed that most were reactive-the library media specialist reacted to the teacher s request. Williams concludes that interest in teacher/media specialist cooperation is high, but actual involvement is low. Recognizing how difficult it is for the library media specialist to try to fit instructional development activities into an already full schedule, Turner suggests that all levels of involvement (including informal advice) between the teacher and the library media specialist are part of instructional development.(9) In a recent discussion of the evolution of information skills and instructional consulting as a synergy,(10) he states that the levels approach to instructional consultation provides the method by which the library media specialist can build a relationship of mutual trust with the classroom teacher. This approach is necessary for the library media specialist to gain access to the classroom and the planning process of a unit that focuses on resources other than the textbook. In the instructional consultant role, the library media specialist then integrates the necessary skills instruction into the unit.
3 By 1989, the term resource-based instruction, the opposite of textbook-based instruction, appears established in the literature. Toor and Weisburg, two practicing library media specialists, further define the term by explaining its worth as a teaching strategy and describing ways to convince administrators and gain their support as well as gain the confidence and cooperation of classroom teachers.(11) Their model provides a six-step framework for teacher/library media specialist planning sessions. To illustrate their model, they present twenty-two resource-based instructional units for elementary and secondary schools to be used by library media specialists in a hands-on seminar approach to implementing resource-based instruction. Toor and Weisberg continue to provide samples of these resource-based units in their monthly School Librarian s Workshop. Linda Waddle s personal reaction to resource-based teaching was a fancy name for something I ve been doing all along ;(12) however, her further reading revealed the difference. The concept originated in Canada with Partners in Action: The Library Resource Center in the School Curriculum, published by the Ontario Department of Education in The American version was described in Loertscher s Taxonomy of the School Library Media Program.(13) The terms reactive and proactive explain the difference. What the library media specialist has been doing is reacting to someone else s unit plans; but with levels nine and ten of the taxonomy, the library media specialist participates from the initial planning of the unit as an equal partner and proactive participant in instructional design. Eisenberg states that... the activities associated with curriculum support and instructional design have not been fully realized, exemplifying the gap between literature and practice. He concludes:... the primary challenge is to narrow the gap between theory and practice and between internal and external perceptions and expectations. (14) Purpose The purpose of this study was to determine if a lag existed between the theoretical instructional role of design and consultation as described in the literature, and the instructional role as practiced by school library media specialists in the DeKalb County Public Schools in Georgia. To make this determination, the study sought answers to the following questions: 1. How important do the library media specialists perceive the instructional role of design and consultation to be? 2. To what extent are the library media specialists practicing the instructional role of design and consultation? 3. What demographic variables relate to the library media specialists perceived importance and practice of the instructional role? This study was significant in that results helped in assessing the success and justification of the DeKalb Department of Educational Media s direct emphasis on the role of helping teachers teach, the term used by Turner (15,16) and chosen by the department to encompass the instructional role of the library media specialist.
4 This study assumed that these library media specialists were familiar with Turner s levels and Loertscher s taxonomy of the instructional role of the school library media specialist and were practicing the role at some level. The study was limited to the 126 library media specialists (seventy-nine elementary; forty-seven secondary) of the DeKalb County Public Schools, which serve more than seventy-three thousand students in seventy-seven elementary and twenty-four secondary schools. (DeKalb County is one of five counties in the metropolitan Atlanta area, and this school system is the largest in Georgia.) Research Design To gather data, a three-page questionnaire, arranged in three parts, was designed and sent to all library media specialists in the DeKalb County Schools. The first part contained the following eighteen statements relating to the instructional role: Provide access to materials through organization and classification that integrate materials in all formats into a unified collection. 1. Provide reference services and materials to individual students and teachers. 2. Gather materials for a teacher with no advance notice. 3. Plan informally and briefly with a teacher for library involvement in a unit. 4. Gather materials requested by a teacher in advance of a class project or assignment. 5. Promote the instructional philosophy of the library media center program. 6. Plan formally with teachers to supply materials or activities in response to a teacherplanned unit. 7. Help teachers plan, implement, and evaluate instructional units in which library media center materials are supplementary or used for enrichment. 8. Help teachers plan, implement, and evaluate instructional units where the entire content is based on resources and activities of the library media center program. 9. Participate as an equal partner with the teacher in assessing students achievements (grading) in a resource-based unit. 10. Participate as a member of the school curriculum committee. 11. Design and produce instructional materials to meet student and teacher needs. 12. Analyze and interpret content of instructional materials in relation to the curriculum. 13. Design and conduct in-service education programs for teachers, aides, and other schoolrelated groups. 14. Explain various styles of learning that account for individual differences among students. 15. Use information, communication, and learning theories and models in relation to learning styles and individual differences among students. 16. Identify appropriate usage of various communication media in the learning environment. 17. Assist and guide teachers and students in the design, development, and evaluation of instructional programs in relation to learner needs, teacher strategies, and learning environments. These statements are based on Loertscher s The Library Media Specialist s Taxonomy (17) and a list of competencies for consultation, utilization, instruction, and learning resources development found in the literature.(18) The first eight statements address the levels of the
5 taxonomy, beginning at level two (Self-Help Warehouse) and proceeding in order through level nine (Instructional Design, Level I). Statements 9 through 18 address levels ten (Instructional Design, Level II) and eleven (Curriculum Development). Using a Likert scale, respondents rated the statements in order of importance to their job performance (rankings are shown in table 1 under Results ). In the second part of the questionnaire, respondents were asked to rate the same statements according to their own practice of the instructional role. The third part contained demographic questions and a section for optional, open-ended comments. Responses were scored according to three philosophical categories-reactive, Proactive, or Interactive-in perception and practice of the instructional role. These three sub-areas correspond to Turner s second, third, and fourth levels of passive participation, reaction, and action/education. They are also based on Callison s grouping of the eleven levels of Loertscher s taxonomy into the three philosophical categories. Levels one through five are reactive levels; the library media specialist simply supplies what is requested. Levels six through eight are proactive levels; the library media specialist aggressively promotes media services and the instructional use of a variety of media. The third category, interactive, encompasses levels nine through eleven: Results The media specialist acts, not only as a leader, but also begins to examine the educational system in terms of evaluating its successes and failures.... The media specialist becomes an important force for curriculum development. This impact involves not only integrating information skills into all areas of the curriculum, but working to revise the lessons and activities to the degree that such lessons require the use of the resource center.(19) Usable responses were received from eighty-three of the 128 library media specialists for a 65 percent return. Of these, 59 percent were in elementary schools and 41 percent were in secondary schools (junior highs, senior highs, and the centers). Table 1 shows the frequency of their responses to statements about the importance of the instructional role to their position. The first two statements ( provide access to materials through organization and classification that integrate materials in all formats into a unified collection and provide reference services and materials to individual students and teachers ) were considered by the largest number of respondents as very important. Statements 10 and 15 ( participate as an equal partner with the teacher in assessing students achievements in a resource-based unit and explain various styles of learning that account for individual differences among students ) were considered very important by the least number of respondents. These two statements and statements 12 and 18, taken from the literature, specifically define the various aspects of the instructional design and consultation role. The ratings for these were noticeably lower than ratings for statements dealing with the traditional roles of warehousing and making materials accessible. Production of materials, an emphasis in the 1970s and now considered part of the instructional design process, was rated of some importance by twenty-five respondents.
6 Table 1. Frequency of Importance (N = 83) Abbreviated Taxonomy and Taxonomy Related Statements Ratings* no. (%) N/A 1. Provide access 73 (88) 9 (11) 0 1 (1) Reference services 78 (94) 5 (6) Gather materials with no 11 (13) 31 (37) 32 (39) 6 (7) 3 (4) 0 0 notice 4. Plan informally 47 (57) 32 (39) 2 (2) 2 (2) Gather materials in advance 66 (80) 15 (18) 1 (1) (1) 0 6. Promote philosophy 57 (69) 14 (17) 10 (12) 1 (1) 0 1 (1) 0 7. Plan formally a teacherplanned 54 (65) 24 (29) 4 (5) 1 (1) unit 8. Help teachers teach as 41 (49) 24 (29) 12 (14) 6 (7) supplemental 9. Health teachers teach in 56 (67) 19 (23) 8 (10) resource-based unit 10. Equal partner in resourcebased 7 (8) 15 (18) 35 (42) 21 (25) 5 (6) 0 0 unit 11. School curriculum 39 (47) 25 (30) 15 (18) 1 (1) 1 (1) 0 2 (2) committee member 12. Production of instructional 13 (16) 18 (22) 25 (30) 21 (25) 5 (6) 1 (1) 0 materials 13. Analyze materials to 26 (31) 33 (40) 18 (22) 4 (5) 1 (1) 1 (1) 0 curriculum 14. Conduct inservices 22 (27) 38 (46) 19 (23) 3 (4) 1 (1) Know learning styles 4 (5) 16 (19) 33 (40) 21 (25) 9 (11) Use information, communication, and learning theories 14 (17) 21 (25) 33 (40) 9 (11) 5 (6) 1 (1) Identify usage of 23 (28) 35 (42) 17 (20) 6 (7) 1 (1) 1 (1) 0 communication media 18. Assist in design of 20 (24) 28 (34) 24 (29) 9 (11) 1 (1) 1 (1) 0 instructional program *Scale: 5 = very important, 4 = important, 3 = of some importance, 2 = of little importance, 1 = of no importance, 0 = no response, NA = not applicable To determine if the library media specialists were practicing the instructional role as defined in the literature, respondents were asked to rate the same statements according to their own frequency of practice, and table 2 shows the frequency of their responses. Again, the first two statements were practiced to a very great extent by the largest number of respondents. Statements 10 and 15 were practiced to a very great extent by only seven and four respondents, respectively. As in table 1, there was an even greater drop in the ratings of statements that define more specifically the instructional design and consultation role (statements 12 throug h 18).
7 Table 2. Frequency of Practice (N = 83) Abbreviated Taxonomy and Taxonomy Related Statements Ratings* no. (%) N/A 1. Provide access 73 (88) 6 (7) 1 (1) 1 (1) 0 2 (2) 0 2. Reference services 65 (78) 14 (17) 3 (4) (1) 0 3. Gather materials with no 17 (20) 25 (30) 31 (37) 9 (11) 1 (1) 0 0 notice 4. Plan informally 30 (36) 36 (43) 16 (19) 1 (1) Gather materials in advance 38 (46) 37 (45) 8 (10) Promote philosophy 44 (53) 16 (19) 15 (18) 7 (8) 0 1 (1) 0 7. Plan formally a teacherplanned 21 (25) 20 (24) 28 (34) 12 (14) 2 (2) 0 0 unit 8. Help teachers teach as 12 (14) 19 (23) 31 (37) 17 (20) 4 (5) 0 0 supplemental 9. Health teachers teach in 18 (22) 22 (27) 19 (23) 16 (19) 8 (10) 0 0 resource-based unit 10. Equal partner in resourcebased 1 (1) 6 (7) 13 (16) 23 (28) 40 (48) 0 0 unit 11. School curriculum 6 (7) 6 (7) 6 (7) 4 (5) 58 (70) 0 3 (4) committee member 12. Production of instructional 5 (6) 6 (7) 18 (22) 30 (36) 24 (29) 0 0 materials 13. Analyze materials to 9 (11) 17 (20) 30 (36) 14 (17) 11 (13) 2 (2) 0 curriculum 14. Conduct inservices 8 (10) 17 (20) 31 (37) 21 (25) 6 (7) Know learning styles 4 (5) 1 (1) 10 (12) 32 (41) 34 (41) Use information, communication, and learning theories 6 (7) 10 (12) 22 (27) 27 (32) 18 (22) Identify usage of 10 (12) 28 (34) 26 (31) 14 (17) 4 (5) 1 (1) 0 communication media 18. Assist in design of 6 (7) 13 (16) 26 (31) 24 (29) 12 (14) 2 (2) 0 instructional program *Scale: 5 = to a very great extent, 4 = to a great extent, 3 = to a moderate extent, 2 = to a small extent, 1 = none at all, 0 = no response, NA = not applicable Table 3 shows the percentage of respondents who rated the statements as either very important or important, the percentage who rated their own practice of the statements as to either a very great extent or a great extent, and the discrepancy between these two ratings. The percentage of respondents who rated these statements with either a 5 or 4 was lower in every case than the rating of the statement s importance, except for statement 3 ( gather materials with no advance notice ), which showed no discrepancy.
8 Table 3. Frequency Percentages of Combined 5 and 4 Ratings for Importance and practice with Discrepancy Scores Ratings* no. (%) Abbreviated Taxonomy and Taxonomy Related Statements Importance Practice Discrepancy Scores 1. Provide access 82 (99) 79 (95) 3 (4) 2. Reference services 83 (100) 79 (95) 4 (5) 3. Gather materials with no notice 42 (51) 42 (51) 0 (0) 4. Plan informally 79 (95) 66 (80) 13 (16) 5. Gather materials in advance 81 (98) 75 (90) 6 (7) 6. Promote philosophy 71 (86) 60 (72) 11 (13) 7. Plan formally a teacher-planned unit 78 (94) 41 (49) 37 (45) 8. Help teachers teach as supplemental 65 (78) 31 (37) 34 (41) 9. Health teachers teach in resource-based 75 (90) 40 (48) 35 (42) unit 10. Equal partner in resource-based unit 22 (27) 7 (8) 15 (18) 11. School curriculum committee member 64 (77) 12 (14) 52 (63) 12. Production of instructional materials 31 (37) 11 (13) 20 (24) 13. Analyze materials to curriculum 59 (71) 26 (31) 33 (40) 14. Conduct inservices 60 (72) 25 (30) 35 (42) 15. Know learning styles 20 (24) 5 (6) 15 (18) 16. Use information, communication, and 35 (42) 16 (19) 19 (23) learning theories 17. Identify usage of communication media 58 (70) 38 (46) 20 (24) 18. Assist in design of instructional program 48 (58) 19 (23) 29 (35) The most notable score discrepancies in the taxonomy statements (1B9, and 11) appeared in statements 7 (45 percent), 8 (41 percent), 9 (42 percent), and 11 (63 percent), which represent the heart of the instructional consultant role. Even though 77 percent rated statement 11, serves on school curriculum committee, important or very important, only 14 percent practiced this statement to a great or very great extent, thus providing the largest discrepancy. This was the only statement with not applicable (NA) responses, because sixteen respondents indicated that their school had no curriculum committee. Labels of Reactive, Proactive, and/or Interactive were given to respondents who gave the corresponding taxonomy statements either a 4 or 5 rating. Labels were given for both perception of the importance and practice of the statements. A respondent could receive as many as six labels depending on the responses to both parts of the questionnaire. If a respondent gave no response or NA to a statement, no score or label was given in that category. Respondents who rated statements 1, 2, and 4 with either a 4 or 5 received the Reactive label. Statement 3 was not used for label determination after the author perceived a difference in meaning in the wording of the statement and that conveyed by Loertscher in level four of the taxonomy. For perceived importance, 94 percent received the Reactive label, while 74 percent received the Reactive label for practice.
9 Proactive respondents rated statements 5 through 7 with a 4 or 5, and Interactives rated statements 8, 9, and 11 with either a 4 or 5. The Proactive label described 82 percent of the respondents for importance ratings but only 41 percent for practice ratings. Interactive labels applied to 61 percent for importance and only 10 percent for practice. Table 4 shows the frequency of the labels and the breakdown by media center position (elementary or secondary) of the respondents. Table 4. Frequency of Labels for 83 Respondents Label Importance no. (%) Practice no. (%) Reactive 78 (94) 61 (74) Elementary 45 (92) 32 (68) Secondary 33 (97) 29 (88) Proactive 68 (82) 34 (41) Elementary 38 (78) 17 (35) Secondary 30 (88) 17 (50) Interactive 51 (61) 8 (10) Elementary 25 (53) 5 (11) Secondary 26 (77) 3 (9) Conclusions Although the DeKalb County library media specialists perceived their instructional role to be important, they seemed to view this role as supportive; only one-fourth of the respondents felt it was important to be an equal partner with a teacher in evaluating student work in a resourcebased unit. The drop in importance ratings for the statements that imply an instructional leadership and innovator role (such as explain various styles of learning that account for individual differences among students and use information, communication, and learning theories and models in relation to learning styles ) also support this conclusion. Several commented that these areas belong to the instructional lead teacher and the assistant principal for instruction. The library media specialists were not practicing the instructional role to a great extent. In fact, fewer than half reported that they were practicing to a great or very great extent the actual instructional design levels of Loertscher s taxonomy. Only eight (10 percent) library media specialists can be labeled Interactive according to their combined responses to statements 8, 9, and 11 ( the media specialist begins to consider unique instructional approaches and accepts the role of instructional innovator ).(20) It is important to note, however, that only 5 percent of the eighty-three respondents reported that they were not practicing level nine at all, and only 10 percent indicated no practice of level ten. An assumption can be made that the library media specialists had a clear understanding of the importance of the instructional role, because in the year prior to the study, Frank Winstead,
10 director of educational media, stressed the planning, implementation, and evaluation of one or more resource-based units with a classroom teacher. The library media specialists were encouraged to include this teamwork in their annual personal goals. During the year of the study, they were instructed to progress to levels nine and ten of Loertscher s taxonomy and were required to show evidence that at least one resource-based teaching unit was developed and implemented with a new or master teacher. This emphasis on implementing resource-based instructional units could account for the percentage differences in both importance and practice for statements 8 and 9. It would appear from table 3 that statement 9, help teachers plan, implement, and evaluate instructional units where the entire content is based on resources and activities of the library media center program, was more important and practiced by more library media specialists than statement 8, which focused on units where media center materials are supplemental or used as enrichment. Of the library media specialists who were labeled Interactive, no demographic variable contributed to the perceived importance and practice of the instructional role. School levels and years of library media experience may have had some influence. Based on perceived importance, only half the elementary library media specialists could be labeled Interactive, while more than three-fourths of the secondary respondents could. Of the eight library media specialists who were designated Interactive in practice, six had more than eleven years of experience. Of the fifty-one respondents labeled Interactive in perceived importance, thirty-two (63 percent) had at least eleven years of experience. Limitations The data show that only eight of the eighty-three library media specialists who responded appeared to be practicing the instructional role to a great extent. One explanation might be that at the time of this study, the DeKalb media specialists had been required to plan, implement, and evaluate only one resource-based unit. The results might have been higher if the library media specialists had implemented the plan over an entire school year when they answered the questionnaire. Another factor that may have affected results was the statement concerning membership on the school curriculum committee, one of three statements whose ratings determined the Interactive label. Even though 77 percent of the respondents considered membership important, 70 percent indicated they did not serve on the committee. Of these, it is not possible to know how many are in schools with no curriculum committee. Only three respondents rated this statement with NA for practice; however, at least thirteen other respondents actually stated that their school did not have a curriculum committee. One stated that she was a member of her school s leadership committee but did not indicate its function. Another stated that the second media specialist in the school served on the committee, and two stated that the principal selected the committee, but they would serve if asked. Even if these twenty respondents had been labeled Interactive in practice, the results (34 percent) would have been greater but not impressive.
11 Implications Craver, in examining research studies from 1950 to 1984, revealed that the instructional role of the school library media specialist had changed but not to a great degree. The literature indicates a lag of at least ten years between the instructional role espoused and that being practiced.(21) The literature from 1984 revealed little change, and the results of this study appear to support the earlier findings. The responses in both importance and practice to statement 10 and statements 12 through 18 indicate that many of the library media specialists may not be in agreement with the instructional leadership and innovator aspects of the role. Although a case can be made for library media specialists serving as curriculum coordinators because they work with all teachers designing instruction and making effective use of materials, they possess neither the line authority nor the accepted academic credentials of the curriculum coordinator.(22) The evaluation of papers adds extra responsibility for the media specialist, but the role is important for an integrated library mediabclassroom instructional project (23) is a rewording of statement 10. The low ratings for statements 10 and 16, reworded from the literature as school library media specialists understand how knowledge is most effectively communicated by teachers and most effectively received by students, (24) indicate that the role of the master teacher or teacher-librarian is not the norm in the DeKalb schools. Although this study did not attempt to determine the cause, the most obvious question raised is the reason for the discrepancy between the Interactive labels for importance and practice. The literature offers several reasons, including lack of interest, knowledge, and/or training of the library media specialist; a lack of administrative support, including clerical, budgetary, and scheduling factors; and a lack of interest, a resistance to cooperation, or a lack of information about the instructional design process on the part of teachers. Montgomery, who expanded this list in her study, corroborates the importance of cognitive style (the manner in which an individual s perception is influenced by sensory data) to cooperation between the teacher and library media specialist.(25) Further studies are still needed to determine why more library media specialists who believe in its importance are not practicing the instructional role to its fullest extent. Administrative support of the instructional role of the library media program must be emphasized. Ellen and Hilda Jay assert: Wherever library media programs have been especially successful, there have been strong, informed, and active partnerships forged among the principal, the classroom teachers, and the library media personnel.... It is this third role, the curricular role [Information Power], that has the most immediate implication for both principals and library media professionals.(26) It is worth noting that the May 1991 issue of the NASSP Bulletin was devoted to the importance of the school library media program and resourcebased instruction. Ken Haycock warns: There is relatively little danger to the continued existence of school libraries. The issue is the continued existence of the school librarian. (27)
12 Information Power defines the school library media specialist as information specialist, teacher, and instructional consultant-giving equal importance to each role. The roles of teacher and instructional consultant go hand-in-hand. An instructional consultant must have the knowledge, expertise, and experience of a teacher combined with knowledge of the total library media collection and other resources outside the center that relate to and enhance the curriculum. Library media specialists should bring their knowledge of research, teaching methodology, curriculum development, learning theory, and instructional development to the process of teaching. (28) Thus, the library media specialist must be a master teacher. The literature goes further in applying the terms instructional leader and instructional innovator to the library media specialist. Do the DeKalb library media specialists meet the standards? Perhaps not yet, but they certainly appear to be moving in the right direction. References 1. M. L. Nickel, Steps to Service: A Handbook of Procedures for the School Library Media Center (Chicago: ALA, 1984). 2. D. P. Baker, The Library Media Program and the School (Littleton, Colo.: Libraries Unlimited, 1984), Lillian Biermann Wehmeyer, Indirect Leadership: The Library Media Specialist as Consigliere, School Library Media Quarterly 15 (Summer 1987): Isabel Schon, Gerald C. Helmstadler, and Dan Robinson, The Role of School Library Media Specialists, School Library Media Quarterly 19 (Summer 1991): Kathleen W. Craver, The Changing Instructional Role of the High School Library Media Specialist: , School Library Media Quarterly 14 (Summer 1986): Barbara Stripling, What Price ID? A Practical Approach to a Personal Dilemma, School Library Media Quarterly 12 (Summer 1984): E. Susan Staples, 60 Competency Ratings for School Media Specialists, Instructional Innovator 26 (Nov. 1981): J. S. Williams, Teacher/Media Specialist Cooperation and Service within Middle School Media Centers (unpub. Ed.S. paper, Georgia State Univ., 1989). 9. Philip Turner, A School Library Media Specialist s Role: Helping Teachers Teach (Littleton, Colo.: Libraries Unlimited, 1985). 10. Philip Turner, Information Skills and Instructional Consulting: A Synergy? School Library Media Quarterly 20 (Fall 1991): Ruth Toor and Hilda Weisburg, Reasons, Roles and Realities: A Hands-on Seminar in Resource Based Instruction (Berkeley Heights, N.J.: Library Learning Resources, Inc., 1989). 12. Linda Waddle, School Media Matters, Wilson Library Bulletin 63 (Dec. 1988): David Loertscher, Taxonomies of the School Library Media Program (Englewood, Colo.: Libraries Unlimited, 1988). 14. Michael Eisenberg, Changing Roles of the Media Specialist (Syracuse, N.Y.: ERIC Clearinghouse on Information Resources, ED , 1987). 15. Turner, A School Library Media Specialist s Role. 16. Philip Turner, Research on Helping Teachers Teach, School Library Media Quarterly 15 (Summer 1987): Loertscher, Taxonomies of the School Library Media Program, 10.
13 18. Staples, 60 Competency Ratings. 19. Daniel Callison, Evaluator and Educator: The School Media Specialist, TechTrends 32 (Oct. 1987): Ibid., Craver, The Changing Instructional Role. 22. Alice Naylor and Kenneth D. Jenkins, An Investigation of Principals Perceptions of Library Media Specialists Performance Evaluation Terminology, School Library Media Quarterly 16 (Summer 1988): Pam Bhalla, Modeling a Library Media-Classroom Integrated Instructional Process, School Library Media Activities Monthly 4 (Sept. 1987): Sue Walker, Information Power: The Role of the School Library Media Specialist, School Library Media Quarterly 17 (Fall 1988): Paula Kay Montgomery, Cognitive Style and the Level of Cooperation between the Library Media Specialist and Classroom Teacher, School Library Media Quarterly 19 (Spring 1991): M. Ellen Jay and Hilda L. Jay, The Principal and the Library Media Program, School Library Media Activities Monthly 6 (April 1990): Ken Haycock, Strengthening the Foundations for Teacher-Librarians, School Library Media Quarterly 13 (Spring 1985): John A. Hortin, The Changing Role of the School Media Specialist, TechTrends 30 (Sept. 1985): 20.
The Instructional Consultant Role of the Elementary-School Library Media Specialist and the Effects of Program Scheduling on Its Practice SLMQ Volume 25, Number 1, Fall 1996 Eleonor Putnam, Library Media
Volume 11, 2008 Approved July 2008 ISSN: 1523-4320 www.ala.org/aasl/slr The Instructional Role of the Library Media Specialist as Perceived by Elementary School Principals Audrey P. Church is Assistant
The effects of social marketing on collaboration in the media Center An action research project -------------------------- Western Kentucky University LME 519 Research in Library Media Education Dr. Barbara
An Analysis of the Time Use of Elementary School Library Media Specialists and Factors That Influence It SLMQ Volume 24, Number 2, Winter 1996 Jean Donham van Deusen, Assistant Professor, University of
Volume 3, 2000 ISSN: 1523-4320 www.ala.org/aasl/slr Block Scheduling Ruth V. Small, Professor, School of Information Studies, Syracuse University Through the 1990s an innovative approach to structuring
The Effects of ALA Accreditation Standards on Library Education Programs Accredited by the American Library Association Michael E. Mounce Assistant Professor Delta State University Contact Information:
College/School/Major Division Assessment Results for 2012-2013 1) College/School: School of Agriculture: Animal Science Unit 2) Review your student learning outcomes (SLOs). Please update as needed. The
LIS 610 Philosophical Position Paper November 18, 2008 Information Literacy Assessment: A Critical Component to the School Library Media Program INTRODUCTION: Because of recent economic conditions, school
ED470034 2002-11-00 Why Should Principals Support School Libraries? ERIC Digest. ERIC Development Team Table of Contents If you're viewing this document online, you can click any of the topics below to
SECTION 4: MASTER OF EDUCATION DEGREE Beginning with the summer session in 1954, a fifthyear program of teacher education leading to the degree Master of Teaching was instituted at Northwestern Oklahoma
Electronic Portfolios in Evolution Roger Olsen email@example.com Nancy Wentworth Nancy_Wentworth@byu.edu David Dimond firstname.lastname@example.org Abstract: Electronic Portfolios in Evolution describes a dynamic
IDEA Student Ratings of Instruction Survey Report Fall 2011 Guam Community College IDEA Student Ratings of Instruction Survey Report, Fall 2011 TABLE OF CONTENTS Page Executive Summary i I. Introduction
Math Science Partnership (MSP) Program: Title II, Part B FLOYD COUNTY: COLLABORATIVE SYMPOSIUM FOR MATH IMPROVEMENT IN FLOYD COUNTY SCHOOLS ANNUAL EVALUATION REPORT: YEAR TWO Report Prepared by: Tiffany
The MetLife Survey of Challenges for School Leadership Challenges for School Leadership A Survey of Teachers and Principals Conducted for: MetLife, Inc. Survey Field Dates: Teachers: October 5 November
Research Report - 2008 Working Conditions Experiences of Elementary and Secondary Teachers in Ontario s Public Schools 1 Research Kenneth Leithwood OISE/University of Toronto, 2008 2 Teachers in secondary
Principals Use of Computer Technology 85 Lantry L. Brockmeier James L. Pate Don Leech Abstract: The Principal s Computer Technology Survey, a 40-item instrument, was employed to collect data on Georgia
For Initial Programs for School Library Media Specialist Preparation Approved by NCATE March 5, 2003 American Library Association American Association of School Librarians Program Standards School Library
School Library Media Endorsement Program (SLM) Summer 2015 Designed for you, the working K-12 educator Preparation for a K-12 Library Media Endorsement Washington s K-12 Library Media Endorsement (WEST-E
Literacy Culminating Experience 11/10 p. 1 CIG 697 Culminating Experience Masters Degree in Curriculum & Instruction (M. Ed.) Reading Specialist / Literacy Education / Children s & Young Adult Literature
M.Ed. in Educational Leadership This program is for experienced classroom teachers who have an inner passion for facilitating student achievement and school improvement. These educators will find the graduate
ARTICLE 67-19 ACCREDITATION: PROCEDURES, STANDARDS, AND CRITERIA Chapter 67-19-01 Accreditation: Procedures, Standards, and Criteria 67-19-02 Waiver of Accreditation Standards or High School Unit Instructional
Workplace Learning as a Field of Inquiry: A Canadian-US Comparison Faye P. Wiesenberg, PhD, University of Calgary, Alberta Shari L. Peterson, PhD, University of Minnesota, St. Paul Abstract: This comparative
The Impact of School Library Media Centers on Academic Achievement SLMQ Volume 22, Number 3, Spring 1994 Keith Curry Lance, Director, Library Research Service, Colorado Advocates of school library media
LIBRARY AND INFORMATION STUDIES EDUCATION AND HUMAN RESOURCE UTILIZATION A STATEMENT OF POLICY EXECUTIVE SUMMARY In 1999 the 1 st Congress on Professional Education created four task forces. Task Force
Please save this pdf form to your desktop, fill it and send it to Dr. Ralph Turner via email as an attachment. School Library Proficiencies Checklist Eastern Kentucky University Library Science Program
IUMPST: The Journal. Vol 2 (Pedagogy), February 2011. [www.k-12prep.math.ttu.edu] Onsite Peer Tutoring in Mathematics Content Courses for Pre-Service Teachers Elaine Young Associate Professor of Mathematics
Understanding How Teachers Plan: Strategies for Successful Instructional Partnerships SLMQ Volume 22, Number 3, Spring 1994 Linda Lachance Wolcott, Associate Professor, Department of Instructional Technology,
The Importance of Newer Media in Library Training and the Education of Professional Personnel HAROLD GOLDSTEIN NEWERMEDIA DO NOT YET HAVE MUCH status in libraries nor, as a consequence, do the in-service
Versland, T. M., Quintana, E., & Malloy, J. (2014). Leader succession and collective efficacy: Conditions that create continuity in transition. The Researcher, 26(1), 3-7. Leader Succession and Collective
2 We are all accustomed to periodic summative testing for achievement, but in this chapter the importance of requiring mastery of fundamentals as the baseline for evaluation, regardless of the level of
MATTC Course Descriptions Multiple Subject Courses: 250. Ethics, Diversity, Reflection: Introduction to K-12 Teaching This course focuses on credential candidates professional development and their integration
VOLUME 16 NUMBER 3, 2006 Striving for Success: Teacher Perspectives of a Vertical Team Initiative Dr. Lisa Bertrand Educational Administration and Counseling Southeast Missouri State University Dr. Ruth
DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATIONAL ADMINISTRATION COllEGE OF EDUCATION UNIVERSITY OF MINNESOTA INTERNSHIP EDUCATIONAL ADMIN STRATION N Department of Educational Administration College of Education University of
Are Arizona Public Schools Making the Best Use of School Counselors? Results of a Three-Year Study of Counselors Time Use Arizona School To Work Briefing Paper #16 April 1999 by Judith A. Vandegrift, Morrison
Faith and Learning Integration as Implemented by Christian Elementary School Teachers By You Jung Jang What makes a Christian school Christian? Christian educators have asked this question for decades.
The New York State Board of Regents and The New York State Education Department Growing Tomorrow s Leaders Today Preparing Effective School Leaders in New York State "The factor that empowers the people
Information Retrieval Design. James D. Anderson and Jose Perez-Carballo. East Brunswick, NJ: Ometeca Institute, Inc., 2005. 617 pp. $35.00. (0-9763547-0-5). Information Retrieval Design is a textbook that
MASTER OF EDUCATION IN INSTRUCTIONAL TECHNOLOGY Student Handbook Overview The Graduate School Department of Education Online Student Handbook is intended to serve as a general guide for current and prospective
Mohave Community College Baseline Education Program Review for 2011-2012 Department Mission: The mission of the Department of Education is to provide a program for students which emphasizes: Stimulating
Field Experiences Computer Science Endorsement Educational Leadership School Library Media Specialist Computer Science Endorsement Field Experiences Field experience is a necessary component of the proposed
EMSTAC Elementary & Middle Schools Technical Assistance Center www.emstac.org Answering the question What factors are important in the selection and implementation of school-based interventions or programs?
SHOW SLIDE ONE. Tell the directors that because Leadership is the first strand, we will be focusing more closely on it today through the Leadership Dynamics PowerPoint. Point out that the Leadership Dynamics
RUTGERS SCHOOL PSYCHOLOGY PROGRAM PRACTICUM HANDBOOK Introduction School Psychology is a general practice and health service provider specialty of professional psychology that is concerned with the science
Bibliography Transitional Programs to Middle Level School Akos, P.; Galassi, J.P. (2004, April). Middle and High School Transitions as Viewed by Students, Parents, and Teachers. Professional School Counseling.
R e f l e c t i o n P a p e r 1 Principal Reflection Paper Michael Ricke South Dakota State University EDAD 707 The Principalship Dr. Kenneth Rasmussen July 24, 2013 R e f l e c t i o n P a p e r 2 Introduction
Teacher Evaluation Missouri s Educator Evaluation System Teacher Evaluation Protocol Introduction Missouri s Educator Evaluation System was created and refined by hundreds of educators across the state.
ACT National Curriculum Survey 2012 Policy Implications on Preparing for Higher Standards improve yourself ACT is an independent, not-for-profit organization that provides assessment, research, information,
leaders UNIVERSITY OF SIOUX FALLS RAPID CITY AREA SCHOOLS Master of Education Leadership in Reading BECOME AN INSTRUCTIONAL LEADER IN YOUR CLASSROOM AND SCHOOL. l e a r n Desire to learn. At the University
Roles of the State Library Agency in Serving Adult Education MURIEL L. FULLER THE ROLES ASSUMED by state library agencies in serving adult education are as varied as the states themselves. The roles range
Volume 1, Issue 2, 2007 Rural Female Entrepreneurs: A Demographic Survey in Rural Pennsylvania Dean Frear, Assistant Professor, The Jay S. Sidhu School of Business & Leadership, Wilkes University, USA,
EXPERIENCE UNIVERSITY 2008 Present UNIVERSITY OF RICHMOND Adjunct Assistant Professor, School of Continuing Studies, Department of Education & Teacher Licensure Teach graduate level courses in Foundations
MASTERS SOCIAL WORK PROGRAM ASSESSMENT Social Work Program assessment is carried out by an Assessment Committee that includes CSU Social Work Department faculty, students, and alumnae. Findings produced
A Guide to Curriculum Development: Purposes, Practices, Procedures The purpose of this guide is to provide some general instructions to school districts as staff begin to develop or revise their curriculum
MO 634 Foundations of the Montessori Method This course offers an overview of human development through adulthood, with an in-depth focus on childhood development from birth to age six. Specific topics
E x e c u t i v e S u m m a r y Improving science content and inquiry standards mastery of fourth-grade students: A study of the effectiveness of National Geographic Science Chicago Public Schools 2010
OHIO DEVELOPS TECHNOLOGY ACADEMIC CONTENT STANDARDS Background Paul E. Post The development of the Ohio is a high point on a long road of curriculum revision in Ohio. Four political paths and three sets
2012-2013 Assessment Report School of Nursing Nursing, MSN Expected Outcome 1 Title Professional Role Development Full description of Expected Outcome: AU/AUMSON MSN students will be able to articulate
MISSION Chesterfield County Public Schools Mission Statement: The mission of the Chesterfield County Public Schools is to work in partnership with students, families and the community to ensure that each
A Review of High School Mathematics Programs Introduction In the winter of 2005, a grant was written entitled Making the Transition from High School to College (MaTHSC). The grant began as a collaboration
Medical Informatics in Healthcare Organizations: A Survey of Healthcare Information Managers Jeremiah H. Sable, MD, MHA, Joseph W. Hales, PhD, Kenneth D. Bopp, PhD Department of Health Management and Informatics
Texas Agricultural Science Teachers Attitudes toward Information Technology ABSTRACT Dr. Ryan Anderson Iowa State University Dr. Robert Williams Texas A&M- Commerce The researchers sought to find the Agricultural
University of Bath Welsh Baccalaureate Qualification Internal Evaluation Themed Report: MARKETING AND PROMOTION [This is one of eight themed reports which draw on issues relating to particular themes that
Uinta County School District #1 Multi Tier System of Supports Guidance Document The purpose of this document is to provide an overview of Multi Tier System of Supports (MTSS) framework and its essential
Music Libraries: Centralization versus Decentralization 139 Music Libraries: Centralization versus Decentralization Lois Kuyper-Rushing Branch libraries, in general, and music libraries, in particular,
Barriers to the Implementation of Project Lead The Way as Perceived by Indiana High School Principals C.J. Shields Purdue University The history of educating youth for a career is as old as humanity. Without
Name Date Student ID # Email School Library Graduate Program Plan Degree Status: school, degree, date Certification Status Desired Plan Bachelor s Elementary Master s Degree Master s Secondary Candidate
Boise State University Department of Construction Management 2013-2014 Quality Assessment Report and Action Plan November 25, 2014 Executive Summary The Construction Management program is accredited by
Science Education College of Education College of Natural Sciences and Mathematics INTRODUCTION The philosophy of the Science Education Program is based on the belief that teachers play a preeminent role
Get to Know My RE Observe Collect Evidence Mentor Moments Reflect Review Respond Tailor Support Provide Provide specific feedback specific Feedback What does my RE need? Practice Habits Of Mind Share Data
APPENDIX A Level II Handbook Education Specialist Mild/Moderate Level II Credential Handbook CSUCI California State University Channel Islands Fall 2006 Jill M. Leafstedt Joan Karp Maria Denney Table of
How School Librarians Help Kids Achieve Standards The Second Colorado Study Keith Curry Lance Marcia J. Rodney Christine Hamilton-Pennell April 2000 CONTACT Keith Curry Lance, Director Library Research
ABC-CLIO S ONLINE HISTORY DATABASES SUPPORT SOCIAL STUDIES INSTRUCTION AT CYPRESS BAY HIGH SCHOOL IN BROWARD COUNTY, FLORIDA Cypress Bay High School Broward County Public Schools Weston, Florida A (2008):
The Teacher Educator Standards From the Association of Teacher Educators Winter Conference Standards Clinic New Orleans, LA February, 2008 Facilitators: Dr. Robert Fisher Dr. Barbara Short Dr. Robin McBee
Critical thinking skills and teaching accounting: a comparative study ABSTRACT Forrest Thompson Albany State University H. Lee Washington Albany State University Accounting textbooks are constantly being
Ruling on the University of Aizu Graduate School April 1, 2006, Regulation No. 4 Latest revision: March 25, 2015 Contents Chapter One General Provisions (Articles 1-5) Chapter Two Faculty Assembly of the
Online Course Syllabus EDFD630 Theories Human Development and Learning Important Notes: This document provides an overview expectations for this online course and is subject to change prior to the term
The ESOL and Bilingual/ESOL Graduate Program Endorsement Western Oregon University s ESOL/Bilingual Education program prepares teachers to ensure that students succeed in all aspects of their schooling:
TExES Special Education Supplemental (163) Test at a Glance See the test preparation manual for complete information about the test along with sample questions, study tips and preparation resources. Test
Ruling on the University of Aizu April 1, 2006, Regulation No. 3 Latest revision: March 25, 2015 Contents Chapter One General Provisions (Articles 1 and 2) Chapter Two Organization (Articles 3-6) Chapter
1 The Effects of Counseling on Academic Achievement among Language Minority (LM) Middle School Students Timothy Fitzgerald Garnet-Patterson Middle School District of Columbia Public Schools Submitted June
Training for Music Librarianship: A Survey of Current Opportunities GORDON STEVENSON THEREIS NEITHER a lack of music schools nor a lack of library schools in the United States; there are, in fact, more
AC 2010-884: TEACHING CONTROL CHARTS FOR VARIABLES USING THE MOUSE FACTORY Douglas Timmer, University of Texas, Pan American Miguel Gonzalez, University of Texas, Pan American Connie Borror, Arizona State
9 Evaluation Online offers a variety of options to faculty who want to solicit formative feedback electronically. Researchers interviewed faculty who have used this system for midterm student evaluation.
LIBRES Library and Information Science Research Electronic Journal Volume 18, Issue 1, March 2008 Getting to Proficiency and Beyond: Kentucky Library Media Centers Progress on State Standards and the Relationship
Master of Arts in Teaching/Science Education Master of Arts in Teaching/Mathematics Education Assessment F12-S13 FOR ACADEMIC YEAR: 2012-2013 PROGRAM: MAT/Science and Mathematics Education SCHOOL: NS&M
graduate programs School of 58 SCHOOL OF EDUCATION PETERSON HALL 206.281.2214 WWW.SPU.EDU/DEPTS/SOE William Rowley, Dean; Henry Algera; Dan Bishop; Lisa Bjork; Suzanne Bond; Rick Eigenbrood; Arthur Ellis;
U N IVE RSIT Y OF MA RY LA ND E AST ER N S HO RE Master of Education in Career and Technology Education Dr. Gerald F. Day Coordinator of Graduate Studies Department of Technology University of Maryland
CENTRAL WASHINGTON UNIVERSITY GUIDELINES FOR SCHOOL PSYCHOLOGY INTERNSHIP PROGRAMS Rationale Over the past two decades, the role and function of school psychologists has been changing and expanding. While