1 Jens Bleuel Citing of Internet sources English translation of Zitation von Internet-Quellen German version planned to be published in: Hug, Theo, Hg.: Wie kommt die Wissenschaft zu ihrem Wissen?. Band1: Einführung in das wissenschaftliche Arbeiten [Buch und CD- ROM]. Hohengehren: Schneider Verlag Abstract: This article discusses the special aspects of citing electronic sources on the Internet. It discribes a proposal for a general referencing scheme, the affected problems and an overview of ISO (Information and Documentation Bibliographic Reference Part 2: Electronic documents or parts thereof). A detailed part deals with references to sources on the Internet like URL (non persistend identifier) and URN, DOI, PURL, Handles (persistend identifiers) and archieved vs. non archieved sources. Also, there are examples for a variety of services (WWW, , Lists, Usenet News, Telnet, FTP, Gopher, WAIS) and the authors view of the expected development. Remark to this translation I did this translation with the help of Altavista s Bable Fish and my school english. If you find any spelling or grammatically mistakes don t hesitate to contact me. Proposal for citation: Bleuel, Jens: Citing of Internet sources Online in Internet: PURL: URL: [PDF-File]. Remarks, updates and links can be found at
2 Contents 1 Basics and general scheme Problems Identification and reproductibility of sources Problems of the reproductibility The inconsistency of the location of a source The inconsistency of contents Are sources in electronic networks citabel? Different data formats ISO Referencing Internet sources: standards, schemes and proposals URL URN, DOI, PURL und Handles Archived and non archived sources Sources on several Internet services and mailing lists Usenet news Telnet FTP Gopher WAIS Special aspects Separations in specifications of Internet sources Citing of certain sections of an online publication Citing with references to original or printed sources Unfinished versions, work on progress Date format of online sources Further technical specification to the source Sources, which are available at several locations in the Internet Authors view and the expected development List of literature... 13
3 1 Basics and general scheme Here it is to be dealt with the special features of citing in the Internet. It concerns mainly suggestions and only partly around standards, which are not present yet in final version or whose complete technical implementation still pends. Publications can take place via many services of the Internet. Certain sources are not archived in the network and to remain therefore accessible, others do. The different citing ways are not to be represented here. For this numerous suggestions and guidelines exist, for example the APA Style of the American Psychological Association (1983, there in particular the notes to the bibliography: ). The following citing examples follow the publication of Klaus Poenicke of the Duden publishing house (1988, ). Underlinings and italics are not used, since these are only conditionally viewable in the Internet. Online should additionally specified for a network source. 1 This serves the distinction for printed publications, since online sources are subject to special problems (see chapter Problems ). Furthermore the type of network should be given (for example Internet ) since other networks exist or could exist in the future. If a publication is dated it is recommended to give this information between the titel and Online in Internet. In the case of using other citing conventions the date can be given for example also after the author s name. The part Online in Internet can be omitted, if in the bibliography Internet sources are specified in a separate paragraph. Furthermore Online in could be omitted, because today most people know Internet is online. In the following schemes and examples I state Online in Internet for exactness. Since the originally reference indicated can change and could possibly no longer be valid (see chapter The inconsistency of the location of a source ) one should according to the source specification give a date with [Cited date], in order to document, when the information was downloaded. In the case of using long-live references (persistent identifiers, see chapter URN, DOI, PURL and Handles ) the accesibility is received, however contents can change, why it is meaningful also here to date the download. All dates of download should be indicated in ISO 8601 (Year-Month-Day) (see chapter Date format of online sources ). Below all variables are included in asterisks; so for example *Reference to Internet source* must be replaced by the appropriate address. General scheme: *Used way of citing* Online in Internet: *Reference to Internet source* [Cited *Date of download*]. It is to be noted that in Internet sources points and hyphens can be contained. These characters, like also large and lower cases are to be used exactly as in the source specification. In Internet sources a blank follows never a point; thus it does not come to misunderstandings with the pointing used in conventional citings. 2 Problems 2.1 Identification and reproductibility of sources Basically the citing specification is to serve for a safe identification and reproductibility (American Psychological Association 1983, 111). The reproductibility here is of special importance; not each source can become fair these criteria. By the following examples this is to be clarified: Books 1 LI und CRANE (1993, 17) use [Online] Also used in ISO 690-2:1997, see Chapter ISO
4 By the delivery of obligation copies to the German library and a federal state library the verifiability of source specification is secured. Newspapers and magazines The most newspapers and magazines are likewise collected in libraries. Furthermore archiving is often given by the publishing house. Radio and television broadcasts The producers archive even to a larger extent. The verifiability of the above sources is thus basically given. CD-ROM and diskettes The obligation delivery of CD-ROMs to the German library occurs at the moment on voluntarily base (Die Deutsche Bibliothek 1999), whereby the verifiability is only given conditionally by source specification. Data bases Archiving takes place at the producer of the data base. The found documents have no unique designation apart from author name, title, date among other things often within the data base. Thus direct search and verifiability are possible only over the given additional information (e.g. document or reference numbers of the data base provider). Unpublished sources The verifiability here is only given for the case that the unpublished source is provided for example as an attachment. Sources in electronic networks The verifiability depends on whether a source was archived or not. If necessary sources are accessible also only for a certain period, then are deleted or are at another place in the network. Beyond that the author could change the contents (with not archived sources). The following paragraph deals with the problems of the reproductibility. 2.2 Problems of the reproductibility The inconsistency of the location of a source The source could be offered over another on-line service, and within the same in another place. By the example of Internet and Compuserve: In the Internet the source could be offered via another service (Gopher, World Wide Web among other things), by another computer or in a new place within this computer. Within Compuserve another forum could be selected or within the forum another section (in detail Bleuel 1995). This problem in the Internet should be solved by so called persistent identifieres similarly to the ISBN with books (see chapter URN, DOI, PURL and Handles ). If despite of all that the source is at a new place in the network and is not discoverable, the verifiability of a citation is not ensured The inconsistency of contents Everyone can publish in simplest manner in many electronic networks themselves. Thus also the author can change its work. If it indicates these modifications or old versions are archived, the verifiability of the citing is further ensured. Otherwise modifications in contents of a source are to be carried out not according to. The only possibility offers archiving, as this e.g. with scientific magazines or discussion groups in the Internet occur. In the future archiving of individual sources could take place for example also by a voluntarily supply to a library or determined organisation (if necessary universities). Thus a verifiability of the citing would be ensured, what is today only conditionally.
5 2.2.3 Are sources in electronic networks citabel? On-line publications are quotable, like other publications, on the condition that the type of publication (e.g. electronic or on-line ) is indicated. Perhaps sceptical voices would be convinced by the fact that there is an ISO standard since 1997 for citing of electronic sources (see chapter ISO ). The verifiability is given only with archived sources. The older a source specification is, which was accessible however not archived, the more probably it has that it was subject to a modification. Otherwise it should be left to the responsible person of a work whether it permits not archived sources to the cited or e.g. requires that these are in the attachment (printed out or also on data storages) available and thus verifiable. With aid programmes, which can copy for example entire Internet pages inclusive diagrams on the local computer, this is possible. 2.3 Different data formats Electronic sources can be stored in various formats. For the representation of the source an appropriate program is necessary, which can process this format. Fortunately the development goes into the direction that a program detects and represents several formats correctly automatically. Thus this problem is rather unimportant. If the format of a source is not unique, this can be marked by an addition with the citation. The URN standard mentioned below contains among other things the data format of the source in the Uniform Resource Characteristics (URC). 3 ISO In november 1997 the International Standards Organization (1997) published the following standard: ISO 690-2: 1997 Information and Documentation Bibliographic Reference Part 2: Electronic documents or parts thereof. Edition: 1 (Monolingual) Extracts are available from URL: [Cited ]. The standard gives the elements and their order. For example for a monografie: Primary responsibility (Required) Title (Required) Type of medium (Required) Subordinate responsibility (Optional) Edition (Required) Place of publication (Required) Publisher (Required) Date of publication (Required) Date of update/revision (Required) Date of citation (Required for online documents; Optional for others) Series (Optional) Notes (Optional) Availability and access (Required for online documents; Optional for others) Standard number (Required) In the following chapters the specific elements were discribed and some tips are given if an element is missing. (for example Date of publication or Publisher) The following example is given: CARROLL, Lewis. Alice's Adventures in Wonderland [online]. Texinfo ed [Dortmund, Germany] : WindSpiel, November 1994 [cited 10 February 1995]. Available from World Wide Web: <http://www.germany.eu.net/books/carroll/alice.html>. Also available in PostScript and ASCII versions from Internet: <ftp://ftp.germany.eu.net/pub/books/carroll/>. There is a logical inconsistence in using Available from World Wide Web for all sources beginning with http: and using Available from Internet: for all other sources on the internet. The reader could think World Wide Web and Internet are comparable in any form. [Everyone knows this isn t, but who knows.] The right thing is
6 World Wide Web is a subpart of the Internet (it s a service). There are a lot of these examples in the standard. But this disqualifies not the standard itself: Chapter gives no detailled information for citing a location: The location information for online documents within a computer network such as the Internet shall refer to the copy of the document that was actually seen and should include the method of access to the document (e.g. FTP) as well as the network address for its location. The elements of location information (e.g. address of the host computer, directory name, file name) shall be transcribed with the same punctuation, upper case and lower case letters as given in the source. For an ISO standard I would have wished more information to the referencing of the locations in the Internet. This only takes place on the basis of examples, which follow the publication of LI and CRANE (1993). I summarize the following elements in my proposal as the used way of citing and don t discuss them detailled: Primary responsibility, Title, Subordinate responsibility, Edition, Place of publication, Publisher, Date of publication, Date of update/revision, Series, Notes, Standard number. Type of medium is integrated in the element availability and access (Online in Internet), so the order of elements changes. Date of citation is given by ISO with [cited date] or an equivalent statement. Furthermore there is a reference to ISO 8601:1988 for the representation of date and time. (see chapter Date format of online sources ). 4 Referencing Internet sources: standards, schemes and proposals 4.1 URL The Uniform Resource Locator (URL) is a proposed standard (RFC: Request for Comments 1738) 2 and is used frequently by WWW and FTP. The source beginns with "URL:", simplyfied: URL: scheme://host/path Scheme gives the service, for example "mailto" ( ), "news", "ftp", "telnet", "gopher", "wais" or "http" (WWW). The path gives the location on the host. Cornell Law School: The Legal Information Institute. Supreme Court Collection. Online in Internet: URL: [Cited ]. An URL can simply entered in WWW browsers 4.2 URN, DOI, PURL und Handles The URL described above is a world-wide, unique naming of a source, which can be subjected however modifications. So their location could not be valid any longer. A solution of this problem represents the Uniform Resource Name (URN): The URN defines (similarly the ISBN with books) a source in the Internet world-wide and unique (Lasher 1994, 38). The difference to URL consists of the fact that a URN remains always valid also with the modifications specified above. This is implemented by a data base, which stores the appropriate URL to a URN. If the URL changes, this is noted in the URN data base (Sollins 1994, 37). The source becomes described additional through a Uniform Resource Characteristics (URC). Here information is stored like the available data formats, size or version of a source and much more (Sollins 1994, 35). By calling a URN it returns thus URL (the place ) and an URC (the type and form ) of the source. The Internet Engineering Task Force (IETF) is working for years on the standard; At the beginning of year 2000 it is unfortunately not yet finished. It appears however that the fundamental systematics (Name Space Identifier as Prefix and Name Space Specific 2 The actual protocol standard is available from URL: ftp://ftp.isi.edu/in-notes/std/std1.txt [Cited ].
7 String as Suffix) will remain. Until these procedures are avowed as the official standard, the well-known URL should be indicated additionally. In the suggested Internet standard (RFC 2141) a URN is indicated as follows: URN:Prefix:Suffix By the integration of URL and URN to Uniform Resource Identifier (URI) (Berners Lee 1998), in which the diagonal stroke is used for separator, and in combination with the Handle-System represented below, a URN should indicated as follows: URN: hdl:prefix/suffix The Corporation for National Research Initiatives: The Handle System Online in Internet: URN: hdl: /4000 URL: [Cited ]. The publishing industry has a similar proposal, the Digital Object Identifier (DOI). The difference to the URN exists particularly in the integration of account possibilities and copyrights. At present the DOI assignment is bound to a membership in the DOI organization, which is used due to high membership charges, thus only large publishing houses and organizations are members. Beginning of year 2000 the german bookseller union wants to advance this standard and enable its assignment even for smaller publishing houses. DOI: doi:prefix/suffix International DOI Foundation: The Digital Object Identifier System. DOI Technology Online in Internet: DOI: doi: /100 URL: [Cited ]. Both solutions to the unique reference in the Internet function already. The Corporation for National Research Initiatives (CNRI) operates the Handle-System for the resolution of the URN or DOI to URL. An URN or a DOI can be inputed directly in the Browser, if the CNRI-resolver is installed. Further information can be found at: URL: or URL: [Cited ] A final standard is not finished yet. It is to be expected however that in the future both systems will become generally accepted. Due to the long time, which will still need this to be a standard, OCLC (Online Computing Library Center) already established an operational solution by a Persistent Uniform Resource Locator (PURL). Everyone can request a unique PURL world-wide. The system is compatible with the future URN standard and CNRI and OCLC agreed to guarantee an interoperability between PURLs and Handles. On February, 26th 2000 already 563,231 PURLs were created world-wide. A Resolve server is placed before the prefix, which resolves the prefix and suffix into the URL. PURL: Resolve Server/Prefix/Suffix In the following examples is the Resolve Server, NET is the Prefix and Cite2 and Bleuel/Citing are Suffixes. Payette, Sandra: Persistent Identifiers on the Digital Terrain. In: RLG [Research Library Group] DigiNews, April 15,1998, Volume 2, Number 2. Online in Internet: PURL: URL: [Cited ]. Bleuel, Jens: Citing of Internet sources Online in Internet: PURL: URL: [Cited ]. On a long-term basis PURL will be transformed into URN and will by supplied by the libraries. DOI is supported by the publishing industry. A central resolution of all systems is to be guaranteed by the Handel- System.
8 4.3 Archived and non archived sources For sources, which do not fit into the URL pattern, but although are available online, terms should be used like available or accessible. Due to the recommendation in ISO to available or a comparable term one should use available. URL and available is to be used for the indication of sources, which are archived and accessible. Non archived or not accessible sources (e.g. s and most Usenet News) are indicated without URL and without available. However it always depends on the information supplier whether it keeps a source accessible or also changes it. The boundaries are to be drawn thus not unique. Nevertheless it is to be expected that high-quality pages are on a long-term basis available. With a specification of URL or available the citing should, as represented in the previous paragraphs, contain the dating with [Cited date]. 5 Sources on several Internet services 5.1 and mailing lists Non archived s: *Used way of citing* Online in Internet: from *Sender* <* address*> (*Date of *). After the name of the author the title follows or, if missing, the Subject of the . An explicit date is very rare, since the date of sending is inserted always automatically. This should be placed at the end. Since the sender of an does not have to be necessarily the author, it is meaningful to mention him explicitly (*Sender*). The specification of the address of the author or sender can be given in < >. By specifying a private address as the source an agreement of the sender should be caught up, since he or she could receive unsolicited s. Doe, John: sample. Online in Internet: from John Doe ( ). Non archived mailing lists: *Used way of citing* Online in Internet: Mailing list *Name of List* <* address of mailserver*> (*Date of sending*). Strangelove, Michael: How to Advertise on the Internet NOW AVAILABLE: An Introduction to Internet-Facilitated Marketing and Advertising. Online in Internet: Mailing Liste VPIEJ-L (10/24/1994). It can be that, so far not archived mailing lists to be archived. If these are accessible, the value of the citing increases. With attention to the above suggestions the reproduction is given. Archived and available mailing list sources: *Used way of citing* Online in Internet: Available: to * address of mailserver * Content: *Contents of * [Cited *Date of download*]. As it is needed, Content: can be replaced by Subject:. Okerson, Ann: The Electronic Journal: What, Whence, and When? In: Public-Access Computer Systems Review 2, no. 1 (1991) Online in Internet: Available: to: Content: get okerson prv2n1 [Cited ]. If it is available via WWW: Okerson, Ann: The Electronic Journal: What, Whence, and When? In: Public-Access Computer Systems Review 2, no. 1 (1991) Online in Internet: URL: [Cited ].
9 5.2 Usenet news Non archived usenet news: *Used way of citing* Online in Internet: Usenet news *Name of group * (*Date of sending*). Although the service usenet news is defined also in the URL scheme, this specification is not suitable for the citing: By the URL the group of discussions with the current contributions is addressed. Individual contributions are deleted after a defined time from this group and are not available any longer, therefore no URL is used here. Noring, Jon: Recommendations for Pre-1920 Books to Electronically Reissue. Online in Internet: Usenet news alt.etext (11/2/1994). Archived and available usenet news: *Used way of citing* Online in Internet: Usenet news *Name of group * (*Date of sending*). URL: *URL-Address* [Cited *Date of download*]. It depends on by which service the archived usenet news is offered. In the example down mentioned the service ftp was selected, which can be indicated as URL (see chapter FTP ). If archiving should be made e.g. by Gopher, available can be used instead of URL (see chapter Gopher ). Dell, Thomas: [OBI] Online Book Initiative FAQ. Online in Internet: Usenet News alt.etext (2/10/1993). URL: ftp://wiretap.spies.com/alt.etext/018.obi.faq [Cited ]. 5.3 Telnet This service is hardly still used in the Internet. For the sake of the completeness the citing for this is however further indicated. *Used way of citing* Online in Internet: Available: *URL-address* Enter: [*Messages at the display*] *Key inputs* <*Selection*> *Remarks* [Cited *Date of download*]. With telnet e.g. a key input could indicated as Key inputs". Messages at the display, after which the input has to take place, are set into square brackets, since they serve as additional information. The inputs are indicated in quotes or inverted commas. Remarks or notes take place without this indication. Listing of all locations of gatt_1.zip: Available: telnet://archie.th-darmstadt.de/ Enter: [login:] archie [th-archie>] prog gatt_1.zip [Cited ]. There is also a possibility of indicating the login name for telnet within the URL: Listing of all locations of gatt_1.zip: Available: Enter: [tharchie>] prog gatt_1.zip [Cited ]. With several options the one which can be selected can be indicated by pointed brackets. With clarity omissions can be used... and messages, which are contained in pointed parentheses, must not additionally in angular be indicated. 5.4 FTP Listing of all books at Uni-Erlangen by Titel, Keyword or Author which are beginning with zitier : Online in Internet: Available: telnet://faui43.informatik.uni- erlangen.de/ Enter: [login:] gi <Recherchieren> <Autor Titel Schlagwort> zitier* [Cited ]. *Used way of citing* Online in Internet: URL: *URL-address* [Cited *Date of download*]. FTP sources are defined unique by the URL:
10 Berners-Lee, Tim, L. Masinter, M. McCahill: Uniform Resource Locators (URL). Dezember Online in Internet: URL: ftp://ftp.isi.edu/in-notes/rfc1738.txt [Cited ]. 5.5 Gopher This service is hardly still used in the Internet. For the sake of the completeness the citing for this is however further indicated. *Used way of citing* Online in Internet: Available: *URL-address* Enter: <*Selection*> [Cited *Date of download*]. Specification of Gopher sources can be indicated likewise by URL, to Gopher URL requires however the denomination of a type of document. The user does not have this numeric code always to be obvious and a citing without this type of document would be a false URL. Gopher supplies always contain options, which are indicated for the acquisition of the source in pointed parentheses: Guedon, Jean-Claude: Why are Electronic Publications Difficult to Classify?: The Orthogonality of Print and Digital Media. University of Montreal: Department of Comparative Literature Online in Internet: Available: gopher://arl.cni.org/ Enter: <Scholarly Communications> <Directory of Journals> <Why are Electronic...> [Cited ]. 5.6 WAIS This service is hardly still used in the Internet. For the sake of the completeness the citing for this is however further indicated. *Used way of citing* Online in Internet: URL: *URL-address* [Cited *Date of download*]. or (see also Telnet): *Used way of citing* Online in Internet: Available: *URL-address* Enter: [*Messages at the display*] *Key inputs* <*Selection*> *Remarks* [Cited *Date of download*]. WAIS sources can be likewise indicated by URL, a wais URL can become however very long. If the specification is not required to URL, it can be proceeded as with telnet. Example of an WAIS inquiry to Germany from the CIA World Factbook 1993 over WWW: 5.7 WWW Germany (CIA World Fact Book 1993). Online in Internet: Available: Enter: [Find:] world- factbook <search> <search of world-factbook93> [search terms:] germany berlin <submit query> <Germany...> [Cited ]. WWW sources are defined unique by an URL. *Used way of citing* Online in Internet: URL: *URL-address* [Cited *Date of download*]. Cornell Law School: The Legal Information Institute. Supreme Court Collection. Online in Internet: URL: [Cited ]. For presence of URN, DOI or PURL this should be indicated additionally (see chapter URN, DOI, PURL and Handles ).
11 6 Special aspects 6.1 Separations in specifications of Internet sources The specification of Internet sources can also be longer than a line, so that it must be separated with a hyphen. In order to exclude mistakes with address constituents, the paragraph separation in this case should take place directly before the /. Gray, Matthew: Measuring the Size and Growth of the Web. 11/10/1994. Online in Internet: URL : http: //www.mit.edu:8001/afs- /sipb/user/mkgray/ht/webgrowth.html [Cited ]. 6.2 Citing of certain sections of an online publication How can a certain part of an online publication be cited? If the text is printed out, also here, by different printers, paper and character sizes, character fonts, a.s.o. the page numbers can differ. A minimum standard for electronic documents should be developed, in which for example the specification of page numbers in the text are defined. As a way out so far the possibility exists, of indicating sections or paragraphs; with large passages this is however in the long term unsatisfactory. There is the possibility of indicating a certain article as orientation, as increasing scope however also here arises the same problem. If in the published document an so called anchor is available, it can be indicated at the end of the URL after the character #. Payette, Sandra: Persistent Identifiers on the Digital Terrain. In: RLG [Research Library Group] DigiNews, April 15,1998, Volume 2, Number 2. Online in Internet: PURL: URL: [Cited ]. 6.3 Citing with references to original or printed sources If the online publication contains the abstract of another source and if the original is not accessible, then it should be proceeded as with a literature source from second-hand. This is marked usually by Cited in (Poenicke 1988, 170). For online publications in the Internet this could be indicated as Cited online in Internet or similar. America Online and Prodigy in Price War. In: Atlanta Journal-Constitution (10/13/1994). S. E2. Cited in Edupage (10/13/1994). Online in Internet: URL: [Cited ]. The information loss can be very high not only by the summary, but also by the omission of the original author in some publications. For existence of a printed and an online source both should be given, since the possibility of finding is increased thereby. For differencing and online in Internet can be used. Differences to the printed source, like the absence of pictures, diagrams among other things, should be indicated as e.g. [diagrams are missing]. In the example below the difference is indicated for the printed version of a book (the absence of the addresses) directly after and online in Internet as [addresses are missing]. Itschert, Michael: 33 Tips für Kleinverleger. Literatur, Adressen, Anregungen. 4. erw. und überarb. Auflage. Mainz: Gardez! And online in Internet: [addresses are missing] URL: [Cited ]. 6.4 Unfinished versions, work on progress It frequently occurs that in the Internet unfinished versions of publications are published to discuss these. During such a publication a remark in the source and in the citing should take place as for example work on progress.
12 6.5 Date format of online sources The specification of the date in english-language publications often takes place in the form month/day/year. To the better discoverable in online archives the format of date should be transferred in the original form. For the representation of current date and time-of-day ISO 8601:1988 (ISO 1988) should be used. This standard defines the specification with YYYY-MM-TT [year-month-day ]. Depending upon requirement also more exactly with YYYY-MM-TT HH:MM:SS [houre:minute:second] (International Standards Organisation 1988). 6.6 Further technical specification to the source Often the range of a publication is unknown. So it can occur that in unawareness a very large publication is downloaded over the network, this is strongly loaded thereby and the transfer costs could be high. E.g. the citing is given with a remark [size:...]. It can be decided in such a way whether the source is referred if necessary on an other way. In the future this aspect might become secondary due to the constantly growing transfer capacities. If the quoted source is not pure text (ASCII) or the data type is not clearly recognizable, these should additionally indicated at the end of the citing as e.g. [grafik], [audio] or [video]. In certain cases, it can be also meaningful to indicate certain character sets with the use of special characters (e.g. with necessity for a Chinese character set). If the text needs a special character set for the representation, this should be indicated by [character set: ], with texts only for certain computers, printers or programs e.g. by [Postscript version]. Likewise differences can exist with the marking of a line end; by the used operating system and the data type this is however often evident. In cases of doubt additionally [CR+LF], [CR] or [LF ] 3 can be indicated. In order to simplify the source specification, already existing standards for electronic documents if available should be used. (see chapter Dublin Core Metadata ) 6.7 Sources, which are available at several locations in the Internet By storing of sources at several different locations in the Internet, for example in the US and Germany, the data lines are fewer loaded during transfer of a place which was situated more near. Here it is to be noted that at different storing places different versions of information can be available, since an update can be delayed temporally or does no longer take place. The URN standard is intended to be able to refer with a URN to several locations. 7 Authors view and the expected development Today, most citings use mainly the specification of an URL with the date of download. The standards URN and DOI are not finished yet and I assume it still will take years to be adapted by the users and become generally accepted. If a publication has an URN or a DOI, additionally also the URL should be indicated for a certain transition period. An integration of the URL and URN is furthermore planned to the Uniform Resource Identification (URI); whether and when this standard is present and will be accepted is not clear. For the systematic description of electronic sources Dublin Core (DC) meta data can be inserted into the publication (Dublin Core Metadata initiative URL: [Cited ]). Among other things the bibliographic information are scanned automatically, distributed to other libraries and the publications can be substantially better looked up and found. In the future, the reader of an electronic work might be able to access a cited electronic publication with one mouse click either free of charge or against a (hopefully small) fee. It would be desirable to directly access certain paragraphs directly, in order to find the quoted location faster. The latter is so far however only rarely possible. 3 Carriage Return, Line Feed
13 8 List of literature Monographies American Psychological Association (1993): Publication Manual of the American Psychological Association. 3rd Edition. Washington, DC: American Psychological Association. Bleuel, Jens (1995): Online publizieren im Internet. Elektronische Zeitschriften und Bücher. Pfungstadt und Bensheim: Edition Ergon. Und Online in Internet: PURL: URL: [Cited ]. Li, Xia & Crane, Nancy B. (1993): Electronic Style: A Guide to Citing Electronic Information. Westport, London: Meckler. Poenicke, Klaus (1988): Wie verfaßt man wissenschaftliche Arbeiten? Ein Leitfaden vom ersten Studiensemester bis zur Promotion. 2., neu bearb. Aufl. Mannheim, Wien, Zürich: Dudenverlag. Scheller, Martin & Boden, Klaus-Peter & Geenen, Andreas (1994): Internet: Werkzeuge und Dienste. Von "Archie" bis "World Wide Web". Hg. Akademische Software Kooperation. Berlin u.a.: Springer. Magazines Lasher, Rebecca (1994): New Model Needed for Locating and Describing Networked Information. In: Serials Review 20 (1994), no Sollins, Karen R. (1994): The Hard Problems are not all Solved. In: Serials Review 20 (1994), no Internet publications Berners-Lee, Tim (1994a): WWW Names and Addresses, URIs, URLs, URNs. Online in Internet: URL: [Cited ]. Berners-Lee, Tim, L. Masinter, L., M. McCahill (1994b): Uniform Resource Locators (URL). Dezember Online in Internet: URL: ftp://ftp.isi.edu/in-notes/rfc1738.txt [Cited ]. Berners-Lee, Tim, R. Fielding, U.C. Irvine, L. Masinter (1998): Uniform Resource Identifiers (URI): Generic Syntax. August [RFC 2396]. Online in Internet: URL: ftp://ftp.isi.edu/in-notes/rfc2396.txt [Cited ]. Die Deutsche Bibliothek (1999): Dokumentserver DEPOSIT.DDB.DE. Frankfurt: Die Deutsche Bibliothek Online in Internet: URL: [Cited ]. International Standards Organisation (1988): ISO Data elements and interchange formats Information Interchange Representation of dates and times. Online in Internet: URL: [Cited ]. International Standards Organisation (1997): ISO Information and Documentation Bibliographic Reference Part 2: Electronic documents or parts thereof. Edition: 1 (Monolingual). [Excerpts] Online in Internet: URL: [Cited ]. Tuttles, Marcia (1991): The Newsletter on Serials Pricing Issues. In: Public-Access Computer Systems Review 2 (1991), no Online in Internet: URL: [Cited ]. Further Internet sources Die Deutsche Bibliothek URL: [Cited ] Sammlung von Netzpublikationen der Deutschen Bibliothek in Frankfurt URL: deposit.ddb.de/index.htm [Cited ]
14 Digital Library: Projekte und Arbeitsgruppen beim BSZ. Bibliotheksservice-Zentrum Baden-Würtemberg. URL: [Cited ] Dublin Core Metadata Initiative URL: [Cited ] Handle-System URN: hdl: /4000 URL: [Cited ] International DOI Foundation DOI: doi: /100 URL: [Cited ] Online Computer Libraray Center (OCLC) URL: [Cited ] PURL, Persitent Uniform Resource Locator URL: [Cited ] List of actual Internet protocol standards URL: ftp://ftp.isi.edu/in-notes/std/std1.txt [Cited ] International Organization for Standardisation (ISO) URL: [Cited ] Internet Society (Organisation für das Internet, seine Technologien und Anwendungen) URL: [Cited ] IETF: Internet Engineering Task Force (Download of RFCs) URL: [Cited ] An updated link list can be found at
ETD The application of Persistent Identifiers as one approach to ensure long-term referencing of Online-Theses Die Deutsche Bibliothek Table of Contents 1. Deficits of current addressing and identification
Standard quality of format and guidelines for thesis writing at the Berlin School of Economics and Law for International Marketing Management Refers to document FE-Marketing-Qualitätsstandards-20.4.2013-FV
Corrections to the First Printing of the Publication Manual of the American Psychological Association, Sixth Edition (July 2009) Errors in APA Style Rules The following are corrections to the first printing
INTERNET DOMAIN NAME SYSTEM http://www.tutorialspoint.com/internet_technologies/internet_domain_name_system.htm Copyright tutorialspoint.com Overview When DNS was not into existence, one had to download
Digital Object Identifier (DOI ) System Norman Paskin Tertius Ltd., Oxford, U.K. Abstract The Digital Object Identifier (DOI ) System is a managed system for persistent identification of content on digital
IOE Library Guide EndNote Cite While You Write FAQs We have compiled a list of the more frequently asked questions and answers about citing your references in Word and working with EndNote libraries (desktop
Evolution of the WWW Communication in the WWW World Wide Web (WWW) Access to linked documents, which are distributed over several computers in the History of the WWW Origin 1989 in the nuclear research
Handbook Articles Table of Contents I. Manuscript Submission 2 II. Article Structure 2 III. Figures, Tables, Audio Files, and Videos 3 IV. Style Preferences 4 V. Formatting 5 VI. Reference Style 5 I. Manuscript
E-Commerce Infrastructure II: the World Wide Web The Internet and the World Wide Web are two separate but related things Oct 15, 2004 www.dcs.bbk.ac.uk/~gmagoulas/teaching.html 1 Outline The Internet and
Final Revision: June 4, 2014 General Information Introduction Digital Data & Image Format Guidelines For School Photography and Yearbook Publication Version 2014-2015 The school picture industry offers
PAPER FORMATTING GUIDELINES FOR POLITICAL SCIENCE COURSES. VANDERBILT UNIVERSITY (For 2013-2014 Academic Year.) Your paper should begin with a cover page. Put your name on it, and a title, at least. Number
HARVARD STYLE (2002) GUIDE TO USING THE UQ LIBRARY ENDNOTE OUTPUT STYLE Harvard Style is a generic term for any style that uses citations in the text that look something like (Smith, 1999), with a bibliography
Internationalization of the Handle System A Persistent Global Name Service Sam X. Sun Corporation for National Research Initiatives Reston, VA USA email@example.com http://cnri.reston.va.us Abstract
Evolution of the WWW Communication in the WWW World Wide Web (WWW) Access to linked documents, which are distributed over several computers in the History of the WWW Origin 1989 in the nuclear research
persistent identifiers (pids): recommendations for institutions persistent identifiers (pids): recommendations for institutions edited by ATHENA WP3 Working Group Identifying standards and developing recommendations
The Intelligence Engine. Simple Search Simple Search offers a straightforward approach to searching, allowing you to target by source or date for high-quality relevant results. Key Word Searching Use the
Chapter NET 2 INTRODUCTION TO THE INTERNET AND WORLD WIDE WEB Before the 90 s the Internet was the domain of the computer industry, universities, and the government. Today there are many people that are
The Internet and Network Technologies Don Mason Associate Director Copyright 2013 National Center for Justice and the Rule of Law All Rights Reserved Inside vs. Outside Inside the Box What the computer
CONTENT of this CHAPTER v DNS v HTTP and WWW v EMAIL v SNMP 3.2.1 WWW and HTTP: Basic Concepts With a browser you can request for remote resource (e.g. an HTML file) Web server replies to queries (e.g.
PART 1: Setting up your EndNote Library 2 Creating an EndNote Library 2 Compressing your EndNote Library 2 Entering References into an Endnote Library 2 Importing References into an EndNote Library 3 PDF
St. Thomas University BUS 323 Human Resource Management Room 210 FFC Course Description: A survey course covering modern human resource management practices, including: human resource management in dynamic,
Search and Information Retrieval Search on the Web 1 is a daily activity for many people throughout the world Search and communication are most popular uses of the computer Applications involving search
25 UTILITIES PastPerfect provides a variety of utilities to help you manage your data. Two of the most important are accessed from the Main Menu Backup and Reindex. The other utilities are located within
Making Data Citable The German DOI Registration Agency for Social and Economic Data: da ra Stefanie Grunow (ZBW-Leibniz Information Centre for Economics, Kiel/Hamburg) Brigitte Hausstein (GESIS Leibniz
Analyzing PDFs with Citavi 5 Introduction Just Like on Paper... 2 Methods in Detail Highlight Only (Yellow)... 3 Highlighting with a Main Idea (Red)... 4 Adding Direct Quotations (Blue)... 5 Adding Indirect
ISO TC 46/SC 4 N515 Date: 2003-02-26 ISO 15836:2003(E) ISO TC 46/SC 4 Secretariat: ANSI Information and documentation The Dublin Core metadata element set Information et documentation Éléments fondamentaux
Email Basics Workshop Electronic mail, or email, is the most frequently used service on the Internet. Being able to use email effectively and efficiently is a core skill required in today s world. WLAC
Communicating access and usage policies to crawlers using extensions to the Robots Exclusion Protocol Part 1: Extension of robots.txt file format A component of the ACAP Technical Framework Implementation
St Patrick s College Maynooth Faculty of Theology Essay Writing Guidelines for Students in BD, BATh, BTh, and Higher Diploma in Theological Studies Academic Year 2014-15 Introduction This brief essay is
IOE Library Guide EndNote Beyond the Basics These notes assume that you know EndNote basics and are using it regularly. Additional tips and instruction is contained within the guides and FAQs available
form 12.181 03/15 page 1 of 8 Guidelines for the Purchase of Licences funded by the Within the framework of the Alliance Digital Information Initiative, licences for journals, databases and e-books are
WebSave - Archiving the Web for Scholar Work Christian Gütl Institute for Information processing and Computer supported new Media (IICM), Graz University of Technology, Austria, (firstname.lastname@example.org) Infodelio
Guide to Formatting 1 Header (consisting of the first 2-3 words of the title) w/page number at.5 from the top of page, 1 from right edge of page, and right justified. Insert the page number in the header,
Proc. Int. Conf. on Dublin Core and Metadata for e-communities 2002: 251-255 Firenze University Press Using Dublin Core for DISCOVER: a New Zealand visual art and music resource for schools Karen Rollitt,
Checklist: Persistent identifiers Persistent Identifiers (PID) are unique character strings 1 attached to various items. Attached to digital items, they are a prerequisite for linked data. Persistent identifiers
Website Planning Worksheet This planning worksheet is provided to assist you in thinking out the elements of your website. The more you know before you begin, the smoother the design process. We ask that
Copyright Fair Dealing Guidelines Introduction: University of Toronto faculty, staff and students are creators of material that is subject to the protections of the Copyright Act. They are also the users
Magenta CMS Training: RAF Station/ RAF Sport websites email@example.com 0207 490 1010 Introduction What is a website content management system? The content management system, or CMS, is software
OPENGREY: HOW IT WORKS AND HOW IT IS USED CHRISTIANE STOCK firstname.lastname@example.org INIST-CNRS, France Abstract OpenGrey is a unique repository providing open access to European grey literature references,
http://ezid.cdlib.org Service Guidelines 1 Purpose This document describes the key services and core policies underlying (CDL) s EZID Service. 2 Introduction to EZID EZID (easy eye dee) is a service providing
SOE GUIDELINES FOR APA STYLE SOE PD 32 FOR PAPERS, THESES AND DISSERTATIONS School of Education Colorado State University This document has three major sections: differences between APA and SOE styles,
Chapter 3 ADDRESS BOOK, CONTACTS, AND DISTRIBUTION LISTS 03Archer.indd 71 8/4/05 9:13:59 AM Address Book 3.1 What Is the Address Book The Address Book in Outlook is actually a collection of address books
ECDL / ICDL Web Editing Syllabus Version 2.0 Purpose This document details the syllabus for ECDL / ICDL Web Editing. The syllabus describes, through learning outcomes, the knowledge and skills that a candidate
Office of History Document Management System Using Code ZH Document The ZH Document (ZH DMS) uses a set of integrated tools to satisfy the requirements for managing its archive of electronic documents.
. WRITING FOR THE WEB Lynn Villeneuve email@example.com Adopting a specialized writing style for the web is important for reasons such as readability, search engine optimization and accessibility.
LOGISTICS MANAGEMENT INSTITUTE Recommended XML Namespace for Government Organizations GS301L1/AUGUST 2003 By Jessica L. Glace and Mark R. Crawford INTRODUCTION The Extensible Markup Language (XML) is rapidly
Zotero 1. Install Zotero works best with Firefox, but Google Chrome and Safari may be used standalone. If you need to download Mozilla go to http://www.mozilla.org/en-us/firefox/new/ and follow the prompts.
Delivery Context in Internet Protocols Larry Masinter Adobe Systems Incorporated Relevant Background! chair, HTTP working group ( 95-99)! editor & participant in many other IETF standards groups: " Internet
TS 184 009 V2.0.0 (2008-06) Technical Specification Telecommunications and Internet converged Services and Protocols for Advanced Networking (TISPAN); Rules covering the use of TV URIs for the Identification
The APA Documentation Style Guide Updated September 2010 For complete information, consult the APA Handbook, 6th edition Paper Formatting Papers should be written in 10-12 font, Times New Roman (or similar),
Whitepaper Going Above and Beyond Using Advanced Techniques to Create Customized HTML Templates August 3, 2010 Copyright 2010 L-Soft international, Inc. Information in this document is subject to change
OCLC Connexion Client Guides Cataloging: Save Bibliographic Records Last updated: May 2014 6565 Kilgour Place, Dublin, OH 43017-3395 www.oclc.org Revision History Date Section title Description of changes
How to Cite Information From This System How you cite material from this system will depend on the style you have been asked to use. This document covers three styles: Chicago style Modern Language Association
Master s Thesis Guide for the Master s Program Political and Empirical Economics June 2016 This guide is based on the experience gathered in supervising Master s Theses in the field of economics at the
Network Scanner Tool R3.1 User s Guide Version 3.0.04 Copyright 2000-2004 by Sharp Corporation. All rights reserved. Reproduction, adaptation or translation without prior written permission is prohibited,
Turabian Citation Style The Chicago Style for Students and Researchers, 8th edition, by Kate Turabian This is a general guide to the Turabian notes-bibliography style of citation, used most often by the
Taylor & Francis Standard Reference Style: APA APA (American Psychological Association) references are widely used in the social sciences, education, engineering and business. For detailed information,
Chapter 2 Encoding Text with a Small Alphabet Given the nature of the Internet, we can break the process of understanding how information is transmitted into two components. First, we have to figure out
Client/Server paradigm As we know, the World Wide Web is accessed thru the use of a Web Browser, more technically known as a Web Client. 1 A Web Client makes requests of a Web Server 2, which is software
1 Endnote Web: Beginners Guide to Using Endnote Web and the Cite While You Write Function 1 Endnote Web User Guide Version 3.4 Created: June 2012 Author: Jessica Eustace-Cook 1 Table of Contents 1. About
Glossary of Library Terms A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z Term A Abstract Advanced search B Basic search Bibliography Boolean operators C Call number Catalogue Definition An abstract
Final Revision: April 1, 2015 General Information Introduction Digital Data & Image Format Guidelines For School Photography and Yearbook Publication Version 2015-2016 The school picture industry offers
TOLLEY S VALUE ADDED TAX 2014 (SECOND EDITION) Excerpt from chapter 63: Special Schemes To order your copy of Tolley s Value Added Tax 2014 visit www.lexisnexis.co.uk or call 0845 370 1234. Special scheme
Guidance Notes for Teachers of Candidates with Special Requirements: Cambridge English Writing Papers Please read through the following information about Braille and Modified Large Print versions of Cambridge
Network Working Group Request for Comments: 2413 Category: Informational S. Weibel OCLC Online Computer Library Center, Inc. J. Kunze University of California, San Francisco C. Lagoze Cornell University
DATA CITATION what you need to know The current state of practice of the citation of datasets is seriously lacking. Acknowledgement of intellectual debts should not be limited to only certain formats of
LATINDEX GLOSSARY This Glossary includes only the terminology used by the Latindex System for a number of purposes including: the methodology for registering journals in the Catalogue, the technical terms
ETD 2003, Berlin Persistent Identifier Management at Die Deutsche Bibliothek Die Deutsche Bibliothek 1 Table of Contents 1 Deficits of existing address and identification methods 2 Persistent Identifiers
Fixes for CrossTec ResQDesk Fixes in CrossTec ResQDesk 5.00.0006 December 2, 2014 Resolved issue where the list of Operators on Category was not saving correctly when adding multiple Operators. Fixed issue
EBSCOhost User Guide Searching Basic, Advanced & Visual Searching, Result List, Article Details, Additional Features Table of Contents What is EBSCOhost... 3 System Requirements... 3 Inside this User Guide...
Stanford Newspaper Visualization By Lisa Louise Cooke Data Visualization is a growing trend online and Stanford University s Rural West Initiative at the Bill Lane Center for the American West uses this
EDITING STYLES FOR THESES/DISSERTATIONS SOUTHERN UNIVERSITY AND A&M COLLEGE OFFICE OF GRADUATE STUDIES EDITING YOUR THESIS/DISSERTATION What is Involved? Editing is all about making it easy for the reader
WEB SITE DEVELOPMENT WORKSHEET Thank you for considering Xymmetrix for your web development needs. The following materials will help us evaluate the size and scope of your project. We appreciate you taking
Learning Services Study Guides Bibliographies and Referencing: Chicago Style 1. Introduction This guide provides an introduction to bibliographies and referencing, and should help you with general points
Running head: APA FORMAT REVIEW FOR SIXTH EDITION 1 PAGE SETUP (Section 8.03, pp. 228-230) Uniform margins of at least one inch on all sides All parts double spaced No extra spacing before or after the
1 Online searching: Emerald Electronic Database This is an introduction to the concept of Online Searching as specifically applied to the Emerald database. This tutorial will guide you through the initial
HP Web Jetadmin Database Connector Plug-in reference manual Copyright notice 2004 Copyright Hewlett-Packard Development Company, L.P. Reproduction, adaptation or translation without prior written permission