Why Don t We See Poverty Convergence?


 Kellie Thompson
 2 years ago
 Views:
Transcription
1 Why Don t We See Poverty Convergence? Martn Ravallon 1 Development Research Group, World Bank 1818 H Street NW, Washngton DC, 20433, USA Abstract: We see sgns of convergence n average lvng standards amongst developng countres and of greater progress aganst poverty n faster growng economes. Yet we do not see poverty convergence; the poorest countres are not enjoyng hgher rates of poverty reducton. The paper tres to explan why. Consstently wh some growth theores, analyss of a new data set for 100 developng countres reveals an adverse effect on consumpton growth of hgh nal poverty ncdence at a gven nal mean. Startng wh a hgh ncdence of poverty also entals a lower rate of progress aganst poverty at any gven growth rate (and conversely poor countres tend to experence less steep ncreases n poverty durng recessons). Thus, for many poor countres, the growth advantage of startng out wh a low mean s lost due to ther hgh poverty rates. The sze of the mddle class measured by developngcountry, not Western, standards appears to be an mportant channel lnkng current poverty to subsequent growth and poverty reducton. However, hgh current nequaly s only a handcap f entals a hgh ncdence of poverty relatve to mean consumpton. Keywords: Poverty trap, mddle class, nequaly, economc growth JEL: D31, I32, O15 1 These are the vews of the author and should not be attrbuted to the World Bank or any afflated organzaton. Address: The author s grateful to Shaohua Chen and Prem Sangraula for help n settng up the data set used here. Helpful comments were receved from Karla Hoff, Aart Kraay, Lus Servén, Domnque van de Walle, partcpants at presentatons at the World Bank, the Courant Research Center, Göttngen, the 2009 meetng n Buenos Ares of the Network on Inequaly and Poverty and the Instute of Socal Scences, Cornell Unversy.
2 1. Introducton Two promnent stylzed facts about economc development are that there s an advantage of backwardness, such that on comparng two otherwse smlar countres the one wh the lower nal mean ncome wll tend to see the hgher rate of growth, and that there s an advantage of growth, whereby a hgher mean ncome tends to come wh a lower ncdence of absolute poverty. Past emprcal support for both stylzed facts has almost nvarably assumed that the dynamc processes for growth and poverty reducton do not depend drectly on the nal level of poverty. Under that assumpton, the two stylzed facts mply that we should see poverty convergence: countres startng out wh a hgh ncdence of absolute poverty (reflectng a lower mean) should enjoy a hgher subsequent growth rate and (hence) hgher proportonate rate of poverty reducton. Indeed, as wll be demonstrated later, the mean and the poverty rate wll have the same speed of convergence n wdelyused loglnear models. That poses a puzzle. As ths paper wll also show, there s no sgn of poverty convergence amongst developng countres, let alone a smlar speed of convergence to that found for the mean. The overall ncdence of poverty s fallng n the developng world, but no faster (n proportonate terms) n s poorest countres. 2 Clearly somethng s mssng from the story. Intuvely, one hypothess s that eher the growth process n the mean, or the mpact of growth on poverty, depends drectly on the nal poverty rate, n a way that nullfes the advantage of backwardness. Later I wll pont to a number of theoretcal arguments as to how ths can happen. To test ths hypothess, a new data set was constructed for ths paper from household surveys for almost 100 developng countres, each wh two or more surveys over tme. These data are used to estmate a model n whch the rate of progress aganst poverty depends on the rate of growth n the mean and varous parameters of the nal dstrbuton encompassng those dentfed n the lerature whle the rate of growth depends n turn on nal dstrbuton as well as the nal mean. The model s subjected to a number of tests, ncludng alternatve functonal forms, sample selecton by type of survey, and alternatve measures are used for the key varables. A subsample wh three or more surveys s also used to test robustness to 2 Note that poverty convergence s defned n proportonate rather than absolute terms, n keepng wh usage the n the growth lerature. The absence of poverty convergence by ths defnon mples that poorer countres tend to see larger absolute reductons n ther poverty rate. 2
3 dfferent specfcaton choces, ncludng treatng nal dstrbuton as endogenous by treatng lagged nal dstrbuton as excludable. The results suggest that meanconvergence s counteracted by two dstnct poverty effects. Frst, there s an adverse drect effect of hgh nal poverty on growth workng aganst convergence n mean ncomes. Second, hgh nal poverty dulls the mpact of growth on poverty; the poor enjoy a lower share of the gans from growth n poorer countres. On balance there s ltle or no systematc effect of startng out poor on the rate of poverty reducton. Other aspects of the nal dstrbuton play no more than a secondary role. Hgh nal nequaly only matters to growth and poverty reducton n so far as entals a hgh nal ncdence of poverty relatve to the mean. Countres startng out wh a small mddle class judged by developng country rather than Western standards face a handcap n promotng growth and poverty reducton though ths too s largely accountable to dfferences n the ncdence of poverty. 2. Past theores and evdence Growth theores ncorporatng credmarket falure suggest that hgh nequaly reduces an economy s aggregate effcency and (hence) growth rate. 3 The market falure s typcally attrbuted to nformaton asymmetres that lenders are poorly nformed about borrowers. The key analytc feature of such models s a suably nonlnear relatonshp between an ndvdual s nal wealth and her future wealth (the recurson dagram ). The economc ratonale for a nonlnear recurson dagram s that the cred market falure leaves unexploed opportunes for nvestment n physcal and human capal and that there are dmnshng margnal products of capal. Then mean future wealth wll be a quasconcave functon of the dstrbuton of current wealth; thus hgher current nequaly mples lower future mean wealth at a gven value of current mean wealth. Models wh such features nclude Galor and Zera (1993), Benabou (1996), Aghon and Bolton (1997) and Banerjee and Duflo (2003). But s nequaly that matters, or somethng else, such as poverty or the sze of the mddle class? Inequaly s obvously not the same thng as poverty; nequaly can be reduced 3 There are a number of surveys ncludng Perott (1996), Hoff (1996), Aghon et al. (1999), Bardhan et al. (2000), Banerjee and Duflo (2003), Azarads (2006) and World Bank (2006, Chapter 5). Borrowng constrants are not the only way that nequaly can matter to growth. Another class of models s based on the dea that hgh nequaly restrcts effcencyenhancng cooperaton, such that key publc goods are underprovded or effcencyenhancng polcy reforms are blocked (Bardhan et al., 2000). Other models argue that hgh nequaly leads democratc governments to mplement dstortonary redstrbutve polces, as n Alesna and Rodrk (1994). 3
4 whout a lower poverty measure by redstrbutng ncome amongst the nonpoor, and poverty can be reduced whout lower nequaly. (Smlarly, efforts to help the mddleclass may do ltle to releve current poverty.) In fact there s another mplcaton of cred market falures that has receved very ltle attenton. 4 The followng secton studes one theoretcal model from the lerature more closely and shows that the smple fact of a cred constrant mples that unambguously hgher current poverty ncdence defned by any poverty lne up to the mnmum level of nal wealth needed to not be lqudy constraned n nvestment yelds lower growth at a gven level of mean current wealth. Ths s not the only argument suggestng that poverty s a relevant parameter of the nal dstrbuton. Lopez and Servén (2009) ntroduce a subsstence consumpton requrement nto the utly functon n the model of Aghon et al. (1999) and show that hgher poverty ncdence (falure to meet the subsstence requrement) mples lower growth. Another example can be found n the theores that have postulated mpatence for consumpton (hgh tme preference rates possbly assocated wh low lfe expectancy) and hence low savngs and nvestment rates by the poor (see, for example, Azarads, 2006). Here too, whle the theoretcal lerature has focused on nal nequaly, can also be argued that a hgher nal ncdence of poverty means a hgher proporton of mpatent consumers and hence lower growth. Yet another example s found by consderng how work productvy s lkely to be affected by past nutronal and health status. Only when past nutronal ntakes have been hgh enough (above basal metabolc rate) wll be possble to do any work, but dmnshng returns to work wll set n later; see the model n Dasgupta and Ray (1986). Followng Cunha and Heckman (2007), ths type of argument can be broadened to nclude other aspects of chld development that have lastng mpacts on learnng ably and earnngs as an adult. By mplcaton, havng a larger share of the populaton who grew up n poverty wll have a lastng negatve mpact on an economy s aggregate output. There are also theoretcal arguments nvolvng market and nstutonal development, though ths s not a topc that has so far receved as much attenton n ths lerature. Whle past theores have often taken credmarket falures to be exogenous, poverty may well be a deeper causatve factor n fnancal development (as well as an outcome of the lack of fnancal 4 Ravallon (2001, 2007) argues ntuvely that poverty retards growth when there are cred market falures. 4
5 development). For example, gven fxed cost of lendng (both for each loan and for settng up the lendng nstuton), lqudy constrants can readly emerge as the norm n very poor socetes. A strand of the theoretcal lerature has also ponted to the possbles for multple equlbra n nonlnear dynamc models, whereby the lowest equlbrum s a poverty trap ( lowlevel attractor ). Essentally, the recurson dagram now has a lowlevel nonconvexy, whereby a mnmum level of current wealth s essental before any posve level of future wealth can be reached. In poor countres, the nutronal requrements for work can readly generate such dynamcs, as llustrated by the model of Dasgupta and Ray (1986). Such a model predcts that a large exogenous ncome gan may be needed to attan a permanently hgher ncome and that seemngly smlar aggregate shocks can have dssmlar outcomes; growth models wh such features are also dscussed n Day (1992) and Azarades (1996, 2006) amongst others. Sachs (2005) has nvoked such models to argue that a large expanson of development ad would be needed to assure a permanently hgher average ncome n currently poor countres. 2.1 A model of aggregate growth wh mcro borrowng constrants I now explore one of these models more fully. Banerjee and Duflo (2003) provde a smple but nsghtful growth model wh borrowng constrants. Someone who starts her productve lfe wh suffcent wealth s able to nvest her unconstraned optmal amount, equatng the (declnng) margnal product of her capal wh the nterest rate. But the wealth poor, for whom the borrowng constrant s bndng, are unable to do so. Banerjee and Duflo show that hgher nequaly n such an economy mples lower growth. However, they do not observe that ther model also mples that hgher current wealth poverty for a gven mean wealth also mples lower growth. The followng dscusson uses the BanerjeeDuflo model to llustrate ths hypothess, whch wll be tested later n the paper. The basc set up of the BanerjeeDuflo model s as follows. Current wealth, w t, s dstrbuted across ndvduals accordng to the cumulatve dstrbuton functon, p F (w), gvng the populaton proporton p wh wealth lower than w at date t. It wll be analytcally easer to work wh the quantle functon, w t ( p) (the nverse of (w) ). The cred market s mperfect, such that ndvduals can only borrow up to tmes ther wealth. Each person has a strctly concave producton functon yeldng output h (k) from a capal stock k. Gven the rate F t t 5
6 of nterest r (taken to be fxed) the desred capal stock s k, such that h ( k ) r. Those wh nal wealth less than k /( 1) are cred constraned n that, after nvestng all they can, they stll fnd that h ( k t ) r, whle the rest are free to mplement k. A share 1 (0,1 ) of current wealth s consumed, leavng for the next perod. Under these assumptons, the recurson dagram takes the form: wt 1 ( wt ) [ h(( 1) wt ) rwt ] for w t k /( 1) (1.1) [ h( k ) ( w k ) r] for w t k /( 1) (1.2) t Planly, w ) s strctly concave up to k /( 1) and lnear above that. Mean future wealth s: ( t 0 t 1 [ w t ( p)] dp (2) By standard propertes of concave functons, we have: Proposon 1: (Banerjee and Duflo, 2003, p.277): An exogenous meanpreservng spread n the wealth dstrbuton n ths economy wll reduce future wealth and by mplcaton the growth rate. However, the BanerjeeDuflo model has a further mplcaton concernng poverty, as another aspect of the nal dstrbuton. Let Ht F t(z) denote the headcount ndex of poverty ( poverty rate ) n ths economy when the poverty lne s z. I assume that z k /( 1) and let H F [ k /( 1)]. Usng (1.1) and (1.2) we can rewre (2) as: t t [ h(( 1) w ( p)) rw ( p)] dp [ h( k ) ( w ( p) k ) r] dp (3) t1 Ht 0 t t Now consder the growth effect of a meanpreservng ncrease n the poverty rate. I assume that H ncreases and that no ndvdual wh wealth less than k /( 1) becomes better off, t mplyng that w ( p) / H 0 for all t unambguously hgher. It s readly verfed that: 5 t 1 Ht p H t. If ths holds then I wll say that poverty s t H t H 1 ( ) t t wt p wt ( p) [ h(( 1) w ( ))( 1) ] t p r dp r Ht H 0 t H 0 t dp (4) 5 Note that the functon defned by equatons (1.1) and (1.2) s contnuous at k /( 1). 6
7 The sgn of (4) cannot be determned under the assumptons so far. 6 However, on mposng a constant nal mean H Thus we also have: t, equaton (4) smplfes to: H t t 1 wt ( p) [ (( 1) ( )) ]( 1) h wt p r dp t H 0 t t Proposon 2: In the BanerjeeDuflo model an unambguously hgher nal headcount ndex of poverty holdng the nal mean constant mples a lower growth rate. Ths model mples an aggregate effcency cost of a hgh ncdence of poverty. But a number of ponts should be noted. An nequaly effect s stll present separately to the poverty effect. And the less poverty there s, the less mportant overall nequaly s to subsequent growth prospects. Also note that the theoretcal predcton concerns the level of poverty at a gven nal value of mean wealth. Whout controllng for the nal mean, the sgn of the effect of hgher poverty on growth s ambguous. Two opposng effects can be dentfed. The frst s the usual condonal convergence property, whereby countres wh a lower nal mean (and hence hgher nal poverty) tend to have hgher subsequent growth. Aganst ths, there s an adverse dstrbutonal effect of hgher poverty (Proposon 2). Whch effect domnates s an emprcal queston. 2.2 Past evdence on growth and the nal dstrbuton Followng Barro and SalaMartn (1992), crosscountry regressons for GDP growth rates have found a sgnfcant negatve coeffcent on nal GDP once one controls for nal condons. A subset of the lerature has used nequaly as one such nal condon. Support for the vew that hgher nal nequaly mpedes growth has been reported by Alesna and Rodrk (1994), Persson and Tabelln (1994), Brdsall et al., (1995), Clarke (1995), Perott (1996), Dennger and Squre (1998), Knowles (2005) and Vochovsky (2005). Not all the evdence has been supportve; also see L and Zou (1999), Barro (2000) and Forbes (2000). The man reason why the latter studes have been less supportve appears to be that they have allowed for addve countrylevel fxed effects n growth rates; I wll return to ths pont. 0 (5) 6 If there s (unrestrcted) frstorder domnance, whereby w ( p)/ H 0 for all p [0, 1], then t 1 / H t 0. However, frstorder domnance s ruled out by the fact that the mean s held constant n ths though experment; there s a redstrbuton from the wealth poor to the wealth nonpoor. t t 7
8 There are a number of unresolved specfcaton ssues n ths lerature. The aspect of nal dstrbuton that has receved almost all the attenton n the emprcal lerature s nequaly, as typcally measured by the Gn ndex. Wealth nequaly s arguably more relevant though ths has rarely been used due to data lmatons. 7 The populary of the Gn ndex appears to owe more to s avalably n secondary data complatons than any ntrnsc relevance to the economc arguments. 8 In the only paper I know of n whch a poverty measure was used as a regressor for aggregate growth across countres, Lopez and Servén (2009) fnd evdence that a hgher nal poverty rate retards growth. As Lopez and Servén observe, the sgnfcance of the Gn ndex n past studes may reflect an omted varable bas, gven that one expects (and I wll later verfy emprcally) that nequaly wll be hghly correlated wh poverty at a gven mean. There are also ssues about the relevant control varables when studyng the effect of nal dstrbuton on growth. The specfcaton choces n past work testng for effects of nal dstrbuton have lacked clear justfcaton n terms of the theores predctng such effects. Consder three popular predctors of growth, namely human development, the nvestment share, and fnancal development. On the frst, basc schoolng and health attanments (often sgnfcant n growth regressons) are arguably one of the channels lnkng nal dstrbuton to growth. Indeed, that s the lnk n the orgnal Galor and Zera (1993) model. 9 Turnng to the second, one of the most robust predctors of growth rates s the share of nvestment n GDP (Levne and Renelt, 1992); yet arguably one of the man channels through whch dstrbuton affects growth s va aggregate nvestment and ths s one of the channels dentfed n the theoretcal lerature. Fnally, consder prvate cred (as a share of GDP), whch has been used as a measure of fnancal sector development n explanng growth and poverty reducton (Beck et al., 2000, 2007). The theores dscussed above based on borrowng constrants suggest that the aggregate flow of cred n the economy depends on the nal dstrbuton. Another set of specfcaton ssues concerns nteracton effects. As Banerjee and Duflo (2003) pont out, whle lqudy constrants stemmng from credmarket falures mply that the 7 An excepton s Ravallon (1998), who studes the effect of geographc dfferences n the dstrbuton of wealth on growth n Chna. 8 The complaton of Gn ndces from secondary sources (and not usng consstent assumptons) n Dennger and Squre (1996) led to almost all the tests n the lerature snce that paper was publshed. 9 More recently, Gutérrez and Tanaka (2009) show how hgh nal nequaly n a developng country can yeld a polcaleconomy equlbrum n whch there s ltle or no publc nvestment n basc schoolng; the poorest famles send ther kds to work, and the rchest turn to prvate schoolng. 8
9 growth rate depends on the extent of nequaly n the nal dstrbuton, they also suggest that there wll be an nteracton effect between the nal mean and nequaly. However, as the further analyss of the BanerjeeDuflo model n the last secton suggests, the more relevant nteracton effect may well be that between poverty and nequaly. Some of the lerature has focused nstead on testng the assumptons of these theores. The emprcal evdence on poverty traps s mxed. At least some of the theoretcal models of poverty traps appear to be hard to reconcle wh the aggregate data; see, n partcular, the dscusson n Kraay and Raddatz (2007) of poverty traps that mght arse from low savngs (hgh tme preference rates) n poor countres. There are also testable mplcatons for mcro data. An mplcaton of a number of the models based on credmarket falures s that ndvdual ncome or wealth at one date should be an ncreasng concave functon of s own past value. Ths can be tested on mcro panel data. Lokshn and Ravallon (2004) provde supportve evdence n panel data for Hungary and Russa whle Jalan and Ravallon (2004) do so usng panel data for Chna. These mcro studes suggest seemngly szeable effcency costs of nequaly. The same studes do not, however, fnd the propertes n the emprcal ncome dynamcs that would be needed for a poverty trap. There s also evdence of nonlnear wealth effects on new busness start ups n developng countres, though wh ltle sgn of a nonconvexy at low levels due to lumpness n capal requrements (Mesnard and Ravallon, 2006). Smlarly, McKenze and Woodruff (2006) fnd no sgn of nonconvexes n producton at low levels amongst Mexcan mcroenterprses. However, Hoddnott (2006) and Barrett et al (2006) fnd evdence of wealthdfferentated behavors n addressng rsk n rural Zmbabwe and Kenya (respectvely) that are consstent wh the dea of poverty traps. Mcroemprcal support for the clam that there are effcency costs of poor nutron and health care for chldren n poor famles has come from a number of studes. In a recent example, an mpact evaluaton by Macours et al. (2008) of a condonal cash transfer scheme n Ncaragua found that randomly assgned cash transfers to poor famles mproved the cognve outcomes of chldren through hgher ntakes of nutronrch foods and better health care. Ths echoes a number of fndngs on the benefs to dsadvantaged chldren of efforts to compensate for famly poverty; for a revew see Curre (2001). Whle the theores and evdence revewed above pont to nequaly and/or poverty as the relevant parameters of the nal dstrbuton, yet another strand of the lerature has ponted to 9
10 varous reasons why the sze of a country s mddle class can matter to the fortunes of those not (yet) so lucky to be mddle class. It has been argued that a larger mddle class promotes economc growth, such as by fosterng entrepreneurshp, shftng the composon of consumer demand, and makng more polcally feasble to attan polcy reforms and nstutonal changes conducng to growth. Analyses of the role of the mddle class n promotng entrepreneurshp and growth nclude Acemoglu and Zlbott (1997) and Doepke and Zlbott (2005). Mddleclass demand for hgher qualy goods plays a role n the model of Murphy et al. (1989). Brdsall et al. (2000) conjecture that support from the mddle class s crucal to reform. Srdharan (2004) descrbes the role of the Indan mddle class n promotng reform. Easterly (2001) fnds evdence that a larger ncome share controlled by the mddle three quntles promotes economc growth. So we have three contenders for the dstrbutonal parameter most relevant to growth: nequaly, poverty and the sze of the mddle class. The fact that very few encompassng tests are found n the lerature, and that these dfferent measures of dstrbuton are not ndependent, leaves one n doubt about what aspect of dstrbuton really matters. As already noted, when the nal value of mean ncome s ncluded n a growth regresson alongsde nal nequaly, but nal poverty s an excluded but relevant varable, the nequaly measure may pck up the effect of poverty rather than nequaly per se. Smlarly, the man way the mddle class expands n a developng country s probably through poverty reducton, so s unclear whether s a hgh ncdence of poverty or a small mddle class that mpedes growth. Smlarly, a relatve concept of the mddle class, such as the ncome share of mddle quntles, wll probably be hghly correlated wh a relatve nequaly measure, cloudng the nterpretaton. 2.3 Growth and poverty reducton The consensus n the lerature s that hgher growth rates tend to yeld more rapd rates of absolute poverty reducton; see World Bank (1990, 2000), Ravallon (1995, 2001, 2007), Felds (2001) and Kraay (2006). 10 Ths s mpled by another common fndng n the lerature, namely that growth n developng countres tends to be dstrbutonneutral on average, meanng that changes n nequaly are roughly orthogonal to growth rates n the mean (Ravallon, 1995, 2001; Ferrera and Ravallon, 2009). Dstrbutonneutraly n the growth process mples that the 10 Also see the revew of the arguments and evdence on ths pont n Ferrera and Ravallon (2009). 10
11 changes n any standard measure of absolute poverty (meanng that the poverty lne s fxed n real terms) wll be negatvely correlated wh growth rates n the mean. There s also evdence that nequaly matters to how much a gven growth rate reduces poverty (Ravallon, 1997, 2007; World Bank, 2000, 2006; Bourgugnon, 2003; Lopez and Servén, 2006). Intuvely, n hgh nequaly countres the poor wll tend to have a lower share of the gans from growth. Ravallon (1997, 2007) examned ths ssue emprcally usng household survey data over tme (earler versons of the data set used here). Ravallon (1997) found that the followng parsmonous specfcaton fs the data for developng countres well: where H, ln H (1 1 ) ln (6) G and G are the headcount ndex, the Gn ndex and the mean respectvely for country at date t, 0 s the elastcy of poverty reducton to the dstrbutoncorrected growth rate ( 1 1 G ) ln and s a zero mean error term (uncorrelated wh the growth rates). At mnmum nequaly ( G 1 0 ) growth has s maxmum effect on poverty (n expectaton) whle the elastcy reaches zero at maxmum nequaly ( G 1 1). Ravallon (1997) dd not fnd that the elastcy vared systematcally wh the mean, although Lopez and Servén (2006) showed that f ncomes are lognormally dstrbuted then such a varaton s mpled theoretcally. Easterly (2009) conjectured that the nal poverty rate s lkely to be the better predctor of the elastcy than nal nequaly, though no evdence was provded. 3. Data and descrptve statstcs In keepng wh the bulk of the lerature, the country s the un of observaton. 11 However, unlke past data sets n the lerature on growth emprcs, ths one s frmly anchored to the household surveys, n keepng wh the focus on the role played by the nal dstrbuton, whch s measured from surveys. By calculatng the dstrbutonal statstcs drectly from the prmary data, some of the nconsstences and comparably problems found n exstng data complatons from secondary sources can be elmnated. However, there s no choce but to use household consumpton or ncome, rather than the theoretcally preferable concept of wealth. 11 It s known that aggregaton can hde the true relatonshps between the nal dstrbuton and growth, gven the nonlneares nvolved at the mcro level (Ravallon, 1998); dentfyng the deeper structural relatonshps would requre mcro data, and even then the dentfcaton problems can be formdable. 11
12 I found 99 developng and transon countres wh at least two suable household surveys snce about (For about 70 of these countres there are three or more surveys.) For the bulk of the analyss I restrct the sample to the 92 countres n whch the earlest avalable survey fnds that at least some households lved below the average poverty lne for developng countres (descrbed below). 12 Ths happens mechancally gven that log transformatons are used. However, also has the defensble effect of droppng a number of the countres of Eastern Europe and Central Asa (EECA) (ncludng the former Sovet Unon); ndeed, all of the countres wh an nal poverty rate (by developng country standards) of zero are n EECA. As s well known, these countres started ther transons from socalst command economes to market economes wh very low poverty rates, but poverty measures then rose sharply. 13 The earlest avalable surveys pck up these low poverty rates, wh a number of countres havng no sampled household lvng below the poverty lnes typcal of developng countres. Wh the subsequent rse n poverty ncdence, ths looks lke convergence, but has ltle or nothng to do wh neoclasscal growth processes rather s a polcy convergence effect assocated wh the transon. The experence of these countres s clearly not typcal of the developng world. The longest spell between two surveys s used for each country. Both surveys use the same welfare ndcator, eher consumpton or ncome per person, followng standard measurement practces. When both are avalable, consumpton s preferred, n the expectaton that s both a better measure of current economc welfare and that s lkely to be measured wh less error than ncomes; 14 threequarters of the spells use consumpton. Naturally the tme perods between surveys are not unform across countres. The medan year of the frst survey s 1991 whle the medan for the second s The medan nterval between surveys s 13 years and vares from three to 27 years. All changes between the surveys are annualzed. Gven the most recent household survey for date t n country and the earlest avalable survey for date t, the proportonate annualzed dfference ( growth rate ) for the varable x s denoted g x ) ln( x / x ) (droppng the subscrpt on t and for brevy). ( / Natonal accounts (NAS) data and socal ndcators are also used, matched as closely as possble 12 The data set was constructed from PovcalNet n December Seven countres were dropped because the poverty rate was zero n the earlest surveys. 13 Pror to the global fnancal crss there were sgns that poverty measures were fnally fallng n the regon, snce the later 1990s; see Chen and Ravallon (2008). 14 The only excepton was Peru, for whch ncomes allowed a much longer tme perod. 12
13 to survey dates. All monetary measures are n constant 2005 prces (usng countryspecfc Consumer Prce Indces) and are at Purchasng Power Pary (PPP) usng the ndvdual consumpton PPPs from the 2005 Internatonal Comparson Program (World Bank, 2008). Poverty s manly measured by the headcount ndex ( H ), gven by the proporton of the populaton lvng n households wh consumpton per capa (or ncome when consumpton s not avalable) below $2.00 per day at 2005 PPP, whch s the medan poverty lne amongst developng countres. 15 Let F (z) denote the dstrbuton functon for country at date t; then H F (2). In 2005, $2 a day was also very close to the medan consumpton per person n the developng world. Ths lne s clearly somewhat arbrary; for example, there s no good reason to suppose that $2 a day corresponds to the pont where cred constrants cease to be, but nor s there any obvously better bass for settng a threshold. I wll also consder a lower lne of $1.25 a day and a much hgher lne of $13 a day n 2005, correspondng to the US poverty lne. 16 Inequaly s measured by the usual Gn ndex ( G ) half the mean absolute dfference between all pars of ncomes normalzed by the overall mean. The sze of the mddle class ( MC ) s measured by the proporton of the populaton lvng between $2 and $13 a day (followng Ravallon, 2009); so MC F 13) F (2). 17 ( These bounds are also somewhat arbrary, although ths defnon appears to accord roughly wh the dea of what means to be mddle class n Chna and Inda (Ravallon, 2009). By contrast, those lvng above $13 a day can be thought of as the mddle class by Western standards; the share of the Western mddle class s F (13). These are nterpretable as 1 absolute measures of the mddle class. I also calculated a relatve defnon of the mddle class, namely the consumpton or ncome share controlled by the mddle three quntles ( MQ ), as used by Easterly (2001). Table 1 provdes summary statstcs for both the earlest and latest survey rounds. The mean Gn ndex stayed roughly unchanged at about 42%. The nal ndex ranged from 19.4% 15 Ths s based on the complaton of natonal poverty lnes presented n Ravallon et al. (2009). The methods used n measurng poverty and nequaly usng these data are descrbed n Chen and Ravallon (2008). 16 The $1.25 lne s the mean of the poorest 15 countres n terma of consumpton per person. $13 per person per day corresponds to the offcal poverty lne n the US for a famly of four; see Department of Health and Human Servces. 17 Smlarly Banerjee and Duflo (2008) used the nterval $2 to $10 a day to defne the mddle class. 13
14 (Czech Republc) to 62.9% (Serra Leone), both around In the earlest surveys, about one quarter of the sample had a Gn ndex below 30% whle one quarter had an ndex above 50%. The average sze of the mddle class ncreased, from a mean MC of 48% to a mean MC of 53%. The mddleclass expanded n 64 countres and contracted n 35. There s also a marked bmodaly n the dstrbuton of countres by the sze of ther mddle class, as s evdent n Fgure 1, whch plots the kernel denses of MC and MC. Takng 40% as the cutoff pont, 30 countres are n the lower mode and 69 are n the upper one for the most recent survey; the correspondng counts for the earlest surveys are 42 and The relatve measure of the sze of the mddle class behaved dfferently; there was ltle change n the mean MQ over tme (Table 1) and the densy functon was unmodal n both the earlest and latest surveys. Table 2 gves the correlaton coeffcents, focusng on the man regressors used later. The correlatons pont to a number of potental concerns about the nferences drawn from past research. The Gn ndex s hghly (negatvely) correlated wh the ncome share of the mddle three quntles (r= for the earlest surveys and for the latest). The poverty measures are also strongly correlated wh the survey means; ln H and ln have a correlaton of (whle s for ln F (1.25) and ln ). The leastsquares elastcy of ln H wh respect to the nal survey mean (.e., the regresson coeffcent of ln H on ln ) s (t=13.340). (All tratos n ths paper are based on Whe standard errors.) There s a very hgh correlaton between the poverty measures usng $1.25 a day and $2.00 a day (r=0.974). There are weaker correlatons between the two poverty measures and the nal Gn ndex (r= and for z=1.25 and z=2.00). However, there s also a strong multple correlaton between the poverty measures (on the one hand) and the log mean and log nequaly (on the other); for example, regressng ln H on ln and ln G one obtans R 2 = The log Gn ndex also has a strong partal correlaton wh the log of the poverty rates holdng the log mean constant (t=4.329 for ln H ). The sze of the mddle class s also hghly correlated wh the poverty rate; the correlaton coeffcent between MC and H s ; 95% of the varance n the nal sze of the 18 For further dscusson of the developng world s rapdly expandng mddle class, and the countres left behnd n ths process, see Ravallon (2009). 14
15 mddle class s accountable to dfferences n the nal poverty rate. (The bmodaly n terms of the sze of the mddle class n Fgure 1 reflects a smlar bmodaly n terms of the $2 a day poverty rate.) Across countres, 80% of the varance n the changes over tme n MC can also be attrbuted to the changes n H. 19 The absolute and relatve measures of the sze of the mddle class are posvely correlated but not strongly so. There s a strong correlaton between the rate of poverty reducton and the ordnary growth rate n the survey mean (confrmng the studes revewed n secton 2). Fgure 2 plots the rate of poverty reducton ( g H ) ) aganst g ). The regresson lne n Fgure 2 has a slope of ( (t=5.948) wh R 2 = ( Snce the tme perod between surveys ( ) fgures n the calculaton of the growth rates mght be conjectured that poorer countres have longer perods between surveys, basng the later results. Table 2 also gves the correlaton coeffcents between and the varous measures of nal dstrbuton. The correlatons are all small. Whle ths paper focuses manly on the developng world as a whole, one regon stands out: SubSaharan Afrca (SSA). By the $2.00 a day lne, the mean of H for SSA s 76.04% as compared to 29.51% for nonssa countres; the dfference s sgnfcant (t=8.84). Smlarly, n terms of the sze of s mddle class, SSA s more concentrated n the lower mode n Fgure 1. Twothrds (20 out of 29) of SSA countres are n the lower mode for the earler survey round; the correspondng means of MC were 22.89% (s.e.=3.62%) and 59.07% (3.01%) for SSA and nonssa countres respectvely and the dfference s statstcally sgnfcant at the 1% level. Inequaly too s hgher n SSA; the mean Gn ndex n the earlest surveys s (0.018) for SSA versus (0.017) n nonssa countres, and the dfference s sgnfcant (t=7.68). There s clearly a SSA effect n both growth and poverty reducton, though we wll see that ths s accountable to the other varables n the estmated models. 4. Convergence? Vrtually all of the papers n the emprcal lerature revewed n secton 2 have assumed that the parameters of the dynamc processes for growth and poverty reducton are ndependent 19 R 2 =0.826 for the regresson of MC MC on F ( 2) F (2) ; the regresson coeffcent s (t= ;n=92), whch s sgnfcantly dfferent from 1 (t=2.946). 15
16 of the nal level of poverty. The easest way to see that ths assumpton cannot be rght s to show that the standard models mply somethng that s not supported by the data. Consder the most common emprcal specfcaton for the growth process n the mean: ln ln (7) where s a countryspecfc effect, 1 s a countryspecfc convergence parameter and s a zeromean error term. (To smplfy notaton I assume evenly spaced data for now.) Next let the headcount ndex of poverty be a loglnear functon of the mean: ln H ln (8) where 0 and s a zeromean error term. Ths assumes that relatve dstrbuton fluctuates around a statonary mean, wh changes n dstrbuton orthogonal to growth rates n the mean. The mpled growth model for poverty s then: ln H ln H (9) 1 for whch s readly verfed that and ( 1 ) 1. The parameters of (7) and (8) (,,, ) can vary across countes but (for the sake of ths argument) suppose they do so ndependently of H mean, have:. Then the speed of convergence for the ln / ln 1, s the same as that for poverty: ln H / ln H 1. Thus we Proposon 3: In standard loglnear models for growth and poverty reducton, wh parameters ndependent of the nal level of poverty, the speed of convergence wll be the same for the mean as the poverty measure. However, ths s not borne out by the data. Table 3 gves convergence tests for both the mean and the poverty measures, wh and whout controls. 20 The controls ncluded nal consumpton per capa from the NAS, prmary school enrollment rate, lfe expectancy at brth, and the prce ndex of nvestment goods from Penn World Tables (6.2), whch s a wdelyused measure of market dstortons; all three varables are matched as closely as possble to the date of the earlest survey. The survey means exhb convergence wh a coeffcent of (t= 20 The test s the regresson coeffcent of g ( ) on ln. Alternatvely one can estmate the nonlnear regresson g ( ) [(1 e )/ ]ln. Ths gave a very smlar result to (1) n Table 4, namely ˆ (t=2.865). Clearly, the approxmaton that e 1 works well. 16
17 3.412) whout the controls and (t=7.435) wh them. But ths not true of the poverty measures. Indeed the proportonate rates of poverty reducton are orthogonal to nal levels. 21 Fgure 3 plots the data, and gves a nonparametrc regresson lne. Clearly these results do not support the dea that the mean and the poverty measure have the same speed of convergence; ndeed, there s no convncng sgn of poverty convergence. The rest of ths paper wll try to explan why. In terms of the model above, wll be shown that the parameter s a decreasng functon of the nal poverty rate whle the elastcy of poverty to the mean,, s a decreasng functon of the nal level of poverty. 5. The relevance of nal poverty to growth n the mean As dscussed n secton 2, nal dstrbuton can matter to the rate of poverty reducton through two dstnct channels, namely the growth rate and the elastcy of poverty to the mean. I postulate a smple trangular model n whch rate of growth depends n turn on nal dstrbuton whle the rate of progress aganst poverty depends on the nteracton between the growth rate and the nal dstrbuton. Ths secton focuses on the frst relatonshp; secton 6 turns to the second. The secton begns wh benchmark regressons of growth on the nal mean and nal poverty rate. A causal nterpretaton of these regressons requres that the nal dstrbuton (n the earlest survey used to construct each spell) s exogenous to the subsequent pace of growth. Ths can be questoned. I shall test encompassng models wh controls for other factors. I also provde results for an nstrumental varables estmator under wdelyused (though stll questonable) excluson restrctons. 5.1 Benchmark regresson for growth Table 4 gves estmates of the followng regresson: 22 g ( ) ln ln H (10) 21 For the $1.25 lne the correspondng regresson coeffcent was wh t=0.393; at the other extreme, for the $13 lne was (t=0.480). Agan, the nonlnear specfcaton gave a very smlar result. 22 The regressons are consstent wh a dervatve of ln wh respect to ln that s less than uny, but fades toward zero at suffcently long gaps between survey rounds; for example, column (1) n Table 4 mples a dervatve that s less than uny for 29 years; the largest value of n the data s 27 years. 17
18 The estmates n column (1) suggest that dfferences n the nal poverty rate have szeable negatve mpacts on the growth rate at a gven nal mean. A one standard devaton ncrease n ln H would come wh (2% ponts) declne n the growth rate for the survey mean. The fact that a sgnfcant (partal) correlaton wh the nal poverty rate only emerges when one controls for the nal mean s suggestve of an adverse dstrbutonal effect of hgh poverty. However, s not smply a relatve poverty effect, stemmng from the varance n absolute poverty attrbutable to dfferences n relatve dstrbuton. Ths s evdent n the fact that the convergence parameter ncreases consderably when one adds the nal poverty measure as a regressor. Droppng ln H from (10) the coeffcent on ln falls to (t=3.413). The presence of the poverty rate as a regressor magnfes the convergence parameter, suggestng that the fact that the absolute poverty rate depends on the mean s also playng a crucal role n determnng s sgnfcance n these regressons workng aganst the convergence effect. It mght be conjectured that the effect of ln H n (10) reflects a msspecfcaton of the functonal form for the convergence effect, notng that the poverty measure s a nonlnear functon of mean ncome. To test for ths, I reestmated (10) usng cubc functons of control for the nal mean. Whle I found some sgn of hgherorder effects of ln ln to, these made very ltle dfference to the regresson coeffcent on the poverty rate n the augmented regresson; the coeffcent on ln H n column (1) n Table 4 became (t=3.547). There s, however, a marked nonlneary n the relatonshp, whch s beng captured by the log transformaton of H n (10). If one uses H rather than ln H on the same sample, the negatve effects are stll evdent but they are much less precsely estmated, wh substantally lower tratos a trato of for the coeffcent on H come out somewhat more strongly f one adds a squared term n wh both the lnear and squared terms sgnfcant at the 10% level or better. though n both cases the effects H to pck up the nonlneary, A smple graphcal test for msspecfcaton of the functonal form n (10) s to plot g( ) 0.035ln (from column (1) n Table 4) aganst ln H. Fgure 4 gves the results, 18
19 along wh a locallysmoothed (nonparametrc) regresson lne. The relatonshp s close to lnear n the log poverty rate. 23 The log transformaton appears to be the rght functonal form. The more relevant poverty lne s that usng the $2.00 a day lne. On replacng ln H ln F (1.25) n (10) the poverty rate stll had a negatve coeffcent but was not sgnfcant at the 5% level. I also estmated the followng specfcaton: g ( ) ln 1 [ln H ln F (1.25)] 2 ln F (1.25)) (11) The estmate of 1 2 was , but was not sgnfcantly dfferent from zero (t=0.801), suggestng that (10) s the correct specfcaton. The results were also robust to usng the poverty gap ndex nstead of the headcount ndex; the correspondng verson of (10) was smlar, wh a coeffcent on the log of the poverty gap ndex of , wh trato of However, the f s better usng the headcount ndex. Recall that the sample n estmatng (10) used both consumpton and ncome surveys, and that the latter may have more measurement error. Estmatng the regresson solely on consumpton surveys strengthened the result; analogously to (10) one obtans column (2) of Table 4. The condonal convergence effect s even stronger, as s the poverty effect. The results are robust to usng NAS consumpton growth nstead (Table 4). The notable dfferences are that the convergence parameter n (10) s lower, ˆ (column 3, Table 4) and that the headcount ndex based on the $1.25 lne s a slghtly stronger predctor of the NAS consumpton growth. (The results usng NAS consumpton growth were less sensve to the choce of poverty lne between $2.00 and $1.25 a day.) Another way to use NAS consumpton s as a control for other nal condons nfluencng the longrun value of the survey mean. Augmentng (10) wh ths extra control varable gves, for the full sample: g ( ) ln (3.942) ( 6.817) 0.011ln H ( 2.382) And for the sample of consumpton surveys: g ( ) ln (4.868) ( 6.507) ln H ( 3.624) The results are consstent wh the expectaton that 0.022lnC (3.682) 0.025ln C (3.346) The poverty effect remans evdent, though wh a lower coeffcent. 23 ˆ R 2 =0.288; n=87 (12) ˆ R 2 =0.317; n=66 (13) ln C s pckng up longrun dfferences. In both cases I have scaled the vertcal axs to accord wh the sample mean growth rate by usng the devaton of the log nal mean from s sample mean value. by 19
20 5.2 Further tests on the subsample wh three surveys One can form a subsample of about 70 countres wh at least three household surveys. When there were more than three surveys I pcked the one closest to the mdpont of the nterval between the latest survey and the earlest. There are at least four ways one can explo the extra round of surveys. The frst s to test for convergence more robustly to measurement errors. 24 One way of dong ths s to calculate the trend over the three surveys and test f ths s correlated wh the startng value. I estmated the trend for each country by regressng the logs of the three (datespecfc) means for that country on tme and smlarly for the headcount ndces. Convergence n the mean was stll evdent; the regresson coeffcent of the estmated trend on the log mean from the earlest survey was (t=2.052), whch s sgnfcant at the 4% level. And agan there was no sgnfcant correlaton between these trends n poverty reducton and the nal poverty measures; the regresson coeffcent of the estmated trend on the log headcount ndex from the earlest survey was (t=0.805). Another method s to form means from the frst two surveys and look at ther relatonshp wh the changes observed between the last survey and the mddle one. Defne the mean from the frst two surveys as M x ) ( x x ) / 2 whle the growth rate s 2 ( g ( x ) ln( x / x ) /. Usng ths method, uncondonal mean convergence was no longer 2 evdent (though condonal convergence was stll found) but there was an ndcaton of poverty dvergence; regressng g H ) (the proportonate change n the poverty measure between the ( mddle and fnal rounds) on M ) ; the coeffcent was 0.029, whch s sgnfcant at the 6% ( 2 H level (t=1.901). There s stll some contamnaton due to measurement error n these tests. Yet another method s to regress g ( x ) on the measure from the earlest survey ( ln 1 ); the 2 result was smlar, namely ltle sgn of (uncondonal) mean convergence but mld dvergence for poverty (a coeffcent of wh t=1.819). 24 As s well known, measurement errors can create spurous sgns of convergence; f the nal mean s over (under) estmated then the subsequent growth rate wll be lower (hgher).clearly stems n part at least from ths problem. It s notable that the coeffcent drops usng only the consumpton surveys (Table 4) or NAS consumpton. However, sgnfcant condonal convergence n the means (ncludng those only from consumpton surveys) and NAS consumpton s stll evdent (Table 4). 20
HOUSEHOLDS DEBT BURDEN: AN ANALYSIS BASED ON MICROECONOMIC DATA*
HOUSEHOLDS DEBT BURDEN: AN ANALYSIS BASED ON MICROECONOMIC DATA* Luísa Farnha** 1. INTRODUCTION The rapd growth n Portuguese households ndebtedness n the past few years ncreased the concerns that debt
More informationCan Auto Liability Insurance Purchases Signal Risk Attitude?
Internatonal Journal of Busness and Economcs, 2011, Vol. 10, No. 2, 159164 Can Auto Lablty Insurance Purchases Sgnal Rsk Atttude? ChuShu L Department of Internatonal Busness, Asa Unversty, Tawan ShengChang
More informationAnswer: A). There is a flatter IS curve in the high MPC economy. Original LM LM after increase in M. IS curve for low MPC economy
4.02 Quz Solutons Fall 2004 MultpleChoce Questons (30/00 ponts) Please, crcle the correct answer for each of the followng 0 multplechoce questons. For each queston, only one of the answers s correct.
More informationAn Alternative Way to Measure Private Equity Performance
An Alternatve Way to Measure Prvate Equty Performance Peter Todd Parlux Investment Technology LLC Summary Internal Rate of Return (IRR) s probably the most common way to measure the performance of prvate
More informationThe covariance is the two variable analog to the variance. The formula for the covariance between two variables is
Regresson Lectures So far we have talked only about statstcs that descrbe one varable. What we are gong to be dscussng for much of the remander of the course s relatonshps between two or more varables.
More informationInequality and The Accounting Period. Quentin Wodon and Shlomo Yitzhaki. World Bank and Hebrew University. September 2001.
Inequalty and The Accountng Perod Quentn Wodon and Shlomo Ytzha World Ban and Hebrew Unversty September Abstract Income nequalty typcally declnes wth the length of tme taen nto account for measurement.
More informationCausal, Explanatory Forecasting. Analysis. Regression Analysis. Simple Linear Regression. Which is Independent? Forecasting
Causal, Explanatory Forecastng Assumes causeandeffect relatonshp between system nputs and ts output Forecastng wth Regresson Analyss Rchard S. Barr Inputs System Cause + Effect Relatonshp The job of
More informationbenefit is 2, paid if the policyholder dies within the year, and probability of death within the year is ).
REVIEW OF RISK MANAGEMENT CONCEPTS LOSS DISTRIBUTIONS AND INSURANCE Loss and nsurance: When someone s subject to the rsk of ncurrng a fnancal loss, the loss s generally modeled usng a random varable or
More informationInstitute of Informatics, Faculty of Business and Management, Brno University of Technology,Czech Republic
Lagrange Multplers as Quanttatve Indcators n Economcs Ivan Mezník Insttute of Informatcs, Faculty of Busness and Management, Brno Unversty of TechnologCzech Republc Abstract The quanttatve role of Lagrange
More informationPRIVATE SCHOOL CHOICE: THE EFFECTS OF RELIGIOUS AFFILIATION AND PARTICIPATION
PRIVATE SCHOOL CHOICE: THE EFFECTS OF RELIIOUS AFFILIATION AND PARTICIPATION Danny CohenZada Department of Economcs, Benuron Unversty, BeerSheva 84105, Israel Wllam Sander Department of Economcs, DePaul
More informationMarginal Benefit Incidence Analysis Using a Single Crosssection of Data. Mohamed Ihsan Ajwad and Quentin Wodon 1. World Bank.
Margnal Beneft Incdence Analyss Usng a Sngle Crosssecton of Data Mohamed Ihsan Ajwad and uentn Wodon World Bank August 200 Abstract In a recent paper, Lanjouw and Ravallon proposed an attractve and smple
More informationCHAPTER 14 MORE ABOUT REGRESSION
CHAPTER 14 MORE ABOUT REGRESSION We learned n Chapter 5 that often a straght lne descrbes the pattern of a relatonshp between two quanttatve varables. For nstance, n Example 5.1 we explored the relatonshp
More informationTHE DISTRIBUTION OF LOAN PORTFOLIO VALUE * Oldrich Alfons Vasicek
HE DISRIBUION OF LOAN PORFOLIO VALUE * Oldrch Alfons Vascek he amount of captal necessary to support a portfolo of debt securtes depends on the probablty dstrbuton of the portfolo loss. Consder a portfolo
More informationStudy on CET4 Marks in China s Graded English Teaching
Study on CET4 Marks n Chna s Graded Englsh Teachng CHE We College of Foregn Studes, Shandong Insttute of Busness and Technology, P.R.Chna, 264005 Abstract: Ths paper deploys Logt model, and decomposes
More informationAnalysis of Premium Liabilities for Australian Lines of Business
Summary of Analyss of Premum Labltes for Australan Lnes of Busness Emly Tao Honours Research Paper, The Unversty of Melbourne Emly Tao Acknowledgements I am grateful to the Australan Prudental Regulaton
More information1. Measuring association using correlation and regression
How to measure assocaton I: Correlaton. 1. Measurng assocaton usng correlaton and regresson We often would lke to know how one varable, such as a mother's weght, s related to another varable, such as a
More informationReturns to Experience in Mozambique: A Nonparametric Regression Approach
Returns to Experence n Mozambque: A Nonparametrc Regresson Approach Joel Muzma Conference Paper nº 27 Conferênca Inaugural do IESE Desafos para a nvestgação socal e económca em Moçambque 19 de Setembro
More informationPSYCHOLOGICAL RESEARCH (PYC 304C) Lecture 12
14 The Chsquared dstrbuton PSYCHOLOGICAL RESEARCH (PYC 304C) Lecture 1 If a normal varable X, havng mean µ and varance σ, s standardsed, the new varable Z has a mean 0 and varance 1. When ths standardsed
More informationDEFINING %COMPLETE IN MICROSOFT PROJECT
CelersSystems DEFINING %COMPLETE IN MICROSOFT PROJECT PREPARED BY James E Aksel, PMP, PMISP, MVP For Addtonal Informaton about Earned Value Management Systems and reportng, please contact: CelersSystems,
More informationForecasting the Direction and Strength of Stock Market Movement
Forecastng the Drecton and Strength of Stock Market Movement Jngwe Chen Mng Chen Nan Ye cjngwe@stanford.edu mchen5@stanford.edu nanye@stanford.edu Abstract  Stock market s one of the most complcated systems
More informationCalculation of Sampling Weights
Perre Foy Statstcs Canada 4 Calculaton of Samplng Weghts 4.1 OVERVIEW The basc sample desgn used n TIMSS Populatons 1 and 2 was a twostage stratfed cluster desgn. 1 The frst stage conssted of a sample
More informationSimple Interest Loans (Section 5.1) :
Chapter 5 Fnance The frst part of ths revew wll explan the dfferent nterest and nvestment equatons you learned n secton 5.1 through 5.4 of your textbook and go through several examples. The second part
More informationOn the Optimal Control of a Cascade of HydroElectric Power Stations
On the Optmal Control of a Cascade of HydroElectrc Power Statons M.C.M. Guedes a, A.F. Rbero a, G.V. Smrnov b and S. Vlela c a Department of Mathematcs, School of Scences, Unversty of Porto, Portugal;
More informationSIMPLE LINEAR CORRELATION
SIMPLE LINEAR CORRELATION Smple lnear correlaton s a measure of the degree to whch two varables vary together, or a measure of the ntensty of the assocaton between two varables. Correlaton often s abused.
More informationJoe Pimbley, unpublished, 2005. Yield Curve Calculations
Joe Pmbley, unpublshed, 005. Yeld Curve Calculatons Background: Everythng s dscount factors Yeld curve calculatons nclude valuaton of forward rate agreements (FRAs), swaps, nterest rate optons, and forward
More information7.5. Present Value of an Annuity. Investigate
7.5 Present Value of an Annuty Owen and Anna are approachng retrement and are puttng ther fnances n order. They have worked hard and nvested ther earnngs so that they now have a large amount of money on
More informationLIFETIME INCOME OPTIONS
LIFETIME INCOME OPTIONS May 2011 by: Marca S. Wagner, Esq. The Wagner Law Group A Professonal Corporaton 99 Summer Street, 13 th Floor Boston, MA 02110 Tel: (617) 3575200 Fax: (617) 3575250 www.ersalawyers.com
More informationGender differences in revealed risk taking: evidence from mutual fund investors
Economcs Letters 76 (2002) 151 158 www.elsever.com/ locate/ econbase Gender dfferences n revealed rsk takng: evdence from mutual fund nvestors a b c, * Peggy D. Dwyer, James H. Glkeson, John A. Lst a Unversty
More informationModule 2 LOSSLESS IMAGE COMPRESSION SYSTEMS. Version 2 ECE IIT, Kharagpur
Module LOSSLESS IMAGE COMPRESSION SYSTEMS Lesson 3 Lossless Compresson: Huffman Codng Instructonal Objectves At the end of ths lesson, the students should be able to:. Defne and measure source entropy..
More informationHARVARD John M. Olin Center for Law, Economics, and Business
HARVARD John M. Oln Center for Law, Economcs, and Busness ISSN 10456333 ASYMMETRIC INFORMATION AND LEARNING IN THE AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE MARKET Alma Cohen Dscusson Paper No. 371 6/2002 Harvard Law School
More informationThe Developing World Is Poorer Than We Thought, But No Less Successful in the Fight against Poverty
Publc Dsclosure Authorzed Pol c y Re s e a rc h Wo r k n g Pa p e r 4703 WPS4703 Publc Dsclosure Authorzed Publc Dsclosure Authorzed The Developng World Is Poorer Than We Thought, But No Less Successful
More informationDayoftheWeek Trading Patterns of Individual and Institutional Investors
DayoftheWeek Tradng Patterns of Indvdual and Instutonal Investors Joel N. Morse, Hoang Nguyen, and Hao M. Quach Ths study examnes the dayoftheweek tradng patterns of ndvdual and nstutonal nvestors.
More informationSTAMP DUTY ON SHARES AND ITS EFFECT ON SHARE PRICES
STAMP UTY ON SHARES AN ITS EFFECT ON SHARE PRICES Steve Bond Mke Hawkns Alexander Klemm THE INSTITUTE FOR FISCAL STUIES WP04/11 STAMP UTY ON SHARES AN ITS EFFECT ON SHARE PRICES Steve Bond (IFS and Unversty
More informationChapter 8 Groupbased Lending and Adverse Selection: A Study on Risk Behavior and Group Formation 1
Chapter 8 Groupbased Lendng and Adverse Selecton: A Study on Rsk Behavor and Group Formaton 1 8.1 Introducton Ths chapter deals wth group formaton and the adverse selecton problem. In several theoretcal
More informationCambodian Child s Wage Rate, Human Capital and Hours Worked Tradeoff: Simple Theoretical and Empirical Evidence for Policy Implications
GSIS Workng Paper Seres ambodan hld s Wage Rate, Human aptal and Hours Worked Tradeoff: Smple Theoretcal and Emprcal Evdence for Polcy Implcatons Han PHOUMIN Sech FUKUI No. 6 August 2006 Graduate School
More informationThe Analysis of Covariance. ERSH 8310 Keppel and Wickens Chapter 15
The Analyss of Covarance ERSH 830 Keppel and Wckens Chapter 5 Today s Class Intal Consderatons Covarance and Lnear Regresson The Lnear Regresson Equaton TheAnalyss of Covarance Assumptons Underlyng the
More informationCriminal Justice System on Crime *
On the Impact of the NSW Crmnal Justce System on Crme * Dr Vasls Sarafds, Dscplne of Operatons Management and Econometrcs Unversty of Sydney * Ths presentaton s based on jont work wth Rchard Kelaher 1
More informationTwo Faces of IntraIndustry Information Transfers: Evidence from Management Earnings and Revenue Forecasts
Two Faces of IntraIndustry Informaton Transfers: Evdence from Management Earnngs and Revenue Forecasts Yongtae Km Leavey School of Busness Santa Clara Unversty Santa Clara, CA 950530380 TEL: (408) 5544667,
More informationUnderstanding the Impact of Marketing Actions in Traditional Channels on the Internet: Evidence from a Large Scale Field Experiment
A research and educaton ntatve at the MT Sloan School of Management Understandng the mpact of Marketng Actons n Tradtonal Channels on the nternet: Evdence from a Large Scale Feld Experment Paper 216 Erc
More informationA dynamic model of demand for private health insurance in Ireland
A dynamc model of demand for prvate health nsurance n Ireland Clare Fnn a *, Colm Harmon a b Workng Paper 17 Research Programme on Health Servces, Health Inequales and Health and Socal Gan Ths programme
More informationStatistical Methods to Develop Rating Models
Statstcal Methods to Develop Ratng Models [Evelyn Hayden and Danel Porath, Österrechsche Natonalbank and Unversty of Appled Scences at Manz] Source: The Basel II Rsk Parameters Estmaton, Valdaton, and
More information1 De nitions and Censoring
De ntons and Censorng. Survval Analyss We begn by consderng smple analyses but we wll lead up to and take a look at regresson on explanatory factors., as n lnear regresson part A. The mportant d erence
More informationx f(x) 1 0.25 1 0.75 x 1 0 1 1 0.04 0.01 0.20 1 0.12 0.03 0.60
BIVARIATE DISTRIBUTIONS Let be a varable that assumes the values { 1,,..., n }. Then, a functon that epresses the relatve frequenc of these values s called a unvarate frequenc functon. It must be true
More informationA Nonparametric and Semiparametric Analysis on the. InequalityDevelopment Relationship
A Nonparametrc and Semparametrc Analyss on the InequalyDevelopment Relatonshp KuWa L a, * and Xanbo Zhou b a Cy Unversy of Hong Kong and Unversy of Geneva b Lngnan College, Sun Yatsen Unversy, Chna
More informationManagement Quality and Equity Issue Characteristics: A Comparison of SEOs and IPOs
Management Qualty and Equty Issue Characterstcs: A Comparson of SEOs and IPOs Thomas J. Chemmanur * Imants Paegls ** and Karen Smonyan *** Current verson: November 2009 (Accepted, Fnancal Management, February
More informationADVERSE SELECTION IN INSURANCE MARKETS: POLICYHOLDER EVIDENCE FROM THE U.K. ANNUITY MARKET *
ADVERSE SELECTION IN INSURANCE MARKETS: POLICYHOLDER EVIDENCE FROM THE U.K. ANNUITY MARKET * Amy Fnkelsten Harvard Unversty and NBER James Poterba MIT and NBER * We are grateful to Jeffrey Brown, PerreAndre
More informationAn InterestOriented Network Evolution Mechanism for Online Communities
An InterestOrented Network Evoluton Mechansm for Onlne Communtes Cahong Sun and Xaopng Yang School of Informaton, Renmn Unversty of Chna, Bejng 100872, P.R. Chna {chsun,yang}@ruc.edu.cn Abstract. Onlne
More informationMarginal Returns to Education For Teachers
The Onlne Journal of New Horzons n Educaton Volume 4, Issue 3 MargnalReturnstoEducatonForTeachers RamleeIsmal,MarnahAwang ABSTRACT FacultyofManagementand Economcs UnverstPenddkanSultan Idrs ramlee@fpe.ups.edu.my
More information! # %& ( ) +,../ 0 1 2 3 4 0 4 # 5##&.6 7% 8 # 0 4 2 #...
! # %& ( ) +,../ 0 1 2 3 4 0 4 # 5##&.6 7% 8 # 0 4 2 #... 9 Sheffeld Economc Research Paper Seres SERP Number: 2011010 ISSN 17498368 Sarah Brown, Aurora OrtzNúñez and Karl Taylor Educatonal loans and
More informationTHE METHOD OF LEAST SQUARES THE METHOD OF LEAST SQUARES
The goal: to measure (determne) an unknown quantty x (the value of a RV X) Realsaton: n results: y 1, y 2,..., y j,..., y n, (the measured values of Y 1, Y 2,..., Y j,..., Y n ) every result s encumbered
More informationUsing Series to Analyze Financial Situations: Present Value
2.8 Usng Seres to Analyze Fnancal Stuatons: Present Value In the prevous secton, you learned how to calculate the amount, or future value, of an ordnary smple annuty. The amount s the sum of the accumulated
More informationAn Evaluation of the Extended Logistic, Simple Logistic, and Gompertz Models for Forecasting Short Lifecycle Products and Services
An Evaluaton of the Extended Logstc, Smple Logstc, and Gompertz Models for Forecastng Short Lfecycle Products and Servces Charles V. Trappey a,1, Hsnyng Wu b a Professor (Management Scence), Natonal Chao
More informationExhaustive Regression. An Exploration of RegressionBased Data Mining Techniques Using Super Computation
Exhaustve Regresson An Exploraton of RegressonBased Data Mnng Technques Usng Super Computaton Antony Daves, Ph.D. Assocate Professor of Economcs Duquesne Unversty Pttsburgh, PA 58 Research Fellow The
More informationCHAPTER 5 RELATIONSHIPS BETWEEN QUANTITATIVE VARIABLES
CHAPTER 5 RELATIONSHIPS BETWEEN QUANTITATIVE VARIABLES In ths chapter, we wll learn how to descrbe the relatonshp between two quanttatve varables. Remember (from Chapter 2) that the terms quanttatve varable
More information14.74 Lecture 5: Health (2)
14.74 Lecture 5: Health (2) Esther Duflo February 17, 2004 1 Possble Interventons Last tme we dscussed possble nterventons. Let s take one: provdng ron supplements to people, for example. From the data,
More informationThe Effects of Tax Rate Changes on Tax Bases and the Marginal Cost of Public Funds for Canadian Provincial Governments
The Effects of Tax Rate Changes on Tax Bases and the Margnal Cost of Publc Funds for Canadan Provncal Governments Bev Dahlby a and Ergete Ferede b a Department of Economcs, Unversty of Alberta, Edmonton,
More informationA Dynamic Model of Demand for Private Health Insurance in Ireland
DISCUSSION PAPER SERIES IZA DP No. 2472 A Dynamc Model of Demand for Prvate Health Insurance n Ireland Clare Fnn Colm Harmon November 2006 Forschungsnstut zur Zukunft der Arbe Instute for the Study of
More informationProblem Set 3. a) We are asked how people will react, if the interest rate i on bonds is negative.
Queston roblem Set 3 a) We are asked how people wll react, f the nterest rate on bonds s negatve. When
More informationStaff Paper. Farm Savings Accounts: Examining Income Variability, Eligibility, and Benefits. Brent Gloy, Eddy LaDue, and Charles Cuykendall
SP 200502 August 2005 Staff Paper Department of Appled Economcs and Management Cornell Unversty, Ithaca, New York 148537801 USA Farm Savngs Accounts: Examnng Income Varablty, Elgblty, and Benefts Brent
More informationOn the correct model specification for estimating the structure of a currency basket
On the correct model specfcaton for estmatng the structure of a currency basket JyhDean Hwang Department of Internatonal Busness Natonal Tawan Unversty 85 Roosevelt Road Sect. 4, Tape 106, Tawan jdhwang@ntu.edu.tw
More informationTime Series Analysis in Studies of AGN Variability. Bradley M. Peterson The Ohio State University
Tme Seres Analyss n Studes of AGN Varablty Bradley M. Peterson The Oho State Unversty 1 Lnear Correlaton Degree to whch two parameters are lnearly correlated can be expressed n terms of the lnear correlaton
More informationBrigid Mullany, Ph.D University of North Carolina, Charlotte
Evaluaton And Comparson Of The Dfferent Standards Used To Defne The Postonal Accuracy And Repeatablty Of Numercally Controlled Machnng Center Axes Brgd Mullany, Ph.D Unversty of North Carolna, Charlotte
More informationEvaluating the Effects of FUNDEF on Wages and Test Scores in Brazil *
Evaluatng the Effects of FUNDEF on Wages and Test Scores n Brazl * Naérco MenezesFlho Elane Pazello Unversty of São Paulo Abstract In ths paper we nvestgate the effects of the 1998 reform n the fundng
More informationEconomic Interpretation of Regression. Theory and Applications
Economc Interpretaton of Regresson Theor and Applcatons Classcal and Baesan Econometrc Methods Applcaton of mathematcal statstcs to economc data for emprcal support Economc theor postulates a qualtatve
More information17 Capital tax competition
17 Captal tax competton 17.1 Introducton Governments would lke to tax a varety of transactons that ncreasngly appear to be moble across jursdctonal boundares. Ths creates one obvous problem: tax base flght.
More informationANALYZING THE RELATIONSHIPS BETWEEN QUALITY, TIME, AND COST IN PROJECT MANAGEMENT DECISION MAKING
ANALYZING THE RELATIONSHIPS BETWEEN QUALITY, TIME, AND COST IN PROJECT MANAGEMENT DECISION MAKING Matthew J. Lberatore, Department of Management and Operatons, Vllanova Unversty, Vllanova, PA 19085, 6105194390,
More informationTime Value of Money. Types of Interest. Compounding and Discounting Single Sums. Page 1. Ch. 6  The Time Value of Money. The Time Value of Money
Ch. 6  The Tme Value of Money Tme Value of Money The Interest Rate Smple Interest Compound Interest Amortzng a Loan FIN21 Ahmed Y, Dasht TIME VALUE OF MONEY OR DISCOUNTED CASH FLOW ANALYSIS Very Important
More informationCellular Service Demand: Biased Beliefs, Learning, and Bill Shock
Cellular Servce Demand: Based Belefs, Learnng, and Bll Shock Mchael D. Grubb and Matthew Osborne December 9, 2011 Abstract We estmate a model of consumer plan choce, usage, and learnng n cellularphone
More informationImplied (risk neutral) probabilities, betting odds and prediction markets
Impled (rsk neutral) probabltes, bettng odds and predcton markets Fabrzo Caccafesta (Unversty of Rome "Tor Vergata") ABSTRACT  We show that the well known euvalence between the "fundamental theorem of
More informationMAPP. MERIS level 3 cloud and water vapour products. Issue: 1. Revision: 0. Date: 9.12.1998. Function Name Organisation Signature Date
Ttel: Project: Doc. No.: MERIS level 3 cloud and water vapour products MAPP MAPPATBDClWVL3 Issue: 1 Revson: 0 Date: 9.12.1998 Functon Name Organsaton Sgnature Date Author: Bennartz FUB Preusker FUB Schüller
More informationMacro Factors and Volatility of Treasury Bond Returns
Macro Factors and Volatlty of Treasury Bond Returns Jngzh Huang Department of Fnance Smeal Colleage of Busness Pennsylvana State Unversty Unversty Park, PA 16802, U.S.A. Le Lu School of Fnance Shangha
More informationThe impact of hard discount control mechanism on the discount volatility of UK closedend funds
Investment Management and Fnancal Innovatons, Volume 10, Issue 3, 2013 Ahmed F. Salhn (Egypt) The mpact of hard dscount control mechansm on the dscount volatlty of UK closedend funds Abstract The mpact
More informationHeterogeneous Paths Through College: Detailed Patterns and Relationships with Graduation and Earnings
Heterogeneous Paths Through College: Detaled Patterns and Relatonshps wth Graduaton and Earnngs Rodney J. Andrews The Unversty of Texas at Dallas and the Texas Schools Project Jng L The Unversty of Tulsa
More information5 Multiple regression analysis with qualitative information
5 Multple regresson analyss wth qualtatve nformaton Ezequel Urel Unversty of Valenca Verson: 913 5.1 Introducton of qualtatve nformaton n econometrc models. 1 5. A sngle dummy ndependent varable 5.3 Multple
More informationAddendum to: Importing SkillBiased Technology
Addendum to: Importng SkllBased Technology Arel Bursten UCLA and NBER Javer Cravno UCLA August 202 Jonathan Vogel Columba and NBER Abstract Ths Addendum derves the results dscussed n secton 3.3 of our
More informationCommunication Networks II Contents
8 / 1  Communcaton Networs II (Görg)  www.comnets.unbremen.de Communcaton Networs II Contents 1 Fundamentals of probablty theory 2 Traffc n communcaton networs 3 Stochastc & Marovan Processes (SP
More informationTraditional versus Online Courses, Efforts, and Learning Performance
Tradtonal versus Onlne Courses, Efforts, and Learnng Performance KuangCheng Tseng, Department of Internatonal Trade, ChungYuan Chrstan Unversty, Tawan ShanYng Chu, Department of Internatonal Trade,
More informationL10: Linear discriminants analysis
L0: Lnear dscrmnants analyss Lnear dscrmnant analyss, two classes Lnear dscrmnant analyss, C classes LDA vs. PCA Lmtatons of LDA Varants of LDA Other dmensonalty reducton methods CSCE 666 Pattern Analyss
More informationFinancial Instability and Life Insurance Demand + Mahito Okura *
Fnancal Instablty and Lfe Insurance Demand + Mahto Okura * Norhro Kasuga ** Abstract Ths paper estmates prvate lfe nsurance and Kampo demand functons usng householdlevel data provded by the Postal Servces
More informationTrafficlight a stress test for life insurance provisions
MEMORANDUM Date 006097 Authors Bengt von Bahr, Göran Ronge Traffclght a stress test for lfe nsurance provsons Fnansnspetonen P.O. Box 6750 SE113 85 Stocholm [Sveavägen 167] Tel +46 8 787 80 00 Fax
More informationSearching and Switching: Empirical estimates of consumer behaviour in regulated markets
Searchng and Swtchng: Emprcal estmates of consumer behavour n regulated markets Catherne Waddams Prce Centre for Competton Polcy, Unversty of East Angla Catherne Webster Centre for Competton Polcy, Unversty
More informationIs There A Tradeoff between EmployerProvided Health Insurance and Wages?
Is There A Tradeoff between EmployerProvded Health Insurance and Wages? Lye Zhu, Southern Methodst Unversty October 2005 Abstract Though most of the lterature n health nsurance and the labor market assumes
More informationWORKING PAPER. C.D. Howe Institute. The Effects of Tax Rate Changes on Tax Bases and the Marginal Cost of Public Funds for Provincial Governments
MARCH 211 C.D. Howe Insttute WORKING PAPER FISCAL AND TAX COMPETITIVENESS The Effects of Tax Rate Changes on Tax Bases and the Margnal Cost of Publc Funds for Provncal Governments Bev Dahlby Ergete Ferede
More informationADVERSE SELECTION IN INSURANCE MARKETS: POLICYHOLDER EVIDENCE FROM THE U.K. ANNUITY MARKET
ADVERSE SELECTION IN INSURANCE MARKETS: POLICYHOLDER EVIDENCE FROM THE U.K. ANNUITY MARKET Amy Fnkelsten Harvard Unversty and NBER James Poterba MIT and NBER Revsed May 2003 ABSTRACT In ths paper, we nvestgate
More informationThe Development of Web Log Mining Based on ImproveKMeans Clustering Analysis
The Development of Web Log Mnng Based on ImproveKMeans Clusterng Analyss TngZhong Wang * College of Informaton Technology, Luoyang Normal Unversty, Luoyang, 471022, Chna wangtngzhong2@sna.cn Abstract.
More informationNumber of Levels Cumulative Annual operating Income per year construction costs costs ($) ($) ($) 1 600,000 35,000 100,000 2 2,200,000 60,000 350,000
Problem Set 5 Solutons 1 MIT s consderng buldng a new car park near Kendall Square. o unversty funds are avalable (overhead rates are under pressure and the new faclty would have to pay for tself from
More informationManagement Quality, Financial and Investment Policies, and. Asymmetric Information
Management Qualty, Fnancal and Investment Polces, and Asymmetrc Informaton Thomas J. Chemmanur * Imants Paegls ** and Karen Smonyan *** Current verson: December 2007 * Professor of Fnance, Carroll School
More informationThe impact of bank capital requirements on bank risk: an econometric puzzle and a proposed solution
Banks and Bank Systems, Volume 4, Issue 1, 009 Robert L. Porter (USA) The mpact of bank captal requrements on bank rsk: an econometrc puzzle and a proposed soluton Abstract The relatonshp between bank
More informationMilitary Conscription and University Enrolment: Evidence from Italy
DISCUSSION PAPER SERIES IZA DP No. 4212 Mltary Conscrpton and Unversty Enrolment: Evdence from Italy Gorgo D Petro June 2009 Forschungsnsttut zur Zukunft der Arbet Insttute for the Study of Labor Mltary
More informationWhat is Candidate Sampling
What s Canddate Samplng Say we have a multclass or mult label problem where each tranng example ( x, T ) conssts of a context x a small (mult)set of target classes T out of a large unverse L of possble
More informationMultiplePeriod Attribution: Residuals and Compounding
MultplePerod Attrbuton: Resduals and Compoundng Our revewer gave these authors full marks for dealng wth an ssue that performance measurers and vendors often regard as propretary nformaton. In 1994, Dens
More informationThursday, December 10, 2009 Noon  1:50 pm Faraday 143
1. ath 210 Fnte athematcs Chapter 5.2 and 4.3 Annutes ortgages Amortzaton Professor Rchard Blecksmth Dept. of athematcal Scences Northern Illnos Unversty ath 210 Webste: http://math.nu.edu/courses/math210
More informationDollar a Day Revisited
Dollar a Day Revsted Martn Ravallon, Shaohua Chen, and Prem Sangraula The artcle presents the frst major update of the nternatonal $1 a day poverty lne, proposed n World Development Report 1990: Poverty
More informationHigh Correlation between Net Promoter Score and the Development of Consumers' Willingness to Pay (Empirical Evidence from European Mobile Markets)
Hgh Correlaton between et Promoter Score and the Development of Consumers' Wllngness to Pay (Emprcal Evdence from European Moble Marets Ths paper shows that the correlaton between the et Promoter Score
More informationAPPLICATION OF PROBE DATA COLLECTED VIA INFRARED BEACONS TO TRAFFIC MANEGEMENT
APPLICATION OF PROBE DATA COLLECTED VIA INFRARED BEACONS TO TRAFFIC MANEGEMENT Toshhko Oda (1), Kochro Iwaoka (2) (1), (2) Infrastructure Systems Busness Unt, Panasonc System Networks Co., Ltd. Saedocho
More information1. Math 210 Finite Mathematics
1. ath 210 Fnte athematcs Chapter 5.2 and 5.3 Annutes ortgages Amortzaton Professor Rchard Blecksmth Dept. of athematcal Scences Northern Illnos Unversty ath 210 Webste: http://math.nu.edu/courses/math210
More informationChapter 11 Practice Problems Answers
Chapter 11 Practce Problems Answers 1. Would you be more wllng to lend to a frend f she put all of her lfe savngs nto her busness than you would f she had not done so? Why? Ths problem s ntended to make
More informationAnalysis of the relationship between working capital policy and operating risk: an empirical study on Jordanian industrial companies
Investment Management and Fnancal Innovatons, Volume 7, Issue, 00 Fars Nasf AlShubr (Jordan) Analyss of the relatonshp between workng capal polcy and operatng rsk: an emprcal study on Jordanan ndustral
More informationDO LOSS FIRMS MANAGE EARNINGS AROUND SEASONED EQUITY OFFERINGS?
DO LOSS FIRMS MANAGE EARNINGS AROUND SEASONED EQUITY OFFERINGS? Fernando Comran, Unversty of San Francsco, School of Management, 2130 Fulton Street, CA 94117, Unted States, fcomran@usfca.edu Tatana Fedyk,
More informationCulture and the Family: An Application to Educational Choices in Italy
Culture and the Famly: An Applcaton to Educatonal Choces n Italy Saggo ad Invto per la Rvsta d Poltca Economca July 2009 Paola Gulano UCLA, NBER, and IZA Abstract In ths essay we revew the assocaton between
More information