1 NOTE No. 100 January 2015FOCUS Gregory Chen and Xavier Faz The Potential of Digital Data: How Far Can It Advance Financial Inclusion? The amount of electronic data generated by computerization digital data is growing at unprecedented rates. In a 30-minute span, the internet combined with devices such as phones, personal computers, and sensors will generate digital data equal to all written works in human history (Inc. Magazine 2012). This trend is accelerating, with digital data storage requirements projected to rise 10-fold by 2020 (Economist 2012). Financial services are an information business can this growing wealth of data be harnessed to advance financial inclusion? Robert Kirkpatrick, the director of the United Nations (UN) Global Pulse, an initiative of the Secretary General s office formed to explore the use of new sources of digital data, calls this a new natural resource that can be cultivated for society s benefit. A growing number of applications in development demonstrate this view. The UN Global Pulse has researched correlations between mobile phone airtime purchases and food consumption to track food security in East Africa (www. mobile-cdrs-food-security). Researchers from the University of California, San Francisco, use weather records to predict concentrations of malaria to help prevention and treatment efforts (Guardian 2014). And following the Ebola outbreak in 2014 some have called for more use of mobile phone data to combat the spread of disease (Economist 2014b and de Montjoye, Kendall, and Kerry 2014). The use of digital data is playing a growing role in the area of financial services in low-income countries. CGAP signaled this development in Can Digital Footprints Lead to Greater Financial Inclusion? (Kumar and Muhota 2012). Since then M-Shwari in Kenya, a savings-and-loan product launched by the Commercial Bank of Africa together with mobile operator Safaricom, has expanded rapidly. M-Shwari relies on mobile phone records to set initial credit limits and their subsequent savings and borrowing to adjust credit limits. M-Shwari reached 7 million Kenyans in its first 22 months. Another high-profile case is Alibaba the Chinese commerce website that links buyers and sellers and uses commerce data to extend credit to small businesses (Shrader 2013). M-Shwari and Alibaba are rather high-profile cases, but there are many other efforts underway. A global scan by CGAP found at least 36 new start-up companies or products focused on harnessing digital data for financial services (CGAP 2015). While many of these models are in trial phases, they signal opportunities to advance financial inclusion. One opportunity is exploring the possibility of assessing credit risk of people for whom no information or formal records exist, allowing many to establish a formal credit history and to eventually engage more broadly with formal financial service providers (FSPs). Another is exploring the potential to improve providers insights about customers needs leading to products that better suit poor people s needs. The opportunities are too big to ignore, but the use cases are still new. This Focus Note asks how far emerging new sources of digital data can improve business model economics, reach more people, and enable greater customization. What can this trend contribute to advancing financial inclusion? Emerging evidence and analysis indicate the following. Digital data can benefit providers through applications in three broad areas: 1. Finding new customers 2. Deepening customer relationships 3. Managing risks The headline-grabbing examples typically involve a new class of short-term credit products (sometimes combined with savings) that use digital data to extend instant credit remotely. The target use case is short-term liquidity, and scale can be impressive in markets where there is also a far-reaching digital payments infrastructure. M-Shwari in Kenya is an example, but several other similar services are being tested in other countries. Other areas of impact span a broad range of existing products and business models, where digital data supplement decisions or help automate processes.
2 2 Multiple steps in the provision of financial services could be improved incrementally, leading to large gains (Economist 2014a). For instance, analysis in Tanzania finds the marginal costs of delivery of a $200 microloan could be reduced 30 percent. 1 Initial provider focus is on credit and insurance products where the gains from revenue and risk management can materialize more quickly. Seizing the opportunity for financial inclusion will require patience, as more data become available and providers build their ability to use data and change business processes to take advantage of it. Potential benefits for providers could be substantial: lowering costs and reaching many new clients. For clients, digital data use can reduce time and documentation burdens, making services more accessible to a larger number of clients otherwise excluded. This Focus Note highlights where and how potential benefits can be realized, recognizing there are challenges and risks. Some hold that digital data are not a full substitute for the richness of an in-person interaction to gather data on clients. Uses of digital data also raise challenging questions around data privacy and protection. Moreover, it is difficult to predict how use of a client s digital data may change client behavior or sense of privacy. This Focus Note does not attempt to comprehensively address all questions or risks. Instead, the aim is to sharpen assessments of potential benefits and contribute one piece to a wider assessment of digital data. This Focus Note draws from three sources. One is case examples of emerging applications. This is combined with interviews with industry experts of varying perspectives. 2 The third source is a deep look at the impact of digital data on costs of delivery from a joint exercise by CGAP with McKinsey & Company in Digital Data: What s So New? The use of data is not new; it has always been a critical element of financial service delivery. Consider how much information FSPs rely on to reach individuals and small businesses. Setting strategy relies on internally collected market research and publicly available data, such as surveys, the census, and maps. FSPs use data to look for new clients, often through marketing campaigns targeted to specific client segments. As new clients join, FSPs collect deeper information, often through sophisticated customer relationship management (CRM) systems. This may include transactional histories, such as purchases or automated teller machine (ATM) withdrawals, but can also go further to collect detailed income and business information. Data are so important that some FSPs have a chief information officer position among their senior management team. Large banks use their data to inform strategy and implementation. Citi, the global banking group, has more than 250 people in Asia working on data analytics, including an innovation lab in Singapore (Economist 2012). New and rising sources of digital data There are three main categories where the pace and volume of data generation are accelerating and will, in combination, affect how financial services are delivered. 1. Individual s financial services use. FSPs are heavily computerized and are collecting increasing amounts of data on each client transaction. Banks, microfinance institutions, and payment companies are collecting ever more information. For example, mobile payment transactions, such as M-PESA in Kenya, are generating a large new digital data trail on large portions of the population The experts interviewed are noted in the acknowledgments. 3
3 3 Examples Sales or purchases histories; e.g., Alibaba e-commerce Use of financial services (savings, insurance, trail of payments transactions) Credit information bureaus Examples Weather records Agricultural yields, irrigation coverage, prices Satellite imagery Surveys 2. Individual s digital interactions. The second stream of digital data is the trail of social and digital interactions individuals leave. The most widely available is mobile phone use. A 2013 review of nine low-income Asian and sub- Saharan countries showed adult ownership of a mobile phone ranged from 47 percent to 67 percent. Each call, airtime top-up, text message, or purchase leaves a digital record (Cartesian and Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation 2014). Internet use is also rising. China reports onehalf its population is online, and there are 100 million Facebook users in sub-saharan Africa alone (Techcrunch.com 2014). Advanced analytics make digital data even more useable Not only are the sources and volumes of data rising, but the ability to use data is also advancing. A key enabler of this is the ease of accessing large amounts of information over the internet. Data are increasingly stored in formats that are easier to read by computers (machine readable) and stored where they can be easily accessed by multiple users (in the cloud ). Data no longer need to come neatly in rows and columns. New database management software makes it possible to derive insights from datasets that would earlier have been too large or too varied to compare. 4 Examples Mobile call records on phone calls and text messages Mobile phone use, airtime purchases, handset type, location Social media (Twitter, Facebook, Google, Yahoo, and various forms of instant messaging) 3. Marketwide data (nonindividualized). The third category is data about the economy or geography. Most often this is not about an individual, but about a region or country. Governments are moving to digitize agricultural information, census data, maps, weather information, satellite imagery, and other sources. More than 40 countries have launched open data initiatives to ensure that data are machine readable, offered at low (or no) cost, and easy to share (Mckinsey Global Institute 2013). Governments are improving national identification, which is critical to more powerful uses of digital data. India s Unique Identification Authority (UIDAI), for instance, has built a database of 680 million residents of India since The unique identifier for each individual is a crucial way to cross-reference databases and link data on the same individual. The power to combine and cross-reference data from otherwise unconnected sources yields more powerful insights. Markets that lack strong identification systems are likely to lag in capturing the opportunity of digital data. Imagine using satellite imagery that can ascertain the size of a farmer s plot or roof type and the ability to cross-reference this to that household s receipt of remittances. Another example is linking historical insurance claims with regional information on health, which could help drive health insurance pricing and geographic targeting. There is great potential to gain insights that can lead to highly customized service. 4 For example, Hadoop and MapReduce are often cited as new analytics software for large data sets.
4 4 Early Evidence: Focus on Credit The earliest evidence comes from experiments with credit. 5 Several firms (e.g., Cignifi, First Access, and Tiaxa) specialize in credit analytics using new digital data sources, especially mobile operator call data records (CDRs). 6 When mining data, some of the focus is on making faster decisions to, for example, find and process first-time borrowers. Cignifi reports that in Brazil mobile CDRs provided insight that was used to double the response rate to a credit card offer. 7 In another example, First Access found that on average more than one-third of Tanzanian borrowers could be fast tracked for loan approval based on an initial score from their recent mobile phone use. 8 Credit scoring a numerical rating that indicates a borrower s likelihood of default is where many see wide applications for digital data. Nicole Stubbs of First Access explains that a person s behavior on the phone are a proxy for their financial stability and social network strength. For instance, a person who adds airtime in a similar amount every week is usually more reliable than someone who buys airtime erratically. 9 Some of the fastest emerging evidence relates to the performance of new loan products driven by new digital data. A widely used credit product is for prepaid mobile phone users who run out of airtime and who receive an advance of airtime instantly, often airtime advances are for small amounts less than $1. A number of companies analyze clients airtime use to determine whether the user should be eligible for these short-term airtime credits. Tiaxa is one such company; it makes 50 million small airtime credits a month for various mobile operators. Tiaxa is confident enough in this offering that it is building a team to expand its analytics services to support lenders decisions for larger loans (Herrera 2014). Other products go even further with credit. The M-Shwari product in Kenya is offered as a joint service of the mobile operator Safaricom and the Commercial Bank of Africa. Those who seek credit can have their mobile phone use analyzed to set an initial credit limit. Once a client begins using M-Shwari, his or her subsequent savings and credit behavior drives the credit limit. 10 In July 2014 Commercial Bank of Africa reported, The bank s M-Shwari unit has a loan-loss ratio below the industry average of five percent (Business Daily 2014). Eric Muriuki of the Commercial Bank of Africa confirms this figure for year end 2014, adding that $289 million had been disbursed in 2013 and Small businesses that make sales with digital payments are also using digital data. Digital sales records can be tracked and credit extended accordingly. Kopo Kopo, a company servicing a network of small businesses in Kenya, is beginning to offer a credit advance based on small businesses sales records. Similar approaches are being applied in other companies such as Zoona, which operates in multiple countries in southern Africa (Deluca, Meehan, and Lloyd 2014). There is clear evidence that digital data are enabling new kinds of services (see Box 1). Only more experimentation will tell how far these innovations can push loan sizes and tenors. The mobile operators call records are critical for finding new customers and setting a first time credit limit. Once a client has saved and borrowed for a short span it is that savings and borrowing behavior that can set future credit limits, according to Jamal Rahal, a leading expert in digital finance and risk management, who has been involved in analytics development for M-Shwari. 5 An initial scoping by Dahlberg for CGAP found that more than half of new data-focused start-up businesses are for credit. 6 CDRs are records of each call or text that notes the time, length, phone numbers involved, and other data. These records are kept primarily for billing the customer for usage. Mobile operators also can collect location data, purchases of airtime, and in some instances also mobile payments usage. 7 Interview with Lauren Betz of Cignifi. 8 Interview with Nicole Stubbs of First Access. 9 The statistical measure First Access reports using is Area under the Curve, which measures the discriminating ability of a binary model (good/bad borrower). 10 Interviews with Eric Muriuki of Commercial Bank of Africa and Tamara Cook of Financial Sector Deepening Kenya.
5 5 Box 1. Global Scan of New Deployments Using Digital Data In fall 2014, CGAP conducted a global scan of new financial service deployments that use digital data. This scan, carried out by the consulting firm Dalberg, found 36 deployments that use digital data as a critical part of their business model. This includes firms that specialize in digital data analytics as a service, but also newly launched products that leverage digital data as a key part of credit or insurance delivery. Of the 36 noted in the global scan most focus on new credit products or improving credit decisions. However, three of those picked up in the scan use new sources of digital data to improve insurance services. A list of the companies profiled in this global scan is available in the annex. Johan Bosini of AFB, which powers the short-term credit product Timiza in Tanzania with Airtel, sees the use of digital data similarly, The mobile operator data gives us access to a large number of potential Airtel clients to target, offering a small loan amount to the right customers, while the subsequent repayment and borrowing behavior becomes the long term basis for adjusting the credit limit, price and term of the credit facility over time. lenders establish strong motivations to repay not only based on good client data. Another key aspect is to build a person s borrowing history and have this determine future access to credit. In emerging markets, formal credit bureaus often do not work well, but the rise of digital data may provide an impetus that allows for creative new ways for credit histories to be established (CGAP and IFC 2011). Beyond Credit Wider Use Cases for Digital Data Early experimentation with digital data predominantly involves credit products. But there are wider use cases. We would expect future uses to fall into one of three broad uses across the customer engagement cycle. 1. Finding new customers 2. Deepening customer relationships 3. Managing risks In time, the applications should go beyond support to a single product and begin to affect how financial institutions broadly manage a longer customer engagement across a range of services (see Figure 1). The loan sizes are initially quite small, often $30 or less and often for a short period of one month. Elisabeth Rhyne of the Center for Financial Inclusion reminds that unsecured lending performs when Finding new clients Finding new clients is especially important for financial inclusion, which requires scale. Real Figure 1. Applications across a Customer Customer Engagement Engagement CycleCycles Customer Engagement 1. Finding new clients account opening pitch product 2. Deepening customer relationships up/cross-selling attrition 3. Managing risks Time Graphic derived from work by Jacobo Menajovsky.
6 6 Impact Analytics analyzed seven months of CDRs across three African countries. This analysis, which included more than 7 billion records, found a strong correlation between a user s social network and his or her mobile money uptake. The analysis provides clues about who to target early on to achieve faster uptake (CGAP 2013). Gathering the basic data necessary to begin a customer relationship is burdensome for customers, is expensive for providers, and sometimes leads to imprecise credit assessments. Digital data can help refine this process. For example, DemystData uses specialized search functions to verify identification information of new borrowers of a U.S.-based microlender. DemystData reports that 15 percent of customers who would have been rejected due to incomplete information actually can be accepted for a loan (Breloff and Hookey 2014). Similarly, Agora Partners is testing a system to gather basic farming data that loan officers of Indian banks can use as part of their loan assessment. This system would allow staff to gather and analyze quantitative information more efficiently and to spend more time on the qualitative aspects of credit assessment. Deepening customer relationships Once a customer is engaged in a basic service, digital data may provide clues about how to enhance the relationship. Tools can be developed to lower attrition or to quickly identify opportunities to up-sell or cross-sell to expand the relationship beyond the use of one product. M-Shwari in Kenya and M-Pawa in Tanzania are both credit and savings services that are offered to existing mobile money users. Mobile phone use and mobile money transactions are used as filters to decide who to target and what early credit limits to set. A free insurance program for mobile phone users who qualify by using a minimum amount of airtime per month is expanding fast (Tellez-Merchan and Zetterli 2014). Peter Gross of MicroEnsure, a company that added 12 million new customers using this model in 2014, believes the next stage will involve converting customers of free insurance to products that offer more benefits in exchange for a small premium, paid through airtime or mobile money. Freemium models have proven that the low-income market wants insurance and will reward a telecom that provides it, he says, but the future will belong to companies that offer durable value for money and can keep this new customer base engaged for the long term. To upsell, MicroEnsure uses data from mobile CDR and insurance histories to better target customers and price new insurance policies. Managing risk Risk management keeping loan losses or insurance claims within expected ranges involves more advanced statistical predictions of outcomes. A lot of attention is paid to how new digital data sources can help improve credit decisions. The applications can be at several levels. For example, it may permit access to borrowers who could not be underwritten before or to help set loan size limits. Insurance pricing and coverage is driven by risk and actuarial accuracy and the efficiency of verifying and settling insurance claims. India is a prime example of where weather stations have collected historical rainfall and temperatures allowing insurers to offer weather-indexed insurance. Verifying the accuracy of insurance claims is also a significant part of delivering insurance. Niraj Verma of the World Bank notes that in India, Satellite imagery can be used to estimate areas where crop failures are concentrated, which can help insurers optimize their claims assessment efforts and farmers to get more timely settlement.
7 7 Assessing the Potential: Changing the Economics of Delivery What could be the benefits of full use of digital data for financial inclusion? To develop a more quantitative analysis, CGAP contracted McKinsey and Company to examine more deeply one market Tanzania. 11 The analysis estimates how digital data can be used to help deliver formal financial products. The analysis focuses on several distinct credit and insurance products to offer specific details around estimates. New class of instant access services Several early experiments involve instant-access small credit. M-Shwari in Kenya is the largest such case, but in Tanzania several such products have launched in This includes M-Pawa, a service offered by mobile operator Vodacom and partner Commercial Bank of Africa. Other examples include Timiza, a credit service of the mobile operator Airtel and partner financial institutions AFB. These short-term liquidity products analyze a person s mobile airtime and mobile money use as part of a decision process to set a credit limit. The credit facility is sometimes linked to a savings account as well. Credit limits change based on the use of credit and savings over time. While there are up-front costs of setting up these new products, the incremental cost of each new client is extremely low calculated to be around $3.50 per year (see Figure 2). These instant access services have the potential to succeed in many markets. However, the speed of scaling up can be faster in countries such as Tanzania, where digital payments already reach 44 percent of adults (Intermedia 2014). It is not unreasonable to estimate such services reaching one-quarter of the adult population. M-Shwari reached 15 percent of adults in Kenya within its first two years of operation. However, CGAP research indicates that early challenges, including a lack of a national identification Figure 2. Marginal Costs for a One-Year Mobile Liquidity Facility Tanzania Examples of Digital Data Uses Finding new clients Deepening customer relationships Managing risks Target some mobile wallet holders for marketing Initial credit limit based on mobile call and mobile money usage Credit limits adjusted by savings and credit behaviors Build historical portfolio performance over time Client already registered mobile money user 1.2 $ Note: The costs assume the client is already a mobile money user and the relationship deepened by having the client register for additional products over the phone. The cost estimates are marginal costs not including up-front investment for product development of infrastructure. Costs assume client borrows on average three times a year. The credit limits are set at $25, but each credit draw is assumed to be $ The cost estimates include text communications with customers, a call center, and loan loss expenses. These estimates are based on multiple conversations across telecommunication providers and financial institutions in Tanzania. Some comparisons were done with providers in Kenya to cross-validate the numbers. 11
8 8 Figure 3. Marginal Costs Delivering a $200 Microloan Tanzania Examples of Digital Data Uses Baseline With Digital Data Finding new clients Marketing costs reduced with better targeting Earlier screening reduces time spent on rejections Less reliance on in-person data Deepening gathering customer More staff time with higher relationships risks Managing risks Predictive analytics keep loan losses within expected range Collection efforts focused on most likely to repay 18 9 $66 $38 Source: Source: CGAP and McKinsey analysis from Tanzania financial sector, 2014 system, in Tanzania are slowing some of the early uptake of credit. payments, savings, and insurance. Consider the costs of providing life insurance (see Figure 4). Reducing costs and extending reach of existing products The applications of digital data can also accelerate the uptake of existing products. Reducing costs can lead to significant market expansion. Lenders may find it more profitable to extend their services to new areas or new clients, while clients may find it less expensive and easier to access credit (see Figure 3). The applications of digital data go beyond credit to The estimates from Tanzania suggest that better screening and predictive analytics could improve targeting of insurance products and thereby reduce risks to insurers. The benefits could enable insurers to expand reach to those who are uninsured and possibly reduce premiums charged to clients. For example, in Tanzania there is very low insurance coverage today, but a basic life insurance product has a very large potential market of 7 million or more who could be served. Figure 4. Marginal Costs Delivering One-Month Life Insurance Tanzania Examples of Digital Data Uses Baseline With Digital Data Finding new clients Marketing costs reduced with better targeting Fewer documents on registration Deepening customer relationships Claims and other behaviors used to market higher value insurance Managing risks Predictive analytics can better manage claims and premiums setting Efficiencies in claims processing $4.4 $3.3 Source: Source: CGAP and McKinsey analysis from Tanzania financial sector, 2014
9 9 Unlocking the Potential of Digital Data So far this paper has highlighted the upside potential of digital data. Not only are the sources of new digital data expanding, but the ability to make use of these data is improving. There is already early evidence of remarkable advances, most prominently digitally enabled instant small-scale credit services. M-Shwari in Kenya is a prominent example of this. There are other applications, however, that could contribute to considerable cost reductions on delivery as well as expanded reach to new clients. However, to unleash the full potential of digital data, key barriers will need to be addressed. While the amount of digital data is growing globally, the reality in emerging markets is that many digital data sources will still take time to become available. The amount of data from mobile operators is increasing; however, the range and quality of data collected vary considerably (Cartesian and Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation 2014). Building a data-gathering process and a useable repository will require patience and creativity and in some cases careful advance planning. Similarly, the trends with public data indicate a growing amount of data is available but there is a lot left to be done. One measure by the Open Data Index shows that, globally, government-provided public data are not always accessible, easy to use, machine readable, up-to-date, or free of cost. 12 The modes for sharing data also need to be improved. Not only do regulatory restrictions need to be understood, but the business case for how partners share data involves significant analysis and processes that take time to mature. Analytics firms such as Real Impact Analytics and First Access report a need for patience with negotiating with partners to find suitable sharing arrangements. Another consideration is building the requisite staff knowledge and technology to use data more systematically. Collecting and working with data is not a one-off quick easy win, but rather it is a longterm investment and strategic commitment. For example, McKinsey and Company estimates that the upfront investment for a bank in Tanzania might be on the order of up to $1 million to establish strong in-house data analytics capacity. Ultimately, Will Poor Clients Benefit? For the use of digital data to achieve its potential it must do more than transform provider business models and contribute to major advancements to bring valued services to those excluded from formal financial services. The most basic measure of some success will be including those who were previously excluded. Poor clients may also benefit by having to present less documentation and to incur less time to access services. There will be unexpected challenges and more complex questions to address over time. Importantly, data privacy and protection rules are not well-established in most emerging markets and developing countries. Traditional approaches to these risks, such as consumers giving their informed consent to use their data, may not be meaningful or practical. In a limited sample of interviews with borrowers in Tanzania, CGAP found that users were often willing to sacrifice their confidentiality to access a loan, suggesting that there are issues that need to be better understood (Mazer, Carta, and Kaffenberger 2014). Another consideration is whether data-driven models unintentionally lead to more exclusion than inclusion. For instance, using data to discriminate systematically against certain groups (e.g., women, minorities) exacerbates existing gaps in access rather than promoting inclusion. Another consideration is whether digital data should, or can, in time substitute for in-person interactions between providers and their clients. Bindu Ananth of IFMR Trust and an advocate for the Keshetriya Gramin Financial Services high-touch rural delivery model in India points out that there [are] attributes of clients that must be observed, such as a person s 12 The Open Data Index is a global country survey with an indexed measure of Open Data available at
10 10 behaviors, family dynamics, or their health. It would over time are all critical parts of the wider discussion. be difficult to substitute these rich observations with There have already been real gains made with digital more abstract forms of digital data. It is also not data creating opportunities to improve access, and clear how clients perceptions or behaviors may be these will likely rise over time. More data will become affected when clients know that their data are so available, and providers will learn better how to rise to much a part of how services are delivered. the opportunity. The challenge ahead is recognizing opportunities and creating an environment that allows Addressing questions around client benefits, adequate for progress to create a new world where digital data protections for data privacy, and how to manage these will be used to enrich and protect the end user. Annex: Digital Data Deployments Global Scan, December 2014 Deployments Countries of Operation 1 Advanced Merchant Payments Hong Kong, Singapore, Philippines 2 AFB-Airtel Kenya, Ghana, Tanzania 3 Aire UK 4 Alibaba China 5 Capital Float India 6 Cignifi Mexico, Chile, Brazil, Ghana 7 DemystData USA 8 EcoCash Loans Zimbabwe 9 Experian USA 10 Experian Microanalytics Philippines 11 First Access Tanzania 12 Go Finance Tanzania 13 inventure Kenya 14 Kabbage USA, UK 15 Kopo Kopo Kenya 16 Kreditech Poland, Spain, Czech Republic, Mexico, Russia 17 LendUp USA 18 Lenndo Colombia, Mexico, Philippines 19 Leyebao Alifinance China 20 Linda Jamii Changamka Kenya 21 Loan Now USA 22 M-Cash Norway 23 M-Pawa Tanzania 24 M-Shwari Kenya 25 MiMoni Mexico 26 Mjara-MFS Africa Ghana, Cameroon 27 Mode Kenya, Chad 28 NeoGrowth India 29 Nirvoy Life Insurance Bangladesh 30 Platiza Russia 31 Progreso Financiero USA 32 Scanntech Uruguay, Argentina, Brazil, Chile, Peru 33 Tiaxa Brazil, Argentina, Mexico, Colombia, Chile, Ecuador, Hong Kong, China, Philippines, Bangladesh 34 Tigo Paraguay Paraguay 35 Wonga UK 36 ZestFinance USA Source: CGAP (2015).
11 11 Acknowledgments Bindu Ananth Robert Kirkpatrick Lauren Betz Michael Kubzansky Paul Breloff Katherine McKee Camille Busette Jacobo Menajovsky Gerhard Coetzee Jamal Rahal Tamara Cook Elisabeth Rhyne Arjuna Costa Rupalee Rupischitma Anamitra Deb Blaine Stephens Jonathan Hakim Nicole Stubbs Jake Kendall Olga Tomilova Tarun Khanna Niraj Verma Josephine Kibe Tauhid Zaman References Breloff, Paul, and Mark Hookey Big Data for Financial Inclusion: Is Boring Better? CGAP Blog, September. Business Daily CBA Aims for 10 million M-Shwari Accounts by Christmas. Business Daily, 11 July. Cartesian and the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation Using Mobile Data for Development. Seattle: Cartesian and the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation, March. CGAP The Power of Social Networks to Drive Mobile Money. Washington, D.C.: CGAP, March Global Mapping of Products beyond Payments. Washington, D.C.: CGAP. CGAP and IFC Credit Reporting at the Base of the Pyramid. Forum. Washington, D.C.: CGAP and IFC, October. de Montjoye, Yves-Alexandre, Jake Kendall, and Cameron F. Kerry Enabling Humanitarian Use of Mobile Phone Data. Issues in Technology Innovation, Brookings Institution, November 2014 Deluca, Thomas J., Jennifer Meehan, and James Lloyd New Approaches to MSME Lending: Challenging Traditional Credit Assessment Models in Electronic Cash-Flow Environments. Enterprise Development and Microfinance, September. Economist, The. 2014a. Little Things That Mean a Lot. The Economist, 19 July b. Waiting on Hold. The Economist, 25 October Crunching the Numbers. The Economist, 19 May. Guardian, The Real Time Maps Could Predict and Prevent the Spread of Malaria. The Guardian, 23 October. Herrera, Miguel Leveraging Mobile Phone Data: Tiaxa s Balance Advance. CGAP Blog, 15 September. Inc. Magazine Big Data: You Have No Idea How Much It Will Change Your Life. Inc. Magazine, November. Intermedia Financial Inclusion Insights Tanzania, New York: Intermedia. Kumar, Kabir, and Kim Muhota Can Digital Footprints Lead to Greater Financial Inclusion? Brief. Washington, D.C.: CGAP, July. Mazer, Rafe, Jessica Carta, and Michelle Kaffenberger Informed Consent: How Do We Make It Work for Mobile Credit Scoring? Washington, D.C.: CGAP, August. Mckinsey Global Institute Open Data: Unlocking Innovation and Performance with Liquid Information. Washington, D.C.: Mckinsey Global Institute, October. Shrader, Leesa Microfinance, E-commerce, Big Data and China: The Alibaba Story. CGAP Blog, October. Techcrunch.com Facebook Users Hits 100m in Africa. Techcrunch.com, 14 September. Tellez-Merchan, Camilo, and Peter Zetterli The Global Landscape of Mobile Microinsurance. CGAP Blog, 10 February.
12 No. 100 January 2015 Please share this Focus Note with your colleagues or request extra copies of this paper or others in this series. CGAP welcomes your comments on this paper. All CGAP publications are available on the CGAP Web site at CGAP 1818 H Street, NW MSN P3-300 Washington, DC USA Tel: Fax: CGAP, 2015 The authors of this Focus Note are CGAP Senior Financial Sector Specialists Gregory Chen and Xavier Faz. The suggested citation for this Focus Note is as follows: Chen, Gregory, and Xavier Faz The Potential of Digital Data: How Far Can It Advance Financial Inclusion? Focus Note 100. Washington, D.C.: CGAP, January. Print: ISBN epub: ISBN pdf: ISBN mobi: ISBN UKa from the British people
UNITED NATIONS CONFERENCE ON TRADE AND DEVELOPMENT Expert Meeting on THE IMPACT OF ACCESS TO FINANCIAL SERVICES, INCLUDING BY HIGHLIGHTING THE IMPACT ON REMITTANCES ON DEVELOPMENT: ECONOMIC EMPOWERMENT
2020 Foresight: Best Practices in Implementing Mobile Payments Product Code: VR0963MR Published Date: November 2013 For more details about the full report, please contact: T: +65 6383 4688 E: firstname.lastname@example.org
2020 Foresight: Best Practices in Implementing Mobile Payments Product Code: VR0963MR Published Date: November 2013 www.timetric.com TABLE OF CONTENTS TABLE OF CONTENTS 1 Executive Summary... 6 2 Dynamics
08 NOTE NUMBER FEBRUARY 2013 FINDEX NOTES Asli Demirguc-Kunt Leora Klapper Douglas Randall The Global Findex Database Financial Inclusion in India In India 35 percent of adults have a formal account and
EFL Case Study: Using the EFL Score to Enhance Credit Bureau Data Equifax Peru Executive Summary: Equifax () set out to determine if EFL could add value to its MSME scoring in one of their biggest markets
Microfinance and Technology Frankfurt School of Finance and Management July 2013 Julia Abakaeva CGAP s Contribution to Evolving Field 1995 Microcredit Proof of concept for microcredit Sustainability in
AMDOCS INTERACTIVE CUSTOMER SUCCESS STORY HONG KONG CSL At CSL, we have a commitment to deliver quality, innovative and relevant mobile data services to all of our 1010 and One2Free customers. The Interactive
DATA FROM THE NEXT BILLION Nathan Eagle Big Data in Growth Markets Small Data in Growth Markets Data Reciprocity 2 ACTIVE MOBILE SUBSCRIPTIONS Developing Countries Developed Countries 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 2000
Market Research MARKET SIZING OVERVIEW Market sizing is traditionally defined as estimating the number of buyers of a particular product, or users of a service. Because of the relative newness of mobile
Mobile Financial Services for Rural Water in Africa A Booming Mobile Economy in Sub Saharan Africa Up to 300 Million Mobile Money Subscribers (2014) Active mobile money accounts stands at 103 million (as
Financing Smallholder Farmers to Increase Incomes and Transform Lives in Rural Communities EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Africa is home to a quarter of the world s farmland, yet it generates only 10 percent of all
USAGE OF METRICS AND ANALYTICS IN EMEA MOVING UP THE MATURITY CURVE USAGE OF METRICS AND ANALYTICS IN EMEA MOVING UP THE MATURITY CURVE When we asked business executives about the importance of human capital
Mobile Money Transfer & Remittances 2 June 2010, Moscow - Mirpal Conference Mehdi Elhaoussine, Consultant, World Bank Expert Mobile Financial Services 1 Market figures Introduction 200 million people around
Global Consumer Bank Manuel Medina-Mora CEO, Global Consumer Banking Bank of America Merrill Lynch Banking and Financial Services Conference November 16, 2011 Agenda Our Business & Results Investing in
CONSUMERLAB Mobile COMMERCE IN EMERGING MARKETS An Ericsson ConsumerLab Insight Summary Report January 2015 contents EXAMINING ATTITUDES 3 GROWING URBANIZATION 4 A CASH ECONOMY 6 PERCEPTION IS KEY 7 ECONOMIC
Two trillion and counting Assessing the credit gap for micro, small, and medium-size enterprises in the developing world OCTOBER 2010 Peer Stein International Finance Corporation Tony Goland McKinsey &
Chapter 2 Introduction to the similar solutions and compare with the proposed system. Chapter two contains the similar solutions done by others and these solutions have been compared with the automated
Citi OpenInvestor sm OpenLend sm Securities Lending Solutions Customized Programs to Optimize Portfolio Performance 2 Citi Transaction Services Innovative Solutions for a Sophisticated Market Lending programs
International Investing get the facts How You Can Learn More About Foreign Companies and Markets PRESENTED BY: United States Securities and Exchange Commission Division of Corporation Finance mutual funds
Data Modeling & Bureau Scoring Experian for CreditChex Karachi Nov. 29 th 2007 Experian Decision Analytics Credit Services Help clients with data and services to make business critical decisions in credit
The World Bank Group March 2006 Issue No. 10 AccessFinance A Newsletter Published by the Financial Sector Vice Presidency Access to Finance Thematic Group SME Credit Scoring: Key Initiatives, Opportunities,
SME Finance Policy - harnessing technology and innovation - G20 SME Workshop Riyadh, March 11, 2014 Douglas Pearce 1 SME FINANCE CONSTRAINTS AND RESPONSES 2 INNOVATIVE APPROACHES CAN EASE CONSTRAINTS 3
The benefits of private equity investment David Wilton, Chief Investment Officer, International Finance Corporation (IFC), looks at how private equity can be beneficial; the different investment strategies
How Technology Is Changing Small Business Lending Faster, Easier Business Loan Solutions Are Online Whitepaper Brought to You By Balboa Capital BUSINESS LOAN + = The year was 1994. The first major Internet
FIELD BRIEF No. 19 August 2012 Making the Case for Mobile Money: A Look at Social Cash Transfers for Development This FIELD Brief is the nineteenth in a series produced by the Financial Integration, Economic
FINSCOPE Zambia 2009 FinScope Zambia 2009 The Government of the Republic of Zambia (GRZ) has been committed to reforming the country s financial sector for several years. Financial access is now a priority
Bank of America Merrill Lynch Banking & Financial Services Conference Manuel Medina Mora Chairman of the Global Consumer Banking Council November 17, 2010 Consumer Banking in Citicorp Agenda Our Business
Corporate Banking Understanding your Corporate Banking needs in Africa Contents 3 Working alongside you to power your success 4 Bringing your business a dedicated relationship model 5 A range of services
Excerpt Sudan Fixed Telecommunications: Low Penetration Rates Get a Boost from Broadband Internet and VoIP Services This report is part of Pyramid Research s series of Africa & Middle East Country Intelligence
Impact Investing Presented by: MicroVest Capital Management, LLC Gil Crawford, CEO David Wedick, Business Development Officer May 9, 2012 INVESTING IN ONE WORLD Impact Investing An impact investment intentionally
LAFFERTY T h e G lo b a l C re d i t Card s I nd ex A ND T h e G lo b a l D e bi t C ard s I nd ex w w w. laffe rty. com Introduction Lafferty s Best in Class series of reports provides you with everything
How successful is your campaign and promotion management? Towards best-practice campaign management strategies Welcome to the new normal Businesses today are under unprecedented pressure to increase spending
The Power of Technology IN CRE Data and Analytics 7800 42 0.2 3420.330 175lbs 32/X 1 4300.250 x21 36.14 3420.330 32/X 1 Potential 21.56 25x100 growth is an organization s future ability to generate larger
Mobile Banking, Financial Inclusion and Policy Challenges Presentation to the 10 th IADI Annual Conference 19-20 October 2011, Warsaw, Poland Pierre-Laurent Chatain Prudential Oversight and Systemic Stability
Mobile Financial services Real cases from around the world 1 # It s time for money to change We believe that as money goes mobile, network operators will play a significant role in the m-commerce value
Growing the Digital Business: Spotlight on Mobile Apps Accenture Mobility Research 2015 Introduction 2 In the past five years, companies have spent considerable time, money and attention developing mobile
USING MOBILE DATA TO REACH THE UNBANKED AGENDA Technology in Financial Inclusion Introduction to Cignifi The Project Analysis and Results Other Applications Conclusions 2 TECHNOLOGY IN FINANCIAL INCLUSION
THE MASTERCARD FOUNDATION: RURAL AND AGRICULTURAL FINANCE STRATEGY SEPTEMBER 2015 The MasterCard Foundation works with visionary organizations to provide greater access to education, skills training and
To Build or To Buy? The Question for Every Marketplace Lender Darpan Saini, Co-Founder & CTO, Cloud Lending Solutions CLOUD LENDING SOLUTIONS Lending Innovation starts here Contents Introduction How Does
Decisioning for Telecom Customer Intimacy Experian Telecom Analytics Turning disruption into opportunity The traditional telecom business model is being disrupted by a variety of pressures from heightened
November 2014 Executive Summary: Global Payments Global Payment Growth Fueled by Cross-Border and Mobile Commerce By Tim Parry Global ecommerce is expected to top $1.25 trillion U.S. by the end of 2014,
FINANCING SMALL AND MICRO ENTERPRISES IN AFRICA 1. THE ISSUES There is the perception that the demand for finance by small enterprises far exceeds the supply, but recent research in 4 countries shows that
For today s companies, a fast, reliable Internet connection has moved from being a convenience to a critical component of business success. Wire your business for success High-Speed Internet is Critical
PUBLICATION DATE: JULY 2016 PAGE 2 GENERAL INFORMATION I PAGE 3 KEY FINDINGS I PAGE 4-10 TABLE OF CONTENTS I PAGE 11 REPORT-SPECIFIC SAMPLE CHARTS I PAGE 12 METHODOLOGY I PAGE 13 RELATED REPORTS I PAGE
Expanding the Financial Services Frontier: Lessons From Mobile Phone Banking in Kenya Mwangi S. Kimenyi Senior Fellow, Africa Growth Initiative at Brookings Njuguna S. Ndung u Governor, Central Bank of
SOLUTION BRIEF Understanding Your Customer Journey by Extending Adobe Analytics with Big Data Business Challenge Today s digital marketing teams are overwhelmed by the volume and variety of customer interaction
Global Funding Marketplace for Invoice Discounters Simple Online Global Highly Liquid Open-Access Marketplace for Invoice Portfolio Divestments partner.aztecexchange.com Welcome to the world of Aztec With
Deutsche Bank Global Transaction Banking Direct Securities Services Securities Services Overview Finding the right custodian with a long-term commitment to supporting its clients business is critical for
From Money Transfer to Transforming Lives E. Emre Kanaat Head of Consumer Services June 3rd, 2015 Agenda Why Mobile Money? The story of M-Pesa Why Mobile Wallet? The story of Cep Cüzdan Why Mobile Money?
Cloud Analytics Where CFOs, CMOs and CIOs Need to Move To IN PARTNERSHIP WITH Analytics and the Speed Advantage Introduction Three recent workplace trends the growth of the mobile revolution, the emergence
Mobile money A payment industry revolution impacting marketing and distribution Pascal Eber Partner Operations Excellence & Human Capital Deloitte Benjamin Deransart Director Teranga Consulting Until now,
34 McKinsey on Payments September 2013 Global payments trends: Challenges amid rebounding revenues Global payments revenue rebounded to $1.34 trillion in 2011, a steep increase from 2009 s $1.1 trillion.
Decisioning for Telecom Customer Intimacy Experian Telecom Analytics Turning disruption into opportunity The traditional telecom business model is being disrupted by a variety of pressures. From heightened
Emerging Markets Review 3 (2002) 325 337 Measuring transparency and disclosure at firmlevel in emerging markets Sandeep A. Patel*, Amra Balic, Liliane Bwakira Standard & Poor s, New York, NY, USA Received
MAXIMISING VALUE FROM DIRECT MARKETING: CUSTOMER ENGAGEMENT DATE: October 2013 Tim Gilmour Chief Marketing Officer aegon.com AEGON DIRECT & AFFINITY MARKETING SERVICES ADAMS (AND ITS SISTER COMPANIES WORLDWIDE)
IBM Software Business Analytics Social Analytics Social Business Analytics Gaining business value from social media 2 Social Business Analytics Contents 2 Overview 3 Analytics as a competitive advantage
Center for Agriculture & Rural Development (CARD): Using the PPI to Promote Microsavings and Enhance Targeted Marketing to the Poor Introduction The Center for Agriculture and Rural Development (CARD),
Get Better Business Results From the Four Stages of Your Customer Lifecycle Stage 1 Acquisition A white paper from Identify Unique Needs and Opportunities at Each Lifecycle Stage It s a given that having
Today, we have access to a vast amount of customer data that can be used to power sales and marketing efforts. That may not be the case tomorrow. behind. Currently, regulations for customer data are looser
VENTURE CAPITAL: DRIVING DEVELOPMENT IN LATIN AMERICA Multilateral Investment Fund Member of the IDB Group SUMMARY Venture Capital (VC) in Latin America is still in its inception but has enormous potential.
Unlocking the True Potential of Usage Data Amdocs White Paper November 2014 UNLOCKING THE TRUE POTENTIAL OF USAGE DATA 2 With the continued pressure to differentiate and lead in a market suffering from
WHITE PAPER DON T REACT ACT! HOW PROACTIVE REVENUE MANAGEMENT CAN PAY OFF BIG IN TODAY S MARKETS CONTENTS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 1 INTRODUCTION 2 REACTING TO A POOR CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE IS TOO LATE AND LEADS
Sybase Solutions for Healthcare Adapting to an Evolving Business and Regulatory Environment OVERVIEW Sybase Solutions for Healthcare Adapting to an Evolving Business and Regulatory Environment Rising medical
Powering Performance with Customer Intelligence Are you ready to make Customer Intelligence your performance advantage to outpace the competition? Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) PNT Marketing Services
Big Data Big Deal? Salford Systems www.salford-systems.com 2015 Copyright Salford Systems 2010-2015 Big Data Is The New In Thing Google trends as of September 24, 2015 Difficult to read trade press without
Micro Crop Insurance and Protecting the Poor Lessons From the Field Aaron Oxley CTO, Micro Insurance Agency email@example.com The Program Who are we an what do we do? Who are the poor?
White Paper Analyzing Big Data: The Path to Competitive Advantage by Marcia Kaplan Contents Introduction....2 How Big is Big Data?................................................................................
The Increasing Role Data is Playing in Travel Marketing Bruce H. Rogers Chief Insights Officer and Head of the CMO Practice Forbes Media Computers are incredibly fast, accurate and stupid. Human beings
Amdocs Commercial Billing Solution Central Fee and Interest Manager THE NEED FOR SMART PRICING AND REVENUE MANAGEMENT EXCELLENCE Today, many banks are facing the need to renew their core business applications,
29-30 November 2016 RAI Amsterdam THE ULTIMATE ACCESS TO EUROPE S BIG DATA ANALYTICS LEADERS, EXPERTS, AND BUYERS ACROSS TOP INDUSTRY VERTICALS #AWCongress www.analytics-world-congress.com brought to you
A Customer Relationship Management White Paper 10 Steps to CRM Success i Table of Contents Step1: It s all About the Customer... 1 Who Are Your Customers?... 1 Define Customer Attributes... 1 Step 2: Build
Banking on Business Intelligence (BI) Building a business case for the Kenyan Banking Sector The new banking environment in Kenya is all about differentiating banking products, increased choices, security
Amdocs Sales WANT TO STRENGTHEN YOUR CUSTOMER RELATIONSHIPS? THE RIGHT SALES STRATEGY WILL HELP Changing market conditions mean that you have to do more than just keep your customers you have to grow your
Mobile Money in Developing Countries: Common Factors Khyati Malik Abstract In this paper, we address many questions related to the adoption of mobile money in developing countries. Is mobile money being
Why Modern B2B Marketers Need Predictive Marketing Sponsored by www.raabassociatesinc.com firstname.lastname@example.org www.mintigo.com email@example.com Introduction Marketers have used predictive modeling