1 POLICY SOLUTIONS: FRAUD, CORRUPTION IN THE COURTS Anne Stevenson, Journalist and Policy Consultant
2 Most court industry professionals are honest and do not engage in corruption.
3 Organized Crime Operating Within The Justice System Itself Is Not Just Unethical or Unfair, It s a Serious Threat To Public Safety.
4 Chief Complaints of Parents Judges, court admins misused court appointment process to force parents into business relationships with unvetted and inappropriate court affiliated vendors Judges ignored evidence, law on their cases. Court admins, Judges with conflicts of interest acted as business promoter s, collection agency for affiliated professionals. BILLING FRAUD: GAL s, attorneys, custody evaluators, visitation supervisors failed to spend time with children, accused of double billing, charged hundreds of thousands in fees for unnecessary services. Consequences for nonpayment: -Loss of parental rights -Loss of employment -Bankruptcy/permanent financial ruin -Bogus criminal charges -Jail/loss of freedom -Children placed with violent offenders, murdered
5 What Is Fraud?
6 FRAUD The intentional perversion of truth in order to induce another to part with something of value or to surrender a legal right. -Merriam-Webster Dictionary
7 Two Broward County Sheriff s Office Deputies Charged With Conspiracy, Rigging Custody Case Charges- Conspiracy, influence peddling, tax fraud, Up until October 2009, Ft. Lauderdale attorney Scott W. Rothstein was operating a $1.9 BILLION ponzi scheme via Rosenfeldt and Adler, P.A. (RRA). Broward Sheriff s Office (BSO) Lieutenant David Benjamin and BSO Detective Jeffrey Alan Poole are corrupt officers who set up a fake company for the purpose of accepting $185,000 bribes from Rothstein to provide Rothstein and his associates with extra-ordinary access to law enforcement and illegal corporate benefits. Attorney Douglas Bates helped Rothstein carry out his ponzi scam. At some point, Bates approaches Rothstein and asks Rothstein to help him rig his child custody case. Bates tells Rothstein that he suspects his ex-wife is an addict who abuses prescription drugs. During a subsequent custody exchange, Bates provided his ex-wife with their disabled son s medication in bottles that were unmarked so that it would appear that she did not have a prescription for the pills. Rothstein, having this information, arranged to have Poole and Benjamin conduct surveillance on Bates ex-wife s home. On June 29,2009, Poole arrested Bates ex-wife during a traffic stop on bogus charges for illegal possession of narcotics. Bates was given a copy of the arrest report, which he then used to fraudulently persuade the family court to give him sole custody of his children and abate his support obligations.
8 Anatomy of Kickback Scam Rothstein Employs Bates Pays bribes BSO Sheriffs Take bribes via fake company from Rothstein Falsely arrest Bates ex-wife Family Court Sees arrest report, grants Bates motion for sole custody of victim s children
9 Conflict of Interest A real or seeming incompatibility between one s private interests and one s public or fiduciary duties. -Black s Law Dictionary
10 NJ Family Court Judge Melanie Appleby November 2014: New Jersey Supreme Court suspended Appleby from the bench for one month, without pay because she created, concealed conflict of interest. Appleby conspired to promote the business interests of a lawyer who helped her with her own child-support issue even though he had cases before her. Appleby met with attorney in chambers to help him with his cases. Attorney used another attorney s stationary, forged signature of another attorney to conceal communications between himself and Appleby, with Appleby s knowledge and implicit consent. *Source: Judge Suspended for Creating, Concealing Conflict, Mary Pat Gallagher, NJ Law Tribune, 11/5/2014
11 Why Does the Rothstein Case Matter? Poole and Benjamin were also charged with arranging to use force and threats of force against the boyfriend of an escort who was threatening to expose the illicit relationship which existed between the escort and one of Rothstein s other partners. On October 27, 2009, BSO Sheriffs assisted Rothstein in loading cash and jewelry onto a private airplane which was used by Rothstein to flee to Morocco as the Ponzi scheme being conducted through RRA began to unravel.
12 COURT CORPORATIONS
13 Former Family Court Attorney Pleads Guilty Charges: Tax Evasion, Fraud/False Billing Sentence: 12 Months in Federal Prison, $63,000 restitution Danielle Ross was an attorney who also served as a guardian ad litem in Lackawanna County, Pennsylvania. For almost five years, Ross was paid to represent the will and best interests of children in family and juvenile court cases, then make custody recommendations to the court in those cases. The court would appoint Ross onto custody cases, then order parents to pay Ross hundreds of dollars per hour out of pocket for her services. Ross also received a $38,000 per year salary under a no-bid contract she obtained from Lackawanna County. If parents could not afford Ross s services, the County would pay Ross an additional $50 per hour to work on their cases. Ross made over $400,000 per year acting as a GAL in Family Court, however, Federal prosecutors said Ross failed to report more than $200,000 of income on her federal income taxes. In some cases, Ross billed both the families and the county for services that were never provided or should not have been double billed.
14 Normal GAL Payment GAL APPOINTED Agreement of the parties Court order GAL PAID Parents pay out of pocket OR State or County pays with tax dollars INCOME TAXES Court, GAL fill out IRS form 1099, W-4, etc. GAL pays state, federal taxes on income
15 ROSS Tax Fraud Parent$ ounty
16 Why Is Billing Fraud A Threat To Public Safety? Corrupt providers sometimes make life or death recommendations in a case without spending adequate time with the children and families whose will and interests they purport to represent. Family court industry professionals are often paid more money if the kids are placed in situations in which conflict is maximized. Therefore, corrupt service providers are always going to try and cause the court to find in favor of their own billable hours. Corrupt GAL s have no incentive to close cases. They may create problems for the purpose of getting paid to solve them. This can be fraud because the services would not be needed but for the deliberate misconduct of the unethical service providers. Law enforcement rarely intervenes in scams which occur within the context of family court cases. In order to falsely discredit scam victims, parents and children may be diagnosed with mental illnesses they do not have, bankrupted, and thrown in jail on false charges for nonpayment and other bogus offenses while violent and dangerous offenders engaged in criminal activity retain custody of the child victims (bear with me for further examples of this.)
17 Accountability: What did these parents do right? Focused on integrity of professional billing, not spouses COUNTY PAY: Used open records requests to the State, County to obtain copies of the vendor invoices documenting payments made to Ross. PRIVATE PAY: Collected copies of the invoices, billing statements, receipts Ross gave them
18 Public Records Requests Open records requests to Judicial Branch, Public Defender s office, State Controller, etc. seeking copies of communications, invoices, contracts, bids, etc. IRS filings available via Guidestar Secretary of State s Office-Business filings, some on-line
19 Resources Reporter s Committee for Freedom of the Press FOIA Letter Generator: Info on how to draft motions, administrative appeals, complaints, etc.
20 Racketeering A system of organized crime traditionally involving the extortion of money from businesses by intimidation, violence, or other illegal methods. A pattern of illegal activity (such as bribery, extortion, fraud, and murder) carried out as part of an enterprise (such as a crime syndicate) that is owned or controlled by those engaged in illegal activity. See Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act (RICO) USCA Black s Law Dictonary
21 John O Brien, Convicted Probation Dept. Chief, Sentenced to 18 Months in Prison O Brien accused of running Massachusetts Dept of Probation like a criminal enterprise, trading favors with legislators in order to gain political clout. Legislators gave O Brien list of preferred hires. Some hires had made campaign contributions. Instead of hiring and promoting most qualified candidates, O Brien hired from legislator s lists, which sometimes recommended candidates who were unqualified and possibly dangerous in such positions. Witnesses including family court judges, legislators given immunity in exchange for testimony. O Brien found guilty of mail fraud, conspiracy, racketeering, sentenced to 18 months in prison, fined $25,000, sentenced to one year of supervised release. Co-conspirator top aide Elizabeth Tavares guilty of mail fraud, racketeering, and conspiracy, 3 months in prison. William Burke III found guilty of conspiracy, sentenced to probation. Both fined $10,000. Source: John O Brien, Convicted Probation Dept. Chief, Sentenced to 18 Months in Prison, Boston Globe, Eric Levenson, 11/13/2014
22 CT Court Employees Face Tough Questions Over Conflicts of Interest -Washington Times, Anne Stevenson, 5/20/ : Family court judges, administrators started a corporation with the professionals who appear before them on cases (attorneys, custody evaluator, psychologist, GAL.) Operated business without registration for 30 years. 2013: Business not registered with IRS, Secretary of State, AG s Charity Registry, etc. Court admins who are corporate directors use court resources to hire company as a contractless vendor, promote business via court offices. Court administrator who oversees grants uses court to solicit fees, donations, membership dues from 500 family court professionals. What accounts were they using?
23 Association of Family and Conciliation Courts (AFCC) AFCC is a trade association founded by family court judges, court admins, professionals who appear before them. Can be a court vendor hired to run vital services, conduct studies (ex. Mediation, domestic violence screening, court services, employee training, etc.) PROBLEM: Inbred, funded with tax $, private donations
24 Why is this a problem? Quality Control: Affiliation provides disincentive to protect consumers instead of business partners/affiliates. Judges may make decisions based on business interests, not evidence/law Conflicted professionals may provide clients with sub-standard services to promote business with affiliated professionals.
25 Marv Bryer v. LA Family Court Corruption Early 1990 s: LA father Marv Bryer s daughter is embroiled in child custody case in LA Superior Court. Family spends $100,000 on attorneys, litigation fees. 1994: Bryer does open records request to family court internal finance auditor Gregory Pentoney seeking records pertaining to donations made by judges to LA County Bar Assn. Finds two "donation" checks totaling $6,750 deposited into LA Superior Court Judge s Association, requisitioned through the bar association by the mother of the man Bryer's daughter was resisting in her custody case. Case moved to Orange County. LASCJA originally belonged to AFCC, uses LA family court as business address, uses FEIN# of LA County on accounts, paying out to judges, but not paying taxes. Shut down by IRS, state multiple times. Bryer sues Pentoney, County of LA 1999: Pentoney, several County employees convicted in related kickback scheme for accepting bribes, stealing millions in LA County Condemnation funds (e.g. abandoned property). SOURCE: Is Justice for Sale in LA? InSight Magazine, Kelly Patricia O Meara, Vol. 15, No May 3, 1999
26 Bryer s LA Court Kickback Scam Donation to LA Bar Association Deposit to AFCC/LASCJA Account Payment to Judges
27 CT Task Force Spars With Parents Over Billing Fraud in Family Court -Washington Times, Anne Stevenson, December 26, 2013 June 2013: CT State Legislature creates family court task force to address consumer complaints re: GAL oversight, billing fraud. December 2013: Task force convenes. AFCC members appointed onto task force to solve problem they are accused of creating. Parents request audit of court vendors: -State auditor s report showed significant money, resources missing from family court budget -AFCC affiliated vendor CT Resources Group double billed parents, court, health insurance company for services not performed
28 CT Resources Group Dr. Sidney Horowitz, Dr. Howard Krieger-mental health evaluators, custody evaluators, paid by family court to train staff, ran GAL certification program, evaluate litigants. Parents provided private billing statements, invoices from providers Communications between Horowitz and court talked to judges off record about cases, double billed. Judges approved payments for services not provided. Checked against health insurance company billing records -Tittle v. Tittle: Horowitz testified children had no mental health problems -Billed health insurance company using dx codes for major mental illnesses the children did not have
29 OUTCOME FOR CT CONSUMERS CT Judicial Branch either has the most honest and efficient workforce known to mankind, or alternatively, serious oversight problems: 10+ complaints about AFCC judges dismissed by Judicial Review Commission. No GAL has ever been professionally disciplined. Ever. Legislature (made up of mostly lawyers) passed laws statutorily legitimizing GAL s role, did nothing to address billing fraud No Attorneys were disciplined. Except those who stood up for clients re: AFCC conflicts of interest. Dept of Public Health investigations into Horowitz, Krieger still open. State s Attorney opened an extortion investigation into a GAL s conduct in one case. Secretary of State s investigation into AFCC still open. No one fired by Judicial Branch. Chief Administrator William Carbone (AFCC member) and Chief Family Court Administrative Judge Lynda Munro (CT AFCC founder) voluntarily retired for unpublicized reasons. CT AFCC founders Judges Gerard Adelman and Holly Abery-Wetstone moved to different courts for unstated reasons.
This booklet was published with the generous support of Stan Marks Begam & Marks, P.A. Phoenix, AZ Robert Pastor Montoya, Jimenez & Pastor, P.A. Phoenix, AZ Sara Powell Law Office of Sara Powell Phoenix,
This booklet was published with the generous support of Melvin L. Hewitt, Jr. Isenberg & Hewitt, P.C. Atlanta, Georgia Civil Justice for Victims of Crime in Georgia For referrals to an attorney or more
Consumer s Guide to New Jersey Law A Free Public Education Service from the New Jersey State Bar Foundation One Constitution Square, New Brunswick, NJ 08901-1500 1-800-FREE LAW www.njsbf.org This bo oklet
Friend of the Court Handbook Based on the Model Handbook prepared by: Friend of the Court Bureau/SCAO Michigan Supreme Court To view the most current version of this publication and other SCAO publications,
This booklet was published with the generous support of Ralph Davis Ralph Davis Law Peoria, Illinois For referrals to an attorney or more information, please call the National Crime Victim Bar Association
This booklet was published with the generous support of Richard Binko Law Offices of Richard S. Binko Cheektowaga, New York Madeline Bryer Law Offices of Madeline Bryer New York, New York Cynthia S. LaFave
This booklet was published with the generous support of Douglas H. Clark, Esq. Las Vegas, NV For referrals to an attorney or more information, please call the National Center for Victims of Crime at 1-800-FYI-CALL
This booklet was published with the generous support of Benjamin D. Andreozzi, Esq. Harrisburg, PA Stewart J. Eisenberg, Esq. Eisenberg, Rothweiler, Winkler, Eisenberg and Jeck, P.C. Philadelphia, PA Jeffrey
This booklet was published with the generous support of JOHN BLUME, ESQ. BLUME, GOLDFADEN, BERKOWITZ, DONNELLY, FRIED & FORTE Chatham, NJ JEFFREY FRITZ, ESQ. Philadelphia, PA HAROLD GERR, ESQ. Highland
This booklet was published with the generous support of The Brumbelow Drechsel Law Group, P.A. St. Petersburg, FL Farmer, Jaffe, Weissing, Edwards, Fistos & Lehrman, P.A. Ft. Lauderdale, FL Gerson & Schwartz,
This booklet was published with the generous support of Keith Franz Azrael, Franz, Schwab & Lipowitz, LLC Baltimore, Maryland Stan Brown Law Office of Stan Derwin Brown, LLC Largo, Maryland Steven Kelly
This booklet was published with the generous support of Mary Alexander, Esq. San Francisco, CA Joseph George, Esq. Sacramento, CA Ivo Labar, Esq. San Francisco, CA John Manly, Esq. Newport Beach, CA Dwight
CODE OF PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY (Superseded February 1, 2007) View the Ohio Rules of Professional Conduct (effective February 1, 2007) Preface Canon 1 A Lawyer Should Assist in Maintaining the Integrity
What you should know about IN ONTARIO This booklet contains information about the law as it was at the time it was written. The law can change. Check the Ministry of the Attorney General website at http://www.attorneygeneral.jus.gov.on.ca
N E W J E R S E Y INSURANCE Special Report: Cracking Fraud Rings F aud r OIFP Draws International Praise Closing Loopholes: Proposals for Legislative and Regulatory Reform New Crime Takes Aim at Insurance
TURNING 18? SOME THINGS ABOUT THE LAW YOU NEED TO KNOW 1 2 TABLE OF CONTENTS INTRODUCTION...4 VOTING...4 JURY DUTY...5 DRIVING...6 DRINKING LAWS...8 CRIMINAL CHARGES...8 EMPLOYMENT...10 APARTMENT LEASES...11
This booklet was published with the generous support of Steven Laird Law Offices of Steven C. Laird Fort Worth, Texas Marc Lenahan Lenahan Law, PLLC Dallas, Texas Tahira Merritt Law Office of Tahira Khan
Office of the Attorney General Idaho Ethics In Government Manual AUGUST 2008 LAWRENCE WASDEN Attorney General 700 West State Street Boise, ID 83720-0010 www.ag.idaho.gov State of Idaho Office of Attorney
General District Courts To Understand Your Visit to Court You Should Know: It is the courts wish that you know your rights and duties. We want every person who comes here to receive fair treatment in accordance
Reaching the Age of Majority Your Legal Rights and Responsibilities A Law-Related Education Project of the Nebraska State Bar Foundation Underwritten by: The Marvin and Virginia Schmid Law-Related Education
Colorado Commissions on Judicial Performance 2014 Training Garfield County Courthouse Denver City & County Building El Paso County Courthouse (Historic) Weld County Courthouse Montrose County Courthouse
This booklet was published with the generous support of Mary Alexander, Esq. Mary Alexander and Associates, PC San Francisco, CA Philip Bourdette, Esq. Bourdette & Partners Visalia, CA Deborah Chang, Esq.
responsibility CODE OF CONDUCT Our reputation and integrity depend upon each of us assuming a personal responsibility for our business conduct. 02 Letter from Our CEO Dear ConocoPhillips Employees, Our
Youth Criminal Justice Act HANDBOOK John Howard Society Criminal Justice Education Youth Criminal Justice Act Handbook Introduction... 4 To whom does the Act apply?... 4 To whom does the Act not apply?...
CONTENTS Foreword 2 Introduction 5 Finding the Noncustodial Parent 12 Establishing Fatherhood 15 Establishing the Support Order 19 Collecting Support 23 Where the Money Goes 31 Working Across Borders 33
YOUR RIGHTS AND RESPONSIBILITIES AS A CRIME VICTIM AND WITNESS This brochure is made available to you courtesy of the Nevada Advisory Council for Prosecuting Attorneys, the Nevada District Attorneys Association,
What to Expect in Texas Family Law Court A Public Service Provided By The Texas Young Lawyer s Association 2004-2005 Family Law & Children s Rights Committee Chairs, Christy Albano and Eric Jarvis Vice